Skip to main content
Loading video...
Transcript 13:30

welcome to on mars extra time now extra time is the format that we use when there's games i want to talk about that i can't quite cover in three minutes and if you watch the review of on mars in about three minutes you'll see there was an awful lot i didn't get to cover now mars is a fascinating topic and something has captured our imagination forever let's go back to galileo when he first built his telescope and observed the surface of mars for the first time i wonder what he saw with that now of course galileo was persecuted for his beliefs about a heliocentric world as observations of the heavens but thankfully the ballgame community is far more forgiving than the puritanical italian catholics of the early renaissance now of course there'll be some people out there who say oh clearly you didn't get the game well if i didn't get the game how did i do the three minute recap of it and it's not like complex games aren't my jam these are my three favorite games that are new to me from the last year and their guy project under all the cities brass birmingham like yeah they might not individually be as complex as uh on mars as itself but i'm not someone who just likes party games and lols what really got to me though is that i really wanted to enjoy this game i wanted to unpack this thing and just have a really good wild time with it mars is a passion of mine i'm actually

designing my own game set in mars so a complex euro game set in mars was exactly the sort of thing i was after but it just kept throwing up roadblocks each and every time i tried to get into it obstacles that just got in the way of me having fun now well-known board gamer trey parker before he got into board gaming had a little tv show called south park and he had some rules about how you write a script than that there was an interview i saw where he talked about how they wanted to get rid of the word and from their storytelling instead of saying cartman and the boys go to the mall and kenny gets run over he wanted the story to flow and make more sense cartman wants to go to the mall because there's a new toy that he wants he brings the boys along because he wants to show off to the others that he gets to have the toy and they don't but because the toy is really popular that leads to a stampede of people turning up to claim it which results in kenny being killed this kind of idea can work for board games as well and i like playing games where the idea of what i'm doing fits with the story and fits with the setting things happen because they make sense because it leads on from something the answer isn't this happens because it's a game and i'm going to run through a bunch of examples in on mars that happen because game it might actually be easier to do this but in front of the old green screen so magic effects first off there's just how the worker placement spots work some require that you put down workers some don't some can be boosted by additional workers some can be boosted by crystals there's

just no consistency there and that all seems to happen because game then there's the core idea that you can only take actions in the area you're at whether you are in space or you're on the planet you're meant to represent the lead of this project can't you use a radio is there no radio communications between mars and the surface and back and forth the only reason that works is because game discovery tiles come down when you return to the surface and they're placed on the surface but you know exactly what they are and you can get them with your rover why do you know exactly what they are and why do they appear when you fly down because game and why does the resupply ship turn up exactly when the colony moves to the next level it's totally player controlled which makes sense because game and why when you place this tile instead of this tile this one generates crystals on the board why is this generating crystals what's the rationale behind that um there isn't one it happens because game which brings me to a side point about crystals what the hell are crystals why are they such a big deal on mars what are they doing why are they powering so many of these building projects why do workers move so much better and faster when they're powered by crystals the only crystals i know that make people go harder and faster is crystal meth but jay all of that's okay because it is just a game and games are allowed to have because game logic not every game is an intense simulation that's supposed to be an accurate depiction of something that goes on my problem is with on mars that each of these

little glitches and interruptions gets in the way of what's already quite a complex game it's like when you're watching one of your favorite videos and it's a really interesting point right in the middle of it an ad plays and it totally distracts you from what's going on and if you were watching this without an ad blocker an ad probably just popped up there which was by design to prove that point that's how playing on mars felt to me every time i sort to get into it there was just this little incongruity that jolted me back out and made me go ah why is this game so frustrating why does it not feel like i think it should feel and again that is an entirely subjective and personal thing on mars didn't feel like the colony builder i wanted it to be and one of the big reasons for that is i felt mars was absent because i know that mars is actually in the game like it's literally on the board this is a game on mars but mars doesn't present as a character it's not throwing out variables it's not throwing out randomness it's not contributing to the game in any way except for being the board that you place stuff on there's no dust storms there's no issue with mars there's it's just a board and because the game never really felt like it was embracing its theme as much as it could have it really felt like it could have been set anywhere to me it could have been set in burgundy for all we know a lot of the features in the game could

have been replicated by other things the ship going back and forth well that's just like any colonialism game the building of infrastructure the worker placement it could have all been themed around a colony in the new world and i know i keep stressing that games shouldn't do that and that's not something i want to see more often i want to see more games on mars and doing science fiction settings instead of real world colonialism but i also want them to play with the idea that they are on mars and i'm going to talk about a couple of other games that i think have done this a little bit better now these games are not perfect by any means and they do have flaws but i think these games capture what i wanted from on mars in a better way that on mars did the first six kill the elephant in the room i'm not going to talk about terraforming mars terrifying mars is a totally different sort of game to on mars and i think comparing the two is it's just weird the only thing they've got in common is mars in the title and they're about mars gameplay-wise completely different and of the two games i want to talk about the first one is first martians like oh god first martians this is a game with a terrible reputation a lot of people have panned it and said it's unplayable or awful or just a complex mess and it kind of is in places but what it does really well is make you feel like you are struggling to build this colony on mars mars is very much a character in first martians as things break down and you have to explore the environment around you

and you don't actually know what's out there until you go exploring the missions are something more than get the most points and there's a real feeling of scarcity when you break down that last set of spare parts you're like i hope this is enough to get the colony through until resupplied first martians for all its flaws embraces that it's on mars it embraces the setting and it embraces what the realities of a martian colony or a martian game should be that mars is a character that's present and that it's scary the next game i want to talk about is martian's a story of civilization a game even more critiqued and harassed and hassled than first martians if that's possible martian's a story of civilization shipped with one of the worst rule books ever it was really hard to figure out how the game worked and that put a lot of people off and early reviews were terrible but it's what i picked up because i'm a sucker for everything mars and i played it and i got through the rulebook and there is a cracking good game there and again it has the same premises on mars you're building that initial colony but the process about how you go about doing that is totally and utterly different it's still worker placement but when you place workers they get to do fun stuff like move around the mining robot to collect minerals minerals aren't just collected by putting people on the board you actually have to go dig them up and you don't know where they are yet until you do some surveying there's a lot of missions to do here and there's scarcity there's never enough food there's never enough time and resources and you're constantly worried about the colony collapsing and falling over

instead of being powered by crystal meth you're powered by power and high winds can make your wind farms work better and dust storms can just completely screw your solar plants so what's the point of a review like this why am i crapping over this game why am i taking this extra time to talk about it and i think that's because i had such high expectations i really wanted this to be the definitive mars game for me with all the work i've done researching my own game on mars i'm just enamored with the planet i love to see games made about it i watch movies made about it i play video games made about it i just really really interested in bars and everything to do with mars so perhaps i put this one up on a pedestal it didn't deserve to be on and you know not every game has to be made for me and i don't have to like every game and you can love on mars you could love its granularity you can love all its little wacky exceptions and how you go about building engines that can be your thing and that is perfectly fine but as a critic i've got to tell you what i feel about games and what i found about on mars was that it was set on mars but that it didn't really use mars anywhere near as well as it could have now there's a potential that they do an expansion which changes all of these things it brings mars in as more of a character that throws in dust storms environmental effects and weirdness and solar radiation all that good stuff fine particles getting into the systems and screwing of everything i mean that would be amazing if they dedicate an expansion to doing all that kind of stuff i would definitely revisit

the game aliens really i think one of my next steps would be to try another game by the same designer that's not set on bars i've played co2 before and i thought that was a really excellent game it made my top 100 in 2018 but i haven't played it in about three years conan one of the testers on the channels absolutely assured me that i'm going to like the gallerist so i'm going to try and track down a copy of that and give that one a go because ultimately i do like crunchy games i do like engine builders i do like games that have lots of decision points and lots to master i just didn't like this one for some reason and yeah it's probably because it was on mars that's almost entirely why it didn't click for me because i was expecting something that wasn't there and that concludes the spoken part of this review for the game with the martian flair and the casuals are yelling no but the grognods have told them to go but the fun is nowhere to be seen now we slump in our sunken seats grab the bits with the brightest hue

and we stare at the reference sheet but the game is a saddening ball or more i could spit in the eyes of fools as they asked me to focus on of the workers board oh man look at those rovers go is it finally my goal take a look at the next guy moving up the wrong tech oh man i wonder if he'll ever know he let the best blueprints go is there fun

Progress saved