Skip to main content
Loading video...

5 Standout Board Games from 2020

Transcript 21:22

in this video i'm reviewing five board games that really stood out in 2020 these are games that take a genre and do something new and different with it games that aren't just repeating the same old themes or the same old mechanisms they're not necessarily my favorites of the year but i think they deserve a look because they could be right for you i'm able to review the games that i think are relevant and give honest critical reviews because the channel is funded by viewers not sponsored by publishers if you find these reviews helpful please consider supporting actual on patreon there's something ambitious about pan am it's got its sights set on mainstream crossover success to be the next ticket to ride or pandemic let's consult the checklist one it's simple two the board is a map of the world everyone loves a map of the world it's where they live three the theme is accessible we all know what planes are they're what we fly around to show birds that they're not special and add to that a recognizable ip that 2011 tv show starring margot robbie something to convince nancy the non-gamer to buy it for christmas and then realize that board games are not just for geeks anymore which is great i hope it sells a million copies and board games become more popular than our role-playing rivals and i get a few more subscribers off the

back of it but is pan am right for you roll titles you play as a fledgling airline setting up plane routes to make money so that you can buy shares in pan am whoever owns the most shares wins to claim a route you'll need the landing rights in the cities you're flying between by building an airport there or having the right card you'll also need a plane and it's all these things you'll be competing for to get the best routes to get anything in pan am you must bid for it you bid for an airport placing your pawn on three in the hope that you can get it on the cheap a vain stupid hope because someone will definitely come along and outbid you putting their pawn down to pay five dollars you get bumped off and you can either bid again or cut your losses bidding for say a card instead it's simple and brilliant there aren't enough airports cards or planes to go around so you have to spend your precious money to get them remember that's precious money that you could spend on shares to win the game and the game makes you fight for the same things each round pan am will buy up routes expanding along a path giving the owner a handsome bonus which means everyone wants those destination cards to claim a route you need to put your pawn on that track so if you spend your first turn trying

to get a cheap deal on an airport you won't be the first to claim a route and that's how you find out that steve is taking the route you were planning for this whole round pan am is gloriously competitive you have to worry what other players are doing and get there first there's a constant feeling of not being able to keep up because the pan am share price is going up every round and there is never a better time to buy than right now the core of pan am is brilliant it's interactive it's strategic it's more complicated than ticket to ride but in return the decisions are more juicy you're more invested than in a game of ticket to ride and that's why it's heavy-handed luck hurts even more one of your options is to take a card from the directives deck these could give you free actions or discounts or they could give you a free share which feels like a cheat every other share is hard-won doing multiple actions to make enough money to afford it this takes one pawn one action and some luck and the events in the final round leave a similar taste there are four possible endings to the game and you don't know which you'll get so you can't plan for it one of them gives you a free share for every route you still own which will swing the game in favor of the player with the most route the result feels too strong it renders

so much of what you spent the last two hours mulling over pointless ticket to ride has luck but it's part of the experience you don't agonize over turns because you know your luck could change one way or another pan am sets a completely different tone the bidding tracks encourage you to really consider your actions and put together a strategy it feels so much more unjust when you're working towards something so doggedly the scores are so close and then the final event card gifts the victory to someone else and you're all left feeling bemused by what just happened pan am does so many things well i applaud its ambition there is 90 percent of a brilliant game there but i personally can't ignore the other 10 to fully enjoy it in santa monica you're building the city of santa monica with cards but only the bit of it that anyone cares about the seafront it's a city building game but one with real character you're not building generic suburban town number 457 where every neighborhood looks the same you're creating the very specific nonsense of santa monica and it's so much more interesting to build a town with a muscle gym called flecks of sand than one with five housing estates that look like every other one in the game the arrangement of your city is everything no one wants to have their beach wedding surrounded by tourist traps so it will score two points for every

nature card it's next to every card will complicate your plans giving you new ways to score such as creating chains of shops but what would a city be without the people you have to attract tourists and locals to your beach community and usher them around keeping everyone happy when i add this car park three tourists will arrive into town but they're not happy i've lured them here and now i have to build something for them to visit this badminton net will satisfy their lust scoring me four points but only if i can get them there and it can be tough to move people around if you have people wandering your beach with nothing to do at the end of the game you have failed as a town planner and you get the minus points you rightfully deserve adding people to a city building game is such a natural welcome fit it gives the game even more character you can imagine these locals that moved to town when you built the apartment block but end up resenting you because you couldn't deliver the volleyball paradise they crave and it makes the game play much deeper you can't just think about getting a nice chain of shops and restaurants along the street if you end up with a surfeit of surfers and nowhere to score them there's plenty of puzzling to ponder it's not the mellow laid-back beach bum of a game you might assume there are shared goals a personal vip that wants to visit certain places and a currency of sand dollars which you can trade in to take stronger turns at times i had so many needs to consider i found

it hard to keep them all at the front of my mind when deciding what card to take and ultimately it's a personal puzzle you are building your own santa monica and there's no interaction beyond taking a card that someone else wants i wish there was more of a reason to care what is going on with the other players santa monica is such a refreshing twist on city building games it has its own distinct feel from its art to its thematic touches even to its decisions and very few new games can claim to have that i've always wanted to find the perfect deduction game there's something appealing about writing down clues and using my mind to work out a mystery i think it comes from being hit over the head as a child by a candlestick in the billiard room i've tried mystery of the abbey mystery express tragedy looper awkward guests alchemists loot of lima sherlock 13 27 passenger incognito witness and kryptos and none were quite to my liking after a while i started to wonder whether i actually liked deduction games modern astronomers believe that there is another planet in our solar system that we've yet to find and their search for a planet x is much like my search for the perfect deduction game a noble quest which may never bear fruit and by contrived coincidence the game that might be my planet x is

called the search for planet x the solar system is divided into 12 sectors as we all know and each sector will contain one space thing such as a comet or an asteroid it's up to you to work out which space thing is in which sector and use that information to deduce the whereabouts of planet x to gain information you can run a survey for example searching for asteroids in sectors one to four the game uses a phone app to give you your info it tells us there is one asteroid in sectors one to four and it's your info the other players don't know what you've discovered you know that asteroids always come in pairs which means your one asteroid must be in sector one or sector four adjacent to its pair each of the astral objects has a specific behavior that will help you work out where things are for more clues you can ask the app for a rule each game there will be a specific relationship between two types of astral object it might say that the dwarf planet is opposite a comet so if you already know where the comets are you've narrowed down where the dwarf planet is the game gives you plenty to be thinking about as you apply all the rules you know to the information you have and try to establish concrete proof you will slowly rule out objects for certain sectors until you're left with what must be there it's a brain burner and you'll want to take some alone time with your notes to go over what you've learned in silence to make some conclusions i

found it hard to transition between chatting with my friends and being deep in thought trying to piece it all together and is that fun you have to answer that for yourself for me it feels rewarding to find connections and make deductive leaps like i've achieved something that's something being maths homework it's a satisfying experience but not one that i play board games for there's something interesting here about all deduction games i won my games of search for planet x i also spent more time staring at my notes than the other players slowing the game down in any other game that would be called analysis paralysis and it would be considered a bad thing but i wasn't paralyzed i was playing the game as it's intended and yet i still feel bad doing it it hurt the experience but i also don't feel there's an alternative in any normal strategy game none of my options will be 100 good or bad so i can rush my decision and do fine but with solving a deduction game there is only right and wrong if i rush myself get confused and decide there's a comet where there isn't one that throws off my entire game in any other game i would argue that rushing a decision and going with your gut is the best course of action but where is the satisfaction in a deduction game if you don't satisfactorily deduct something it takes you as long as it takes and if

it takes you as long as me you might leave it on the shelf for everyone's benefit where planet x shines is in its thematic touches at regular intervals you can submit scientific theories if you know that an asteroid is in sector six you can secretly brag about it if you're right at the end of the game you'll get points not only for being right but being the first to discover it and remember how when you do a survey it's a secret well the other players do know what you surveyed for and when it comes to submitting a theory if you've only been surveying for comments they're gonna have a pretty good guess of what you're theorizing and they could copy it later on and that's the limit of the interaction in this game much like a real space nerd you'll spend more time interacting with your scanning device than with your contemporaries there is no sharing of information or asking questions like in some deduction games but that comes with advantages i've never enjoyed the disappointment of being passed a card in a deduction game only to be added some evidence you've already seen and by using an app they've eliminated the possibility in those games of someone answering a question incorrectly and breaking the whole game when you think you've found planet x you can tell the app where you think it is and if you're wrong you're still in the game unlike any game where once you've seen the culprit you can no longer participate the search for planet x is a rich deduction experience that

really fits its theme it has had more polish more thought put into it than any deduction game i've played but it's not for me so it's time to cool off my search the search for planet x is my deductive planet x it's just that i've traveled all this way to the outer solar system to find it and realized i don't actually like planets i just remembered there is a deduction game i like it's called sleuth sometimes you spend your whole life searching for a planet x when you had pluto under your nose all along charles darwin this game is a clever idea thrive is an abstract game where your pieces evolve they begin the game as lowly chess pawns only able to move one space forward shown on the piece itself with this peg every turn you will move one piece then add two pegs to any of your pieces now they can move in new directions if you land on the spot of your opponent's piece you take it and if you get them down to one piece you win it's tempting to put all your pegs in one basket evolving your piece into a sharknado that can do anything but if your opponent traps your special piece in a corner that you can't get out of and takes it out of the game you will lose all of your pegging progress and you'll be left with a bunch of pegless pawns who were going nowhere fast thrive has that classic strategic feel of chess and other abstract games you

can see the moves laid out before you if i go there she will go there but with a new layer if i go there and put a peg there she'll have to move to save her piece but she can only move there so i can put a peg there to get her there as well there's a simple genius in putting your pegs in after you've moved you can't reap the benefits now you're forced to plan ahead so often a peg is a threat to the other player if you move forward i'll take you they respond to your threat not by moving but by evolving their piece further and just like in chess you get locked in delightful stalemates they could take your piece they could have taken it five turns ago but if they take it you'll take theirs and they're not ready to settle for that loss hoping to find a more advantageous situation being able to put in two pegs means you can always keep one eye on attack and another on defense on one hand your options are easy to visualize because the pegs give you a very clear indication of where the pieces can move it's as close as you'll ever get to them lighting up like in an app but as the pieces grow so do the number of potential moves meaning that it can take a while to consider your options and take your turn and one downside of the pieces always evolving is that you never get used to the way they move you have to reassess the situation anew each time it's not a long game there aren't many pieces to lose

but the turns can feel long compared to chess it's probably a walk in the park but i don't play chess for that reason i definitely found myself taking longer with my turns than in onitama because there's more going on in thrive it has a purity over onitama in its simplicity of form but that means the game starts in the same way every time like chess or thrive's rhyme's sake hive it means the game has no luck in it but could lend itself to repeated strategies or a feeling of sameness thrive feels like an exciting fresh injection into the world of abstract games one that does something significantly different but remains as streamlined and pure as you'd want from an abstract game if you're after a thinky abstract for two players give this one a try from the makers of let's make a bus route comes another command to remember our trip and with it another inspired theme a while ago you went on a trip to singapore remember and you're reminiscing with your fellow players what it was like when you were all there you'll be recalling the layout of the city where landmarks hotels and restaurants were and you'll be rewarded when your memories match up with the other players the game is a tile laying puzzle each tile represents a section of a building such as a shop or a hotel each round you will pull some tiles from the bag creating groups

you take it in turns to pick a group of tiles then you must arrange them on your personal map in the shape that's defined by the card that was flipped this round a shape you can't rotate you're trying to create certain shapes with your tiles to complete buildings and it's really hard because you never get the collection of tiles you want and the shape you have to place them in is sadistically shaped so that it's hard to interlock with previous shapes and the feeling it gives me is of never being good enough you seldom have a happy turn where everything comes together it's more about trying to salvage what you can from a tricky situation and that does provoke some analysis paralysis in me in the vain hope that i can find a better place to put these tiles only to eventually resign myself to the fact that none of them is perfect where it improves on most modern tile lane games is in its interaction when you complete a memory by finishing a building you'll take the matching tile and add it to the shared memory board if there's space the first person to claim a memory will score a memory match bonus a point for every space they filled so there's a huge advantage to finishing buildings as soon as possible if you finish a building and there isn't space for it on the shared board it won't get placed and you won't get the bonus this means you really have to keep an eye on everyone's personal board to see where they're going to be finishing their buildings but the clever twist of the shared memory is that you can score the memory match bonus if you remember the same building in the

same place and the game encourages you to align with these travel photo spots you took a photo of a restaurant in this place in town and if your memories don't match up with it you'll lose points which means every player is trying to put a restaurant in the same place the restaurants and shops introduce some nice risk-taking the bigger they get the more points you'll get for them but you can only score them if you've added a tile to them this turn so the dream is to create a big six tile restaurant but what if you never get another restaurant tile or there's no space to fit it in and the longer it takes to finish your restaurant the more likely it will be that someone else puts a landmark in that spot on the shared board and you won't get the memory bonus there's a lot to love about remember our trip i only wish it was a little less punishing and a little more satisfying to better fit its pleasant theme those are five games from 2020 that i thought deserved some attention if you'd like to buy any of them there are links in the description below and if you want to see more videos like this please subscribe to the channel i'm john perkis thanks for watching you

Progress saved