Skip to main content
Loading video...

12 Board Games Ranked - Episode 8

Transcript 22:43

hey everybody and welcome to another edition of month in review this is a series of videos where i talk about all the new to me games i played during the previous month this one being december 2021 and i rank them from my least favorite to my most favorite now i will say some of these games are very kind of preliminary ratings ones that i've not really locked in that final score of but at least it'll give you an impression of my you know initial impressions of the game i've got 12 games to talk about this month um some of them not so keen on some of them very happy with um but before i get into those games i just want to give a shout out to kianda dot co dot uk who are my go-to online retailer in the uk and i'm very happy to have them sponsoring uh the channel so um yeah 12 games this month um you know a modest amount not too many but i'm quite comfortable with this um because i don't think it was really sustainable to hit the you know 18s or something i was normally doing in the previous month but but let's get started with number 12. so at number 12 i have hokkaido so hokkaido i think a game that's had you know moderate popularity um over the years this one i suppose was one of the the pioneers in using this puzzly um grid system where each of these cards is divided up into i believe it's sections of four it might be six in this in this example and all these different sections have different terrains on them and they all score in different ways and then in this one you're drafting those cards and then

laying them over each other trying to score points of different ways i do like the fact in this one you have this mountain mechanism where whenever you draft a card with a mountain on it you have to add it to the existing mountain which essentially kind of cuts the um your whole scoring table in half where one side of the table will um will score the cities and the other side will as well but only your your lowest of the two will score so it does have this kind of balancing act and then you score points for your forest and your biggest river and all that kind of standard stuff and i think standard is probably one of the words that i take away from this one it doesn't feel like it does anything special and i will say that i think that whole again that that kind of cross-hatching mechanism has been has been improved upon by games such as circle the wagons and games such as agropolis and sprawl opolis so i'd rather play those titles than this one i just think they're a little bit more interesting and a bit more fun to play whereas this one just feels very vanilla and quite generic so i didn't dislike it but i certainly wasn't um hooked on it i wasn't i'm impressed by it it was just fine so you know probably about 5 out of 10 for hokkaido at number 11 i have flea market which is an older game by leo culvini i'm a designer who i've already kind of been um digging into a bit more lately this one is a very random game and i don't mean that in a negative way um it certainly is more caked or tailored towards more introductory family weight gamers but this one has some interesting things in it as you are rolling these oh sorry

a pair of dice and then depending on that value actually i think it's three dice and depending on the combined value you are picking up a particular tile matching that and um putting up for auction so you'll be spending your money to acquire that and then in future rounds if that number is rolled again the person who previously acquired it gets some money and then can potentially get more money if people buy it off you but i like the fact that you know the more commonly rolled numbers are worth more because they're more likely to come out for re-auction and give that owning player more money so very simple only takes 15 20 minutes to play which i think is about right so at least it doesn't have states welcome i think there's some fun to be had from this i think maybe the randomness is a little bit too much of a factor but it's pleasant it's fine nothing special and it's just good at what it does i suppose that is flea market at number 11.

at number 10 i have kodachi so kadachi is kind of a hybrid pushy luck and deck building style game with this ninja theme so the idea is you're trying to overcome all these enemies and the more you overcome the more cards you can acquire you've got currency cards and then you've got the actual card you're going to add to your deck so you need to kind of bounce to make sure you have enough currency to buy the good cards and add it to your hand which will let you overcome more enemies easier um so i do quite like the idea of this one i like that hybrid and it works quite well in terms of meshing together i suppose i had a couple of issues with this one and number one being that a lot of these pushy luck style games everyone is kind of playing from the same or kind of a level playing field but this one you actually have two kind of grades of enemies you have to overcome you've got the more common ones that you can easily overcome and you've got the really difficult red ones to overcome and one of the things that really did turn me off this game was the fact that a player could have a really easy run of cars and overcome them with a pretty um you know nothing special an average um set of cars in their hand but then the next person could get shafted with a bunch of red cards and just have no options even if they did have a good uh hand of cards to start with so that for me didn't quite feel right and i'd quite like or i'd rather it be pure randomness on the outcome rather than a set deck where you know one person could benefit from and the other person couldn't but i did like the fact that no matter what the outcome was that everybody got to draft a card from the center to keep all players engaged it was a very near

miss for me this one i think it's it's good but there are a few problems with it which i will cover in a review and you know one of them being the fact that you can be kind of backed into a corner and have no options um when there's nothing you can do about it so that for me just tends to rub me the wrong way but the rest of the game is fun the deck building comes through quite well um and i will say that the game does go on a little bit long as well so you know that's normally a bit of a problem for me but other than that it's a good game so i didn't mean it to sound overly negative that is kodachi at number nine i have hashi which is a 2021 release this is a a roll and write style game or a flip and flip and right style game as you have uh this map made up of all these different islands and then each time you're gonna be flipping a card which is going to show a number on it which you're going to write on one of the islands and also a number of bridges which you're going to be using to connect those islands together and the idea is you want to be having a number on the islands all those islands are going to be complete for scoring once you have a number of bridges equal to that number so you're going to circle it and that's going to contribute towards your scoring however once it's circled you can no longer add any more bridges to that particular island which can kind of cause a domino effect and mess things up for the surrounding islands so it really does have this constant choke on you as the game goes on it's getting tighter and tighter and more restrictive and your options are quickly running out and i tend to like those kind of games they kind of make you or keep you on your toes um this was

a very kind of um early rating i've only played this one once i need to play it a few more times to solidify my rating but at the moment i like it very puzzly i'm very tight intense but decent i've got a few concerns about the replayability you know once you've played this a few times is it gonna hold up i i have my doubts but um for now it's enjoyable and a certainly a different different style of uh of flip and right game that is hashi at number eight i have the rise of augustus or just augustus depending on which version you have this is a bingo style game as you are drawing tiles out of a bag randomly with all these different kind of roman symbols on them you got your swords and daggers and chariots all that kind of thing and everybody is going to have a a bunch of cards in front of them with those matching symbols on them and then you're going to be placing your little meeples on them and once a card is complete with all those symbols you're gonna score are you you're gonna shout out i think of this one you're shouting ave caesar and then you're gonna score that card for victory points but it's also gonna give you a kind of benefit which could be more of these meeples so you have more flexibility and it can be endgame scoring combos and all stuff like that so that's pretty much the depth of the game it's basically bingo but with some game with some set collection and with some other strategies you can go for works very smoothly and very simple style game family friendly anybody can play this really um i will say i think one of the biggest turn-offs to me in this game is the fact that it's in a big box so this is a

full-size you know standard eurostar box where as the gameplay doesn't really warrant that for me so you know shelf space is a premium and i don't think i can really justify having augustus taking up a big box um a big box space but the gameplay is fun it did fall a little bit flat flatter than i would have liked it to um but it was okay i i enjoyed it i'm glad i've played it because it was really a game i wanted to try and see how they were going to tackle and put a spin on that bingo mechanism but it's good it's decent and um you know i can't really say more than that if you like bingo you'll probably like uh rise of augustus at number seven i have dragon master this is a small box rhino kenicia two player game as you're building up this grid of cards up i think it's a four by four grid and you're playing these cards down and you're trying to basically score as much as you can on each of those rows or columns because one person's going to control the columns one person's going to control the rows and only your lowest score out of those four columns or four rows uh is going to be your final score and you're trying to basically put the same numbers of cards down because if you do they kind of multiply with each other and but of course your opponent is trying to sabotage that at the same time and lower your score really simple game and it takes 10 minutes to play works well you know i don't really know of any random casey games that don't mechanically work well you know some are funner than others and this one for me is a decent one um especially because it

is so fast and easy to get to the table so a really solid two player only game um and it fits a nice niche you know if you do want that 15 minute or less game to get to the table that's packed up and and packed away as well so yeah really happy with dragon master at number six i have another brand new game now this is a game of thrones betwixt so this of course is using the uh song of ice and fire intellectual property um and this one uses the between two cities or between two castles of making ludwig mechanism where you are working with your neighbors so the person to your left and the person to your right is working with you and you have a small council a small council of cards um shared with that player so you're basically acquiring all the different characters from the book series and they all have unique abilities they all have different different point values um and you're acquiring them by um basically using a hand of cards and they'll kind of play with things they'll have a bidding value and it's kind of a a game where you really have to manage your hand quite carefully because if you really want a particular character you might spend all your cards and not leave yourself with much in in the next follow-up round but i really do like the variability of all the different characters i think this one might be my favorite version of a game using that mechanism i was kind of lukewarm on these other two tiles whereas this one i like quite a bit and a big part of that is because of the ip because i am such a big fan of george rr martin but um nice

game i want to play this one more um scale as well because again you're always just working with the person to your your left or right and or chucking those bids in but happy with this one and again probably better than it has a right to be so that is a game of thrones betwixt at number six at number five i have sweet landia which is another 2021 game that pretty much nobody knows about and i i only know about this one because a uh a fan of the show recommended it to me they know i like auction and bidding style games and this one is that so this one you have a bunch of cards laid out in for all the players which you're going to be bidding on everybody's going to have a hand of cards and those cards are going to have a unique number on them ranging from um or very low you know yeah i think it's five or something all the way up to 30 something um and you're going to be using these cards to gain the cards you want in the middle of the table so you can pick the ones you want they can be a few point values they're gonna combo with other cards some of them might even have negative values or mess up the tableau forcing other people to take those cards um and it works pretty well considering you have public objectives and private objectives as well and it has a nice forward momentum as you can keep hold of some cards i have to give some cards away and it's just a decent well-rounded auction and set collection games game it doesn't have anything especially unique about it or special about it but what it does it does you know it does a good job of so and it comes in a nice compact little box and i think it scales pretty well uh

too so a nice game one that i think is going to fly under the radar but a nice production good clean rules and um some good different strategies as well and when you have to kind of pivot when you see the cars that come out so that is a sweet landia a nice solid auction style game at number four i have brussels 1897 so this is the card game version of brussels 1893 i believe which is a more kind of expansive euro game this one you are i always have like a worker placement style mechanism with this big tableau of of cards out there you've got like art pieces of arts you've got buildings you've got materials to build buildings you've got money and you've got these nobles as well which will give you unique player powers and then you've got these kind of other spots as well where you won't use your workers for the money value on them because whenever you place a one of your cars down to claim one of the cars you have to pay an amount of money um but the other ones you just have to pay an amount of cards to which will always be available to you and but what i really like about this game is the fact that when you're claiming these cards not only are you trying to you know get the resources or buildings etcetera to get points you're also contributing to the column in which you're putting that card in which has a um a kind of boon at the bottom of that column which you might say climb the noble track which means you can play more nobles or you can climb the building track which makes your buildings worth more or climb the shield track because when you place these cards down they build they make these little shields

when you have a complete set of four and that's another way to get points if you have majorities so i like the way that this has worker placement but a kind of area majority game within that worker placement and i think that is such an unexplored mechanism that that just has so much potential this one does it pretty well i think some parts of the game are way stronger than others i particularly didn't like the way that you constructed the buildings but i won't go too much into that one because i have already reviewed the game and i will touch on that in more detail um so be sure to check out my review dropping imminently really so that is brussels 1897 a really solid kind of a filler plus style game it you know if it's that nice hour long maybe 45 minutes to an hour bracket but it still has some meaty decisions to be made so i haven't played the original but this one is a good kind of substitute for that until i get that main game played so that is brussels 1897 at number four at number three i have curious cargo so this is almost like another filler plus style game however this one is strictly for two players and this one um is a twist or uses some of the mechanisms used in the pipeline game which is a game i haven't tried but i have heard it's compared to this game quite a lot and this one you're trying to build up this network of pipes with these machines in order to basically ship off goods onto these trucks and then get points for doing so um it's very puzzly a lot of things are always going to be kind of um moving you in

different directions as you are laying out a foundation of pipes then one minute you have to redivert it by placing new towels um very frustrating at times but can also be very satisfying at times and again this one is a bit of a niche game because it does it is quite thinky there is a a lot to think about a lot of things to balance and consider and because not only are you trying to kind of outsource your different resources you're also trying to um kind of intake your opponent's resources because your board kind of attaches onto your opponent's board so their outgoing goods become your incoming goods and that is another way to get victory points um i did think this game did get better as it went on you know the more you build up your network you have that foundation to play around with where at first it feels like you're chasing your tail a bit and not getting anywhere but again once you get that network established it's a lot more fun it's a lot more dynamic and i think you need to get in the in the in the headspace that nothing in this game is is permanent you have to be willing to move things around and tailor things to your particular needs at that particular time so you need to be a bit more tactical i think than my initial thoughts on the game but enjoy that i think i'm i'm unsold on it but i'm also think you know i have got potential to love this one or really enjoy this one but it also has potential to sync as well because you know am i willing to put that much work into a game because it does sometimes feel a bit like work um but for a two player game it is unique and um so yeah more plays are

going to determine which way this one's going to go but as for now i certainly appreciate how different this game is it's fun it's refreshing but again it feels a little bit laborious at times and that's going to be you know where this game is going to stick for me you know is it going to go up can i get past that more plays will tell so that is curious cargo at number three so let's get into the top two and these are the only two games with my shield of quality so these are straight up recommendations from me so at number two i have another leo convenient game this is verbunk so if a bunk is actually a game that's been out of print for a long long time i've been after this one for ages um there was a kickstarter campaign last year which was actually sadly unsuccessful but the company went ahead and printed it anyway with some minor changes but this one is a bluffing and gambling style game as you have this big wheel of these different gambling tables and as the game goes on i think it's three or four rounds these tables are going to start acquiring money and as the game goes on the more and more money is going to start building up on these tables and then you're going to be moving your player piece and trying hopefully to collect these different piles of money but before doing that you're going to play three cards from your hand one of those cards that's going to double the value of that table one of them is going to be a pure bluff that's not going to do anything but it could potentially be one of the other two cards and the other one is a trap and that trap card is going to mean that if somebody lands on that particular spot with that with that

trap card on it then you are going to take that money instead of that player so you really need to know how to use those cards are you going to lure people into that trap are you going to put your bluffing card on the higher values valued spots and hopefully your opponent think it's a trap and guide them somewhere else so that bluffing part of the game really does shine through has a real kind of loud cheering moment when it pays off for you and um i just love the the full momentum and the pure tenseness of this game um because yeah there's a lot of fun to be had and you have to play the spatial element of the game quite carefully as well because you can only ever move up to four tables um in front of you so yeah really good fan and definitely lived up to the height for me for this one i tend to really like these lightweight gambling style games and um this one is probably one of the best examples of that so the bank a big hit for me and um definitely accessible to uh not non-gamers and very casual gamers as well so love this one that is verbunk at number two and finally at number one the best game i've played this month is progress the evolution of technology so this is a card driven tech tree civilization style game as you are going through the annuals of time building up technology and trying to you know be more advanced than your opponents and get points by building these cards but i love the hand management system in this game i like this end this degree of engine building in the game as you have your personal player board and that's going to get better as a game because it goes on which is going to let you hold

more cards in your hand or let you develop more technologies at once or let you kind of draw more cards at once which are all massively important to have but also i love the actual way you build these cards in the first place as you know some of these cars might have a certain amount of requirements on them they might say you know have this many culture points have this much um engineering points have this much science points or stuff like that but you can acquire these permanent tokens which you can use round after round after round or you can sacrifice other cards in order to build them in the first place and some of them are just straight clean prerequisites for other cars so some might say um maybe the uh inh card is a you can play for free if you've already built the bronze card for example which can be such a more efficient way of of building those cards rather than having to spend and sacrifice all those other cards in order to do so so i really do like that it has real kind of satisfying tech trees as you're playing things out and watching your civilization develop and it's just really fun to play remarkably smooth um one that doesn't really get talked about anymore um i think this was quite an early kickstarter game but it still stands up remarkably well and um i think this is actually published by nskn who are modern day board and dice so very popular company very successful um publisher and uh this game if it was released today i still think it would do pretty damn well so um definitely one of the best civilization and tech tree style games i've ever played and i'm i'm really looking forward to playing again to be honest so really pleasant surprise

and um yeah one if you like your card driven more more kind of thinking style games um with a lot of manipulation a lot of kind of um adjusting your hand going through discard piles and stuff uh this one is certainly one to um you know to cast your eye upon because it's very good that is progress the evolution of technology the best game i played this month so that concludes the video really so if you have enjoyed the video please hit like and subscribe to my channel and check out my other other videos too and also be sure to check out kianda.comuk um and for everyone else i'll see you next time on chairman of the board bye

Progress saved