Skip to main content
Loading video...

Board Game Designer Rates His Own Games from WORST to BEST!

Transcript 20:17

we're reviewing all of Ivy Studios games and I'm here with uh well Austin Harrison from Ivy Studios I don't know how you talked me into this uh so I proposed doing a best and worst a uh unabridged Unapologetic on a bridge this I thought it was gonna be very abrasive they're slightly Abridged this is what I do like about your game okay one mechanic this is what I don't like about your game and I'm saying the same thing and if you hear banging in the background that is his heartbeat thumping through his chest because we are not approving this by his company or his bosses wait a second going up tomorrow okay as well there's also some construction happening downstairs which is Australia but also that is also true so you were up here because you have a brand new project coming out yeah beautiful fractured Sky yep uh as far as I'm concerned potentially my favorite game from your lineup I still want to get a few more plays I think I'm like five or six plays in okay uh but really really enjoying this we're gonna have coverage of that and of course you already know we love Ivy Studios we collaborate with them very often and we do uh some sponsored content with them so uh while this is review content this in itself is not sponsored uh but take everything we say with a slight grain of salt uh but since we're doing highs and lows I don't I don't feel like I have to you know I'm not hiding anything I'm just uh just telling you what I'm gonna say and tell negative things about our games all right moonrakers your first game do you wanna you wanna take the first swing out or do you want me I will um so things I like things I don't like high and low the high that's your

favorite thing about this game the high is definitely the collaborating do you want to give a quick a quick 15 on what moonrakers is too for people that don't know 15 seconds moonrakers you're playing as a band of space Fighters that are trying to pick a new leader and so you're working with those other space pirates to complete contracts and get Prestige Prestige or Victory on my floor

nice to meet you uh so you were saying yeah so my favorite part about the game is the short-term alliances I love convincing someone to go on a contract that is slightly better for me than it is for them and then being able to complete it just barely and Andy probably needed their help a little bit oh yeah I definitely need their help you know the game is designed you got the bit more out of the deal than them oh yeah so for me my favorite thing about moonrakers is the combinations that you can get I love finding it's a deck building game uh and so I love digging through the customizable pieces that you can place on your ship and finding these powers and abilities that like for instance one of my favorite sequences is to find the ability that makes your dead cards your X cards oh yeah worth something yeah and then you just start building them into your into your deck so instead of running a deck that's full of really cool upgraded like amazing cards you're building a deck full of trash cards yeah and those trash cards are actually working in the game yeah so you like the synergies I love this energies it's one of my favorite Parts about deck building systems is the way that you mold combine and the fact that you know you have synergies that aren't just about the deck that you've built but those synergies are actually contained within the board and the Tableau that you have in front of you and so you have a few different areas from crew to upgraded cards to the actual Tableau of your ship and all of those pair together into some fun I wouldn't say broken but fun uh seemingly unbalanced combinations until everyone you realize everyone else is doing it right and then everyone else is uh sprinting their way towards Victory worst thing about this game so in moonrakers the core game you are a

little bit underpowered for I think where we we want it to be and so what that leads to unless you build a really really fantastic ship if you're good at negotiating you'll get to five six seven points people will stop working with you and your ship's just not good enough to do a contract or you're not lucky enough to get the contract you need to end the game yeah so that's my thing is as well it's the biggest criticism about this game and do we I mean we should probably bring up the expansion I think in this conversation so my biggest criticism about this title uh by far is the moment where other people stop wanting to work with you they stop wanting to help you because it really does it takes the wind out of your sails and then no one else wants to engage with you it can cause you to lose the game in a way that just it's anticlimactic yep it's not it's not a crescendo to Victory it's instead like a Peter towards that last victory point the expansions You released uh in Titan uh are expansions that are designed to fix a few areas and enhance a few areas you have exploration that's introduced that gives a little bit more story and theme you have binding ties which is which is actually the uh ability to get benefit by working with other players including sometimes the last victory points you need and you have overload or overhaul overload overload which is just giving me more cards yeah each of them in their own way help binding ties will give you another currency you can spend to get over the finish line overload just makes you feel more powerful and Nomad lets you go for specific contracts that your ship is built for so in the uh in that system let's say we take the game and we say moonrakers new moonrakers Titan which people are going

to be receiving very very soon what is the is the high the same or is the high different and is the low the same or is the low different I think the high is the same for me but the deck building definitely gets better in the expansions I would agree and then the low for me at that point is I think there's just so much content um that if you're trying to build a very specific type of card or a specific type of ship you like from a specific expansion you might not be able to find that if you were fine playing with all the expansions and so you kind of have to change your play style to be what's available in the store okay to help with that you can cycle cards to store faster but it's still not if you're trying to build I'm gonna go for a pure binding ties build and you're playing with all the expansions it might be hard to find those mining size cards I think that's probably the negative now so I my favorite expansion in out of the group even though binding ties I think is essential yeah my favorite which is going to be the overload that's so good because you're just adding more on the stuff that I love the most about the game right and adding more combinations you have different types of powered cards you have multi-colored cards you have more powerful base cards it really does a great job but bridging that down and looking at what I like the least when it comes to the brand new expansion I think it has to be the fact that introducing things like introducing things like binding ties or the positional movement on the exploration right uh or the upgraded base cards that maybe you're not always paying the closest attention to yeah more things are introduced that require you to have a long-term strategy instead of just playing the game and seeing where it takes you right or the other game where this base game could be anti-climactic at its ending but I think with Titan you

can sometimes be surprised by the ending and you think that you're set up and ready to go and then suddenly shira's like hey I'm turning all these things you gave me from working with me into two victory points and I'm winning we had some play testers that started playing to ten and back and so they would turn their ship around and go back to zero to 100 see that and we were like why they're like well we're just winning too fast and it's like doesn't feel like we're at the end and so we actually changed there's a score track to 15 and a score track Contender yeah but that's funny that that's one of your thoughts I think I think the score track at 15 is probably where I'm gonna live more likely than not those those last five points will go fast too because people will beat they really are wrong they really will but it'll give you that little bit of a window you need to uh to kind of get there your second game yeah veiled fate what is your favorite thing about this game winning without people knowing the color I'm in I am is the best feel you want to give it 15 on this you can hit the button again so uh veiled fate you were playing as a God who has made a demigod that they were not supposed to and you're helping that demigod get to the throne however all the other gods are no you're not supposed to make a demigod and they can figure out which one is yours they're going to downvote it they're going to make it have bad decisions it's going to lose Renown and it's going to lose victory points and so everyone's trying to help their demigod while hurting everyone else's and so you're trying to hide who you are while giving your God Prestige or uh Renown and the first close back I've already walked off um

I love that we decided to film this video right when like they were like we're gonna finish installing the floor they're putting in the floorboards right now it's great um favorite thing about this game like I said winning with no one knowing my color okay least favorite part of this game is probably that the card economy is too tight hmm I think that if there was just a few more cards in the game her around people would use the god Powers more I don't see God Powers get used very often at all no and that was cool it's somewhat intentional they should be big moments sure however I think we we saw too many God Powers being used and it was just causing pure chaos and so we ratcheted that back to try to stop them from being used quite as much sure I think we went too far sure so for me my favorite thing about veiled fate is specifically the Seven Player count I mean this I cannot think of another game that I want to play at seven more than veil of Fame if I had seven people coming around the house I could not I could not pick out another game that would have like would be on the table faster right it plays so well and the reason being is you hid this mechanic at the back end of the game design we're at six you pair up yep you you pair up with someone around the table and you have no idea who you're pairing with so you're moving a piece and other people are moving pieces and you don't know who whose any color is but instead of just trying to discern who other people might be you're now looking around the table and saying who also might be with me the

reason and why I love seven is because seven leaves a floater and so you have pairs of people and then you have one person which could be yourself going you're my friend oh you're my friend you have to be mine you don't know you're alone and you have no friends but you get extra points at the end of the game for being the person alive which just recently someone playing the Discord and they want is the seventh player I just think it's I just super cool I think it's such a cool mechanic I think this game is the strongest at those High player counts I also love two player two players two players this really fun like head-to-head social deduction type game my least favorite part about failed vate half fact that some people instead of getting into the economy of the game the atmosphere of the game the subterfuge approach the game from the standpoint of I'm just gonna move my piece what a dumb game I'm just gonna move my piece yeah I'm gonna move blue and you can either it results it results in the group knowing who they are yeah and then kind of awkwardly shutting them down like maybe or not and they win it could result in either it having a player like that around the table who instead of saying hey I'm gonna I'm gonna join in the atmosphere that we're playing in I'm gonna try to trick you I'm going to try to play and keep the walls of this game up yeah you could have someone come in that's just like why are we playing board games I'm just gonna do this yeah so it can fall flat so we have every like every few months we get someone that comes in the Discord and it's like hey I just played my first

game of failed fate and one person just played their character the whole time and they've won um like is that like a known strategy and I mean the truth is sure it's a known strategy but usually it's because they think that person's bluffing that color yeah but really experienced players should be able to stop that no matter whose color it is they need to stop if you're playing with us and you're playing a flat strategy you're gonna we can stop you from winning yeah every once a week every time however that doesn't mean it's fun to do that right uh it kind of sucks I I want to play a game it might cost us the game yeah yeah it's just it's I want to play a game where we're all playing a mystery and trying to deduce and if I find out Midway through because you slipped up or did something obvious yep awesome that's okay yeah but playing it straight just playing just moving one straight character it ruins the atmosphere of the game and it's a game that does require an atmosphere to be maintained

Mischief oh I should have thought about this one more favorite and least favorite also elevator pitch Mythic Mischief you were playing as a faction of students in a library that you were not supposed to be in and there is a teacher called the tone keeper that's been hired by the school to kick the students out the students think that's hilarious and so they are playing a game to see you can stay in the library the longest

asymmetric player Powers focused on moving three aspects of the game environment you move your characters you move the uh opponent's characters four aspects of the game environment even few characters you move your opponent's characters you move this thing that is catching you the tone keeper and you change the environment itself the walls debris and other tokens that are across the board uh I think it's a really cool abstract game yeah I love it favorite part I think the the feeling of changing the path that the tone keeper is going to take and managing to get a three catch getting a three catch is just like a wonderful feeling in this game and you gotta perfectly line people up they have to be a little stupid yeah you know and you gotta like throw someone lift a wall homekeeper one space over big puzzle and you and them kind of see the gates closing and then it clicks and they just go yeah I love I love that going with three catch what is my least so my favorite thing about Mythic Mischief has to be the asymmetric player Powers I really like the fact that players play very very unique to one another and the strategies of play aren't just about how you play your character they're also about how you play against the characters that you're playing against if you have a character that can spawn through walls you might not need to worry about repositioning them as much you have a character that can throw in diagonals you need to close off the board maybe stay around the outer edges a little bit more there's a whole there's a whole economy of play an economy of actions uh that is built around who you're actually going up against and how their Mechanics Work right I really love that so I've

been sitting here ragging my brain I think what I'm going to go with as my negative is that it can be AP that is mine that is mine living Mischief can be extremely analysis paralysis you have so many options and so many options for your options yep I've seen someone try to like walk back a whole turn that they did because it didn't result in the catches that they thought it would and that's just like really frustrating to watch I think I've done that I think it probably happens in almost every game I play because it's a perfect information game I see the puzzle it's just a matter now of deducing and laying out what the puzzle needs to do and I almost every time I play me and my opponent are playing a very friendly game of being like move here and shift here shift here I didn't get two people move that back back this was actually here and that creates sometimes that can be very frustrating it can be very annoying the the concept of a chess timer we use a blitz timer um from the other version of the game really does help with that but it also creates a much more stressful environment that's a lot of stress I don't know that there's a good solution for it it's an abstract game with a lot of variables one of the reasons why I love it is that also one of the reasons why it kind of remains it creates some analysis paralysis I would be hard-pressed to teach this to people that are still figuring out new games yeah it is I've played it with like you know nine-year-old 9 and he's done very well it's just there's a depth to the strategy that you know that that I enjoy yep that requires

quite a bit of chaos and Analysis nope make sense all right your brand new title oh we're doing this one oh yeah absolutely fractured sky elevator oven uh fractured Sky you're playing as a nation hunting for pieces of a fallen star the the nation that collects the most will be blessed with a gift a wish being blessed by this uh mysterious creature under the waves that has asked everyone to get these stars um on the board you are going to be placing out three airships you have 10 troops that you're gonna be mixing up among those airships and you are basically trying to deduce where are the starfalls going to be landing on the board and then having the most troops in that region in order to collect them involves a lot of bluffing misdirection involves some gathering information involves engine building basically you're gonna be blind bidding on eight or ten different regions spending on player count so what is your favorite thing about fraction sky um the bluff the the feeling of a Bluff Point paying off like I misdirected them into going all in on a region that didn't matter or maybe it mattered but that allowed me to get more resources or more starfalls because of it just the idea of being able to successfully mislead someone is is really fun in this game but I've heard a lot of different I think that's just me there's I think there's a lot of different reasons why what can be your favorite in this game so so my favorite thing in fractured Skies specifically growing towards round four and five oh yeah there is so much payoff this game can use to escalate more and more victory points come out more and more opportunities to trick and

and and deceit and you know you've built out markets you've built out resources you have so many little pieces of information that you can grab you can play it almost as a perfect information game in a way with the only Bluff being what people are playing down yeah uh or you could play it a little bit more randomly a little bit more open-ended and I really enjoyed both of those play experiences but round four and five in this game which only take about 45 minutes to get to are some of my favorite rounds in board games period awesome um really really enjoyable and so the payoff in a very quick amount of time very satisfying worst part least favorite thing I've been thinking about it I know on the game on the game you still have to tell people to get right well I mean no it's just you know deciding it sucks I know no I just I terrible again there's so many things you just can't accomplish I think maybe I don't like it just no one fast array of stuff to list when no one is going for an objective Peak strategy those points can feel random but as soon as one person's peaking the majority that's where you're looking at the hidden potential objectives uh so it's random except for really the person that's taking the first player should win them more often than not so it's not entirely random but most games people are Peak I mean the game we just that's still set up we Peach three out of five objectives yeah two of them were random in the fact that we didn't know what they were going to be but the person that won them did something to get them yeah it's it's kind of I think that might be my least favorite maybe a little bit of Randomness um if if that strategy is not taken there's a little bit of random okay my least favorite part is uh when sometimes

because because of just action economy you're pressured into making a decision right and you very quickly can can realize that the decision you made it's too late to take it back but it's also entirely the wrong thing to have done right even sometimes without much new information showing up right uh you know for instance I might put a 10 down somewhere and then very quickly realize that I don't have the math to gain resources or I overlooked the fact that you're able to go right next door you already have you already have like you know your troops there you already have your towers built so there is moments there's moments in this game where I place down a piece first or second or you know sometimes third time and there's other there's other players that have larger action economy than me and they get to continue playing and I see everything that I thought was really smart right just kind of fall apart it can be satisfying it can be fun but also it can it can definitely especially if it's the first piece you put out and then by by the next time it's your turn you've realized that you you over committed and no one else is interested in the place you went yeah uh that can be a really that could be more of a negative experience totally so also like kind of a trick taking game you know so cool

and do you like the concept of sitting down next to a designer slash publisher and talking about the things that you like and don't like about their games uh I don't know you tell me whatever the case though whatever you do remember do the important thing put as many hamsters into your mouth as you can fit and then go to the movies trust me they'll enjoy the show we'll see you next time bye

Progress saved