A Critique of Secret Hitler (and a comparison to avalon)
Transcript
some games make you lie to your friends so that you can fake being on the good guys team while other games lie to you about being a good game social deduction games have hit massive success over the past decade games like Goose goose duck Among Us town of Salem All Digital games that 10 year olds love but nothing comes close to a nice in-person social deduction game where you can see the reactions directly in front of you games like One Night Ultimate Werewolf deception murder in Hong Kong feed the Kraken all of these games are well received well loved but of all of these games the most popular the one most people have played is secret Hitler and secret Hitler is a bad game it's a bad game that desperately wants to be good and I want to explain three reasons why I think that and the first problem with secret Hitler is that the policy deck is terrible game design it intentionally creates false tension and what I mean by this is each game there's a game State that's predictable don't believe me watch this little magic trick so let's imagine that the Liberals are having the best game of their lives they're able to assess people out instantly they're able to figure everything out but the game still has to do its motions it still has to create a story so Watch What Happens so let's give it a nice Shuffle and see how it goes
so president takes the top three one two three oh all three of them are fascists so even though he's liberal he passes two fascists to the chancellor fascist policy goes into play one two three oh boy again wow how wonderful here we are two fascist policies out one two three oh lucky them they got some liberal cards so the fascist policy goes liberal gets deleted one goes onto the board
and this this state of the game the four and four this is the default state of secret Hitler this is the natural intended State no matter how good you are four and four is the default State this is the only time where your decisions actually matter for those other eight rounds it's a complete waste of time it's false buildup it's just a rubber band and I know what you're thinking eight rounds of game is a lot of game and you're telling me it doesn't matter yeah it doesn't matter because no matter how well you play no matter what you decide to do it will almost always go to this game State because the game wants to go there here let me give you some examples Smosh Games a massive YouTube channel plays secret Hitler and when you go through their games it always goes to four and four the past three for example April 14th 4 and four June 2nd 4 and 4 July 28th four and four it always shows four and four there's four and four no matter where you look and the reason for this is secret Hitler wants to build attention and will do so by removing player agency It's Just an Illusion that your choices matter because no matter what you decide to do the rubber band effect is too powerful it's like you're playing Mario Kart except Force because at least Mario Kart is fun
the great tragedy in all of this is secret Hitler is a boring game there is no player expression your choices don't matter your accusations don't matter what you do in the game is all subject to the powerful rubber band and it's not just me who's saying that the designer of the game even says that you can't be good at secret Hitler I don't think that you can be good because the game is so random and there's so much self-balancing going on this is a problem like social deduction game without the deduction part is just a social activity it's not even a game it's just an event and this is intentional because the story of secret Hitler the rising tension the climax that's what's important in secret Hitler for people who like the game it's not about finding out who's who it's not about what actually is going on behind the scenes the mechanics of secret Hitler encourage a final finish that's exciting but once you realize you have no control over any of this it's exciting a way of playing sloths are or watching a horse race it's not exciting in the way that good games are and to show the fragility of secret Hitler's illusion is only played in one way what I mean by this is social deduction games have been used in alternate characters and Alternate roles for decades now but secret Hitler only allows for that one unique player that one unique Hitler player because anything else that's
added on immediately destroys the illusion and immediately reveals that players have no agency in this game and this makes it boring too because you can't spice up secret Hitler you can't add to the puzzle because there is no puzzle that really exists the information is faulty just to give you the illusion of complexity your choices have minimal impact on the pathway of the game the first six to eight rounds have no dramatic effect it's just to build that tension to create that climax so that a story can be told and once you know the twists of the story it's a boring game
Avalon is actually a fucking game it actually plays there's a logic to it secret Hitler used Avalon as the base the designers admitted it Avalon was the inspiration for secret Hitler but secret Hitler was so obsessed with this plot line with the story of this tension and climax that it forgot to make a game around it Avalon completely disregards any form of RNG or a policy deck and instead just sticks to truthful information by revealing a successor fail card not only that but Avalon only needs five rounds to build a story and the story is organic it's through the players it's through betrayals it's not through a deck it's not through RNG each round feels important and critical and the mechanics are so fucking sound the balance between Merlin who knows who the villains are in the assassin who's trying to figure out who Merlin is makes for a far more intense and interesting game that happens in half the time as secret Hitler not only that but look at all this extra stupid shit there's so many variable characters that you could add on to spice up the game because the core of the game can hold on even with all of these new variables all this new information all this lack of information all compiles beautifully into this organic mess of Social betrayals and deduction for example if the table
you're playing at is really good at being the evil team you can add an Oberon who's fucking hilarious because he has no clue what's going on and it's fun or if you want to make it more competitive I think Percival and Morgana on top of the base assassin and Merlin is a masterful way to play the game you can mix and match with all these wacky characters and you can have a great time because the story that's told is your story it's not the designers Avalon is a mechanism to actually deduce what people's intentions are and when you are revealed information you know it's truthful and it's fun because of that secret Hitler is a game meant for people who don't like social deduction because the plot is already laid out your following the designer's motion Avalon is actually a game game it's a game where you have your own stories to tell that each round feels fresh and unique that you can modify and adjust so that your table is meta is fresh and exciting week after week and this is why I think secret Hitler is a bad game the mechanics of secret Hitler are not meant for players to experiment with there is no room for creativity secret Hitler is meant to tell one story the designer's story they know what they want they want that rise and tension they want that climactic finish but almost all the information you get is faulty each round just trods along there's no Stakes to be held until the very end Avalon is so
mechanically sound that you can add in any combination of these wacky ass characters with all these variable cards or situations and it still holds on so tight because they're honestly great mechanics that can handle the scrutiny of variables so if there's any debate in your friend group of which to get go with Avalon get the big box there's so much wacky shit inside there's so much potential for experimentation Avalon lets you tell your own stories it allows for your own creativity and your own social deduction to come through secret Hitler tells one story and it's a story that's pre-programmed in the Box and that's why I think secret Hitler isn't a good game it's just a social activity after all is said and done I give secret Hitler a two out of ten and I give Avalon a 9 out of 10.