Boardgame Musings - my love for games with "take that" mechanisms
Transcript
hey everyone it's me again Lance Miker I'm dead Viking and I was thinking about this the other day actually what happened was is that on my normal weekly Wednesday night podcast me and a few other people were talking about different games we played and older games we played and games that we enjoyed when we were younger and a lot of the games that I played you know like back in the day um they had a lot of take that now if you're not what what take that is is that um basically there's a mechanism there's a card there's an action whatever that you can take while you play the game that directly hurts or um diffuses the plans of your opponent and I mean there's like lots of those games uh you a lot of them were like really weird like like old card games if you will as kids and it was like in all those older games too like sorry you know they actually were made to like like hurt each other and like knock each other down and um I mean and I don't really I mean it kind of sucked to you know have that happen to you but for whatever reason it never really bothered me that much I mean maybe I'm not remembering maybe I had a lot of uh fits you know with when playing with my siblings and and I got into arguments or whatever but later on maybe I rosecolor glasses it a little bit and I remember those those gleeful moments um you know and I think that uh like
your mentality or or where you're at when that that happens is is is how well you can like or not like it and I really enjoy it I really enjoy having to safeguard myself against somebody doing a take that on me and I really uh don't and I really like being able to throw a wrench in somebody's gears and and and stop what they're going to do now I think there are some some exceptions um and I'm not going to mention really any negatives about I'm not going to mention games off hand uh uh that I can remember that had these things happen but I can remember several games that um the take that aspect was was way too capricious like I mean I always thought that like being able to defend yourself against it like knowing full well that somebody could do this uh to you and then being able to have some Avenue to change or defend yourself against that was needed uh intake that and but there are a few games I know that um and they're older I I really can't think of one recently that basically like you you play the entire game and not like a half hour long game or a 45 minute game I'm like talking like two hours of a game and all of a sudden like somebody plays a card or does an action that completely and totally inhibits your ability to win at that point and I think that is an extreme and
something that I don't like but for the games that actually have it integrated into it I really enjoy um one of my favorite games of all time is a game called Santiago and I think it's out of print and probably for the reason but um Santiago is a game ostensibly about growing crops and selling those crops but the problem is that uh you eventually like have to have irrigation to make certain crops grow and you can really mess with people by changing the water flow of of of that and and you can really leave somebody hung up hung up hung out to dry uh you know good P there actually uh in those situations and and but that's part of the game it's understood that that's part of the game um an older game like uh lifebooks uh same thing where you really like you're you're voting you're bidding things like that and you really have to like you know push people back to push yourself forward and and again those games have it as an integral part of the game and and you and it needs to be part of it um also uh I mean like uh noi haot uh which got remade into I think it's called the Estates or something by Capstone games um that is another game that has this kind of mean take that portion of it and and I enjoy those games like I said I I think the interaction between the
players is almost always more important than the actual game itself um sometimes you play a game where uh you get put upon and I mean I think I've told the story before but pretty famously um at uh at at Gen Con four or five years ago uh my wife came with me and we were playing um big group of us were playing uh uh Lovecraft letter and and I I won't bore you with the full story but basically it everybody at the table just decided to go after me constantly and and it was one of those things where and I asked and name drop here I asked Scott Alden the guy who runs board he was like why why did everybody go after me because he was playing too and he said because it's you're the most fun you're the most fun to listen to to playe to do whatever and um and yeah I mean it was kind of like you know playing a role and and I lost the game but but I still look back at that game with having a lot of fun even though I had no chance of winning because everybody was just beating me down it was a good time and I guess the point of this is is that I like take that games but they just seem to be Vanishing they they they they don't seem to be being created and I think it's just it's an EB and flow of the industry type of thing and I think we're moving away from uh that aspect of like Joy shot and Friday right Joy over somebody's misery
um we want to make games that everybody just kind of succeeds and and and and does well together and uh and and whoever ends up with with the best Garden at the end of the game wins and and that's fine I mean those games can be fun uh but for me uh you know like having a little direct competition I like having a little friction between me and the other players and I like always having to be worried about that friction uh and and and those people coming after you so um yeah so I guess in this thing I it's like tell me um what's your favorite uh games with like a take that aspect uh which which you've enjoyed um maybe if you could tell me about some recent games that have been made that have that aspect to them um that I'm not aware of uh you can list those below and then um if you don't like the take that aspect or whatever or you do like whatever tell me why in the comments below but um thanks again for taking the time uh to watch this video is always like subscribe share whatever do what you can do what you will um I appreciate that and in the meantime have yourself one heck of an awesome day all right byebye