5 Reviews of AEG Games
Transcript
welcome to allies or enemies I'm Jess and I am Sean and we're gonna do something a little bit different today we thought we would just focus on one publisher and because we just we noticed we got a bunch of games from them on our shelves so we're going to talk about five games from AEG yeah this gives us a chance to talk about some games that are a little bit lighter although one of them we did Cover previously for our for a full review yeah we have talked about Cascadia and we've talked about it a bunch but it's interesting to talk about a whole bunch from one publisher at the same time just because we noticed a lot of similarities between them in terms of weight sometimes in terms of mechanics as well so let's just dive into it thank you
first up we've got Santa Monica designed by Josh Wood and so Santa Monica like its name might suggest is a game where you are building a tableau and that Tableau is your Boardwalk slash Beach area so each turn you've got four or eight cards two rows of four cards that are in a Marketplace and you're drafting one of those cards and you're adding it to your Tableau either in the boardwalk area or in the beach area and at the same time you've also got these meeples that are townies and tourists and VIP usually there's one sometimes two and you've got to move them around the town the vip's got to look at buildings the townies and tourists have to get to various spots to play volleyball or do whatever beach activities they need to do once you've built out your town which is 14 cards plus you're starting Tableau space you just add up the points that you got from those cards and then also you compare that to the goals that come out at the beginning of the game and that's basically the yeah it is really really simple because that is all you're doing is taking a card and adding it and then sometimes the card might let you do certain things like add in the people and now those people are on that card or move people or give you the sand dollars which are your are your money so it's it's quite quick in terms of turns and how you play but there is a little bit of strategy in terms of aligning your card to match up with the point scores that are on the cards or what the different goals that come out each game
are yeah and there's a few interesting things it's interesting because there are a few different kind of routes to kind of roots to Victory so there are some cards that give you points just if they're next to another card there are some cards that give you points if you can draw a line between a number of adjacent cards that have the same symbol there are some cards that give you points if you move townies and tourists to them and then there are cards that just give you kind of one point at a time as you move your VIP around them and then they're also the shared goal so there are a bunch of different ways to score the end game points too but it's not too complex like that stays fairly simple yeah and it is uh interesting that there are slightly like powers that you can use your sand dollars for that change up each game and again keeping it really simple it might let you take a card from the back instead of only the front or whatever that might be so enough that each game feels a little bit different but still on a very basic kind of premise and it's it's so it's super approachable rules wise but it's also super approachable from just how it looks it's it's just really pretty and like chill and it's so beachy and it's all of these nice kind of beach pinks and blues and I just I love love love the look of it and I genuinely like the components as well the seashells the one big knock on it is the Box yes uh this box could be at least a quarter maybe even smaller the size eyes so it is a
bit frustrating that it comes in such a large box and there's only that much stuff in it but the stuff in it is good and it looks so pretty that you can only put out 14 cards and almost every game we both do seven beaches and seven boardwalks because we just love how the town looks with having it a line like that yeah I cannot bring myself to to build it like asymmetrically it needs to be perfectly aligned I I just I I can't do it even if I would lose I feel like I have to do that and the box size thing is I think you can still buy this game fairly cheap like I don't think that the price has changed that much it's just we get a lot of games on our Shelf we would love to have smaller boxes to fit on our Shelf it is surprising that we did pick this up because we actually it has this bit of a vacationy Vibe and we picked this up on vacation despite having such a large box we got this when we were up in Edinburgh and so it was really nice to get a a game that feels like you're on vacation uh that we bought while we were on vacation and it's great too because it always it it like evokes that feeling for me every single time we play it so it's both in the cards and just kind of in that memory and it's nice the board games do that too uh but let's talk next about a game that is in the correct size box for what it is the next game is point salad which is designed by Molly Johnson Robert Melvin and Sean stankiewicz and it again is a very simple card drafting game but you start
with nine cards out and three of those at the top are your scoring cards and then the other six are vegetable cards and on your turn you can either take one scoring card or two vegetable cards and that's it so turns go really really quickly but the goal really is hopefully to align the vegetables you're getting with your scoring cards and because the scoring cards are double-sided and they flip out any time to fill the roads those cards are constantly changing so throughout the game you have to try and decide like oh that scoring card's really good but I really want those two vegetables which one am I gonna get and so really simple decisions but super super interesting sometimes you only end up with a couple scoring cards but like just the right vegetables and other times you end up with tons of scoring cards that get you little points but enough that it you know you can win with that yeah you've got to be really you got to be able to think on your feet I feel like in this game because because those scoring cards are constantly changing you're not going to get the stuff that that you want to get as well we have been playing this we've been playing this on BGA for basically since it came on to on onto board game arena and AEG actually supplied us with this copy so thank you for that but it it is definitely a game where I feel like some games I'm just I'm killing it and everything's aligning and some games I feel like I and it's usually when I play it almost backward where I collect a whole bunch of one vegetable and then
I'm like please please please I need a carrot scoring card I need a carrot scoring card I need one and then someone takes my carrot scoring card Dan and then and then I end up with no points at all because I've got a suddenly totally change what I'm doing so you do kind of have to get the scoring cards and then play to the scoring cards that you've got and just kind of as you go see how that how that scoring is evolving you definitely have to play like that because at two players you're only using I think about a third of the deck so you don't even know what scoring cards are included because ideally each time you set up you you you know separate your cards and then it's totally random which third you're gonna get for that reason if you play with four you're playing with almost all of them if you play with six you're playing with all the cards but even if you're trying to set yourself up for the card the odds that it's going to be available when it's your turn is is like no odds it's not yeah it's just not gonna happen but that does mean that you have to kind of sort the cards at the beginning of the of the game so there is a little bit of for what is such a simple game there is a little bit of setup to it yeah and because they all play through until all the cards are gone and that's why it has to do it so it does involve a little bit you could kind of preset your deck so you could play a couple of times back to back at two players but then you'll know which scoring cards aren't included which isn't a big deal but I don't think that would help me honestly there's no there's no way I am card counting to that point so you you could you
definitely you could definitely do that and it is really a game that I don't know if we've ever just played once it's a game that you're gonna play a few times because it plays so fast I think really the situations where this game is probably going to shine is it's a great game if you're just hanging out with people having a few drinks because it's the sort of game that you can play without kind of your 100 of your focus even though the scoring does take a little bit of mapping yeah that's where the BGA kind of helps you out with the score it was nice to play that first so then we were able to kind of get get our heads around that a little bit but it does play fairly differently at at two versus higher player counts I would say because at two you have a good sense of what is out and what would likely still be out on your next turn and that might influence your decision because if there's like a lot of tomatoes out you might take the Tomato scoring card knowing that you can then get tomatoes on your next turn or you can purposely try and uh look at what your opponent's trying to do and take things that is going to mess them up specifically yeah yeah whereas with four it's you just you don't know what's going to come up it's all bets are off people can mess that's what people end they will but you you just kind of you really have to play the hands as the the cards as they are dealt as they show up for you and there isn't as much pre-planning involved although I like I like both yeah I yeah I think maybe I like two a little bit more because I do like that head to head but I think it works totally fine all the
way from two to six yeah because even at higher counts the turns are so fast that that is the nice thing at it it still plays quite quickly the next one we're going to talk about is also supplied by the publisher and this is Tiny towns and is designed by Peter McPherson and in tiny towns really you're trying to you're trying to build a little town and how you do that is each turn you're going to name one of the resources whatever it might be and you're gonna put that down anywhere in your section everyone else has to do it too and the reason you are doing that is you're trying to build these different buildings and each building has a different kind of recipe so that's a number of different specific resources that it needs in a specific shape and kind of little Tetris shapes and once you've made that shape of resources you pick all of those up and you put down the building in one of those shapes and each one of those scores differently so some of those score based on adjacency some of those are going to score based on the number of buildings that you have in town and basically you just keep doing that you go around the table each person chooses a resource chooses a resource and you put those as best you can until you've run out of space either by building all your buildings or by building most of your buildings and having the other spaces filled up with resources I think that is the tricky bit is those resources are stuck there that is it so you do end up in situations where you have to put down a cube and the only space you have because you're you're about to finish another building so everything's taken is to put it
somewhere where you know it means that one and like the one next to it now there's just not nothing that you can build but you have to put that down in one of those available spaces even if it wrecks your plan and it means that you can't build what you're going to build or and now it's just going to be negative points at the end for that Cube and possibly other cubes that are now kind of useless based on the placement of that one yeah you can probably tell from just talking about it this this game can be a little bit frustrating and it can be surprisingly mean for the cute animals that are on the front here and the animals don't really show up this is a very it's a very abstract game inside of the box that said I still I I still generally enjoy the puzzle that is here and it is definitely one of those games where you again like we talked about with points out where you've got to be able to change your focus and change your plan as you're going you can't always do that though and it is going to be frustrating sometimes and you can definitely now I've done this to Jess before where I played like six wood in a row and she's ready to jump over the table at me um so you definitely can play mean if you want to play mean as well and so on that note there is another way to play that I prefer for exactly that reason which is it comes with a deck of cards of the resources so instead of each person taking an interns calling out a resource you flip two cards and then your third resource everyone gets to
pick their own and I really like that because you get a bit of a sense of the kind of likelihood of a certain resource coming up based on how many cards have been flipped and you know the third resource you're always going to get a complete choice for and if you're only playing against somebody who is Chris trying to mess with you they can't do it that way so I do prefer that way of playing yeah it does kind of randomize it a little bit and on the same note as well there's a solo mode that I I do quit like and I get some chances to play it as well because this is again my end up playing by myself quite a bit um but you you've got a solo mode where you use that same deck of cards and it works almost exactly the same where you're flipping over most of them and both ways it randomizes it and makes for an interesting puzzle on I think the puzzle is really the fun it's the most fun part of the game well it's really the game is is you've got this puzzle that you've got to try and work out and it is nice that there are different options for each of the buildings in terms of how they score and so again each time maybe one game doesn't go your way but the next time you get you just happen to be able to figure out the perfect combination of how they all work together and you have each game uh is it a monument that you build and so that's your own personal building and and that's quite nice I really like having that personal building that the other person has no idea what resources you need or want so can't mess with you and it's really important to know this game can be meaner than it looks on the front
so this is really for people who like that abstracted puzzle and are okay with a game that is going to sometimes be frustrating and is gonna sometimes be mean depending on who you're playing with but it is quite nice all of the buildings are very different looking um but it is like like you said off this top it implies that there will be animals involved there are no animals they're on the cards there aren't some of the cards but yeah this is it's it's a very pretty wooden abstract game the next game is Cascadia which is designed by Randy Flynn with art by Beth Sobel and on your turn you are drafting a landscape tile and an animal token but they come out in four pairs so each pair has one of the landscape tokens tiles and one of the animal tokens so they may not necessarily be the tile you want with the right animal wand but you have to take one of them and you add that pair so you add the landscape tile and then you put the animal token down on any icon that matches it so it doesn't have to be the one that you just grabbed and and that's it you keep adding your tiles and adding your animal tokens until the end of the game and then you add up your landscape tiles for the biggest regions that you have for each of the different regions and then the animals they all score differently and each of them have various scoring conditions that you can pull out but generally Salmons score for a kind of run that they might make for example and
foxes is usually about kind of which animals surrounded and each of them will score differently uh depending on which scoring cards come out and then that's it so we did a larger review of this back when it came out which was about a year ago and this was one of our top games of that year as well but a lot of these games you know you talk big about at the time and everyone's really excited about them but it's like are you still playing this a year later and yes absolutely we are we haven't we really haven't cooled on this one it's just a terrific game the best mobile art is great it's just it looks so uh it looks like the Pacific Northwest and it's so inviting and there's just there's so much variance in those cards I'd wondered if the Simplicity of it would get would get a bit old because it is so simple and the gameplay is so quick but because of those different scoring conditions um it really is which is a more than enough I think each game yeah even just the landscape that you're building I find really rewarding of trying to figure that out and it could be super satisfying if you manage to kind of get a huge mountain range of like 10 long or wide or whatever it is and it is something about we both really like games when you are building out something and so when you look down at the end it looks different every time you play it and it's of of these five games too I feel like it's kind of the chillest one like it's the one that you can you can play this with anybody you
can explain it super quickly they're gonna be just happy while playing it there's an interesting puzzle and there certainly are times when you've got that animal token and you're like I don't know where to put it but you get these like these little leaves I feel like often enough that actually allow you to choose a different token with a different tile so it's so rare that you end up with an animal you just totally can't use I think what helps with that is there is a rule that if three of the same kind of animal are the only are on one of the four that you select you can get rid of those those three and draw new ones so sometimes I'm really hoping that another one comes out because I'm like oh I don't want any of those foxes one more come out so I can just put them all away and try again there usually is a way for it to come out although someone is usually left with the foxes which don't score as well yeah one I do wonder if there are other people who have a lot of success with the foxes because we tend to they definitely tend to be the bottom or the interest that we have in the different animals we go for I go for Bears I really like getting Bears first and I go for salmon and I think it's because I like having those two together because it feels like it it makes a nice little Tableau I go for those two as well and we often just play against each each other so Bears is having as soon as one of them's out there it's gone it's taken they're very very popular but the elk are fine as well it's just yeah the foxes I'm interested to know if anyone has had a lot of luck with foxes and if we're if we're missing out on on their utility and perhaps you can get a lot of points
with foxes I don't know but this is definitely a game that is held up for us the last one we are talking about is calico and Calico is designed by Kevin Russ with art by Beth Sobel and like Cascadia this is also made by flat out games and Calico is another tile placement game although um more difficult one I think famously so so in Calico you are making a quilt and you're trying to make the nicest quilt that will attract all the best cats so each turn you're drafting one of three quilt tiles and you're putting it on your board well you've actually got two in your hand so you're drafting one having that in your hand for a moment looking at those three that you now have and placing one down on your board and what you're trying to do is first of all fill these different scoring conditions so you've got three scoring conditions that you placed at the beginning of the game and they're not necessarily going to be the same as the other player's scoring conditions and they're going to have things like you need three of one different pattern and three have another different pattern or two two and two or whatever that might be and also three of a different color and three of another different color or two two or whatever that might be and so you're trying to get both patterns and colors to match these three different scoring conditions as well as make little sets of colors which are going to allow you to add these little um their buttons that can come in kind of like Lucky Charms shapes
and colors and then at the end of the game you're adding up both the scoring conditions that you've got on your board and all of the buttons you've got and actually a third thing as well is the cats that you've managed to attract with your lovely quilt because you've also got three cats that are out votes and each one of those cats likes a different kind of pattern and a different shape for those patterns they're very picky as cats are and each time you can make one of those pattern shapes you can add one of those cats to your quilt as well and I think the thing to bear in mind is you really want to be successful in all of your scoring conditions so you're really really trying to make sure you get both the colors and the patterns around each of those and you're trying to attract all of the Cats and you will never be able to do all of that so you have to be okay with that and and be all right with that time when you have to give up on on something you know and and the tricky thing with the cats as well is the higher scoring cats are a lot harder for those goals to accomplish so it can be really tough if you come so close but you just can't get the title you need or you have to put something else down instead to be able to kind of attract the the higher scoring cat to your quills yeah there's definitely I've heard from folks who who aren't fans of this game and I feel like generally it's because they they want it they want everything to be perfect they're perfectionists they need to be able to solve this puzzle perfectly and you can't and I I actually I really like
this game and I think one of the reasons I like it is because I actually almost enjoy just being like you know what screw it I'm just not doing that part that's fine I'm gonna do this other thing and like the freedom of just no fine you're not gonna work this time I'm focusing on this thing and so you've got to be able to it's almost almost like triage of like what what can I do first what is going to be the easiest what can I get done quickly that is absolutely not what triage means but it does mean that in the terms of cats and quilts I've just invented that now but there there certainly are those moments where you try and push your luck a little bit where you think okay if I put this tile here that's going to fulfill one of my scoring Center scoring conditions perfectly but I'll be able to get a yellow button if I put it here and I'm sure the tile that I need is still going to come up to go there and so and then like three turns later you're like no no I should have I should have put the other one over instead you definitely have those ties where you're like oh I wish I just wish I could turn it back that is part of the fun of it and last game I know we had I had one tile that would just be absolutely perfect it was like a light blue polka dot if I get this it goes right in the middle of all three scoring conditions and I've nailed it and that did not come out and I gave myself like 10 turns to get it too and every turn was just like oh no oh no oh no so you really do have to play you got it you gotta kind of play the odds but when it does come out oh it's really nice and I think I I like playing this
two players especially because people's turns are a bit long and you're just grabbing a tile but the decision of which tile you take can take a little while as you try and figure it out and and you are able to have a little bit more information at 2 players so the tiles don't change over as much but that does mean that you know well odds are that one that I also want might still be there by the time it's my turn again whereas it'd be less likely at more players yeah I'd say if if I were to rate these games heaviest to lightest this would come the heaviest due to that decision space and how how tricky that decision is and how how much of like your brain Ram you're using each turn but that's our our thoughts on on AEG so please let us know what you think about this format we haven't done this before but it is something as we were looking around at our games thinking you know we got five from this public this publisher so it think that we may make a little bit of a series out of if people are interested to see more of these yeah so there are some games that have been out for a little while uh let us know what your favorite AEG game is as well and thank you so much for watching please like subscribe and hopefully see you for the next one thank you