Skip to main content
Loading video...

10 Board Games Ranked - Episode 36

Transcript 17:09

hey everybody and welcome to another ranking video this is where I take a look back at the last 10 new to me board games that I have played and I rank them from my least favorite up to my most favorite now as usual there is a diverse range of games here um games going back pre thee 2000 and some pretty new games too from last year um before I get started on these 10 games I want to give a shout out to the show sponsor kendra. co.uk who are my go to online retailer and if you use the link in the show notes or the QR code then you can get 5% off your first order okay so at number 10 I have strike or more specifically Harry Potter strike now i' never actually played strike before um this occasion this is a pure dice chucking game where you essentially have a bowl um you're throwing dice into the bowl trying to create pairs by not only the ones that you've just thrown but also by nudging other dice already in the bowl um I believe you're trying to um deplete your opponent's hand of dice and keep going that way essentially until everybody has been uh knocked out the Harry Potter version simply adds a few little twists and turns by adding these powers on certain faces of those dice um they're pretty Min minimal don't change the game too much and the um the gameplay experience is the same essentially which is just chucking um di so I struggle to see the gameplay here it is pretty much pure luck um not really something i' I'd lean towards playing or something i' just suggest

playing but if somebody really wants to play it that bad I would because it is so easy and you can just switch your brain off and um throw some dice so that is strike at number 10 at number nine I have Star Wars the Clone Wars now this is in the pandemic series of Cooperative games where you're working together to Traverse this map obviously set in the Star Wars Galaxy um and in this one instead of fighting off play cubes Etc like with the original pandemic you are fighting off I believe the empire and you're basically trying to tackle the big boss who is a modular thing you can add into the game depending on the difficulty uh you want to play um the thing that weirded me out a little bit about this game is that there was no card sharing because I actually thought that was the coolest part of pandemic where you had to puzzle things out and swap cars Etc this one you didn't do that which I thought was a bit of a missed opportunity but essentially you're trying to save up currencies of different types to conquer the bad guys um generally speaking I'm not a huge fan of pandemic or cooperative games in general so so take that into consideration and I'm not even a fan of Star Wars so um again that's not going to help my uh help my experience with this game but I can see if you do like Cooperative games and you do like Star Wars then you're probably going to have a reasonably good time um with this one but it's just not one for me at number eight I have first in flight so I think this one's going to be somewhat controversial because this is doing quite well in terms of um critical reception um this is a deck building p push your luck Style game as you are

trying to construct the first aircrafts and trying to fly as far um as you can now this game has the cool scoring system that you might be familiar with um in games like Coliseum where only your best flight is your score so it doesn't matter if you score say 20 points in the first time you fly if you score 17 points in the second time you fly your score will still be 20 because that's where you've kind of set the bar I really like that system however I feel like in first and flight they missing Opportunity by not compensating you um if you don't beat your best score essentially so I did compare this with qu of quinber in my um in my review by saying like at least in CRA of Kleberg if you go Bust or if you don't have a successful round you at least get something in return and they can invest in making your deck or your pool better in this one you cannot do that um I also thought it was a little bit too underwhelming at times because you go bus too frequently um there's a lot of downtime um in certain points in the game and it just didn't quite land for me I thought it was a bit of a missed opportunity with a cool theme with certainly a gorgeous looking um production um the design I believe did tell me that maybe I'm approaching the game slightly wrong and thinking that I should be flying a little less um you know a little less frequently and prepare my deck a bit more carefully but you know for me that's the point of the game you want to fly as often as you can because that's where the fun of the game is um but it just didn't quite pay off so um yeah not one for me that is first in flight at number eight at number

seven I have starlink now this is a party style game a drawing game where you have this really nice looking um board full of all these stars and then you are you're given like a a clue or a word on a card and you are trying to draw that shape using Constellations by your connecting stars um with each other um if if your opponent gets it correct then they get a point and you also get a point that kind of thing it is um certainly unique it's a bit of a gimmick that I has I think it has its leg I don't think it's going to um stand up to repeated place at least in a short succession because you know it's very syy but I did like this Twist on the game where you are rewarded for keeping the constellations in a small proximity so you have this kind of little round um kind of measurement gauge that says if you fit your constellation in that Circle then you'll get some extra points because generally speaking if you can look at the border at a macro level you can draw pretty much anything because you have so many options but keeping it small is where the difficulty uh lies so definitely a contender for being one of the unique games that I've played um of the year and it will certainly be on that short list but um again I think the game playay is a little bit too much of a gimmick and there's actually not too much of a game there at number six I have House of the dragon Sky of fire now this is obviously set in the Game of Thrones Universe it's a deck building game where you are trying to get your character and your dragon um along this track and to the Iron Throne before your

opponents do um very standard deck building stuff where you are given a bunch of basic cards currency cards to buy other cards from a market to make you more efficient and to move your dragon and character um faster and faster along this track obviously trying to race um to the Finish very standard stuff here but I was quite quite impressed with how smooth this game operated because there's kind of no rules by new sha at all the rules actually all fit on a single page um of paper so as a kind of an introduction or kind of a my first deck building game this is actually quite a good option now I don't feel like the longevity is there because you do see everything quite quickly and there is literally One path um to Victory but it works it's certainly functional and it's way better than I thought it would be because I only picked up this game because I'm a huge um House of the Dragon fan and I wanted this just as a collector's item um when in reality the game actually functions quite well and I think if um you know non board gamers pick this game up simply because of the IP it could be a good gateway to start trying more board games out because you know deck building isn't a mainstream mechanism and this could certainly again bridge that Gap so yeah Sky fire a decent deck building game and surprisingly so at number five I have blockers now this is a game that I heard nothing about so my brother picked this one up um and it's surprisingly good I mean at least way better than it should be looking at it so you b basally have this grid um and you have different symbols on the kind of vertical and horizontal axes and you

have a token matching several of the different parts on the board and all you do on your turn is you place one of your markers on the board and control um that space and what you're trying to do is you are trying to create groups of your own shape because for every separate group that you have no matter what size they are you are essentially going to gain a point and points are a bad thing in this game so you could essentially look at this as a a negative point for each group gr um you collect it's all about trying to prioritize which um which placement you do first how to use these tokens because each token has a few options when to cut people off and it even has a few little wrinkles in the game where you can actually kick people off their spots to guarantee that place for yourself to hopefully connect things together um but you'll start gaining other negative points that way um and kind of the the more you do it the more negative points you acrew um yeah very smooth certainly familyfriendly um I think it definitely plays better at the higher player counts because it's so much more competition and the board gets gobbled up way quicker it's a bit more f um but it works and you know these kind of games I'm enjoying at the moment and I have only played this at three players so far but I am very almost quite excited actually to play this one at four or even five players which I believe the game does cater to so that is a blockers at number five at number four I have Enchanted plumes now this is the kind of card game that I really enjoy and that I kind of feel like I have to have in my collection so you know I love my small box um card games

and this one feels quite distinct to a lot of the other ones I have in my collection because all you're doing in your hand or with your cards you're playing them on the table in front of you um trying to gain as many points as you can by making these kind of like peacock plumes that kind of um you start wide and you go you funnel down into one card essentially you start with five cars then four then three then two then finally one The Twist on this game is the top row is going to gain you negative points so essentially you want to be playing the low valued cards on top and work your way down to the high valued cards but of course all the other players are trying to do the same thing and there's a further restriction because every color that you play on the top row are the only colors that you can use in the future row so you know do you want to be narrow-minded and only leave yourself with a few options or do you want to spread wider of course maybe game on next netive points but give yourself more flexibility and you're always racing against that tempo of the deck running out and the game can end very abruptly and you can be caught off guard with a lot of negative points by not completing um those peacocks and as a further incentive um if you complete the peacocks by actually finishing the whole reverse triangle then you will get a point for every single card in that particular plume very clever I can see this one growing or climbing on my rankings of card games um because I think it's extremely clever and I like that back and forth almost lost city feels of giving cards away to this shared Market which could kind of

lay um you know the foundation of opponent's turns as they grab them from you so it then constant back and forth here which I really enjoy so um this one very narrowly missed my um my Chairman's Commendation but I think to be honest sooner rather than later it will creep up into that bracket and we'll eventually get a accommodation so that is Enchanted plumes at number four at number three I have another card game uh with gap now much like Enchanted plumes this one was very much on the cusp of getting a commendation um I just feel like I need to play a bit more and see if it stands up to the test of time um but this one um I think the cool thing about this game is the scoring system where you're collecting different suits of cards your best suit or suits that you collect are going to be positive points but the lowest suits that you collect are going to be negative points you're going to deduce them or deduct them from your positive points but if you balance everything perfectly then they're all going to be positive points so it does have this kind of knife edge gambling system where do you want to go all in and get all positive points or do you want to play a bit safer and just take those negative points on the chin but the way you collect these cards is by playing through this um this hand of cards that you do not replenish so it does have that kind of six Ned feel to it um where your playing cards if you match the number you cut all the the same number and play it in front of you if they don't match the number but you have adjacent numbers to it in the market then you collect those in front of you or if you don't match any of those then you'll simply shed the card completely and not score it and put it

in that communal uh Market um I think this game is going to be a bit easier to explain re via a review which I have recorded so I'll be sure to um drop that review very shortly but yeah this is again small boox card game very easy to play but it does have a Twist or two that I enjoy and again more for me more the marrier with games like this so that is Gap at number three okay so let's get into the top two games now and this is where my accomodations begin so two fantastic games here and at number two I have Empires end now this one wasn't on my radar at all you know my brother picked this one up um and I'm quite surprised that happened because know this for me is what I love about these style of lightweight Euro games and I supp another big thing that's prevented me picking this one up or even paying it attention is that the designer is John declair and I don't think I've played a single John declair game that I've enjoyed so far until uh now now this one is a kind of a disaster mitigation Style game using the no thanks mechanism where you are shedding tokens to not take negative cards and in this one you have this array of buildings which will kind of generate you resource or income or build an engine in different ways as long as those buildings are not destroyed but each round there's going to be a card that comes out that says you know if you take this card you're going to destroy this certain building and therefore you're shedding these tokens to not take it of course with

each token that you shed is an incentive for the next person to take that card and what I love about this game is that the tokens are actually different it's not just a currency like in a game like no thanks they actually have practical uses for example they allow you to um to repair your buildings or they allow you to compete in this separate combat phase which will let you get generate more points and give you extra bonuses um there's some engine building as well as you build this this Tableau and Tuck cards beneath your engine it's just a really well constructed game and exactly the kind of game and weight and involvement that I want in my collection at the moment so this one ticks so many boxes for me and I'm just so glad I had a chance to play this one and I'm really eager to play this one some more because I enjoyed it that much and again completely C me off guard because um I wasn't really sure what to expect with this one and I thought that building a bigger game around that no thanks mechanism would just convolute the system rather than enhance it and I think this game actually just did it remarkably well so that is Empires end at number two and finally at number one I have pattern a mandala game so if you are a regular consumer of my content you might know that mandala is probably my favorite favorite two-player game of all time um and when I heard patents was coming out I thought is it going to be as good as the original probably not um but I have to give it a go because I love the original so much and what I

love about this game is that it is so distinctively different to the original because it's more of a an abstract pattern building game which you're shifting tiles around this um this board connecting chains but it does keep the original mandala scoring system where the first set you collect to is worth one point the second collector is worth two points third set three points and so on therefore you and your opponent are working at different Paces really and things that could be worth a lot to you are not worth much to your opponent and vice versa um lots of turn anx lots of prioritization um just a brilliantly and well defined game you think would have been designed a long time ago so I love it when Games come out now that still feel elegant they still feel pure um but have enough to sink your teeth into and for me this is the kind of game that will reward repeated plays with the same person as you both kind of sharpen um each other's skills and kind of build up this bit of a meta game and again polish each other and become more and more um competitive so yeah love love love this one and to be honest it's gone right to the upper echelons of My overall two-player games I think it is that good and it's just made me so much more excited knowing that a third mandala game is coming out uh this year so at number one I have patterns so there we have it that concludes the video hopefully um something on here has caught your attention and I believe I'll be releasing content on most um of these games if you want to check them out in

further detail um of course if you have enjoyed the video please be sure to hit like And subscribe uh to the channel and you know what check out my other um videos in this series because you know they're not time stamp they're not they're not date relevant because I play games from all over the kind of time span so I'm sure there's always something there that can catch your attention but thanks as always and I'll see you next time on chairman of the board bye-bye

Progress saved