Beyond Solitaire Podcast 123: Jeremiah McCall on Gaming the Past
Transcript
thank you it's ad break time I'm pleased to announce that the Beyond Solitaire podcast remains proudly sponsored by Central Michigan University's Center for Learning through games and simulations and as usual they are up to amazing things first their latest game 500 year old vampire is on backer kit through August 16th and that means you have two more days to get over there and check it out second it's time for another year of courses for clgs's certificate in applied game design Damon Stone's class core Loop finding amplifying and refining the fun starts on August 28th so you should absolutely go and register for it as usual I also want to plug my own patreon which can be found at patreon.com Beyond Solitaire if you enjoy my work your support would mean a lot to me that money is what lets me be on site for con coverage pick up copies of unusual games to play for the channel and upgrade the equipment that I use to film and edit videos so anything would help but for now thank you so much let's get on with the show hey Gamers this is Liz Davidson from Beyond Solitaire and I have a very special guest on the podcast this week this is Dr Jeremiah McCall he is a history teacher and a historical game studies scholar so Jeremiah tell us about uh tell us about your teaching life you like me are a postdoc High School teacher and we both spend our lives getting run around by those kids so tell me about it yeah so so the quick ver the quick version is yeah I finished my PhD in Roman history in uh I guess 23 years ago um and for many reasons uh decided to go into High School teaching
um and really from the very beginning was interested in games um and and history education so uh I had some courses very early on where kids were making historical simulations there wasn't a lot of talk about that I mean simulation games like physical ones had been talked a lot about in the 60s and 70s in some writings but hadn't been really talked about since so I was kind of just making stuff up um and from there because I ended up at this this wonderful school I'm still at since now the Country Day School where they had laptops a one-on-one laptop program I started exploring video games and did a lot of work with that but then Maybe uh a lot of work with that in the classroom I mean but um maybe eight years ago something like that um I really started getting back into board games some more um just because as as I know you know there's things you can get out of board games in the classroom that you can't get out of video games you the same is true the other way but there's just some really nice particularly like social things that are going on with board games um so I started designing some games for classes um and started incorporating uh more sort of teaching basic uh board game design and things like that um and uh yeah and so I've been doing games in the classroom for 20 plus years and um if by writing you mean I have a contract I am writing a book on how to
have teachers design board games for history classes and have students design board games for history classes if by writing you mean actually physically writing I'm procrastinating and doing everything else um but I'll get to it hey this podcast is important public scholarship absolutely right that's right this I what do they call that it's outward facing I'm outward facing exactly exactly okay so next actually my 10th year in the high school classroom and I honestly cannot believe it because it really feels like I fell asleep yesterday and I woke up in year 10. um but I feel like gaming pedagogy has just been getting hotter and hotter over that time um what was the state of classroom gaming when you first got interested in it and then how have you seen it change because I feel like you've probably seen a broader sweep than I have yeah so it's a great question um and and you know and and any answer I have to this question right shout out to all those teachers who 20 and 30 years ago were using games and and I I didn't meet you and and you're wonderful and and and you know and I'm sorry that we didn't uh uh um know each other um so for me it felt very much um so I first used uh uh board games and computer games in the classroom out 21 22 years ago maybe 23 years ago um I've been at this uh at this teaching
position for 21 years um and at that point there there wasn't a lot there were individuals doing things with board games in the classrooms like they had been for years but there weren't really any texts on it in the late 90s or early 2000s um there wasn't uh any kind of conferences on it um I think you know part of that right is it I'm not I'm not a board game historian in any sense but if we're going to date like you know modern board gaming to like Catan right that's only middle of the of the 90s so the idea that there'd be all these varieties of games out there that people could use for uh classrooms I just don't think was was really thought of very much um so for me I started I I taught a class in 2004 called designing historical simulations and it was about making physical board games and um because what I had learned as a teacher designing is that there is no better way to learn your history about something than to make a game about it because you've got to know it you've got to research it and know the details and figure out how the systems are working and everything like that um so there was that part of the class but then I was like Civilization three that seems to say some things about the ancient world that aren't the craziest things one might say about the ancient world so how about we play a little bit of that too um and there was and there's been a Revival of this there was a group at the
time at the University of Wisconsin-Madison called games learning in society that was mostly video games but doing some board game work too and they started uh having me come and speak and talk about my classroom experiences and so I thought hey cool and Shout Out Kurt Squire as always as I do for inviting me to do those things um I thought cool this is something that I'm interested in the kids seem to really enjoy and people seem to want to hear what I have to say about about the uh uh about the topic so take that about 2004 2005 what happened in the middle was historical game studies um it turned out that when I wrote I wrote a book called gaming the past in 2011.
um on using video games in the classroom totally use it for board games that just wasn't where my my focus was at the time that ended up being part of a series of very few but a few monographs that were written between about 2010 and about 2016 on games as history and how they show history and what you could you know what to think about when you're critiquing them as history and everything like that and I think it's really that sort of early two strands historical game studies sort of at the 2010 on and games and learning at the maybe 2005 on that started to grow from there and now yeah I think you're right I think it's picking up a lot of steam um I am an adjunct a research adjunct at Carleton University in Ottawa which is mostly because I have some colleagues there and I just really enjoy being able to work with them on some things but I've I've been a reader for two masters Theses in the last year or two where the students decided decided to design a historical board game as their thesis um rather than rather than um just writing a standard dissertation on the topic so that's cool I think it's coming which is why I'm writing that book is the Hope is that you know even though this has been going on for so many of us for decades I'm kind of like okay seems like it's actually the right time to say hey have you thought about board games yeah on the one hand they've been here a lot longer but on the other hand we haven't been focusing on them as much as we should in in history education so so I
actually have it's sort of a parallel set of questions that has emerged from this so I want to talk about video games first and then board games but it's basically the same set of questions so when you're using video games to teach in the classroom how do you do that like how do you make sure that the kids are getting play time that they're getting the right play time how do you select the games how do you get the licensing for them to play those games like how does that work yeah absolutely um and and and don't even for a moment I know you I know you don't Liz but don't even for a moment listeners think that I get much money off this if you happen to go and buy the second edition of gaming the past but there is a book out there I wrote on that uh if you want to just like buy me a Starbucks I think the royalties ends up being about the same um but shout out there because that's certainly the place to go for more detail but um for here and now so um purposeful play is the goal and that's kind of what I've kind of uh what I've found and um any you Liz or anybody else who wants to talk about this just hit me up it's easy to find me and I'm always happy to talk shop about your specific case um but generally speaking you gotta find games and you got to make and you got to make um uh lessons you you have to prepare for students to learn the games if it's something that's in that's very simple like for example have you heard of a Charles games B carbonize no it's a climate change game from Charles games which is a game design company in Prague with the university I
forget whether it's the University of Charles or Charles University but they made this free game uh that runs on Android and Apple but also on computers uh about uh catastrophic climate change and the things that might be done and might not be done um um to help with that that's a game I can throw in front of kids they can play for 45 minutes and there's gonna be some good learning in there I can talk about okay the structures and the systems and stuff like that something like a civilization or I'm I'm jumping off the deep end this year and using Europa universalis for my 10th graders um I have never tried that before I don't know of anybody who's tried that with 10th graders before that's going to take hours and hours of play time to be able to learn what you need to to get to that purposeful play but that's part of it so you kind of tailor um remember like the Glory Days what was it when did Flash die Flash died what permanently like five years ago four years ago yes there were so many historical games yeah I think 2020 maybe when the browsers maybe yeah I think I was at my current school because we started getting notices about it oh it's so sad um and there are ways to kind of get some of the stuff that was on there but that was always my first go-to stop for people say go play a flash game kids can learn it really quickly uh it's probably it's probably free uh it probably can run on whatever computer you have um and go from there um I'm fortunate enough at Country Day um I'm really it's a fantastic school
and I'm very and I'm very privileged to be able to to teach here our kids have surface computers so we can actually run Steam games um wow modest Steam games um but running Civ 4 is possible although civ4 doesn't seem to be playing well with Windows 11 it turns out but um so I'm fortunate enough that I can actually have my kids purchase a game or two as if as a book uh you know as a bookstore purchase if you will um if if you don't have that then you start to think about well do you have a computer lab and can you purchase a set of uh uh copies for the compute for the computer lab if you want to go completely free you can go with uh uh is fsiv.net I believe is the one is the 3D version of uh civilization that's public domain uh be carbonized as I mentioned is a really good free game um there's lots of good ways to do that too uh so I don't I probably didn't answer like half of your question but that's like the starting sort of things to think about no but you gotta learn how to play and then I think you need an analytical framework to make that play purposeful absolutely just play in a game by itself fantastic as a human being go play a game by yourself as an educational thing that debriefing that interaction that analysis is the part that's really critical yeah I think there's actually establishes a couple things that I want to do which is one you know we talk about video games in the classroom that doesn't mean that every kid is playing Assassin's Creed and like using that to
learn the geography of whatever City that volume is in video games can Encompass like a really wide range of things things that are free things that are educationally based you know it's not like you're having to bring a triple A game and a PlayStation 5 into your classroom but like I did I I actually have used um do you know about the discovery tours with Assassin's Creed so so I did play around with uh the Assassin's Creed Odyssey Discovery tour I have a gaming laptop um again I'm so fortunate to be at the school I am because they covered the gaming laptop so I could do some of this exploration but we've actually done that where we've played the discovery tour partial portion see I say where we've played but really what I mean is where I've played on my Gamepad and then the kids got to go wow I wish I could play this and it's like yeah but you're not old enough but at least this part's rated for kids so take it up with your parents yeah exactly that is not that is not for me to decide indeed I mean let us help us haven't we were young but that was their choice I this is this is where our age Gap is going to be a little different there was no Grand Theft Auto when I was a kid so my parent you know when when I was a teenager it was like Ultima four and three and stuff like that I mean it was still very 2D characters on things so
is the idea of overhead so one thing that I appreciate when I'm playing a video game versus a board game is that a video game you can pretty much boot it up and start playing I I will say that is not true of what I've been trying to learn recently which is Europa universalis 4 which PhD or not uh terrifies me but we're working on it um but you know for the most part you know a modern game will have a tutorial you know kids play a lot of video games so they might intuitively kind of pick it up I think board games are a little bit different and you have to budget that time to teach the game um versus let the game do the teaching so yep I how do what weight of board game what types of board games are you bringing into your into your classroom and how does that selection process work for you yeah so I mean you're absolutely right I mean the the the the the the ability of a video game to boot up and work and run really complicated calculations in the background and things like that uh is amazing um and um and has lots of places in the classroom the ability of a board game um has amazing kind of uh tactile qualities to it it has amazing social engagement qualities to it but there's the uh there's the overhead you got to learn to play which you do with digital games like you said um you've got to set up the game and if it's not playable within a class period you got to break down the game and find some way to sort of save the game State I think that was part of the reason that
I wasn't actually you know it now that I think about it absolutely is our school made a a conscientious decision for educational reasons to extend our periods so we'd have one hour periods and 70 minute periods and that was probably four or five five years ago and my first thought was fantastic we can actually use a board game because you can get games in there where they can play them in an hour right and and and and be uh and and have a meaningful play experience so um that's part of it I'm looking for a game that I can play that the kids can play in 45 minutes to an hour uh if they can play it in one setting that's that's going to be better than two settings um there's all sorts of ways you can try and save game stage uh you can take pictures uh I once created I once put a digital picture of a Catan map up on screen and we just use digital pen to Mark where people put stuff um when they played it on the board so that they could have this kind of uh record difficulty wise um I mean quite honestly I've got a figure in mind you're looking about somewhere between like a 2.1 and a 2.2 or 3 on Board Game Geek uh any more complicated than that and it's probably going to be too much to do for uh let's learn this let's play this so um games I've used this year or this past year when I was teaching ancient world history I'm shifting courses so I've got to find new board games uh roll Through the Ages
the Bronze Age love it um fantastic right Yahtzee dice rolling but you're and you it's a roll them right so you get to keep track of the things that you built and the food that your cities are consuming and stuff like that I can teach kids to play that in 15 minutes and have them have a meaningful first play through in 40 minutes so that's that's a perfect game uh Seven Wonders Architects that's one of the various Seven Wonders spin-offs um this one is just based on you're trying to build your wonder of the world and you're trading in resources and things like that um that's another one I can teach people how to play it in about 10 or 15 minutes and they can have a meaningful game um in well 30. that's the thing if you are teaching ancient world history and want to use board games seven wonders are Architects once you've got kids trained to play it they can play it in 25 to 30 minutes which is amazing uh uh to be able to do something that fast so that's kind of what I'm looking for I'm looking for things that are not too complicated on the on the on the rules or the playthrough turn um I've used Catan I'll probably use Katan again this year with my class that's on imperialism in games I've tended not to use Katan as much just because it's so abstract and I want something that's a little more closely tied to things but that works as well as far as I learn and play yeah yeah this actually brings them another question so um I'm full of them uh so it's fun to talk yeah so you talk about you know a
lot of commercial games that fit your classroom so when you're looking for something commercial it's not just about weight right I guess it has to be about what the game can teach um it sounds like you also design a lot of games yourself for your classroom so yeah I mean I I wish it were more but I'm a perfectionist but I have two right now that I'm running uh in in a couple of classes that I really really like um that I'm still continuing to develop and then I've got a third one that I've got to kind of put on the shelf for a bit but yeah I've been designing for I think the first physical game I designed for students was in 2000 and one so yeah I guess I have been designing for a while as you know I I've I've been laughing with you about you know some people are gatekeeping and say that I'm not a game designer but I've certainly been designing games for 20 years so you can make of that what you want I mean if you design games I don't know what else you'd be so right a house plant no probably a game designer oh man um so I guess where I was going with that though is it so it sounds to me like you will take a game like Catan even though it doesn't necessarily fully fit your purposes in the classroom because it's close enough that you can use it to make the point you need to make I assumed a lot of your designs kind of arise from your desire to communicate something that doesn't exist in a readily teachable commercial game so what kinds of things prompt that from you and what kinds of mechanisms like I want to hear about some of the stuff you're bringing in your classroom to try to teach kids the things that you really
want to say to them through games yeah so so the games that um the game that I've been designing the longest and came up with a breakthrough in design this year that I think is really going to move it forward maybe getting into a state where I can give it to people who aren't in classrooms is on the fall of the Roman Republic and I had well so I had this game um in mind that I started designing I had a version of it 20 years ago and it was on Roman Aristocrats competing for offices and how that led to uh Empire and conquest and things like that and how there's this intense competition between these Aristocrats for power and office and things like that because that's kind of like my dissertation geek stuff that I like um and um at some point in there I was I did I even get to play it I don't you know I honestly don't even know if I got to play Republic of Rome the I'm sure I haven't played the original Avalon Hill version I don't know that I ever got to play the is it GMT I can't remember who remade Valley games yeah Valley games Okay um and they had this fantastic part in it most of it it was like yeah that's fine it's okay but the part that I thought was fantastic was if you don't band together collectively to defeat the wars of the Republic as they grow up
then everybody loses but if you do band together and defeat the threats to the Republic then only the person who gets the most uh dignity um during all of that wins and I thought that was perfect because capturing that idea of aristocrats competing excuse me intensely um but um not wanting to go too far or the state wouldn't function anymore I thought was great and Republic of Rome is too complicated for for high school kids to play in class I used a modified version once I basically took the games and wrote a set of rules that was a simplified version where we cut out all this stuff and I had the kids I got a field trip cleared again love my school I got a field trip clear where we spent six hours in in a room with like pizza delivery uh playing this game and that's as close as I got but it's still too complicated so what I've been working on is a Roman Republic competition Collapse game that's um easier this that's more playable and I'm going to test out the new version in the spring when my Roman Republic course comes along but there I really wanted to teach a dynamic I wanted to teach this idea of aristocrats are trying to block each other from getting meaningful legislation and reforms and things done which is it's a point of view but I think it has some Merit and in their
blocking of those things they developed rivalries and got to the point where nothing was really being done for the rest of the the rest of the world that the Republic was ruling it was just these Aristocrats kind of bashing at each other for honors and things like that and so it became really easy Once one became powerful enough to say hey you know what I'm gonna take over and nobody out there in the Mediterranean is going to care because we all just look like a bunch of Rich uh Aristocrats fighting with each other for our own privileges and stuff like that so that kind of dynamic is something I wanted to get um the other one I've designed recently that I've been liking and I'm putting more work into uh this year too is called day agricultura right the Cato reference um and it is the what did I call it I wanted to make sure that my tongue was enough in cheek it was the universal excessively abstract uh uh peasant agriculture civil uh simulator um and I wanted something that takes you out of great person history right because so many of these board games and video games put you in the position of the great person right making the decisions the politician the the Monarch the things like that and so I wanted something that really got into um what it's like to be a peasant farming um and so that one I did a lot I did some research and there's an awesome blog out there by a historian named Brett Devereaux who does this series on
bread and farming and subsistence and it was perfect and and what he what he helped me to see because I'd known some of those pieces but I'm not an agricultural historian he helped me see that risk management was the core kind of decision that hasn't had to make you know am I going to plant this Cropper this crop am I going to have backups how much am I going to have in backups how much seed am I going to preserve and and that becomes a central thing and so I think sort of wrap it around to your question sort of big thing what am I trying to teach I'm trying to teach something about agency in systems because that's what games do the best right is teach you about individual agency or state agency or whatever you're playing as right and systems that help or hinder it I call that a historical problem space um and and games are really good at that so that's what I'm trying to do there the one that I have not tried out yet other than like really light play testing was I wanted to do a game on missionary religion spreading um because I thought it would be really cool to have a game about early Christianity spreading but you have to take out all the actual content so that people don't get offended that you're talking about these things and instead talk abstractly about about uh spreading religion so I kind of had this game of missionary expansion that's pretty cool but I haven't done anything more with that yet oh that's interesting sounds up my alley um so yeah I guess it would be with you with your Fields yeah so first fun fact uh Brett has actually been a guest on
this podcast I will put a link to Brett Devereaux's episode in the show notes for everyone because this uh historical game Circle just gets better I like it his stuff is great it's so and and he writes in ways that and just yeah as as a pitch for his stuff if you're doing historical game design about anything he's talking about read about read his blog because chances are good that he's looked at it in a systemic way that's going to make it lend itself very well to games indeed and also I'll throw into my trap no I'm kidding I wanted to ask you about historical problem spaces so this is the perfect moment so a lot of your scholarship centers on what you refer to as historical problem spaces so for people who are kind of on ramping into your work what is a historical problem space and what makes gaming a unique access point for one so a historical problem space is is bottom line games about hit about the past games about history present their history as if it were historical problem space so that's that's kind of the the Baseline statement if it's a game about history it's presenting its history as a historical problem space what does that mean okay it's not it doesn't mean anything fancy though there are interesting ramifications for teaching and design it means that games about history present the world in terms of a player agent um which could be a person could be
fictional could be historical could be the state right we're playing Europa universalis you're the state whereas if you're playing Assassin's Creed right you're an individual so you got a player agent they're in a world some kind of realized partially realized or wholly realized or whatever world and that could be three-dimensional and it could be described in text but there is some game world that they're in in that game World they have goals that the designers have set out for them and the problem that the player agents have that make it historical problem space then is to solve the problems that are set by the goals now you don't have to right you can play games for whatever reason you want and you can reject all the goals that the designers have for them but historical games I haven't seen a historical game yet um somebody's going to go design one now that that proves me wrong on this and that's fine I haven't seen a game yet that didn't have goals that the designer set for you on some level whether you chose to follow him or not so player agent with goals in a world and that world contains stuff I call them elements and the stuff is stuff that either helps you or constrained you um it's it's I'm certainly inspired by affordance thinking but it's not quite the same as affordances because I I would suggest that as game designers myself included um and just you know as game players definitely in video games a lot of the time in board games there is nothing in
that game that doesn't boil down to is this going to help me get my goals or is this going to hinder me from getting my goals um and that's actually a bit of a problem as far as like how it's presenting the world as far as like you're you know you're either for me or against me um so about a decade ago um I started talking about games as historical problem spaces and I've come up with some different passes and I've talked about it in articles and in gaming the past um what it all means is a be aware when you're teaching historical games in the classroom when you're playing historical games as a player who's interested in the history if you're doing historical game studies be aware that it's not a text narrative be aware that it's not a video be aware that it's not these other things it's a game so there's going to be some kind of player agent they're gonna have some kind of goals and they're going to be trying to seek those goals um and that's and that's going to be looking at history a particular way um with with the peasants right you could have you could have a video about peasants that focus on the emotional struggles of being a farmer in in bad weather but if a game does it as a history it's going to have some kind of person who's a player agent they're gonna have some kind of goals and they're trying to do it within a world so that's all I really mean with historical problem space um I developed it to understand the medium more but then also
understand another part and this is an interesting difference between board games and video games it's the only one I've found for historical problem spaces um all the parts of the game fit together and so if you're going to critique a game whether you're a scholar doing it or a teacher doing that with students don't critique how the player agent is represented in the game without thinking about the rest of the game and the genre and what it is right so don't critique the Assassin's Creed uh uh protagonist of the day uh for being able to jump around and do athletically amazing things without remembering that is the third person game and third person games are usually based on these over-the-shoulder views of figures that that um uh kind of kind of climb and fight and all these things if you're going to play a game about uh trade and your goal is to make the most money possible well how does that fit in well it's a game so it's going to have goals and they're going to design things around it why is this group uh and this is this is an important one why is this marginalized group not necessarily represented what well probably they should have been but the designers were probably thinking about a problem space that maybe wasn't being broad enough maybe it wasn't understanding other people's roles board games are exactly the same the only difference between board games and computer games on historical problem spaces is that board games don't have code and so there is a negotiation of rules and the ability to interpret and
stuff in board games that you don't have in computer games but player agent World goals elements board games do the same thing when they're presenting history the way that we treat board games as a historical representation from the way that we treat text I mean as you know within Academia right the idea of the textbook the monograph the article like that is the standard way of communicating our ideas and opinions and evidence about history how it works what really happened so how do we I guess show the proper respect for games because I feel like that's something that is an interest of yours yeah it's it's yeah it's a great question there's a lot of uh there's been a lot of writing not a lot but in relative on these subjects um on what do you do with historical games because a number of people have realized that uh I mean it's it's not really an argument to be had whether they're history um the only argument for game historical games not being history is it is an argument that privilege is taxed and there there are no kind of reasonable grounds for why text has to be privileged it just happens to be a medium that we've been using longer than than many other mediums in our many other media in in our society so um what do you do with that power of historical games to represent and there
certainly have been claims that suggest that you need more historians designing them what you really need are historians designing the games and then you'll have historical games that provide proper history and that's that's I mean that's colonizing right that's the historians colonizing games and saying you got to do it in a historian way so I don't think that's probably the best approach to it I think that I think that the thing maybe to think about is like kind of like your question asks what are the strengths what is it that these these systems referring um and here wait right we get into conversations about what is a game and what's agency I was reading something yesterday a fascinating book um oh on gamestay Study Buddies they they're awesome too and uh and so I was reading the latest book they were they were commenting on um understanding that world out there I understand there's a whole bunch of scholarship talking about whether this is what makes a game a game versus a text or other things like that and I'm not trying to trample on anybody's Theses for me the ability to make choices as a player that affect the overall outcome of the game and you can call that the outcome of the game narrative that's fine I don't have any problem with that I would want narrative to include everything the player was doing as as the eight player agent in the game and the ability to make choices that influence the overall outcome of that narrative I would say that's the
thing that games do that texts usually don't unless they're modified into a form of game that's the sort of thing that games do that videos don't do unless they're modified what was that one was it bandersnatch or something like that I never saw it but there was you remember that there was like a game video on Netflix or something like that yeah I remember that I didn't play it but I know what you're talking about yeah um so so if they don't without modifications texts and film and other things aren't going to do that so with a game I think what you do is you start to think about I want to look at a certain at the agency of a certain person or people I want to look at how that person or people's agency is curtailed by the world that they're in whatever factors I Define they can be intellectual limits they can be physical limits like food and geography and stuff like that I want to know I want to know what you know can kind of constrain them um and I want to know what kind of decisions they can make and what kind of outcomes they can have through their agency in these systems that's what games do really well and um the powers there like um you know Oregon Trail right they did a new version of it um sorry I keep using video game examples those are the ones I'm usually thinking about for uh um this but like Oregon Trail uh came
out with a new version but before it came out with a new version there was when rivers were Trails which was the awesome uh indigenous produced uh uh game that was sort of speaking to uh uh Oregon Trail but talking about being um a Native American in Minnesota um and and I'm not going to do a disservice by mispronouncing the name of of the people of the nation um but you are in Minnesota in the early 1900s and and um it's forced from your home by U.S land policies and needing to Journey along and find a new place and what they've done there is so fantastic because what they've done is it's still a historical problem space but it's a historical problem space focused on an agent that's marginalized and so games can do that too like like I hope my little peasant agriculture game will do at some point so that's what I would say using being be aware of them whether you're critiquing them first or trying to use them present history for what they're really good about they're really good about putting you in systems as an agent and making you see how those interactions work board games are extra good because you can get multiple perspectives in a way that you can't with computer games so you can have different agents with different points of view uh interacting with each other but at the end that's agents and systems that's what games do that's great do you find that by giving your students agency in that historical problem space
that they identify more closely or feel more ownership of historical topics because in a way they've been involved and if so um did the type of agency they got to exercise seem to affect who they sympathized with or like what they valued most from what they've been taught yeah those are great questions so you know my my anecdotal evidence from Little surveys and stuff that I do is that agency becomes really powerful for them as a concept and honestly teaching with games has changed my teaching as a world history teacher over the years I didn't teach about agency um when I first started teaching 20 years ago I don't know if you had this experience Liz but I wouldn't be surprised since you came from an ancient program right my experience was here's the ancient text our job is to understand these texts and then do it right and yeah were there human beings involved yeah yeah yeah but but let's look at them through their texts um and so games got me to think more about agency got me to think more about equity and diversity got me to think more about about World Systems got me to think about all these kind of things that you can sometimes lose if you're just focusing on looking at a text and Illuminating it so I definitely think I'm getting making progress with that with agency I'm learning as I go I mean I'm constantly trying to sort of revise what I do I do think there's a danger I think maybe you were alluding to that right
since so many of our games at the moment are based on the powerful and the hegemonic um what are you doing right if you're having your kids basically identify with the powerful all the time um what I try to do there is two things one that's why I tried to design this peasant agriculture game a couple years ago because I can use it as a start and say remember there are these systems of exploitation going on um for 90 of the population that we're not looking at most of the time um but the other thing is I get them to pick on it I I've I've often thought and I think it does hold true getting students to criticize a board game or video game and its point of view is a great way to empower them to critique um when you play Seven Wonders Architects uh I had them write a little essay was it great person history or was it masses history and some of the kids were really clever and were like well actually it does do some masses history because as you there's like seven layers to your uh wonder that you can build and there's little people on the scaffolding that you can see and stuff like that and and and and I'm like okay okay okay that's fair right but at the end of the day who are you really right you're the person who's deciding all trade all construction all everything you're the great person and so trying to get them uh to think about that uh I was using a city Builder maybe last year and some kids did a really nice job looking at social hierarchy and show and and
uh taking the game to task that enslavement wasn't represented even though in ancient Mesopotamia there was enslavement um so so I I'm I think you do actually you do absolutely have to be careful about agency and what you're saying about it and whose agency you're representing for me that's that analysis part that you shouldn't do the game without I I would the uh I wrote a Blog essay uh um the unexamined game is not worth playing riffing off Socrates like 13 years ago and of course absolutely go play games and don't critique them all you want in your personal life but in it but but in a history education setting you got to critique them um and that's the part that kind of gets us into our responsibilities as Scholars and human beings and stuff like that so um yeah so interestingly though right we will find we are finding more diversity among board game designers more diversity and board game topics um so this is gonna get better and better there's going to be more options for playing as the marginalized people um as more people design games like like you're like your night witches game I mean I guess they're not marginalized to some extent because they're like you know kick butt like airplane like fighter pilots and bombers and stuff like that but women in in combat are certainly an undertreated subject so yeah and I won't but I could talk a lot
about a lot of the decisions that David and I have made in terms of how we're choosing to present them and which elements of their identities are represented in what ways um because those are all you know really key choices I think when you're designing a game but actually you know what you said about Texas just had me sitting here thinking for a bit because I think especially because I came from a religious studies program right like where we did ancient Christianity and you know there's like a mix of people with different religious backgrounds but it was certainly considered a little bit distasteful to be doing the research purely from your own perspective or to prove your own point if that makes sense like it was you know we were all looking for some sort of common language I think it was it I think the focus on text comes from this desire to feel like you've de-personalized a lot of the work and therefore made it more intellectual because it is more objective and I think that in a way you know games can trivialize things but I also think that games personalize things and make you feel about a subject differently from the way that studying a text might do you're absolutely right I mean it's it's that I I keep I I I try and figure out my words I um think of that as the agency issue again right that they're putting you in in a particular um space um games are really good at strategical
and tactical thinking uh too because that's a place where we commonly have that sort of agency um I do a class with seniors where we look at games of imperialism and one of the really scary things about uh 1990s Pro Imperial project Pro colonization project games like Sid Meier's Colonization and and lots of other games that came out they're really good at putting you in the mind of a conqueror who is not much interested in the individuality and personality of the people they're conquering because it problematizes it I mean it basically turns into your problem is how to expand how to grow um so yeah so so that's a that's a that's a danger but also a reward right that same putting you in those in in those uh uh shoes of the copper can put you in the shoes of uh a person displaced from their home can put you in the in the shoes of of any number of of peoples but yeah I think you're right I think the text thing is to de-personalize I think also I mean it's part that's part of our tradition right that's the ancient history tradition too right of the is that pointing to the text since we only have three of them you know you better you better point it no no there's four now but yeah um so you just kind of go that way but I think you're right I think there is a depersonalizing that goes with that so if you are a new teacher who's
thinking about introducing more gaming to the classroom what would you recommend to uh that person How would how would you get started uh how would you start introducing these things in your class without making yourself feel overwhelmed so I think um if I were a teacher let's just sort of say General world history um if I were a teacher doing General world history I had started I'd look at roll through the ages of the Bronze Age uh it's it's a nice game if you're doing want to do board games for getting people into it uh I'd look at um um Seven Wonders Architects it's a good game to work with um video games if you're doing US History I'd probably start with the mission us series there's a whole series of Middle School uh uh audience designed um uh games on U.S history that are sort of point-and-click Adventures they run on most machines they are free they come with teacher support um so I'd look at that I might I might try be carbonized because it could run on every kid's phone basically um I would I would basically try and find a game like that where it's not going to take me too long to do it and have it be an experiment and see what we get out of it I wouldn't commit to something huge I think it's a very I think it's a very scary idea to use a grand strategy game as your first game um that that you're using in the classroom also very scary to use Republic of Rome in you know in your classroom so I would
start with that I would I would look for a game oh the you know what there's a game too uh shoot what's the name I'm gonna use this next year I haven't played it yet um I forget they're these two games on Resistance and protest and one's called block by block and the other is called something that I can't remember and one of them is coming out in like a fourth edition Kickstarter but they have a third edition that's print and play that they've made available um look for things like that look for things that are freely available I guess the other thing I'd do is probably write me an email and say hey can you help me kind of think about any games that I might look at and I'd be happy to do that I love doing that um but start Simple Start simple start with an experiment and most of all make sure the kids do a debriefing analysis if they don't reflect on it in writing or reflect on it in conversation or reflect on it in a recorded chat whatever but they got to reflect on it otherwise the learning really doesn't happen or rather learning happens but it's not necessarily any of the learning that we're trying to Target in formal education right is trying to actually predict learning outcomes and try and design towards them well that's why you have to debrief in game so keep it simple uh keep it short katam would be a good one too I have a colleague here who uses katam with sixth graders to teach about world geography and it's fantastic uh you know like terrain and things like that um keep it simple keep it cheap make sure that they
reflect interesting a good starting place and also kind of a good stopping place because we're moving to the the softy questions now uh so the first one I'll ask is just um what have you been playing recently that you've been enjoying so recently um so uh on computer I've been playing Fallout 4 because I never play a game when it's new uh because I'm why does my dad like to call it Frugal yeah I'm frugal so uh so I I got I got Fallout 4 on sale and bounced hard off it um when it turned out there was crafting and then came to a spot in my life where I was like I'm ready for this now so I put 30 or 40 hours into that um I've been loving playing Seven Wonders Architects with my parents because I like the fact that it's got theme but it's not too difficult um so as a board game I've been enjoying that um I guess it's the Seven Wonders podcast I have a I have a buddy here who's a math teacher a new friend um who taught me Seven Wonders duel and it's perfect for two teachers that have like 35 minutes once in a while where they're both free where they can where they can play a two-person game I've been loving um I've been loving Seven Wonders duel um I think those are the big ones I've been playing right now um oh and I just and I just picked up War Tails uh which is a video game again which is a uh everything gets called like an x-com clone it's not really an x-com clone but
it's basically like a tactical role-playing game where you have a little battle map with your with your figures and you can move them around and do this in turns and stuff like that so those are kind of the new ones I'm working on now and then probably all game playing will stop soon because what I really have to do is get that agriculture game together in a better version I had oh my God this game pushes so many cubes because I really wanted them to get the sense of planting and hunger and stuff like that but like the original way it's designed if you have a class of like 16 kids there's hundreds of Cubes being pushed around and that just it's just not any good I've gotta simplify it and get it down and stuff like that but that's the stuff I've been playing around with with games recently and if people want to find you and talk to you some more about all this I know you've mentioned your contact information throughout but let's put it in one place where can you be found online sure so gamingthepass.net is always a good way to find me um that's my website for 13 14 years it's collected basically all of my thinking uh it has bibliography for people who want to read those things it has um a lot of wrecks to computer games but I've got to fix those because a lot of them are in the pre-flash days it is underdeveloped on board games as far as recommendations for them and that's an area that I want to spread into at some point but gamingthepass.net on Twitter I'm gaming the past all one word on
Mastodon I'm gaming the past at historians.social uh I'm not afraid for you to have my email it's jmc.hst gmail.com I love cold emails where somebody wants to talk shop about these things so feel free to just introduce yourself and and ask me a question and I'll be happy to talk with you fantastic and I of course can be found anywhere online as Beyond Solitaire so please feel free to reach out to either of us those of you who are out there listening uh Jeremiah thank you so much for coming on the show this has been a lovely conversation and it's given me a lot to think about as a teacher and as somebody who is interested in you know taking games in history and gaming history seriously well thanks so much Liz I really appreciate getting a chance to talk about all this stuff I I appreciate your time and your and your interest so thank you so much we will definitely have to meet again about this work in the future uh but for now uh thank you so much uh everybody who's out there please like subscribe comment ask questions and most of all happy gaming
thank you