Skip to main content
Loading video...

TCbH Podcast - Solo Board Gaming in 2025

Transcript 1:05:44

hello and welcome to the cardboard heral podcast thank you so much for tuning in I am Eric joined as always by my lovely uh irreverent co-host Jack uh how are you doing today Jack feeling awfully irreverent you know how I do as I'm known for the normal yeah the thing that you're known for frequently irreverent yeah uh very blue very irreverent you know everyone's like man he he cuts but he he cuts deep is that what I'm known for exactly I'm a reverent yeah exactly no reverence over here the reverence um well welcome in um how are you doing this week Jack you doing you're doing good all things considered yeah I don't know what to consider I don't really know why I live with that sentence Oh man okay uh well we're just going to like go over NPR All Things Considered like review cast I guess that could be one thing to consider no uh I'm doing good uh things are uh pretty great on the channel right now I was happy to get out a quick review of Park second edition which went up on the channel and um it was kind of a special project because uh 5 years ago just a little over 5 years ago which I couldn't believe how long ago that was um I recorded a a review for the

original Parks uh out at the menen hall Glacier area here in Juno and uh so I went and kind of did a sequel to that uh which was a time for some reflection um which made sense because it's a second edition of this game and more than anything it was a cause to go back and listen to or watch old review and man anytime when I think I'm having like some audio issues on a video where I'm like the audio isn't that good holy crap what I thought was okay five years ago was apparently you I should have no worries about anything that I'm posting at this point when people talk about potato quality for visuals it is potato quality audio um but other than that uh things are things are going good How how are you doing ER I'm doing well I'm getting ready to go on a trip uh I'm heading down to uh Puerto Rico for a friend's wedding um we uh I call her my first wife because I I married her in a middle school play um and she's my sister's best friend still and so we're we're going to go down um to celebrate with her um so I'm very happy to get out of the very rainy DC weather right now I went on a run earlier and it was supposed to be 10 miles and we got like an utter downpour starting at around Mile Three

so I ran six miles because it took me three more miles just to get back home yeah well I I got to imagine with the beard that you're rocking that kind of uh downpour is going to be quite the accumulation you know like you end up weighing an extra 10 lbs just by absor under your chin it's actually good resistance training yeah terrible on the neck though terrible terrible on the neck terrible but you've been playing any board games lately I guess we should talk about those on a uh board game podcast people don't tune in to hear us talk about board games they want to know about the the training I do when I run in my beard weight um hey we could we could turn this into a kettle bell podcast if we wanted to go over my routine right now like that is a whole world in and of itself like and and I'm like this dorky soft touchy feely type of guy uh the world of kettle bells does not typically cater to the soft touchy Fey audience just let's leave it at that well uh I have been playing some games so I've been playing more of Witchcraft uh I'm I'm working my way through there's a campaign in in witchcraft uh it's not anything too too crazy so far like it doesn't change the gameplay experience that much um but it's interesting and it definitely gives the game quite a bit of uh legs for it being a solo only game

um which I've been enjoying a lot and then I also got a play of spots in um push your luck Dalmation game I like that I like Dalmations and as any child who has grown up watching extensive amounts of 101 Dalmations I like it you you mean both movies oh yes extensive amounts well I mean I I mean extensive amounts of repeat did you not like have a VHS that was just worn out by by playing that over and over again not1 dominations Lion King was our was our big Jam yeah we had a lot of lion king um we straddled different Disney Generations I typically think of like my generation ending right around maybe Pocahontas or um uh even uh Tarzan is maybe the eclipse of our era of Disney but like Lion King was like third or fourth grade that was perfect for me Everyone Cared about it mhm but then we we had the older ones that were 101 Dalmatians Beauty and the Beast I remember Aladdin coming out it was a big deal Return of Jafar came out I remember talking even as like second graders being like well it's not as good because Robin Williams isn't cast in the role

and that's why they didn't put it in the movie theater obviously I mean that's probably not wrong um so tell me about spots so it is a game where you get dealt uh cards that have dogs on them that you have to roll dice and fill in the spots that you have on your dog so like all the dogs have like three two to four different places to place D and the Dy have to be an exact number uh you roll the Dy there are like six different actions you take um and if you ever have more than in at this point I forget because I played it earlier this week but like it's either seven or five die and you're like you can't place this dice somewhere section uh you bust and you have to get rid of all the dogs that you have not completed um and it's uh really tight cuz you have to the actions make it really precarious where you can't just do like it's hard to play it safe you kind of have to take risks and it's choosing how much of a risk you can take um I really love the aesthetic of this I I just brought it up the illustrations are awesome and the the cards themselves are really cool um

initially when I looked at the cover art uh I guess for the riginal Edition I'm seeing that there's a a newer Edition um but the original Edition makes makes it look very uh Domino's esque uh whereas the current art that just has the dog in the middle and a couple dice placement on top of it that's um that's pretty interesting too I like it yeah it's cool it's fun little it it's small it's really easy to teach like I I can see this being a game that I could play with with my parents um uh really just about anybody um yeah I liked it I I would recommend checking it out it's on board game arena that's how I played it um I feel like this would be a game that playing in person might even be more fun just because it's everybody loves Roland dice Roland dice is like a universally positive Human Experience now I know you're a big drw poter fan uh have you played the Oink game rafter 5 no I haven't even okay I've heard of it you should look it up I I just uh played that recently at the local game night here and you mentioning spots made me think of like smaller games that I really enjoy it's a very cool stacking dexterity game the easiest analog is uh Rhino hero super battle but in an oink sized box uh so it's even more precarious it is silly and goofy

and weird and very Japanese as with many OA games uh but uh it was absolutely a hit and something that was uh one of those like visceral as soon as you see it you know you want to play it types of experiences um often referred to as like kind of a beer and pretzels type of game um we had experienced Gamers uh we had um newer Gamers uh we had a 12-year-old uh and we had um someone who was a grandma there and we all had a great time at this uh public uh gaming event it was just a blast rafter 5 if you if you like dexterity games or you have a tolerance for them if they're like at the stacking variety uh then this is an easy one to have on hand and and worth checking out um you don't really need to think too much about strategy or anything uh and that's not really kind of the point of these types of games M um the only other thing that I wanted to to to mention gaming wise maybe you'll have some recommendations for me or some listeners uh might is I've been thinking hard about what it is I like so much about Spirit Island and what I want out of that experience and what I want um to to maybe not replace that experience but to replicate that in

different ways um it's not just that it's a Cooperative game that's part of it it's not just that it's uh a game that's big and Meaty with lots of pieces though that's part of it uh core of the experience to me in spirit Island that I don't think many other board games do in quite the same way is the kind of cultivation aspect you feel like you're on the back foot as the Invaders are coming in you have a really distinct character but then you're making really interesting choices about how you're going to flesh out that character through the growth through whether you get minor or major Powers um how you cultivate the island and the choices that you make about where you position yourself uh there's a lot of preparation that one thing leads to another which leads to another and it's not really a a engine builder but there is this sort of curve to it an arc of empowerment that is so tasty in that game um that I'm hoping to find some other experience particularly in a multiplayer cooperative game uh you might already be like oh my God Jack have you played this game Imperium uh but um the uh my my instincts right now uh initially led me

to aon's end which is a game that people like but I I haven't uh touched at all though I did interview the designer at one point um but then I got turned on to void fall which I thought was a competitive game which it is but it also has a Cooperative mode and normally that's like a big red flag for me when a game is both cooperative and competitive and it can be a little bit of everything it feels like it's not particularly good at anything but uh it seems like from doing a little research people really like The Cooperative mode and some people consider that the the favorite mode of playing and there's a lot of comparisons to like this is a space forx Spirit Island so I I might try and check that out but I don't know based off of my my love for Spirit Island what what's in your mind what what do you think you'd recommend to me aon's end is really solid I think that that is a game um I I've played played it um through Steam um cuz there was like a steam like a Humble Bundle sale at one point or another that I got that as part of it um I think that's really rad um have you have you played Mage Knight uh I have and I got rid of Mage Knight and then I got Mage Knight again and then I got rid of Mage Knight and then I got Mage Knight again oh okay and

then decided third time it's still not for me and I got rid of Mage Knight again yeah yeah that's that was the other one I was thinking of cuz that I mean it's it's a pretty heavy Cooperative game and you do definitely like build in power but it's it's a little obtuse in some ways so I think that that's that's fair it's not quite the same as Spirit Island um void fall fall sounds interesting I I remember seeing this I had no clue there is a I guess I mean I really should have looked at who designed it Nigel buckle and David Turk the designers of Imperium uh I should have known there would be a well they Imperium doesn't have Cooperative but um to my knowledge unless unless there's a community but certainly there are plenty of people who have answered the question you know like on BGG people have asked if I only intend on Ever playing this solo is it worth getting and people are like yes absolutely I've only ever played this solo and I don't regret my purchase and then there are people asking the same question about cooperative and there are people being like I only ever play a cooperative and you know I've played it once competitive and instantly recognize that for me Cooperative is the only way that I want to play this game um I would have to see for myself right because hype is real people who have invested money in something tend to be more

favorable towards it because they are either consciously or subconsciously trying to justify their purchase um and especially if you feel like you were part of the campaign to make something come out which I believe void fall was uh crowdfunded so I I don't know there's a degree of skepticism but also optimism involved so I want to check it out yeah totally I mean I I think based on what I'm seeing for one thing I love Imperium despite all its flaws uh so I think the same designers I'm I'm down to go in on anything they have going on um I think I haven't gotten void fall yet because of the expense um and also like I it's a chonco it's a chonko and at the same time like I'm down to play Space 4X games I don't usually love them like they're I I like sci-fi so I I want to like for space 4X games but I just they usually don't land for me quite as well MH um so I think that was like another reason where there there are some things that kept me from trying it out but I mean it does look it does look great if there's a uh Cooperative mode I can see this being being a hit um I would love to hear your thoughts after you are able to

check it out at some point or another if you're out I'm a huge Eclipse fan and uh this kind of feels like it's in that vein of being like a very yoy uh action forx game um and mine Clash has done some really awesome stuff so I don't know I'll check it out uh but it's interesting uh that you bring up um Imperium and uh Mage Knight uh and we mentioned Spirit Island and also we're talking about void fall where some people are like the I you ever play it solo these are games that are iconically or purportedly iconically in void Fall's case um beloved by solo playing audiences so what does that mean for us I mean I think we are currently at a time where solo board gaming is the best it's ever been um and in 2025 solo board gaming is a super viable path for someone to get into the hobby I think um we're talking about that this week which is just solo board gaming in the year 2025 um I think that yeah there are so many amazing games

that came from pandemic era that are just now getting to being published uh there are a lot of games that have been uh published recently that are not solo only games but have solo modes um I pulled up Board Game Geek uh just to see what their top sellers are and aside from aul duel uh all of these either have a solo mode that's just implemented in the game or a solo mode implemented by the community in a way that is satisfying um and I think that that is kind of the great thing about where we are right now in Solo games is that pretty PR much any board game coming out right now not this is not true across the board but for the most part any board game coming out right now either has a solo mode a dedicated solo mode within the rule book or there is a community solo mode that has been tested and played and confirmed to be like a good functioning solo mode um and I play a lot of games solo I mean I think that that's my primary way of playing games just because of how my work schedule is

set up and also just I like like that's that's how I spend my free time is like I got nothing else going on I'll either set up something really quick I'll set up something really big I will play it by myself I will have a lovely time doing so um and I think another thing to just consider with it is it's slowly becoming more accepted that this is a thing that you can do right and we talked about that on prior podcast where you know like solo gaming is something that uh has had a stigma Bard gaming in general as adults has a public stigma though I think that's largely gone away um but there was a time when if you were like at the water cooler at work and people are like what do you do and they're like oh I'm really into um I I'm on my adult soccer league okay well what do you do oh I'm really into baking oh what do you do oh I play board games and people would be like like Monopoly um and I don't think that's as persistent of a thing anymore because board games have come to the Forefront that is going to happen to a degree but it is nowhere near what it was say 15 years ago however there is a similar stigma uh that people have towards um uh solo gaming uh even among

other Gamers like uh you know like you'll hear people say like oh the the reason why I play board games is because it's something for me to do with my friends it's a social thing I have no interest in Ever playing solo board games and it's like if you just wanted to hang out with friends it could be anything clearly there is something that you're invested in with board games and I think people associate playing board games by yourself as like somehow a lacking Endeavor and it could be that you do want the an opponent to challenge you but if your investment is with the the game itself even partially uh then having a solo opponent uh can be a really interesting way to play a game and in some ways can be the best way to play a game um especially if you're considering ing like uh strategic implications of moves and you don't necessarily have access to players that want to meet you at that same level then an otoma is if well-designed can be a fantastic way of testing your strategic muscle um improving your skill out the game and really exploring systems in a way that um opponent who either doesn't want to commit to that level or just doesn't click with the game in the same type of way might not um so that that's a cool thing about uh solo gaming but

one thing I I wanted to kind of talk about when I was throwing around this um this topic idea with uh Eric was that we're at a different era um the first time that I recall uh hearing largely about solo gaming um it was probably early 2010s probably around the arrival of Mage KN um and hearing about people talking about playing a Cooperative game by themselves you're playing pandemic which wasn't on the box as a one to four player game it was a two to four player game but playing it by yourself uh Lord of the Rings the um uh the the uh RAR Kenia game playing that by yourself where you're using multi multi- hands um and then also playing even competitive games multiple hands but playing one against another in order to get a game played that wouldn't otherwise be something that you'd get to the table and then I think it was um I mean certainly there were other game companies that were developing uh solo modes at this point but when I first took notice that it was really becoming an official thing was when viticulture uh came out and Morton monrad Peterson um who is now the head of the uh OTA

Factory that almost exclusively I think works with uh uh ston Meer games or rather ston Meer games exclusively works with them for otoma and they've branched out to other things um I think Morton contacted stonem and was like hey you're coming out with this cool game um do you mind if I get some of the documents because I'd love to like actually create a solo mode for this I I think it was just a fan Endeavor at first um I'd have to go back I I have a couple interviews with Morton that I could have researched for this uh and jamy STM talking about this event as well um but um that's when it felt like it was becoming an official thing and especially with arrival to me of terraforming Mars and sidee right at the same time that's like 2016 uh that's when like these big games were like hey we have components and dedicated modes large sections of our rulebooks that are about solo gaming and we are adopting this as a completely uh justifiable reason why you might purchase this game and that felt like a big shift then covid happened and that's uh that's when I think it shifted from being something where it was a nice accommodation that would occasionally

happen to board game Publishers were seeing that uh unless we have the absolute love of our audience we have to have a single player and two- Player version of our game to have any real viability yeah uh coming out with something that was three and up um was an absolute Rarity because you had no idea if people were going to be able to find the audience for that and now we're in this postco world um there are still some bigname games that are coming out that don't have it you know you mentioned Azul duel um obviously uh arcs isn't a a solo mode game out of the box uh but leader games did just hide um uh someone to be a dedicated solo designer uh there I don't know like we're in a different world and I've been talking for a while what what are your thoughts about like where we are as a solo gameplay Community now contrasted to you know say like when you first started doing you know your your tiptoes into board gaming yeah so well I mean I'll say uh me getting into board games was around 2 16 like that is I mean maybe 2015 um was when I was dipping my toes in with Katon and pandemic um so for me

solo gaming has for the most part been at least a facet of the community it's not it was definitely not like the the primary uh way I played games back then like I was only playing games in in social settings um but I think it was I the the work schedule I had um right out of college um was a lot of days working and then a lot of days not working and I just started being like Oh I love playing board games I have these games that have solo modes like pandemic uh and then that got me into uh getting Gloom Haven and then just playing through Gloom Haven solo and like having all of these experiences where I was just like I to me this is just a thing that happens um but it's become more and more accessible like I at this point am more surprised if a game doesn't have a solo mode like from when I first enter the hobby super reasonable for a game to just not have any any solo mode at all and now it's definitely to the point where I expect a game to have a solo mode and if it doesn't I expect the

community to have made one for it for example ARS doesn't have a solo mode out of the box but there is a there are like five or 10 solo modes on Board Game Geek and at this point any game that I purchase unless it is a a dedicated two-player game that's that's the only time where I I I think that solo modes can work but not always in dedicated two-player games um but that's like the time where I'm like okay this game might or it might not I'd have to look into it before I get the game but yeah at this point pretty much any board game I own I expect to have a solo mode um either through the box or through the community and it's become just such a through line for a lot of games and how and how I experience them at least do you think that they is a consideration for like solo dedicated components that I mean obviously you and I both play solo games almost every game that has a solo mode I at least try the solo mode um I do more multiplayer gaming uh contrasted to your uh more frequently playing game solo but we both consume the material yeah what about you know

like I don't know like I kind of hate when there are variants to a game and there are elements that are dedicated to that variant and I just never touch it and they just kind of sit in the box and I go like man I wish they hadn't spent production money on this whole thing that I never touch do you think that people who never want to play a solo game that they look at the solo materials in the same way like man this game could have been five bucks cheaper if they didn't have the development time and the production cost on the solo cards and tokens and all the other crap that's in this box I mean probably but that's kind of their problem to deal with like well I mean yeah it is their problem to deal with but it is interesting that there is a expectation now that you're going to have a solo mode right and so now in a time where uh margins are really small people are talking about the tariffs that just got announced uh I sent you and the cardboard underground which is our our group for uh Pax dwellers um an article from a a company um a oneman company that is like hey Reddit audience tell me how you feel about like if I if I were to say I need some extra help to actually deliver a game and I'm going to break down all my numbers here and it I thought it was like a really transparent and Earnest like here's what I'm facing and here's

what I did with my last game and if I had this again it would be like Financial collapse for the company so how do you think you would want to be communicated with if you backed my game um and I found it more interesting from the the kind of like numbers perspective now is like well I got to have the production cost because I got to have the solo thing but I guess I don't know it's capitalism right yeah my my two sents on that are one it helps sell games like if I know a game has a has a in thebox Solo mode that tells me one that they've play tested it enough that they're willing to include it in the Box two if there are extra components they have made the decision that those components are necessary enough to include in the solo mode to make them and figure out a spot for them in the box so for me as a person who mainly plays game solo uh that helps sell games to me like if I know that I'm getting a solo mode from the publisher I will take that over a board game geek solo mode any day of the week so it's helping them sell games and on top of

that I think about it also a bit in Reverse which is there are parts of the game that I don't touch if I'm only ever playing game solo and at the same time that I wouldn't want to take away my solo experience from a game because I didn't want it to fit in the box or or I was worried that things would not fit into the box um I don't want to take away the multiplayer experience for the people who that is the primary way they play so I in my mind I understand that it's it is getting more expensive to make games uh due to Rising production costs and the Tariff scare that we're still seeing how it's going to work out for for people importing games into the United States um so it is a consideration that it's maybe a bit unfortunate that their components are being made that are going to make games more expensive for people who won't engage with them at the same time that's it's a little the Publishers are just going to have to make some decisions on whether or not they would like to sell the games to an audience of

solo board gamers or if they want to Outsource that development time and component cost to the people on Board Game Geek where they're just going to say hey we're not going to a solo mode because clearly the community is doing it for themselves and they're just going to have to weigh that with will that make up the cost of the game yeah I I guess it all comes down to is it going to attract more people if you have solo on the box and Publishers are doing it because it does uh and I honestly think that most solo modes are Savvy enough that they don't require that much additional overhead compon but this was a discussion on Reddit not too long ago where someone was like I hate you know all these dedicated solo modes in the game they they're making my games more expensive uh and I was like I never really thought about it that way because you know like I do think of game bloat um with stuff that I never want to engage with and modularity is often a big problem with that but you know I I never really thought of solo modes as being part of that but let's let's talk about like now here in 2025 we have so many types of games that have had interesting solo adaptations that I back in 2015 2016 I wouldn't have necessarily thought that there would be

meaningful and cool ways to play these games a good example of this is uh the Fellowship of the Ring trick taking game mhm um I think it's actually the Lord of the Rings The Fellowship of the Ring the trick-taking game uh God that's a terrible name but point being is there is a trick-taking game with a solo mode and it works pretty well and there are people on uh Reddit and BGG and other areas who are playing it specifically as a solo game who are having a really good time with it um and so what what are are the things that you're either most delighted in what what makes a good solo game to you and what are some examples of like games that kind of continue to impress you um in their solo adaptations yeah I mean I think for me the thing that I most want out of a solo game or a solo mode is uh uh just being mentally engaged while I'm playing like for the most part I think there are sometimes where I just want to have a game on the table and I clock out mentally like this Justus a stress relief thing uh Cascadia is definitely there for me um where it's yeah I

mentally clock out when I play a Cascadia as well I know I know you do but I I think I want games that either give me some sort of a symmetry to deal with uh which is why Spirit island is is a rad solo game uh Imperium works really well Imperium is I in my opinion for one thing it's my most played solo game um where that is just I am there's so much asymmetry to take care of with or uh uh take a handle of every time you play where you have to learn your faction you have to learn the faction you're playing against um and you can play against the same faction playing the same faction and it's going to be a really different experience each time just based on what cards come out so for me I think having something new every time I play or new choices um are really that's the thing that's going to make me play a game solo over and over um I also don't necessarily love a game that just has a AI not ai ai is not quite the right term for it but just an opponent that is supposed to mimic a human player like I think there are some games that have that have that where it just doesn't

land and it's it doesn't give you the depth of playing against a another player and it doesn't give you the depth to make interesting choices CU you're going to win the game anyways yeah very true I I tend to think of this as uh like I I think when I first played wingspan solo is when I really codified this feeling um which I really like the ottoman wingspan uh and in that it really simulates the experience of playing against a real opponent opponent in that you're effectively doing the same thing that you would do otherwise uh and the opponent is having the same interactions with the game that you would experience from an actual person they're going to take up some of the eggs they're going to activate some uh Powers they're going compete with you on the endgame scoring things but it doesn't have the the the overhead of actually having to perform all those actions it has very rudimentary steps that are involved that still provide you the experience of playing the game um and a a challenge that isn't uh I guess just uh predictable you know like it it has a degree of Randomness that um you know

has the unpredictability of a human that you're playing against with a degree of accountability that it will make choices that uh are meaningful for it or generally meaningful for it if it's too rudimentary uh then it just kind of feels um solitary instead of solo if that makes sense uh whereas if it's too laborious um and I think to contrast a ston Meer versus ston Meer game um a lot of people really like scythe and Scythe was one of the first games that I played solo but I actually like the game solo at this point I mean it's fine and I'm glad that it's there but I think it it has too many uh too much overhead involved in the uh performance of the Solo in that game and that may be partly at fault with uh one of the most difficult uh types of games to adapt well uh is like a dude's on a map combat heavy game um I think uh uh mine Clash we were talking about mine Clash earlier uh did a pretty Valiant attempt with Ironwood which is a dedicated two-player game but has uh some solo uh progression for each faction that you can play as um that has a good amount of overhead but it's it it is good uh yeah not perfect

but good uh and then um hidden movement and games with uh deception as an element uh social deduction are the other types of games that tend to be the hardest to come up with an interesting adaptation it's I I think that just goes with the joy of those games comes from trying to decipher your opponent which it's if it's a a deck of cards it's either so random that you can't engage in that part of the game or it's so not randomized that it is Trivial to interact with that part of the game of trying to like figure out what your opponent is doing and it that just is kind of what it is uh and I think that those games if anybody has ever made a good solo mode of a pre-existing like hidden movement or social deduction game I will be very interested to try it out does code names hold on I'm going to check right now on 14 Geeks does code names have a solo mode I'm actually looking up right now Beast does beast have a solo mode and sure enough play as Beast against Hunter Bots uh and that Mak sense yep yep let uh

and uh replies are very positive about this solo mode and uh some of the feedback which I also love how much of the community engagement is here not only the person coming up with the solo mode but the feedback that the players who are essentially play testers are giving and the amount of iteration that has clearly gone into this based off of the feedback um so once again you know solo Community uh just uh really really crushing it here um but yeah uh you know like you put a game out there and solo gamers are going to find a way to make a solo mode whether you wanted one or not um not to say that that should be exploited uh and if you're a publisher then I think uh if you haven't already come up with a solo mode um and you're on the verge of publishing a game then consider bringing in a second designer for the dedicated solo mode uh there are plenty that have done that a great example is Ricky Royal uh did the uh solo mode for PAX Premiere which I still think is the best solo mode for any of karly's games to date um and maybe is my favorite way to play PX Premiere um but uh you know like Cole was like I don't really have the

experience in playing solo games that's not really my jam however I see the value in it and I want to bring in someone who really understands uh these types of games and can you know like bring a a a panach to this that I think Rises to what the design deserves uh and that was extremely successful um or now I'm just I guess c whiring um I'm spiraling out and keep going here um on rout uh there was an initial real bad mechanical Maris uh solo mode that was yeah it was part of that that early wave of like well we we should accommodate everyone let's put a solo mode in here and it was bad and it wasn't uh until the uh Community came up with the mechanical Maris 2.0 and uh all of the robotic factions which then leader games approached the designer of those to make those official expansions uh in the official solo mode and continued to produce that uh in conjunction with that Designer which is you know like a a great way to go about it that if you don't have a solo mode but you think that you could sell an expansion as a solo dedicated expansion then look to the community and see if someone has done it and see if you can work out an agreement um to use that as

the design you don't have to put everything on your back especially if you don't have the experience in designing solo games yeah and the thing that I was going to say I was thinking about it earlier and just wasn't quite sure where I what point to to bring it up but g games that have been out for a bit can also get a solo mode added in either later on Via expansion or through uh um apps like I I've played Clank solo Clank does not have a solo mode in the box but uh uh Renegade games I think that's the publisher dire direwolf digital is the one who implemented it so I'll say them um made a solo mode of Clank like that you can do that you can do expansions that introduce it furnace has solo modes available on Board Game Geek but then they also have the expansion which has a solo mode that they introduce after the release of the original game so solo modes are just way more easy to they're far easier to implement I feel like nowadays with you can have computers do the solo mode version of it so the computers are doing all the heavy lifting of it through apps um when I looked up code names solo uh one thing I found was an April

Fool's Day post by the publisher saying that Cod name solo existed and then the other one was there's apparently through the code names app they do like daily puzzles of code names that they'll like give you a clue and you have to figure out what the things are in it that's technically a solo mode I haven't played that one so I'm not going to comment too much I just I just just found it but like you can make more expectations that your players will have a phone that can operate the solo Mode work that needs to be done because I agree that especially early on there were a lot of solo modes that required the player to do all of the work to do the small part of the fun part of the game uh like with Scythe Scythe solo I haven't played but based on your description I've played games very similar where most of the solo mode is uh uh busy work to reset so that you can play solo again um so I think we're also at a point where phones and apps can be used to augment a

game that doesn't have a solo mode so that it can have a solo mode right yeah apps are uh a lot of people are resistant to utilization of apps for board games and I I totally understand that but as a tool to help with automation um it could be really helpful yeah um a lot of um uh uh Dungeon Crawl type games uh work especially well with an app uh to drive things um even coming out as a secondary thing um you know like heroquest uh the the modern uh remake of heroquest um that has an app that you can play with or you can play in the traditional way uh where it's one V all but using the app you can play fully cooperatively or you can play solo uh to automate the opponent uh and then there's also um like Star Wars Imperial assault which is one of my favorite dungeon crawls of all time um has some really fantastic solo uh and Cooperative modes that you can play with that um when the game was intended for being like a hidden movement game a One V all um now uh the the last thing that I I think we should kind of touch on on this um this whole topic of solo gaming is

like what games do you think if there's a portion of the audience here who have not dived into solo yet um what are to you like good solo Gateway Games the games that you would be like here or three that I'm pretty confident that if someone tried these then it would give them a a pretty good experience of solo and if you like that then I think you should you know move on to to other solo games based off of your own preferences yeah well one game that I think is a good Gateway game for solos then I I also think it's a good Gateway game for just board games in general would be harmonies um harmonies has a really approachable solo mode um that is especially if you are already aware of how the uh competitive version of The Game Works uh or if you aren't aware of how the competitive version of The Game Works harmonies has a really solid solo mode to introduce people into that um another one that I would recommend because it kind of got me into solo gaming uh would be Maki which is uh solo only uh you can do it print and play and it works totally fine um but it's a solo only board game that has just enough challenges but it's not overwhelming um I think that one is a

really easy game to play especially because it's print and play and I think that's also like a massive part of the solo board Gaming Community is print and blazs um I think mck is a great introduction to how do solo board games work uh and especially since that when is solo only it doesn't have to like rearrange itself from being a different game to be a solo game um and then finally and this one is this one is more for a person who has played board games and is like really into the hobby but maybe hasn't tried solo games Spirit island is is the best solo game like that just it is a good it's really good Gateway game it's a really good just end end of end of if I had to choose one board game to play solo for the rest of my life is a at the moment is a tossup between Imperium and spirit Island like those are like the two best solo board games in my opinion now now that Imperium Horizons is out and I've played it enough I think I had it ranked lower in my solo board game ranking that we did when I first joined the channel uh cuz I hadn't played Horizons yet but I think with Horizons that's good it's a great solo game I don't think I would recommend

Imperium as a Gateway whereas Spirit Island I think is approachable you can learn how to play it cooperatively and get the experience is the same for the most part as the solo edition versus playing cooperatively so those those would probably be my three and those are kind of approaching different levels of experience in the hobby with harmonies being somebody who's new to board games in general Maki being somebody who has played board games maybe it isn't like as serious of a hobby as it is for like you and me and then Spirit Island for somebody who is as serious as you and me who is a very into board games but maybe hasn't played solo games yet yeah well I I think those are fantastic choices mine uh if I were to just add another three to that uh because off the top of my head harmonies was one of the ones I was going to mention uh regicide is a fabulous Cooperative game but it's really good as a solo game and it has the uh kind of like cultural Touchstone of you're playing with a deck of cards which has for a lot of people the familiarity to solitire which to many people they think that's the only tabletop game that's played solo right so um you know having a deck of cards can give you that degree of feeling or familiarity and everyone has a deck of

cards somewhere or at least access to a deck of cards so uh low investment and fantastic game um then I think uh that um it may be uh a little bit uh more complex Lex uh but terraforming Mars Aries Expedition is um really soft on what um the the parameters are that you're having to face against it's difficult uh to win but it's not really difficult to work against and it has the addition of giving you a slightly more rigid structure than what an opponent is going to do which just turns the screw just a little bit um not necessarily making a more interesting game but it gives you just a little bit different of a view on what that game is um in a really interesting way uh which I I have nothing but great things uh to say about that and then uh from there you know like there's any number of um games that you could check out but I think uh so many people have access to wingspan uh or now any of the span games uh but I I do really think that the solo mode for wings ban is not really like noteworthy other than

it's just so nice it's just like very well put together very well presented uh very low overhead while still being more than just get as many points as you can um I think it beautifully uh like matches the level of game that wingspan is uh by being more complex than just a a light game but not so complex that someone new to gaming would not be able to ever figure it out uh and so I think wingspan is probably the best solo adaptation that uh uh stonem Meer has done uh certainly um the most accessible one uh so I I think that's a good way to go too yeah totally and I think that the other recommendation I would have is more of a nebulous one which is just if you really like a game and there is a solo mode for that game available either in the box which would be at least for a person starting out would be my recommendation is a lot of the board games you already own probably have a solo mode in the Box um or if you just really like a game and there's a solo mode available on Board Game Geek or Reddit or any of the other places where board game or solo board

gamers are publishing rules for games that don't already have them give that a go cuz you already like that game so you know at least that part of it is is taken care of like I think sometimes you might not like a game and if you don't like that game it might be difficult to enjoy the solo mode because you just don't like that game and that's totally a reasonable take to have um but so many games that are coming out nowadays and that are getting into collections nowadays either already have a solo mode or have solo rules available online um then I think I would recommend trying those out cuz those are going to be the games that you you've already gotten through the tough part which is learning the base rules the solo rules typically don't change the game you're playing that much for the most part sometimes yes sometimes like the the solo mode for Sky Team some of the rules have changed a little bit because it's just one player as opposed to two players but that that's notwithstanding don't don't don't don't listen to those those are the exception I Ru I think Eric's advice is spoton if something is a um if it's something that you're passionate about chances are that you're going to see the solo mode through to the end and you will be able to maintain some

objectivity that it's not the game that's bad it may be the solo mode is bad so if you already know that you like it great and that goes with Gateway Games in general a lot of uh emphasis is put in this hobby about G Gateway Games you know what's a good Gateway game um to me a good Gateway game is one that is something that someone is really excited about and has a an honest opinion about it uh an example of that is like if your best friend is someone who is way into Lord of the Rings they have not played any board games since Monopoly as a kid but they've played plenty of like complex video games and they understand that war of the ring is a really heavy duty war game there's going to be tons of rules and components and all this stuff and they're like yeah that sounds great that's exactly what I want out of a big old boore game then that could be the perfect Gateway game for them exactly um in one one other thing I wanted to note and this is less this is kind kind of looping back to a different part of the conversation but uh there's also so many resources online now to play board games in general that you can just filter for solo mode so it's also easy to find games that interest you like through board game arena they have a

filter that is show me games that have solo modes and there's a lot of them there's there's so many of them and I think that that takes up so much of the administrative work that sometimes solo modes have that uh it can be a very easy way for one learning how to play the game and then two playing the game solo um totally so just as another thought uh it this is a much easier gateway to play solo modes or just play board games in general but solo modes uh uh that that we did not have access to I think in this is a new development that board game arena has as much of a collection as it does of solo games um so get yeah you'll get to squeeze more out of that lemon things are expensive now and if you haven't played your game solo maybe that's a different take on them and a way to enjoy them that you hadn't in the past and maybe you don't have to buy new games if you have 30 games on your shelf that have solo variants maybe it's a way to go but that also kind of represents our time to go and become solo Eric solo apart for the evening we will we will part here uh thank you to

our fantastic Community for listening thank you for tuning in if you have any comments or questions or you want to let us know what your favorite solo game is and why first of all I'd love to hear favorite solo games I think I'm always interested to see what people think of as like their favorite solo game so please and if you want to win a copy of Park second edition which has a solo mode and a better solo mode than Parks first edition you can comment over on the review that we have uh for it'll probably be up for like another week uh you can enter to win a copy of parks yeah that's a plug am I allowed to do a plug on this you're kind of in charge of the podcast part I think it's your channel you're allowed to do whatever you want on your channel take it I don't know Live Your Dreams man uh but I'm a GL for punishment please comment down below with any of your questions comments or concerns or email us at cardboard Herald gmail.com uh thank you all for listening thank you for tuning in uh I been Eric with cardboard Herold along here with Jack bye everyone

Progress saved