My Problem with Gloomhaven: Jaws of the Lion
Transcript
So yesterday I published a video all about cheating in board games or at least deciding that some homebrew or extra advantage can be given when the game one is cooperative and two necessitates it. Now that conversation was specifically about Jaws of the Lion, a campaign game that my wife and I are this close to finishing. We played another two episodes last night and once again didn't technically win the scenario we were on, but it was the sixth time we'd played it. We'd already uh leveled up. We'd went to another scenario, delaying this one for two whole sessions and we got the strategy figured out. It came down to a few card draws, a little bit of luck here and there. And I'm going to be totally honest. As much as I am enjoying playing Gloom Haven, as much as I love figuring out the puzzle and upgrading my characters and throwing axes halfway across the board while she relays dynamite, demolishing everything in her sight. I don't want to play a scenario for six, seven, or eight times. I want to move on with the story. So that has now prompted this video, a video about how campaign games progress and what you think is the best method for progression in these giant storytelling board games that I love so much. Now, I know a lot of you are here on this channel for the
same reason that I am here in this industry, which is uh Kingdom Death Monster, giant big black box of death, of gloom, and of uh cascading failure. And Kingdom Death sets in motion the first of what I was able to determine are three progression methods that campaign board games utilize. Kingdom death focuses on the uh there's no such thing as failure method. It's hard to be specific because the term I kind of want to use is fail forward, but it's actually not quite right. You see, fail forward is a whole another category and then gloom haven is a replay till you win. So, Kingdom Death, there's no true failure. When you dive into a game of Kingdom Death Monster, you're trying to keep your settlement alive. You're venturing out and fighting creatures and bringing resources back to home base and crafting and upgrading. And every now and then, or quite often in fact, things will not go the way you want it to go.
You will either lose an entire hunt, meaning that a lantern year has passed and the resources you desperately needed didn't come home with you, or you'll lose some of your prized warriors, meaning valuable skills and abilities and experience have now been left abandoned on the plains of uh darkness outside the uh glow of the lantern light. But no matter what happens, whether you've lost a fight, whether the resources you needed are missing, or your favorite heroes have died in combat, or if you have some glowing successes and easy easy victories due to some very, very critical dice rolls at the right moment, no matter what happens, the game continues forward. In Kingdom Death Monster, there's no such thing as failure. Well, until you lose the game, until your settlement dies, until you have to restart from the entire beginning. And that's not the same as fail forward. What I categorize as fail forward would be a campaign game like Tainted Grail. In this, you're not as worried about a settlement or, you know, overall survival of a waring party.
Instead, you're journeying through a narrative. And every step of the way, you might have some situations that result in the worst consequence possible and some that result in only positive glowing results. But every single step, every single chapter, every single choice that you make progresses the game and specifically progresses the game through the narrative. There is such thing as failure in Tainted Grail or in ISS Vanguard, but those failures don't mean you have to replay that same environment or that same situation and experience. You can you can journey back through the mist. You can go searching on the lost planets that you've neglected along the way, but you don't have to. And even if you do, the world will continue to grow and adapt and change. So, this is one of those games that uh does have failure, but that failure, even though it has consequences, continues progressing the narrative of the story. And eventually, you'll still hit endame even as you stumble your way forward. And even if that end game is a narrative path that doesn't quite sound like total victory.
And then finally, we come back to our lovely Gloom Haven. Gloom Haven Draws the Lion or Gloom Haven Gloom Haven or Gloom Haven Frost Haven or Gloom Haven Crimson Scales. All of these games functionally require you to win every single scenario or chapter that they present you with. Side scenarios are optional, of course, but for the main story line to progress or move forward, you need to level up, equip yourself, and learn the strategy well enough to win. And every victory is what actually pushes the game along. Now sir, in Big Box, Gloom Haven, and in Frost Haven, the world changes a little bit more than it does here in Jaws of the Lion. This is a little bit more narratively driven, a little bit more scripted. There's less routes for you to detour your way off of, less things to distract yourself with. You don't draw a bunch of extra road events and city events every time you fail and come back home. In base game Bloom Haven, the world still changes around you, but you still got to go fight the same battle. You still got to accomplish the same task. [sighs] And in Jaws, there's no option to level up past the character that you're playing.
I mean, we're near endgame, but we're also near level 9 already, and we'll hit that before we actually make it through the last few chapters. So, in this, we kind of hit the cap and then have to win our way to the end. base game Bloom Haven, you can go off detour on a little bit of a side route for a bit and you can end up triggering your leveling system. You can draw a new character. You can restart in a way which adds a little bit more dynism dynamism. It adds some different differentiation. Wow. Neither of those words are working for me. It adds some variability to the game. So my question, the ultimate conversation that I want to have because I I I found the conversation yesterday to be very interesting. A number of people responded to the video and a lot of people seem to feel the same way that Shar and I feel where you don't want to invalidate the rules of the game. You don't want to cheat your way to victory, but you do want to preserve the fun. And if at a certain point your time is being sacrificed due to the rules of the game and the way that the progression system works and the fun is being sacrificed, it's okay to fudge the numbers here or there as long as it's within the boundaries that you and your gaming party have agreed upon to continue moving forward. So out of these three
systems, what do you all prefer? Do you prefer a game that presents you with a dynamic puzzle like Gloom Haven and has you master, you know, learn and adapt and replay until you can overcome? I think there's value to that. I think the strategy determined or or or reliant in those type of campaign games is a little bit more deep. I think the uh opportunity to have big moments that you feel like you crafted and perfected yourself is probably a little bit stronger. But on the negative side, you can absolutely get stuck on chapter 1 or chapter 15 or 63 and end up playing it three game nights in a row while you're trying to get your opportunity to move forward.
Do you prefer a game like Kingdom Death Monster? a game that I call there is no such thing as failure. A nonfailure progression system where a loss isn't really a loss. It's a consequence. It's part of the brutal reality. It's what exists in the world of Kingdom Death. feel like that system lends itself to a bit more chaos, to reckless attacks or defensive plays to try to mitigate how wild the game system itself is. You're being pulled forward. There's no going back. There's no turning around. There's no pausing. There's no learning and strategizing. If you're facing a level two butcher and you've never fought him before and he rips your bloody head off, well, your head's being ripped off and you're going to go home mournful to the people who you love and tell the settlement that you need to make a few more babies and then journey back out again because life doesn't stop when a few of your civilization die.
Do you prefer that? A little bit more wild, a little bit more chaotic. I think the negative side here is Kingdom Death leads itself into a position where a loss never exists until it restarts the entire campaign. Takes a lot of gameplay to see end game for Kingdom Death Monster. That could be good. That could be bad. That could be seen as replaying the same system over and over again just on a grander 40hour long scale. I know a lot of people have gotten tired of fighting the White Lions specifically because they've had to do it so many times they as they've restarted those first 10 lantern years again. Or do you like a system where you fail forward like Tainted Grail or is Vanguard? A system where the narrative will continue in a very tangible way.
not abstract things or side things like a road event or city event that you draw in Gloom Haven, but the story is going and you can be strong and powerful during that course, during that narrative, or you could be weak and vulnerable. You could lose a scenario or succeed at a scenario and the consequences of that will have narrative threads that build out as the game continues to play itself. It's similar to kingdom death where there's no such thing as failure. But here, a chapter loss has consequences other than just losing resources. There's narrative ties that tell the story, that paint the picture, that change what might happen next. Kingdom death, you lose, you go home, you rebuild, you keep doing the same thing you would have done anyway. You just didn't bring it enough home. you didn't have enough with you.
You can create narrative overtones on it if you'd like, but it's not necessary. So, what do you prefer when it comes to campaign games? These big box games that I myself and many of you have fallen in love with over the years and probably played through a fair number of them yourself. Do you want a strategic puzzle? Do you want a game that rewards success with progression? Or do you want a game that uh has narrative consequences to the failure and the story continues revealing itself as you play? What do you think works best in this genre? What do you like to play the most? Is there one of these categories that you just really honestly won't pick up again or will only play digitally? I can see that being the case with something like Gloom Haven where restarting, resetting, and committing to another session takes quite a lot of time. But Kingdom Death also has a very very popular simulator that they've made. And so there's an argument on behalf of uh the speed and ease at which you can restart an entire arc. No one starts from zero in uh Gloom Haven. No one starts from zero in Tainted Grail.
Maybe the definition for Gloom Haven might be better as like there's only one failure, the loss of the game as a whole. So you have fail forward where the game narrative progresses no matter really what happens, win or loss, succeed or fail, and it'll come to an end story at some point, a narratively driven end story. You have Kingdom Death where there is no such thing as failure until there is. So there's only one true failure and then you have something like Gloom Haven where success is necessary. Okay. All right. Thank you for watching. Thank you for being here. Hopefully we can continue the conversation and uh continue playing some games. I am so excited that uh I have annihilated the first of my 10x10 challenge. I'll have a video coming out down the road talking about that, but I need to add the last little pip to Gloom Haven Jaws of the Lion there. And honestly, we're like three or four playthroughs above it at this point. We're going to finish it here in the next few weeks hopefully.
And then I think we're starting a in the table Gloom Haven campaign. Not on camera, just something to play together as a couple while the baby takes a nap or falls asleep a little bit earlier than us. But that's what I'm leaning towards. If you have suggestions as to the campaign game we should dive into, let me know. If you think Bloom Haven is the wrong choice, let me know. We've enjoyed it quite a lot both digitally and in the small box experience. So, the big box seems like maybe the next step we should take. Whatever the case though, whatever you do, remember to do the important thing. Get out or stay in and play some games. We'll see you later. Bye.