Skip to main content
Loading video...

Episode 93 - I'm Done With Campaign Games (And A Small Earth Abundance Retcon)

Transcript 1:19:48

you're listening to the broken me show a podcast that speaks passionately about board games for the benefit of those who play them my name's Luke Hector best known for the broken meeple YouTube channel and I'm an everyday gamer just like you and I'll be talking about reviews top 10 and just about anything that connects me to board games as long as I have a tea or coffee in hand that is so grab a cup relax and enjoy and remember it's only a game hi everybody this is Luke Hector oh trying to get the camera right on that one this is another podcast episode recording on the 12th of May 24 and we're in the middle of a heat wave in the UK which is oh so joyous for me Isn't it someone who lives in a newb buil house which turns into a saer the moment the Mercury gets above like 18° let alone early 20s as it is at the moment and yes I'm doing everything I can to keep the house cool curtains closed you know windows open at night you know ice drink I have smoothies now cuz I'm trying to go on a diet cuz I've put on a bit of weight over the last couple of months so I need to seriously lose a bit of that before the Expo uh but mainly just lose it in general got cooler which I can't use because the microphone will pick it up it's yeah I'm trying to keep myself cool and I don't like it I hate I hate the summer I hate the heat it's just not something that I'm particularly accustomed to but you know that being said it will cool down at the end of tonight and should be a bit better for the rest of May or at least proper May temperature so it

should be I think this is just a shortterm boost of heat but yes I'm going to dread when we get into June July and August and I start sweltering like a pig particularly when I'm trying to record videos because obviously I can't use any type of cooling when I'm recording a video because the sound would just pick up and you know all we have is an air fan you know freeze pack cooler we don't have air conditioning like the Americans and that so it's it's not my favorite time you know I would much rather be able to go somewhere like the Arctic Circle which I'm looking into doing but that wouldn't be until something like December January time when the northern lights are around and I know at the moment UK is apparently seeing the northern lights but I have not noticed them I've been doing other stuff and even then where I live you would have to use a camera lens in order to see them and I don't know about you but I don't want sloppy seconds when it comes to the Northern Lights you know if I see them I want to see them properly I want to be in the Arctic Circle up north you know Crystal Clear Skies no light pollution and seeing them for all their Glory that's how I want to see them I don't want to see some camera lens knock off of the Northern Lights I know it still looks cool but I don't know this is just me being you know picky with that oh well but that aside you know things are generally still fairly all right with the health you know the wrists are healing you know they're they're they're getting to a good point you know the left one is still a little Troublesome but not too bad you know that is definitely on the menend my right finger middle finger on the other other hand I've stubbed it so many times now I swear it's broken beyond belief so

that one's always a bit of a pain but other than that generally pretty good you know work is work whatever I'm not exactly like bored over about work especially as it's a annual appraisal time of year which is never a good thing to have to sit through I hate annual appraisals you know they're always focus on the negative and it's always trying to tick a box for PR and HR purposes so you you never feel that an appraisal is done for your benefit you always feel it's just something that has to be done by the corporates and you know you all that gets you know you you you might have like oh you do really well at this this and this right that's under the carpet now let's spend the next 45 minutes talking about this negative that we must address you know it's always like that just never a fan uh blog wise though uh uh the blog could be better I mean it's still going strong 23322 figures for subscribers but recent content has not been as popular as I would like I I haven't done a huge amount since actually know I feel like I've done a decent amount I mean I got the moon breaker expansions and moon breaker review released so Moon Breakers has done all right 2,000 views but that's been out since May the 1st so I don't know the expansions not even a th000 views canvas barely over 1,000 views the expansions nowhere near 1,000 views so yeah viewership has been quite low recently and I wonder if that's just down to timing bank holiday weekends in the UK the weather being good therefore you know people are off out doing stuff even did the earth abundance prototype review which we'll get on to in a minute

cuz I need to address something with that one but that one has been popular you know two and a half thousand views not too bad since May the 5th you know give credit that one's done pretty well but uh again I need to talk about that fairly shortly but yeah just not a huge amount uh viewership wise so hopefully some content along the way will you know address those concerns I mean what have I got left the problem is not a lot gets released this time of year so you know we don't get anything until about sort of Gen Con time when it comes to board game releases and then it all explodes Essen which makes that bit horrendous for me so at this time of year there really isn't a lot of games to talk about I mean I've said that I probably should do a Great Western Trail New Zealand review at some stage um I had Moon rakers and you're uh abundance thing but other than that the only review copy I've got at the moment is a game called Open Season by sitdown games they've sent me that so I need to do a review for that one and at the moment people have requested I review unsettled which I'm going to give some first impressions of later this episode but you know it's not a review copy it was just a late delayed Kickstarter that finally arrived and I'm like okay fine maybe I can give it a review but I probably should use this time to do some top 10 lists you know the patreons did vote on some top 10 lists and I am overdue trying to get those out but have no fear they are coming I mean I definitely want to do a uh solo list for I think top 10 sandbox games I think that would be quite an enjoyable one to do but they voted on top 10 irritating design decisions and you know in games

and I was going to do that solo for us this weekend but then um Mark monk from Ninja geek games got in touch you know we were discussing what we were going to play at games Expo and I said to him well you know what you know let's do a collab again you know it worked well last time I'm doing this list you're fancy and he said yeah let me get on with it so I'll wait for him to see what he says you know probably if he can get a list together of 10 I've already got my list um I've got my list shortlisted I just need to arrange it in rankings but you know once we've both got a list together we'll do a live stream so we'll do a live stream collab with the top 10 irritating design decision so I'm a bit overdue patreon sorry about that but you are at least getting a live stream collaboration for it so you're getting a better version of the list just a little bit later than I would have liked to have got it out so sorry about that uh anything else to really mention no not really well other than that content is a little bit on the light side this is not a UK games Expo preview I will do one but I'm going to wait until the next episode because the next episode will be literally a few days before the Expo starts and I think that's better timing wise because then all the information we're going to have about the Expo would have been released by then but also as I glance through the Expos uh you know like list of oh here's the new games that are on and stuff like that there is really not a lot I mean the games Expo really is not good for new releases there's one or two that I've seen Ali cat's got a nice uh simple one coming out uh there's a a kind of Lord of the Rings Jewel coming out um

you know which I we don't have much detail on but I should be able to hopefully get a chance to try that one I think Asma day is sort of put um putting that one out and other than that there just really isn't a lot that I'm interested in or haven't played already and you or haven't seen Essen before so the Expo for me is mainly just a case of see what's there immerse in the atmosphere meet people uh go play some games I mean going to be doing a fair amount of gameplay you know Mark as I mentioned Mark monk earlier wants me to teach him in his friends hegemony so that's going to happen and you know that'll be a pretty lengthy game but that should be quite fun but other than that you know I'll just play some games if I see people I know from the content creator World it'll be great to play some games with you know the respected ones of that crowd uh I think um Sarah SHA board games in the minute should be there and we tend to meet up and have a good time I'll no doubt probably spot her at the Press preview but it's hinted that I'll be able to try out um inventors the South Tigress uh cuz she's very good at getting that Garfield games are very good at sending her Advanced copies not necessarily me but uh we already know why it's shipping uh but yeah shipping from New Zealand isn't cheap but it's a shame because I love their games you think they I'd be the first person to get a review copy from them but you know shipping cost what can you do but uh last time Sarah was kind enough to show me um Scholars of the South Tigress early uh we had to try that one I think we also did Wayfair early I have a feeling um or maybe it was just werr I can't remember but she's definitely shown me another game like that but yeah I'm definitely looking

forward to seeing what inventors is like so if I get a chance to try that at the Expo I will no doubt uh if I'm allowed to relay some thoughts on that so that would be quite cool but other than that I'll see a bunch of you there and if you do see me just rock up and say hi I've got very few meetings in fact I haven't really booked any because there's not a huge amount to talk about with a lot of them you know I'll speak to them while I'm at the Expo because it's never that busy but aside from yeah apart from a couple of times where I may have the odd meeting slot I'm not going to be that busy other than playing games with people so by all means just rock up and say hi don't feel you know don't get to what's the word um I forget what the phrase is where you sort of like get a bit nervous when you meet your Heroes that kind of thing I mean I am nobody's hero but it you know if people just want to say hi don't feel like you got to be afraid to do so if I'm busy and in a hurry I will tell you but I'm not going to shove it in your face okay you know I'll I'll be very apologetic about it but most of the time you catch me I'm going to be willing to say hi you know selfie photo just to say thanks you know it'll be it'll be great to see you all so right what have I been getting on with in terms of gaming well let see I've got games I've played and I've got my topic of the day I'm going to do the important message first though so Earth abundance I did this as a prototype review and as you know I hate doing Kickstarter prototype reviews there are several reasons for this I don't like you know talking great or bad

about a game before it's like when it's an advert effectively because the game hasn't been released properly so I'm always a bit tety about that especially with Kickstarter because effectively Kickstarter is trying to sell this game and if I go out and give an honest opinion then some people are going to not buy it and from a publisher standpoint from a designer standpoint that's not a good thing but I give honest opinions I don't sugarcoat things and a lot of previews for Kickstarter games are all just sugar coating it's like here's this it's amazing you definitely want it go spend your hard-earned money whereas I try to be a little bit more um realistic with my cash so you know they're not they're not great for me but I do cherry pick my favorites and I specifically requested this one because of course I love Earth so it was definitely something that was in my interest anything else I might do probably New World Order uh the one that or world order whatever it is from the creators of aemy that I'm definitely interested so if I get a chance to preview that I will but like I say it is few and far between so seriously I know you all you Indie Publishers out there if you watch any of my shows if you pay attention to what I do at all and don't just send out cold cool emails which I cannot stand if I know that your if I can tell from the language that your email is a cold cool email you will not get a response okay to your Kickstarter game review request it's not going to happen happen but even then I'm not in the market for doing previews or Kickstarter Indie Games it's not what I like to do and as we're going to find

out later there's another reason why I'm not a fan but on with the main plot so Earth abundance I did this prototype review and I did it pretty much as a prototype review so I was giving my honest opinions about what I liked about it what I didn't like about it and what it added and what I wish it would change before it gets a final release okay so I gave a a decent opinion I think I gave it a six out of 10 which is not a bad rating it's above average I you know wasn't quite saying You must go out and get this and even with what I'm about to say in a minute I still don't think it's a must buy I think it's a nice addition but I don't think it's like essential it doesn't particularly fix anything from the base game apart from one minor aspect you know so and I had issues with it in the review now the review is still valid okay I mean a lot of the points I raised are still valid there is one point that I do need to clarify a bit more though and I made a pinned post on the video to uh Rectify this and I've been in discussions with um Maxim the designer who you know is probably one of the friendliest designers I've actually had to deal with um in recent years uh you know he is a very nice guy I hope to get to like meet him in person at some point if I haven't already I'm so useless with names and faces so apologies of that but I got to say there are some designers I have dealt with before who if you say any remote criticism about their game they will rip your head off and I hate dealing with them you know it's like this is my precious baby how dare you touch this how dare you a super Club yeah we can

think about that one but you know this actually got in touch with me on like the comments now because he responds to a lot of YouTube comments on the reviews which is quite cool it's good to see that it shows that he has an interest and you know not just in the channel but also his game but the the thing was we were discussing a point I made about the interactive player Powers the ones that say are based on other players all players or your neighbor and I had a little not a rant but I had a criticism where I thought the way that these work the fact that the timings weren't entirely clear and such uh you know made it so that it made the game a bit clunky because you're constantly having to shout out oh you're getting this you're getting this and all that and it was like grinding the game a lot from you know that kind of perspective and the ones I'm I'm kind of talking about let's say not the ones these are the seeds if I can find an example of the player power ones yeah here we go so you know where this one is saying you get plus two seeds and everybody at the table also gets four Sprout cubes and there's several instances of this where essentially other players like here you know you get you get something for what your neighbor is and stuff like that well I thought you know partially what happened is that there's two things that mean I need to kind of reccon this firstly um I did interpret some rules wrong from the book um you know one or two rules I got slightly wrong but and Maxim has acknowledged this the rule book is not entirely clear on some of

these aspects and certain key things that would have rectified it for me were written in the wrong place in the book like the the book the rule book is still okay but it does need a spot of rearranging and a bit of clarity in places and because of this I'm not the only person who has made this mistake other reviewers from other countries and stuff I know have done this and Maxim has acknowledged this as well so both of us have learned and we we debated this on the on the comments and very friendly debate I mean this is what I like to see if you disagree with something I said then let's debate and you know we could convince each other that one of us is wrong or we agree to disagree whatever but this was a very good civil debate and it was once it was clarified exactly how these Powers worked things lit up a little bit more for this game now you know essentially firstly this particular ability here where you've got like the neighbor one that wasn't entirely clear at first and I I did interpret this wrong and you know this one's a little bit clearer than others but this one is basically saying you get to compost a card from your hand for every event that a single neighbor of yours has played now that one's a little bit clearer than some of the others but there's one or two which had you know like color abilities and things like that and some of these were mistaken to mean that you and the other players could trigger those color abilities uh it's like whoops okay that was wrong but you know that wasn't necessarily the main problem but it was more the fact that the idea is is that you now have this new rule

where Sprout cubes can be put on your board effectively and then you put them out to you know other cards at the end of your term now this is written later in the rule book as is the point about player powers that involve other players these cubes go into that board you know so there was a little bit of like oh H know this was missed and you know because not all the abilities are sprouts cubes some of them are you know triggering abilities and things like that it it made it a little bit weird to say well how does the timing with these work how does the timing with these work now it has been explained to me and it will be corrected in the rule book it will be written with more clarity so both of us have learned something from this which is good we both come away from this you know feeling better about what we've done and also the game is going to be improved as a result so everybody wins but with the clarifications in mind what I said about the game grinding a lot during those multiplayer Powers doesn't quite ring true anymore I mean it there's an element of that because technically you're constantly saying to people you've got more Sprout cubes and this is you know constantly like going around while you're trying to concentrate on your Tableau and people are shouting at you oh by the way you get cubes and are you going to interrupt your Tableau like ability triggering to get the cubes or you you relying on that other player to give you the cubes there's there's going to be an element of that that Still Remains which is a little negative but the rest of what I said doesn't really hold true the rest of the grinding kind of goes away at that point and with that

in mind the multiplayer powers are better than they were before but I still don't think the expansion is suddenly like a must buy as a result but it has improved my estimation so where previously I gave it a six out of 10 I would probably now give it a seven out of 10 I would actually give this a seal of endorsement and say based on I've played on the Prototype I think this is a solid expansion that's worth considering but I still don't think it is essential because it doesn't really fix anything from the base game it just adds a couple of new elements and both elements are fine I think the multiplayer powers are okay but I don't really care that much I mean when I've I've played the game more since with the clarifications in mind and yeah the multiplayer powers are a little better but a lot of the times I don't care if I'm giving the opponent stuff because I should be giving myself more for what I'm doing so yes I'm giving you two Sprout cubes every time someone triggers the red ability because of my Powers but I'm composting five cards from the deck at a time every time you trigger red so why on Earth do I care if I'm giving everybody two Sprout cubes if I can compost five cards I'm getting five victory points you're getting two you know yeah you can convert Sprout cubes into soil in that but you have capacity issues with you know Sprout cubes so yeah I might give you a bunch of sprout Cubes but you might still not have room on the cards to put them out so there's not really a time when I'm looking at any of these multiplayer cards and going maybe I don't want to trigger one of these this turn no if I can trigger it I'm going to trigger it so I still don't

think they're as impactful as could be but they are improved I still think the best scene as an expansion is just having more cards in general and the seed germination mechanic I think the seeds are cool they did help me fast track the end of the game in the last game I played cuz I use seeds to get soil which was necessary to do a final planting but mainly I just think the seeds are good for that search ability because I used it in the last game I had a had a spare seed I couldn't find anything to give me more seeds but for my ecosystem I needed directional Aid cards I said that as my seed searched for a card got one that worked with that as well as a couple of other forer objectives great so the seeds I think are the best part of this expansion but again I could do without them it's not like I need it so you know I I'm still keep to get this expansion and add it to the pile I think it will still be something I'm going to get but it does sort of mean that you know I don't think I had to rush it I mean if somebody had Earth and didn't have the expansion I wouldn't bat an eyelid about playing it if they wanted to play it I would still play it and have a fantastic time and I still think that this expansion could have added more islands and climates and ecosystem and Foreigner objectives because it really doesn't add that many and what they do add aren't that interesting I mean the four the four six like forner object objectives uh the brown cards are literally just points for this ability on a card this ability on a card this ability on a card you know not it's adding more Powers but they're not particularly interesting ones they're kind of generic so as say

seven out of 10 I hold my hand up you know got something wrong not entirely my fault but you know fair enough it's there and it does need to be mentioned and I've put a pinned post on the video to like highlight this fact I would probably go now to a 7 out of 10 another 6 out of 10 and say that this is a good expansion worth considering just not a must buy so it's not like my rating has changed dramatically but given that we had such a nice debate the fact that he's a nice guy and the fact that you know fair fair you know I wasn't uh entirely right on my interpretation of some of the rules I felt a correction was definitely needed you might be wondering what the jiggling is that is me holding an ice cube filled squash because of how cold sorry how lovely and cold this drink is and how hot in this room at the moment oh that feels so good every time I take a sip right okay so that out of the way what else have I been doing but let's quickly talk about uh other games I have played um very briefly uh siderial Confluence this is a big massive Euro game about negotiation and trading cubes of various colors who cares what they're called they are cubes and it's a game I enjoy I don't love it I like it you know my friends are bigger fans of it than I am but we played it on Friday I played it several times with them before they've played it more times than I have and we're going to play it again next Friday because what we're trying to do is test out these expansion races from the bifurcation uh is it bifurcation uh bifurcation whatever I don't know what the hell the names mean but this is the

expansion to uh Cal confence and because we know how to play the game we can play the expansion races and deal with all the janky stuff they do so we're kind of on a mission to test them all out well played it the other time and I was playing the charity Ze uh Foundation whatever they're called so they're basically um the uh was it the pink race I forget what the Ze do in the base game I don't think I've actually played them in the base game version but in this particular one they have some cool undesirable generators that other players own but you basically have to pay them in order to run them um but you can kind of like coax them into doing it and obviously that's part of your bartering power but you can't run them yourself you but you're the only one who can run them so even if they own the generator they have to pay you to run them or you have to pay them to get access to them it's kind of odd really how it works but the other thing with them is that they have no Colony supports they can't take any planets whatsoever instead they put a little token on the planet and if another player takes it they get to upgrade one of their starter generators and if the planet gets consumed which rarely happens unless you've got two very specific factions in the game you'll get it back and get a VP point the game was fine and fun but I think the charity Z are very weak and not particularly fun race I mean there's not much jankiness to them they have low impact but they're difficulty five so they're quite a high difficulty race to play but I just found them kind of boring because they don't have anything really that interesting the fact that they have to buy use of their own kind of generators some other

players just means that you're having to go through more hassle to run anything decent and a lot of their generators and what they can make makes a spread of resources they're very bad at making anything in bulk the problem is research teams how you get points and win in this game to do research teams you have to make stuff in bulk and if you can't make stuff in bulk then you're going to struggle you know it's all right saying oh well you trade with other players but unless you are trading for the one thing that nobody else wants good luck with that you've got to be able to make a lot of stuff yourself and the charity Z just don't seem to be able to do that as reliably as other races so you know I lost quite badly and you know without much fun to the rules of them they they they feel like the blandest faction on the expansion you know all the other factions have got more interesting stuff to deal with but charity Z yeah just felt very me so I don't recommend you play this faction if you're looking for a really good time I don't think the faction is particularly powerful I think the other factions that were in play which I think we had the uh the the new version of the bees we had the new version of indrill I'm not a fan of inil in the Bas set but you know the new version was doing okay and we had this other faction the net or something who basically says that you get to generate these Cubes but you can never use them yourself that was interesting but the problem is the combination of all those meant it was one of the highest scoring games for everybody else because they could produce so much stuff with all the stuff that was happening whereas for me you just couldn't do it I mean the having to get my generators back of

other players is just annoying and no colony support so we can't have any planets at all that hurts they're like a big resource generator and not being able to do them at all just is painful and that token you put out whoopy dooo I mean your starting generators aren't that great and even then you have to hope that another player takes the planet which is hard enough to do when there's several out there but when the B faction adds another planet to the row to choose from it just basically makes your your like game 20% harder it just really didn't work and consuming a planet is not something that people do very often so you're not going to get the token back so you're going to do it maybe twice three times if you're lucky in the game it just really sucked I don't like charity Seth I'm never playing them again I I challenge other people to do well with them at the table but next week I'm hoping to play the robots of regret High difficulty all right next up let's talk let's talk a little bit better very briefly I just want to give some first impressions of unsettled I've played through the first planet that's it just the first planet nothing else this is a space exploration game where all the planets come in these little boxes you have a core set and then the planets introduce some new rules for a particular scenario it's not campaign based thank God and basically you have uh like a mission to do in order to survive and there's three different ways that you can kind of play each planet but basically you will move your explorers across these map cards

this is the first mission so it's not really spoiling that much but you have these dice Focus dice well this I say dice they're technically cubes because you don't roll them but you put them on various skills on your characters and they go up and down focus and you basically have to micromanage what skills you can do in a round because you have three cubes but one of them has to be to rest so you technically only get two actions turn and the timer is ticking down and if it gets too too long then you run out of endurance and you die so you know you've got that problem but the idea is is that as you go through you're not soldiers you're not shooting aens or anything you're researching what's on the planet and in doing so you're getting these breakthroughs and you're um finding opportunities where if you take advantage of them you'll get Nomes and these give you like really cool powerful bonuses and with these bonuses you need to use these in teamwork in order to get past the mission so and you even get some starting variations to your skills based on draws from the a big pile of skill sets and you just draw one so you get a bit of variety with the characters as well it's by orange nebula and the production is Stellar it really is nice I mean this is a step up even from something like Vindication you you have got game trays which are functional as well as useful for storage you have a very good quality cards you have very nice artwork across the board these big cubes that use with a focus dice are huge and chunky uh this massive like giant sweet Gob stopper or whatever it is is basically um like an opportunity

marker I mean it could have been a could have been a lot smaller I must admit I don't know why it had to be that size the size of a planet but it does the job and it looks cool but it's a cool little puzzle game where the theme is there from the standpoint of you know exploration and checking out a new planet but at the end of the day it's an optimization puzzle so I played the I don't want to lose the game so I have played the first mission which is a sort of toxic Spore type Mission okay now I'm enjoying it enough but I do have some reservations so the game itself as I say it's well produced and the puzzle is interesting you know you are really having to micromanage your abilities really are going to have to focus on what needs to be done and you are against the clock there are a couple of problems that arise firstly being against the clock means that you don't get a lot of opportunity to really explore the way you want to you feel like you're playing a bit of a rush game all the time particularly if you were to play this on higher difficulties I played this on standard but you know you don't feel like you can go after every opportunity you don't feel like you can explore every location you have to go against the clock and if you spend too much time Dilly dallying you're just simply going to run out of time which is kind of a little annoying I wish there was more ways to lose than just simply like running out of time but on top of that the game length is a little bit questionable I mean the weird thing is on this page here it says 60 to 90 minutes the first planet box says 15 to 30 both of those are lies both of those

are lies now granted I was learning this straight from the rule book and the rule book's not bad actually I found the rule book to be pretty good but there's a lot of rules intake you've got read quite a lot of stuff before you can really get into your first game and there's no tutorial I mean it kind of handholds you a little bit for the setup and setting up the first planet which is good I'm glad they did that but then they emphasize that the first planet is now a tutorial it's just one that doesn't have a lot of complexity to it and I kind of wish that they had done something like tainted grow and introduced a proper tutorial Mission something that was nice and short because there is quite a lot to get through in the rules and I found that I was reading a lot of stuff before I could actually get started and I haven't even read the full rule book because there's a glossery at the back that is basically things I'll read as and when they come up but yeah took a while to get into and I played this for a good three plus hours to get it set up learn the rules and play the first mission so yes I know that's not a typical play time but 60 to 90 minutes if you're playing solo I guess two player maybe but with three or four no way is that possible you're going to be discussing with players you're going to be thinking about what you're going to do there's more people acting on the table I mean I I'm you know I'm only playing two-handed because you have to play two-handed as a solo player you know I don't see why it would take 60 Minutes to do that but even solo 60 Minutes I mean if you know all the rules to the top of your head and you know you have no trouble with checking any rules in the book unlikely given that the rule book's quite big if you know the planet

inside out like you've already done it you know exactly what's going to happen in what order it's going to happen Etc at which point why are you playing it again when you've already explored it to death you know and if you do not think about any of your turns and you just play at super sonic speed in which case well done you're playing an optimization puzzle too fast and probably going to lose I just do not get the time frame on the box I mean 60 to 90 if people want to argue it fine but the first planet said 15 to 30 minutes per player no even if you do it by Explorer I don't believe you can play the first planet box in 30 to 60 minutes I think that is hogwash if it's only by player count emphasizing as a solo player I should be able to play this after setup in 15 to 30 minutes that is that is complete BS that is sorry that is total BS and I cannot believe that Publishers are still lying about these timelinks they really are I mean I don't expect the next one to take me 3 hours I'm going to play the next one later today hopefully and I expect it to take me about 90 minutes hopefully sry you know and I would probably Grant you 90 minutes is doable if you are playing at a good speed and you know the rules off the top of your head but again I don't know the next Planet so I've got to read the rules of how that planet works and then I've got to obviously go at a slower pace for that so that's going to take me probably a good 2 hours to play is is not a short game and it takes a while to set up as well because there's quite a few trades you got to lay out and obviously the planet specific stuff so nothing about this is super fast so do not believe the time frames it says on the boxes okay that

being said though the optimization puzzle is cool I feel that the rush mode thing is a little bit annoying I wish you had more time to kind of just do it like you like it's not a particularly sandbox like game because the survival path that you are taking even though there's three one three of them you can pick for the game which is quite cool um you are still kind of on a linear path as to what you need to do and it's the only way that you're differing how you approach the scenario really is what bonuses you get from scientific breakthroughs and anomalies that's kind of what's going to change your play style but that's it it's dictated by those it's not me saying well you know what last time I rushed it time I'm going to take my time it's we can't really do that so this is potential there's potential in this game but it hasn't bowled me over I mean a lot of people were saying they want to know my verdict and I will certainly do a full review of this uh there were some people that say they love this game like this is one of their favorite solo games I can certainly see why people are liking it but I'm not getting favorite solo game Vibes out of this this is giving me kind of okay it's cool I mean I would probably sooner rather play this than I don't know ISS Vanguard is another Spacey exploration game that you can play solo there's way more rules it is more complicated and it takes longer and it's a campaign which I hate but ISS Vanguard had a fantastic theme and it really did feel like a good expiration storyline this one is scenario based which is so much better to get into each of the boxes are played separately and

they do not form a campaign fantastic but I don't know the the theming is there but it's not as super strong mainly because of the way that it feels more like a Euro optimization puzzle more than anything else but there is some element of exploration there but I don't know how often I'd want to revisit all the planets after I've played them once maybe twice you know I reckon there's probably two plays of each box before I get a bit bored playing each one now I have the Supernova pledge so I've got nine planets I think to get through like quite a lot I do not intend to play all nine before I review it I will probably play three planets like two from the base set and one of the expansion lot and and probably maybe play each planet twice so that I try out extra survival paths so I'll probably play it about five or six times before I review it but I'm not playing through all nine planets and that's not happening because they were expansions in a Kickstarter if you buy the core set you're only getting two planets so I'm technically going above and beyond to review like to talk about a third planet when technically I'm only reviewing the Cor set so we'll get to that one eventually just buy your time it's not going to be a quickie right take a little swiger that by me I'm on 37 minutes and I'm not even anywhere near the uh main topic although the main topic is going to be pretty short today I think so let's let's do what you guys love me to do a rant oh boy do I need to rant about this game I

have finished the pandemic Legacy games with my friends and we wanted a break we wanted a break from campaign and Legacy and stuff like that so we're going to play some one-off games uh my friend had bought this little indie game from Kickstarter called Silverwood Grove I had never heard of it I don't know what it I didn't know if it was based on a book or anything uh she bought it literally because it was relatively cheap and it was pretty that was literally her only reason for doing it and she's relatively new to games plays a decent amount of games but you know doesn't have a wide breadth of knowledge of what a lot of games out there but I said you know what I want to try it it's on your shelf you said it looked nice it's short simple I'll give it a shot just for something like a nice change I wasn't expecting greatness from this but I thought it might just be a pleasant little game oh boy is it anything but that this game basically commits pretty much every cardinal sin you can commit with regards to board game Design This is what the stereotype for an indie Kickstarter game is like when you see these tiny little games pop up out of nowhere with these self-published games you know with no backing no like pedigree from the designer or anything like that this is The Stereotype where you think the game is going to be absolute trash and this game is absolute trash everything about this apart from I'm not even say the artwork because the artwork is okay but

the covers probably the nicest looking bit in it when you actually look at the artwork on the table it's fine it's colorful but I wouldn't say it was anything particularly special you know so that's not a major thing the action point system it's a dated system we should be done with action points and it's not too bad that you have to turn this little wheel uh that you can see down there an action wheel to decide what you're going to do so if I've got five action points I have to go right let's see I want to do I want to do the uh higher function so I need to turn it twice to higher okay that's two action points point then do higher that's three action points then I'll pend the fourth action point to turn it to build and then the fifth action point will be to build the problem is there's no easy way to track your action points as you do it I mean you've got this little uh Cube on your thing but that's about it and most of the time I just forget to do it but it's not the easiest thing to sort of keep tabs on and five action points is is not a lot to achieve anything in this game but it feels like a lot when you're waiting for your turn to come around but uh let's go into some sort of closer with some of these uh photos oh no there we go so not the best of looker I mean you got dual layer boards but they are very cheap boards it's not asymmetric Powers they just different artwork for them you track resources uh for generic Resources with cubes and you have a research track and a develop track which is literally just put a cube on the space and you get a symbol which unlocks the ability to build certain cards that's pretty much it but why is this game really really bad well firstly it's 10 rounds and you really cannot get a

lot done in 10 Rounds you know it is really restrictive as to what you can do there are not a lot of options for you and you know it just feels very linear these are player Powers now Dale of merchants and Cosmic Encounter have a similar theme where they have all these player powers for different creatures that give you like sort of gamebreaking rules I have not seen a worst case of broken and unbalanced Powers as these there are some that I clearly like years better than others and there just doesn't seem to have been any for or play testing put into these I had a power that basically I think it was a cabur bird or something like that parakeet and basically it could steal every time I trigger the ability I could steal free resources from another player turn my wheel to wherever facing it likes and they get a solitary Victory point which in our game you know one Victory Point can be a little bit but it's not that big a deal but you don't get resources very easily in this game I mean you have to do pretty much an entire turn bear in mind you only get 10 turns in this game right 10 rounds is 10 turns you only get one like so many resources in this game and the fact that those things can go up to 10 is just ridiculous you will never have more than three or four of any resource at any one particular time let alone 10 it's just not going to happen but stealing free from another player not only is punishing but also that could have erased their entire last turn I could have basically just annoyed 10% of your

game and I have to cherry pick who I do this with so if I pick on one player all the time that's just mean so I spread the load out but it's not fun for them to lose 10% of their game every time I do this possibly more than 10% and even then I give you a victory point if I'm giving three other players a victory Point each that's nothing I'm getting so many resources from that it is way too powerful and it doesn't end your turn some of these end your turn when you use them great this one doesn't no way it does not uh so that was no good but then a friend of mine had a power that basically could copy anybody else's power so it completely negated my power because anytime I use mine she just uses it on me so my power has become null and void and her power ends up being broken and unnecessary it just who fought up these Powers they were just ridiculous um on top of that you have these icons at the top you know there's three factions that they can belong to the green blue and a Red Faction effectively and there's no balancing as to which ones you start with but it's usually with their abilities emphasizing the fact that you should hire and build that you hire employees and you build buildings and you should do it with the faction that your leader is with typically so you might have with four of you three of you with the blue faction one with the Red Faction person with the Red Faction is fantastic because they can get a lot of the red cards and nobody has to bother them fre people people with Blues are constantly fighting for the blues again completely

unbalanced uh what else is there the rule book complete load of trash the rule book is so brief doesn't mention key rules in the game so much so that the community put up a fan-made rule book to balance the game out and even then it's still not 100% clear there is an FAQ that goes on for miles it I mean this game is not a complicated game how can you mess up a rule book for something like like this absolute trash um what else is wrong with this game uh the victory points you get for these employees are not balanced I mean one employee might literally get you one point a couple of symbols and that's about it you know not much another employee the horse horse doctor or whatever it is can be worth 15 points by the end of the game and all you've got to do is simply upgradeing which is not difficult and get your research track up to Max which everybody should be doing in every game anyway because having the research track at Max unlocks your ability on your card uh your player power as well as other abilities along the way so there is no reason to not research you have to research so by two-point character who barely gets me like a resource each Turn versus a 15-point character I mean we finished a game barely scoring I think 40 to 50 points it's not a highs scoring game and yet the score track goes up to 150 how the hell do you get 150 points in this

game I have no idea that is impossible yeah here we go 153 I mean it goes up to 153 purely because they just the board was just that shape but in no way will you ever score that many points it's ridiculous oh God where else do I go with this what else can I say that's really terrible um come on there's more terrible stuff than that uh yes the building right so I'll try and show closeup the building I can only show so much but these buildings right in order to build you need symbols from the various characters and possibly from your developing research tracks which are exactly the same thing they just get you a symbol and you know like you can't build the storehouse unless you have a hammer and a a quill or whatever so think of it as the apprentices from architects of the West Kingdom had a similar system it said it did it much better here the buildings take ages for you to build and you require these various employees in order to do it and by the 10th round you barely get one maybe two buildings out if you're lucky you're not going to get enough resources to do more than that but also these employees and buildings are on basically like a display and when you buy them they don't refresh until the end of the round but the problem is because it is so hard to get resources in this game as well as the symbols you can end up with a situation where both displays remain so stagnant that is nonon impossible to see much Variety in this game like you're stuck with it which is compounded by the other issue that there are objective cards in this game and the objective cards much like

the player powers are completely unbalanced you know you basically have an objective and if you complete it you get points usually it's six or eight points two point differential that's it right put it this way somebody had a six-point objective where all they had to do was get all their research track leveled up in one term you need one of every resource so you basically just just have to spend time collecting a bunch of resources and then you spam it in one turn and you get six points right easily done they did it on their first second turn I think probably even their first turn Okay so that was not difficult my eight point power required me to get two locations which is already very difficult and have their Associated employees in them because you get one employee for a building and up to a cap of two or something I can't remember but the idea is is that I not only have to find two buildings that are the right affiliation but I have to to have employees that match the buildings that is light years more difficult than simply spamming your research at once and it's two points difference and because the displays are stagnant if I'm get if I've got blue employees and I'm hoping for blue buildings and the display remains stagnant I cannot physically do my objective for no reason other than blind bad luck this game is trash absolute trash it is everything that is wrong with you know

Kickstarter Indie board gameing where anybody any Tom Dick or Harry thinks that they can just make a board game stick it on Kickstarter and get people to buy it and people actually bought into this I mean where is it Silverwood Grove Kickstarter this came out in 20121 this is embarrassing that a game like this came out in 2021 you know maybe covid hit it in design play testing meant that it couldn't happen but this right it got how much did it get 2200 backers pledged $144 Australian dollars this is an Australian game $144,000 Australian dollar to bring this project to life I don't know what $144,000 is $10,000 Australian dollars goal which blatantly would not be enough to make this game but how much is 10044 Australian dollar 2 how much is that the conversion rate so oh sorry 144,000 not 144 so 144,000 is £76,000 this wasn't exactly a massive Kickstarter in the first place which means the goal for this wait a minute 10,000 so what was the goal for this 5,000 quid this Kickstarter was going to fund and do all the logistics and everything for 5,000 quid no it was not but people actually fun this and backed it for what was a cheap price I mean you could get a Collector's Edition for $ 59 Australian dollars uh you could buy the basic version for uh $ 39

Australian dollars so this wasn't expensive but BGG even put this as best Euro game in the 2020 card game design contest third right third place this got third place BGG what cocaine have you been smoking to come up with that did literally everybody else just com spontaneously combusting flames in order to give third place this game is trash I'm sorry I don't I'm I don't care I'm saying this I'm talking honestly and hopefully you're enjoying this rant you know if you love this game fine please explain why you love it I would certainly like to know be civil about it but I would certainly love to know why you love this game but I just found this to be everything wrong in design design the action wheel is probably the one Saving Grace of the game but the actions you're doing are not fun they're not interesting the display is stagnant and if you haven't already guessed you are getting animal and from animal characters that look all cutes see you're getting the characters and some of them will interact with other buildings so that if you have the the doctor and if you get the hospital you get more points you get little buildings and you track resources and spend them to do it is this giving you any kind of Vibes yeah everdale this game is totally ripping off everdale the game is practically taking the exact same theman setting and using that and everel came

out when uh 2018 so this feels like a complete cash grab you know like oh ell's really popular let me just make another cutesy little animal game about you know card Tableau and stuff like that and then people might back it people who back this game you got duped even my friend who backed this and show me the game admitted oh yeah this is pretty terrible it had been a while since he'd played it last and she couldn't remember what her thoughts were on it everyone around the table admitted pretty much halfway through the game or earlier than that that this game was terrible but we had the soldier on and get through it and when we finished it we were so glad to play a game of Earth to cleanse the pallet because we were sour about this game and boy did I have thoughts to say on it seriously Silverwood grow I would give seriously I would actually give it a one out of 10 this is a like an absolute trash game I can't even see if I would give it a two out of 10 you know I mean it functions if you can understand the rules which you can't do they had to fix you I don't think you could play this game from the rule book The the community had to fix that the artwork is so so it's nothing special the action wheel is maybe a Saving Grace I'm not going to give you a point for an action wheel cuz action points are a dated mechanic anyway way but the rules are bonkers the players are unb the powers are unbalanced the invents are unbalanced the displays are stagnant the character victory points and buildings aren't even balanced you know this game was just an absolute garbage Fest one

out of 10 avoid this at all costs well there you go did you like that ramp I hope you did it's been a long time since I could unleash by that and you know what that kind of makes me feel a little bit better so better that I'm going to take a drink lovely lovely lovely so have I got something nice to finish up with well this is only going to be a short discussion because it's 53 minutes already so if you wanted a bumper episode you're only getting one but I want to talk not necessarily about Kings of Ruin specifically but just a kind of Revelation I've had recently I've played through the entirety of kings of Ruin okay the entire campaign now so I I really love Ted gril I think the story and setting is amazing I like the combat and diplomacy systems in it I think the artwork is gorgeous there's a lot of stuff I like about it but I have to house roll the difficulty a bit because even on story mode the game is Just frankly too punishing and there is a bit of a grindfest with the original version now Kings of Ruin fixes a lot of that but I still had to hous rule a few things it was still very punishing in some aspects and to reduce the grind I definitely did try to house for an easier difficulty because I wanted to experience the story rather than grinding and the story is still really solid in this I still really like the setting and what you do but by the time I got to about chapter 6 seven remember chapter seven odd I was starting to get

to a point where I'm like can this finish already I feel like this has been taking up my table for a long time now and I basically spent bank holiday weekend binging for about six chapters of this game to get it finished uh you know because I was just getting to that point and certainly chapter nine onwards I was kind of a little bit done because I don't want to spoil too much about the story but basically put it this way halfway through the campaign you're going to get a choice of to go two routes one of two routes if you go whichever route you pick you will spend the next three chapters focused on that particular route and then you spend chapter nine dealing with the ramifications of the other route because you didn't pick the first route and that's cool it gives you an a a chance to replay the campaign a second time by simply going the other path which is cool but then chapter 9 is literally just going through that it's quite a long chapter but you're just basically dealing with the after effects and then chapter 10 is the resolution of which the final encounter did feel a bit like a grind Fest I mean there was definitely some house ruling that needed to be done there it definitely felt like this was padding the game out a bit to make a finale climax but by the time I was kind of done with chapter R I was just like yeah can we rush this Al I kind of need to get this finished and it's not necessarily tainted gril being a bad game you know I I do think as I say the difficulty in some of the grinding came through a bit more by the time we got to the later sections but there was also a

couple of instances where I kind of trivialized some of the game I found a card in Kings of Ruin uh for my character I was playing uh o is he Oberon or I forget his name begins with a not osbert that's it yeah osber a little dwarfy type character right so I was playing him and he's I geared him up to be a diplomacy uh munchkin because I just hated the fact that the first tainted Grail focused so much on combat I wanted to see if they'd fix that now there is definitely more grounds to use diplomacy in this version particularly with the boss encounters you can choose combat or diplomacy um and each one has their own way of working so I was glad of that but the game I feel still really wants you to do combat in some respects because I had to basically run away away from 95% of the combats that I came across and the only way I could do that was because osbert has a very cool ability to make smoke bombs which basically allow you to run away from a combat and ignore the outcome fantastic but you got to spend action points in order to keep making them which is annoying um and certainly I must have house rawed a few of those uh um cards that say automatically resolve an encounter when you go to them I'm not a fan of those yes there's a delay after you've done it but it doesn't last that long and then when you go back to location you have to do another encounter and it's just like I got to the point where I'm like look these are annoying can I just do one encounter and then that's it for the card that certainly made life a bit better but certainly I was making a lot of those smoke bombs but the diplomacy card I had

basically meant that I could um you have like a duration counter and you have to try and end with the diplomacy marker on green a lot of the time the card I found I won't tell you how I got it but basically it allowed me to raise the market as much as the duration counter and then resets the counter to zero so it ends the diplomacy that card was so damn powerful in the game that it trivialized diplomacy encounters for bosses I basically found that it was it was quicker to resolve the diplomacy than it was to set up the actual diplomatic encounter itself because if I had that card I basically just ended it and it was easy to time with the other items I had and bosses had that I think finished a boss battle a level two boss battle right there they come in three different difficulties for each one I did a level two version on the first card played literally the thing started got a few raises from stuff i' done before used one or two items to get a couple of other raises and then because the duration marker I think was like pretty high used my card to raise it all the way up again it went to green and it the whole thing ended one card wow for a boss now granted it's not easy to get said card you have to go through quite a big personal story in order to do it but it still trivialized a lot of the Diplomatic encounters which kind of was a little bit weird for me but what I'm getting at with this is that Campaign games I think for me I'm

dumb you know I I you I like tainted Grail and I still love it but I'm actually now trying to sell my collection of Tainted gril Isa said they D CU each each season of Tainted gril is like £250 for stuff that I can't post and I am not taking this to the games Expo no way am I trusting it in the Brin and buy there because the Brin and buy at games expo sucks but it's just clog chaos and full of theft not going anywhere near it but the the thing is is that as much as I enjoyed my experiences with the tainted Grail series and I still have churned a lot of hours into this and still enjoyed my time 90% of it I have got to the point now where I think Campaign games are just not as enjoyable for me anymore and a lot of that down is down to time there's a lot of games I want to play and I just can't because you know the the games are just too long they take ages to finish and my time is precious I'm a 40-year-old man who granted is lucky enough not to have kids but you know and unlucky enough not to have a partner but the you know not to have a girlfriend but the the fact is is that that would take up a decent amount of time in itself if I did but even without that I run a YouTube Channel I have a full-time job which is quite demanding I have a social life to go to game nights and do other things and there's other Hobbies I mean I want to play computer games I want to play my PC and play like cyber Punk and Jedi Survivor and deep rock Galactic and valheim and stuff Stellaris I'm playing a bit of I want to watch TV shows I want to you know go out and hike I want to go

to the gym I need to keep myself in shape I want to learn how to cook more stuff you know there's a lot of stuff I want to do I don't have the time to go through one solitary game for hour hours and hours and days and weeks and months for a campaign the pandemic Legacy season zero this group of ours we can only meet up once a fortnite and that's not always happening and you know we're lucky to get through a game on each night maybe two if were're Lucky it took us eight like 8 to 10 months to get through pandemic Legacy season zero it just took forever and we were just like can we play something else now even by the time I mean I I gave my review of pandemic Legacy season zero and I thought it was only a six out of 10 because I had problems with it but by the time we got to I think August September of pandemic Legacy season zero I was done I'm like the story's not that engaging we're rinse and repeating a lot of the same stuff here I mean um let me get the picture up while I'm at it but you know you you basically just rinse and repeat so M so many of the goals and objectives and stuff that it just wasn't that engaging and the story is not very good in this and a lot of the branchy path stuff mean nothing you know it's all there just for show and it just it really didn't work out for me this one so by September I just wanted this over and it just felt like a chore to get through the remaining months which is not how I want to feel in a game and I've got divus down there um divonis came as a late uh Kickstarter I don't even know why I backed it I think I

reviewed the I previewed the Prototype my friends liked it and we thought we'd buy it but it's now sitting there and we are going to play it I think this will probably be the last camp campign game I do out of choice but I'm not looking forward to this reviews have been very me for this and it's another campaign game all I can hope is that this one is short and quick and we can get it done nice and fast but I'm not looking forward to it I can say that uh say that much you know rank 8881 you know it's not exactly getting a huge amount of Buzz I mean uh I mean who can I let's see uh well Sam Healey did a live play fine uh can't trust that uh Dice Tower did a review yeah they did a where is it yeah here we go so I mean who can I trust review wise here so we got a lot of these people I've not heard of so I can't speak about them but um neverboard gaming did a preview of it so be interesting to see what they think uh yeah yeah I did a preview ages ago so I was kind of keen on it back then I said H this is fine not amazing but I'll give it a sh sh but this was back when I actually cared about previews but yeah not a lot of people that I can say overly know or trust on this one so but I looked at the dice tower one Tom vassel did it with his children and they only gave it sixes pretty much for the most part across the board so yeah this one I'm just not expecting to be particularly good but the thing is is

that I just don't feel like I want to play any campaign game anymore you know I'm at the point where I've looked at my collection of games and I actually can't find many if any at all that have campaigns in them now that's not including expansions so uh this war of mine has one of the best campaigns I've ever played like I think actually it beats tainted Grail in terms of campaign that I love it's called days of The Siege and if you have this war of mine and you can get days of The Siege do so this is a free act campaign so you only play three games and finish it so I'll probably play a campaign if it short but long ones no like these awaken Realms ones or these massive ones that say here's 150 hours where content I mean even if unsettled wasn't a scenario game I would not be playing nine planets of it as a campaign it's just not going to happen but if you can get days of The Siege this is easily the best campaign I have played from a story perspective from a mechanics perspective it is absolutely brilliant it's one that I would actually maybe replay at some point because I am kind of done with campaigns but it's only three games wouldn't take me too long to go through it again it's tempting but it's only because this is that brilliant okay but other campaigns I just don't think I actually have on my shelf I'm looking back and the only ones that I can see that I believe are campaign based so

they require me to go through specifically a lot of games in order to finish them as far as I'm aware off the top of my head the only ones that I have now if by the time I sell tainted Grail is going to be the lcgs Lord of the Rings lcg Arkham Horror lcg and Marvel Champions lcg they have campaigns but even then I'm not playing them a lot um lately because of time although I do want to play some Marvel Champions soon because uh um I've got I want to print out the dividers for them I want to play it I've missed it and also because I'm enjoying the X-Men 97 series Series so much it is fantastic you have got to watch that series if you are a Marvel fan or you like X-Men it's so good cannot wait for the finale next Wednesday um I got to so avoid spoilers for that but the the fact is because I'm riding such a hype train with that uh I want to play Marvel Champions and I want to play a cyclops deck to me my X-Men deck cuz I just kind of in the zone for a bit of it so you know but the thing is I don't like playing the lcgs as campign CS anymore Arkham Horror campaigns are eight sessions long they take a long time to get through and so by the time I'm halfway done I'm like ah and that's put me off playing Arkham horr lcg now you can play Standalone but the Standalone rules for the middle of a campaign are not brilliant I don't love them that much and so there's not much incentive but the Standalone scenarios that Arkham har lcg does are pretty

sweet and there's still one I haven't tried the fool and fortune or fool and Folly whatever it's called it's like a casino based one haven't played that one yet so I do want to try that at some point but Standalone scenarios I'm cool I haven't played Lord of the Rings lcg in years you know but that one's a little bit better with Standalone missions I find even though there are some uh you know some stand Some Like rules for playing the campaign ones but again they're campaigns and they're typically uh what are they nine missions maybe eight eight or nine missions those so they take ages to get through the entire thing as well Marvel Champions has um you know campaigns in them but I actually actively dislike the campaigns in them because they throw in some like fiddly little extra rules but on top of that they're just not balanced for difficulty I mean they are super hard in Marvel Champions to get through some of those campaigns particularly lately the power creep is insane you know some of the bosses that you fight in the campaign are so difficult that they're just not fun and the good thing with Marvel champions though is that it is a lot easier to do Standalone because Marvel Arkham hor and El and Lord of the Rings were built as campaigns but then they had extra rules to make the mission stand alone Marvel Champions is the opposite these missions feel like they are designed Standalone but C and have added rules to play them in campaign mode which means

that every time I get one of these box sets and I am literally looking at the base set as well as seven boxes there there's seven box expansions that have come out with this game and I have them all despite my better judgment of buying into a game that's the thing is if I wasn't sponsored if I wasn't you know if I wasn't getting sponsorship and stuff like that I probably wouldn't be buying a lot of these lcgs but to be fair that's what some of it you know some of my my own money goes on you know to just buy a few of these extra lcg packs because they are cool but there's a lot of content there but I can play any mission in there Standalone there are some standalone scenarios like I haven't played Mojo Manor yet I really want to play that one that stand alone the Kang scenario really great stand alone but even the campaigns themselves I have not the last one I played all the way through I think was Galaxy's most wanted and didn't like how powerful the enemies were Ronan is ridiculously hard even The Collector was pretty hard and I just didn't enjoy playing it so I will now I have not played the Titan Shadow campaign I have not played next Evolution campaign I've not played uh mutant Genesis campaign and I certainly don't intend to play Age of Apocalypse campaign I'm going to play them as Standalone missions but they will be Standalone I'm not throwing in the extra campaign rules so if I want to fight apocalypse first I'm going to do it first I'm just going to do that one first I'm not playing in campaigns I just don't like them and I say I think it's just the time commitment I I wonder if other people have this similar problem with it where you know time is

the killer for a lot of these campaigns and there are some games that I think are good that I've avoided because I can't play enough Campaign games tainted Grail has been the one that's been on my shelf as the go-to long campaign game now that that is finished I'm done I don't even feel like I want to play a tainted Grail fre at this point because I just feel like I'm done with long campaigns but I passed up ISS Vanguard and um o swarm both of which I thought were pretty solid games you know both o sworn has a few flaws and ISS Vanguard has a few flaw they're not as good as tainted Grail but both of them are like here's a bucket ton of content and all these hours and this massive setup and all these rules and it's just I haven't got time to devote to you if I had no job then maybe but then I would still probably want four gaming tables just so that I could have them all laid out and never have to pack them away because unpacking and packing a campaign game is usually a complete ball ache you know they may have save game functions but they still involve a lot of setup and a lot of takedown and you not incentivized to you know have them out so to pack them away so you want to leave them out which means they clug up your table this table was out of use with the underlay for months it was annoying I wanted to play other games like the I played the Great Western Trail New Zealand solo mode twice the other the other couple of days and I enjoyed it I'll talk about that maybe in a future review but I can do that on this table without getting rid of Tainted Grail first but it felt

good to play a game that yes those modes for Great Western Trail take long a long time they're not short but at least they end at least they end on the same evening that I'm playing The Wretched thing I don't have to go away and leave it there and then come back to it at some point soon it you know there is that problem and I passed up those Campaign games and other Campaign games on the horizon there's the aridia one um uh I think um orange I think oh I forget who's doing it Shadow born games or is it Shadow Forge I don't know um they're doing one called uh oh oh what was it it was coming out of games Expo awaken or something like that I'm not sure but as I say they're doing something and if that's a campaign game I'm just not that hyped up on it and I've passed up a lot of other Campaign games I just don't want to do them anymore I just want to play a game and have it done in dusted I love scenarios I can play Marvel Champions as a scenario based game which I think is why it's going to be now my favorite of the three lcgs I think it is risen above Arkham Horror at this point if it didn't already in a top 100 uh but if I was to say right I'm only going to have one lcg and sell all like I'm going to sell two out of the three lcgs I think I would keep Marvel Champions because I can play at easier in a scenario basis but you know a lot of these other games they could be lawn I mean I could play a lerta game behind my head right a cban EV I could play that solo it's going to take me a while to set up it's going to take me a while to play it but at least it will be done on

the evening I play it at least it finishes it has an end timer that isn't several months into the future and if you play a game solidly over and over and over and over again unless the game is so good that you just can't bear to live without it it's going to get stale it's going to lose its Effectiveness by the time you get to the end of the campaign and I'm just finding that a lot with the vast majority of campaign games I play even the ones I really love I get to a point where I'm just done I'm getting bored can we move on to suig gals it's why I that's probably why I like playing shorter games rather than longer games a lot of the time because the shorter games you can fit more of them in a night if you're only playing one game the entire night you've only played the one game that one game better be amazing like a geminy but you know I do make an exception for that game being stupidly long but yeah it's kind of the way it is so honestly I think for the future you know excluding divus which I think I'm going to be for to play um I think that I'm done with Campaign games and I don't think I want to play anymore I don't think I want to review anymore I think I'm just I think I want to stick to one shot games with scenarios if there's a lot of content but the scenarios I'm fine with that unsettled is fine right there's nine planets but their scenario and they don't link together great um you know I even tried massive Darkness too I sold it eventually but at least that one you played as scenarios that was fine and a

lot of other games I haven't played in ases that I want to play like Chronicles of crime still on my shelf I barely tapped into all the expansion content that game has but you play it in scenarios it won't take long for me to get back into it any other examples on M shelf for manches of Madness perfect scenario perfect example you play it as a scenario you might play a 90-minute scenario you might play a 4H hour scenario it is a scenario they don't link together once I'm done with the scenario I can pack it away and I don't have to get out again the next day you know so that is definitely as I say a keeper um even the Arkham Horror board games kind of fit into that anything else uh that on my shelf I'm looking at here that benefits from being scenarios Marvel dagger yeah that is scenario base and that one definitely works uh but a lot of these bigger games are all scenarios they're all scenarios empires of the Void Great Space game it scenarios ah sleeping Gods now that is a campaign but to be honest when was the last time played sleeping Gods I think it's a good game but after I played it all the way through once I haven't had the desire to get it out again I've got to solo hand nine characters and go through all that again and it wasn't a perfect game it's a solid game but it's not perfect I'm not entirely certain why I've still got it in my collection I think that one probably has to hit a c pile at some point near and far has a campaign mode in it we've played the campaigns all the way through I have no desire to repeat the campaigns but is the scenario system in near and far good enough to just play one-offs I'm not

convinced it is so you know that could be a problem for a cile anything else let's see Scythe oh yeah the Fenris campaign was okay but it wasn't great but honestly I think I would have been just as happy if I cannibalized the whole box and simply uh decided not to use not to do the campaign but just to take all the cool bits out of it I think it probably would have been better doing that you know again a campaign uh anything else uh dominant speech species no ghost stories no Seven Wonders no Cerna no um the lcgs obviously are campaigns looking down there Ward The Ring the card game no that is a oneoff that is a one shot uh Feast of odm one shot Fields ofar one shot pandemic Iberia the one pandemic I do keep one shot yeah most of them are one shots which is great I just think that's the way I'm going so I'd be interested to know your thoughts I think it's time to wrap this up this is a very long episode which hopefully you've enjoyed uh but yeah I I think I'm done with campaigns there may be exceptions to the rule this is not necessarily A I'm going to say pathologically never never never again another campaign game after divus assuming we actually play it we're still I'm hoping I can convince them we don't need to play it but I think they do want to play it so I think divus is going to be the last official campaign I play but after this honestly if you're bringing out a new campaign game I'm going to be less enthusiastic about it and if it's going to be one of these like 100h hour campaign things I'm probably not going to want to buy it I mean uh stalker was an example uh stalker looked like a cool

game but was it campaign based I can't remember but it may be cool but I've have no interest in buying it if I'm forced to buy a 100 hours of campaign content you don't experience 100 hours of campaign content you know tainted Grail and effer fields and all that L had so much content in the game you're never going to see it also why is it there it it I don't know this is my sort of pet peeve I have a feeling that this you I'm going to try and objectively stay away from Campaign games maybe one will come out that's based on something I truly adore and I make an exception maybe if you tell me the campaigns really quick and short like the days of The Siege when I mentioned know free games not that long you tell me it's something like that I might be more interested but if you are trying to sell me a game that's like a 200h hour massive huge 250 Kickstarter with a ton of content that's a huge campaign I'm just going to be like cannot be bothered I just don't have the time I have a lot of games on my shelf that have been neglected as a result to Campaign games Suburbia collector's edition I haven't played in ages I really want to make sure and I justify that the mine clash games I do like J Caron and all that I would like to play that with the expansion more but need the time to learn it Spirit Island haven't played in a while you know would like to play some more games than that there's so much I want to tap into on my shelf time is lack time is a precious resource I'm not getting any younger my life is not getting any easier you know

not unless somebody can grant My Wish Upon A Wishing Upon you know when you wish upon a star that you win the eurom millions if somebody could Grant my wish and makebe win the euromillions so I can cancel my job then believe me I would be the most ecstatic person in the world and I would do a lot of gaming but and probably a lot of cruising but still it it's just that situation now so what are your thoughts are are you done with Campaign games do you have the time for campaign games are they the only things you play I mean I can totally get that if you're not a big pref if you don't have a massive board game collection but you just have five Campaign games that are your life then great Gloom Haven's that example for a lot of people and I totally get that so I'm not in that situation if you are then fantastic and I can see that you'll love Campaign games but for a lot of you are you siding with me are you done with campaigns do you wish they were shorter and quicker do you like these massive huge things that suck up all your time because it's a massive cost but then if it didn't have so much content then maybe it wouldn't cost so much there is that um I'd be interested to know your thoughts are campaign good games good for you or like me are you just kind of dumb so yeah that's it for me on this episode of the broken meele this bumper episode next time I'll do some kind of a UK games Expo preview but I don't know if there's going to be that many games to talk about it will probably just be a kind of tips and tricks of how to attend the and get the most out of the convention as well as what I'll be doing when I'm there cuz I'll probably have solidified a few more Plans by then but I'll be there for the whole time Show

preview and everything so you know and I'm not helping out with a stand so I'm I'm being very laidback I tend to do a lot of my formal blog stuff with Essen because Essen has more reason to do it the games Expo I tend to go as more of a consumer um with the occasional bit of formal stuff throughout the day sprinkled in like little sprinklings on the top so I don't tend to go full form noral like appointments and stuff for the gamees Expo cuz I just don't think it's that worth it but you know hopefully I'll see a bunch of you there but I'll talk more on the next podcast so uh bumper episode over my throat is sore got to get on with other stuff and it's hot in this room so take care love you all remember it's only a game and uh bye for now enjoy the hot weather damn I wish it was cooler

Progress saved