Skip to main content
Loading video...

Board Games I've Been Playing - February 2019 (Part 2)

Transcript 27:48

hi welcome to actual all anjaan Perkis these are the board games I've been playing lately I'm actually gonna start off with a book this is called it's all again a short history of board games and I've been reading this lately and I just really wanted to share it with everyone because I've really enjoyed it it is talking really a lot about the history of board games but coming up to modern day and I've found that I just learnt loads from it and I think if you're into board games and you like reading I think that you find this quite fascinating so um I'm just gonna remind my source um of the things I learned from the chapters so it goes through it starts with ancient board games so talking about synapse ancient Egypt and one of the things I found fascinating about that was that there was a board game that they found that had been played for 3,000 years if you can imagine the same game played across like civilization spanning that time I just found that amazing I really hope that monopoly doesn't stick around that long and then they're talking about chess and how that evolved and I found it fascinating to learn that drafts actually came after chess it was like a simplification of chess which is interesting cause if you imagine these days you've got all these dice games or card games simplifications of bigger board games as opposed rafts is that to chess then they were talking about a chapter on backgammon and I found that

fascinating because I learned I didn't really know that backgammon was a really popular almost sport game in the way that poker is now in the 70s and you would get these big international tournaments where celebrities would turn up and huge amounts of money were bet on it and there's a really interesting bit that I highlighted in the book because it was talking about how as the game as more money got into the game in backgammon in these tournaments professional players started to play so it wasn't just kind of Playboy's that enjoyed the sport and they had loads of money to gamble people that were really good at it started to play it because obviously they can make a lot of money from it what happened though is that they took it so seriously and they would take ages on their turn that it took all of the fun out of there and then people no longer wanted to watch it as a sport and basically the tournament scene kind of died off or all the big money and all the celebrities around it died off and that just made me think of analysis paralysis and where people can take games a little too seriously and it kind of sucks the joy out fate for the other players and it seems like that happened in the world of international backgammon tournaments then they talk about monopoly which is more of a famous story that you might have heard of course originally it was designed by a woman back in like the 1920s I think it was supposed to be teaching people how being a landlord is bad and how the world is

set up in this capitalist society so that a few people get very rich and everyone else gets poor and it was trying to instill a certain economic sort of ideal to people and that just didn't happen at all and actually what happened was that the game didn't pick up for a good sort of 10 years it changed a little bit but eventually when it really got popular it was popular because of that capitalist idea that it was pushing and people enjoyed that about it they didn't actually really learn the lesson that the game was originally trying to teach one of the things that was fascinating to learn about a lot of these games is that they were made by just one person who sort of down on their luck may be looking for some fortune there's a lot of mentions to the Great Depression and often is very sad stories because they the game wasn't necessarily successful for them or they sold it and didn't actually make as much money as they would have and I think it's just really fascinating to me to hear the personal story behind these designers because you sort of look at game designers today and often they're doing it as a side thing but the way it's painted in this book for a lot of these people is it was a really kind of a last-ditch attempt or it really had an impact and some of them get very rich and others it's a more heartbreaking tale there's really interesting story about a father who taught his three daughters how to play chess from a really young age and how they just turned into chess grandmasters and how you've really can

if you want to make someone really good at ball games then that guy proved that it's possible so towards the end of the book they talk about more modern stuff and the author is interviewed Matt Leacock and he talks about what inspired him to make pandemic and then there's reference to Twilight Struggle Catan obviously the the rise of German board games and the kind of history behind that so later on it really it talks about the stuff that I kind of already knew about but giving more details there's certainly things that I learned about this era that we're in since the sort of 80s and 90s and there was still fascinating bits in there but I found it especially fascinating to learn about the the games that came before and how they came about and often there was very strong reasons why they existed they came about a certain part of time and and something like Trivial Pursuit for example came in the 80s at a point when people thought the games were for kids and Trivial Pursuit was really marketed as an adult game and it had a really high price point and yet it blew up it it changed board games forever because it said to people look you can make you can put a high price tag on it you can make a game that is solely for adults and it can sell and sell and I think the Trivial Pursuit is kind of a terrible game but it's really nice to look back and learn kind of what it did for us so

yeah I I think it's really nicely written with loads of interesting anecdotes that I was kind of reading and then immediately kind of telling to my girlfriend because I found it so fascinating so and highly recommend checking out it all again and the author is Tristan Donovan I want to talk about two games now that are quite similar they are through the desert and Blue Lagoon they're both designed from the great designer Reiner comitia but through the desert is from the 90s this is a more recent version from z-man games Blue Lagoon came out for the first time last year in 2018 they have some similar mechanisms and that's why I wanted to talk about at the same time so I'm going to we're through the desert so they're really these path building games and they're the thing I love about them is that they're a little bit mean there's there's a fair amount of blocking in the game they are abstract largely through the desert is about building camel caravans so you're placing down these camels onto the board to connect up to your caravans that have been started by these camel leaders I'm trying to connect up to AC s to get five points then if I place a caravan if I place a camel that basically connects me to a watering hole I take that tile and they're worth one two or three points you also get points at the end of the game for having the longest caravan in specific color one of the things I love about it is that you're just inch closer

to things and you'll know let's say I'm right next to this this two watering hole here and nobody else is nearby for now I know that that is mine and so I don't need to take it I could I could take my turn and I could place a camel there and I've got this token but I don't need to rush and do that I need to worry about what other things I can get closer to first or what plans my trying for there's a so you have to keep your eye out for all these different things that you want to get but you're not going to take them right now because that wouldn't it's not the best time to do that but make sure you do keep an eye on it because if somebody inches closer on their turn now if somebody then when went here on their on their turn all I have to do is then take it I'm right next to it I've got it but if I forget to do that on my turn or I don't spot it and of course they've got it so there is a lot of keeping track of everything that's going on and and that's why really it's this abstract game of of trying to see where the best move is it's so simple in terms of the turn that you take you just place two camels and the the way you get points is simple too but there is loads to think about and I love how interactive it is you can really get frustrated we have the players is definitely pays to be blocking people often stopping them from doing what they want to do if you can also do that whilst also getting points yourself then even better I think it's a wonderful game and then I

play Blue Lagoon and I'm really just trying to work out which is my favorite between them so let's get Blue Lagoon open in Blue Lagoon you are competing to settle these islands and there's a pretty heavy Marana theme with the artwork so what you're doing is you're taking interns to place down one of these little chips that represents one of your people and it plays over two different rounds where the board kind of resets in between so in the first round you are turning up in your boats so you're going to be spreading out across these islands and there are a number of different ways to get points in this one you can move on to a resource to pick it up and you are collecting these resources either in sets of themselves or a set of one of each of four types of resource then you are just trying to control areas and what you're trying to do is to either have the most on an island and they all have points so you've got ten for a big island eight and six points you're trying to have the most tokens on there at the end of the round you're also trying to just be on every island so you get points if you're on seven out of the eight islands or eight so you that's quite hard to pull off then the really tricky one is trying to create a path that connects up loads of islands so this pink player here has connected up one two and then three

islands here and if they could continue to move around the board then they could collect they could get a lot of points like that but everyone can see what they're trying to do with that and they can just quite easily block them off stop them from getting across and creating this path here in itself is just really blocking off the other players either side because now they can't get through this massive island in the middle it feels a lot like through the desert because you are just taking in turns to do one thing place down one of these and you're creating these pathways and you are blocking off the other players there's definitely this mean competitiveness to it that I really enjoy there's so much to think about on your turn and yeah it's so simple in the rules you just place a piece on the board and that's one thing I slightly prefer about Blue Lagoon is just that on your turn you place one thing in through the desert you place two things and so that just raises the potential AP by a hundred percent and I think these games do have the potential to cause analysis paralysis in players because there's a lot of things to consider and it's competitive but that's why the games so good and every decision you make will have an impact on your success it isn't one of those games where you sort of do a load of meaningless things and then a few big decisions no everything will count in this what I like about Blue Lagoon is just that it's got more

colorful artwork it's just a bit brighter it's also a smaller box I think that through the desert I quite like the theme of but the board and the watering holes just the kind of drab I think it would have benefited more from a days of one the kind of cartoony field that Blue Lagoon is is definitely much closer to what's interesting though in Blue Lagoon is as you ramp up to the end of that first round you are having to worry about where to place these huts they are the only thing that's going to stay on the board for the second round so all the tokens will come off all of the resources will get put back on in a random order and these huts will stay and from then on you are placing your tokens adjacent to the huts so you need to make sure that you've spread out some huts in some nice places for that second round or it's really going to cost you really I love both games but I'm not sure I want personally want to keep both and so for me I'm just leaning towards Blue Lagoon because I I just think it's gonna be more appealing to a newcomer I think they're both great games for newbies and I would highly recommend both of them so that is Blue Lagoon and through the desert kick-ass is a cooperative game based on the comic book of the same name and there's also films about it and it's about a teenager and sort of a band of plucky terrible superheroes they don't have any superpowers they're just effectively vigilantes that dress up in suits it's a cooperative game where you all take on the role of one of the main characters in the story so

there's a bunch of different characters you can be here you've got kick ass and Hit Girl and those boards will be tracking certain aspects of your character and then you've got bad things happening in New York and there are these various bad guys that are coming to terrorize different neighborhoods you have to go and fight them off and there's also these plot events that will be doing bad things and you are trying to deal with those or otherwise they have a really negative effect what you're trying to do is complete three events and then the boss will be revealed then you've got to defeat the boss and that that's how you win the game of course you're trying to survive as you go and the way you lose the game is if City Hall this section in the center is overrun by bad guys then you've you've lost and the way it works is that they will spawn every turn and they get placed on these different locations but if the location is filled up you will follow the arrows and as more and more fill up they're just gonna end up all ending up in City Hall and I've found that it happens very quickly surprisingly quickly so some of the cool things about the game is you've got your character here and you're tracking your happiness and generally when you fight bad guys that makes you unhappy you don't really want to be doing it and it's probably hurting you so that will bring down your happiness if you get too

unhappy you will reveal these hardships you've got these two hardship cards and I think this is a fascinating mechanism because you don't know what your hardships are going to be and three until you get unhappy and they will get revealed so for example this one is that you have a gambling problem so you're going to lose money this one is depression so every night phase you're going to get even more unhappy I really like the the thematic touches of those there's just something really nice about the way they work and if you get happy again they get covered up again so they're no longer affecting you and I I just think that perfectly fits with life and things get bad and your sort of depression reactivates itself and then you things go good again and you kind of can deal with it easier you've also got your strength so you can go and work out in Central Park that will improve your strength which generally means you can roll more dice then you've got your social media success so depending on how many likes you have on social media will have an effect on things so if you get famous the shop where you buy items suddenly becomes cheaper because people like you so the way you take actions in the game is with a hand of action cards it's really simple and I'm really like how simple the system is you basically have five cards you can pick from some will refer more to kind of moving around and activating locations others are focused on combat and that's these red cards here these are the basic cards you would

start with this time icon here just relates to doing an action in the location so every location has an action so for example if you go to Wall Street you can spend some time it makes you unhappy but you make a bunch of money that makes sense you go to Central Park you can spend some time you can be happy in the park or you can workout and get stronger combat is fairly straightforward you've got red dice that you roll depending on how many items and how strong you are you'll roll that you're looking for hits but you also have to roll the blue dice which is protecting you generally it's quite easy to get hurt when you're fighting which makes sense because you're not a proper superhero you're just a guy the thing that I really found with combat is that it is harsh there isn't much to change the fact that you are just rolling dice and the dice are brutal they have a 50/50 chance of getting a hit I like cooperative games that are close that you play it the first time and you feel like yeah we can come back and we can beat it and the first time I played it we got to sort of round four out of nine and we were done and then the second time I played that I thought yeah I've learnt from there we are going to improve we're gonna build up and know we got destroyed in like round four or five so I think there's some really cool things here I think if you absolutely love the comic books or the films I think there's probably a game that you could really get used to really understand I think there's lovely thematic touches

and it's a solid game in terms of the way things work it doesn't over complicate stuff but I want a cooperative game that you can enjoy from that first play so I can recommend it if you love it if you like punishing cooperative games I'm talking really punishing then check out kick-ass but it wasn't quite for me escape tales The Awakening is an escape room style game that I've been excited about for a long time came out at Essen the idea with this is that you're a father whose wife died five years ago and your daughter is in a coma and you try to perform this ritual of awakening to get her out of this coma and you end up in this sort of weird world where you're having to solve puzzles to get through it and to try and get her back I think the bulk of the game like this all comes down to the puzzles and I'm certainly not going to be spoiling any of them for you and I would say on that level this game totally succeeds if you like escape ring games and you want a game with interesting original fresh puzzles and loads of them then absolutely get this game and we had a blast trying to solve some of these puzzles there was definitely a lot of them at that perfect level of like yeah I had to put loads of thought into that and now at the end of it I feel great because we solved it we've really worked as a team and it just has exactly what you want from the skate room game the way you solve puzzles actually using an app except what I liked about it is that you just

accessing a website you're not having to download anything and then the website will track which puzzles you've done and another thing I really liked about it was that when you had a puzzle you could click to see how many cards were required it's such a small little touch but in something like unlock you'll be like oh my god I think how could why can't we solve this and then literally it's because you are supposed to do something else first and you needed another card and you had no idea and you're spending ten minutes trying to thinking you've got everything to solve it and in escape tales you can just check and it'll say you need four cards to solve this and you you've only got two so you realize oh okay we can't solve this right now let's focus on other things I love that that's just it you don't have to even click on it you don't have to reveal that if you want to sort of keep it a secret but I like viv it's an option my experience with the story book was that it was nicely written but I didn't massively buy into it I didn't feel like it was adding a whole lot to the experience it was slowing things down because you're having to read stuff but I actually found that the story didn't massively work for me I'm not sure if that's because of the specific story that it was I I'm inclined to think that it might just be that you can't necessarily tack on a story that easily to an escape room game because when it comes down to it these puzzles whilst different are still similar to other escape room games and you can't just intrinsically linked a story to those

things you have to jump out of the story oh I'm trying to save my daughter too then doing like a math problem or a color matching thing and there's no way to connect that the idea of this being like a ritual that you're trying to perform and you're trapped in this netherworld and it's like yeah it might be the closest that you can come but it didn't really do that much for us and the other thing that we found with it was just that it was dark and not in a sort of like refreshing oh you know this war of mine type of way it was just sort of like dwelling on this idea that you're not only is your wife died but your daughter is in a coma maybe dying and there's all sorts of references to hospital beds and things like that and you sort of think well if somebody had actually been through this that might be really kind of triggering for them and and even if it was only boy what I wouldn't say it triggered anything in me I just found it kind of bleak and there just wasn't anything very exciting about it I don't want to come across as overly critical because I think escape ring games whether they succeed is down to the puzzles and the puzzles in this game are great and if you like escaping games and you want to play another one with interesting puzzles absolutely play escape tales The Awakening my reaction to certain aspects of the game didn't stop me from enjoying those puzzles and really that's what it's all about that is escape Tales The Awakening tag city is an interesting rolling right game that I picked up at Essen the way

this one works is you are graffiti artists you're trying to tag up the city and you're racing to complete things it's got an interesting ice but you choose mechanism in it that I've never seen in another roll and write game basically the first player would roll roll these guys and then they will assign them so you've got this this is like a communal board that has these different Tetris shapes on and so for example if I've got a six here I can assign it to either this shape or this shape so I can aside our let's say I put this one here and I put this one here and let's say this is a three and I go here and here so I have sorry here I have made these shapes available to the other players so they are looking at their city board and they are deciding what they want to fill in I get to pick last just like any I split you choose games so somebody will take a dice and they will draw down that shape take a dies draw that shape when it comes to me there'll be two left so I will get a bit of a choice and so maybe I take this shape and I draw it somewhere on my board so the last piece everybody gets so we all share that goes on their board so the boards fill up pretty quick and what I'm trying to do is to complete regions to get points to complete rows and columns so these different regions depending on the size they worth different points so the first person to finish off blue is going to get 14

points then anyone else that is able to finish blue doesn't just not just the second player will get 7 points you can see other people's boards you know what they want you know that they're also going for your regions so you can try and stop them maybe by not giving them the shapes that they need you get 5 points for completing a row if you do it first three points for completing a column if you do that first and you're just racing to do all this stuff and do things in the most efficient way and so it's fascinating some of these pieces are will take up more spaces on the board so this one is one two three four five spaces whereas others are only four so you're going to fill up a lot more of your board if you use those bigger pieces but they might be harder to fit into everything so there's that what I have found with the I split you chooses that often you will just try and put the dice on the things that you won and just hope that they come back round to you I haven't too many times worried about as much what the other people are doing but often especially in a smaller player count you might be going for a different region to them so there isn't necessarily that direct competition but I do like the fact that you're having to think about the same thing that there is a sort of interaction in - in terms of what's available but I also do think that it does slow it down a bit there are lots of rolling right games where you're drafting dice and this is a bit similar to that I like that you are deciding what's available but making that decision about what to take will slow it down because you're not all

using the same results and turns on whipping round like that and I've found that it it's one of those rolling right games where you're racing to get stuff you're not being so much punished it doesn't have as much push your luck to it as something like Avenue or Quinto it's very reminiscent of a game called nochmal I much prefer this one and this one has an advanced board on the other side where the regions of the cities are more interesting shapes so I think that's really cool I think it's a really nice package and is definitely one of the better rolling right games that I have played ever III think I like that it's whiteboards not bits of paper you can also introduce different Tetris shapes so not only can you make you can flip the board for an advanced version on this side but this board has a more advanced version where you're not dictated what shapes you can just play with any shape so you can bring in really hard shapes or you can have a little mixture and it makes the game a little bit different every time you play so if you really like roll and write games then I think tag city is definitely one to try out it's it's not up there for me with like my absolute favorites because it doesn't have that that push your luck and the really the punishing play but not everyone likes that that's just kind of my style so if you prefer a style where it's more about working out the puzzle and trying to push for the most point

but also with this entry interesting interaction of watching what other people are doing then absolutely check it out that is tag city those are the board games that I've been playing lately I'll put links to where you can buy them in the description below I'm John Perkis thanks for watching

you

Progress saved