Skip to main content
Loading video...

Rival Cities, Come Sail Away, Lands of Galzyr, Biss 20, Florenza Dice Game - Ranked and Reviewed

Transcript 26:52

Hey everyone and welcome to another Chairman of the Board ranking video. This is where I take a look at the last five new to me board games that I've played and I rank and review them in order of preference. And I have a pretty strong lineup today. Uh but before I get into the five games, I want to give a shout out to the show sponsor kiender.co.uk who are my go-to online retailer. And if you use the link in the show notes or the QR code, then you can get 5% off your first order. At number five, I have Bis 20. Now, this is a pretty silly party game with a heavy degree of memory, which I understand is a big turnoff for a lot of players. And admittedly, uh I was a little bit apprehensive going into it because I thought, you know, memory isn't really my jam. Um but this was surprisingly good fun. So um it's pretty wacky as you are basically counting from 1 to 20 but as you go through each number there is basically new rules introduced which will uh substitute those numbers. So for example instead of saying number two you might have to stand up or instead of saying three you might have to moo like a cow. Um but these rules are dripfed round after round. So all you're doing is that you are saying a number in turn order. So you go like one, two, three, four, and then maybe the five is replaced with a moo. So it' be like four, moo, six, seven, stand up and so

on. But again, as you are completing these rounds by going from 1 to 20, then new rules are constantly added which should just make the game crazier and crazier. You know, numbers are swapped with each other. Um, you know, you are introduce farmard animals, maybe you are um scratching your head or doing different things like that. And you know, I normally find memory games a bit more off-putting if there's a big dump of information you're, you know, you have to try and manage are thrown at you at once. But again, I love the way this one is very lightly scattered. And if someone does make a mistake, they simply lose one of their lives and you start again from that round. So, it's not like it gets progressively more difficult regardless of how well the players are doing. So you kind of find your level or your group's level to to um in relation to how much memory you're expected to uh you know to master. So this was actually again surprisingly good fun and despite being at number five um this one might hit the table more than all the others combined. So I can really see this one being a nice filler game. You know only takes 10 minutes or so. Um and you know even if you are rubbish at it, it's it kind of enhances the game. It makes it even more fun. And it's one of those games where you you don't fight until all the players are eliminated. It's simply a single elimination and there's one loser and everybody else wins. Or I suppose you could say the player who's lost the fewest lives would win. Um so it's doesn't it's not like it outstates it wealth or takes too long or you know

after the novelty has worn off it's not like it keeps on forcing you to play. Lots of cards as well to play with. So you're not saying you're not seeing the same things each game. So, tons of variety and yeah, if you want a completely silly party game, a good icebreaker and it almost feels like a drinking game. So, you could take this one to a pub or something and have good fun with it. So, that is Abyss 20 at number five. At number four, I have Florenza, the dice game. So, this is this is actually the third iteration of the Florenza series. Now, the first one being the board game, then there was a card game, and now the dice game. And this game is even a few years old. And admittedly, I've not played the other two versions, so this is the only one that I've played, so I cannot compare it to the board or card game, but this is a pretty straightforward, at least in the mechanical sense, roll game, but there is a stronger emphasis on resource management. So, essentially what you're doing is that you are drafting dice.

You're using those dice as certain resources. as you try and complete artworks, buildings, climb tracks, uh, and so on. But there are quite a few nifty little twists on this game that did intrigue me. So, um, first off, again, mechanically, very easy. You're just rolling, I think it's five dice. Each one corresponds to a different resource. The higher the pit values on those dice normally means you'll get more resources um, to fill in your sheet with. Um, but the lower valued of those pips are helpful because they let you climb the tracks faster and they'll also let you buy these artists which are used as your kind of rubber stamp to finish your different pieces uh of artwork. Now, the track climbing is fairly interesting because you do get combos as you go along, you know, helping you tick off other things or getting resources and so on. Um, but it also might give you a an ongoing boon as long as you are in the lead on those tracks. So, for example, there's this leader track where if you are the leader at a certain point in the game, then you'll get a free resource.

Or I think it's the the church track or the pope track, which means that if you are in the lead, then you can actually choose dice that other players have already drafted. So, you get lots more flexibility. Um, and I do like the way this game actually does introduce um, some good uh, player engagement because when it's the active players turn, they choose three dice from the pool and the other players will get to choose the remaining ones. So again, you're always interested in what the other players are doing. Now, most of it is pretty straightforward. You are just again ticking off the resources that you've drafted um, and getting points accordingly. Um, but there's one little twist I thought was really interesting and I'd love to see more of, and that is this idea that you can only build buildings um, from left to right. You can choose what those buildings are, but you cannot start or complete the next one until you've already finished the ones um, earlier in it in your little player sheet. So, you actually have full freedom of what you want to build. So you can start off really, you know, really heavy buildings if you want to, which might give you a lot of points. Or you might want to start with some of those more affordable buildings that will give you ongoing benefits such as having the ability to use any pit value when you choose a certain dice or getting more resources and so on. So lots of cool things you can do with the building step, but as I said, if you want to commit to something, you might have some overspill of resources and you might start allocating those resources to your next plan building. So, I love the way that you're forced to think ahead here. And if you do very carefully and meticulously plan which resources

you need, not only for your current building, but the future ones, then you could actually play this game super efficiently if you are uh careful. So, I love the way this game forces you to think uh that way. Um the rest of it again is pretty standard stuff. again, just constantly getting benefits, trying to score as many points as you can and getting the right resources um and making the most of the PL powers that you've collected for the buildings that you've already built. So again, simple stuff, but I do like that. Again, those small little tweaks to make it more interesting. Now, in the grand scheme of things, I'm not sure this game does enough to differentiate itself from so many other uh Roland Wright games. You know, I've already said on this channel many, many times I tend to enjoy roll and write games when they are a bit more um pick up and play, you know, 10 to 20 minutes. This one you're looking around 30 to 40 minutes. So, it's again almost double what I'd normally use a roll and write game for, but I don't think it outstays as welcome. But I think if I'm going to play a 45minute roll and write resource management game, I might lean towards say, you know, a 70 or 60 to 90 minute proper euro instead and get that full experience. So it kind of walks a weird line of what I want in my collection and I kind of struggle to see who this audience or who this game's audience is. But that's no discredit to the game at all. The game is good fun.

Again, there's some clever tweaks, some good resource management, and the d the dice drafting is actually pretty tense. So, uh that is Florenza, the dice game at number four. At number three, I have The Lands of Galia. So, this is a game that, you know, to be honest, I was going into it thinking that I would not like it because I'm much more of a mechanically driven gamer. I like euros. I don't care how dry a game is. I'm not really interested in storytelling when it comes to board games because, you know, if I want a good story, I'll just read a book. But this one did very pleasantly surprise me because it didn't try to be anything that it wasn't. You know, it didn't kind of half halfassly um try and add in unnecessary mechanisms. It really did focus on that storytelling and um I think it did it in a very charming way. You know, a big part of that is the the theme and setting because these are very cute little critters that you're running around this kind of fancy world talking to other little critters um and doing rather funny things. So, it didn't take itself too seriously, but at the same time, it wasn't too wacky either. So, again, mechanically, this game has almost nothing going for it. You are just visiting different locations and rolling dice to resolve these different events. Now, you do have a little bit of say over how your character or how their strengths are divided out. So, you have like all the different classical fantasy traits, you know, your your fighting ability, your charisma, you know, your

survival skills and so on. And you have these different markers on your little player board to see how good or how efficient you are in those different fields of expertise, which will drastically affect your ability to roll well in those different fields. So again, you are just going around um trying to complete missions, picking up new ones off billboards and the way that you actually resolve these different events is used through this app system which is really good. It's very well polished, easy to navigate, nice and easy to read. Um and yeah, you are doing again pretty silly things. Now, we had a really good time with this one because again, we didn't take it too seriously. We just went with the flow and just enjoyed the chilled out nature of it. Now, just as a um just an example scenario that we ran into. So, one of us actually went to this theater location to discover that the the main actor had an injury and then the production manager wanted us to sort out for him. And we had the option to either try and use our survival skills to heal up the main actor or we could use our say charisma skills to try and take the actor's role for ourselves and do that performance. And then of course you're again rolling dice uh and hoping to get certain symbols depending on the category you'll have much more a much higher probability of rolling the the faces that you need if you are again efficient in that particular skill. Um and then again if you roll well you'll get a much better outcome and you will then get more of these kind of legend points where you're trying to increase the aura or the um yeah the the legend

or mythos of your particular character which is the idea of this game. So, it's not like there's a particular objective to this. You're not trying to defeat the big boss or anything like that. You're just meandering around trying to build up your reputation. Now, each character does have their own special abilities and they also have their own starting story just to get you moving on the board. And yeah, it's quite nice how you can just go along this at your own pace. You can play it for as long or as short as you want. And one of the biggest things that impressed me about this game is how easy it is to pack away and just set up and play again and pick up from where you left off. So, you know, you can have all your old equipment that you picked up that will make you better at different things, you know, disguises and things like that. And you just have everything ready for you, ready to start again. And the next time you'll already have your mission cards in your little player pack. And again, there's no fiddliness. There's no different um kind of components here and there and everywhere to try and track how well you are. It's all just boiled down onto that little playerboard with a few cards. So again, this is a very difficult game for me to review, but I had to do it on an enjoyment factor uh alone. Mechanically, this game is as weak as it gets, just rolling dice to see the outcome. But it oozes charm and it's the kind of game where this is particularly works for me.

If I've had a really tough or exhausting day at work, then this is a nice one just to sit down with your friends and just enjoy the process with rather than, you know, racking your brain over playing some euro efficiency puzzle. So, it's a good game to have in your back pocket for those occasions. And I think it works for our game group really well. Now, I've had quite a quite a a mixed history of playing like RPGs and things like that. You know, I tend to think that they they always strike that balance wrong. they're either too combat driven or not mechanically driven enough. This one I think hits that sweet spot for me and it didn't yet it didn't try to be anything that it wasn't and that's what I really liked about the lands of Galia. So that is the lands of Galir at number three. At number two I have rival cities. So this is the newest design by Andrea Steding who is most known for Hanza Tutonica and Forenz. So made some really good games. Now this is a bit different to his normal fair because this is a twoplayer only kind of sudden death style games. There are actually five different fronts that you and your opponent are fighting on. Now four of them are sudden death conditions and one of them is simply victory points if none of those sudden death conditions are are met basically. So the game is a kind of a rondelle style game as you have the board with a bunch of cards spread around. You you can do it randomly if you like or there is suggested setups as well as some special

cards mixed in there as well. And you can simply move your player piece one or two spaces around the rondelle for free or if you want to go more than that then you are going to have to start paying resources. Now, the different fronts you're fighting on are kind of several tugofwar tracks as well as some set collection. And there is a kind of a strong thread of resource management going on behind the scenes to get those cards that you need. So, I suppose we'll start with the the different ways to win. So, first of which, there's this big tugof-war track like this prestige track on the main board where if you collect these hearts, you could pull the little marker in your direction. And if you pull it far enough, you'll instantly win. But if it's on your side of the the table, then you will get some passive income at the end of the round, which can be really helpful and help you with the different fronts you're fighting on.

Uh you can collect these ships that will give you instant or ongoing benefits. If you ever have three more ships, or maybe more than three ships, I can't remember, than your opponent, then you'll instantly win. The ships, of course, cost resources. Uh, you've got these kind of affiliation cards that there's four of them available at any game or any time. Um, and as long as you are in control of these cards, you'll get quite a powerful benefit. Um, but every time you go around the Rondell, you do need to pay resources to keep hold of them, and you can even snatch them off your opponents. And these will do things such as increasing your yield of resources or giving you discounts on other parts of the game. And you also have these lawsuits, which are kind of multiple little tug-of-war games, um, where when you go to the lawsuit places, you will pay resources to move your little market in your direction, um, and try and again beat your opponent. But unlike the main tugof-war board, these um these ones are resolved at the end of every round. So even if you are slightly ahead of your opponent, you will win that lawsuit and get the benefit from it. And if you ever collect, I think it's three lawsuits, you'll instantly win the game. But there are lots of ways to manipulate the state of play by shifting those lawsuits around so that maybe the ones you're struggling on will be pushed back into a couple of rounds time and you can focus on the other ones and use that time to catch back up. Now, despite having so many moving parts, the game is pretty easy to digest and there is some good synergies between those different facets of the game. So, you know, for example,

you know, you might buy the ship, which will be one of the ones that you need. Um, and that ship might let you move down the tug of war track. So, you're constantly looking over your shoulder here because there are so many things you need to manage and you're spinning so many plates. the game just forces you to feel paranoid and which I think the is what the game is trying to do and the feeling the game is trying to get across. So if you want a game that as soon as you set it up you need to be looking over your shoulder and being aware of all the options that not only you can take but try and block your opponent from taking actions that they want to. Uh the the game system itself is pretty simple. Again just move around the rondelle use one of the basic abilities if you want to. You can use these more powerful abilities, but they will take you an extra turn because you spend a turn picking them up and then a future turn playing them. And those are normally really really good and much more powerful than the the basic abilities. But you even do have this um additional option to spend these envelopes that you can collect to do both those actions, which can be a good got you moment uh for your opponent. So this one again on paper is everything I like. is very mechanically sound. Kind of runs like a welloiled machine, very well put together. Um, and realized uh production on a on the whole is is pretty decent. I mean, it looks it looks relatively, you know, like a traditional Euro. Maybe pretty boring looking to some players. I personally like the way it looks. Um there are some major um

minor issues I'd say with some of the components, especially when it comes to these law tracks where you have these little kind of cardboard pieces. You're moving the little marker up and down. They kind of slide around easily on the board. Um and they're not too they're a little bit too fiddly and chintzy. I think they could have been a bit more robust because you can quite easily lose your place on those lore tracks. So I do like most things about this game. In fact, I kind of feel like I'm nitpicking on it because I can't actually put my thumb on why exactly the game or why I didn't love the game. So, I did like it a lot and I think it's going to be very popular and highly well reviewed, but the game did feel a little bit soulless to me. Um, and I didn't really connect with it, if that makes sense. I kind of felt like I was looking at the game from a from a bird's eye view and I could appreciate it, but I didn't really feel like I was not enjoying it, but I didn't really feel like this is a game I want to keep coming back to. It kind of felt like, yeah, I played it. I enjoyed how all the different parts mesh with each other, but I wasn't really invested and keep on coming back and seeing how the game what other things the game had to offer. Um, I think maybe a big part of that was because I have games like Seven Wonders Jewel in my collection. I think Seven Wonders Jewel has a slightly elevated fun factor as compared to Rival Cities. But I do think if you like one, you'll like the other. And if there's room in your collection for for two

games that are I'm not going to say they're similar, but they do have some crossover, then you will probably um have space in your collection for both of them, and you you won't you won't regret having both of them in your collection. Now, I'm kind of at a spa a place now where I want a game in my collection or a single game in my collection for each occasion. And I think for my tense two player tugofwar style game, I'm probably always going to choose seven jewel over this one. Hence why I probably won't be keeping hold of it. But if you do very regularly play all your games and you regularly hit the game game table with two players only, then this is a very credible choice for your collection. and I think you're going to have a good time with it. Um, as well as making good decisions because there is a good degree of resource management. Knowing what to do at any time is highly important because again, you are always looking over your shoulder um about what your opponent could do and you don't want to be caught off guard and lose when you least expect it. So again, nice game. I think maybe it's not going to be to everyone's taste when it comes to the visual appeal. I think just because it's not like, you know, we're in this age now where everything's animal themed or nature themed and it has that cutesy feel. This one has a kind of more traditional early 2000s look to it. Um, which doesn't seem to be the, you know, the thing in trend at the moment, so that might work against it, but gameplay it is rock solid. That is Rival Cities at number two. And finally, at number one, I have

Come Sail Away. So, this is by Sashi and Daryl Chow. Two designers that I tend to really respect and enjoy their designs. And this is a game that I've been after for a couple of years now. And it's only just become available here in the UK. Now, a big part that of why I was so interested in this game is because it truly focuses on the Marcala mechanism, which is a mechanism I tend to really enjoy. One of my favorite games of all time. Train uses that mechanism and I've always loved it and been interested with how to very carefully and meticulously place your tokens down on different locations. Now, if you're not familiar with what the man car system is, it's basically you are picking up a bunch of um tokens. In this in this case, it's going to be these colored meeples and then dropping them off in a fixed order kind of chaining out on different tiles.

Now, this one those tiles are different rooms in a cruise ship. Um, so you've got your kind of your staircase and your different lobbies and things and cabins and you're trying to get the correct colored mele in the correct place and you're going to get points once you've completed the criteria of these rooms. So, for example, the cabins, say the blue cabin wants a blue mele sat on it. And once all three of those cabins are complete, you'll flip that tile over, get victory points at the end of the game, but you will also then restrict yourself going forward because that's a new space that you cannot place a mele on during that mana dropping system. And if you ever have a a mele that you cannot deposit in a location because you can't physically do so, or you might even choose to opt to do so, then you'll put those surplus meuples in a negative scoring pile. So, this is a true example of an efficiency puzzle where you're very carefully mapping out where all your meeples go, keeping your options open, but there's also this thread of racing because if you get certain rooms completed before your opponents, you'll get some additional bonus points. So, there's a good little push and pull there um that runs through the entire game. There's a good degree of um kind of replayability added in as well because not each game not only do you play with I think it's the five basic cabin rooms. There are five special rooms that you can choose to mix and match as the game goes on. So they're all pretty similar but they do work in different ways. So, for example,

some of them might say you want two pairs of meeples of different colors or one room might want one mele of each different color or only meeples with these little cabins of little um luggage symbols on. And if you ever get a a mele with a luggage symbol in a luggage room, you go along this luggage track, which will unlock additional rooms and give you more kind of freedom mitigation tools to move people around, maybe pick them up from the supply or take them back from your negative pile and put them on the board. Um, so there's this there's lots going on, but it's all boiled down to this very simple mechanism. And I like I tend to like games that focus on one mechanism and try to utilize that to the best of its ability. Now, I must say the game, you know, mechanically is pretty repetitive.

You are literally repeating every single turn, but one of the strongest kind of attributes this game has is how quick it is. It only takes around 25 minutes to play, but it does deliver this real satisfying feeling, and it does actually feel like you're playing a grander and bigger game. um at least by the time you finish you kind of feel quite proud of what you've done and it's quite satisfying kind of putting everything in the right room and there's good decisions to be made and how many meles you're putting down because you are restricted to these cards that you have which will show the colors you're depositing and the order in which you can do it. And are you going to go for a card that has four meeples on it, which means you're going to fill up your rooms much faster and hopefully get those endgame points by completing those rooms, or are you going to maybe place um meles down that only have two on each time where you can place anywhere on the board, but of course, you're only putting two meles on the map then, which means you're working at a way slower pace than your opponents might be doing.

So again, there's not really much more to say. It's a pretty barebones game all built around that one mechanism, but I love the the escalation as you're climbing up those tracks, putting more buildings or more rooms into your cruise ship. Uh the how the game chokes you as the game goes on as fewer and fewer spaces are available for your meles. It kind of feels so nice when you've got like four four rooms that only need one or four tiles that only have one room left and you get the perfect array of meeples and you deposit them all and finish four rooms at once. But at the same time, you could end up creating little isolated spots on your cruise ship. Meaning that you can't really get meles into that room without taking negative points. So yeah, this one really works for me. I'm not gonna say it's an amazing game, but it's a a really nice and rich kind of 30 minute game experience that has its own niche. So, I said earlier that I really like the M color system. Um, but those M color games are normally, you know, involved in more heavy Euro games that are going to take, you know, an hour and a half to two hours. Um, or are they going to be more abstract of nature? You know, you think of those traditional African man cara style games. This one has much more of a modern feel and it just feels more bright, vibrant, and more fun. But again, I love the how simple the game is blended with how restrictive the game is in those later turns. So yeah, two

thumbs up from me. Thoroughly enjoyed and I think this one's going to stick around for quite some time in my collection. So that is Come Sail Away at number one. So there we have it. That concludes the video. Hopefully you've enjoyed it. If you have, please be sure to hit like and subscribe to my channel and check out my other content, too. And for everybody else, I'll see you next time on Chairman of the Board. Bye-bye.

Progress saved