Skip to main content
Loading video...

BGG Has A New #1 ... Or Does It?

Transcript 18:35

thank you this video is sponsored by game Toppers turn your own kitchen or dining room table into a premium portable game solution at a fraction of the cost hey everybody welcome to another quick mini Vlog I don't know if some of you noticed over the weekend but brass Birmingham actually passed gloomhaven to become the number one ranked board game on boardgamegeek.com and then slip back down to number two and then as the time of this recording is back up to number one so that may change by the time I actually push publish on this video and when I saw that I got super excited when it initially passed the gloomhaven uh because I'm a type of person that likes change I like things to be different and so on and I was really excited about it and I was like I'll make a vlog about this because what I did I'll have links to these geek lists below is I went and looked at all the number ones that there's ever been on Board Game Geek and there'll be links below uh there's been some joke ones uh but sort of off top my head I think I've got to memorize you've got brass Birmingham gloomhaven which was the longest reigning number one I believe and you've got Puerto Rico which is a very close second as long as raining and they have Agricola which was on there for a while Twilight Struggle uh pandemic Legacy season one uh Paths of the glory tigers and Euphrates and I think that's it I'll also have another geek list there that has kind of the history so like the uh what a game tops out as because for a while there I thought that Kayla's actually hit number one but it never did it was at number

two for quite a while um some other things Hammer of Scots was number two so I'll post that geek list you can see kind of how far uh a game made it so like I said I was really excited because brass Birmingham has been kicking around for a while and you know it's kind of the newer iteration of brass which I really like and you know there's been age of industry and all this stuff and so the game has kind of like been developed over time uh and it was cool because it's a very different game than gloomhaven when gloomhaven was a very different game than pandemic Legacy although they do have some things in common but those games are all different from Twilight's struggle from mcgreco from Puerto Rico and the reason it's I think it's kind of important relatively is because the number one game is kind of like the face of the hobby you could definitely argue that back and forth you know uh is working geek necessarily the face of the hobby so to speak and all that stuff but let's set all that kind of aside it's the number one game theoretically on the planet right now is brass Birmingham as of this second and so that got me really excited to see that change because it's a heavy Euro and all that stuff and one of the things that I really like about this hobby for me is kind of the diversity of things that get attention and that get sort of you know a little bit is the Winds of Change you know the hobby kind of shifts the demographics always are growing

that's all kind of morphing within itself you know the fact that a pretty heavy euro is the top game versus a very euro-y Dungeon Crawl is pretty cool and you know the fact that pandemic Legacy hit number one was really cool because at the time the Legacy thing was such a New Concept and it's neat that we've seen kind of these old you know curmudgeonly Euros like Puerto Rico and Agricola although I think Puerto Rico is a little bit more commercial than the Regal is um you know we had that had their time in the sun has the glory had its time in the sun which is like a real straightforward war game Twilight Struggle is a war game but kind of a more modernized war game twice struggle is in that war game arena you know you can argue it all you want but it's in that thing so you could look at like twice struggle versus brass Birmingham and pandemic Legacy let's pick those three there's such a diversity there of things and it just really got me excited and the thing that happened was as I was kind of putting notes together was oh there was like a brigading kind of thing where a bunch of people were raiding brass Birmingham with a one so they all went rated with one and then they were changing their ratings to gloomhaven to a 10 or whatever to bump a glue payment back up so then it bumped up and then the same thing happened to gloomhave and a lot of people were going to rank Glenhaven with a one and then you know rating it with a 10 and that kind of stuff and that really bugged the out of me because I thought that was really stupid and Penny to do that I was like I'm so excited that something different is is now number one and gloomhaven had the longest run ever of a

number one and it's a great game and you know and then now this the Seas have changed because that's what does it doesn't just like stay the same for Infinity because that would suck I was super excited and then now brass Birmingham is back to be number one so that whole thing really kind of bugged the crap out of me um and it made me kind of start thinking about a lot of things and you could really sit here and talk about like the rating scale of how you rank on BGG because they have their own suggested thing like 10 is I would play this all the time I would forsake my family and my children and just play this game I'm exaggerating but that's kind of what the tan is and then one is like I would never play even if it was the only game that I had on a desert island I wouldn't even play it then that's kind of what a one is now everybody kind of ranks their things differently they use rankings as a way to kind of track games they don't even actually attribute any sort of quality to it so there's some nebulous nebulousness there and so I will I will tell you how I rank games and then I will talk more about one other kind of thing which is interesting and so let's just set aside my excitement I'm still excited because brass birmingham's up there and Arc Nova is probably going to jump over brass Birmingham pretty soon because it's already at number four and it just came out like a year ago less than a year ago almost and it just keeps shooting up the rankings I think we're going to have a new number one here probably by the end of 2023 we're going to see Arc Nova jump over everybody uh we'll see we'll see it's still got I think it has more copies got to get out there or more people got to play it and that'll kind of dovetail them too my last point but before I get to my last point one point is how I rank the games

I rank them as a kind of quality now I had put gloomhaven as a 10. now you will not see gloomhaven show up anywhere in my top 50 when I do it because there are other games that do that Dungeon Crawl thing that I have way more fun doing okay I just reviewed one League of legendaries I would put that way above gloomhaven okay now I think I ranked League of legendaries a nine or ten I can't remember nine because it was some if he's with the rule book but I love that game so far you know I love it and I don't usually go back and re-rank my games because I want that kind of first sort of not initial impression but initial sort of Impressions plural but I give glue Maven a 10 because it was such a friggin achievement of all of this stuff at the time it was Legacy it was dungeon crawly it had Euro mechanics like kind of major Knight sort of card play-ish and all this cool stuff it was a campaign any of your Euro Gamers you liked it sometimes and you know if you're like a Dunder call person you liked it and you know kind of hit all those different bells and whistles and so I give it a 10.

and now I ran into brass Birmingham uh a nine I don't know why it probably is a 10 there's nothing wrong with the game now since this brigading happened I actually dropped my gloomhaven rating down to an eight so I'm a little bit guilty but whatever kind of like I said it kind of ticked me off and then I bumped brass Birmingham from a nine to a ten but there are certain things like pandemic Legacy season one I gave it a flat ten I'll never play it again now the board game geek rating says this is what you would play at any time but I'm never gonna play a legacy game like pandemic Legacy again as a 10. it just the rating system doesn't fit for that it doesn't work doesn't make sense but my quality of experience this is again this my subjective quality in a sense of trying to look at it in an objective way what do I think the quality of this game is what do I think it is I think this is a freaking tan pandemic Legacy season one in this example because it just was a rocket ship of a story all the way through I mean it was you know I would say it wasn't the perfect experience but it was about as close to perfect as you could get and this is just what I took away and I just admired the game on itself in a vacuum like that and the same idea was gloomhaven it's not in my top 50. it's I don't care about it that much I would if you want to play denture crawl there's a list of probably at least five or six that I would play over it but when I take a step back and look at it my subjective objective kind of analysis of its quality is a 10 because I don't think you can be purely objective about games because it just you know you can't be

so but my try to my attempt to assess it was that's a 10. okay but I'm happy that something else passed it because frankly I do enjoy brass Birmingham more if somebody said play one of the other I play breast where I am so that excites me too but I like that it's a totally different game but that's so that's how I ranked the games um there's a lot of other games like that like Arboretum is another one I give a 10 because I think for what it does that little simple card sort of rummy-esque type of thing with a little bit of uh area sort of mindset thing I think it perfectly works with the 10. it's a 10. because I would play that in that case I kind of fits the BGG ranking I would probably play at any time if you know given opportunity but it's not my favorite game I don't even know my top 50. but the thing is a freaking 10. like it's just perfectly elegantly discreetly great it's just a great little filler 30 minute game and it's perfect for what it is um so if it's Barbara yeah so anyway that's kind of my thing these Jokers that are like brigading each other back and forth on braspberry this is stupid it's dumb it's just a dumb thing and this whole identity gamer crap of like my identity is this style of game that pisses me off because I I started to make this video and I was like this is great we have all of these different things that are all of these kind of different identities of games that are giving me these different experiences I don't always want to shuffle cubes and do economics and do all this stuff sometimes I want to mash Thanos against

the Warhammer army or whatever and just trip out on this like weird shroomed out fantasy battle thing because whatever you know because the Earth is not super great sometimes and so sometimes I just need that to unplug and you know Jack that IV into my vein and go that way today you know what I mean so that's a that's an awesome thing that's one of the best parts of the hobby is that aspect is that I can push and pull and do whatever I freaking want to do based on my mood or whatever or whatever I feel like getting into I can go relive the 1960 election between Richard Nixon and John F Kennedy if I really want to sit down and sort of be in that mind space that's great that is not any better or intellectual or anything than playing Warhammer on a tabletop it just isn't it's just whatever you feel like so this identity thing which I think was what drives some of this like brigading because how are you so invested in a game that you're going to go rate this other game that you've never played a one so your game can be on top that makes sense so that dovetails into my last Point here and I will put a link to a video by Eric Martin who works at Board Game Geek and he sort of reestablished um a nice Baseline for you know how the Rings are I thought he covered a pretty pretty deftly there and this whole thing is kind of reaction you know that you see people being invested in a game and stuff uh he had some different takes than me and I but largely like 95 agreed with everything he says in that video there was one thing that I thought and he kind of talked around it too so I wouldn't say initially disagree with him

here um but I just had like kind of a different spin on it so let's just set kind of a thought experiment here so let's say you're somebody that I'm going to steal a little bit from Eric you're somebody that played pandemic didn't really like it like you give it a five or six let's say or maybe he hated it so you go and you rake it and that's fine you don't like pandemic give it a five whatever he feels appropriate based on your sort of take on it and then pandemic Legacy season one comes out and you you're like ah Legacy maybe that seems neat but it's pandemic I don't really like that so I'm not even gonna look at it okay so now you are sort of logging a phantom non-rating because you didn't go in and log it because if you did play it you probably get of a five or six maybe a four because you're like us it's not only is something I don't really care for now it's a legacy and I have to play it 13 times so you might even drop it down lower but in this state that you're like okay I'm not even gonna play it so most people and Eric says this and I agree with it are just going to go oh don't care for that move on and not go and actually downrank the game because they don't want to play it now some people will now I've seen them especially with Legacy games and other stuff they go that looks like a game I don't want to play let me make sure I give that a four or three or a one there are people that will do that but Eric and aircon talked around this you can go watch the video and kind of get his words but he was also like well in a way

the BG ranking sort of fails because it isn't logging the normal person that doesn't want to go down vote a game it doesn't log their thing because it could be um very honest and sincere that they would give it a five because they just really wouldn't play and they can kind of see that and maybe if they did play a couple of games of it they'd end up giving it a five anyway but that five doesn't exist because they've moved on with their life and I don't think I think that's perfect I think that's the rating system working as designed in that particular case because if you look at let's take a look at gloomhaven now like I said at the beginning that was this perfect storm of things that people really like Dungeon Crawl nice modern mechanics Legacy stuff campaign Etc good combat you know so that was a perfect storm and so that stretched its sort of umbrella and its little bubble in its membrane around a larger swath of people than everything else so you know if you take the BGG rankings as they are it bubbled it up to the top and that's fine that is a way it doesn't push anything else down unnecessarily it just happened to rise to the top in a very I think very positive and healthy way and I assume in a healthy way with brass Birmingham when it hit the top when Twilight Struggle and it hit the top and that kind of stuff so people really love the thing that's bubbling its weights at the top okay so that to me I think that's an okay sort of state to be in now you can debate the aggregate algorithms and all these things that you

know BGG does in a in a transparent and sometimes a hidden way with some of its chill ratings that it throws in fives to everything and to kind of even stuff out I don't know I'm not gonna get into the math of that I don't know if the math is is good or not um I think that's another debate but I think that if the outcome of it is a lot of people love this thing even though there's a lot of people that maybe even more people that just don't inconsider it they don't even think about it they pass it by then it's okay that these things bubble up to the top because these are the most enthusiastic people about it and this is where the game the enthusiasm lies in the hobby right now it's like gloomhaven brass Birmingham what else is up there Arc Nova Twilight Imperium fourth is up there uh trying to remember what else that they're doing Imperium is really crept up over the last couple of years that's where the enthusiasm is that's the important part because like I said there's not really a good concrete objective objective objective you can kind of be subjectively objective I think that's possible I think it's possible myself and I think that's a lot of what goes on is it's just the enthusiasm sort of energy and all that stuff that's where the energy is those are the games that rise up that's okay that's what that indicator is that's where the Enthusiast energy is at now it does lend itself to more complex games you know not very many family games and hit that top level and all that stuff but I think that's okay because you might sell more copies of Ticket to Ride and you know the base game of

pandemic and that's great and that's another metric you can look at and that's a metric that they can live on and that's a good metric because you can see it's hitting a lot more homes and a lot more families those particular games but if you look at the BG rankings where's the enthusiasm where's the enthusiasm Gap where's that metric it's right there that top you know probably 500 games on BGG frankly um is where that enthusiasm is at and I think that's a good thing and that's what got me excited to go to talk a little bit about that and then these Jokers started brigading each other and I'm like ah you guys are being a bunch of jerks to each other be happy that something new has come I think something new is coming by the end of the year and I said this when gloomhaven come out I said by the end of the year Blue Man's gonna be the number one game on BG I just knew it and I was way late it was by the middle of the year I think it was by like May or June that year it was number one I think Arc Nova is going to hit there I think our numbers maybe I'll be a little off but arcanova's gonna hit number one I think probably by the end of this year 2023 and then you know we'll have another a new one I wish I kind of wish for brass birmingham's sake it would have a year or so and they could get replaced I kind of like that something will sit there people will get exposed to it you know be excited about it and then a completely different type of game maybe you know replaces it although brass and Argo aren't really that far apart they're different styles of Euros but they're big heavy Euros uh but then we'll see and we'll see in like five years maybe there'll be some maybe League Engineers probably not but you know or something like that something

different you know what I mean something a little a little different than what we've seen so that's what I like that was getting me excited I think if you your number one game that you love is getting replaced just just around okay um that's it thanks thank you

Progress saved