My Top 5 Favourite Games: #3 to #1!
Transcript
last episode we started counting down my top five favorite games of all time and this episode of brains on games we're going to talk about the top three welcome to brains on games I'm Dr Brian McDonald in this episode we're going to crack the top three of my top five favorite games of all time so let's talk about the number three game and like I said in the last episode if you haven't uh peaked at it yet in the last episode I mentioned that my top five might be you know it's always in flux it depends on the mood that I happen to be in but we are talking about games that I have had the greatest experiences playing with my family so let's with that out of the way let's talk about my number three game of all time number three the only dexterity game on the list although I do love dexterity games uh it is an old game called crocodile let me pick up my crocodile board this thing is gigantic so you're gonna it's kind of heavy and large let me see if I can get it up there well you might have to see some some pictures of it I might put up some graphics of this beautiful thing this is a a board a tournament sized crocodile board that I picked up from a local crafter basically perfect.ca is their
website but this is just a gorgeous game one of the reasons why I I wanted to have a crocodile board at home I you know I I honestly I wanted to have a pool table but pool tables do take up a lot of space you really do need a dedicated space for a pool table and I didn't want to take up my entire game room with a pool table but I think that croconol was the next best thing and then I wound up enjoying crocodile even more than I like pool this is a beautiful game when you get the right board it's a beautiful game and I'm I was lucky enough recently to find a a mounting system so now I'm able to get it out of the way and hang it up on the wall so this thing is like a piece of art and I'll try and find some other photos of boards from basically perfect who's like I said these guys are local so I was excited to track them down online so it's a dexterity game where players are going typically be playing with two players and you're going to be flicking these discs across the board trying to earn the most points the first player to 100 points wins we've been using poker chips to keep track of those points I have dice in the bag as well to a 10-sided dice so that uh each in in the same colors as the discs that I have so there's some black discs and some black Dice and some blue discs and blue dice in this bag and you're just flicking discs across the board trying to get close to the center you can create blockers there's these
pins here that are in the way and they are quite bouncy if you give it a good flick that they are quite bouncy sorry for the racket but uh if if you've got a good board that has some good action uh this is a game that is just so much fun everybody wants to watch you play you'll you'll be cheering when an amazing shot happens uh and you'll be very disappointed when you're just not quite able to thread the needle and and uh do what you want make that disc do what you want it to do uh but boy oh boy when you've got pieces laid out and you just make an amazing shot crocodile is a special game and we've always had great experiences playing it I did a video about croconal um way back when I talked about croconol and Binion which is another great flicking game but crocodile is definitely my favorite I mean it's in my top five of all it's number three in the top five games of all time uh and it is a game I I don't know if I said this on the video before but I know I've told my dad before that I'm not a guy who goes out to wax his car but I do regularly wax my croconole board to make sure that it's nice and slippery for those discs to slide across the board so croconol is definitely uh in my top five sometimes it's higher than number three but for today's video it's my number three favorite game foreign number two number two on my list of top five
favorite games uh is another sort of Euro style strategy game um one of I think the the best strategy games of all time for reasons that we'll talk about uh it is Concordia now the version I have is Concordia Venus I think that's the one now that you can get Venus was an expansion to the original Concordia but now you get the base game and the Venus expansion together in one box and it is a big box with the big board here you'll only be able to see a little part of it because I've kind of kept it folded up so that I had enough room to show some things but it's another one of those economic games where what you're doing is you're traveling around this map of of Greece or other parts of Europe and you're establishing trading houses so each of the cities is going to have some logo on it where it tells you what resource you're going to collect if you produce resources in that City and you're moving these little meeples around or you've got sailboats as well and what you're trying to do is build trading houses that are going to allow you to collect those resources you can sell and buy resources and and you're collecting cards there's a deck building element to it as well so you're creating trade routes and you're buying these cards that are going to allow you to take actions so you start with all of these cards in your hand and you discard them to do an action in the game uh and and that is really the I think unique
element here so you're you're it's action selection but you've got all of these cards in your hand and you're going to discard them to do that action maybe to build a trade house or to produce resources or to trade goods whatever it is that you're trying to do and then you can't take that action again until you collect your cards back so every player has a card that allows them to collect their discard pile and take it back into their hand but you earn more money if you're collecting more cards so you don't want to keep playing that and using your action to take the cards back anyway it's just a brilliant brilliant mechanism and and it's it it is also clear because exactly what you're doing is explained it's described on the card you don't need a giant rule book to play this game it does not take very long to learn the basics but it is very strategic and so you you will find yourself you know okay well I understand how to play this now but you may not understand how to win until you've played it half a dozen times uh so you it's it's got the trading and the trade routes there are all of these multiple Maps these maps are are double-sided and different maps are better for different play counts so you can have a nice crowded map when you're only playing two players or a great big one for five players so it's very very flexible uh of course we've upgraded all the resources so we've got bolts of cloth here uh and little containers for the wine in the game you've got wheat and iron that your tools really that you might be
collecting and Bricks of course as well and these resources are going to allow you to do some other things the other thing that's neat about the game is that you don't count up your points until the end so you can sort of tell from looking at the trade routes you know what people are and what cards people are collecting into their hand uh what they're going for but you don't really know what the score is until the end of the game beginners can do kind of at the halfway point they can count up their score to see where things are and where everybody stands but you don't really really know until the end which I really liked and it winds up being a game where you're pulling these cards into your hand that are going to give you into your deck that are going to give you points at the end of the game and it really is the deck building that's the most important but that deck also gives you more options in terms of what you can do on your your turn because those cards are going to come into your hand and each of those cards gives you some action so you might be trying to collect all of the cards that are about having a trading house in each province of the board or having multiple trading houses province of the board and then ah it's it's just a fantastic game and because the actions are so clearly explained on these cards like you don't need to understand any crazy iconography the pictures on the little city tiles are very clear what you're producing there's a picture of a brick so you're going to get a brick for that one I didn't pull
out a tools tools resource here but it doesn't quite it looks like an anvil instead of looking like this iron ingot that I have here it just makes it easy to explain so it's very very strategic but new players can pick it up fairly quickly and it's one that gets pulled out at our house when someone wants to play a more advanced or complicated strategy game but they're just learning and you don't want to spend an hour explaining the rule or watching a video to learn how to play so Concordia I think is just perfect for that reason it's a great introduction to complicated sort of Euro strategy games it's a nice economic game where you're building trade routes and you're moving things around the board and then if you've got those upgraded resources you're playing with your toys as well number one and that brings us to my favorite game my favorite game of all time now it might not have the highest ranking on Board Game Geek or or whatever but this is a game that I've played again and again and I've had such good experiences so much fun to to play with my kids this game and it's a game called You're Going to Hear It rattling around here because all of the tiles are inside the Box a game called The Duke now this is not the original box I had a custom box made because we had so many expansions they wouldn't all fit uh in the original box so we'll put up a graphic of what the Duke box looks like this this is sorry it's rattling here but this is I think one of the First videos I made on the
channel was about the Duke because it is a game that I love so much and it's a game that I love apparently because it it's small enough and it doesn't take up too much space on the table and you can play it it's a two player game and when my son was at soccer practice his younger brother would be with me and often we would sit at a table somewhere and and play The Duke uh it's a game that doesn't blow away because all the pieces are made of wood and so we would play this at restaurants we would play it on picnic tables uh near the soccer field Whenever there was a soccer practice we had I I mean I carried a copy of the Duke around in the trunk of my car for years uh honestly just so that we would be able to pull it out and play at any given time let me open this up and I'll show you what the Duke is all about so the Duke is a game it's it's a little like chess that's how it was sort of introduced to us we were at I think we were at Comic-Con or something a local Comic-Con and we went to the game table area where people were playing board games and my son was with his friend and we had played some other games but his his friend liked chess and so we said to the guy who was running the joint you know what's a game that that someone who enjoys chess would enjoy trying out and this was the game that got pulled out so it is a chess-like kind of a game uh but it's it's just brilliant in the way that it works because you've got these tiles but each tile has a grid that shows how it moves so this one can move forward or backward or from side to side one space
you start the gain with a Duke and two footmen and then you've got a bag full of these other tiles on your turn you can either move a piece or pull a piece at random out of the bag and put it onto the board next to your dupe always has to be next to the Duke unless you have some special ability that allows you to do it to do it a different way there are expansions that replace some of the tiles or that you can allow you to draw that allow you to replace the tiles that you've drawn there are characters from movies Conan we've got a Conan expansion we've got um King Arthur there's a King Arthur expansion that's why they're so I needed so much room you can see here I needed so much room for all of these pieces that wouldn't fit in the original box so we've got the Three Musketeers and we've got Siege engines there's a catapult in there somewhere but your the idea here is that I've got things placed in the wrong spot here now the idea is that you're either moving your piece or you're drawing a new piece out of the bag and putting on on the board beside your Duke once you move it you flip it over and now it moves in a different way so again it's just brilliant you've got to plan ahead how you're going to move these things one of the variants the main way that you're going to play this game is that you're trying to capture the opponent's Duke uh and the Duke can move all the way from one side of the board to the other or all the way back and forth depending on which side of the piece is facing up uh so you're trying to capture the opponent's Duke but there are variations in the rules where you're playing Capture the Flag or there's a
dragon in the middle of the field that's going to go back and forth and and really take some of your pieces off the board if you get too closer if you're in the wrong place um you've got just these great pieces in here that allow you to move in all different ways you can jump over some of the pieces can jump over other players some of the pieces can slide all the way across the board but you're not always going to have the same pieces on the board at any given time because you're pulling them at random from this bag so you start out with everything except for your Duke and two footment in here and you go from there like I said there are some variations that allow you to do different things you might draw one out and have to replace it you might put different pieces in your bag depending on if you're playing with the the uh the Robin Hood expansion or the Three Musketeers or Conan the Barbarian in uh because there's a Robert E Howard expansion as well so it is um it is a game that uh I just have nothing but fond memories of playing and I didn't even even though I was playing against my son when he was young I didn't always win he is really good at those spatial games and one thing I can say about these kinds of more advanced strategy games especially games like this where it is quite abstract and spatial is that uh for my son at least he always had that skill and these games allowed him to kind of experience those feelings that feeling of Mastery that feeling of oh this is something that I'm good at and I think through playing these games he's developed this sense of himself as a guy who has kind of an engineering
brain he's wired to see things in this he was all he had a natural Talent at this but it was a natural talent that kept I think that kept building and building and developing through playing games that forced him to I mean this is one of the reasons why I did this I started this channel is that it's it's through through practicing that skill you're kind of developing and reinforcing uh those abilities by playing this game and gradually he developed a sense of himself as a person who who had strong spatial skills who was very good at visual problem solving who who was excellent at at thinking ahead and anticipating what the other player was going to do and he could lay traps for me because that's not the way my brain works so he could lay traps for me on the board he knew how I was going to react a lot of the time and then he he would just uh sometimes it was frustrating for me because here I am playing against this little kid uh and he's he sometimes he would just wipe the floor with me with these kinds of games but the Duke was the one that kind of that did really start at all I would say um and uh and really helped my son to develop a sense of himself as someone who had those kinds of skills and now he's doing computer programming engineering kinds of stuff you know I can't say that I owe it all to the fact that we've played these kinds of games because I'm certain that he was sort of wired that way genetically but experience also plays a role and this was something he wasn't just doing
Hands-On things he wasn't just doing sports he certainly wasn't only playing video games although that was something that he still loves to do but we did play The Duke a lot and those kinds of games I think encouraged him to see himself in a certain way and and that set him on a pathway and now he's taking courses that he really loves he's getting in touch almost every day to tell me what that he learned about at school because I like technology and computers but I don't know the things that he's learning about I'm not a programmer it's just a game that we've had nothing but great experiences with and that's why the Duke is number one in my book I think tabletop bellhop really likes the Duke as well so I'll give him a shout out too I don't know if it's his favorite game of all time but certainly just the ability to to Lug it around with you wherever you go to have it in the back seat of your car in the trunk of your car and to pull it out because you're not playing with cards and pieces that are going to blow around um it's I can't say enough good things about the Duke and that's why the Duke is my number one favorite game of all time just like I said last time if you have suggestions if you want to talk about your favorite games if you want to give me suggestions for games that I should play that maybe are similar to The Duke or one of the other ones that we've talked about here in the top five I haven't played I mean I have hundreds of games back here but I haven't played every game ever made uh you can leave those comments and suggestions in the comment section below the video or you
can email me at Brian brainsongames.ca brainsongames.c is the website that's where future episodes ago and the previous ones are up there already brains on games is the Twitter handle and the Facebook page and the Instagram feed so we're all over the place and if you enjoyed this video and you want to be notified of future once you can head on over to YouTube and click that subscribe button thanks for joining me and hopefully I'll see you next time
thank you