Viticulture Bordeaux puts a fresh face on an icon - TCbH Expansion Month Review
Transcript
Ah, Viticulture, my love. Oh, oh, hi. Um, yeah, so, uh, one of the inspirations for TCBH's expansion month, where we're spending all of April doing interviews, reviews, and discussions centered around the good, bad, and ugly of expansions, is that Viticulture, along with Root, Beast, Wingspan, etc., etc., has a new expansion. But, unlike the others, Bordeaux is maybe the slightest of the bunch. A single board, a set of cubes per color, and some cards for reference. In general, I tend to not love board replacement expansions, particularly in Euros, as they mean I'm displacing other content and usually just for a light change of variable position or some minor rule variants that doesn't feel particularly consequential enough to warrant keeping multiple boards on hand, and the fact is that I play so many games that the frequency in which I'm playing any individual game means that there's enough time in between that the original board ain't exactly getting stale.
I get it, some people love them, but for me, for the most part, they're just kind of nah. But, Bordeaux hits a bit different. Instead of being some parallel variant which you could optionally choose, which I guess technically that is exactly what it is, it really feels like the approach made in this board is to try to reimagine what a new edition of Viticulture, if designed with modern sensibilities, could be. To the untrained eye, Bordeaux's board looks pretty much like the Viticulture you know and love, with a front and back featuring the two seasons of the base game and four seasons from the celebrated and often seen as essential Tuscany expansion. Look a little closer and you'll quickly spot that each worker action location has a highlighted box below indicating an expert bonus you can invest in, generally available at a small cost from a spring worker action. When purchased, these bonuses just give you, and only you, an exclusive bonus or improved version of the location's action when you place there, with some notably powerful effects ranging from increasing your residual income to being able to place your hired worker immediately on a vacant spring or summer spot. Some others are still powerful, though a bit more situational, but all in all, the utility of these is dope.
Next, and less flashy, but low-key just as important, is the trade zone. Gone is the star-based area control mini-game of Tuscany, the only element of that expansion that can't be carried into the Bordeaux board, which, frankly, is the least important and most tacked on. And this new trade system accomplishes just as much tension, but gives you more interesting levers. Now, when you make a trade, you mark the exchange you did, making it so no one can make that same trade again, meaning there's a bit more pressure, but the economy of exchange creates some interesting dynamics throughout the game. I didn't expect to really care about this so much, but this ended up being the most clever and subtle part of the expansion to me. Finally, in every nook and cranny of familiar actions and game flow, you'll find some fine-tuned balancing, gently shaving and shaping it based off of a decade of feedback that the designer has had at this point, from making it so two vine and two order cards are always available in the display to be chosen from if you don't want to blind draw from the deck, to numerous actions and wake-up chart bonuses doing individual or even group wine and grape aging, to the take another action anywhere on the board spot, or harvesting by default giving you a harvest on two fields. Heck, even the economy is all balanced out, giving all players one starting residual income, something that was previously incredibly [snorts] precious, but to
balance that out, you start with only one field, your center field, available and the other two on their sold side, which can be purchased at a spot which, might I point out, also lets you harvest in spring, but only harvesting one field. So, again, you got to make important economic choices. Bordeaux isn't just introducing new mechanics, it's the kind of new board that, if this came out with a Viticulture second edition, third edition, extra essential edition, essential edition part two, yeah, anyway, point being, if this were the new definitive board, I think everyone would just accept it, and I commend that. It's the stated goal in both the rulebook and a recent interview I did for expansion month, which you can check out on this channel, that this is Jamey Stegmaier coming back to Viticulture as a more experienced, mature designer, and thinking about the things that gamers have said about the game over the last decade, and figuring out ways to tool it so that way players can get into the action faster, have more choice about how to approach their engine, have more paths to their winemaking, and just, in general, have more agency. But then last year I was like, I kind of want to revisit it. I've learned a lot from this game over the years. I've learned a lot from playing it, hearing what people say about it, and I've learned a lot from Tuscany, too, and how people played with this
extended board and how they liked having four seasons. And so, even in the in the Bordeaux rulebook, I outlined some of the things I started to think about and goals that I had for revisiting the game. So, two very different maps there for two two games. Um, a desire from a designer to come back to revisit it versus a a plan that we wanted to execute over time. Here's the thing, I don't think Bordeaux is an essential expansion, as Viticulture Essential Edition is already one of my very favorite games of all time, and had this never come out, that wouldn't have changed. But, it's hard for me to not imagine playing with it. The compatibility with other expansions, the fact that it has all you need to play the four seasons without Tuscany, even if you don't want to play with the buildings and special workers, it's really an elegant and inviting expansion. I've taught new Viticulture players it. Heck, our buddy Steve bought Viticulture and Bordeaux later in the evening after playing it with us, and I can't believe I'm saying this because it's so long been celebrated as one of the best board game expansions of all time,
considering that you can play with all four seasons out the gate here, which is one of the most essential parts of what makes Tuscany so, essential. There's a world where this expansion is the perfect amount of complexity for you to get along. But, let's be real, though. I love the unique buildings and the special workers, so I'm going to be playing with Tuscany and Bordeaux. If I have any complaints, it's a sneaking suspicion that some of the expert actions are going to be a mandatory rush every game. Not to great in balance, but you know that every game they're going to get bought, but that's going to come with more time and reflection, and isn't that far of a departure from some of the challenges Viticulture has always had. So, in the context of expansion month, this is such a great example of a refresher expansion, a category I didn't even really think about when I was originally working on my notes with on this month with the rest of the TCBH crew. Nothing here feels terribly new or additive, and it's not really fixing anything, but it is a smart and competent refresh on Stonemaier's debut, and I dig it. And that's our review, but let me know, what is your favorite way to play Viticulture now that it's such a story game, has a bunch of different ways that you can approach it.
Put it in the comments below, and then, as always, thanks for watching, thanks for supporting, thanks for doing all the things that help us grow, including the like, subscribe, comments, shares, and of course, checking out our Patreon. Definitely check out all the other expansion month coverage that we're doing. We're trying to make this a real event, and hopefully, if it goes well, then we'll do this in the future, and you can look forward to it in 2027. But, above all, thanks for being such a great community. You know, I've been Jack for The Cardboard Herald.