Skip to main content
Loading video...

Do These Board Games Still Deserve a Spot in Our Collection? | Collection Curration Shelf 5

Transcript 23:40

Hi, I'm Sarah.

And I'm Drew.

And we're back for another uh collection curation video today. It's been a while.

Oh, yeah.

Um we're both teachers and this time of year is super busy for us. Plus, I think we got hung up a little bit on this shelf, which we'll talk a little bit about later here, too. There's only five games on this shelf.

Um, and so I thought this would be so easy to just knock out, but we we did get hung up on this one a little bit. But if you're new here, collection curation is our project where we are playing through our collection shelf by shelf and kind of deciding what deserves its space on our shelves and what could probably find a new home,

right? We're trying to be pretty ruthless. I'm feeling a little bit philosophical on this one. Um just because there were some tough calls in this bunch of games and

um just I may not talk about this a little bit later with one of the games, but I just want every game when I look at it to be like yes, that is a yes game. That is I will play that. [snorts]

Maybe not anytime,

but I definitely know when I will play that.

Right. Right. And I think as as a precursor, there'll be some people that will disagree um maybe with a decision or two, but at the end of the day, if it's not going to hit the table reliably, it's just it's not going to stay.

Yeah, I definitely think we have a few firsts here. Um so, we'll talk about those as we get to them, too. But, um this was a hard shell for us, as you can probably already tell. But, I think we're ready to just dig into it. Here we go. Firstly, we're going to start with the game that we played with our daughter, [clears throat] which is Sunrise Lane. There were no games on this shelf that we played as a full family, but Emma was interested in trying Sunrise Lane with us.

And Sunrise Lane, um, I kind of look at it as a little ticket to ride

um where you're collecting these cards to then be able to play out on the board, but instead of building routes and trains, you are building sections of this city,

right? And so each space has it's a it's a it's a color. Yes. Each space has a color that you can place there. And um the number Yes, the value. So um as you can tell, I've already kind of forgotten a little bit about how to play this game. We had played it once before we played it with our daughter. But there are some interesting combos that you can do. You can skip a space and continue building.

Um that's not going to gain you points, but um there's some interesting decisions to make.

Yeah. And um it it's an interesting little citybuer. Um it's kind of neat with the time you get done what you've built up and and um a fairly lightweight game. Um

I do appreciate how each player color is a different style of house. That's really interesting and adds a lot to the gameplay. It's very tactical. So or like tactile, not tactical tactile.

Um but in the end,

are we ready to kind of give our Okay. Three, two, one, call.

In the end, it just didn't capture us enough.

Yeah. And it's it's a fairly lightweight game. Um that, you know, I I don't know that it goes on too long, but they we once you play it a few times, you kind of know what it has.

Yeah. Maybe you've we've seen in just a couple plays, we've seen kind of what this game has to offer. And this type of game has choices that we will lean towards more often than this one. Yeah. Yeah,

it kind of gets lost in the shuffle for what it is for us personally.

Yeah. And but if you know if you had kids that were 8 to 10 or something like that, this is a really good um again, not route build route building, but it's it's a really interesting um

there's a little area majority to it.

Yeah, exactly. So, there's there's some decisions and and how you're going to lead to bigger spaces and from smaller scoring ones to bigger ones and stuff like that. So,

and the art is really pretty on the cards. It's a pretty productive.

It's a great I mean it's a great game, but

just not for us at this point in our collection.

Moved on.

So, Sunrise Lane is going to be a call.

And um now we're moving on to probably what's going to be the most controversial call perhaps of this whole project. And you're going to know right off the bat, we have called this game because it is no longer in our collection. We had the opportunity to attend a local con that has a a swap meat type

type market

and you can usually get

and we were able to sell this game there.

Yeah. Um this one has it's got a lot going on. Uh you've got everything from set collection to um what do I want to say?

Worker placement uh track movement. There's there's a lot going on and it's definitely one of those that has a lot of thinking moments and I can definitely see a lot of AP. I know I felt that the first way we played. Um this last time we played I liked it quite a bit better.

Mhm.

Um but I just didn't feel like it was going to hit the table.

Yeah. It's it's a heavier game. I'm giving lots of clues here. It's a heavier game. Probably one of the heavier in our collection. But we had just come off of this um what what did we call it? uh CrunchCon where we were playing some of the heavier games in our collection and this one it just fell flat when we compared it to those other games. And so I think if we have the time for a heavy game, we're not going to reach for this one. We're going to reach for the others. And so this one was Darwin's Journey. And this is going to be so controversial because I know this is a darling of so many and so many people really love this game

for us. for the weight that it is, the very limited worker placement doesn't always work well for us. We feel like we get trapped and we can't do as much as we want to. Whereas I know a lot of people love that puzzle of, oh, I can't do this, so what can I do what to maximize my turn still? That doesn't feel good to us,

right? I and I think that in the end that was the one thing that got it cold was it just felt like on your turn you wanted to do these things, you know, these however many, but you could do about half of that or 2/3 and it just it left that I'm not I'm not making all the strides I want to.

Yeah.

At the end of the day and that those games don't usually stick around for us.

Yeah. I mean there there are a lot of big names that we have bounced off of because of this. we don't feel like we can do anything on our turn. And that's just a personal preference that something we've learned about ourselves in gaming is that we want to have these epic turns. It doesn't have to be every turn, but we want to have that ability at some point in time. got to happen some point.

And I think you can in Darwin's Journey, but it's one of those where you need to know the game a little bit better than we probably

and even even then you're going to have a couple of those throughout the entire hour and a half game.

And between, you know, the the limited times you make that really tick for you compared to the time it takes. I think [clears throat] those things just like I said, just didn't work for us. And I think the thing that drew you to Darwin's Journey in the beginning as a science person, science teacher was the theme. And we just felt like the theme didn't come out as strongly as some of our other heavier, more thematic games.

Yeah, agreed. It it felt like this could be anything. You are going through this set collection, but those sets could be anything. You're playing this these players here or there, but that could be, you know, it just didn't feel

as immersive. Yeah. As we wanted it to. So, unfortunately, Darwin's Journey has left our collection already. It's a Cole. So,

there you go. [snorts]

All right. Our next one is another big box game, but a much faster play. This is Distilled. Um, Pverson Games does such a great job with production. Um, this is one of those that I backed based off of the theme, based off of, you know, just a few different things like this. And it's it's really an interesting one. You've got uh what do I want to say? You're you're deck building to a degree.

Yeah. But you're you're not going to keep those cards once you use them. Um and we just said talked about a game that we bounced off of because it wasn't as thematic, but distilled is [clears throat] so thematic. Everything is tied together to what you're doing in this game, which is distilling alcohol.

And so you can gain things to your distillery that are going to help you. You can upgrade your distillery. You can get people that will help you in that upgrade area, too. Marketers, that kind of stuff. You can get premium ingredients that are going to add to the value. You can get premium bottles and equipment that are going to add to the value.

And so, that whole washback system [clears throat] of a little push your luck, a little bit of hedging your bets as far as how many of this type of card do I need to have in here to make sure that I make what I want to make,

right? Um, and so much of it, again, it's so well themed, it's so well done, the art is really good, the production value was great. Um, all these things, but it's also it's not that long of a game once you understand what you're doing. You know, you're going to play this in an hour if you

It says 30 minutes per player. We've only ever played it at two, so take that with a grain of salt. Maybe it is longer at a higher player,

but you know, honestly, what what takes the most time is the market phase. And usually on that, you kind of know what you're going for anyway. And then the washback, the the uh distilling pursuit, that's all, you know, in unison. So, yeah, I I just think that this is a really interesting game.

Yes. And we have kind of come to the part of the this shelf where I was really excited because this shelf does have some of our very favorite games on it. And so, that's why I really thought it would be so easy for us to go through, especially this time of year. We just got stuck on a couple of things. Um, but Distilled is a very game, I would say. Probably more so for Drew, but I really do enjoy it as well. So, are we ready?

Yep.

3 2 1 Keep.

We're even looking forward to the expansion that's coming out very soon, I think, within the next few months. So,

we did get a chance to play that and it's fantastic. So, it adds a lot.

It adds a lot. Um, I don't know if I'd play it if I'm playing a bigger group of this. I don't know how you'd fit it on the table if you were playing with four, but for two, it added a lot a lot to this um experience. So, not only are we keeping distilled, but we are going to be adding to our distilled world that we have on our shelves. So, distilled as a keep. Next up, we've got Earth. And I think I am always surprised at how divisive Earth is. It feels like it's one of those games where you either love it or you really do not like it. Um, things that I really enjoy about Earth, I think that the photography is really beautiful.

Um, I love the engine building aspect where every time you activate a color of an action, you are going to then activate your whole tableau as far as that color that's in there. And so that's really satisfying

and the positive interaction. Somebody takes a turn, they get the the higher power um of that turn, but everybody else gets something and they all get to activate all those types of things. So there's a lot going on and while it is a little, you know, solitire,

it it can be um there's a few things that add to it.

They Yeah, they they have added to it um to try to get a little more interaction here and there.

The expansion, the abundance expansion does have some cards that will say

take this if you if the people on either side of you have this. So, there are some things like that that they've tried to do, but it's still

it's my sweet spot of gaming as far as I don't want anyone messing with my area. Like, I don't want Drew to come in and be like, "Oh, I'm taking that card." Like, that is just the worst thing to me because you can plan and really be intentional about how you're building stuff, but when someone can come along and ruin it, that just doesn't feel good.

And especially if it's got a the certain things that you're going for for your goals and stuff like that and somebody, you know, that's that's rough. This doesn't have really any of that. Everything that happens is fairly positive.

Um, and you're really in charge of your stuff. Like you said, you don't have that interaction that's going to mess it up.

Yep.

So,

exactly. Um, and I just think the scoring opportunities are so big in this game. You can go into sprouts, you can go into trees, you can go into the goals, you can really pursue a lot of different strategies. And in the end, you probably need two or three of those things to really take home that victory in this game. You can't just go all in on one strategy and expect to win this one.

Yeah, there's there's a lot there. Um and uh it gives you a lot of flexibility when you're starting to get cards right at the beginning and you're just not sure, you know, I don't have the sprouts. Maybe I'm going to have to go for that growth and some of the other uh what is it? the um ecosystem type cards you put in too. So there's a lot that that's just phenomenal.

Yeah. So are you ready?

Yep.

3 2 1 keep.

This is my number one game of all time. It it was realistically not going anywhere. No.

Um I am looking forward to the animals expansion is going to be coming out soon that had kickstarted. And um there are a few new offshoot games coming out. There's Behind the Lens and The Earth Express, which I we just um are going to have the opportunity to play here soon, and I cannot wait to see how that translates.

I Yeah, 15 minutes for that experience.

So, stay tuned for that. I'm sure that we will have some coverage of that on on the channel because I I just I don't know how it's going to work, but I've heard it's really good and taking one of my favorite games and making it even more accessible just sounds amazing to me. So again, like distilled, not only are we keeping earth, but we will be adding to the amount of earth that is on our shelves. So that's a keeper.

And our final game is Beast. So this is by Studio Mithall. They have some really interesting things. So it's a hidden movement uh essentially game, one versus all. One player plays one of the various beasts that they can pick from, and then you have the others, however many are in the game, playing as hunters. uh trying to track down the beast before the beast is able to make enough big kills to basically drive people out of their area of the ancient forest that they've always been in. Um so it's got this uh kind of a interesting give and take and again that hidden movement on the beast part. Each beast has different uh strategies and things that they need to do. And at the same time, you as you get these cards, you are then playing one as an action and then passing. And so, it's got some interesting things as far as do I play this card that maybe isn't that great for me, but it'll keep it away from the beast or the hunters so that they don't have a much bigger power. Um, and some stuff like that. So, it's a really interesting game. Um,

yes. And I know our our copy, the production quality is fantastic. I don't know if this is the Kickstarter.

It is the Kickstarter, but it fairing pretty well across the board. Studio Mithall really does do some amazing production. And the art uh the art was actually done by one of the game developers themselves, which the art is gorgeous. Um, really an interesting vibe to it.

So, um, this is this is what This is the one that I really struggled with. Um, we various issues here when it comes to collecting board games. Sometimes you take a risk on a game. You think it's going to check all these boxes and then it's just not hitting the table.

Um, especially with with Kickstarting with crowdfunding.

And it could be that it checks some boxes for one,

but those boxes aren't for somebody else. And that can definitely happen. And and then it comes down to this is the it's a hidden movement game. It's not a single player. You can't, you know, you can't play it with

two works, but really you want three or four. Uh do you have a group that's going to get into this enough to to enjoy it and like some of those mechanics and some stuff like that. And so that at the end of the day, that's got to be part of it, too. Mhm.

Um

um we we pulled this the shelf of games. We it sat for a while. We played everything else fairly quickly.

Be set.

Yep.

We got back from our local con. We watched a how to play video just to refresh our minds. We're going to be like, "Okay, we're going to get it done." And it's still sad.

Yep.

And at the end of the day, do I want to have a game on my shelf that I have to make myself play?

And I know and I feeling I'm feeling very guilty about this one because it's me. It's a me thing and Drew wants to play this game, but hidden movement isn't my thing. One versus many isn't my thing. I don't like ganging up on someone and I don't like being ganged up on. And so I think that's a big part of it just psychologically for me.

Yeah. And when I first backed that, we didn't know that about how we played. And so I thought this is amazing production. The art is gorgeous. Those are boxes we like to have tick both of us. I thought hidden movement might be kind of fun and interesting. one versus many, especially as our daughter is getting a little bit older, you know, those types of things. But again, at the end of the day, I'm not going to force a game play on somebody. Um, it's definitely one that if if somebody's setting it up at a con and they're there, I I might jump in, I'm 100% for We had kind of the opposite when it was Grand Austria Hotel, which

was a game that I I enjoy enough that I would like to keep it around, but every time we pull it off the shelf, it's like pulling teeth for Drew. And like he I can just tell he's sitting there miserable playing that game. And I don't think either of us want to have that experience.

And and playing this that that first time was a lot like that for you. I could tell Emma and I were the hunters. You were the beast.

And it just was not going well. And I

I mean I even think I ended up winning that game.

Um but it just it just wasn't that fun for me. Um and again, we've got the multi-layers of guilt of a game that somebody else enjoys that I just don't and so it's not hitting the table. A game we spent money on and now we're looking at getting rid of it. Um but at the same time, I don't want to look at my shelf and see a game and every time think, "Oh, we haven't played that in a while. Oh, I guess we should pull that off the shelf." like I want to feel like I want to pull that game off the shelf to play it, not like I have to pull that game off the shelf and play it.

And so that's kind of where we are.

Yep.

Just in general with with creating this collection and making sure that every game

needs to be here. [snorts]

Well, I'm guessing they kind of know where we're going with this.

We can do 3 2 1.

We are going to pull the trigger and call Beast. And I'm sure somebody else will enjoy it as much as Drew does. and a lot more than I do.

If if you like um what's the hidden movement everybody goes to

mind management?

Yeah, mind management. But you like more of that what do I want to say? Middle ages dark, you know, theme and stuff like that. If that I think this would be a great game for somebody like that. It's just it's not going to it's not going to hit the table here. So, it's not worth keeping.

Yep.

And again, that's just where we are. We both had a few games like that now that just I enjoy it or Drew enjoys it, but it's not hitting the table because it's just a little bit harder of a sell for the rest of the family. And so that's where we are with Beast. It will be leaving the collection.

Okay. Uh that was kind of a rough shelf. I'm not going to lie. Um that is 60% of those games are leaving the collection. Three out of five. And so

at the same time, the other two that stayed were probably evergreens never leaving the collection. So,

so I mean, and that's what this whole project is all about is just creating a collection where we look at it and I can't pick a game out that I want to get rid of. And so, I think that's where we are right now. We want a lean, mean collection that we want to play those games and we have time to play those games. And it's not a bad feeling when we look at that shelf and think, "Oh, we haven't played that game in so long and I don't really want to."

So, um, that's where we are overall.

We did the math. I've got 12 calls out of 36 games so far and we're sitting right at 33% right at oneird of our games.

It's pretty good. Um,

and that's kind of where we've agreed that we need to be.

I don't know if we're going to hit it, but right now we're there. I think there'll be some shelves that are going to be tough tougher to get.

But I thought this shelf would be tougher. Honestly, I really did. I didn't I didn't expect to say goodbye to three of these games.

No, you know, I didn't necessarily either when we first started playing. I knew uh you know, Beast was was going to be a hard one to pull um to keep pull the trigger on.

I knew was 50/50.

Yeah. Yeah. And then, you know, again, that that last play of Darwin's I think for both of us kind of solidified like much like beast. We'd like to like it but it just isn't it's not not there.

Yeah. And I think you know that whole term of shelf of shame that applies to your games that you have bought but haven't played yet. I think for me honestly my shelf of shame anymore is becoming the games that we have played and that are still sitting on my shelf out of obligation, out of I feel like I should like this game. I feel like everybody else likes this game so I'm missing something. But the truth of the matter is not every game is for me. Not every game is for Drew. Not every game is for you. And so just kind of release that guilt if that's if you're like me in that like it you don't have to like a game.

Yeah.

It's okay if even if it's the most popular game, if it's the number one game on BGG.

Yep.

You don't have to like it.

And I was a former uh Kickstarter addict, so I've I've come to terms with I spent decent amount on Beast. They spent a decent amount on Darwin and they just don't hit at the end of the day. We got a few plays and we're going to move on. You know,

we we got we got at least some value back out of that experience. And even if it's just understanding that we where we are as gamers

and and what we like as gamers because getting into at the beginning, you know, you you hit the ground so many of us hit the ground running and don't fully realize who we are as a gamer and that changes over time no matter what. Anyway, so

yep, various stages of life we when we had younger kids, we definitely gravitated towards different games and now that we have older kids, we're trying to explore some new things, too. And so it's fun to see this collection change over time and it's fun to see us grow as gamers and it's fun to see our kids grow as gamers and just learning when it's time to say goodbye and to let go. And that's what this whole thing is all about.

Stay tuned here. If you enjoyed this collection curation video, please make sure that you're subscribed. We come out with hopefully more of these soon and a lot of review content and some how to plays mixed in there, too. So, you don't want to miss that. Thanks for watching and we'll see you at the table.

Progress saved