TDG: Cody's Top Fifty GMT Games (#10-#1)
Transcript
Hello ladies and gentlemen and welcome to the discriminating gamer. You know I'm giving up drinking for a month. That came out wrong. I'm giving up drinking for a month. Ladies and gentlemen, today we're going to go ahead and take a look at my top 50 GMT games of all time. Today we're taking a look at number 10 through number one.
All right, ladies and gentlemen, my ultimate GMT top 50 games of all time and number 10 through number one. If you've been watching the list, I appreciate you sticking with me this far. We're going to have a lot of fun today as I look at my top 10 GMT games. There were some games on here that honestly surprised me. They were as high as there were, including my number one. Let's take a look. All right, my number 10, ladies and gentlemen, is a game that is is part of a series. I mentioned some of the other games in this series on this list. This is undoubtedly um my favorite of the GMT versions. There are some nonGMT versions I might like a little better. I'd have to think about it. But as far as the GMT games go, this is easily my favorite. This is Commands and Colors Napoleonics. I love, love, love Commands and Colors Napoleonics. Again, Commands and Colors, you got three sections of the board. the center, the left, the right flank. And you're playing cards that let you activate these block units on either of those flanks. Dice combat. You're trying to take your enemies. There's terrain. And I really like this one. Now, the the the core box is the battles in um Spain between the British and the uh French.
And it's really a lot of fun. Um the English army versus the French army here. Uh, they are consistently the battles here are consistently fun, well balanced. I really enjoy it. I I keep thinking at some point I need to get some of the expansions. Honestly, I'm a little nervous about the stickering. Uh, but I but I really do like Commands and Colors and I like the Napoleonic system. I like the depth of the Napoleonic system. I like how you can form squares uh to kind of keep the cavalry at bay. I really like like that aspect of the game quite a bit. But just overall great history. I'm you know I did a a minor field in Napoleonic warfare for my PhD and I just I'm very fascinated by the era and this game packs a really big punch. So that is uh my number 10. This is Commands and Colors Napoleonics.
All right, my number nine is a game that I just played recently and I absolutely fell in love with it. I've only played it the once, so I need to play it some more. And I think it potentially could even go higher, but right now I'm comfortable with where I have it. My number nine is Liberty or Death, the American Insurrection. This is a coin game, and this is a game where one of you is the Americans, one of you is the British, one of you are the Native Americans, one of you are the French. And you kind of have these kind of pseudo alliances like the the the the Native Americans and the British kind of have to work together. the French and the Americans kind of have to work together, but of course everybody's going for the individual victory. Now, I really like this coin system, of course, with the card play telling you who goes where and how you select the actions and you can kind of limit the the next person to go and and what they can do.
But I like too in Liberty or Death how there are battles and casualties and kind of your casualty levels kind of depend, you know, can kind of affect the further gameplay. Uh it's cool. the French take a time, but they come into it and they can uh fool around on the board and and and make a dent. It's it's really tremendously fun. I absolutely love love love Liberty or Death. I love the theme. I love the this battle system and I love the way the coin is implemented here. Just some great great history abstracted to a wonderful wonderful game. So, this is my number nine, Liberty or Death, the American Insurrection. Now, my number eight so far, I would say is my favorite coin game. Now, that could change as I play Liberty or Death some more, but right now I'm I'm content to say this is my favorite coin game. I've heard some people say it's probably the easiest coin game, so that may have something to do with it, but this is Kuba Libre.
Again, I just played this about a year ago and it knocked my socks off. I played it for the first time a year ago, and again, I was always kind of reluctant to get into coin. It always seemed like it was so it seemed like there was such a learning curve to it. Man, if I had played this game when this came out like 10 years ago, I would have fallen in love with coin. I absolutely love Cuba Libé. Um you you're the different factions during the the the Cuban revolution in 50 50 was it 58 59 thereabouts. And u you know you it's asymmetrical play. You each have different objectives. You got the casino owners, you got the communists, the government. I mean, it's it's really a lot of fun. And again, great coin mechanisms. The the cards come out, tell you who goes when and how you you eligible players can select what action they're going to take and then that limits the person that follows.
Tremendous fun. Uh like I say, I was not expecting to enjoy this game as much as I did. I absolutely fell in love with it. So, that is my number eight, Cuba Libre. Now, my number seven is not a coin game, but it is coin adjacent. And in fact, this is one of the games that helped me helped demystify coin for me and helped get me to the point where I would really enjoy coin. But this my number seven is a jest of Robin Hood. A jest of Robin Hood is a great irregular warfare game where one of you is the sheriff and one of you is Robin Hood. And it plays just like a coin game would. It's a two-player game, however, and you know, Robin Hood has his kind of irregulars that are trying to to to to take out these um supply shipments that are going through nodding through Sherwood Forest into Nottingham. The sheriff wants those supplies to arrive.
And what's cool here, what's fun and interesting too, though, is you've got this track of justice and order. The sheriff wants order. Robin Hood wants justice. And so there's a tugofwar here on this this scale to try to to to get the um you know to try to get it to your side. And it's great. I love the card play here you know with the cards coming out with the events and how you play off of them and the decisions you're making, what kinds of uh actions you're going to be able to take or if you're going to play the event. It's just it it's spectacular. This is it's one of my fa it's quickly become one of my favorite two-player games and it's just a fan fantastic coin adjacent game and a great learning. If you're looking to get into coin, this is probably a great way to place to start either here or the British way. Both two great two-player games with coin DNA.
So that is my number seven, Ajest of Robin Hood. My number six is another one of the great Jason Matthews games. This is 1960 making of a president. 1960, the making of a president, is the 1960 presidential election in which Kennedy and Nixon went head-to-head. And one of you takes on the role of the Kennedy campaign, one of you takes on the role of the Nixon campaign. And it's area control. You're going around the board. You're trying to lock in electoral votes from the different states and you're using cubes to do so. And you're kind of attacking each other. Again, you got these these cards you're playing, and you you're trying to a lot of times trying to make the best of bad decisions. Um, you've got these momentum tokens that that that allow you to manipulate the the board, do other fun and interesting actions. And then about halfway through the game, you have a debate and and things can kind of shift radically during the debate as you're trying to beat each other on certain issues in the game. It's really a lot of fun. And then the best part is at the end of the game, you actually get to go through and figure out um all the numbers and who won, who got the most electoral votes, and who ultimately wins the game. And it's a nailbiter just like that actual 1960 election. It's it's a lot of fun. It's a great kind of American politics game. It's a great game of area control and card play. And again, I love love love the history of this game. Fantastic. So that is my number six, 1960 Making of a President.
My number five is a science fiction game that is really cool starship combat. This is Talon. Talon is a great game. You have a map of it's kind of a hex encounter game. Uh but your spaceships that are the size of the hex's actually have they're dry erase boards and you write like your power curve on the different dry erase boards. And that's because you don't take turns. You have an impulse system. And depending on what your power curve is, that's going to trigger off of the impulse system and activate your different ships. And you're firing at the different ships and you're crossing out kind of your shields and taking damage that way. It's really fun. In fact, the game reminds me a lot game play reminds me a lot of Star Wars Rebellion. Now, Star Wars or not Star Wars Rebellion, um Star Wars Armada.
Star Wars Armada is a miniatures game with actual big miniatures you're physically maneuvering around. And here they're on hex's. you know, in Talon, they're on hex's, but you still have that same feeling of capital ships, big lumbering capital ships that are not terribly maneuverable, but you're still trying to maneuver for those for those firing solutions. And I really really liked it. And this game's a lot easier to set up and take down than Armada is, but it's just a a tremendous science fiction game. I played this game a ton. I played it four player, I played it two-player, and it's just great science fiction battles. I've got the expansion for this which gives you more ships and and scenarios and stuff and I and I just really really get a kick out of Talon. Um, so you can actually play this with another game kind of interchangeably.
I've never done that because I think it'll be too much, but there's options what I'm saying. Love Talon. And that is why Talon is my number five. My number four is a game that came out a couple of years ago and it is a game that I thought would be pretty fun. I didn't expect to like it as much as I did. I like it because it's another political game. It's another game of politics and it's a game that is kind of intimidating when you first look at it and then as you learn the systems, it's actually a pretty easy game to play. But this is Prime Minister. Prime Minister actually takes place during the Victorian age of Draeli and Gladstone. And it I played two-player scenario with two-player and it's fun, but the game really shines when you have the full four players because what you do is you have each of you uh take on the roles of either the Liberal or Conservative party. So there's two of you who are on the same party, but there can only be one winner and one of you, one of the four will be the prime minister. And even the person that is not the prime minister is kind of taking shots at you because they want to be the prime minister. But you got to make sure the Queen of England is pleased. You got to make sure that you're winning elections.
You've got to make sure uh that you're in the right places on the different um issues of the day and the different constituencies are following you. It's really a lot of fun. It's it's just a great game of political backstabbing and clawing your way to the top. Some just some great uh card play and and interesting ideas that come out throughout this game. Really really enjoyed Prime Minister. Again, there's there's so much more depth here than I was expecting and it's a really really fun I'm talking about it now. I want to get it back to the table. I actually haven't played this one in a while. I got to get it back to the table. It's fantastic. So, that is my number four. That is Prime Minister. All right. My number three. My number three is another great game that takes history and just creates a wonderful abstraction of it.
This is Versailles 1919. In Versail 1919, of course, you are the the victors from World War I and you are meeting to discuss what you want out of a peace treaty. And it's such a good game because these different issues come up and you kind of compete to, you know, through through kind of an area control mechanism. You you compete to to win these issues and then you put them in front of you and they're your victory points. But different uprisings can occur around the world and you may have to commit military support to that which is unpopular at home but sometimes you have to do it. And what's interesting too is if an uprising occurs in a part of the world where you have one of these issues settled suddenly it's back up and anybody can can then try to claim it. It's just fantastic.
But the game, like I say, it takes history and it runs with it. And again, you've got some some really fun card play. there's, you know, there's different things, like I say, that you want out of a peace treaty that you're trying to work toward, but it's not always that easy to get there. Um, but it's just fantastic. You know, I'm fascinated with the with the creation of the Treaty of Versailles. So, again, I love the history here, but I just love the gameplay, the area controls. You're trying to win these different issues and then the events come out that that trigger all sorts of fun and interesting things. Absolutely a ball. I love love love Versailles 1919 and that is why it is my number three game from GMT Games. Okay, ladies and gentlemen, my number two, I'll tell you this right now. When I sat down to make this list, I was convinced my number two was going to be my number one.
It always has been my favorite GMT game of all time. Now, the game that ultimately will be my number one, I'll explain my reasons for choosing it when I get to number one, but suffice it to say, my number two easily could have been my number one. I love this game. In fact, this may be my favorite two-player game of all time. In fact, it's probably a tie between this and Star Wars Rebellion. I kind of go back and forth between which one I like better. But this one is a game I first played I think in 2012 and I have played it many times since. Twilight Struggle. Jason Matthews masterpiece. Twilight Struggle is a game of the Cold War.
One of you is the Soviet Union, one of you is the United States, and you're competing for influence around the globe. And this game is just as I say, tremendous, tremendous fun because you've got this card play that as you're playing cards either for an event or for the operations points. Um, if you play a card that belongs to your opponent, you can get the operations points, but you're triggering the event anyway. So, all of these events are popping on the game, many of which you do not want to happen because they will screw you over. And you do have a safety valve with a space race. You can burn a card to try to move up on the space race, which is pretty cool, but only one. And so every round, you're playing through these cards and you are making these terrible choices.
It's so much fun. I have never played a game that makes you make the best of bad decisions as well as this one does. It is horrifying the decisions you have to make sometimes. And if you get a hand of cards that are just going to help your enemy, yikes. It's it's such a terrible feeling and it's such a fun game from turn to turn. I remember one time it maybe the third or fourth time I was playing this game with Shawn and we were in the um the last stage, the late war. And I played the the the the card gosh I can't remember what it was. It was something about Ronald Reagan. I can't remember what it was, but I played the card that if certain conditions on the board were met, you would in instantly win the game. And I played that card and I won the game. And he Sean was so pissed. He was so mad because he he felt he had his path to victory. And I was just thrilled that I was able to win that game. Uh at that point, he was pretty mad. But Sean and I played this a lot. Zach and I have played this game a lot. Zack, I know, got a copy, plays it with his son.
Um played it with with several people. And I just I I love it. I love it so much. I love the history. Again, I live through some of it. And I I I love the way this game presents the history. and again gives you these really tough choices. It's brilliant. A few years ago for it was like Christmas or my birthday I think Zach bought me the upgraded um tokens. So I don't use the cardboard tokens it came with. I use these little tiles for the tokens and they're beautiful and they're fun to play with and I'm really glad that he did that. Anyway, I love love love Twilight Struggle. I was very pleased. Um last March I was in Washington DC for uh Circle DC and I met Jason Matthews. super good guy. Really had a lot of fun meeting him. He bought me lunch. Uh and my wife really nice guy and it was and it just a just a fantastic fantastic game and he's and he's authored many great games. This is my favorite.
Well, that is my number two favorite GMT game of all time. Twilight Struggle. All right, ladies and gentlemen, my number one GMT game of all time. Now, as I say, Twilight Struggle, I was pretty sure was going to be my number one. But the more and more I thought about it, and I really thought about it, I was forced to conclude that my number one is my number one. And it's interesting, too, because my number one is not a new game. In fact, it's a game I've had for over a decade. And I have always loved this game. I've always loved this game. And I've just recently started playing the game um a lot more, going through some of the expansions with Ry, and I just remember how much I truly truly love this game. This is Space Empires 4X. In fact, Space Empires 4X, if I recall correctly, was the very first game the GMT game sent me to review. I was working at a paper and I did a a print review. And then a few years later, just before I moved to Texas, I actually did the video review for the channel.
I love Space Empires Forex. It It is a Forex game. You're exploring and I love you're sending your ships out and everywhere you explore potentially has promise, but you could lose your ship. There there's there's danger in a lot of places on the board. And so there's there's always that push your luck and tension in in that in that aspect of the game. You can also build up your civilizations. You can create new colonies and and pipelines that give you more more more money each round. I love the, you know, a lot of people were turned off because there's a bookkeeping phase because you actually every three rounds or so, you actually have to go and add up all your money and how you're going to spend it and stuff. I actually like that. To me, that's that's a fun part of the game is kind of growing your empire and determining how you're going to grow your empire in those in those phases and that's just a lot of fun.
Even though it's definitely a Forex game and you get a lot out of the Forex, to me, at its heart, this is a war game. This feels very much like a war game. And you've got the great fog of war system where your ships are turned upside down. And as you're moving your ships around the board, you don't know what's on them until you reveal them during combat. And you reveal them during combat. And the combat system here is awesome where you're looking at all your defense values. And you study, you can research tech here. So you can improve your your offensive capabilities. Then you can improve your defensive capabilities. And that's all going to adjust uh what the die roll the the window that your die roll can hit in during combat, which is great. I love the combat here. And like if you've got more ships than your enemy, you can screen some of your ships and protect them. They can't fight, but they won't be destroyed. Great stuff. I really, really like that quite a bit.
It's got kind of the, you know, the ABCDE EF system, so it's not simultaneous. You know, your your A ships go, then their A ships go, then your bishops go, and their bishops go. I really like that. You can get tactics, so if it's tied, even if you're attacking, you can go first. I I love it. I love it. I love it. I love it. I do love the different kinds of tech you can get in this game. And then I've just been starting to get into some of the um expansions. I haven't played them all yet, but the expansions all bring some fun and interesting things. More spice and sugar to the game. Um the Replicators expansion has the tiles, so you can actually replace a little black hole counter with an actual black hole tile, which is fun. And and and and I really like that. There's just so much about this game I love and I every time I play this game I'm just giddy. It's just one of my favorite games. It is so so good. You know, I'm thinking at some point I got to do my top 100 games of all time. I I haven't done that for four or five years now. And it's like, wow, I'll be surprised if if Space Empires isn't in my top 10. I don't think it's ever cracked the top 10. Maybe it did initially, but it's always been close.
It's always been in my top 20. It may crack my top 10 or next time I do it. We'll see. Man oh man, I love Space Empires Forex. One of my absolute favorite games and my favorite game from GMT games of all time. Well, ladies and gentlemen, thank you very much for joining me for my top 50 GMT games of all time. I hope you've really enjoyed this series. Please, please, please let me know what do you think uh of the games on my list. Do you like them? Do you not like them? Would you have ranked them differently? Very eager to know what your thoughts are. And I apologize if your favorite game wasn't on this list. Now, uh please uh let us know, leave a comment here on YouTube, on Board Game Geek, on Facebook, on X. We'd love to hear back from you. And then also too, I would ask you to uh please thumb this video if you enjoyed it. And please, please, please, if you haven't already, subscribe to the channel. We would love to have you uh be part of our family here. We'd really appreciate it. Now, also too, if you do like what we do, I would ask you to check out my other channel that is Cody Carlson PhD where we talk about history, military history, books on history, fun things like that.
I even post some of my lectures on that channel. So, please, please, please check that out. That would mean a lot to me. And also too, if you do like what we do here, I would humbly ask you to click on the super thanks button and leave a tip. You know, I had planned to work out this morning. Didn't work out. Help me on my feet again. AND I DON'T KNOW WHERE I'M GOING. And I don't know where I've been. Please somebody help me on this ground. IT'S A LONG TIME AND I'LL BE DYING. Once a year I wind up in the I love to fight, but I don't ever win. It's my life.
You know there is nothing more important than the people. [screaming] Sean, why? You knew what I was when you asked me to review board games with you. You want you want to go review a board game right now?
Yeah. Yeah, let's do it. Okay.