Games That Dropped Out of Our Top 50s (2025)
Transcript
Hey, I'm Ryan. This is my brother Daniel. And this is Rolls in the Family. And today, you know, Daniel, I think this is this is a new video idea that I think is here to keep us accountable here on the channel
cuz we do our top 50s, right? Every year we do this big countdown of our top 50. But you know what we haven't talked about in past years? We have not talked about what are the games that actually fell out of our top 50s, you know, and somebody watching it doesn't necessarily know. I don't think anybody's going and cross referencing.
Can you imagine? People are people aren't writing down everything and and tracking year to year.
I don't think we got any raging comments about like where did this game go? Yeah, but it occurred to me that this should actually be a nice follow-up video to that is what are the games that were in the top 50, but they either dropped out or maybe even dropped out of the collection entirely.
Oh, I couldn't imagine that happening.
I can't imagine why that would happen. Um, but we're here to explain ourselves hopefully. So, we've got um a bunch of games. We're going to be starting with the
lowest ranked from previous year's list. higher number, lower rank,
and we're going to move, you know, up
to the more and more egregious,
the more egregious cuz by the end of this, it's ones we were saying were, you know, way up games that weren't way way up there will collection.
Looking at our list, and let's just say you're going to be hearing a lot.
Daniel's going to have a lot of explaining to the back half of this list. Uh, we would love if you would leave in the comments below maybe a game that was one of your favorites but has recently fallen off and maybe why that is. We will have links to all the games we talk about below. A lot of these games, even if they slid a little bit, a lot of them are still great games and um, you know, none of
we'll take them case by case whether we still recommend them.
Uh, but I'm actually going to get us started, Daniel. That doesn't happen often. I feel like I'm always throwing it to you to start a video and I'm going to smack it back. Smack it back. Set. Spike. Uh, I'm going to start with what was my number 50 last year.
Okay, so this barely squeaked onto the list.
Come on.
Uh, and this is RAW. Uh, Raw dropped 12 spots uh to my number 62. And I don't think really anything changed about how I feel about RAW. I mean, I probably had,
let's just say that for every game.
Yeah. Yeah. And nothing changed. But I I don't know how many new games I had on my list this year, but like that probably is a lot of why it's getting bumped down. The other big thing is I'm I have a hard time finding groups that'll play this with me. Um like I um had a my best games of it were with a group that then kind of, you know, one of them moved away and so we haven't had that group again. I've had a couple times I I put your uh play of this in this category where it felt like it kind of fell flat. It was it was a weird play.
It was a weird game with Yeah. the way we drew raw tiles and stuff and so it felt like it wasn't quite
I still think this is a really unique fun game that and and like I've seen what it can be and so um I don't really have any thoughts of getting rid of it but there
there does come a point eventually where if a game's not getting played that you have to really look yourself in the mirror but for now RAW
yeah RAW is still uh holding on there still a game I really enjoy really interesting push your luck auction game um and a really nice new addition from
is the 25th Century Games 20.
Don't ask me.
Don't ask Daniel. Really nice new addition. Uh, so yeah, Ra Raw's a I don't know that he'll see the top 50 again.
Oh, wow. Now that's a hot take. Okay,
stay in the collection.
Very nice, Ryan. We're going to jump over to me. Uh, I feel like these first few games, it's less of something happened and more just the arbitrary nature of ranking games. uh cuz we don't look at our previous year's rankings when we rank the new games. Um so it feels like this one has sat in a similar spot um going from 49 squeaking out to 52. This is Roll for the Galaxy. Uh we have experienced both race Race for the Galaxy and Roll for the Galaxy and I think we've well we've played Race for the Galaxy a ton if you saw our um most played games of all time video. Uh spoiler it's up there and we've but but we played this one quite a bit too. I mean nowhere close to Race for the Galaxy. it's a longer game. Um, and felt like it was a different enough experience that it was like, oh, you know, I feel like these both can kind of, you know, live in that space now. I don't I don't own it. You're the one who who has it now, so obviously I'm not playing it much. Um,
it's probably been a while since you played it.
Yeah, it's been a little while. And I don't know. I I really enjoyed it when I did like the, you know, the rolling of the dice and uh kind of all of the,
you know, dice manipulation and all of that. Um, like I don't know. This is one that's just I think we've played it a good amount. Um I'm not sure it delivers any like moment for me that's like oh my gosh that like makes it really stand out and maybe that's why it's kind of floating down here just on the fringe of the top 50. But a game that I I still really like and and would totally uh totally enjoy playing again.
Well, you might be hearing more about it later. Uh so stick around. Daniel [snorts] can see the list. Uh, I have the next one here. Uh, this is the Crew Mission Deep Sea. I think there's a little of a caveat here cuz I think it was actually The Crew Quest for Planet 9 that was on my last year list, but I consider them close enough to the same game that I had them maintain the ranking.
So, you got Mission DC and it dropped
and it dropped.
That's a bad choice.
It basically stayed in the same spot. So, it went from 49 to 53.
It actually relative to there's probably more than four new games that came in above it. So, you could argue that it went up relatively.
I can argue objectively that it dropped.
Yes. Um, this one I I Well, I I'll I'll say now that Mission Deep Sea is an even better version of the crew.
Despite what they're feeling kind of the pressure here, I feel the hot seat right now.
This is I really enjoyed the original crew. I always felt like um it was hard to get to the table cuz I like started these campaigns with specific groups and then didn't necessarily get those groups back. Um, I think Mission Deep Sea really captures everything I loved about that game. Injects more variability with the way that the missions work cuz now there's all these mission cards. And so it is it you get a lot of more variety just from which of those get drawn, not just which mission you do. And so it's a lot easier to just be like, we're just going to re replay this mission and get a very different experience every time. And so I really like how now I feel like I could pull this out with a group that we're not going to do the campaign, but we're just going to play some. Um, which should hopefully help this get to the table more. Now, it still is a game that like I'm only going to pull out with people who know
trickt taking games because like that's just and because it's a team game and like
one person can kind of like pull down the team if they're just bad at trick-t
and then if we pick this game over other games. But I think this is an excellent game. Um,
I was going to I was going to get it until I saw this.
Yeah. Until you saw this data,
this ranking here. Yikes.
Uh, yeah. So, still still just holding on just dropping slightly out of the top 50. But who knows cuz I I have played it since we did these rankings and had really positive plays of it. So, maybe this is one that could crawl its way back up there.
But now we're moving to some bigger bigger
this next one's a bigger drop here. This is a long time staple in my collection.
Yeah. And actually one that we have said needs to get reprinted. This should be re in print and it is being reprinted now. Eagle Griffin Games has relaunched uh Pitch Car. I didn't say Pitch Car yet, but now I did. Pitch Car is the next game. Um so Pitch Car was my 48 uh last year and dropped to my 72.
Oh my.
I think this is a combination of a couple things. one, it isn't getting played a whole lot though as my son who I'm, you know, training, you've already got him on cro training in the art of crocodile. We should probably be pulling out a pitch.
Um, I think part of it is like the last few times I've brought it out, I've been reminded of a little bit of the finickiness of like the track and getting it all to play smoothly.
But when I like think back on us playing, I don't remember that being a huge issue. Like once we like got it up, like we always had like fun races on it and stuff. So, I think I maybe I'm starting to like overplay that in my mind that that's something with this game.
So, I really need to just let this one get played more so that it can recalibrate to,
you know, what it should be in this year 2025 cuz we've had this game since 2010. Like, this was a pretty early
um acquisition. I have some of the expansion stuff for it, so I've got a lot to make, you know, cool tracks.
Yeah. Um, but yeah, I mean I have memories of, you know, getting one of those flicks that goes right around the rails and like over a jump all in one go. It's got the nice like push your luck of how much do you go for on your flick. Really good
flicking game. I think it's just Yeah. slipping. There's the natural slip when you're not playing games and then sometimes when you're not playing them,
your memory latches on to certain things.
Yeah. And like I think because I'm thinking of some of the finicky stuff that's like weighing it down even more.
Um
but it's a good reminder that uh need to get pitch car played and who knows maybe Toby will just love it and then suddenly I'll play it 100 times this year. So
right.
Um
yeah, you also need kind of a big table though.
You do put it out there.
You want to make a cool track anyway.
It's true.
Okay, Ryan, this one this one honestly I'm like looking at it and I'm a little surprised. That is
surprised. Who ranked this?
Who ranked this? I don't know who gave me these rankings. Uh, this is a game that I really like and yet apparently I don't because it dropped from 47 all the way down to 71.
Yes, please tell us why this game is no longer good. This goes to Thank you for prefacing with that, Ryan. This goes to Stella Dixit Universe. Um, and I feel like Yeah, Ryan, this is like a good counseling session for me of like why why is it why did it drop so low? You know, I feel like so this was a game when we we've played Dixit a ton and then we were kind of at first we weren't interested in this because it was kind of like well we like Dixit, you know, but can they really do a that much different, you know, version of the kind of same system and we my first impression of this game was great. It was like, man, this really um just I feel like we and I feel like we had some like really great plays of it early that I was just like, oh my gosh, must buy. I ended up getting it and I'm super glad I own it because I I I do like it more than uh Dixon. I I hope I ranked it higher than
I think I did. Um
but the more I've I've thought I think I've maybe cooled a little bit from that like first few plays of just like oh wow. And it's still really fun like you know like doing the super spark and all of that. Um, you know, you're you're looking at these cards and trying to, you know, match up with different people. Like, I still think it works super well. Honestly, I just think I've cooled from the initial few plays of it.
I think that's the distinction is like I don't think it's a game that gets worse with repeated plays. I think it's more that natural. It was such a cool novel thing.
Yeah.
Out of the gate that you It almost got overranked, right?
Oh, yeah. A little bit. Um, but I think we both I don't think either of us have cooled on how much we like this game being in our collection and and playing it. But yeah, that when we first played it, those first few,
I think we were blown away a little bit by how well it worked. This new twist on Dix.
No, totally. And just the the super spark moment is like that is just such a fun thing. the more you play the game, you know, you aren't as like, oh my gosh, you know, in that
this wasn't the ranking change wasn't after you had that game where you, you know, were the first to go and said one that nobody had immediately.
I will not confirm nor deny whether that influenced the severe drop in the rankings. Um, but still a very good game, Stella Dixit Universe.
Nice. Uh, we talked about how sometimes when games don't get played, they're naturally going to slip. This next one is an example of it. Sadly, it's a game I've only played once. I really This is I play it once, too.
Very near my Yeah, not with me, but Daniel advised me not to get this game.
Uh, this is very high on my list of games I need to get played again. And this is Inish. Uh, it debuted at 47 after my one play of it. And at that point, it was like, I don't really know yet, but I had a really good first play of it. I just haven't had the right group or or whenever I do have the right group, we're picking a different game to play. Um, I need to get this one played. I actually think our sister Caitlyn might like this one. Um, it's a little bit more interactive um
on the map there. But, uh, yeah. Uh, dropped from 47 to 54, which is 54 was kind of an arbitrary rating cuz I literally didn't play it.
Those ones that's like I haven't played it in four years. What do I rank?
And I'm going off of one play. Like sometimes you don't play it and you're like but I played it a hundred times, you know? I remember where this is like, man, I don't even know. But I know I really enjoyed the one [clears throat] play of it. So, um I it just needs to get played more. Um and maybe that's going to be the recurring theme on this list is
I don't know, Ryan. I think you should have listened to my advice of not purchasing this one.
Yeah, maybe maybe you should have listened to Daniel.
I got a good deal on this one. This is a Facebook market. Yeah. This next one uh is a game that is an iteration off of one of uh the original games my wife and I really loved playing together, but this one really intrigued me because it was a specific two-player version, which is how we always played the original game, too. Um with a twist on it. This goes to Splender Duel. And so this one drops from 46 all the way down to 68. And
yeah, that's that's not insignificant. Um and honestly, I I think somewhat justified. I still like Splendor Duel. Uh, but honestly, I actually just played Splender um with my wife's family this last week and uh I think I just like Splendor better. And I do I it's
Splender Duel is a decent amount more thinky.
Yeah.
Than regular Splendor like and in an interesting way. Like I the whole like you know which gems to take. There's just there's more going on. And I don't know, there's just something about the purity of Splendor of just the and the race, you know, up to just the very clear race that you're, you know, making whereas Splender Duel, there was just more going on. And I don't know, there was a little part of me that's like I think I just kind of like the and I don't know, it's hard when you like you're you're you've played one thing so many times and so the different thing is kind of like
But it is a it is a weight difference. say that like the Splender duel does push you a little more in how you have to think about it. I I think what you're saying it reminds me a little bit of like um we really love Ticket to Ride and one of the expansion maps I have for Ticket to Ride is the uh is the UK one where you get like the technologies you like can't play in certain and I found that I almost feel a similar way about that one of like
I really enjoy that map
but sometimes if I'm going to play Ticket to Ride I just want to sit in the comfortable Ticket to Ride and just like play it and not have to like push with these extra systems. Well, because something and and I don't know how much Splender Duel does this, but you know, if you do something and it's adding more, you the game might be shifting into a different space in your collection. You know, whereas Splender, you know, was is you know, more just accessible. I think uh Splender Duel is one that is a I takes a little bit more to, you know, kind of grasp it. I still think it work it works really well. It's welldesigned. I think the how you choose chips like that's just an interesting mechanism. So it's all all the mechanisms are good. Uh I just I don't know the comfort food of
I guess it's going to boil down to if you and your wife when you play two-player if you're reaching for Splender instead of Splender Duel that might be the nail on the cuff and for SP
cuz that's the situation.
That is literally the situation and I don't know the answer to that yet.
To be determined if it stays on this trend let's just say Yeah, if it keeps dropping 22 spots, everyone will be here.
That is not good.
All right. Uh, similar.
I got one that dropped, what is that? 17 spots. Math. Uh, this was my 46 last year. Dropped to 63.
Come on, Ryan.
This is one that I haven't played in a while, but I've played a ton.
This is Cosmic Encounter. Um,
so Cosmic Encounter I've played over 180 times. Most of that was during these college years with this core group that just latched onto that game. It was the glory to the golden era of Cosmic Encounter. I mean, there was really nothing like it. Such good memories from that.
Now it's in this new era where it doesn't get played very often. I don't often have that group. It's hard to want to bring it out with like a new group because one, it's a little bit
unpredictable in how good a single game is going to go. and I'm only really going to want to teach it to a group if I have some confidence that that group is going to play again because that's really the this is a game that really rewards multiple players with the same group. Um, and so I don't often get that and so this doesn't get played a lot though it's still such a unique
game and one that I get excited about thinking of teaching to people or teaching to kids.
Well, that doesn't happen.
Well, like I'm just saying like this is a fun game to introduce to people because it is really wild and different. Um, but I just haven't had the right situations to really justify investing in teaching it.
And sometimes it's hard when you have such high memories.
Like you're comparing every play after that to those moments,
you know, and as we talked about before, during that time we would often play it many times in an evening.
Um, and know that we're probably within the week playing it again. I know there were a bunch of lackluster games in a month, it didn't matter that like eight of them didn't go great. You just spun, you know, passed out the aliens and played again, right?
Um, so yeah, this is one that I think has had a natural slip over time. I think there's also some of when you've played it this much,
I've seen so much of what can happen in Cosmic that it's less likely to have that moment of, whoa, I've never seen anything like this before. Cuz I have seen a lot of the different things that can happen in this game system. Uh, but still a really unique with the right group, right situation. Um, I mean, some of my best gaming memories I can't deny are with Cosmic Encounter.
I don't know. Ryan, you want to sell me your copy?
It's well loved, man. Like you can tell when you look on the shelf, you can tell which games are really well loved just from the box.
Cosmic's well loved.
It is
uh a game that actually the recent development. This next one,
breaking news.
I think this one is on the uh the cusp of maybe getting cold out of the collection.
Um a game I really enjoy, but that hasn't stopped me before from getting rid of
hasn't made bad decisions before. Uh, this is Roll for the Galaxy. We talked about this one a little bit. Daniel had it higher in the list. Mine fell a little further. Mine was at 44 and dropped down to 61.
Um, this is a really fun dice based twist on on Race for the Galaxy. I think when we first got it, it was so novel after playing so much Race of the Galaxy. I think you even would have said that you liked Roll for the Galaxy more for a season. I was probably pretty close. I think over time it became pretty clear that like you know race is still my favorite of these two.
Um but there's a lot of cool things going on in roll and I've had a lot of good games of it but I think I I'm it I'm finding it's starting to fall into this category for me where we talk about there's games that you really like them. You play them a bunch but they just kind of
finish out their season in your collection. And that's how I'm kind of feeling. And not often are you is this one that you're thinking about we got to we got to play this.
Yeah. I don't like Yeah. try to get it to the table. Really
active. And that's kind of the beginning.
There are certain situations. I don't have it very often. But if you have like four or five gamer-minded people and not a lot of time, this is a great great option.
But I don't have that situation very often. So it's not like um
Yeah. And other games that might fit that.
Who knows? and maybe I'll get rid of it and then have that moment and be like, "Ah, Roll for the Galaxy would have been perfect here."
Um,
but yeah, it's, you know, it's a game I still rate like an eight out of 10. Um, but I I feel like maybe I just have kind of reached the end of my We'll see. We'll see. I haven't 100% made the decision,
but this uh drop from 44 to 61 seems to support the way that I'm trending with that one.
Right. Well, my next game, Ryan, is the only game on the list that went from ranked to didn't even include in my rankings, but not because it left my collection and not because Daniel forgot, which has happened on
which is also a very plausible reason. Yeah, that's happened before and that's been rough. Um, this goes to my city and this is a kind of a weird weird um weird situation because I have started we started a my city you know campaign I guess you call it um couple years ago and so then ranked it and and really liked it like it felt was and really enjoyable and so had it at 43
and then haven't played it haven't continued in the ne you know past almost 2 years and so like when I got to doing the rankings I'm just like
I haven't even finished it like it's 2 years ago so I made the arbitrary decision of I am not going to include this one in my rankings currently uh because uh yeah it's just how do you even formulate an opinion
on does it have any any chance of that group finishing it so because sometimes these things like life changes people move and it's like this will never
Absolutely. And honestly, we just got to we just got to make it happen. Um, so
yeah, this one. Yeah. No, it's a really great game like so far. And I haven't even, you know, you've played the whole thing.
I played not the whole thing. We played more.
Any chance of that finishing?
Well, I we had the friends we were playing with move. Um, so they're back here sometimes, but you know, it's kind of like when you're back here sometimes where it's like, okay, what are you gonna play this time? we going to um so there there is a chance I mean it's my wife's sister and her husband so it's at least guaranteed these people are going to be in our life you know who knows
but that I will say that is the other hard part about these kind of things is if you do have a long gap
it kind of kills the momentum of like I want to go back to this you know
forunately this game's like pretty rules like it is that like the hump to get back in is not so big that if like you hadn't played Gloom Haven in 2 years and you're like, should we get this thing rolling again? This is a little harder.
It's true.
Um,
okay.
But yeah, we'll see it. We'll see if you uh get to play the next year.
Yeah.
I don't know how good the odds are.
Uh this next one's interesting actually for me. It is. I want to hear.
This is a game that uh we had a long time history with the game Ghost Stories. Really enjoyed. Was one of the first cooperative games. Got had so many good standup moments playing this cooperative game rolling dice. and we really enjoy this new version of it, which is Last Bastion. It was my 43 last year, which I think was not that long after I got it.
Uh, it dropped to 55, so it fell out of the top 50.
Um,
I think it's one of these situations where it's a new game. Last Bastion's a new game,
but it's also not It's like this game. It's one of the oldest game experiences in my collection
and I have played it so much that like I'm not super drawn to making sure it gets to the table and like
but it hasn't yet gotten to the point of what I was talking about of the galaxy where it feels like it's you know finished its stay in the collection.
Um so it's kind of in this weird in between. Um, and I think that has led it to drop, you know, out of the top 50.
But still a really fun uh
just cooperative [clears throat] kind of this almost tower defense thing with all these
enemies coming and you're moving around the castle and using abilities and you know the the fact that it uses dice the way it does means that there's going to be exciting moments and it often leads to a very kind of like climactic ending.
Um, yeah, it's a fun one. If you know this game well, what I mean, can you play this in an hour? Is that
Yeah, under an hour because that's one of the things we complained about with the uh ghost stories white moon expansion is it kind of bumped the
that's still and cuz I have Last Bastion as well and that's why it's in my collection is it is that under if you can have that I just haven't taught it to like my group yet, but if you want that under hour but
still kind of operative, a little bit epic but not too heavy. It fits a nice kind of spot there. Um, it's got nice variety with especially the new edition with all the different
uh abilities and stuff. Um,
so yeah, it's one I think it makes sense to me that it's dropped out of the top 50. I don't like think it's necessarily going to make a jump back in. Um, but yeah, still a really fun cooperative game.
Nice. Uh, my next one is I really don't know. I mean, I don't know. 13 drop from 41 to 54. That's not huge. Um, this goes to So Clover. Um, and So Clover, man, talk about a game that I think far out exceeded our expectations when it came to
I mean that has been one of the biggest hits in our family.
It really has. Um, and super fun uh game of cooperative where you're uh you know, you're trying to write on your on your clover a clue for uh two words that are you know, kind of at the center of your clover and you write a clue on each side and then ultimately trying to get the the rest of your team when it gets to your turn is trying to orient the cards to orient them the way that that you you had them. And that it just is a system that works so well. So much fun. And I think we were surprised at how much fun the like
re the team just figuring it out phase is cuz they're, you know, people are talking out loud and arguing for, oh, maybe they were thinking this and cuz you're trying to get in the mind of the person and so [clears throat] just
super fun group game. I don't know. I I think it had been it's been a little while since I've played it. I think I also had a play of it like it was like maybe four of us and it and it just didn't quite hit and so that you know when you go into your rankings often times it's your last few plays are kind of the things that are fresh and so it had I think just cooled a little bit. Um but still totally like I mean it's one of my favorite. It's hard for party games to make the top 50.
Yeah, I don't think I had any party games in my top 50. Uh I know I do, but uh this I think is my like third highest party game, something like that. So um super fun one still. Yeah, this one does a really good job of getting the group to just have fun talking together.
Yeah. Like there's other games that like even like just one like there's a lot of
time that's like you know everybody's quiet and somebody guesses but this is like you just have like a fun time all just chatting while you're trying to like solve
and even as the one who wrote the clues it's so fun to listen to what people are saying to and and when you get it it's exciting.
Yeah creates a great dynamic with our family. Uh, my next one is probably the closest I have to what you were saying with my city of where it was probably on that border of where I could have left it out of my rankings. Um, for a similar reason cuz it had debuted at number 39 because I had uh played it a bit. This is
like a premature 39 Ryan.
Well, okay, let's talk about this is Arkham. This is Arkham Horror of the Card game. So, all I had played of Arkham Lord of the Card game was the initial three game scenario mission and I played uh two-handed. But you got to understand I'm coming from Lord of the Rings the card game which I've played a ton and is much higher on my list.
And so like based on those games, I felt like pretty confident about ranking. And honestly,
I think that's probably where it still belongs is up there.
But I haven't played it since because I've I haven't really been doing as much. solo gaming and like that's a little bit more of a heavier solo game experience to do the two decks and and do everything. I've also realized, man, this game uh is it would be so fun to play with another person and really share that as you found to be true.
Um so I still ranked it even though I probably shouldn't have because like it didn't really drop. It kind of just it's in like purgatory of games just waiting to get actually played. Now here's the thing, Daniel. This is recent development. I haven't even told you this.
There's a very real possibility that a friend and I next year start playing the campaign of this.
Who?
Well, I'm not going to name drop here. But, uh,
is it me?
Yeah, you're moving back.
Uh, no, but I I had a friend that reached out actually asking about it. Uh, and and I was, you know, it was one of those things. I was like, "Okay, as long as we're okay that that means that like times it probably means we play a little less of other games, but if we're both okay with that." And I was like, you know, the timing might be right. He is like the kind of the perfect
uh you know, type of person, I think, is the the sweet spot for it.
So, assuming that all happens, this could see a real calibration uh next year. In fact, me ranking it and having it go to 58 this year is setting it up for just a massive jump. Yes.
Yeah. We'll see.
To the moon.
So, Arkham of the Card Game went from 39 to 58. My next game went from 38 to 59.
So, you're saying it's exactly like Arkham Heart of the Card Game.
This goes to Decrypto. Talk about party games, Ryan. Uh, so this one interesting. I actually I didn't even look at this list ahead of time. I'm just Ryan puts this together and I read it live on camera. Um,
type out exactly what he should say. But this dropped below So Clover, which is interesting. They're they're in a pretty they're similar similar rankings, but very different game experiences.
And the crypto is a hard one because
it is very hard to have the right group for it and like the right situation.
But if you do, and I'm optimistic, Ryan, that coming up here at Christmas, we might have an opportunity again because our siblings, I feel like it's almost tradition at this point to play our game of Decrypto. And when you have that group, this game is incredible. This back and forth of uh trying to get your team to guess the, you know, which word of the four secret words in front of you, but you're trying to throw off the other team cuz they're trying to listen and intercept and and like I I'm trying to think of a game I've played where you have this feeling of the other team is on you like they've they're and then you've got to like try to throw them off with like the clue while still also giving your team a word. when you do that is like such a satisfying moment. And I I just know we've had several plays as a as a family where, you know, it's a game that escalates every round it goes and where we're just like, "Oh my gosh, how are we still going?" Um, so this game, the high of it is so great.
It's just hard to have that, you know, get to the table and I think the ranking affect, you know, is affected by that. Yeah, it's always hard to rank those games that the ideal scenario is like so great, but
it's also so hard to get played and there's a chance that you might not hit that I like you might try it with a group and
it's a it's a riskier game with a new group you can
you almost have to go in being like we might play this more than once like you know if the first one goes quick and
right
but yeah to crypto excellent excellent game
it is And my next one I mentioned earlier in the video. Um, and this is probably the one on my entire list that I'm going to strongly disagree with what I put.
Disagree with Daniel.
Disagree myself. Um, this goes uh to Splender. I mentioned Splender duel earlier. This dropped 37 all the way down to 55. And that is not accurate. And again, you talk about
that is not okay.
That is not what's out of the top.
No, it's it's not okay, Ryan. And you know, I talk about how, you know, rankings are always affected by your recent plays, but I'm telling you, I played it this last week,
and I just was reminded, this game is so good. I just love the efficiency puzzle cuz it's a race. You know, you are racing to 15. And so trying to figure out the best path, you know, you kind of look at all the cards at the beginning, you look at the uh nobles at the top and you're like, "Okay, what is a path that I think can get me there, but you also have to be willing to adjust a lot along the way because you're getting, you know, someone takes like the whole reserving of cards. I mean, man, this game is it it can be cutthroat of, you know, watching your opponents and reserving something when someone you think someone, you know, is going to get a lot of points going for that one. Do I reserve that card? Because reserving, you know, is less efficient in the sense of if versus if I just grabbed more gems and bought it, you know, by itself. Um, so it's always that tension of, you know, how when to reserve, when to go for gems and, uh, and yet, like I said before, it's just the rule set is so simple. The the rules are simple, but the strategy in it is so fun. So, uh, I'm going to I think I think I mean, I don't know if it'll get back up to 37 cuz that's pretty high. Um, but I I firmly believe this one will be back in my top 50s next year.
Mark his words, everybody.
Oh, no.
Yes. Write it down. Remind me in 10 months.
Yeah. Know, it's interesting that reserve mechanism. It's it's kind of like this reverse push your luck thing. Like a lot of times push your luck in the games is like you take an action to push your luck or you choose to keep going, but this is like you're pushing your luck by not doing it
doing. Yeah.
Yeah. No, totally.
It's like the default is to push your luck,
right?
Interesting. Uh my next one and last one, let's just say
we still have a lot of video left. After this one, we have Dangle's four highest ranked ones, and they all What is that? They all left the collection.
Oh man, this is about to get spicy. Uh, mine still is in the collection. Mine dropped from 37 to 51. This one totally makes sense why. This is Lord of the Rings Journeys in Middle Earth. When it was 37, I had just been finishing and doing a campaign of this game
and so was really enjoying it, having a lot of fun with it. haven't played it since because we didn't start like a new campaign. So, it's a natural. It's always hard with these campaign games, right, where it's like,
well, how do I continue to rank it? And my philosophy tends to be like if I'm not playing it, it has to slide.
Like even if that like top experience I know is higher, if it's really that good, like I should eventually play it more, right?
I feel like a game like TI4 is an exception to that rule.
Well, that's different cuz that's not like a campaign. That's more just like
Oh, gotcha. Campaign.
But like, yeah, with a camp I I feel like it's a little different with campaigns. Uh, this is a game that I really think someday would be very fun with kids. Um, especially, you know, like I I'm hoping eventually to uh, you know, like read the the Lord of the Rings to to my boys. And uh, who knows, maybe that'll reawaken just like the Lord of the Rings segment of my collection. will just get this boost of
um but yeah, this one I mean it's so fun. It's
it's kind of a much more adventuring feeling campaign game. Like it's got some cool mechanisms with the card play and everything,
but it's it's a much lighter like compared to something like Gloom Haven or whatever. It's just like asking a lot less of you as a player. So, it just feels a lot more casual having fun going through this scenario. It's really cool with how it uses the app to manage a bunch of things. Um, so I had a really fun campaign of this. Um, but it may be a while honestly
before it gets so I I could see this sliding.
Well, here's the thing. Well, it is a little hard [clears throat] with some of the Lord of the Rings stuff of like even if he's ready for it,
how much do I want to spoil that universe
through games? Now, fortunately, Journeys Middle Earth is like not based on the real story, but it's still got some of the characters and stuff versus like, you know, I'm interested in a game like Fate of the Fellowship, which is like literally the plot of, you know, the books. And so, it's like, well, I probably wouldn't want to play that way cuz I really would love to, you know, have the books be his his introduction to that. But, we'll see. Report back here. Uh you can you can stay subscribed to the channel to hear about my developments on the uh you know bringing up my children in the uh love of the Lord of the Rings universe.
Very nice, Ryan. Well,
I'll hand it over to Dango for the next 20 minutes here.
Well, here's what's weird, Ryan. How is it that the last four games here, one are all me, and two, all got cold?
Yeah. Like nothing else on this list the collection. Everything just slid. the four best ones.
Dango. Dango. When he when he replaces a game in his collection, he doesn't mess around. He I don't mess around. Yeah. I I try to I try to remove my favorite ones first. No, I for I think three out of four of these games, um it's an example of a really good game potentially being replaced by a game that I think can deliver something like that game. Um but but even more. Um, and this is gonna start off with a game that went from 32 to leaving my collection. A game that Oh, this one honestly I would say of the four of these honestly hurts the most that I I don't have it anymore. This goes to Aon's End. Um, I man I feel like I loved Aon's End. Like I loved what it was doing. I loved the just it took like Dominion with uh but turned it into this cooperative fighting, you know, uh a boss. There's tons of like variable, you know, just the nature of it. Like
honestly, this is a game where if I just had someone who loved this game with me, um it would still be in my collection. So, it it wasn't getting played a ton, which was hard. Um, and then uh, and then it was ultimately I, and these are two totally different games and totally different weights and all that, but a game that is also a like build your deck. And then I tried uh, Slay the Spire, which you have. And already I was kind of like a on Zen. I'm like, it's just not getting played. And so maybe it's better for it to leave my collection. Played Slay the Spire and I was like, oh my gosh, this is the greatest deck builder I've ever played in my life. like yeah
it was just blew me away and so looking at uh Aon's End has left hoping to get Slay the Spire and uh but still honestly yeah I kind of wish I still
Yeah. Yeah. And they're definitely a different category. SP is a lot longer way heavier. Totally different. Yeah.
But I would say it's a similar type of other person that you would play those two games with.
Right. No, it's true. It's true. No, honestly I I can I don't know why I got rid of it. So
yeah, regret.
Um regret. Um so that's my number 32 to cold. Uh then one step above that, a game that was ranked uh 31. Kind of surprised it was this high. I think I was maybe
this one shone bright right out of the gate.
Yeah, I think I I really was loving it from the start and then I don't know, I kind of cooled fast on it. Um I feel like a lot of people like I feel like I heard a lot of buzz around this game and then I have not heard a lot more recently.
Yeah. So this is World Wonders and this game I there was so much I think promise in it. one I uh I'm always intrigued by games with polyomino elements of you know fitting things together and this game obviously has that and then you add these getting these wonders which are these like cool 3D wooden things and so like the board just looked really cool as you're kind of building it out and and all of that. It was a game that I ended up just having a few things with it that I didn't love. one, it ended up falling in a weight or or a length that was a little bit higher than I was wanting it to. So, like
just a little bit just a little longer.
Like we we played this five player, I believe, on a on a family vacation
and it was like, man, that ended up being like the time that we could have played like
one of our two. Yeah, it was like that that that is like your prime your best games need to hit if for that. And it was good.
We had fun,
but it wasn't great. And that was and that was like the I think the other thing with this was I just really had a problem with the wonders. And I know the expansion I think is supposed to help this a little bit. Although even the solution there I I wasn't like fully satisfied with because in the base game they just they're all the same. They just give you a point, you know? They just
Yeah.
They like you get one and and it like at first it's like you know the way they look visually it makes you think like I need to do whatever possible to get this wonder cuz look how cool it is. And then you realize what it's actually giving you and you're like, "Oh, I mean, it's good.
It's like a little sprinkle.
It's like it's like, you know, it's a couple points or something like that." Like, I think it would have been amazing if the wonders had like a a variable power or something like pushing the weight even higher
or score. Well, but maybe it would deliver more at that weight of like a variable scoring based off what's next to it. Something like that, you know? So, it ended up just it was a little underwhelming of what was actually uh what it was how it was actually scoring and all of that. So, I ended up kind of just realizing I'm not
I'm not as huge on it anymore.
Yeah. And I I really enjoyed my play of this one. Actually, I think I only played it once. Yeah, that one time.
Um
but I I was at a point where I was waiting for Planet Unknown to come and Planet Unknown. Really enjoyed Planet Unknown. But I was at a point where it was like if Planet Unknown hadn't landed the way I wanted it to, I was actually considering getting this one to fit that kind of
No, it's a really I mean it's a really good game. Um,
but that was the other thing. I played Planet Unknown and I mean it wasn't even close for me. Planet Unknown was
You threw simultaneous play in
simultaneous play I the building out was more fun. the integration with the tracks like it. I love that game. So, that was the other kind of nail in the coffin.
You have that one now, don't you?
I do. And the Super Moon expansion. So,
Oh, wow. I still haven't played with the expansion. I actually just played Plan Unknown last night.
Did you win?
Two two game. I did.
There you go. No one cares. Um,
okay, Ryan. Back to We're into Daniel's top 20
and my number one game that got cold. No. Uh this is a this next game, you know, you love this game. You just played this game actually recently. A
really good game.
Um this is a Ryan and I love the U Rosenberg uh games. You know, some of our favorites are in that uh in that space. And this is a big one in that that space that both of us uh have loved. Although I think now that time has I mean clearly cuz I get rid of it but [gasps] now that time has gone I've seen that you've really I think lashed on to it more long term.
Yeah, we probably are a bigger gap on this than most.
It is kind of large as far as how we feel about it.
This goes to a feast for Odin. Um and this is one that honestly like played it quite a few times and really enjoyed it. Got it myself. Got the Norwegians expansion which is a great expansion and all of that. There were a few things that led to this game leaving the collection. One, my wife did not like it. And that
I still wonder like if she had continued to really like it, like how it would have played out.
I know. And that's just hard cuz like she's the main person that I
could [snorts] have at least in that season of life maybe had you're in a different opportunities to play it with. Um so that was hard. But also, I realized I just really don't like wide open sandbox style games where where I
where I feel like I like here's a feeling I hate, Ryan. I never like when I'm at the start of a game and I'm just like, huh,
I could kind of do anything here.
Yeah. What do I want to do? like I have to just like arbitrarily pick a route with whereas I want to like be you know you think about a game we love a gorilla where you're like giving cards and and you like discover a direction based off
discovering the route is a puzzle of itself.
I love that I don't want to have to just arbitrarily say you know what this game I'm going to try this or this game I'm going to try that and I just felt that a little too much in in this one. Now, the game is great in terms of the whole fitting pieces together, going up on the, you know, and I think I also just wasn't very good at it. I didn't know how when to grab islands or, you know, there's there was there's a lot going on in this one. And that's another hard thing. This one felt like it was at a weight that was above even some of my like like for me like I think of like terraforming Mars. This is above that for
Yeah. I mean we we I think like where we have this on our website and stuff we would say this is a high complexity versus like a gripple interf it it felt like a burden to get out to the to like get out and teach and like you know at some point a game is just it has that much of a of a burden that it's just not getting played between that my wife not loving it um and me just having a few things I was like h you know we talked about the cards as well are just like okay They're they're fine. Um, but
yeah, what's kind of funny is like we actually have the same complaints about this game. Like my complaints of the games are exactly what you're talking about it being a little too sandboxy.
It's just for me the the experience the game delivers like overcomes it to the point where it's still one of my favorite games. You know, people talk about like the term flawed masterpiece, like what's a game that you like acknowledge that there's like flaws in it or whatever. This feels a little bit in that category for me of like I see things that I like can point to and be like I don't love how this works in that game,
but it it still I just have so much fun playing it.
And I would like if you said, "Hey Daniel, we're going to play Feast for Odin." I would have a great time,
you know?
You'd probably say, "Why would we do that when there's so many other games?"
I would also say that.
Yeah.
But a game that I
in this particular hypothetical where
Yeah.
You would hypothetically say
yes. Yes. where I don't this hypothetical where none of those other games exist asking if you want to play feast road.
That's right.
Well, Ryan, this is game one higher than a feast for that
I got rid from my collection. Uh but this one I guess feast was the only one that didn't have a direct like replacement.
Yeah.
Um which maybe says something about it. But this one uh is a game that I really loved it when I first played it. like I there was I just was I it was I've played games that kind of are in this hybrid realm, you know, I think of like Scythe or something like that. And this one kind of lives in that space of this kind of hybrid workers, but also there's combat and all of that. This goes to Dwellings of Elder Veil, uh which was I think debuted at 18, which I mean that's that's pretty high. And man,
the system in this game was just so cool. the uh this whole like you're putting workers out onto this, you know, interactive map of like, you know, there's other people out there and you're taking actions, but also you can go out and there's like combat that can happen, but then you're taking workers back and you're building up like kind of a like action selection for when you're taking your workers back and and there's, you know, you're you got a kind of unique player power and all that. So, all of that was really cool and I had no intention of getting rid of this game. It was like this was fun. My play with you was a little weird. I don't think you had had a great first game with that. Um but it was like
I acknowledge that was more my own mistakes than the game.
Oh, I acknowledge that too. Yeah. Um
but I I was like, "Yeah, this is this is one that I think this finally delivered what I was kind of looking for in that that space. It felt different enough." But then Andromeda's Edge got released and you know when they say a game is a sequel uh
forcing gamers everywhere to make a hard decision in their lives. We we we always ask ourselves, we look at the games in our collection, we say, "Is this the best version of, you know, for what it's delivering? Is this the best?" So, I had to, you know, I started watching some reviews of it, and when I listened to the changes that were made, I was very intrigued. You know, it's interesting. Initially, the theme actually I didn't like it as much. I actually kind of liked the Dwellings of Elder Veil uh kind of fantasy
fantasy and and whatnot. So, that actually was a little bit of a a downside. But but when I started looking through they just felt like they tightened so many things up in it um and improved a lot of things and I you know I can't remember all of the changes. I know the they you know made some improvements with combat to make it less likely that you can just with like one person you know defeat someone's thing. they have the whole targeting,
you know, targeting mechanic which feels uh really solid. And I don't know, just like across the board, it just there were
a lot of improvements to uh to the system. I'll say one huge benefit that I don't know if I realized and and I and I'm receiving it because I got the base version. I didn't get the deluxe version. I'm so happy I did. The box is so much smaller than Dwellings of Elder Veil. This This is one of my favorite boxes of games I have because it is a on the shelf. It is tight. And
got to love when a big game doesn't need to have
Oh my gosh. Like Like I'm looking at it. I'm looking at it right here, Ryan. And like this game is like thinner than like, you know, Ticket to Ride, you know? It's like that's
and I'm just like, man, that is so nice to have a game that is just packed in ice box. The presentation I think is beautiful. The board, that was another actually thing I really liked. I like having that board out there. It just looks really great. And um and I thought
I liked when I played it that it brought the like cards and stuff onto the board. It felt more like cohesive to me of what I needed to look at. I mean I know speaking for me at least now I would had a very like lackluster play of Dwellings of Elder Veil because of mistakes mistakes were made but my my uh play of Andromeda's Edge was like way more positive. Like I really did enjoy it a lot. Um, yeah, it's one I definitely would be interested in playing again.
I know. I haven't gotten it to the table again. It's actually towards the top of like games that I'm like, I got to get my group together to try because we only played at two-player. I'd be interested to see like a four three or four player game of that.
I think could be a could be a ton of fun. Um, but a super in both like honestly it's one of those things that's like if you love Dwellings of Eldervil like
Yeah. Yeah. And I think, you know,
it's one of those things where if Dwellings of Elder, if Andromeda's Edge hadn't come out and Dwellings of Elderville was still in your collection, it probably would have ranked around the same place again. Totally. So, yeah,
more of a direct replacement. It happens sometimes.
It happens sometimes.
Hey, thanks for watching. Hopefully there aren't any games here that we're going to greatly regret. I guess it' only be Daniel that's regretting. He's the only one that got rid of any of these games. Um, mine still are sticking around, jocking for position on next year's list. We've got some other videos here that you can check out on the channel.