Game Design Hall of Fame: What KINGDOMINO & expansions taught me about BOARD GAME DESIGN
Transcript
I received review copies of dragomino and King Domino Origins from the distributor so thanks to coiled spring build a landscape around your central castle by placing Domino tiles in a grid matching terrain types and amassing crowns to score points King Domino burst onto the scene in 2016 winning the prestigious Builders yares Germany's Game of the Year award the following year and even among the distinguished company of past Spiel winners King Domino stands out as one of the most successful it's a true Evergreen never out of print and regarded highly by casual players families and Gamers alike and inevitably followed by a slew of expansions and sequels Queen Domino was first out of the gates in 2017 introducing a lot more complexity to the game currency income majorities and new scoring opportunities this was King Domino blown up into a light Euro game 2018 saw the first and at the time of filming only expand Mansion for King Domino age of giants the expansion focuses on take that mechanisms along with a number of different scoring objectives to bring variety to your games notably the expansion is compatible with both King Domino and queen Domino with King Domino rapidly expanding into quite a hefty experience publisher blue orange backpedaled with their 2019 release King Domino duel this two-player Edition converts the gameplay into a simple roll and write game in a portable package the following year blue
orange pulled back further still dragomino was something of a surprise King Domino has always been a fantastic family game but dragomino was pitched even younger advertised as appropriate for ages 5 and Up This title brought the series its second spielder's yara's win this time picking up the kinderspiel award in 2021 2021 also saw the release of King Domino Origins another Standalone game utilizing familiar mechanisms from King domino in a prehistoric setting with three alternate modes of play with increasing complexity and 2023 will bring the sixth Standalone title to the series there aren't many details yet released about the upcoming Moon River except that each Domino is formed by connecting two puzzle pieces and the crowns are replaced by cows which can be moved around the terrain using Cowboys King Domino joins sushigo viticulture and everdale to become the fourth entry in my game design Hall of Fame I'm Adam Porter I design games and I review them on this channel with a particular focus on product design if you like what I do please subscribe share the video and comment I love reading your thoughts and opinions my game design Hall of Fame is reserved for games which have made a significant impact on the industry often becoming Evergreen best sellers but crucially it's very much my collection I'm the curator of this haul so there better be games that I love initiates into the
Hall of Fame receive Deep dive videos such as the one you're watching right now where I can pick apart the product the gameplay the ingenious design decisions and the missteps most importantly I'm going to share with you some game design lessons we can learn from the King Domino family of games and I'll throw in a game design challenge for you at the end now I know many of my viewers are game designers like me and a common question that I get asked is about the best way to make prototypes to pitch to Publishers I've recently used launch lab for the first time and this is the perfect way to do it if you really want to impress launch lab is a print-on-demand prototyping service it's free to create an account and the simple user interface will guide you through the rest of the process you simply select the components you need upload your artwork following the clear instructions provided and your game will be posted to you wherever in the world you're located with an incredibly fast turnaround time launch lab is a service provided by launch tabletop a full-scale professional manufacturer so the quality of your prototype will be indistinguishable from professionally published games if you'd like to create a single copy of your game or anything up to a thousand copies then visit launchtabletop.com and start prototyping use the coupon code Adam in Wales or one word for a 20 discount kingdomino is a simple strategy game for two to four players from prolific French designer Bruno katala the creator of some of my very favorite games such as dice town and Abyss in King Domino players take turns to select a domino from the display and add it to their Square grid
you your chosen Domino must join your Castle tile or any other Square which has matching terrain at the end of the game you're going to score points equal to the number of connected squares of each terrain multiplied by the number of crowns within that terrain so a region of eight desert squares with two crowns in it would score 16 points but the real hook in the game is its drafting mechanism when you select a domino you're not just selecting terrain to add to your grid you're also placing yourself in turn order for the following round so if you select the Domino closest to the box you'll play first in the next round and so on for each subsequent domino in the display this drafting system is brilliant it means each turn you've got two key decisions to balance which tile will score me the most points and where will that put me in turn order for the next round the conflicting objectives score points or play first creates a compelling but manageable dilemma and when you're playing at a slightly more competitive level there is a third consideration should I take a tile to deprive my opponent while the drafting system is undeniably the core of the game the mechanism which engages the players and the aspect which caught the attention of critics and award panels the spatial planning is a fun simple puzzle too attempting to build a perfect square while matching terrain types and attempting not to leave any gaps is a gentle Challenge and a pleasant activity it helps that the pieces are chunky and attractive the resulting Kingdom looks delightful with Fantastical
illustrations by Cyril bouquet on every tile I want to zoom in a little on that drafting mechanism and highlight a few of the design decisions that went into its creation Now I wasn't there when Bruno katala was pushing dominoes around his tabletop evolving the gameplay but I would imagine the process went something like this many games have shifting turn order in the worker placement game Agricola a player might use one of their workers to take the start player marker for the next round in the economic game power grid the turn order is determined at the start of each round depending on which player has built the most power stations Bruno katala had a moment of inspiration pairing drafting decisions with a battle for turn order and that might create an interesting Dynamic placing four random tiles from the deck into a display and letting players select tiles with the tile closest to the Box awarding an earlier position in turn order for the next round creates a constantly changing sequence of play but it's pretty random by mid-game with their personal grid starting to develop players have diverging wants and we might repeatedly see the least desirable tiles sitting in the fourth position resulting in a double punishment sorry pal you get the worst tile and you get to play last Meanwhile your mates picked up the best tile by far and retained the start player spot for three rounds in a row it hardly seems fair so katala's solution was to introduce a grading system for the Domino's each tile is numbered on its reverse according to its
relative value with the rarer terrain types with more crowns awarded the higher values when tiles are revealed at the start of each round they're laid out in numerical order with the lowest number closest to the box it's an ingenious solution under this system if you select the more desirable Domino that's going to force you to play later in the subsequent round but of course it's an imperfect system because the value of each Domino varies from player to player depending on the tiles they've previously laid and it's this imperfection which creates the delightful moments in the game it may be that for one player the fourth tile in the display the lowest rank Domino is exactly the piece they need and they get the wonderful double reward of getting just what they wanted and going first next round one of the lessons you learn quickly when you start designing games is that every ingenious new mechanism comes at a cost and that cost frequently takes the form of added complexity the numerical positioning of tiles at the start of each round breaks the flow of the game and it adds to the pre-game rules explanation the random selection of tiles is more intuitive and smoother presence of a bunch of numbers in our fairy tale kingdom is pretty unappealing too it lifts us out of the game World exposing the engine driving the activity we're conditioned to ignore numbers in games where they represent points or even stats but they're aesthetically jarring when they refer only to setup so the decision for the designer is
whether the benefits of a gaming mechanism justify The increased complexity and in this instance King Domino is such a slight rule set with minimal complexity that it can bear one such inclusion the benefit outweighs the cost and talking of gaming mechanisms King Domino sequel Queen Domino is full of them the game introduces a new red terrain type on which you can place buildings which can be purchased from a central market board the building score points for collecting various terrain types or other resources and they often award players with immediate rewards in the form of knights and Towers the player with the most Towers at any point in the game controls the queen token which gives them a discount when purchasing buildings but it also counts as an additional Crown in the highest scoring region at the end of the game Knights can be placed into terrain on your turn to earn coins and it's these coins which are spent to purchase the buildings the added complexity in Queen Domino is quite a step up from the original game there's a substantial amount of new stuff to learn and it may come as quite a shock to players familiar with King Domino Queen Domino is slickly designed with each of the parts neatly interwoven and it's hard to imagine removing any aspect of the system without unbalancing the entire design it feels like it might have started out as expansion material for the original game but ballooned into a package requiring so much additional content the expansion would match the base game for size and retail cost hence repositioned as a standalone product
Queen Domino was followed by the first true king Domino expansion in a clever move by blue orange age of giants is a shared expansion compatible with both earlier titles this is a fun product the sort of expansion I really enjoy focusing on three key features the first is a quality of life upgrade I'd like to see more of these in expansions in this case it comes in the form of a tower in which you can stack your dominoes with a slot at the bottom with functions as a dispenser allowing you to pull out a random tile as and when you need the second feature is a series of giant tiles and when you take one of these you gain an adorable giant token which takes up residence in your kingdom covering one of your crowns and hence costing you points so you don't want Giants unfortunately the expansion provides you with another set of giant footstep tiles which allows you to pass your Giants on to an opponent the final feature in age of giants is a set of scoring tiles for King Domino or queen Domino these include the basic variants from the original game score bonus points for keeping your castle at the center of your Grid or for filling out your grid perfectly without any spaces but they also bring in a host of other fascinating scoring opportunities score points for placing certain terrains around your Castle or in the corners of your final grid layout or perhaps score points for rows of connected crowns or large areas of connected terrain without any crowns at all so we have a mix of new take that
Elements which won't be to everyone's taste though I enjoy them and some fantastic added variety provided by mixing and matching scoring tiles playing Queen Domino with the age of giants content mixed in becomes quite an involved Affair and the complexity sits on a par with carcazon with a couple of expansions mixed in you know it's perfectly manageable for an experienced gamer but it's not a great starting point for a beginner player the age of giants expansion highlights one minor stumbling block within the system how can the designer introduce new tiles when the game has a curated numerical ranking if the new dominoes are interspersed with the existing tiles you're gonna have to allocate them 0.5 values numbering the new tiles 13 and a half 47 and a half Etc or if the new dominoes are considered less valuable than the original tiles how are you going to indicate this negative numbers age of giants takes a different route using letters for the giant dominoes and these are ranked lower than the numbered tiles from the original set I don't think there's a better solution but it is hardly slick now these minor challenges give does designers sleepless nights despite the fact that they go entirely unnoticed by the vast majority of players I wonder what the impetus was that led to the creation of 2019's King Domino Jewel was it an attempt at duplicating the success of katala's two-player hit Seven Wonders Jewel or was it designed to capitalize on the recent Roland right Trend to sit among
popular titles like Quicks railroad Inc and Gan Shone clever perhaps it was simply a desire to produce King Domino the dice game and then scaled down to two players to reduce component costs regardless catala's frequent collaborator Ludovic malblanc was brought on board as co-designer and the final product was cleverly designed to utilize some of the key aspects of King Domino with less table space required and far fewer components just a pad of paper four dice and a couple of pencils in King Domino Jewel a round starts with a roll of four dice the starting player selects one die the second player takes two dice and the remaining die goes to the starting player and both players combine their Pair of Dice to form a domino and then they Mark the faces on their grid using the usual King Domino placement rules the coats of arm represent the six different territories and the crosses replace King Dominos crowns and the scoring works as in the original game King Domino duel presents some interesting new decisions and a little more tension the two players compete to be the first to fill in rows on a shared sheet Each of which Awards them with a single use bonus ability placing a domino without matching terrain or use your two dice independently instead of as a combined Domino or draw an extra cross somewhere on your Grid in theory this functions as a mild catch-up mechanism because you only fill in a box if you take a cube without a cross on it but in reality the special abilities are only of minor interest and a player can win easily
without using any of them so this results in a lot of bookkeeping with little genuine reward and filling in those boxes just tracks from the core gameplay now it may sound like a minor complaint but the flow of play is constantly interrupted and it's very easy to lose track of which player started in subsequent rounds so we ended up using an eraser as a start player token passing it back and forth at the end of each turn ultimately King Domino duel feels like a package with some nice ideas that doesn't quite come together the board state is tricky to read at a glance and the gameplay is unintuitive the precise opposite of the original King domino game it's a passable roll and right experience in a portable affordable package but there are many better Alternatives in that genre so I can only really recommend this one to Die Hard fans of the original who frequently play with two and who are looking for a familiar King Domino experience with a smaller footprint 2020's dragomino once again brought in co-designers this time Marie and Wilfried fought the designers of the Fantastic children's games Valley of the Vikings and Moonlight castle at adapt in the game for children aged 5 and Up the team took the Bold decision to remove the Central Tile selection mechanism arguably the headline feature of King Domino and in dragomino players simply select dominoes in a clockwise sequence however the designers did cleverly manage to incorporate an alternate system whereby the start player token constantly shifts between the players giving some of the feel of the original
game with a lower barrier to entry in dragomino the requirement to build a square grid has gone we simply match terrain types to hopefully score points you can place a domino anywhere whether it matches other tiles or not but it's a good idea to match terrain because each time you do you select a face down Dragon token of the corresponding color when you flip the egg you'll either find a baby dragon worth one point or a broken eggshell which is worth nothing but this allows you to take the start player marker so you select first in the next round there's a highly recommended variant rule where matching terrains feature entering a lake allows you to peek at two eggs before deciding which one to keep and the other one is return face down to the tabletop this introduces a memory element to the game because you'll need to keep track of this egg for future turns either to select it later because you know it's a dragon or to avoid it because you know it's a shell dragomino is wholly successful in creating a gorgeous engaging Domino matching game for young children it isn't going to hold the attention of an adult group for long but as a game for parents to play with their kids there's enough here to prevent the parents from dropping off 2021's King Domino Origins abandons the established naming convention I guess prehistamino was taken and it swings back in favor of complexity though perhaps it doesn't push as far in that direction as the earlier Queen Domino King Domino Origins is set in prehistoric times the core King domino rules remain but crowns have been
replaced with fire and kingdoms hence score points for the size of a particular terrain multiplied by the number of fires in it the game features three modules of increasing complexity the first introduces volcanoes so this terrain type allows you to take a lava token showing one two or three fire icons and you can add these fires to your terrain to increase the points scored at the end of the game but they must be placed within a few squares of the volcano the second module introduces wooden resources mushrooms fish flint and woolly mammoths and when you select Domino with one of these icons on it you gain the resource and the player with the most of each resource type is awarded bonus points third module allows you to spend resources to purchase Hunters gatherers shamans and other cave people these tokens score if you have specific resources on the eight surrounding squares and the Warriors accumulate points if they're placed adjacent to each other scoring the sum of the value of all the Warriors in the group multiplied by the number of warriors King Domino Origins recycles certain ideas from Queen Domino the purchasing of scoring tiles majority scoring for resources but unlike Queen Domino it provides three modes of play of increasing complexity so players can grow with the game the first module is only a tiny step up from the original King Domino now I rate games using my own ladder engagement system so a game is awarded zero to three points in each of five categories and every Point scored climbs the game one rung a score
of 10 or above reaches the highest rung and indicates a real favorite with me for thematic immersion the original King Domino scores zero the game looks beautiful but there's no semblance of a narrative the game is very clearly an abstract puzzle with a fairy tale overlay Queen Domino dragomino and Origins do feel slightly more immersive they certainly don't tell coherent stories but the added components resources Towers night coins dragon eggs do at least suggest that these kingdoms are inhabited there's a sense of a little world occupying our tableaus it's enough to award these titles one point a piece for interaction the original King Domino scores one the competition for turn order is engaging and there are opportunities for deliberate blocking but most of the game is spent with eyes firmly on your own kingdom assessing placement opportunities and planning a turn or two ahead age of giants enhances the interaction by incorporating take that mechanisms and queen Domino and Origins introduce majority scoring which force you to pay attention to your opponent's progress there are also more opportunities for blocking depriving your opponents of just the building they need from the marketplace in Queen Domino or just the caveman they need in Origins King Domino Jewel also steps up the interaction with players racing to fill in rows of boxes to benefit from the relevant bonus abilities a large
part of King Domino's appeal comes from the stress and tension in the game you can easily build yourself into a corner with careless tile placement and when the perfect terrain appears in the display yet itching to snatch it up before your opponents this tension is only heightened in Queen Domino and in Origins where the fight for majorities is also fierce dragomino is more easy going as you'd expect for a game for five-year-olds but there's still palpable tension when flipping those dragon eggs feedback refers to the various ways in which a Game responds to the player's input so rewards penalties and other effects resulting from your in-game choices King Domino doesn't offer up much in the way of feedback beside end game points though it is satisfying to slot just the right Domino into place matching two terrains at once substantially enhancing your score drag or mono scores higher for feedback every tile Edge which matches the terrain of an adjacent Domino earns you a dragon egg so you can amass Two Three or even more on a single turn the ability to send Knights out to generate income from your largest domains is very satisfying in Queen Domino and similarly it's rewarding to gather delightful wooden resources in Origins exchanging them later for high scoring tiles and of course the tactile feedback and anticipation of a dice roll is present and correct in King Domino Jewel the original King Domino offers up a delightful but manageable Dilemma on every turn should you collect matching squares of terrain to enlarge your
domain or is it better to focus on crowns to ensure that every one of your domains scores well and when should you prioritize turn order over tile selection Queen Domino and Origins bring in new meteor considerations but potentially they do so at the expense of diluting and obscuring the core dilemma of the game turn order simply swaps back and forth in dual so one of the key facets of the game is absent but if you really want to enhance the decisions in King Domino then the age of giants expansion is the way to go the wealth of scoring criteria brings a lot of variety to the game without clouding the central mechanism the addition of just two simple scoring objectives really changes things up making each game feel fresh it's tough to position the dominoes in exactly the right spot to complete the objectives while also remaining within a five by five or seven by seven grid and also maximizing crowns and connecting terrain types I'd love to see a similar set of scoring tiles for Origins though it'd be easy to adapt the queen domino rules yourself the decisions in dragomino are of course super light but they're perfectly pitched for a young child and the game isn't mindless now I want to make clear at this point that this system is calibrated to my needs Adam in Wales a seasoned gamer in his 40s and a low score doesn't necessarily indicate a bad product dragomino is a wonderful game for young children it's just not all that engaging for a group of adults I find King Domino delightful but I'm more
likely to bring it to the table with a family group than I am with my regular gaming Pals Chucky and age of giants though and now you've really caught my interest Queen Domino plus expansion Rivals many light midweight euros and it's a great option for a game night Origins likewise offers up a fresh king Domino experience and this one has the benefit of a variety of play modes so you can adapt it to your own taste now I've been reflecting on why King Domino achieved such extraordinary Commercial Success where so many other games struggle it's accessible for a wide range of player ages and types it has a brilliant Central drafting mechanism and it's beautifully Illustrated not enough to Garner this much praise and attention what is that secret source which continues to catch consumers interest Domino's I'm pretty convinced that's the answer there are a handful of game components which every family in this country is familiar with dice for sure playing cards definitely and both of those have been explored and exploited thoroughly in hundreds of thousands of games but dominoes has got to be in the top five right and there's a significant shortage of modern games utilizing that ubiquitous resource carcazon has had the monomino market wrapped up for two decades a game featuring a grid of square tiles is immediately going to draw comparison with Klaus Jurgen Raiders behemoth there's been an ongoing battle for the polyomino throne ever
since Hoover Rosenberg launched Patchwork in 2014. Rosenberg has struggled to establish a total Monopoly on use of that component despite a large number of polyomino titles in his portfolio Phil Walker Harding is one Pretender to the throne and Frank West has blown the market wide open with a wildly successful Isle of cats but there aren't many other candidates vying for the title of domino King what katala's game does so well is enhance and enliven the traditional domino game that we all recall fondly without straying far from the original gameplay the few domino games we've seen in the modern era have complicated the core gameplay considerably and seen far less success than King Domino one gamey drafting mechanism is permitted just enough to freshen up the classic and the result is a very approachable product for a parent or a grandparent to purchase for their offspring and a game that everyone can enjoy the title itself is a master stroke King Domino is a vaguely amusing play on words invoking a fairy tale theme while declaring its USP clearly up front and center no ambiguity this is the king of the domino games it's interesting to observe how blue orange have handled the property since the spielder's yara's win in 2017. after a slightly bloated sequel a belated expansion a junior Edition and the obligatory Dice Game King Domino seems
to have hit its stride with Origins and the hints we've heard so far about 2023's Moon River suggests that blue orange is planning to go the way of carcasson with annual releases of King Domino products to maintain their dominant position in this board game Niche on my idea execution Matrix strong commercial products occupy the red orange section of the grid a brilliant central idea perfectly executed and King Domino is such a product a fantastic concept filling a genuine Gap in the market and appealing to a wide audience with Gorgeous production throughout now personally I'm a big fan of Queen Domino it turns King Domino into a light medium Euro Tire laying game with a central currency income majority scoring and set collection bonuses what's not to like oddly though the shift in weight puts that product into a weird category and the game loses some of its unique charm Queen Domino is an enjoyable midweight Euro but it struggles to stand out from its peers in that category the simpler King Domino shines in a more naive Family Market standing out because of one ingenious Central mechanism and some delightful presentation so while Queen Domino would always be my preferred way to play I think King Domino is a more effective product age of giants is a no-brainer it's almost obligatory for a spielder's yara's winner to have an expansion and this is a good one focusing on increasing interaction variety and meaningful choices while also offering a
quality of life upgrade with the domino tower for me King Domino Jewel was a misstep a perfectly serviceable two-player Roland right it struggles to hold its own in a saturated Market dragomino is a brilliant little product worthy of its kindersfield as yara's win I'm not sure anyone was expecting the already very simple King Domino to get a junior Edition but it works and it's gorgeous to boot and Kingdom no Origins points to the future of the line a more sensible naming system future-proofed for subsequent releases and a product with graded difficulty levels The Best of Both Worlds occupying a space somewhere between king and queen Domino you to hold for the king Domino line place your bets how long before we see a Cooperative variant when will the first licensed Edition arrive and what will the license be it's got to be Disney right King Domino Legacy anyone so we're going to finish off with a design challenge can you think of a traditional game component familiar to every family which hasn't yet been fully utilized in modern board games what are the unique properties of that component how did it find its widespread appeal in Years Gone by can you tap into that coupling nostalgic appeal with some simple modern mechanisms and an evocative theme sounds like a promising starting point for a successful product if you'd like to hear about other entries into my game design Hall of Fame click on the link and until next time
all the best