Skip to main content
Loading video...

Why I'm Selling Zombicide & Cthulhu Death May Die

Transcript 19:38

I'm currently making some hard decisions around what's staying and what's leaving my board game collection. And the reality is a lot of games have to go. Probably half of my total collection has to go. And you can't always keep nostalgia. You can't always keep history in mind when you decide what's staying in the collection and what's leaving. I keep running across these two classic Sean games. Zombicide. We've got Black Plague here. And we've got what I will honestly say the bitter disappointment which has been the Marvel Zombies core box. We'll get into that in a moment.

And we've got Cthulhu Death May Die. Not only this copy of Cthulhu Death May Die, but also the expansions, an upgraded wooden box for it, the second wave from the printing that happened maybe a year and a half or so ago. I've got a lot of these two games. And for a long time, Seimon's philosophy was that they wanted to deliver a lifetime worth of board games in a single Kickstarter pledge, in a single wave of content. And I understand that philosophy. I even think there's something to be said for it. [sighs] The problem is is that if you are moving or downsizing, if you have multiple lifestyle games, if you live in the reality of the board game hobby, which means you have more games than you tend to actually get to the table.

A lifestyle worth of games can sometimes be more prohibitatory prohibitory than it is uh a gift or an advantage. Marvel Zombies really was the experience of this for me. Marvel Zombies core box played through the entire thing with a group of friends over a long weekend and it wasn't as good. It wasn't as good as I remember it being. It wasn't as good as it could have been or should have been. And the reason being is because it got diluted, separated in an effort to make a lifetime worth of a board game. They put all the expansions to the side, the interesting mechanics, the more nuanced rules, the twists and variances, the upgrades in the characters that you really wanted to play. They covered all of it. But they did so by dividing it, leaving the remnants, the scraps for retail to pick up for brand new intro gamers to sit down and play. But it made this less good.

And that meant that I needed to add expansions, that I wanted to mix it up, that I wanted it to get dark and gritty, and I wanted it to feel powerful and threatening. And it wasn't until you started mixing in all of the extras that it reached that threshold. It's one of the elements that we loved and still love about Zombai Black Plague, this brutal, gritty, hard, challenging game. But it comes with the same caveat. It comes with the need to own as much as possible, to customize your own scenario, to mix it up and make it chaotic. And it started that journey of spin-offs and expansions of little modules that get tweaked here and there per scenario and that end up dividing the game making it so that this one little core box is no longer enough enough to be enjoyable past the first cycle of plays. And I'm not saying we regret the first cycle of plays, but there is a lot to be said for a cohesive game that contains everything within a package or two. And you often find that with newer titles, with publishers that are putting out something for the first time, their love language happens to be give the fans, give the hardcore backers, give the people that are as insane as them everything they can in a single little package because this is the shop they have. This is the the call to arms. This is where they get a chance

to step into the ranks of the board game world and make a name for themselves. and Sean, I mean, maybe now to their dismay, lost sight of that along the way. I mean, the classics, the old school Sean, the dogs of war, everything was contained in that box. And yeah, marketing tactics certainly swayed and impacted uh the community. There were exclusives that I never got my hands on, characters that I wanted to play in that old classic. But yet, I could have one box on my shelf, and that box punched above its weight every time you had a good group sit down to play it. So, as I've been making hard decisions, I think I've come to the conclusion that Zombicide and Cthulhu Death May Die really don't have room on my shelves anymore. They're too big. They're too ambitious. And as much as I would love to keep both of them, Zombicide specifically sprawls out of control.

I might keep this unspeakable box. But this towering behemoth, the second wave, I haven't even opened it cuz I'm intimidated to try to find a space for it to exist. And the reality is that most of the expansions aren't things that I'm going to end up touching as much as I would love to think that I will. And the lynch pin for this decision, the contrast, the the thing that I'm anticipating coming down the road is that I have another game on the way. a game that I think will take the spot of both of these, at least for my collection. That game's called Insania. It funded on Gamefound a few months ago, and I had a chance to sit down and play it recently, and I was absolutely aruck. I really, really enjoyed it. Now, I played on TTS, didn't play a physical prototype, and TTS makes the experience of the game worse, which means the fact that I enjoyed it in a digital platform, in a little bit of a clunky experience, means that the experience of the game, sitting down at the table with a group of friends, laughing at the cards we pull out, seeing the brutality expressed on the table in front of us, is going to be better than I'm anticipating.

It might not and probably won't be right for a lot of you, but if you're a fan of Zombicide, a fan of Cthulhu Death May Die, and like that hardcore gritty, nonapologetic style of things like Kingdom: Death Monster, Insania is one of those games that you really should have on your radar. And in my opinion, I think it's one of those games that will take the spot of these two titles for a number of people, myself included. There's three things that stand out for me. One is how it is better than Zombicide. Two is how it's better than Cthulhu Death May Die. And three is how for me it stands on its own. It draws my attention and doesn't let it go. Zombicide is a game that was highlighted in my collection for a number of reasons, but the primary role that Zombicide has played in my collection has been that oneoff challenging scenario-based adventure with a group of friends. That RPG on a table for one evening for a couple of hours. That get real close to the finish line feeling. that random chaos could happen that could cause you to lose. But for the most part, you can scrape your claws out and scrape the zombies claws out and you can uh or eyes out. Claws are the things that are doing the scraping and you can get across that finish line by the skin of your teeth and the hair of your knuckles. Zombicide is that full of random loot and things

that you can grab, items and upgrades and character development. It gave us that little pocket-size story. Well, Insania is modeled in that same way. It's a group of adventurers hopping into this Roman Cthulhuesesque nightmare of a landscape. We're not fighting zombies exactly, but these flesh abominations that are wandering their way towards us are a mix of mythos and the undead, the demons, the architecture of whatever it is that lives behind where you can see. I mean, if you pause for a moment and you just imagine what's right behind your head, or even better, what's right in the center of your skull crawling and squirming around, that's what Insania is seeking to expose. It's their own lore, their own world, their own creation, and they've moved past some of the Cthulhu, some of the zombie, some of the tired tropes that we see and love time and time again.

Insania gives us that oneshot scenario, that challenging cooperative adventure, that party of explorers going off and fighting something evil and unknown. It gives it to us in at least an equivalent way to how Zombicide does. On top of that, it gives you the option to play through a larger, more comprehensive, more striv story story focused campaign. Strivy, not a word, but I like it. It rolled off the tongue smoothly. And so that combination, that offering, that play through campaign, sit down and play a mini campaign, even a set of one, two, or three scenarios that all link together, that all flow from one to the next, that let you carry just a bit of the remnants of the last game forward.

That's the promise that Insania is making. That's what it's currently delivering. And that's why for me it's going to be taking the spot of Zombicide. Smaller box, a little bit more contained, a little bit more an indie publisher doing their best to make a statement without a aggressively large footprint, and uh a game that's not hitting the table as much anymore, that's taking up a little bit too much real estate. Cthulhu Death May Die. Of course, the lore here and the storytelling here is one of the masterpieces. But for me, the thing that always drew me to Cthulhu Death May Die was the characters, the level progression. It was more advanced, more complex, felt more personal to their individual stories than Zombide ever did. We hear we have heroes that are grabbing weapons. Here we have characters that are real, that breathe, that fight, that die, that struggle through the chaos of their own minds and unlock both buffs and debuffs as they go. That's where Insania is at least entering the conversation. Their character development is different. It's a merger of the two in a number of ways, but you gather weapons, you gather items, you gather armor and gear, and your character by pairing together the right sequence of cards, by searching out, finding, and equipping the correct items can create matches. Those matches then unlock their own character potential, their own specific power. And

so whereas in Zombicide you're gathering weapons, armor, and gear and equipping them to the most appropriate character and then going off and fighting, here you're paying attention. What does my character need? How can I unlock their special unique abilities in a similar way to how you're unlocking your character abilities throughout Cthulhu? On top of that, you have the madness, the insanity, the way that your mind breaks as you play. and Insania, you know, title declaring has that as well. These debuffs that could be magical abilities, suddenly the inability to feel pain or the fact that your right arm just swings a little bit harder. Those could happen. You could go insane for a positive reason, but for the most part, you're going to be going in in insane for aggressively painful and negative reasons and causes. I mean, the world around you is literally crumbling apart. And so, uh, you got to grit your teeth and bear it or break and survive. Either way, the character development between these two games is sort of right in the middle in Insania.

It's not as empty of storytelling, of live living characters as Zombaside. You still get that fun grab weapons, grab equipment, and upgrade your way to power. And in Cthulhu, you're kind of playing your role. Well, in in Sia, the items, the gear, the equipment that you get allow you to unlock your powers and abilities. And those powers and abilities do give you a type of character arc, a type of role that you might experience. But there's enough flexibility there that you can also if you need to or want to or find the right weapon and item suddenly become a mage who has an insane bow and is firing across multiple rooms slaughtering people or demons or creatures as they rush in your direction. Insania gives me that rich deep character building without compromising either of these two sides. So for me, it satisfies the conditions that I'm looking for in Cthulhu Death May Die and therefore can take its spot. Now, why would I hold on to Cthulhu Death May Die or at least the small box? I like the storytelling. I like the Cthulhu mythos.

So, there is a chance that one little package lives and we play through the last few scenarios that we still have to experience. but honestly feels a little bit repetitive or redundant or unnecessary with another game on the horizon. The third thing that for me makes Insania a right style game for my shelf that might venture to uh leave it off the table for some of you watching is its unapologetic nature to history to brutality to humanity. I like a game like Kingdom Death Monster. I like artwork that's gruesome and brutal that doesn't hold punches when punches are going through skulls and hearts are exposed and the flesh is flayed off the bones of those living and unliving.

And so Insania does that. It has fun at every corner and feels like it doesn't sacrifice the story in order to have fun, but it it leans into the mythos that it's playing in. the gladatorial arenas that were as ruthless and brutal and sometimes uh you know chaotic as possible, the fall and rise of the Roman Empire, the Cthulhuesque nightmare that it introduces into the city as if instead of barbarian hordes and the internal politics were the ones tearing down the uh marble structures, it was otherworldly dimensions and demonic enslavement that were ripping apart the foundations of a once great society.

Insania plays with all those things. Plays with sexuality, plays with brutality, plays with human form and history. And it doesn't apologize as it does it. And I enjoy that. I think it's fun. I think it fits the story. I think it fits the world that we have lived in and still live in and makes for an interesting gaming experience when you get a pair of earrings or a necklace that have an oddly phallic shape. feels true to Rome being the culture that it was and the culture that in some ways America has inherited and also is a hilarious piece of equipment to apply that gives you a buff that happens to save the day creates and makes and brings about some fun moments.

So that's where I am. That's the pitch I'm making. Zombicide, Cthulhu, Death May Die, take up a little bit too much room, have debuffed their core boxes to a point where I don't want to play them without the expansions. And given this, I don't want to play the expansions either, cuz there's just too much to sort through. I want to be given a game that's good, that's competitive, that'll hold my attention, and I want to uh not have a workout while I do so. So, there you have it. the first on a series of calling and choosing videos.

The first entry into this conversation around how one takes a collection from several hundred games down to 100, 150, cut it in half or a little bit more. Now I am counting each individual box as a separate game kind of. It has to do more with space and the value that those games add for the space that they take up. Like cockroach poker is, you know, one of the most aggressive smallbox games in my entire collection. Or Crokinol sitting over here on the wall. One hangs in a unique location, takes up a decent amount of space, but is a powerhouse when it comes to a good game night.

These two, I don't think they're carrying their water anymore. And Insania is on the near horizon. So, Insania it will be. Thank you for watching. Thank you for being here. Let me know. What are your thoughts around all of this? Oh, do you think Cthulhu Death May Die and Zombicide have overstayed their welcome? Do you think uh you're going to go swing over and check out Insania on their Kickstarter? Give it a back. give it a pledge and talk to me about it when it actually arrives and we can laugh about the stories it tells or not or you just watching cuz it's fun because you think my shirt's pretty cool. Well, either way, whatever the case, whatever you do, remember to do the important thing. Get out and play some games.

We'll see you next time.

Progress saved