My City / My Island Trilogy - Review and Ranking
Transcript
welcome to allies or enemies I'm Jess and I am Sean and today we are going to talk about this Trilogy of games My City My City Rolland build and my Island all of them designed by Ryan arenia all of them released by Cosmos and this guy we did get as a review copy but all of our thoughts are all our own and they are all tile placement games which is a type of game that we really like playing and they are all also all Campaign games and we have played through each of them so combined we have played a whole bunch of these games yeah we played like I would think like a 100ish times cuz these guys are like 24 game campaigns um and we played through this one twice and we played through this one I think we're on to our second one too so we played Oodles of these we've got a lot to talk about and we won't give away any spoilers but we will do a brief overview of how each of them work starting with my city so my city is the first in the series and this is the most just kind of regular what you would think of as a tile placement game so you got your old school polyomino and all of the classic Tetris shapes and those are different buildings you start off with this empty board and then each turn you play out a card and that tells you which polyomino shape you can play to your board and in
the first part of the campaign you're just trying to put those next to each other you're just trying to fill up the board you're trying to cover rocks avoid trees you're not allowed to go on the river it's basically all the rules As you move on they're going to add different rules you're going to be grouping those buildings differently you're going to be making lines from this to that you're going to be adding stickers and other stuff that I don't want to spoil from you but pretty much that's how that one plays in my city roll and build you are doing the same same thing as in my city of putting buildings out onto a field but it's the ru and right version so instead of a card getting flipped and picking a tile you roll dice and then those dice how they fit together is the type of building that you're drawing out and they keep the building drawing really simple it's like solid lines diagonals and then an X so you don't have to be an expert at drawing and each episode is done on a separate piece of paper so it means the map is able to change a little bit more than in my city where it's all done on a board and just like my city new things get introduced throughout you go as you go although there are fewer episodes that you play in this one my island is the newest one in this series this one just came out this year it's a 2023 game and it does change things a little bit in that you're no longer using those polyomino Tetra shapes now you're using hex's and actually you're using little kind of clusters of hexes so each each hex is a different building but they come in sets of two three and
four buildings but like the original you are playing on a card that card tells you which one of your tiles you're allowed to put out and then you're adding that to your Island you're trying to cover up spaces you're just starting in the early ones just kind of around the outside and then stuff's going to get added you're going to reach more parts of the board and all of that stuff that you would expect and it definitely follows along the same lines but it does add a little bit of complexity but let's just jump into kind of the different categories and talk about which one we think shines in different ways let's start with replayability and just by playing the campaign you are going to play these a ton my city role and build is 12 plays to play through the campaign the other two are 24 so already 24 plays of a game is a is a lot of times yeah there's not a lot of games on our shelves that we've played 24 times that's Oodles of plays you do have to keep in mind that like the average play time it says is 30 minutes and that's probably like the a Long play time for a longer scenario so these are fairly quick but even with that there's like three different kind of little episodes in a chapter and we play it like three times back to back every time we play it and still like we've got a lot of plays out of this yeah and I think they intend for you to play it three back to back because it's divided into a chapter so for each chapter you get to open up for the big games at least a big envelope open and introduce a whole new rule set some new maybe components and bits that
come out and it's just really exciting to get to each chapter as well that we're like okay let's play through this so the next cting we can open up a brand new envelope and my city Rolland build even though it doesn't have that envelope and it's a little bit shorter it's just 12 plays a great thing about that one though is that you've got um like the between the front in the back of each one of those sheets you've got 24 play through of that campaign so that is oodles Oodles of dim that you're playing through that game if there's 12 campaigns if there's 12 within a campaign and there's 24 times that's like 288 plays there and there definitely wasn't an edit there what I quickly grabbed a calculator and looked that up but just guessing I was only eight off so I'm very proud of that but that means that there there that's like a ton of plays and so that one it actually plays from 1 to six players so even with six players that's like quite a few you can play all the way through that what four times yeah four times yeah we didn't even need a calculator for that map so that's very impressive um but an important thing to remember is each one of those plays is really short none of these took us more than kind of a couple of weeks to get 100% of the way through the campaign even if we're busy with other things or playing other games it's just something that you kind of come back to and come back to yeah the end of the campaigns for my city and my Island there are ways to play them that
aren't the campaign style we haven't found ourselves drawn to play that because I mean we played my city like 50 times so we didn't really feel the need to like keep playing but I feel like that's kind of when you got a campaign game it's like who's ever played pandemic when you're done pandemic I think Clank Legacy is the only one that's broken that for us not sure these are going to be the ones that do it as well but you would have played them a lot by that point anyway yeah you have 48 plays under your belt that's you know they cost like 20 bucks that's a pretty you're getting a pretty good return so let's talk a little bit about components and all of these have fairly equal component quality like it's not going to knock your socks off but it's important to kind of remember that they are trying to be pretty affordable and their Campaign games so they're also a little bit disposable yeah nothing's super fancy but it does its job so for my city Roland build I think the dice are nice and chunky but they are a little bit like light they weirdly light I wish there was a little bit more I almost want to like open them up and put something in there yeah they're weirdly a little bit too light and I don't think it came with pencils either but I mean you usually have pencils kicking around I always they always give those little golf pencils that I just Chuck in any sort of rolling right game but the sheets are double-sided and thick enough that it doesn't bleed through so that's nice that you can use pen and you can use pen on both sides without it like impacting the other side for my city and my Island the tiles are like a decent thickness they're like I feel like a
little thinner than kind of a Baron Park or kind of your average tile placement game but also it's meant to be a campaign game so they're meant to be kind of disposable and they're trying to keep it affordable so all of that's reflected but you know they're they're decent I think everything in them is like is good so for complexity all three of them are light tile placement games and I think I would play these with relatively new Gamers it does a really good job of that very first episode you can just start playing and it keeps the rules really simple really straightforward and then builds complexity as you go for for each of them I think with a new gamer you probably couldn't start them in like episode 22 but if you start them in episode one and then you're playing through the thing episode 22 is going to be absolutely no problem because it does such a good job of just holding your hand from game to game and I think all three of them do that yeah if this is the first tile placement game they're playing I think after this they would easily be able to pick up other tile placement games because it has built that complexity already so I think my island is the most complex I think they've kind of added layers as they've gone through which is what you would hope that one would do with this sort of a series but that's a little bit misleading to say it's the most complex because all of them are super light but but I think my city is such a terrific starting point for folks that I don't really see any reason to start with the other ones cuz you're going to get so much out of that and then it's great to
go from my city to my city rolling build to My Island or even my city to My Island if you're not into the rolling right thing but I do think that my city is probably the easiest one to get people into so that's such a great starting point and my Island does build even newer stuff that if you've done my city already You' got to the end you're still going to have new surprises be learning new things seeing new things when you play through my Island so that leads us into who it's for and we mentioned it's a good one to bring new gamers in but also if you just like tile placement games and you like Campaign games this mushes those two together very nicely but I don't know if you would necessarily need to start with my city I think it is a good one to start with but if my Island's the only one available I think you could play that one first and then play like my city afterwards yeah yeah it's not it's not like there's like a story like you're going to ruin anything and we haven't really mentioned that that there is a story in it kind of there's like a sentence or two before each episode so don't expect this to like be this enthralling story the story is just like and now this new building arrived it's like unbelievably simple um so you can totally play them in any order but I would say one group this is really going to be for is I think this is terrific if you're playing with two players I think this is such a solid there aren't maybe there are a lot of two-player but this is such a it's such a solid two-player campaign game both because you can play
through it again and there's just there's not any reason really to have more than two players there's not really interaction there's it's mostly just like ra trying to get the most points but you're not messing with each other any reason You' have more people yeah so I don't think I wouldn't play it if I was more than two but I just think the bonus of being able to play through it again is is such a nice bonus at two players right yeah if you got a A group of four and they're all desperate to play it don't be like no only two of us could play yes all four of you could play you would all have a good time but what is I'm really going to put you on the spot here usually we don't do this sort of thing but let's do it but what is your favorite of the three like how how would you rank them from your experience playing through them it's really tough to decide I think if I had to my favorite would be my city it was the very first campaign title placement game we played and we enjoyed it so much we played through right away afterwards I think it's just also the classic polyomino shapes that are so satisfying to fit together my island is second I think they introduced a few layers and I really like the new stuff that they brought in I found a little bit more surprising than my city but just the hexes didn't quite grab me as much as the other polyomino shapes and then the Rolland build version version is really great for like a roll and right and you can play it through so many times just the the components are are just a sheet of paper supposed to like a board in
your own tiles yeah no I I I think I agree with that list I asked you the question and then I had not thought of an answer yet but yes the rolling right I would put on the bottom which isn't really fair because it's a super cheap game it's it's a rolling right is not asking as much like it's not trying to do as much but it's doing a lot for what it is I think but it would still be third but then the top two are just so neck and neck I'm not oh it's so hard to say I think I would put my Island first that's partly because we've played my city like 48 times we' played all the way through it twice I think like 50 times cuz we actually tried to play the Eternal game as well so I kind of have my fill of my city whereas my Island had a few kind of cool like interesting surprises and other things in there that I'm still really Keen to play back through that again and play another 24 of those if I was saying though like which one to start with I still think my city such a great way to start yeah I am really looking forward to playing through my Island again and I think that's another bonus about it playing through as two players cuz the first time you're not entirely too sure like where all the points are going to come from for either my city or my Island whereas I found for the second time we played through my city we had a much better understanding so we're targeting those points that would come up more at the end better and so for my Island I already have some ideas of some things I want to do differently oh see I don't like that
because my city just won first and then I won the followup but my Island I won first and I'm very worried that because I kind of lucked out in some parts now you know and so I'm I'm worried about I'm going to have to be on my very best in order to win the second time and and that is it that is our thoughts on all three of my City My City rolling build and my Island thank you so much for watching please let us know in the comments if you played any of the three and if you have which one is your favorite and as usual please like subscribe and hopefully we'll see you next time for another game