Top 10 Board Games That Should Have Been MEGA HITS - Chairman of the Board
Transcript
hey everyone today i'm talking about my top 10 ball games that should have been mega hits so every now and then a game comes along that just blows up to tremendous success i'm talking games such as king domino or quacks of quedenberg you know code names splendor now these games are selling you know hundreds of thousands if not millions of copies and then sometimes games come along that seem to have that same winning formula and they just don't go anywhere they seem to flatline or maybe even have their five minutes in you know fame and then just fizzle out whereas those games are always kind of considered evergreen and just uh kind of constant cash cows for those companies and just again just just remarkably successful now i normally find that those games are pretty accessible so i think maybe the more complex or the more involved games games become they start to lose interest of the kind of more casual gamer which is more than fair enough and understandable and those games that also tend to be attractive and inviting to a lot of different people and i think again i think all these games hit those marks and um again you could have easily been as successful as the other ones had the wind blown in the right direction so let's start at number 10 and we'll talk about the reasons why i think these games could could have been as successful as those other ones at number 10 i have good critters so the reason why this is at number 10 is because i feel this one is a little bit more niche in relation to the other ones because it does require a higher play account which isn't so easy for a lot of other people and it also requires people to be a bit more outgoing and be willing
to engage in negotiation so this game is a negotiations negotiation style game as you take the role of these different mobsters but every round someone is going to be a mob boss and they're going to get given a number of money basically and the idea is that you can distribute that money out however you see fit so you can give it all to one player you can keep it all for yourself you can spread it out fairly if you like and even not even give yourself any money and the objective is to get as much money as you can however whenever you are happy when this money is distributed out everybody is going to take a vote or do an action simultaneously now that could be things such as voting confidence for the mob boss or even trying to out kind of kick out the mob boss and overtake them and be the new mob boss you can blackmail other players you can bribe other players it's absolutely fantastic how engaging this game is and just the the room for negotiation how creative you can be and the level of paranoia that sits into this game is absolutely um just so engaging and a lot of fun and i've never had a duff game of this one again it seems to have all those things and all those points to hit which generally are successful you know i've even talked this game to people who didn't know anything about it i'm not even the most outgoing of people and they always leave the game feeling that's excellent and even maybe buy a copy for themselves so i have no idea what this one isn't as popular as it is this one should be considered one of the best party games out there but again the people who play it really do enjoy it but the problem is not enough people know about it and not enough people are enjoying it and when
they should be because again this one could be a mega hit if only more people knew about it so that is good critters at number 10. at number nine i have cross clues which is another party style game um this for me this for me i'm completely blue code names out of the water so i know that's blasphemy for a lot of people i know code names is considered an absolute classic and in a lot of ways it is but i do have issues with code names mainly being there's a lot of downtime and it can really put people on the spot to think about a clue when they don't have the ability to do so and it can really draw the game to a halt this game completely fixes every single problem that i had with code names and just offers a better experience because of it this one's faster because you are playing in real time and you're also working cooperatively so you don't have that kind of toxic competitiveness that code names brings out in people but this is another simple word association game where you have a basically a grid and on one axis you have a bunch of words and the other axis you have a bunch of words then you're basically giving out clues and then hoping your teammates guess the right grid reference that you've that you've associated that word to and if they do you're going to put that thing down a card down with that grid reference on i'm going to keep going until the time runs out until um until the till the time runs out and then calculate who's or how many points you've got as a group this game is so quick it only takes about 10 minutes to play maximum and that's including the setup and you're just going to find yourself playing it again and again and again and it's another game that's so affordable it's attractive looking it's you can explain the rules in 30 seconds
and for me i don't understand why this one didn't take off to the level of code names or didn't take off like games like just one did because this one is as good if not better than those games and i absolutely adore this one if you want to try something um you know another word association game one that's accessible you can teach it to anybody very fast and a lot of fun that is cross clues at number nine at number eight i have tumbletown which was actually designed by the same person who designed calico which did actually reach a quite high level of success but for some reason and it's baffling to me why tumble town didn't do the same it seems to have so many things going on to it which a lot of people enjoy such as building a little town and dice rolling and it kind of combines those two in a very nice way so this one each time you're rolling a bunch of dice and then you are basically allocating them to these different formations to make these buildings so you're actually physically stacking dice on top of each other but when you're building these buildings they need certain kind of restrictions or criteria you need to build them so some might say the total value needs to go to above 15 or you need to have a consecutive row of numbers all these different things and the more you build these buildings the more mitigation you tools you have going on so some might say activate this building to re-roll again or activate this one to flip it over to the opposite side and it's a very satisfying game that actually has a quite a cool table presence which isn't just a gimmick so i love that you're actually building up a physical town of dice as the game goes on again i have no idea why this didn't take off i even think the name is good and it's very marketable i think maybe the only issue that worked against this
one is the artwork isn't as good as it could have been you know it does feel like a little bit prototypeish but the gameplay is very well um designed it's it's smooth it's polished and refined but again it just doesn't have that visual appeal that it should have because it's so family friendly and again i've not had a bad game of this one it's just an absolute travesty while this one didn't blow up and i think maybe as time goes on the designer or the publisher might re-look at reskinning this one or giving it a bit of a revamp to reach a whole new audience because like my words if you like family weight games you like dice you like dice kind of mitigation and building things then tunnel town is a fantastic option that should have been a mega hit so that is tumble town at number eight and number seven i have free ride so free ride is a more kind of traditional train and route building style game which obviously this is a winning formula from the success of games like ticket to ride you know that game sold millions of copies uh for me free ride is the better game it's a slightly um slightly more sophisticated game it's slightly more advanced but not that much more advanced because there's only like three rules in this game or like three actions you can take um so very easy to digest but the decision space is there in this game and that those kind of games are very accessible but they give you that extra hope to keep coming back to it to try and refine your skills and improve upon your previous plays this one you are simply trying to build up these roots of track all across europe and then move your train along the track
to visit different locations um however when you build a track it belongs to you um so you can travel along it for free but when you when somebody else uses your track they have to pay you a coin to do so and playing those coins is a big factor because money is very tight in this game so i love the elegance of this game there is no convolution at all as simple as it gets i think the box artwork although i think it's very attractive it does look good it kind of appeals to or it looks like it's marked towards an older audience rather than again those family market or they get that gateway to lighter style games whereas maybe if it did have a more cartoony look to it maybe more people would have you know looked at this one twice maybe thought about picking this one up but this one i've heard next to no buzz on it was one of my favorite games from last year and still nobody's talking about it maybe this one is going to be a slow burner who knows you know it's designed by friedman freeze who i think is a fantastic designer um so again i've got no issues with this game at all in terms of the rules trains are popular um you know geography's popular this game did have a couple of production issues as well where things weren't color coded so you just spend a lot of time looking for cities but they're easy fixers and the gameplay easily transcends that and another game that should be huge and should be talked about and should be hitting everybody's tables very regularly but it just is not and i can't understand why even got a good name um that's free ride by freedom and freeze at number six i have sheen at the terracotta army so this one is on this
list for a different reason so this one is a more euro style game a more strategy style game but it is that medium lightweight and for me this is where a lot of people a lot of gamers seem to hit that glass ceiling and don't want to go any further and try multiple more kind of involve difficult games which again perfectly fine but i always find that people always go towards the same games it's always loads of water deep it's always stone age on games like that and they've been kind of the the infamous gateway style games for a long long time and they've really cemented their legacy in being that for me xi'an is a hell of a lot better than those other games it's more interesting there's some really cool card play in this game as you have to pair cards up one of which is going to be your initiative and one's going to be the action and there's some work replacement as well that work placement is extremely tight so you want to be having that really fast initiative but if you use the fast initiative you are forsaking a strong action and the idea is you're trying to collect these resources as with a lot of resource management games but then you're building these terracotta statues on this grid for area control so this is like a perfect game to introduce a whole wide array of mechanisms that you'll see time and time again in board games and this one just drip feeds them in a very accessible and digestible way and it's even got an interesting theme you know the idea of these terracotta terracotta armies i think is a fascinating subject um but again this one just did not take off and i i just i think that's such a shame because this is like such a refined game it's so interesting and this one could
eat or i could easily see this one being a staple of so many different people's collection just like laws of water deepers and just like stone ages again this one should be in that place because it is the better game it's fast it's fun it even like offers different strategies each time you play it because you're gonna get those cars in a different order and you can even unlock powers and things and despite sounding like there's a lot going on here it is just as i said drip fed to you so you can easily understand and explain this to gamers of all different experiences and um it's a fantastic game and um again if it appeals to you go take a look at it because it is that good and it should be in in your collection if you do have an audience or a game group that does really lean towards those gateway plus level style games that is xi'an the terracotta army at number five i have juicy fruits so juicy fruit is actually probably my least favorite game on the list but despite that i think it should have reached a much higher level of success because it has so many things going on here that people tend to like at least for my observations so this is a pretty simple resource management game but the resources in this game are fruit very nice looking components they're bright and vibrant looking board very family friendly but the cool thing about this game is that it uses this sliding scale puzzle mechanism i've never seen before you know when you are have these different resource tokens and you have a grid in front of you and you're basically sliding these tokens along and the number of spaces you move along is how many resources you get so you're kind of moving things out the way so you get more resources more efficiently and even unlocking things on your map as you go to give you more space to move around in
that for me is a completely unexplored mechanism and juicy fruits used it very well it did tailor itself towards again that lighter style audience and more family friendly and i think it lends itself well to that because the rest of it is simply just fulfilled contracts and things and there was even a slightly um more advanced variant if you wanted to play with maybe older kids or again if you want a lighter game experience just to add a little twist on the game to make it a bit more interesting but again visually this game is very attractive um it has those novelty components where they're nice and tactile and chunky in your hands those things tend to normally be successors and do well and increase sales for games but the gameplay here as well in its own regard was very strong i know this one's only a year or two old and maybe still has some time to blow up and gain some popularity but you would have thought it would have would have achieved it by now considering how quickly some other games get popular you know talking about games like um cascadia you know it didn't take that one very long at all to blow up why didn't that happen to juicy fruits i'm not quite sure so that is juicy fruits at number five and number four i have ship shape which is a very fun puzzly style game with some simultaneous card selection and this one you are trying to build up this puzzle and you're going to do that by placing these tiles and these tiles are going to overlap each other however all these tiles are unique and will have different little jagged bits sticking out which will cover up other things or reveal certain things and the idea is that you're trying to kind of reveal or expose as much of this gold as you can because gold's going to be victory points you're trying to get these
cannons and you're going to score in relation to how many cannons you have in in compared to your opponents and also contraband where if you have the most contraband you scored nothing but if you have anything other than the most you score the amount of points of contraband on there and you're gonna be flipping and rotating to do the best you can um and that for me is satisfying enough as it is i think that's such a cool mechanism i find this one addictive in a way where you constantly trying to map things out as quickly as you can even trying to cover up these rat symbols which will um score you negative points so again i love that tactile puzzle and i find it very engaging and it also has some cool simultaneous selection where you have an identical set of cards to your opponents and each round you're going to be revealing a card and whoever's got the highest number will draft from the basically the stack of tiles first so if you really want this this tile on the top then you're going to have to play your number 10 but maybe give that up for later when you might want to use it again but if you tie the same number with somebody else they cancel each other out and then the next person who put the highest will take the highest title so you need to have that little bit of mind games and getting into your opponent's head um as well so i do like that but yeah a pirate theme you know pirates tend to be popular very nice artwork i'm even a good designer in rob davio um and even a small pox as well it's affordable so many things going on in this game's favor nobody plays it i have no idea why they should be this game is fantastic that is ship shape at number four at number three i have rumble nation which i think is a bit of an anomaly for this list because i think maybe the reasons
this game isn't popular or not as popular as it should be is due to reasons that aren't the game's fault so it's i think there's some supply chain issues and there's not been widely available in the kind of um in the western world as much as it is in say japan or something um but by god this game should be this is such a versatile game it's an area control style game where you're using dice to deploy cubes onto this map and you do that by rolling three dice and then you separate them into a pair and a singular the pair is going to show the reason you can put in your cubes into and the singular die is going to show how many cubes can go in it that is pretty much the extent of the game you're going to keep doing that until you spend all your cubes and then resolve each of these regions in numerical order however when you resolve a location the winner is not only going to get the most amount of points but they're also going to kind of chain reaction out these white cubes to bolster your surrounding regions and that has such a cool thread of strategy to the game where you can almost predict what's going to happen should you win certain regions but i think the thing i love most about this game is the experience it offers you know it has a lot of tactical decisions it has strategy it's simple you know you can explain this in a minute but the fact this one plays in 30 minutes is remarkable for me i've not really seen an area control style game be this rich and engaging for that time frame you know you're normally talking an hour and a half to two hours for a good area control game this one achieves it to that to a high standard in 30 minutes which again a massive massive success um it's attractive it's bright
it's vibrant it's another example of a game with a cool name i think rumble nation sounds great and more people should be talking about it but sadly people are going to have to kind of import this one from further afield if you want to get a copy of it but i really hope something has worked out where a big successful and publisher in the states or in the uk have picked this one up and can distribute it out and remarket it and get it into more people's tables and because the game is that good and i know for a fact that people will love this game if they only knew about it and if they had it on their tables and could play it themselves um but it's not happening at this point this game is like five years old now and still nobody knows about it which is just a crying shame that is rumble nation at number three at number two i have my farm shop so this game is very similar to games such as space base and machu koro which were both remarkably successful you know sold a lot of copies and if you're watching this video i'm sure you've heard of both of those games but you might not have heard of my farm shop but despite that my farmer drop is by far the best of the three it's not even close yet it still doesn't divert away too far from that simple dice rolling system where you're building up a display of cards you're rolling dice and then you're activating the cards that those dice pips relate to and this one you're just collecting these different kind of farm resources and your eggs and your i think it's like woolen stuff and you're basically trying to convert those into points using other um other cards so you are really building up this tight engine of
cards you have some mitigation in this game as well which you don't have in these other ones so you have these sacks where you can actually choose to you know manipulate the dice up or down by the pit values so it gives you more control to activate the cards you want but again it doesn't make it too convoluted and kind of steer away from the target audience who will be enjoying this one um but i just think this game is so satisfying it plays in about 30 to 45 minutes it's got a good degree of resource management because of you know how you're going to manage those resources and convert them into points but you also have a capacity of goods you can keep so you can't just keep spamming the same action because it's going to be wasteful and you're not going to have the room to store the goods in the first place so i think a big factor that came into play hurting this game's success is the way the box looks now the box after this game is absolutely horrible it looks like this cheap phone app that's going to give you a virus um where if it had a more inviting theme um that didn't look so synthetic and cheap and nasty really then this one game could have really taken off because the gameplay isn't that good again it's already a already a successful formula people love rolling dice people love collecting resources as proven by matchy coro and um and space base but for me those games have glass ceilings there's only so many times you can play them because there's not much to them my farm shop offers that extra wrinkle or two but still remaining simple remaining inviting you know everything but that box cover is great just it's a shame that happened um because this game is so good it's one of my favorite family games if not my favorite family game of all time that is
my farm shop and finally at number one i have me abbey so miyabi for me is probably actually the most successful game out of these ones but despite that this game should be you know 100 times more successful this for me i have no idea why this one hasn't taken off as well as it should have this game is unbelievably good it has so many things that people like it has polyominos it has stacking it has drafting and it has some really cool restrictions as well to make it unique where you can only ever place certain tiles in certain columns but when you do that you cannot place somewhere that somewhere in that column again and this game also does a fantastic job of making it tailorable to your own needs so you can play the very basic rules or you can start drip feeding in these more little advanced rules to put little twists on them and maybe for an hour on you're going to score your empty spaces or you're going to score for your biggest connected region of um of of symbols where that normally would be the case so depending on who you play this with you can really tinker that game to what you want and i love that and it doesn't even take away from the game so there's no real optimal way to play the game every single version of the game is optimal in my opinion but the actual table presence of this game is great because you are not only scoring points by placing things kind of on a flat level but also for building them on other levels as well where you get a bigger multiplier so it hits kind of that niche of offering all those dopamine hits where you get a big chunk of points and laying these foundations to put tiles higher and higher and higher and it's it's attractive it's bright it's simple looking and another
game you can teach in one minute but you would happily play this one 50 to 100 times without getting bored of it it is that good and you know michael kiesling is one of the best designers ever and this one i think is probably his uh my favorite design of his and again i know this is a game where anybody who has played this one thinks it's remarkable but not that many people know about it um so that is miyabi a definite definite number one and this is the first game i thought of when i thought of this list check this one out if you love tile placement again you love polyaminos you love puzzly style games and you love restrictions and you also like games that don't have too many rules brilliant design that is me abby at number one so there we have it we have 10 games there that should have been mega hits but were not you know there's still time for these games and who knows i could be proven wrong down the road but that's how i feel about this game so as i said at the beginning of the video i don't have any um strict data on these games i don't know how many copies they've sold but i'm pretty sure they haven't done as well as maybe they would have hoped for um but i would be really interested if you leave a comment below explaining what game sport you think should have been mega hits or you would have thought might have been mega hits had only things been a little bit different i'll be really interested to know um if you enjoyed the video please be sure to hit like and subscribe to my channel and check out my other content too but for everybody else i'll see you next time on chairman of the board bye now