Skip to main content
Loading video...

Is Winning in Board Games Important? Featuring Surprise Guests - Stella's Tabletop Diary

Transcript 20:54

winning in board games is it important is it not coming up hi it's turned and Stella from University welcome to my tabletop diary this week we have covered different flow because we have a questions which you at home can definitely participate in answer and we are also bringing different people in boredom industries even our friends to talk about weather waiting in board games is important or not and why so at any time please feel free to run the comment sections below to say and share your opinion whether it's important or not so before we get to our friends let's discuss this briefly who is winning in board games important to us I was gonna ask you first okay winning in and of itself is not important to me but I do derive my enjoyment for excluding party games yeah for for a heavier game my enjoyment definitely derives from attending to win I think

that other people's enjoyment also derive from somebody else's attempting to win if you know not like oh my god you know it's not like I have to win sort of attitude but like if you already have like no I don't care about this I don't care about that you know do whatever I know it's not really making other people's games enjoyable as well yeah I know that and I know that if I'm playing a game and I fallen behind early and I can see it I tend not to enjoy the rest of the game because if I'm a long way behind and I know that last is the position I'm going to come in I can't even fight a second at that point yeah that will kind of dampen a game so I think the the capability to win is important very serious about it very good yeah but if it comes to the end and the scores are counted up and it's close and I've come second or if I fall into third cuz it just didn't quite come to pass that's fine okay happily look back at what went wrong do me first game well everyone switching magnets for his game suppose you came second well I'm lucky well I mean and it will sound bitter cuz I'll remember the I'll remember the really heavy losses because they will not bad my bad experiences yes it will sound like I'm bitter but yeah essentially as long as as long as I'm in the hunt to win or even yeah

in the hunt to come second because someone's already gone miles ahead it's fine I'll enjoy that yeah if I know that it's all over early on that's all I don't like same thing with me I mean winning is not everything but attempting to e brings enjoyment to other people well cooperative games sniffing right you trying to win whatever this is why I like cooperative game most cooperative games because you win together with your friends there's no losers or we lose together so in a way we're doing it together um no it's not there's not that important so I mean game mechanics I think the face-to-face interactions the social interaction the chance to meet your life partner that's how I met Tarrant by the way if you don't know that so no it's not about winning it's about playing with other people playing games that you like I'd rather be loosing and playing my favorite game then winning and playing the game so or not I don't particularly like as well so um I mean I know that some like people are different like it's just like just so general Hughes of winning and not all of you who has got the same opinion it's us and if but I'm pitching games it's hard to like I have to keep track of everything I can't really multitask that well despite of people think that women multitask well maybe I don't know I don't think I'm not it thought that well but I think think about like I have to run the game Peron what did you say the audience so I have to come like run the

game so have a look at other people's like they would have they would have questions so I have to make sure that everything is doing things correctly you're not always because I don't also have the focus on my own games then you know I don't really care if people people enjoying themselves then that's fine so with that we have asked several people to share their opinions of billion board games important or not starting with our friends are usually group of friends which we have played a lot of games together join them hi we're friends of seller and Taryn and they asked us to make a quick video about how we feel about a certain question is winning important board games and why hmm so for us we play a lot of board games together and we play with friends and we find that if you're just to focus on winning a lot of times people don't tend to enjoy the whole interaction and situation I agree I only add the one I'm the one who's trying to explain games and stuff and some people's enjoyment is the most important if I find someone who's you know wanting to we know their mind then you know it takes away the fun out of the other people's participation so you know Brooke was pretty good I don't think we have awful company competitive

people know everyone's generally really focused and on the game and the mechanics of the game and just kind of enjoying each other's company and just being around each other rather than being focused on meaning so but yeah that's how Vanessa

hi I'm Karla from where draft games um winning isn't too important to me um I play games for a lot of different reasons mainly to socialize to learn more about games and just to try to do better um I really like to do like if I'm playing a game a second time I'd really love to do a little bit better than I did before um and I much rather try out a new strategy I wouldn't play a game over again and lose then to do the same thing I've done before and win often I'm the only female at the gaming table it can be pretty intimidating I'm thinking these guys look like pretty seasoned gamers like heavy euro kind of guys aren't they just gonna smash me because I play casually in all seriousness some of my favourite gaming memories are of winning but more often than not I don't remember who did win remember losing well is a skill and if you play off it enough you're probably gonna level up in that skill and if you're like me you're probably gonna multi-class so for me I love the winning I can take the losing and I really just love to play the game

hey folks mark here so this topic is interesting you're right because the thing is how do I feel about winning in games you know I used to be super important to me and I'm still am I'm pretty competitive but these days I'm more about the experience I love cooperative game for instance where everybody's around the table everyone's engaged everyone's actively participating that's way more fun to me than a big heavy thinkI game where everyone's focused on their boards and there's hardly any interaction going on I feel like I'll just play a video game if I want a solo experience like that I want an experience where everyone is engaged everyone's having fun everyone's laughing and it's just a memorable night and I'll say that I would suggest to you that I've had way more memorable fun moments in losing than I have in winning so that's pretty interesting as well and because of the way I do videos these day four dice tower previews and such I find that I my game style is changing where I'm playing just so I can try all the things and maybe not just putting together the best optimal path but I just want to try all the different things that are available in the game and so I've also when I'm playing for fun I find that I'm gravitating more and more towards that more of this experience you'll type gaming I would say I find that way more interesting

than being all gung-ho about winning you know it like said it's it's fun to win but I would prefer to have a game night where everyone is just actively having a blast and engaged so there you have it that's my two cents and until next time folks we'll see you at the table

all right things are having this on your show Stella we very much enjoy talking about these types of things in fact if you're not familiar with our tantrum talks segment once most on YouTube we get together and talk about things very similar to this if you're not familiar with change for house at all check us out at inter mouse comm we've got all kinds of cool media stuff that we make what do you think is the answer to the question is winning important in board games I think it is but I think my opinion has changed over time I think in the very beginning it was crucial to win and I think there are very specific instances where I am deeply involved in the game emotionally as well and then it matters if I win and then there's other times where the game is enjoyable enough that it doesn't matter as much I'm enjoying the gameplay whether or not I win yep and that's my personality is that I'm here for the party I'm here for the friends I'm here for the fun the board game is just the kind of the venue for an excuse to be able to do that but I do agree I think that the very definition of a game it requires competition while cooperative games are cooperative you're still like trying to beat a high score or the system or something almost always and I think there's a big difference between like sitting down to build a puzzle or do an activity and for whatever reason those don't seem to generate the memories and the emotional responses that you get when you play games so I definitely do think winning is important in playing

games hello eful university this is Tim Vernick brand ambassador for thunder works games and Vince Lombardi the famous coach of the Green Bay Packers from my home state of Wisconsin has a quote that says winning isn't everything it's the only thing and as far as I'm concerned about hobby board gaming that's not true for me I love playing games and winning isn't the reason that I play I mean I like winning as much as the next person but it isn't the reason that I play games I them to gather around the table with friends old and new and just enjoy myself and have the camaraderie of playing a game and chatting enjoying some snacks and if I win that's great and if someone else wins I'm just as happy for them as I would be if I want I guess that goes back to my background in playing role-playing games when I was a student playing those games together telling a story together that was really the the main purpose of the playing those games and so I really enjoyed that and that's why I'm so excited about our new title role player adventure is sitting Kickstarter June 23rd because that will be a cooperative game where players can play together to try to share resources and try to tell a story and beat the

monsters and be successful through the campaign so we're really excited about that so again for me winning it's really just about playing the game thanks hi my name is Monique I'm Naveen from a channel called before you play and today we're gonna ask the question and answer the question is winning and board games important to you ah hmm kind of kind of usually not I'm gonna airline decided I'm erring on the side of no especially if it's like the first time I played a game or if I'm playing like a party game or just like a like a lighter game no definitely not I really really don't mind that okay this is fun but in games where I've played a lot maybe like my favorite games are like heavier and longer especially then it would be nice to win but it's not integral how about you I think it matters more so than it doesn't matter for some reason there's something about winning a game and knowing that you out maneuvered your opponents that is really really fun that stuff that's a game within the game itself for me it's true you know that faction of crushing especially in the heavier games of course it's always good I do like winning by close margins though oh you don't like crushing no no I'm just yeah I like to see where like at the very end we're like ooh two points for a snake yeah just final between any decision there that I do like that part and I also I hate losing at two rooms in a

boom can't leave that yeah hate it and I'm always on the losing end of that because I can't figure it out well always in different rooms so I always win you know we play 1v1 - indigo yeah cool thank you his winning board games important to me yes but let me throw a couple of caveats on to them if me winning the board game and the way in which I win it would be detrimental to the fun everyone else is having at the table or some individuals or one individual is having at the table and no winning isn't that important to me it comes back to why I play games in the first place I play games that bring my friends together and to share the experience and enjoy your Bullock's fit if playing in a particular way and eking out a victory dragging our game means that the level of fun the level of enjoyment the table is going down and that's not why I'm doing this that's not why I've brought friends together all that's not why I'm there so yes I will always Buy and win but I'll always be mindful of is that goal increasingly

enjoyment at the table or is it decreasing it hopefully it's increasing it and even that case yes a hundred percent along where he's trying win but I usually lose hi Stella thank you for including me the question is is winning at board games important to me and why there's kind of a I'm kind of two minds with this I don't think winning is important yet I like to win I'm competitive so I kind of have a weird dual nature with this question I played competitively Pro Magic for five years when I was a kid my dad put me into a bunch of chess tournaments and I played nah I mean yeah I was competitive so the competition I care about like I try to win on social party games sometimes I don't care about running I'm just interacting having fun but with strategy games I often become very focused and I try to win so I clearly care about winning even though if you ask me intellectually I don't think winning is important I think I don't think it says anything about someone being smarter I don't think it's you know I don't think it's necessarily a trait that should be respected I

supposed to like treating people well which is very important and yet I care for some reason so there you have it I've done I'm of two minds I'm not sure why hi my name is Dan van Kelly and I do with you know enemies here war game news news and so star like you know when one of our brainy ideas writes to me and says hey you want to do some video you know waste your time a little bit then tell me you know I feel like if winning at board games is important to you well stuff okay let's play you think I'm gonna turn out like that okay one successful winner oh how about that guy Dan sounds like one of my goombazz from New York that guy that guy's a winner huh he's got a place in my heart you know why cuz she's got that fighter in his eyes he cuts her loose because mr. bonocore the Prez is such a tough guy you know he can even turn a guy like me and because of you I'm gonna give this a shot no General Patton comes

to mind and he said once no man ever won a war dying for his country a man wins a war by letting the other guy die for their country man God hath mercy on my enemies cuz I sure won't sir that was a that was then that was then the last one but hopefully you enjoy all the other friends opinion see there's different opinions you know you are allowed to have different opinions where winning is important or whether you just want to play around with it so again I really like to hear your thoughts about this this from the comment sections below if you have anything that you'd like to suggest to us to discuss like this one also please write in the comment sections below Karen do you have anything else that you'd like to say I usually just blabbering around and closed in there just agreeing with me busy so yes so as usual also please hit like button if you've been enjoying this and subscribe to us if you haven't already done so you can also hit the middle in the corner and hit the bell if you want so that you get notification from us and if you're on social media like Instagram find me dead people underscore University and I do put your photos reviews there as well so hopefully enjoy this and I'll see you next time bye

Progress saved