Catacombs (Third Edition) Deep Dive
What the Community Thinks About Catacombs (Third Edition)
Reviewers describe Catacombs (Third Edition) as a dexterity game first and a dungeon crawl second, and most agree that the two halves fit together better than they sound on paper. Foster the Meeple approached the idea of a flicking dungeon crawl with doubt about whether it could work, then described the finished experience as chaotic in a good way. BoardGameBollocks placed the game fourth on a list of dungeon crawling games, praising the dexterity core while acknowledging that some of the iconography takes effort to learn. Grant, Grant's Gamerecks, included it among unusual board games and stressed that it is neither a family dexterity game nor a party game, but a mediumweight title with considerable depth beneath the flicking.
Agreement is strongest on the premise and the presentation. Reviewers consistently point to the layered theme, the artwork, and the physical satisfaction of the flick as strengths. Disagreement tends to center on the learning curve and on the one-versus-many arrangement, which some reviewers accept with a shrug and others would prefer to avoid. The broader consensus is that Catacombs (Third Edition) rewards players willing to invest a few sessions before judging it.
Core Mechanics That Define Catacombs (Third Edition)
Dungeon Crawl
Catacombs organizes its dungeon crawl as a progression through rooms. Heroes move from room to room, and each room brings harder monsters and different rules as the group pushes toward a final boss. Foster the Meeple highlighted the asymmetry of the heroes, noting that a ranger carries a bow and smaller arrow discs that get flicked around the board, so each character plays differently. BoardGameBollocks described the same arc, with the heroes working through the levels of the dungeon until they reach the big bad boss at the end. Reviewers see this structure as what turns a dexterity game into a campaign-style adventure. Players gather loot and gold from defeated monsters, which fits the explore, fight, and loot loop that defines the genre.
Flicking Discs as Combat
Combat in Catacombs is resolved entirely by flicking. Characters and monsters are represented by discs, and contact with an opposing piece inflicts damage. BoardGameBollocks noted that many characters carry weapons with their own small discs, which can be flicked as missiles, and that a successful hit does damage to the target. Foster the Meeple described how each disc performs a different function, so the player controlling the monsters can send out a varied army and watch the board fill with obstacles. Reviewers agree that those obstacles, combined with the physical skill of the flick, make every attack feel uncertain in a way that a simple flicking game does not.
The Catacombs (Third Edition) Experience
Controlled Chaos
Reviewers describe the table as busy, loud, and unpredictable. Foster the Meeple said that the flicking dungeon seemed unlikely to work and then worked anyway, producing a play experience that felt chaotic but enjoyable. Much of that disorder comes from discs bouncing off obstacles and from the gap between technique and outcome, since a player can have excellent flicking skill and still lose a disc to a badly placed wall. The result is less a feeling of losing control than a feeling that the physical mechanics keep the outcome open until the last flick.
Playing the Villain
For the player who runs the monsters, the Overseer role is a large part of the appeal. Foster the Meeple said they like to play the villain, sending out flicked minions that each do something different and building a board of threats over the course of a session. That role carries steady tension. The monsters must pressure the heroes without being cleared out too quickly, while the heroes must push through to the boss, since the Overseer wins if the heroes are all defeated. Grant described the game as mostly a one-versus-many experience, with one person controlling the bad guys while the rest of the table works together against them, which gives the session a campaign-like momentum.
What Makes Catacombs (Third Edition) Stand Out
A Dexterity Game With Real Dungeon Structure
The feature reviewers praise most is the way a dexterity core supports a dungeon adventure. Foster the Meeple said they had played a great many dexterity games, but that Catacombs was the first to feel unique enough to build an entire game around the flicking mechanic, rather than flicking toward a target for points. Grant noted having never seen another game of this kind, calling it a dexterity dungeon crawl in which the fighting, challenges, and special abilities all happen through flicked discs. That combination is what reviewers return to when explaining why the game stands apart from other dexterity titles.
Theme, Artwork, and Components
The presentation earns frequent praise. BoardGameBollocks described the third edition artwork as fantastic and said the designer has layered theme onto the flicking in a way that is astonishing. Grant pointed to the size of the box and the variety of playmats, each with its own levels and challenges, as a reason the dungeon feels fresh from one session to the next. Reviewers also note that the game can be expanded in several directions, including by combining it with Catacombs and Castles, which gives players a route to a much larger setup over time.
Potential Drawbacks
Iconography and the Learning Curve
The most consistent criticism is the iconography. BoardGameBollocks observed that some symbols can be confusing, and that players have struggled to remember what the different icons mean, which can bog the game down. The reviewer framed this as a hurdle that players can overcome with perseverance rather than a fatal flaw. Grant made a similar point, suggesting that new players will likely need to look things up during the first game or two because of the range of special abilities and edge cases. Groups planning to teach the game should expect a slower start than the box might suggest.
The One-Versus-Many Structure
Catacombs (Third Edition) is built around one player controlling the monsters against everyone else, and reviewers accept that trade-off with varying degrees of comfort. BoardGameBollocks described it as a one-versus-all arrangement but said the dexterity elements made the structure easy to forgive. Grant characterized the game as mostly a one-versus-many experience. Groups that want every player working on the same side from start to finish may find this format less appealing.
If You Enjoy Catacombs (Third Edition)
Players who enjoy the flicking combat in Catacombs (Third Edition) will find related satisfaction in Crokinole, which shares the physical, disc-based skill at the heart of the game. Players who are drawn to the dungeon side of the design may want to try Dungeon Fighters, a title Foster the Meeple brought up as a dexterity and dungeon game with a very different feel, built around throwing dice in unusual ways while fighting monsters. Those who want to extend the dungeon can explore Catacombs and Castles, which BoardGameBollocks noted can be loaded in alongside Catacombs (Third Edition) for a larger setup. Fans who want more of the same world can also look at Catacombs Conquest, the related title in the Catacombs line.
What Reviewers Are Saying
"It's a very novel game, it's just flicking discs, right, but the way that the designer has added layer and layer theme onto this is nothing more than astonishing. It looks absolutely fantastic, the artwork in the third edition is fantastic."
— BoardGameBollocks
"And it is very dungeon crawly. Like you will be fighting bad guys, you will be trying to overcome challenges, but you are going to be doing that by flicking discs around the board."
— Grant, Grant's Gamerecks
"We've played a ton of dexterity games up until when we played this, but this is the first one that really felt like it was unique enough that put a game around that mechanic, as opposed to just flicking close to a certain thing to score a victory point."
— Foster the Meeple