La Cosa Nostra Deep Dive
What the Community Thinks About La Cosa Nostra
Reviewers who have played La Cosa Nostra describe a mafia negotiation game that is willing to be ugly, and they treat that ugliness as part of its appeal. In a tour of John Perkis's board game shelves on the Actualol channel, Perkis introduces it as a game where you are "playing like mafia people," and where it is "cutthroat" and "really quite mean." Perkis follows that immediately with "but it's really fun," and calls the game "completely underrated" and "under the radar."
A later countdown video from the same channel places La Cosa Nostra at number thirteen on Perkis's list of favorite games of 2017. The reviewer notes that the game first appeared in German, reached English that year after a Kickstarter campaign the reviewer backed, and stands out for taking its subject seriously.
Core Mechanics That Define La Cosa Nostra
Job Cards and Declared Targets
Perkis describes a "quite simple system" built around job cards that players try to complete each round to earn money. A player might sell drugs through a nightclub, or might turn on another player and attack them. The timing of an attack is the key detail. The attacker must name the target before the card is flipped, so the table hears the threat before anyone knows what the card will do. That gap gives players room to bluff, and to offer protection in exchange for cash while the card remains face down. Perkis points to this moment as the point where "there's so much potential for negotiation."
Shared Buildings and Negotiated Access
Businesses are not locked to their owners. In the countdown video, the reviewer explains that if another family needs to sell drugs, they can come and use the reviewer's nightclub, but the owner will want money for that access. That single rule turns every business on the table into a bargaining chip. Players are constantly pricing favors, deciding who to help and who to squeeze, and the deals they strike shape the rest of the round. The reviewer calls it "one of those perfect negotiation games where money is flying around all the time."
The La Cosa Nostra Experience
Cutthroat
The tone is set plainly in the house tour, where Perkis describes La Cosa Nostra as cutthroat and "really quite mean," and places it alongside Sons of Anarchy and Spartacus among the big negotiation games Perkis loves but rarely gets to play, since mean games are hard to find people willing to sit down for. Taking from other players, extorting them, and turning on them is part of the premise. The countdown review frames that aggression as the logical behavior of the setting, observing that this is "what mafia people do" and "how TV and film would treat it."
Social and Interactive
The countdown review is the clearest statement of how the game feels at the table. The reviewer says what they love about these games is that "you spend most of the game just talking with each other." The house tour makes a related argument, calling negotiation games "so interactive" and "so social" and saying they create "such interesting moments." In La Cosa Nostra, conversation is not decoration around the game. Money, threats, and favors move as the talk evolves, so what other players do directly reshapes your plans from one turn to the next.
What Makes La Cosa Nostra Stand Out
A Theme Taken Seriously
The countdown review's strongest praise is for the theme. The reviewer says the game "takes the theme seriously," describing a dark adult setting in which players sell drugs and do terrible things, and argues that this is how crime fiction would portray such people. Many games soften their subject matter, so the reviewer's appreciation of a design that does not flinch is a distinctive point in its favor. The house tour echoes this, presenting the game as a thematic experience rather than a set of abstract tasks.
A German Design That Breaks the Mold
Perkis is surprised that a game this thematic and interactive comes out of Germany, which Perkis associates with "the dry euro thing." That contrast is part of the appeal. The house tour notes that La Cosa Nostra shares a designer with Micro Macro: Crime City, which the reviewer calls "completely different." For a reviewer who keeps games that do something unusual, that contrast is a large part of why La Cosa Nostra earns its place on the shelf.
Potential Drawbacks
Harsh Play Can Sour Some Groups
The reviewers' enthusiasm comes with a clear caveat. The game is "really quite mean," and the house tour acknowledges that "some people can really dislike" negotiation games in general. For groups that prefer cooperation, gentle banter, or a lighter touch, La Cosa Nostra's aggression may be the reason they walk away rather than the reason they return.
A Long Session for Only Four Rounds
The countdown review points out that the game plays only four rounds, yet "still lasts two or three hours." That runtime is the cost of a game built on conversation. The countdown review also notes that negotiation games tend to be long, which is why the reviewer doesn't play them as often as they would like. Players looking for a quick evening will find that length hard to justify, even if they enjoy the talking.
If You Enjoy La Cosa Nostra
The reviewers' own comparisons offer the clearest starting points. Sons of Anarchy and Spartacus are the big, mean negotiation games Perkis names in the house tour, describing them as the kind of experience Perkis loves. Lords of Vegas, which the reviewer calls a "brilliant negotiation game about setting up casinos," is another strong pick for players who enjoy building and bargaining over a shared business landscape.
For a game with a more political edge, New Angeles casts players as corporations exploiting a future city, where pushing too far risks a revolt. Hidden objectives and a traitor add a second layer of deception, and the reviewer, who discusses it in both videos, argues that it "just got no love" despite being a rich negotiation game. Players who want the same mix of betrayal and deal-making with a stronger political flavor may find it a natural next step after La Cosa Nostra.
What Reviewers Are Saying
"This is a negotiation game where you're playing like mafia people, and it's it's cutthroat. It's really quite mean, uh, but it's really fun."
— Actualol
"This is a crime negotiation game, you play as mafia bosses, and one of the first things I like about it is that it takes the theme seriously. This is dark adult theme, you are selling drugs and doing terrible things, and but that's what mafia people do and that's how TV and film would treat it."
— Actualol
"It's it's just got it's it's one of those perfect negotiation games where money is flying around all the time, and and that is that's what I love in those things, that you spend most of the game just talking with each other."
— Actualol