The Others Deep Dive
What the Community Thinks About The Others
Reviewers agree that The Others is mechanically sound but split on whether its theme earns the investment it asks for. John Peris, Actualol calls it a "beast of a game" with scenarios that can run around three hours, and Peris finds the core loop simple: heroes move and fight, while the depth comes from deciding whether to stick together and how far to push into dangerous districts. Peris praises the design as well constructed and balanced "in a way that thematic dice chuckers often aren't," yet Peris argues that the theme feels like an afterthought in both the rulebook and the gameplay.
Enthusiasm runs higher among those who played it in a convention setting. The Rolling Dice & Taking Names group, previewing the game at the Cool Mini or Not Expo, described it as a big, thematic co-op that rewards conversation. They noticed that the team realized over time how much strategy discussion mattered, and they found the experience tense because the city keeps deteriorating while players manage their corruption. Their verdict was clear: fun, thematic, and worth watching for later in the year.
The most critical voice comes from Board Games UnLocked, which ranks The Others fifth on a list of games the host no longer enjoys. The complaint is less about the core rules than about balance and pacing. The host says the sin player seems to pull punches during a first game, that the heroes never feel they have a real chance to stop the sin, and that the dice handling slows the game down. Taken together, the consensus is that the game plays well for players who enjoy its tension, while the theme and one-versus-many structure divide the table.
Core Mechanics That Define The Others
Dice Combat
Combat in The Others is resolved with dice, and the design by Eric Lang, published by Cool Mini or Not, makes that choice central to every fight. Reviewers describe the mechanism as a push and pull between rolling and the corruption track. Players can voluntarily raise their corruption before or during a fight to gain extra dice or automatic hits, which is the most tempting part of the system. Peris calls this "the cleverest part of the game," and warns that once a hero reaches the end of the track, every further point of corruption converts into wounds.
The community's experience of this mechanic is mixed. Peris and the Rolling Dice & Taking Names group both praise the decisions it creates, while Board Games UnLocked objects that the dice pools become a chore to count, roll, and sort, particularly when there are not enough dice in the box for most fights. Players who enjoy rolling and tallying will find the system engaging. Those who do not will find the bookkeeping gets in the way of the decisions the design wants them to make.
Scenario and Mission Play
The Others is organized into discrete scenarios, and the heroes move through a storyboard that works like a mission tree. Eric Lang explains in the Rolling Dice & Taking Names interview that the heroes "go from step to step" and sometimes make choices that change the path, while the sin player's goal is simply to eliminate the heroes. Peris highlights the seven scenarios in the base box, which Peris groups into corruption, redemption, and terror, saying those three types "feel like you're playing very different games," which gives the campaign material real variety before any expansion is needed.
The The Others Experience
Temptation and Tension
The clearest feeling reviewers describe is the pull of the corruption track. Players know the cost is coming, yet the bonuses are immediate and powerful, so they keep taking one more step. Rolling Dice & Taking Names describes a heroes' table that repeatedly took corruption it could not afford, watching its characters fall as a result. The emotional arc is one of gambling with a character you care about, and the group described the game as "tense" because every decision carries a visible price.
A Ticking Clock and a Doomed City
The second dominant feeling is pressure from the setting itself. The Rolling Dice & Taking Names group notes that the city "gets pretty gross" near the end, with fires and corruption spreading while the sin's powers unlock every turn, so the players feel they are racing a clock. Peris describes a similar drift, saying the heroes need to act quickly and coordinate closely. The result is a grim, cooperative atmosphere where the group is always one bad roll away from losing a character it has invested in.
What Makes The Others Stand Out
Miniatures and Presentation
Reviewers consistently praise the physical production. Peris describes the artwork and miniatures as "gorgeous" and "incredible," while the Rolling Dice & Taking Names group says the minis look amazing and wanted to paint them. Peris also notes that the box includes a large number of corrupted minis, although only one set is used in any given game, a design choice Peris finds generous and questionable in equal measure.
Scenario Variety
The second standout is the range of play that the base game provides. Peris points out two sin factions, three types of acolytes, and seven scenarios, which together give the game enough replayability to make the Kickstarter exclusives feel optional. Reviewers who go past the first session tend to find that the scenario type matters as much as the choice of sin, which keeps each table's experience distinct.
Potential Drawbacks
A Theme That Feels Bolted On
The most consistent criticism is that the theme does not match the mechanics. Peris argues that the rulebook opens with a screenplay instead of an introduction, that the monsters are made scary mainly by adding tentacles, and that the heroes feel like tokens on a track. Peris sums up the concern plainly: "you don't feel like you're saving anyone. You just feel like you're transporting a token from one place to another." Players who want story-driven play may find this the biggest obstacle.
Dice Load and Sin Balance
Board Games UnLocked raises the sharper concern. The host argues that the dice mechanism is not succinct, with so many dice that players spend their turns allocating and organizing results rather than making decisions. The same reviewer also doubts that the one-versus-many structure is balanced, since the sin player holds the dice advantage, a large minion pool, and special cards. The host's experience was that the sin player seemed to hold back, which suggests the balance depends heavily on the table.
If You Enjoy The Others
- Blood Rage: Players who enjoy The Others's corruption-driven risk taking will find a similar push and pull in Blood Rage. Peris notes that the two games play very differently, but both come from Cool Mini or Not, and both reward players who can plan around an aggressive, thematic engine.
- Zombicide: Rolling Dice & Taking Names pointed to Zombicide as one of the publisher's past hits. Players who like the cooperative tension of a group fighting a growing threat with miniatures will find a related satisfaction in that series.
- Kingdom Death: Monster: Board Games UnLocked describes a game built on fighting monsters over and over, with heavy miniature presentation and a grinding sense of long-term investment. Players who enjoy The Others's dark, sacrificial tone and its willingness to let characters fall will recognize some of the same appeal, though the reviewer found the grind far harsher.
What Reviewers Are Saying
"The cleverest part of the game is the corruption level. Every time you fight a monster, you can voluntarily raise your corruption to get extra dice or automatic hits. But if you reach the end of the track, every corruption you get afterwards counts as wounds."
— John Peris, Actualol
"It's a fun game, it's very thematic, it's tense, as you're trying to manage your corruption and people are dying, and you see there's a basically a clock ticking in the game that's going to make it harder and harder of a time."
— Rolling Dice & Taking Names
"I actually feel like that the dice mechanism in this game slows it down because it's not succinct. You have so much dice that you have to then roll and then basically allocate and organize on the different faces that are there."
— Board Games UnLocked