2018: Further Thoughts - The Broken Meeple
Transcript
everyone now I'm serious here this is the last video I am doing of season 2 . ok this is a lot last one I'm already turning through a lot of the lectures for Adobe Premiere Pro and stuff like that and I feel that even if I can't be an expert at it by the time I get season free going I think I can at least be proficient in it enough so that the next time I record videos I can do it on that software rather than Camtasia so maybe you will see the general quality improvement throughout season 3 as opposed to right smack at the start but I hope you'll at least get something out of it so you know that's all coming I'm still trying to find the time to learn it but yesterday I went for a turn of those lectures learning through it and you to me does do some pretty good courses on the subject so we'll get onto that but yep this will be the last video of season 2 and this is a bonus video that I wanted to get out before Christmas I literally I'm doing this on Christmas Eve so um before I go home to Somerset and that is I want to talk a bit more about 2018 I already did my top 10 list and but I mean it's blowing my mind how popular it is at the moment it's already at something like eight and a half thousand views and I only put it up two days ago it's insane you know thank you for watching it and thank you for all the comments on it you know whether you disagree or agree with the choices I love the debates that are going on such good comments but I wanted to talk more about 2018 as a whole because then generally I liked the year yeah I thought 2017 was a bit of a letdown there was some decent games there but most of them were just kind of yeah they're okay they're a bit meh you know
and then there was some overrated Stefon of gloom Haven and all that lot so I didn't really go for 2017 that much 2018 I thought did a better job of giving me a decent amount of good games rather than just me in average but that's not to say that this one wasn't full of a few overrated disappointing or cash-grab titles as well so the problem with there are hobby at the moment is that we're just getting flooded and flooded with so many games right now and it's impossible to a play them all and be certain decent games are getting lost underneath the flood of all these other games that come out just because they're hyped up to my crazy levels or because they just happen to get publicized more you know what's the word advertise better and you know they get to the forefront and some of them don't deserve to be at the forefront so I'm just basically I don't have an official award I can give up two games I mean I'd love to get that in the future you know patreon campaign come on but I'd certainly would love to be able to do that in a future but now this is completely unofficial I'm just giving out my personal choices for various categories like the diced our awards do and various other people so I've just been filling out notes on it over the last couple of days and you know I've been thinking about those surprises the point disappointments innovation artwork good and bad production good and bad cash grab as a category for mine to player only worst game of the year format it game overrated game reprint family game you know I've come up with quite a few in fact the only major category I don't think I've done is
party and that's only because I never really got to play a lot of party games this year which is a bit of a shame really I mean I picked a crypto and one other I think apart from that there's a few party games I want to play but they've just never came on sale where I could find them I mean I want to play just one that sounds like a great party game but never got a chance to and I've heard of other ones throughout the year and it's just for some reason party games just don't seem to get a lot of buzz or get released in UK much so it's kind of weird but I miss a good party game I really do like them so I say I'm no particular order I'm just gonna go from top to bottom in this list then just go through the categories and give you a couple of honorable mentions and just tell you what my favorite is and that's kind of all I'm doing here
let's start with a good positive one is my favorite family game of the year so when I think a family game I needed to a be accessible to families B be appealing to families that includes children as well but doesn't have to be a kids game adults should want to play this game as well but of course you can't make it too complicated for the kids otherwise you're gonna have problems and of course it needs to be generally good value you know if there's a family game that costs like 60 70 pound to buy that's not the best of value for something you want to buy for the family but you know if it's like twenty thirty pounds that's a lot better so I'm looking at the list I have a fair few to choose from and I I um Denard Weaver fireball Island the Kirsten volt car but like for it's a bit of a fiddly one it's also quite expensive and I don't know if I mean that was a good second choice out for but I just felt was a bit above the price point to be like a perfect family weight game not to mention small kids are gonna have a field day with some of those marbles and we also considered the river the river is a solid worker placement game by Days of Wonder and is basically renamed as my first worker placement game it's that simple but perfect for families you want to introduce in the worker placement I can think of no better game to do it than that but my personal vote goes to reef reef is basically what for me has even though they're not really that similar if you're gonna put a zoo land reef in front of me I'm gonna pick reef every time a reef is just a fantastic gateway level family game all you're doing is
draw a card or play a card there are two options but you're basically trying to play the cards in such a way that you can build up these blocks of reef pieces on your board in such a way to score points and you want to stack some of them up in towers you want the colors to be grouped together if possible and it's it's very tactical but super fast I mean it's easy to play half the rules are on the back of the box it the turns are super fast there's no downtime and the game is done and dusted within 30 minutes even with four players perfect for a family weight game so I mean if you haven't checked out reef you really need to let's see next step perm I see I'm gonna take these off as I go so dick let's go for reprint now reprint there's a particular caveat with reprint it must be as near as makes no difference the same game as before so I did consider empires of the void to briefly but then I disqualified it because even though it's technically a reprint of the first one it's so fundamentally different than the first one I don't think it qualifies as a straight-up reprint otherwise it would be the top this list easily so I'm looking at a game that is pretty much identical to what it was before oh yeah and or is identical to what it was before now surprisingly I did consider brass yeah okay I'm not the biggest fan of brass but I'd give it some respect but I'm not talking about the Birmingham one I mean that's what will get lumps out there but yeah I'm talking about Lancashire brass the straight-up Lancashire reprint from Roxy
games as much as I don't adore that game if you're gonna do a reprint that's how you do it you take this game that looked horrible vomit-inducing ly bad in its old iteration it looked so bad it was unbelievable and you know I had a horrible app to go with it you know the in tried to make an app and it was horrendous it just didn't look good I just really hated it but this is how you do it properly you put some of the best artwork I have seen ever that probably doesn't even deserve to be in this game but if it's in this game anyway you give you clay poker chips if you bought the upgraded version you know you put a really nice finished board you put proper card you put photorealistic artwork you just up the production quality to ridiculous levels and you get something that is worthy of a reprint so you know my top that was a very close reprint for me but not my favorite the favorite reprint I have which I feel has it's gonna bring it back to the limelight I think it's up to production quality to what it really needs to it's gonna be more appealing to a lot of people but my personal favorite was by margin I mean I was dis will browse but this one for enjoyment factor I think has to go to Camelot second edition the camera up second edition a new rule with yo partnerships and crazy camels that go backwards which is really good fun but I wasn't that desperate for the old camel app I
thought the components with Qin see it didn't look that great that pyramid was basically just a cardboard mess you know not particularly great this one though oh my god you open the borders that you've pop-up oasis which does nothing but just look good cosmetically it camels a solid chunky wood the tiles are now nice thick and sturdy your artwork has jumped up to 11 it looks gorgeous so much so that cam up is now in my collection in the other room as a solid gateway gainer I love to pull out for anywhere up to 8 players you know this I would never even consider putting camel up in my collection therefore this reprint now the reprints out it's in my collection and it will stay so it had to go to camera often en but it was close very close okay let's counterbalance this with a co it's good for a negative one here not the worst game I'm gonna save that for a bit longer let's go for cash grab now I want innovation in my games okay we're getting flood with so many games I'm getting sick and tired of people just turning out the same old stuff all the time it's getting infuriating yeah at this rate nothing's gonna change and we're just gonna get the same old stuff every time of which the cotan in you are basically gonna go oh my god there's the best thing ever and then people like myself who are a bit more I say balanced or more towards co2 the old are gonna be like well this game right here why do I need this one you know everyone bangs on about century spice road but I've got splendor
I prefer splendor and it's a similar feel you know why would I want that if I got this it's it's that kind of thing but oh my god there are some times when I just see a game and it's just like it has got cash grab literally stamped on the front there's no reason for it to exist other than just a quick buck earner for the publisher for a way to get it height for the designer to literally just take five and not bother with designing too much in the next game it's like you know these get on my nerves and there was some doozies this year loosely I considered founders of glue Haven because literally after playing that game it's not that interesting it's way too long it doesn't look great it's pretty fiddly as all get-out but the only reason this got hyped up like crazy it's because he stenciled the word gloom Haven in it that was why everybody was like oh my god I must have it oh but it's not that great and literally people are already see that it's not that great a game there's some lovers there's some fans of it but most people thought it was average at best yeah so that was a consideration but no that's not direct cash-grab because it is fundamentally different from gloom Haven so I had to give it props and I did consider brass mainly because and this is brass Birmingham yeah because brass Birmingham everyone's going oh my god my favourite game of the year my best new game of 2018 hello guys it's Lancashire weed beer at it is
literally what the game is you can make the locations different whatever yo ticket to right does that all the time yeah you can basically say ah but now you have a you know the flexible market thing since like okay you could have literally done that with a variant but some tiles and Lancashire that's not exactly a whole new game but everyone sort of goes oh yeah the beer now makes it fundamentally different it's not that fundamentally different guys it still feels like Lancashire it's still basically right okay so I mess around with turn order with this money I go and get my stuff on the board oh yes they've got to do that coal and iron thing which is still the best thing to do in the game and now I just have to consider that beer is essential which basically just makes the game more punishing than Lancashire which is not a good thing but you know it's got some differences but come on guys I I just even if it would have made my top 10 I just qualified it on my caveat of too similar to the original game but every brass fan is going on that this is the best thing of 2018 it's like I feel that is basically just a standalone expansion it's basically got as bad as much variation as a Ticket to Ride map pack but my vote easy cash grab the the number one has to go to a zoo stained glass of Sentra come on Plan B you know better than this you've come up with decent stuff over years and even if I don't think they're the best games ever century spice road is hugely popular fair enough I give it respect I prefer Splenda yeah Azul I actually have a salt on my shelf down there I prefer the original resort to stained glass a syndrome winners all came
outside okay this is cool I don't love it but I taught it so many times people want to play it great this is a cash grab pure and simple I'm sorry if you think that this is so widely different from assault seriously take off your sunglasses that they're attented Weaver's all love and think about this what is different in this game literally you have taken out the mosaic like oh let's see well what are you doing is all you take tiles from the middle you track them from each town they go into the middle and then you keep going until all the tiles are taken you put them on your board and you try to fill up certain colors as fast as you can what you doing is all 2.0 you took some towels in the middle you draft them from there the tiles go into the middle or you grab them until all of them are right now and you put them on your windows as fast as you can I hang on a minute where's the difference literally your difference is you have this tittle meeple that moves along the windows to say where you can place them and you have window tiles with a slight different scoring mechanism then the mosaic ones that's your difference 90% of this game is a Zul the core thing of what I even like about us all is the drafting of the tiles and how you've got those tactical choices that's exactly the same in this one all you have done is literally changed the scoring mechanism and the scoring mechanism isn't even that interesting a and B side of scoring in the zoo is a fundamentally different game a and B side in 2.0 stained glass a Sentra is literally two very similar scoring mechanisms that's
it and not different and even then the stained glass syndra has the problem of being more luck dependent and as all was you know you can have a game you can have a round where tiles come out of a certain color and your windows just don't happen to require that color you're screwed you have no way to recover after that oh yeah yeah I could ran on more but I'm sorry you know boom for them a decent enough games I prefer the originals Oh if you prefer staying diocese intro fantastic great that's no problem you know cuz I give both games respect but people saying you can own both no no you own one of them yes definitely own one of them but don't need both pick your poison which one do you prefer the windows are the mosaic and there you go that's pretty much it so definitely as all 2.0 stained glasses sintra there's two non of my name as easily the biggest cash gravity yet right but after doing cash grab how about we go back to positive and go for the best innovative game this year this was actually quite tricky there's been a few games this year that I've actually pushed the envelope and tried something different now this one had to be the level of innovation you know like doing something really vastly different to what's been done before and having it still succeed so I considered war chest war chest was on my top 10 a year and I think that that that coin bag building along with the abstract war game was very different very different indeed and it works very well I really enjoyed that one there's a
good two-player game but there were some better ones I could think of I mean I was also considering Selenia so then the era has a really cool mechanic where as you move this airship along the tiles you take the back one flip it over and put it at the front it looks like you're sailing through day and night that's really cool and all the cards have little portholes on them that you put down so you can see what's underneath it really cool idea that was very close and I did briefly consider where there's no architects the West Kingdom which as much as spoiler alert is bite at my tap game of the year it certainly did a good twist on worker placement but that was kind of the main animation it did so my personal vote goes to key Forge key Forge is a really cool to play a card game from you know from the same go get Magic the Gathering I got Richard Garfield and it's it's got some cool mechanic site you know you've got three different factions and you choose one every turn and you can do as much as you like with that faction but only that faction really cool decisions but this was the main pioneer of the whole unique game system which means that every deck is unique and it's such an easy entry point you just go out by a deck there you are you can play key Forge that's literally as much of an entry point you need you can buy multiple decks yeah but it's your choice you don't have to buy pack after pack after pack you could just buy one pack and there you go you're done great little system the balancing has yet to be determined but it does have a system in place that if your deck is particularly good you can balance the two deck so that one person is that a handicap so you know it's a
nice innovative way way to do that as well so yeah keep food for me I thought was a very good refreshing change I really liked it not quite top ten material but it certainly was just something very different yeah very different and that's what I want to see innovation in my games okay take that one off that's a good ones if I got left I've got one two three four five six six good ones and I've got one two three four bad ones okay so let's get another let's get a couple more I'm good ones out the way then I'm gonna go with let's see some think that's it alright here we go formatic form edit games oh yeah no theme I love theme you know I love theme you know theme is that big contender for why I love a game you know and that's to say every game has to have team you know hello posts are 28:49 much but you know the more it has a strong theme the more it will draw me back to wanting to play it more often and I can forgive some slightly dodgy mechanics if the theme is so good and engrossing whereas I can't forgive poor mechanics or annoying mechanics if the game is so bone-dry I didn't feel like it in the first place it's you know that's the way it is this year I thought we were a bit lacking on formatted games really I mean there was a fair few but I don't know I just there weren't as many that sort of grabbed me at first this year seems to have been mostly about fairly dry heroes and fair enough that seems to be the trend now but some did go through and I
certainly have to give them props again I did consider empires of the void to you know the very good formatic space game you know all the planets have got different events that trigger off all the races feel different you diploma size with Sam you conquer others that was a really good formatic experience but I also had to come sitter detective as in detective the portal game right there the deduction heavy deduction game ripen theme you feel just like those CSI agents and the TV shows you know one person on the computer one taking notes solving this really intriguing and grossing plot for you know for a typical sort police drama really cool bit heavy for some but you know it's a really good formatted game but I had to give props to the one that even though this is the theme I don't tend to go for all the time this game is literally just oozing in this Fame and at Western legends Western legends I'm not the biggest western fan in the world you know for a great western intro much but you know if you can call that formatic not but with western legends oh yeah I mean you play this game and you know you want to be the outlaw the marshal you want to be ranching cattle we want to be a prospector you want to go play poker you want to you know get just drunk in a bar and talk about your deeds you want to you know use your using poker cards for all the actions you can do it you're like it's a great sandbox western game and it just oozes theme I mean you just if you squeeze it the literary floods out is that you know it's kind of like think of The Shining that scene where
all the blood comes out the door and a bad analogy but yeah that scene from The Shining I think it's a shining yeah it's basically that but imagine that steam coming out of western legends it's just pouring everywhere and it's one reason I love it so much it's one reason it hit my top ten of the year it's just you know I want a quintessential Western game that I can put some music on in the background some guitar and harmonica going along and there you go it's just so such a good essence of theme and yeah can't say enough about it okay and next group on let's go for expansion expansions love expansions I like expansions more than I like a new game because a new game it's got to teach me something completely different and chances are it's not always going to work whereas an expansion you get some iffy expansions but generally it's going to expand a game I already like or possibly even fix a game I don't like so expansions I do look forward to and I had a lot to choose from this year there's some pretty good ones Seven Wonders Armada was tempting there the up we put that in a compilation review in season 3 because I know I haven't done a single review on it but yeah sevens of Wonders Armada is a solid into a expand the base game of seven wonders without necessarily being forced to put leaders and cities into it basic plus seven wonders arm are there is enough to give it enough sorry is enough to give it a fresh outlook without having to stick all the expansions in which is how I generally like to play it anyway so a mother was definitely worth considering prelude to terraforming Mars
not the biggest fan of terraforming Mars but I warmed up to it a bit more now and the lot of it is down to the prelude expansion so I gotta give it props this basically shaves a good two to three generations off the time length of the game and that's one of the biggest issues I have is that the downtime and the time limit era for mass is way too long for what is basically a mid-weight drafting game so you know being able to shorten it and give you a differentiated starting set up always a plus point in my book and prelude does back in spades I refuse to play this game without Prelude that's how useful it was but you know there was slightly ban in that this love - abyss down there caught the violin fixes the one problem I had with the base set and then has basically made abyss one of my top 10 favorite games it is just so good now with that expansion but it only really brought that in there wasn't much else on top of it so my vote goes to cite the rise of Fenris as if scythe could get any better oh it did the campaign itself is already good fun to go for as it introduces the elements but even if you just ignore the campaign and just think you know what don't need it I'm just gonna shove the modules in this game into my game of sight oh my god they're good modules you can now customize the triumph track so it's different every game you can now have you know customized mods for your board you can have customized mods for your mechs you can add and these even just those free modules alone completely revamp the experience of seif the other modules are
still pretty sweet as well you've now got well actually say no I don't wanna don't spoil too much you know but suffice to say the other stuff in that expansion I will use every single game and the campaign is still good fun to go through honestly if you like sight and you really want to spice up you need that expansion it is a must-buy so I had to get the best vote here okay so I think we're now left with at four good one two three four yep and one two three four yep so poor feet let's go on to I want to end on a high note so let's start with a disappointing you know start with disappointment here we go disappointing game now it's if anything a game that I expect to be bad and is bad yeah whatever not really caring yeah I can get used to that sort of thing but when the game you hope is gonna be great it just falls flat I hurt you inside especially when it's a designer and a publisher that you give respect you cut me deep Shrek you cut me real deep just now and yeah there was a lot of disappointments this year sail on from Essen I was expecting a lot better for a FEMA bout making tea for ya I'm not seeing this theme before I really want it to be great and it's basically just move around a map put some leaf tokens on do this cube like turn cubes into victory points and it just wasn't very formatic for a game about making tin it's like yeah was not as big of a fan of that was it's not bad
but wait more Imaginarium that's all right it looked funky you don't get how I mean you aren't working it it's just bizarre and I thought oh please let the the game and the theme match this weird artwork yeah it's a bone-dry engine builder and it's not even that great of an engine builder it's okay but you know it's kind of it drags on for ages with anybody with ATP and there's not many paths to victory so that was a bit of disappointment nemesis was another one I like it okay it certainly was a potential for the most romantic game but you know it does have some weird things about it and yeah probably should have mentioned it with the fermented games category actually I did consider it but the problem that missus has is it's just far too long far too long for something that has player elimination and sin I coop involved this game takes easy like two and after three hours to finish every four plus per game despite the fact that you don't do a lot on your turn it only take one player to slow it down and the admin and stuff as well it's just there's so much to consider is a lot going on and it just takes forever you know this really should just be a 60 to 90 minute game and it never takes that long unless you're playing it by yourself or with one other player with a full group it's just too long but you know and also player elimination I don't want that in a game that can last hours what if you get kicked out halfway through because somebody had the objective to kill you off as their main thing oh great
they succeeded early and killed you up well now what you do is it's a fine I'll play it but I've really got to be specific about who I play this with and how many players before I really get back into his mr. Shane dough cuz the famous so good but yeah biggest disappointment discover lands unknown oh my god this was such a disappointment I mean a unique game system had already made its way with key forged I thought oh yeah where can we take this nut board game but I was skeptical I thought can this pull it off is this not gonna work for a board game as it does for a current game and a survival game you know I'll go with that but it's bed by FFG in koi bhi Nets get a great publisher and a great designer it's kind of work right yeah no he didn't it was boring it was repetitive the fact that it came with two different bits of Train really made little difference apart from just slightly differentiating what cards you picked up and the plots were predictable and optically interesting it literally the only thing this game had going for it was the fact that the turns were really quick and there's a solo game it was pretty fast and pretty you know streamlined but yeah everything else about it just fell really flat and I expected this to be great or at least something better than what it was so yeah discover lands on the biggest disappointment so let's move on to surprises now yeah when a surprising game comes through that's such a good feeling you know a game that disappoints you is horrible in the flipside a game that sight that didn't expect it to be that grainy go wow yeah that is one of the best
feelings you can get from a board game and there was a few to consider actually this was the biggest surprise in the lore that there was a lot surprises funny enough ever Dell was tempting yeah everyday life Otto grace is another hiked up Kickstarter it's got a giant tree whatever it's a gimmick you know how good can this be turned out pretty good it made my top ten of the year it's a solid game in a light tableau builder we have a great production and artwork as you're getting this collection of woodland critter creatures and you know their you know their various locations and trying to come up with combos and sort of build up a little engine neat little game but you know it did look nice so it was thinking yeah you know maybe this has potential I also considered great cult raked hoped or a cult how everyone else it the Icelandic green house farming game formerly Rosenberg didn't think I was gonna go mad for it I mean I like gory Rosenberg games but I fought well they did new sport the other year and that was pretty bare-bones an average so is this just gonna be another one of those turned out I though it's a very cool game people already liking it it's just a nice light to mid worker placement game that is you know gives you that farming feel of growing vegetables but rather than having victory points it's a race around an exterior track to feed the tourists it's just very quick very streamlined shouldn't take too long unless you've got some AP players you know keep them off this game well produced it was generally a good surprise and it's still sitting in my collection but my biggest surprise of the year was passing through Petra this one I looked at I fought okay canyon
walls definitely a gimmick tiles just messing around with tiles okay I don't think the theme is gonna be particularly strong here you know but is it gonna be a good game turned out it was nothing left to be tapped ten material but I really was thinking that this was just gonna be like meadow cam you know not too fast this one I think it's gonna fly under the radar for a lot of people and I think you should give it a shot it's a it's kind of a tile manipulation game you're trying to circle around all these different rondelle's for different nations and it doesn't matter what nation is watch what they trade I mean it's not very formatic at all but the idea is is you're trying to place out your influence cubes and the first one to do it wins the game so again a victory points I like it when they stop doing that but the tile manipulation is a really cool puzzle it's kind of the gives me a similar into how you play Otis if you remember that one with the divers and you've got to rearrange the divers in such a way to be at the right place at the right time this is kind of similar you have to manipulate your market board so that these tiles come on on the Left they push off tiles on the right that go above your board and then you can use them to do the market trade actions but you they trade with certain partners so the purple ones you need to know for example you know trade with the Reds so you want Purple's at the top and right at the bottom you've got to manipulate the tiles in such a way that you can do this but on top of that you've got cards for special abilities and power-ups you've also got multiple scoring opportunities with the cubes and you've got little bonuses you can grab and I
really like the grid system with the little porn that you move did they take what action you do so whichever direction you move in is the action you're allowed to do but you can only move so far so you have to balance out your actions you know you can't just spam the same one all the time it's really cool yeah also frustrating in a good way at the same time and this was a big surprise enough that it's in the collection it will stay there it's not particularly complex although read a certain bit in the rulebook really carefully because if you get this wrong it will break the game but you know it's not too difficult to play pretty straightforward to explain the walls are a bit of a gimmick but they look cool on the board you know and the tiles do slide in between them not too bad but again it's a bit fiddly and yeah generally I really enjoyed it I didn't think it was gonna appeal to me as much as it did but it was just a really cool puzzle in a streamlined short game I mean this is a sixty unit game possibly 90 taps it's really cool little game and you really should try it out passing from Petra okay well next do okay I wonder let's see we got I think I miscounted the number oh no no no six six categories seven I think of miscounted the amount of categories I've got left oh well who's that it's a bit of a surprise so let's go with a very quickly two-player game 2 player only game and yes you might be able to play these with more players but they're more of a variant as opposed to how you should play it I considered quite a few here I
mean forge was very tempting key for tis a solid to black card game won't belittle it I've already explained it princess Jing was another one this one I think it's gonna fly under the radar but it's a very well produced game for mana go where you're trying to hide your princess from the opponent as you move your princess through these like so weird though like statue things you know alcoves and you can manipulate where these how codes are but you've also got this guy with a little mirror that if you look through the holes you can try and see the mirror and try to see where the princess is so really cool to play back and forth game probably over produce for what it is but it's a very neat idea Julis or island I think could be the top of this list but I have not played it it came out too late in December for me to consider it for this I'm sorry but I will get it played soon probably there's a compilation review edition but yeah I want to play it it does look cool but just haven't had the chance yet so for now two-player game goes to war chest war chest that innovative bank building coupled with an abstract war game yes you can play this as a a 2v2 but honestly it's best played as a one on one one on one pure drawing out the bag you know how do i tailor my bag do i make it all the different units or do i tailor it to just a couple the different unit cards every game for both players so you're differentiated makes for vastly different gaming experiences you play it not that difficult to learn the rules reference is barely a page and yeah it's a solid abstract war game that i didn't expect much from this surprised
me a bit as well but yeah it's a two-player game it's a really good strategic and tactical two-player game and definitely deserves perhaps war chest so that's due to I wanna mm-hmm two three four five six I think I've miscounted how many bags I've got left actually I've got four bags and two goods I don't know how it managed to do this is because I'm not going from top to bottom anymore but let's alright we're gonna have to do a couple of bad one bad ones then so no we'll say the two bad for the end yeah I'm gonna save those so those so let's start off with production quality yes production quality in a game really matters I love good production in the game and I think that these days you've got to up your level with regards the production quality or it's gonna fall by the wayside so let's let's talk about my best and my worst so best production first off this was hard there was a lot of good production quality this year and I think there's gonna be a lot of different opinions that I think it just has to come - which one when I see it on the table do I just go oh it does it does it just sing to me when I when I put it down in I mean I considered ray colt ray Colts got lovely artwork it's got the little wooden knot with a nun the sort of like cardboard case things you build hold all the components in there wooden components they're shaped in a really nice production cerebra again great beautiful artwork aren't works in a separate category but you do get the miniatures and then I fall
behind on most of this is Kickstarter so I had to it's a very good production but a lot of it was Kickstarter based and I had to disqualify it for that Tod who icon or whatever you pronounce as really it's a great production you've got those a domino wooden tiles you've got all the different cheats you've got a board that looks great but I thought maybe half of it is down to the artwork as well and you know it's still really good production quality but in the end I felt that I had to go with Rising Sun Rising Sun as well as having good artwork has got some fantastic components for like you know the different war tiles your honor things the negotiation things your player boards and like the combat board some money but and this is what I've been considering the Kickstarter versions of it but the miniatures oh my god that miniatures are so good not just for your players but those monster miniatures are amazing as well it's an expensive game I will say but Wow when you get all those miniatures on the board you have any sprawling battles it just looks at the business this is one of my favorites if not probably the favorite game I have from cool mini or not and that's saying because I don't tend to have a lot of their games but for Rising Sun really did up the bar with some production quality for this year but I will accept that a lot of people are gonna have different opinions on this one because there was just a lot of good choice I'm giving if you preferred one of those other free that I just mentioned I can see exactly why there's probably several other games
out there that you might say even weren't on that list of four and you think they were better production quality I mean um lots of Hellas looks pretty sweet as well you know I have not played it so I didn't really think about it that much but you know lots of headless if somebody thinks that's better production quality and Rising Sun I could probably see why it does look pretty sweet so this was a hard one to do however worst production quality oh my god yes as well there's been some good ones there were some pretty bad ones now when I think wurst production I don't just think oh god this looks horrible Blin I've also got to consider the price point you give me a game that cost 10 bucks and it's bad production quality well I'm paying 10 bucks for it which expect it's only so much you can give me for 10 bucks so something like crypted that does look pretty horrible it's not that expensive a game it's basically a little deduction filler so there's only so much you're paying for here so I've got to think about the price point and there were two that sprung to mind rise of tribes there that's not a particularly well produced game it's not even a very good game but you know Kickstarter improved on certain aspects of it but the retail version of it oh my god some of those components are horrible but but I had to give it it's not the most expensive game in the world and it's okay production but still not great but also I published here but I think it was like a fairly newish publisher I wasn't that desperate for that stuff anyway this one though is a publisher that should know better they've done some great production in the past they did a reprint of Camelot
2.0 but yeah my worst production here the one that just made me go what is this you should know better for this amount of money black out oh my god forget the fact that there's practically no artwork in the game just cubes for resources a board that is pretty much entirely black black bordered cards that are so wafer thin that the second you touch them they already start escaping and you just little token shits and you know not a particularly pretty bad production for a game that is not this is now the cheap game to acquire it's a full-priced game and on top of that it's edgar spiel you know better eggox feel you have done some great production in the past or at least decent production and then you came out with that what how did you think this was gonna work I don't get where the thinking was on this yes okay it's black out let's make everything black that doesn't make for a good production game just because you want to tie it into the title yeah it was not a big fan of this one for for the publisher and the reputation they had for what was a pretty expensive game to acquire come on you can do better and see okay let's go to artwork yes artwork now again tough choice with some good artwork this year things are just starting to look so beautiful I love it people people still defend ethnos as
being a really good-looking game seriously what you want but you know there were some good choices for artwork both bad and good so it start off with the good I really like I say avid L very nice-looking artwork you know that everything's colorful it looks very forest like and I mean I think the ones I considered that was probably my second choice it really does look beautiful I also considered brass okay brass is not my favorite game in the world but I gotta give it props my god I want that aren't working another game I want that it looks so nice even if it does look a bit dreary it's either nighttime or it's wet and miserable so it's not the best setting to depict an artwork but my god there's no denying that the artwork in brass is beautiful and fantastic cerebra was another consideration very good artwork for our bit of a busy board but vibrantly colorful you've got all these different emotions on the cards it just I does quite jump off the table I must admit but for me I had to think when do I look at a game it's a bit like a production which one just sings to me which one do I want to play partially just because of the artwork or which game that when I put out on the table am I always saying god I think so beautiful I love it and that's empire's at the point two empires of the boy - Ryan duck it's artwork is fantastic and it impairs of empire to the point - oh my god it looks so divine when it's on the table all those blues and blacks together over the planet escapes that the different
color planets all the the hand the hand-drawn style of all the races and you know your player boards and the cards themselves artwork just oozes from that game in such high quality and the board is a thing of beauty what I love the game already but yeah every time I put it on the table I just have to take a minute to stare at it and just admire the craftsmanship of that artwork as I ah yes so good it had to be my personal pick worst artwork Oh some of these games really did just make me want to vomit in terms of how bad the artwork is now one thing I will caveat and I can say this about production as well I say about artwork it's a very subjective viewpoint the eye of the beholder is gonna be different for everyone one man's vomit-inducing artwork is another man's you know thing of beauty on the wall so take this with a pinch of salt this is just what really there for me I did consider founders of gloom Haven its Browns its Grey's it's horrible muted greens I mean the player boards are okay but the rest of it just look really dull especially with all these little chips everywhere I mean it's not a very nice looking game I also consider dice settlers you know I mean I give the designer props for his solo modes and in Akron II and stuff like that but you know settlers didn't win me over as much and as much as I'm sure the artist has gone on to great things I really did not like the are in this game the tiles look super bland the woman on the player
boards I swear is staring into my soul she is like creepy as all get-out oh my god ah and even the dice themselves don't look that great so yeah our word was a bit of a low point for this but oh my god and to be fair I've not played this game I've just seen pictures I've just seen it being played but oh my god this game looks I mean this could have made bad production it looks bad production but hard work wise oh my god there is nothing about the aesthetics of this game that makes me want to even consider playing it and that's before you even get to the fact that it's done by one of my least favorite designers ever Stefan Feld but and this is just because I don't like that style of game not because he's actually about designer but oh my god carpe diem what is this there is bad and then this horrendous and then there is seventh layer of hell bad artwork this is so making me feel sick just talking about it if you have not seen carpet diem and you think oh yes a really good fun spelled game there is no way you're defending your artwork in this you can say as much praise as you like about the game itself in its mechanics whatever that's what most people talk about with fellas you certainly don't talk about a theme but the aesthetics of this game you cannot say it's got good artwork or good aesthetics no you can don't even try if you do then I don't know what to say because if that is your high bar for
good aesthetics then what on earth is empires and and rising sun and ever Dale what are they I mean if you think our per diem looks good just looking at ever del make your eyes literally bleed it's like when gorgeousness is that how can you get much worse carpe diem horrible looking game and I'm not exactly expecting it to win me over as a mechanical game but that's just because I'm not a failed back there so wrong so horrible okay we got two categories left and they're both bad ones yeah maybe I should have come with more good categories I'm a procession had gone through all the good categories first but yeah - I'm gonna start we're gonna start with overrated overrated / overhyped because I hate hyping games I mean there are games that I love like scythe and even I admit that was overrated because people think of these games as the Second Coming is so bad how hype these games get what's that tainted Grail one at the moment I mean I know little about it okay it's got an interesting theme and it's got cool miniatures now everybody's going yes batkid amazing but I much do you really know about the game it's like giving the chance to come out and actually play it before you start thinking it's the next Jesus but yeah you know I really don't like hype and people will praise games loads and I would just think why you know it's fine but it's not that good it's not fantastic and there was plenty of choices for this one as well blackout was a consideration people were
hyped up like crazy over this they were thinking oh my god yes this is gonna be great I want to buy it on the buy it I want to buy it but seriously you know it's not that great of a game it's prone to ap it's too long it looks horrible and but people were hyped up about this game with knowing nothing about it literally nothing about this game they didn't know anything they just went with it seriously come on play it first and then you might realize it's not actually as great as you think it was a consideration but I don't think this one's getting as much buzz as I expected it to I think most people are playing it and going yeah some people love it but I'm not seeing it get in as hyped as much so I disqualified it then um I did consider Queen Bram coimbra is a good game I like Klingberg it's in the collection I don't know how much longer though because I super dry there is no phim in this game and it's fine I mean the dice mechanic is the best thing I like about it but at the end of the day you're moving your guy on this map just to get tiles and you've just got four tracks that you're living up it's more tracks tracks tracks this is good enough to be a meme in that's right tracks tracks tracks but it's like I say it's a super dry euro game it's fine I don't have a problem with it per se but everyone thinks is so amazing and I don't I'm not getting that same level of enjoyment from it as others are not to say it's a bad game I just think you know come on but and this was a tough one because I did think blackout might
win this one over but loads of people are putting this as their tap like game of the year and it doesn't even feel like that newer game like I said I mentioned this in my cash grab category but I give it respect but brass isn't fantastic I give it respect but I still think it's overrated you know it's it's a very long very punishing euro game the theme is there but it's not the most interesting theme in the world we would be a building : Iron Works and the Industrial Revolution era yes like so formatic and interesting no but I mean it's got some theme but really it's about as interesting to st. reigns and while you're building railroad link so it's got some aspect of trains but everyone's lording over this and it's just like it's an economic game you're just balancing your checkbook you're you're doing stuff with money purely for turn all the purposes which is just kind of weird when I see that in games and you know at the end of the day it goes on for longer than it should there's a lot of luck in those cards I mean if you don't draw the right cards you are screwed because you cannot afford to take the slow brute to getting the place that you want because people are doing more actions in you and if you there's not a lot of actions you're doing in the game so losing an action is pretty painful but for me I just find it too punishing you make a wrong move early in the game and you are done you will not recover you can play the long
game by doing slightly worse in the first era to be better in a second era that's fine but if you make a quintessentially wrong choice and it might not even be your fault you might have just gone for something and someone has blocked you out of it you're screwed you can't recover and you're just sitting there on like that pseudo knockout times - it's I don't don't go I don't go for the most punishing euro games I want flexibility I want to be able to do my own thing I want a mistake to be potentially correctable not like destroy me for the whole game and but everyone's like top nine of the Year brass brass brass brass even though it's basically just brass with beer on it it's it's fine I'll give it respect you know I mean I'm not a massive fan of Martin Wallace has gamed anyway but I have to say that this is probably one of my favorites that youdon't that's saying something but yeah everyone's lording over it it's just like it looks cool it's a great read print I'll give it that but my dad it's getting hyped up that crazy it's no I just don't think it all that and a bag of chips you can tell a British so yeah brass took the spot just on the overrated site and here we go finally oh yes my worst game of the year oh boy raisa tribes was very tempting because raisa tribes is basically just a very boring very dry Civilization game where you're just basically area controlling on the board people are in each other's faces all the time and
those dice with the the moons and the Suns your turn can basically be so screwed over by pure luck of the dice they just might roll badly for you or it might be so and so internal that the previous two players got really cool turns and then you're left with nothing and it's just some phenomenally unbalanced some of those player powers are ridiculously unbalanced I remember having one that barely got used and another player was continuously able to trigger is not a very good game at all and some people still like it I don't get it raisa tribes was a big dud for me Museum Rush was another tempting one I mean this is basically just a luck fest that you just move your guy around these museum tiles you're trying to collect money from these various places these cops are going around the board every now and again it's just I dunno it just felt really mad I just really didn't get into it much at or I can get into the theme it just had fiddly rules there were some rules I just fought really why is that in there so I wasn't a big fan but easily this was the easiest worst game of the year I do not find it fun to sit in front of people and do this
that's not fun I didn't like the predecessor of this game I thought you know I thought it was a horrible title I thought it was a horrible experience and mostly just luck this one is just the epitome of it people have come out with articles trying to say how strategic this game is I'm sorry you sit in front of your people that you're playing with hoping to have a social experience and you sit there and you don't talk at all you literally just sit in silence and play cards in numerical order just to hope that you play them in the right order with no information from anybody as to what you should play and when I've got a middle card here number 42 when do I play it people are taking a while to do they've just been chicken or is it because they've got really high cards I don't know you have no basis for this information it is purely guesswork and even if you argue whether it's got strategic choices or interesting decision it's just boring it's badly produced it's it's boring you just sit there and do nothing you just sit there in silence and just played America cards and then the round ends and you just do it again but you have slightly more cards that's the variation in the game why is the mind so respected by people I didn't want to put this on the overrated because I don't think I mean I almost thought about should I put on overrated I thought well I can't put it on both overrated and worst yeah and also I think for as many people that love the
mind I think there's just about as many people who hate it as well you just tend to hear the people who love it more than the ones you hate it that's why I'm here but you know to fill in the gap shall we say but oh my god oh my god the mind is horrendous I hate this game with a passion this is something I would rate a 1 a 10 it's just not even a game it's an activity but even if you argue it's a game it's a very bad game sitting in silence and guessing when you should play a card is not fun I literally could just I mean you can break the game by simply doing a mental in your head among all four players yes people might slightly count out of sequence but the amount of times you will succeed doing that more than when you fail will break the game it's just not fun at all and if you have lots of players is basically a chaotic luck fest you might be able to save with two players you can get into your partner's head but with four or five of you you're just not gonna do that and ah I mean I just want I literally just solve flip I mean I played one game literally I played one game where I was so bored I basically flipped a coin every now and again and if it came up tails I played my card that was literally what I did I actually succeeded about as half as often as I did when I thought about when I should play the card ah my mind so bad and they got nominated for an award as well seriously is as the hobby really
downgraded to such a level that a game like the mind is wherefore spill the yaris winner no that's all the categories I got oh I need to take a rest now and edit this video but yeah like I say I've done some bad categories I've done some good ones generally 2018 was a solid year and I can respect certain games I can love a ton of games and I can hate on a few games yeah that's the same every year but it's all subjective it's all just my opinion you might think an overrated game is your best game of all time fantastic go with it that's your opinion and you're entitled to it as much as everybody else's so you know it's purely just sort of my opinion of how the year went I know some of you were going to agree and there's some of you were gonna disagree but again keep it civil put it in the comments I want to hear what you guys think so that's it for me until season 3 this is definitely the last video last podcast everything now from this point in the first half of January I say first couple of weeks in January when I start putting out more content again will be season 3 whether the quality is an upgrade I need your opinion so when I do put out those videos and podcasting please give me your feedback you know have they changed enough if they're not changed enough do you want different you know different things done you know I'm still getting to grips with the software but I'm hoping it will be an upgrade I've got new camera batteries for these unlight solution died out mid video again you know and Premiere Pro allows me to do color correction so I might be able to put some lighting effects in here that will make the video just a little bit less washed out so yeah the stuff that I am considering and I will get more details
when I start season 3 as to what format I'm gonna do review videos in and podcasting top tens and like I say you did ask for it I will do some solo play for videos but again just gotta work out the kinks so you know there's some good stuff on the way for 2019 but for now have a very Merry Christmas have a great new year thank you for watching season 2 throughout its entirety I hope since mid 2017 I think season 2 started with my review of Baron Park I think that was the first one I did but like I said thanks for your comments thanks for your feedback thanks for the positivity you've given me because trust me this can sometimes feel like a thankless job at times when you get like the the trolls after you and it's a stressful thing to do particularly as a hobby as opposed to an actual job I'd love to do this full-time but until three four thousand patreon sign up to my campaign and pledge $1 each I'm not gonna be able to do this part-time or full-time so I have to do this on top of my job which is already a pretty stressful job so you know it's great to get the crying feedback from a lot of you particularly at conventions when you come up and say hi or even just on YouTube Twitter Instagram Facebook however you talk to me on there so thank you guys have a Merry Christmas have a great new year and just generally take care and remember it's only a game
you you