Board Games That Tell Great Stories But You Wouldn't Expect Them To - Part 3
Transcript
all right it's day three and we're going to get Chris's list of games that tell great stories but you wouldn't expect them to plus an honorable mention that doesn't technically count that's right I it got nixed cuz this guy's a jerk all right let's go all right so I got three great ones and an will mention Jamie I will say that I got rid of the scotch so you can calm down now it's stank tired of getting crap I'm getting like tons of crap today Scottish whiskey is not as good as Irish whiskey oh that's true yeah we you get out that red breast I got you oh anyways okay so my three should I go with the honorable mention first I'll do that go with it first all right honorable mention is above and below now I got crap because it's a storytelling game by default right mhm but which is hilarious because that that's not the one that I ned Oh I thought you did NX that one all right well anyways so uh above and below I it it I hate you guys I really do pretty sure he Nicks Gloom yeah I did gloom's funny because I've seen so many people not play that as a story game okay go ahead anyway two honorable mentions and one pick a I hate you taking back all my Christmas beer give it to me anyways anyways above and below not because of the story that is told by the game but the story that is made up by the
villagers that you get that I can I can agree with that CU um a lot of people that I play with will come up with a story as to why certain characters are in their town and why they go out on adventures and why other one stay behind yes you had a herum Jamie well it's just because they were all women in one dude that's yeah yeah right see when I'm playing I got a robot I got a cat person I got a human I think I'm Star Wars we there yeah see there you go so that was my that was we'll move on no I I think that one's the pick that makes sense because you're not talking about the specific storytelling elements of the game because above and below does have where you're building a city you're collecting a group of characters to use to take actions and part of it is going and and exploring underground and you're reading the story book and reading story out which none of it really ties together and makes a cohesive story but what I liked about your pick here why this one wasn't the one that I nied is because of what you just said the fact that there's an emergent story that comes from the characters the way they look the you know like in that situation the gender of the characters sort of like there was an all women town that I just happened to make it wasn't like I was picking them specifically it was like they had cool Powers Yeah so it was like neat that I was like oh there there's this town full of women with one big giant dude with a bald head with a hammer Nam that was just building things I don't build things I don't know why he had to jab at you there but I don't know either with a bald head but my my there's a mergent story there right and the types of buildings you build so there's like a there's like sort of like
the the infrastructure of your town so it felt I always feel that as that's the story of the game as opposed to going down and fighting the gloos right you know yep okay so I have four good games then oh well all right we'll see so my number one non honorable mention is last will oh that's a great P which is the game of Brewsters Millions essentially and if you haven't seen the movie go see it because it's fantastic but essentially you got a you got a ton of money and you got to get rid of it by getting prize horses by taking your wife or girlfriend on some crazy expensive dates but and taking that horse with the wife yes see that's the thing I love it's when we get into that that I think is great because not only you buying properties and stuff but when you go on the dates you got to take your horse or you got to take your Chef or you got like so you drunken friend from college goes with you too and he's kind of like a hanger on that like you spend money on him so you're making up these stories as to like why are these people mures and need $10,000 to go on a date like why is the horse going there she's going on a date with the horse obviously like it's it's fun to make up stories as you're spending lots of money it's a great game you know the only thing that I would think could make that game better is if all of the characters were different and had personality of themselves right like as every girlfriend character is the same character and every horse is the same and every Chef is the same every you know old friend from college is the same it' be cool if they had like a name like like old old stinky Joe from from
college and like he had this like this guy look like a bum he's like that'd be like hilarious and like oh then Steve got like The Old Ship Captain who's always drunk that'd be like hilarious if they were all different types of characters so then it lended a little more personality to it would I actually that would be fantastic we need to get that done cuz that's what I that's what's great about above and below going back to your last pick is all of the characters are completely different yeah so it gives them all like individual personality the same would be awesome in last will if it was the same kind of concept and going back to above and below again so we have characters in above and below from our permo that's right and I specifically recall even though I don't remember the powers our powers were very attuned to our particular personalities yeah yeah cuz I remember seeing mine I was like seriously Ryan told me that I'm one of the most powerful characters in the game he say I'm I'm almost broken so in life I'm so powerful I'm broken that must be it all right I'm glad I gave you the upstage P all right did upstage both your picks at this point oh ridiculous all right number two is z Legend of a drift system because no Nix in here because that's great no it is great and I was I was stressed because I wanted to put eclipse in because every time I play Eclipse I feel like there's a story going on but there is then I thought no Zia is the one Z is the one where it's so sandbox that as people play and develop their
own strategy and playing patterns I see Steve as the pirate or I see you as the cop or or like me as the merchant and what you're doing and I'm I'm making up a story or is he brand The Reckless jumping into a supernova and dying every single time every time so it it it builds a story and it's a space game which I love and it's sandbox and it's it's very um it's it's not the best game sure it's definitely not but it's still just fun got tagline for it in space no one can hear Brent scream that's right because he just goes Boop and blows up well I'll tell you I agree with you Chris and and going to your point of it just being like I see you as the the merchant character who's delivering goods and you as the the the pirate character what makes uh what the reason that is is because eclipse is such a big scale game right it's a fleet game and there's no personality to anything in there you can give it personality to the whole civilization in general but really it's like taking like this giant epic Space Opera and taking it down to Firefly where it's just a crew and with one ship and you can think about what's my crew like and what are their motivations and what are we doing in this game Z has that in Spades because it's just so it's there's so much to do in it that you can do anything and have any personality you want y mhm yeah that's a great pick Z is
fantastic yep so my last one since I get four today yeah uh my my last one thank you Steve is Robinson cruso I had not even thought about this even though just the other day I was trying to plan getting the expansion uh it is a game of being lost on an island essentially I got the idea from a book I read oh yeah but the fact that you go out and you explore and certain things happen uh that primarily it's that uh I think certain situations occur in the game that get shuffled back in for later so it's it's when you get bitten by the snake and the card goes back in the deck then now I start thinking about you as having the snake bite and when's it going to what's going to happen like what's going to happen to you or the cannibals are out and now we like we've got cannibals coming uh it's it's it's really cool and the characters because they're so generic as far as like chef and this and that uh they can be you we as players can kind of interject ourselves into that character and when it's done well you take on the personality of the chef and you do what the chef would do um it's it's kind of goes back to we make decisions based on what our character is and not necessarily what is the best yeah Choice cuz we're making story choices as opposed to gameplay choices not a lot of people I mean well I would say there's a
lot of people out there that would find that annoying I play with people that that find it annoying I I go uh I'm sorry I'm going to I'm going to choose this because that's what my character would do if you didn't want me to choose that you shouldn't have told me to take this character Chris is playing the coward this time so he runs from every and we die but no no this this is a perfect pick and I'll tell you why it's a perfect pick and why it's the greatest one to be l because this one is also designed by aacy ignasi yes and uh his company Portal Games their tagline is board games that tell stories so his focus is making games that have emergent storytelling uh you know even when you know some games like detective have an actual story you know but games like stronghold games like Robinson cruso they have emergent storytelling that it's just events and that sequence of events all cluster together tell a story that's different every single time you play it and that's why I love ignosi in Portal Games I even go back to the weather in Robinson cuso because I I just I distinctly remember the very first time I ever played that and I was like this game is nothing this is so easy and then the winner hit and I all I could imagine was us shivering in our shelters like trying to find heat shivering because we didn't build shelters because I didn't think we needed them so it's not even just the story cards I have pictures of us in Camp dealing with all this stuff so I it's so good we don't need food we just eat Steve I
don't know if there are cannibal we can cannibalize people that's the Tony variant yeah you don't want to eat me I'm full of worms you's got full full of toxins is what you are you got you got giant ham well Chris I have to say that I am fully happy with your list mine is GL Gloom Gloom was the one where you just tell stories I'm just it's still a great game though yes it is but all the other ones fantastic all four including the the uh honorable mention which was actually a pick now all right thank you so yeah I get four that means I'm better yeah there you go your list was great thank you all right well thanks everybody for joining us for our lists today come on back in two weeks where we're giving you another list that we haven't picked yet out when it gets there I'll pick mine an hour before the show apparent all right thanks for joining us everybody good night later good night thanks so much everybody if you've enjoyed this video please do us a giant favor by subscribing to the channel and clicking that wacky Bell icon if you're into board games Miniatures games role playing games we have a bunch of audio podcasts you might enjoy you can find those at the secret cal.com or on iTunes and Stitcher