Skip to main content
Loading video...

We messed up . . . what now?

Transcript 22:09

what do you do when you make a rules mistake in a board game something that quackalope knows very very little about I've heard it said that we have some of the most accurate game plays that have ever existed why are you laughing I I'm enjoying this you're you're in the fact that we are one of the most prominent preminent all in all in on it absolutely here's the thing quackalope is known for our accuracy our competency our clear reading and analytical breakdown of all rules all games all times that's actually one of our Motts yes Perfection one of our Motts Perfection Beyond Compare I want the videos I create and the games I play to be as handsome as the man sitting next to me on a Thursday afternoon baked in Golden sunlight but every now and then when you're relying on this man to teach you big box games mistakes can happen sometimes they do even if they spend 80 hours learning them on a car ride down it can happen and it's certainly not the Publisher's fault yeah it's just it is what it is it is what it is we're playing through Gloom Haven right now we're actually going through we're we're probably going to get I hope almost done with Crimson scales Trails of Ashes we're working on episode three right now and we just finished episode 2 we've had so much fun so much fun and yet there was one little note one little moment in gameplay to

where a creature or two should have spawned and so it changed the dynamic it changed the puzzle and we hit this point we're 2 hours in we've had a blast it's been a challenge we are struggling to finish M and we realize that it actually should be slightly harder than it was yep and so we ask ourselves like what do we do and we wanted to ask you all we wanted we wanted to like this is a conversation with you the audience so please please please leave a comment how do you respond and react when you find during an active game that a rules mistake has happened whether someone's missed something in reading the rules someone has taught something wrong someone has done one of the worst villainous acts in board game industry which is they've taught people everything but the few rules they need to actually win that's a horrific tragic experience but it can happen when rules and games are complex so I'd love to hear your thoughts on this but I have some notes I have some like back and forth on what I what My Philosophy around rules mistakes is how I try to approach and mitigate them and what happens or what what I feel like should happen when you discover one in game yep and you know a lot of it is for me based on when the mistake occurred and how long you know how far back was the mistake when you discovered it I also have quite a few things here that how to prevent mistakes from happening to begin with so you know we'll throw some of that in there too because I think you know an ounce of prevention is is worth a pound of or whatever yeah no you

that's the right quote Yeah it's an ounce of an ounce of prevention is worth a pound of chicken feed that yes yeah yeah well then but then you got to finish the quote okay it's worth a pound of chicken feed you give the chicken feed to the chickens so they can feed the cows the cows then feed the goats the goats then Feed the Children the children grow up to be successful entrepreneurs except for one named Jim okay Jim should have had a little bit of prevention he went to jail and then you tell Jim a pound of prevention or an ounce of prevention is worth a pound of chicken feed and the whole story starts over again you know that just didn't roll off my tongue that well I was I was trying to get there original original language is Yiddish it's complicated when you translate it over to English it just doesn't flow quite quite the same yeah all right so uh for me a rules mistake happens you catch the mistake did it happen on this turn and you can undo it and I absolutely if it's just an honest mistake we're not here playing Super head the nobody's there's no money on the line back up undo what you did and retake your turn so this is this is an interesting question okay with that interesting question I even broke down on mine my notes competitive versus Cooperative competitive I'm agreeing with you when it comes to time Cooperative I have a different approach so let's start with competitive which is what you're talking about now I think my philosophy is in the first third of the game it's a friendly table and I'll announce that I'll say hey if you make a mistake even if it was a turn ago it's a friendly table rework it redo it

do whatever you need to do to to justify and be accurate in your gameplay especially if you're learning the game but then I have two big rules that come into play keep going on yours I've got two I want to mention um so yeah it for me I was going with timing so if it's a a turn right now and I when I play competitive games for me I want to win I'm going to try to win and I'm going to do everything I can but I'm not one of those competitive players that is oh my gosh that's going to affect the outcome of the game and it's not fair and you you should have to play that as like I'm much more easy relaxed we're going to have a good time and that might even turn into the story so I'm okay with that if the mistake happened last round and we've already changed game components around now I'm that's where I kind of draw a line I say all right you know what we're just going to move past it we noticed the mistake you know if if it's completely inconsequential to everything else that happened like oh I forgot to mark off a you know a token here and you you whatever that is you mark that off and it's like all right whatever you know it didn't affect anything on the board I'm okay with going back and fixing that that's one of my rules M revealed information yes is almost irreversible if it is your first mistake if it is the first time playing the game then revealed information can you can react if it was oh it's obvious that that could have happened the dice roll you only had a one in 10 chance of getting it why didn't you react better well

because you just didn't know so sure but the two Frameworks here if something has changed in the game State Cooperative or competitive a card has been flipped a dice has been rolled someone has revealed that they're doing something that is going to upset your turn or change your turn you can't go work that back yeah the world has changed life has moved on you suffer for what you've done and the mistakes you've made except if your like very first mistake but then that comes as well if it's your first mistake mhm at any point in the game for almost any mistake I'll forgive you but then we acknowledge right then yeah that there is no more mistakes like that coming forward right right you communication is key you roll a dice and it jumps out of the dice tray mhm and it's a zero you decide then do dice outside of the dice tray count or not yep if they if they do count then you take the zero yep if they don't count then I don't care what you've rolled if it is not in the dice tray it doesn't count doesn't count communication is the absolute key and I think that's you know it's it's one of the things I was going to talk about anyway you know it help prevent mistakes and also how to handle mistakes when it is communicate the expectation you know if you if you handle a mistake in you know in a vacuum you say all right we're just going to deal with this instance and then it happens again and then you're going to deal with no you have to communicate to

the table all right this is how we're going to handle this when this happens or this was the one time everyone's on the same page right and get buyin from everybody that I think is the critical piece so um you touched on something for me there um you know where I'm actually a lot more stringent or strict with rules I'm more strict with Cooperative than I am with competitive interesting because I feel like the Cooperative experience is US versus the game and you want to defend the game's right to be played right like I I'm more strict I'm far more especially a solo game you know and here's sometimes not even like you know necessarily rules it's getting a little bit of adjacent but like this war of mine love that game okay you're like all right do you want to feed that you know homeless guy that just knocked on your door or do you want to send him away and you decide you know what I'm going to go ahead and feed him and then he shoots you in the face and you're like don't you're like you know maybe I send him away you know like I I don't do that I can't like it's it's something in my brain where I'm like I have to live with this and if I make a mistake in a Cooperative game even if it's you and I doing this you know I I'm more of the of the opinion that hey we now have to we made this game a little harder for ourselves than it needed to be we made a mistake that you know like we got to live with it you know whether it benefited us or not I'm like far more strict with Cooperative games than I am competitive games I'm a strong Advocate that in any game you're going to make

mistakes for and against you and in a Cooperative specifically campaign game you're going to make enough that they balance out that's what I believe I don't know cuz I don't know the mistakes I've made and the ones I make that benefit me or don't benefit me because they're mistakes and you usually pass them up till you post them online and then everyone criticizes you then you cry in the closet by yourself for a long time before coming out and people are very confused I'm happily married just but he's cute here's the thing here's the thing I think it balances itself out and I also think you never play board games right I thought you did play board games right before I started creating content I very quickly learned you I never play board games right no one at the table really does because there's a lot of little nuanced elements to keep an eye on and and parts to run and understand so if it's obvious mhm I like working it in a Cooperative or a solo game if it's obvious if it's just like oh yeah why in the world did I ever do that I'm going to lose the game now because this guy shot me in the face and I know cuz I've met him before and this same card always shoots me in the face there's no other option so no I'm not going to feed him I'm going to rework that and I'm going to continue playing because I want to sit and I want to play a game should have known better I understand I understand it I don't I don't have a memory that that supports me not being forgiving to myself MH my other rule though when it comes to competitive games specifically if you're

in the last third of the game there's a middle third that's a gray area but if you're in the last third of the game you need a unanimous vote everyone at the table has to approve any game shifting game altering rules correction hey I missed getting my resource okay hey everyone are we okay if they get that resource hey I didn't take the action I was looking for or I forgot to cycle my cards whatever it is M yeah I'm cool with you doing it I'm always on the side of for the most part unless it's going to change Victory unless we're right there I'm pretty much always on the side of being friendly to you but I'm also very comfortable looking at someone and them being like I don't really want them to have the resource and going I'm sorry you can't have it I agree with them you if they don't I agree with them if if they don't want you to have it we're not at a point in a game where you change things yeah I I I agree I I can agree with that um for me the prevention piece of it and I want you know can I give a couple or do you want to get in so I I have one more thing I want to add and then let's get to the prevention side of it all right my rules I I said for competitive game my rules is that third system right you can change things it's very friendly then it's kind of in a weird middle ground and then you need dramatic approval from everyone around the table that's a competitive game yeah when it comes to a Cooperative experience I believe that you're going to make mistakes and I am an advocate for never other than spending 30 seconds maybe don't go digging in the rules don't go

searching too deeply on BGG here's my Approach final girl lays it out Final Girl sets it up thematic strategic solo puzzle of a game it is in the back of the rule book it says hey if you're in the middle of a game and you come across something you just don't understand or doesn't make sense and you can't quite resolve it quickly what do you do you do do one of these three things you either tell the story you play thematically accurate you or you're mean to yourself you do Kingdom death's rule of death right the idea of for the E for the sake of moving the game forward you do whatever is worse for you that's fair you're probably ruling in your favor more often than you realize so let the game punish you a little bit supports your function of why can't the game just be mean or three and this is the one that I actually think is really cool that they included it you do whatever is the most fun you're playing a game and you miss something for instance we miss spawning some characters that stinks it should have been a little bit harder do you know what isn't fun it's not fun replaying a scenario that we've spent 2 hours in it's not fun pretending like we have to to come up with some unique solution like oh well instead of that end game let's just change the puzzle let's kill the characters which is one of the things I suggested I was like should we just wipe them out it's not fun trying to debuff shift or interrupt

the flow of a game yeah a mistake was made MH so let's move forward what is the most fun and in Final Girl specifically it's saying rule in favor of fun like chos what is cool is it cool to be able to like drop a grenade in that area and blow up seven people including all of the little like other final girls or other like victims that are standing in that area and also kill the boss or near kill the boss at the same time yeah that's cool so what can you do do that why not move forward check the rules later go to BGG ask questions of course get rules right but in the middle of the Game Preserve the sake of the game play thematically accurate play mean to the players rule of death times whatever or rule for the sake of fun and be consistent with one of those three if you're ruling mean rule mean if you're ruling fun rule fun so here's some uh prevention ideas for how to avoid mistakes before they happen one don't overshoot your group and read your room all right so when you're selecting the game that you're going to play and you know you've got some people who you know katana's there that I love board games I've played Katan a 100 times yeah you know you're not going to bring them times you've played well back in the day I don't think a 100 times but I played Katan a lot how many times you're going to lose a lot of respect before this is before I completely derailed your statement I

played Kat oh you're just committing to it yeah I play Katan I used to play Katan a lot back you know 15 20 years ago absolutely it was it was the only game I knew of is that bad no I love Katan I just think it's funny that I've completely derailed you your your message oh anyways people are going to yell at me in the comments though it's like 4:00 a.m. we've been filming all day you know so read the room no bring out games that are appropriate for the group that you're playing with so that's that's the first thing um next is the uh you know refresh the rules before you play the game if you sit down to a game that you haven't played in five or six months and you're hosting game night and you haven't gone through and refresh yourself on the rules you're going to run into a lot of mistakes I'm pretty sure I know enough to you probably doen I want my game group to play Kingdom Death and I'm pretty sure cuz I've been taught by like four other people how to play I know how to run the game why would I need to read the rules I don't know so that's you're you're labeling things I make mistakes on you realize we all do this we all do this U sometimes it's just time you get stuck at work you're like man people are going to be over here in 20 minutes um next assign and divide the responsibility so you know like for gloom Haven for example somebody's managing the element board someone else is managing the damage someone else is managing the conditional tokens I don't even think I know how to run characters like run the AI for the enemy bosses in Kingdom Death anymore Shir always does it and she probably does an outstanding job and she has no idea how to build gear yes divide and conquer and give other people responsibilities for some segment it's

it solves a lot of problems and uh do things systematically so this you know fits the fire service as well you have a process in which you do things and you do it the same way every single time and you know if this thing goes on that shelf it always goes on that shelf that way every time you need that you go get it and bring it back so same thing how and this is kind of like chaotic for me cuz this is not how I set up Gloom Haven but you know so I'm kind of doing a little bit of the all right you know what are we doing here but if you have things set up systematically where it's in the same order too so if you're going to do the order of operations hey let's stick with this this this and this rather than oh sometimes I do this first sometimes I do that first unless that's the nature of the game but where you can have systematic you know routine set it up and then lastly um you know get a few game plays in in a short period of time that way you learn a game you play you know get that game to the table five six times over the course you know don't don't do it once and then walk away and then come back 3 months later play it once you just won't remember the rules you'll make a lot of mistakes that way the one thing I have cuz I didn't have I didn't have a lot of these this was I'm glad you brought this element up into the conversation something I've learned from filming and from producing this content mhm always especially with a new game talk your turns yes don't do anything in silence and a lot of people will play Heavy Euro games or any of these puzzles and they'll just kind of sit there or they'll scroll on their

phone with other people are doing things one of the reasons I love filming and love playing on camera is because both people have a responsibility to the viewer in the camera so that means they're talking through their turns they're thinking through their thoughts they're playing cards and announcing what they're doing and you will catch so many subtle mistakes absolutely and you can do this solo too I don't know if you've ever done this but I love playing solo on camera because I'll sit down and I'll talk through the strategy and the thoughts and the guidelines and what I'm doing and I'll even do it when there's not cameras around and I will catch myself because I'm hearing myself speak in a way that I never do or never would if it was just in my own mind I've absolutely done this I've sat down with solo games and you know just recently it was Robinson Caruso and I'm talking to myself and realizing like there's no one else in the room and I'm talking out loud about like all right well if I go for the basket over here uh maybe I should do that or no no I need to I need to build a tent ah man yeah I do that all the time absolutely I think it in you know in competitive games especially you talk to your turns some people can catch a mistake be like oh you're right I can't do that otherwise you just don't know and then you catch it three turns later and it's also honestly more fun to have everyone engag at the table something that just popped into my mind that I don't think anyone is crazy enough to have done although person who taught me feudum they actually kind of did this they built a plan they rewrote the rules in their own words and the thing that popped into my mind is there's different levels of knowledge retention

when it comes to academics yeah right there's there's the level of knowledge retention that involves listening Reading Writing articulating teaching right so there's this scale and one of those important on that's a higher level than than reading is writing do you find that you're often times missing a rule or you're missing a mechanic or you just can't get something quite figured out rewrite it in your own words or write that rule 10 times on a page get it ingrained in you through some physical action that could be playing the game but if you're missing it because there's other things that are distracting you that's actually a really good suggestion if you just jot down you start like hey we noticed that we got this rule of wrong a few times wrri in your own rule where that and then put that paper in the Box yeah and now each time you do that you might have three four 10 things on that paper we have a video series called 10 rules you might miss that is almost that's really what that is so now when you pull that game out you're like I got the rule book but I also know the 10 things that we've gotten wrong off that we wrote it down yeah that wasn't a great that's a good idea actually I would love to know how you all find identify prevent learn table play the board games that you have um the challenge of rules is a challenge that I think we all suffer with and and are faced with and I'd love to know how you resolve it when it comes to the game table are we too easy are we too hard like what's your I know some game groups that a ru's mistake is you can't yeah you can't shift that yeah I look at it

like if you're that diligent on rules Maybe video games where you can't necessarily Break The Rules that's that's more your speed probably you can probably still Break The Rules I like the well yeah I mean the yeah okay I've played Call of Duty I know whatever the case whatever you do remember the important thing rules are meant to be broken why else would they make books so thick and impossible to remember as long as I don't get caught by myself or anyone else they always catch me that's the problem y y I would have no problems if it wasn't for you get everything right everything right and you'd Win Every Game appreciate you all being here love to have the conversation we'll see you later bye

Progress saved