Skip to main content
Loading video...

Q&A: Dylan Cromwell - Delivering Three Years Late

Transcript 53:51

hey everybody Edo here and I am super excited because we have the founder and creative director of quality Beast Dylan Cromwell on the line say hello Dylan hey what's up y'all and so this is going to be an interesting video because what we're going to be talking about is seize the bean a game of which oh Jesus heavy game that I have a copy of but is noteworthy because this is a Kickstarter that delivered three years late and so uh and you know and kudos to you for for holding through and making it happen but this video is really to talk about that experience as a Creator both in terms of what happened and like how we got there or you got there I didn't get there but how you got there and um sort of dealing with it and working through it because there are a significant number of creators that fall behind run into troubles the shipping the printing and um there's something to be said for the creators that stick through it and and eventually get through and deliver um of what you're in that category so that's great but so to start you know I think you know some folks might not be as familiar with seize the Bean or quality Beast um it's worth note that uh actually quality Beast has also done localization and will has localized a couple uh pencil first games games from my company in um in the German and Dutch markets but um where did you start how did like

you know take us through getting to seize the bean and then go from there yeah sure I've always had an entrepreneur background and worked in Tech and had some successes with startups especially in Berlin and my wife said to me one day you know when these companies get bought there'll be an end to the party what will you do next right and we were thinking of having a family and I wanted something that just was more wholesome than working you know 80 hour weeks for a tech startup and so I thought maybe I'll get into video games like yourself um but I realized quickly that that industry was hard to get in from the side so I decided I would try to release a game and then releasing a video game turned into releasing a board game and then the idea for seize the bean was born mostly just as a side hobby to do while I had a job and so I mean seize the bean is a pretty dense robust big game um I mean again from picking up and knowing the components but so you know uh uh like did you do the entire design on your own and that like what was the creation you know you have it just created by uh Dylan so what's the sort of story there how did the actual game come to fruition yeah I think my best skill is being a producer uh meaning that I can do many different talents um but I really push the energy of a project and so when I played tricerion from Minecraft games I was super inspired by how mechanically sound it

was but how much the mechanics were dripping with the I was just blown away by that someone that also just loves products like well-made products it just inspired me so much and I think you'll see a lot of DNA of games like that like these kind of like bigger denser Euros but with thematic Vibes in seize the bean um but I quickly realized when I started designing that I was not sound enough mechanically on my own to tackle that and pay homage to to the game's inspiration which is the city of Berlin shrouded in this idea of a coffee game when it's not really about coffee so I brought on a co-designer that I met at the first Spiel I went to in 2016 Andy couch and we also have a co-creator Josh Wilson who was there from the beginning um but not in charge of mechanics more helping with World building and then of course we had the artists who Mario Fernandez Garcia Polgar and kind of before there's a lot of Art in there it's incredible looking yeah the four of us were like a really um interactive team so there was a lot of game design happening because of Mario's art which is kind of chaotic but also really integrated I really like when the art can Inspire the game mechanics and that's a hard you know back and forth to set up but for sure it kind of explains the chorus team but there's a lot of other people that work oh yeah for sure um and thank you and so but so and you you all bring it together and this is

like you know a a a pretty successful I mean a very successful first campaign 3 000 plus backers it's in Euros it's a 137 000 Euros which with today's rate to dollars is about 137 000 actually um but maybe at the time it was a little bit more but so um so you so you have this incredible campaign and and and and and a campaign with like a lot of you know a little bit of what I would consider like over-the-top stretch goals but setting that setting that aside you have this campaign you have this it funds in 48 hours like a big success out of the gate and you know and then so like what went wrong like what what what happened such that your 2018 date became a 2021 date kind of a lot of things um most of them do to me just doing things without knowing what I'm doing so my advice to anybody out there who's listening to this is uh take take the scope and bring it way down and and that's one of you know my biggest flaws is having really big ambition and in the tech world in the startup world I'm able to do things and I'm able to follow up with my ambition and it was the first time in making a board game I had honestly no idea what I was in the store for and we had also no idea um that it would fund like that no idea and um if I think back to the time my co-designer had told me all of the content by the way for the stretch goals was planned um that's how a lot of stretch goals work sure um but he had still said this

is way too many expansions for an initial release and I had said I know but this is my vision and and to this day um I stand by that I love it when even people like yourself got the game opened it up and they're like whoa there's a whole city in here it's like that's what I wanted and I'm seeing some of our community actually play through all of the expansion content and finding that value I wanted there but didn't need to be done that way no so that's the that's the start of what went wrong yeah well can we tease that out a little bit I mean sure because I think it'll be useful for folks who are listening so um you know like where are the categories right I guess it's one thing to say I haven't done you know a game before and tried to do a lot but like what are some of the specific things that you either misjudged or underestimated like like a commonplace even though things were planned like was all of the development design work complete prior to the kickstarter or what or was there still ongoing like was it print ready upon funding or was there different like that's a place where something sometimes spirals out of control others you know there's three areas that are really easy to Target one we can just go ahead and put me on the spot one is just honestly I should have done this better it's not that hard to do I didn't do an art test and go oh this is how long it takes to draw each card and then map that out

well it's just stupid like and that's anybody out there just don't do it just do a test the second thing which is a lot harder to form so that and so that is to say you discovered that even though you had budgeted this the cost of all the development that the time to complete was just not in scale of just the art because it was like 600 cards for Mario um to do and we have a really close like art I give Art Direction he does cards we do feedback so I didn't even I didn't even recognize like how much of my time the art direction that we do together but we take the second thing though which is much harder to map out was we had planned and of course designed these expansions you know they had been played but they hadn't been played well enough to release them to thousands of people and I'm the type of person that isn't going to release something that I don't think stands up I mean the reason why we're called quality Beast is because I do care a lot about the quality of the game production but also the quality of the mechanics and so we started you know doing the after campaign development and we had to scrap like I think uh 20 of the 23 groups almost entirely and then redesign and and develop them and that was that was huge and the momentum going through that with with having to announce delays it's hard that's a hard as a Creator the third thing which is weird to say out loud but we really cared about the accessibility and the professionalism of the rule book and I'm not saying it's a perfect rule book but I think most people's reaction to it is

like wow wow okay they they know what they're doing which we didn't and we achieved that result at the end because we went through so many iterations and that took months and now the product designer that I work with uh Ava she can slam out a rule book in way less time sure with way less help but it was our first time so it was really it was a grind we that kind of hit us like a ton of bricks we thought it was going to be like a couple weeks and the rule book's done and that's just naive but I think a lot of first-time creators wouldn't see that coming and also the rulebook is uh 36 pages and the expansion Rule books 56 pages and we laid out five languages internally so that's 460 pages of layout oh no I mean it's it's a crazy amount of work and I I I I think these are all three really good categories that I think I want to play back just a little bit and and some of this maps to like what would be um how you'd consider you know is more common in video game development but certainly appropriate for board game development which is you know essentially a lot of people it depends on where you are but move into a Kickstarter effectively what would be in a pre-production phase that's now being unlocked or gated into a production phase um pencil first games at this point actually we don't typically do a Kickstarter unless we're like most of the way through production but that's just because I don't like having any on I like minimizing unknowns after having done this as many times but um the key thing about a pre-production

phase um is that you want to like when you're going into production it needs to just be the work and you want to understand the work requirements the time it takes the scope of the work the time it takes to complete the work and then on the design side you want to mitigate design risk know-how play testing development such that when you come out the other side if you have a schedule you know with a good amount of certainty that that's actually the effort the people needed the budget needed and the time needed and I think in your example is a great example which I've seen lots of times it's just not that that simple but not always done thing which is like hey and it's not always about development time sometimes it's about quality or Target which is like hey we need to have a representative image a a final in a final version of each element of the game right like I don't need 600 cards but I want to have made two or three that are approved at the Target quality Etc so I know what that production track is or or this track or that track and that gives you some sense of experience I think I think that's a really good call out that you've made for sure um the the redesigning stuff comes up a lot um and you know that's another reason I think creators sometimes you know a backer makes a suggestion that they take on or a feature or solo mode and it's like well those aren't like instant things those take a lot of work um and even you know from a pencil first games perspective we delicious which is uh upcoming title of ours

um which is Awesome by the way oh thank you but actually we um we went through the pro we skipped Kickstart on which is a whole nother topic but we went through the process of making the rule book and then I was doing some play testing or somebody was doing some play testing and we were running into some really key confusion and we had spent a lot of time on the rulebook and a lot of iteration and blind testing and that but like and you know ultimately we determined that there was some language and information Clarity that needed to be added which was like an over not overhaul but like a rewrite of a lot of the rule book and then actually impacted the visual of the key it's it's a pen and paper game and and redoing some of the layout so that it was really clear at least couple components totally and and you know you know you look at those that it happens but you look at you're like man how did we how did we why are we here having to redo all of this now like we we should not have had to but so and then your third category so you that that oh in the rule book I think just again the rule book in general is especially if you want to do it well right like if you don't really care about how you're doing it you know it's not that much work but still writing rules for like 23 different um you know abilities cards you want them to be understandable and then they're changing and then you're updating diagrams oh yeah for sure um you're trying to do examples like the reason our Roblox or so many pages is also just because we have tons of examples and I had a lot of debates about this with the team early on I was like forget examples and they were like Dylan we need examples like oh yeah for sure um and actually Roman from um uh One More Time games worked on an early

version of the rulebook and he really won that one that discussion with me so thank you Roman I look up to him a lot you need examples and if you're not if if you're not using illustrator um or even Photoshop but with reference images going through and having to update a rulebook uh is deadly um really being able to at least make it so that when you fix a card you can re-export and the card gets fixed on the 15 pages it appears on is like a very important part of the process like one question I had you mentioned the look work was that part of the kickstarter in other words were you offering versions in different languages from the get-go totally yeah it was totally ridiculous it was totally ridiculous suggested that to you I mean I guess you're you're based in I mean it's based on Berlin so there's probably a German in English but like why all the other issue comes from like how connected I want to be to the community and how transparent and how I probably want to please too many people but I also want to really listen and so um like I love all of our backers really um but I think I felt kind of pressured to launch that Kickstarter when we did because I remember going to spiel um I guess it would have been the second time in a row and we had already been to half a dozen events and I think people were saying sort of like oh showing the game again and I don't think they meant it in a negative way but it made me feel sort of like a peer pressure why haven't you launched this yet and of course I've learned that I can take control of that by maybe don't show the game until you're really ready to start a promotional track but but I didn't I didn't realize that at the time

right so we had all of these things localizations but also solo mode and tons of other things the whole resin Snack Pack like um all of these things were suggestions from backers the milk carton deck boxes that happened during the campaign I mean I designed the solo mode during the campaign so that's that that's pretty so those weren't even so much so were those those weren't stretch goals those are just extra content that was suggested yeah totally like totally you just I I just thought you know what I'm feeling wild let's go but of course I've learned and I have an amazing team around me that has also helped to say hey it's cool that you have a big imagination that's really good for creating games that's really good for product that's not really good for us you know planning something realistically so we're gonna like cut off your imagination in these spots and I'm happy with that that's kind of why I like being creative director and not like a managing director and let's wrap up all those three topics into one big topic I never had like a true business partner that was their helping me and even though the industry is filled with really cool people it's also filled with some suits and I did I'm not going to name names but I did have a couple people that it felt like were trying to get something out of the project from the beginning and it made it a little bit hard to navigate being more of a creative type and less of a bit I'm not I don't consider myself a business owner right right I never set out to own a business I just wanted to make a game and it's kind of wild the journey it's taking me on well and I think there's

also it is separate from sort of people trying to leech um which is clearly there I just see tons and tons of people providing awful advice new creators on a regular basis and it's just like totally it's just like this is awful advice and not necessarily like sometimes advice is like good in like a certain slice of like if this is if this is advice for this person in this way like that's appropriate but like if you just apply that advice to somebody who doesn't have the perspective or the IP or the like whatever the is that different contexts the context it turns from good advice to terrible advice it's like so I got a lot of that and I and I recognized it but I felt a little to be honest I felt a little bit lost and I was a little bit on a moving train because there was so much hype and belief in the game at these events I mean 2016 we went to spiel with a terrible prototype and everyone was like wow this game's amazing am I that's where I met my co-designer and he came back to my house and he was like we have some work to do and that's not exactly what he said but you know so why were people so hyped about it ever since then I've learned to take um you know event attendees I love you but I've learned to take what you say with a grain of salt because you're just sure excited to be there with the with the team okay but so let's so so so let's break this backwards in terms of okay so you've mentioned these three miscalculations these three but like was that three years or one year like how did that fall into like does that encapsulate like yep those are the three reasons we were delayed or did you end up doing other issues no that was pretty

much it there's a couple of things where people try to bring up like how we did production like sugar cubes or anything but that's just more of a meme um most of the production didn't delay things and you know I'm not gonna go back and read every update because we could probably improve the communication too but what happened was the realization of these mistakes didn't happen at once it was like oh there's an art problem okay everybody we have a delay and then everybody being like oh really and then us kind of like trying to like gulp that down stay respectful stay communicative stay energetic and then months later going oh no we have like another one and this one's even bigger about development okay everybody and then everyone will be like what come on and then by the third one you know I think I think there was definitely some updates where people were saying it's been months how could you still be working on the rule books and we're over here like we don't know I think um that whole communication piece of it is is important I actually want to spend some time um talking about it but I just want to clarify because so I mean also I guess you know because it's also been such a such a long period of time but so what I'm hearing from you and this isn't loaded in any way but what I'm hearing from you is in terms of the issues that you see for seize the being and the time Associated you are not in the category of maybe a Kickstarter that came out a year or two after you in saying oh well actually this was the pandemic or actually this

was Freight or and I'm not trying to put words in your mouth but I'm just saying for people listening this is not a video about those problems during covid and we met like this is important somebody should go back and check the update I forget the number when we finished creative we've been saying for years years when we finished creative work the rest we can tell you realistically and we we started delivering the backers on the month we said from that update during covet that's like I don't want an award for it I'm just like we got a lot of like comments about stop blaming covet and we were like where did we do that like we we did have some issues in the U.S with uh covet and afraid it was pretty wild but it wasn't but boats on the water it was boats stuck in ports at the U.S it was super weird you know um but yeah all of our problems were like Dylan caused they were well sure well I mean I think I think that's important and would you say just curious ultimately were like so just I I want to get back to that backer communication portion but yeah like how like how big of an impact were things like like financially right like like a couple there's a couple key things that are happening during this period one you know maybe you had the art production mapped out and budgeted but you know whether it's your time or other people's side when things stretch out over time you know I mean every people may be working for back end or not being paid or whatever I mean like like there's different versions but usually it means there's an increasing

cost if if it's going over a Long Winter of time and then also that was a time when the tail end of it when you're getting into fulfillment some of those those prices are starting to escalate in the marketplace so yes you know yes did the game was there a time when the game delayed because of money well not delayed because of money but like well you you were you didn't say that so but I guess that's a fine question did we ever get delayed because of the money but like more important like did it go from a success like you did you end up having to fulfill basically with a lot of additional expense on your part which wasn't covered by the kickstarter so you basically ate all of this extra cost that sort of fell out of all this yeah sure like it sees the beans second printing or second edition we've now gotten to the point where I can I can say that there can be a viable product for distribution and Retail but the current seems to be this seems to be like there's no there's no way that after all of that and also just simply the way that I priced it since again I'm not the business guy and I was learning at the time it's not a product to build a company around now it might be a product to show we know how to make a product from from a product point of view but not from a business point of view because you have this price that you on the case release this was 39 Euro and then you were like this is a five dollar discount off of the retail price of 45. retail ended up being 55 Euros and what the team did was shout out to Killian um who does a lot of number crunching that found a price point that was a

reasonable for us to make sure that people can still get it at a good price and we're not just totally eating everything and would allow us a nice transition to what will be the MSRP of the of the second edition which should be close to about that but I mean yeah I mean some modified content just as a general for my perspective holding this in my hand I mean it's like a slightly smaller box but um which but this this feels like you know this is a 60 game that's the weight of an 89 game I mean this is like what how much does this weigh eight pounds or am I just I don't know six but yeah maybe not that heaven but this is a real I mean this is this is also gonna have to be expensive to ship right so but it's important to talk about that I mean I know sometimes money topics are private or taboo I'm not afraid to to say that um one money has been it's it's been hard I didn't intend to run a board game business and uh one thing we didn't touch on was why did I transition to do full time and um I had a child and then had I basically lost a job um kind of back to back right after the campaign succeeded and there was sort of like a question of okay should I give this a spin and when I look back now I realized you know especially when I look at someone like you who has their job and runs their Joby as you call pencil person you did once to me and I admire that a lot and I think that that would have been a smarter decision but it's not what I did and um I think that that didn't help but

there was no team member who uh who like stopped working um because of a money topic or there wasn't like a delay at the factory because of money we have amazing partners that have put a lot of trust in us an amazing team um and we've had a lot of luck too so uh you know I wouldn't tell anybody else to do it this way no oh sure sure it was nerve-wracking that's for sure like for sure okay so um Okay so we've sort of covered off on the on the uh on what happened and I think it's important that I mean I don't know if you want to I mean ultimately you can take all responsibility but like talking about it as like no this was like development decision making you know production not like oh the printers had a covered lockdown for nine months and we couldn't solve that um and then so this game wouldn't that way this game wouldn't have happened without Joe Wiggins I'm just there's a lot of people shout out they're in the rule book but like with him when he was at Panda manufacturing this game would not exist without him at right like he's a he's a board game God basically like and so awesome and so and so but so just in terms of the backer communication right like I mean I'm sure it's like blazed into your brain but like um you know how would you like in retrospect not saying I wish we just knew everything up front or we wish there wasn't surprises like what are maybe a couple things you think you did well with backer communication um and and and maybe what were some things that you're like I we should if

you're gonna be in the if you're in this situation I would recommend XYZ which we did not do well yeah uh honesty uh we were always honest I know we didn't always say things clearly so that led to some people going wait a minute this doesn't add up to what you said before it's like I have bad communication and we were almost always um uh present I'm not sure what to say like I'm not saying we send an update every single month but we sent tons of updates um and when we would get overwhelmed in email or Kickstarter messages we would try to be available in other ways so we never like we never like ghosted at all so these are these are the things that you're saying you did well was honesty and and being staying uh you know regular regular updates and communicating yeah which is hard I any Creator out there who gets into a tough situation I feel for you like if you're not ready for thousands of people to be waiting on you it's going to be hard emotionally to get through and then I think the third thing is and I love this because I when we delivered I was like okay we delivered that's it I'm happy but there was like a podcast and I've heard this more than once where somebody said worth the wait and I was like wow that's I can't believe that those words came out of someone's mouth because that's a long way and I'm not I don't think I'm like you know the tale of the Serta over here or something you know like it's like I didn't you know I just we just wanted to make a game so I think the fact that it's landing and that it's still tracking quite well on Board Game Geek um you know we're sold out in German in Germany and we're getting

pressured really hard to reprint German at least and we're rapidly selling out in all other regions like I think we this is what I'm saying the creators should do deliver on what you promise if you're if you're saying this is going to take so long because we're doing something really good we have a strong Vision even if you get flacked for it at least do that you know sure um and and I think we did that to enough of a percentage that it was like okay you know whether or not folks love every aspect of the game and and that piece I mean there's no doubt just getting it and seeing it that it it contains the contents as promised totally and what more I mean there's more in there than we promised too because we felt bad so we're like let's put a little more right right um I I think that I think that's good advice right I think that's you know ultimately just this assuming like if you're going to go through the process of having all these people hanging on you and being late and all that make sure that you get to the end of the line and and deliver something that sort of you know makes up for it for lack of a better way of saying it I also asked what what did I do bad though oh yeah okay so what what oh the I guess those are the three good things okay what are the what what what do you think you didn't do well can we get a bit vulnerable on here is this a safe space so I didn't know something about myself that I now know thanks to our next title philosophy and it's a really important thing to know and it's that I'm autistic and I'm a high functioning um honest and I've been masking it my

entire life and stumbling through communication and and even my early communication with you as a localization partner I look back on it now and I realized like I didn't read so many social cues and so many Basics sure um and I'm not blaming anything on that but it has been an obstacle for me and I noticed that a lot of Partners and people around me say hey you're too wordy you write huge emails and I go back and I look at a lot of the updates that were confusing and the same thing was happening and I think what I'm saying from this is find out things that are your flaws and I'm not saying autism is a flaw but what it created was um often bad communication if I was the only one writing those updates and if no one was editing them and then later on we had different team members a huge shout out to tabea since she's the main one who was really helping to either write updates or edit them or even just back and forth with me don't say that like nobody cares about that and again I don't want to blame um being autistic but since I found that out I realized how often it makes it um hard for me to be understood or hard for me to understand others and I even go back and look at the comments during the kickstarter and there were times where I would be responding to somebody and I'd get sort of like a defensive response back from them and I'd be like oh why is there emotion now and then people would tell me yeah because look at the way you respond and I never it didn't add up to me you know so I think I would tell people like no matter if

you're neurotypical or neurodivergent it doesn't matter but have somebody check your language have somebody check your understandability um and make sure there's someone who's not afraid to like bark at you that's what's cool about tabea she literally will be like Dylan get out of here like sure that's important don't have someone who's like your big fan come and say oh yeah everything's good you know oh because often people who are backing a project they won't tell you they don't understand they just they'll be like this is kind of long I'm not really going to read it oh yeah I mean future thing we did we did wrong um and that I need to improve on you know and that's hard being I'm so passionate I want to answer every question I want to talk to everybody and I'm so hyped that I I sit there and I write out like paragraphs you know yeah I mean it's absolutely critical um as an individual over uh if if as you are growing and changing and and and learning right to be able to pay attention to and learn about what you're good at and what you're bad at like what your superpowers are and what your your super weaknesses are and um you know whether whether it's autism or whether it's just you have a rage problem right like there's different not that those are equivalents but like you know like whatever's your personality like some people like in you know I again not gonna start naming people but they're like people who like hey man you really just you clearly don't do this well why don't you have somebody else what are you gaining from you doing this um and you know both of us have a production background but like fundamentally

um and I think it's especially true when you like I think there are certain skill sets and certain things that people feel like everyone can be good at like I don't know like whether it's writing or communicating that seems like a generous to everybody skill um but like once you if you're making video games or complex project management you're like yeah I'm not an architect or like yeah I'm not I'm not a uh this fantastic dealer so you get used to the idea that there are just people who are way better than you at at everything and so I as a person for myself I've just come to accept that basically everyone's better than me at at just about everything and if I can find somebody better than me at something let them do it like there's nothing I see a good project manager though you know I looked up to you because you said once in a call with me no you said it in a YouTube video and I asked you to call about it you said um being good with timelines is you can just practice it and that's what that really opened up this whole thing in my head like oh I just haven't practiced this and for me um I'm not afraid to let go of something I'm just not used to it because I I you know I'm a professional glass board that's my background I just we just lost watch Blown Away season three like a week ago that's pretty awesome all right as as a total of somebody who has zero zero overlap I at least enjoyed they hit enough realism that I feel okay about it but like coming from a really rich raw art background like the last thing you ever think about is oh somebody else can do this better than you because you're a crafts person you know you're like no I'm gonna hone Mike

I'm gonna make a thousand glass cups a day until I'm just a champion of it so that's really hard to transition into like manager mode which is what I think like you um uh an executive producer at a a pretty hard video uh game company and uh she was sort of lamenting um relatively new EP and sort of like the the craziness and stress of everyday coming in and firing this and this and sort of coping with it um and it was like a ranging conversation but one of the things I mentioned was sort of like it doesn't feel like now now but like in a year two years five years everything that's like stressing you out and and giving you like just like making your life hard right now it'll be easy like you'll look back at what the challenges you face now and they'll just be like you're basic everyday like table Stakes no problem whatsoever um and so it is really a lot of these things it's just about learning understanding even even getting good at running kickstarters right um yeah just doing them again and again so I do think that overall concept of like figure out what you're good to get support certainly when it comes to communication having people review and read I mean even you know I mean I I didn't update for I did two updates I did like a sensitive water pocket update uh sensitive water update about something about the Pocket Edition and something else and like I misspelled pocket in the title and I did like three at once and Jessica who would

be the person who would normally be like looking this over uh I don't know was like Hey Team Awesome who came up with that was that you team Austin's from the original that that's me but the um but anyway and like it's just a person who would have looked at it and I don't know it was the weekend and it was 9 p.m and I like you know mistyped in in the title and like so one Kickstart is annoying because they're like oh you can't edit it I like then watched a show and the half hour passed and they're like that's burnt in forever but then you know then you also then even had the backwards like you can't even get the title spelled right in your um you know but you know it's just a good example that it really is valuable to have people look at your stuff um the two other the two other bad things I'm glad that you're like Ed stay on topic well one is the timeline that we just talked about I didn't I should have practiced timelines in any way I say this to everybody out there you can practice timeline like with your family like planning like a family outing or you could do the thing that I didn't do which is you could just release a simple game first and the third thing and this one's hard to admit being a founder of a company but I just I'm not that passionate about like pricing things it kind of scares me um because as soon as I set the accurate price I'm like oh but then maybe people don't want to buy it like you know um so it's a little hard for me to Value um my own work and I think that that would have been better to have priced it correctly because it would have put me more into sustainability um line of thought I wasn't in any sort of like how do I sustain this team how do I just you know resources wise even

financially wise just timeline wise like there's a lot of like reality that I think comes um when you have so much work after a campaign um and and so I've learned quite a lot about that but what I've learned the most is hmm maybe I should find somebody well and did you probably better doing this you know probably would have made uh had a higher outcome on your Kickstarter with a thousand less backers which is just a you know um so there's some interesting Dynamics I remember when we I did liftoff in my first campaign um and like I just I remember this like distinct thing where I just fought for every backer and we wanted that we were gonna stretch rolls and breaking whatever 50 000 and just like grinding every like at some point if you're gonna put the effort in you can go find people like if you're willing to like be on every every channel every place and just like get out there and you know do the grill marketing and and the uh boots on the ground you can get those backers um but what I came to realize was and it's not specific to the backers but like the effort to get the last whatever ten thousand dollars of lift like like created a ton of risk it was like it was like in some ways having not pushed that hard at the end would like would have been okay like it would have been okay to have a little fewer and and not have push for that one because that last like put us into put us created a bunch of things that ended up biting us on that campaign so like sometimes it took I mean I've sort of I

you know ultimately there's always different expectations for different kickstarters based on X Y or Z but from my perspective like I don't uh at some point I'm just trying to freeze it right like you do a lot of kickstarters it's like I don't need the next Kickstarter to be bigger than the last like I think a lot of Kickstarter creators are like oh my first Kickstarter was 20. I want my next one to be 40 and my next one is 40. so I want my next one to be 80. it's like you know I have a title like Mall Peak which has like a a lot of upside and upset another word but like a certain type of audience and size and price point and then I have something smaller like um expansion for diverging pests and this art project with hanafuda right and like sort of where like it's it's totally fine to have a Kickstarter that like they don't have to just be it exponentially more people and more growth right and I and I think it's easy to get caught up in in that desire for more YouTubers say that now there was an interview where Tommy in it was saying um I think with Colin and Samira on Colin Smith show uh you can't measure the success of a video just by uh its views on YouTube because that's just a game that's just an algorithmic game you could have a super high quality video that just doesn't have a good thumbnail and so that's kind of what you're saying with Kickstarter is like you can have a really dope really beautiful really wonderful game that doesn't have this big splashy um you know thousands of backers um and I and I do think that that's kind of cool about our conversation is because like I think you have found that spot where you're really just focused on the games and not worried about like the

glamor of like oh I launched these giant kickstarters look at me um yeah there's nothing to see here um the other thing I thought I thought was also interesting you know which is unique to for folks who are coming into board gaming um you know with a video game a mobile game or whatever you know price point isn't a isn't a component of cost price point is a component of just Marketplace and and you know sort of how you're looking to scale your user base and your Revenue what model you're it's like it's more of like a model whether it's a subscription or free to play or you know dollar 99 app or whatever the the thing that's really amazingly challenging about um making a physical retail product or physical product that's going into a more into effectively a supply chain and and um distribution chain is like the cost of it cost of making it the components of getting in then the you know wholesale and all the different you know steps you know people in it and what what how you're selling it all ties in and into well and then what's the value of the product just from like uh size of the Box weight of the Box complexity of the game perspective and that complexity of all those factors is not something you're gonna have like that is just inherently not something you don't you'd have experience with until you've experienced making a physical thing totally exactly that caught me completely

um like off guard especially when you talk about like viable for distribution because the percentages you pay uh or you receive you know the discount that you give to Distributors not just the stores Cuts deeply into like what you sell it for and I think I think a lot of people who buy games just kind of don't don't understand that they don't need to but I was one of those people who just buys games yeah it's certainly as a consumer it's totally different than being a uh uh uh yeah you know a manufacturer but so Okay so we've actually I mean I think this has been great it's been pretty ranging um you know at some point in this conversation you did mention uh philosophy and an upcoming Kickstarter so you have gotten to the other and actually somewhere in the middle and I don't know where it was in our knowing each other but I did a preview of tower of of Son Of The Sun um very very very very very cool game but this was like at some point you know I have this I have this graveyard of uh videos I've done for Kickstarter creators that like never got released and everything it's in the ice box ice box anyway you know once in a while I reach out to folks like hey is it what's and and basically at the time you're like we've decided that we shouldn't do this until we fulfilled and finished season and all that which is totally inappropriate decision by the way um but you you've now fulfilled yeah right you so so are you smarter better faster and back on Kickstarter or what's your like what what's your mentality going forward yes okay so um the mentality is

whenever we go oh we're ready to launch Towers we stop and go wait are we really um the tower's base game has now been through enough core development that anything happening is like balance like there's a 25 or 22 crystals in the Box there's no changes to the Core Design Systems and if we noticed something um we would need to say we're not changing and and say oh second edition um there's a couple of potential small um expansions or things that were in the base game that we thought weren't good to learn for a first time player that are optional and right now we're trying to either green light or red light those before the kickstarter and if something doesn't get green lit before the kickstarter it's automatically red lit meaning it won't be part of it um we've already gotten quotes um already distribution and Retail viable from the quotes that we've seen um we haven't done like graphic design for the rulebook because we expect to get some feedback during the campaign and that's okay but you will see when a Kickstarter for Towers goes up you will see a much longer uh timeline Intel delivery that's well and that's I mean level of text perspective is much less you know that's an abstract strategy game like it's much less and even with the expansion stuff um it's nothing on the magnitude that sees the bean was right I can actually just show a couple components just for fun for people that don't know the game yeah

you're you're you're creating these towers and you're moving yeah Guardians Legends here whatever those are Gods around the board um so we wanted to go to Kickstarter in September we have announced a date and that is overlapping with Spiel um and we've started to talk to press and the shipping times we're seeing to get press copies out we're not 100 sure if the best time for that is like before an overlapping English feel or if it might be better to move after so I can't say anything about that because we're still discussing with the designer so then maybe I'm a little confused so which is the next Kickstarter you're playing today or philosophy I'm getting that so the reason why I talk about Towers first is because it's a true crowdfunded game meaning we're going to bring it to crowdfunding where it's 80 done we need to do some print file work afterwards um it's not just like fund and hit print and that's okay we feel okay about that we've learned a lot and I will actually write up a blog post of all the stuff that we talked about in this video and more about what we learned on seize the bean and what we're changing on Towers because we know that it would help people to you know be able to read through that and get some confidence however in the meantime we have a completely done game I'm literally holding the pre-production copy this is done done done the English the German rule books are done the factory samples

are done um there's nothing to do on this game this is complete we just need to hit print so this is philosophy and um we originally were going to take this direct to retail and it was really hard to write the blog post that I wrote on BGG about it but I needed to admit that if I learned anything about business ownership it was don't take unnecessary large risks and Freight has just increased way too much cost of materials has increased way too much and I just don't think that it's a smart decision to not run a sort of pre-order campaign if you will and people can look at that and say oh well you're just going to a crowdfunding platform for reach and they would be right that's right we're paying a percentage of our pre-order money that we would get for running a pre-order on our website to have wider reach and we think that that is the right thing to do for the designer of the game and the artist of the game and the team so we're actually running this one as soon as possible and we're running it on game found we'd like to test that platform the reason Towers is going to Kickstarter is that again it's a true crowdfund campaign and I know Kickstarter better because I did it before sure and game found one we don't want to confuse anybody about what's going on so we thought okay let's do a different platform so we can have a clear message this is a pre-order campaign this is a crowdfund campaign in the sense of what kind of work well yeah I mean I mean that that seems to make sense because certainly not that I'm in anyway an expert on game

um found but the you know the idea of a pre-order is a little trickier I think on Kickstarter it sounds like it's not as as it's a little bit more common on game of Fountain perhaps we also don't really like the state that kickstarter's in right now we're really excited about seeing what backer kit does and we're sort of undecided so that's why we're trying different platforms and this just felt like a cool opportunity to kind of run them back to back so um the only catch about the game found campaign is that since we've never worked with them before there was a little bit more Hoops to jump through for things like business verification it's totally fine it's just taken like a week or two longer than we had hoped and we're thinking and we spoke with the designer actually this week we're thinking it would be better to move that campaign to August 29th so it was originally August 15th uh so in about a week week for Monday and we decided let's let's give it a little bit more time to make sure that the campaign page is approved by game found sure you you don't wanna you I mean I mean that's all it's all part of it right it's all part of uh learning and getting better at these at Kickstarter and crowdfunding in general is sort of you know again being willing to push or adjust dates or think about you know Readiness um and and resist the urge to to to just go because there's some idea that you need to go and yeah and yeah and so I think that that you know that's a general lesson or general things that crowdfunder should keep in mind is just

like you don't never have to do anything I mean like there's lots of external designers you might contractually have to okay be careful writing contracts that like force you to go to a market before you're ready but shout out to Galen goodwick for being an awesome and really understanding designer for allowing us to like move things around sure no no so it's interesting it's interesting uh maybe sometimes we can we can compare contracts my typically for the crowdfunding stuff my contracts go so far as to say Kickstarter might not even happen and it might not fund right like those are outcomes um can I ask something to your audience maybe they might not respond we'll see what they if they got this far but go ahead ask ask away okay do y'all want to see US Open Source our designer contracts because uh I think what Jamie did over the Stone Mountain games he wrote a blog post about their contract but didn't release it and I spent a lot of years literally years putting together a contract that balanced between the publisher and the designer well and I was thinking maybe it'd be cool to open source it to the uh board game Community but I'd have to talk to our lawyer about that yeah so I can I can answer this question yeah the interest in the broad gaming space for template contracts is through the roof I you know I mean not it's not like there's that many Publishers but like the amount of times I get asked for contracts is high however big yes right however well I'm thinking I'm answering the interest however you know ultimately you know you know contracts are never perfect

never complete never necessarily representing the type of business operations you want to run they're all different um and so the reason I've almost I've never published I mean I'll give like planning sheets and other things but the reason I've never been like oh here's a template contract for y'all to use is because like I don't want to like I I feel like it's inherently assuming responsibility where you're saying oh if you discover a problem with this you can like get upset with me about providing attention as a problem right and like potentially potentially if it was actually provided like you'd need a I almost feel like you would need a legal disclaimer in front of the consequences I understand that in using this contract I do not hold quality based or Dylan or whomever responsible for any outcomes in any legal situation right um that there might be I would I wouldn't be surprised if in like general contract law there's like a cause that already exists for the sanity of lawyers but um I'm not aware of it so that's what the reason I've hesitated a few times in a cool idea but be careful basically yeah I mean I mean if you have a lawyer you can look into it now I mean I've um I mean it's also there's also interesting things where like a German law is not the same as U.S law which is not the same as California which is not the same oh for sure um yeah and so and there's some gotchas there but um but I could at least tell you that the interest is there um okay whether or not we'll see let us know in the comments they'll take a safer out like Ed said or should we go wild

just put a disclaimer on it make it have a click through but um no I do think the interest is there um they're actually some really good I think the um I'm feel bad for not remembering their site but the guy they have like the you know cardboard Edison oh yeah thank you cardboard isn't thank you see uh who you know has some really good digests on like the types of terms that you might see in a contract totally yeah that's the kind of thing I thought like maybe like maybe even providing it to someone like that so that they can do the disclaimer you know but um but so listen we've we've been on for for a good 50 minutes um I thought this was fascinating and certainly I think for folks who um are perhaps in the situation or feel themselves teetering into it or leading into a Kickstarter um some really great information in here and so I guess upcoming just in sort of like news from quality Beast one philosophical is going to be philosophy I believe we'll make official announcement by the time this this video drops but August 29th on game found and it's basically a pre-order campaign as soon as campaign is over we're going to push print and then we won't have anything to do which is why we'll then be preparing towers of the sun which will announce if the kickstarter is moving or not we just want to give it the appropriate space and it might be better to not have it overlap Spiel but we'll see what the designer Stephon Blackman says about that because he's the boss

awesome all right thanks so much for being on and thanks so much for your um openness and honesty I think it's it's super super great yeah thanks for having me Ed and thanks for everybody out there who backseats the bean and stayed with us through that Journey absolutely absolutely and thanks for watching bye ciao everybody Edo here and thanks for watching gaming with Edo reviews over here on this playlist league and Insider videos over here on this one subscribe share all that good stuff but most importantly play some great games thanks bye

Progress saved