The Mill Is A Sponsored Show... and Yes, IMO, P/Reviewers Should Be Paid - The Mill
Transcript
hello and welcome to the mill i'm your host dusty crane and you may notice there's a little pop-up here on the screen that says paid content and i want to talk about that because that is the talk of social media right now our board game social media right now is whether or not it's okay to pay reviewers or previewers of your product and so being that i am a sponsored show which if you've read i've been very open about it it's in the introduction to welcome to the mill like you go to the youtube page it's the very first thing you see and i discuss kind of the concept of this channel but also in the description of every video and it has been this way since the start the description of every video says this is a sponsored show and it goes into the relationship that i have with stonewire games and our agreement for being a sponsored show and so i wanted to be even more transparent about that to explain um what i do and don't do on the behest of stoneware games and so let's talk about the original agreement that jamie and i you know when we were started talking about the mill um i have been for a very long time now a i'm not going to say super fan because i'm definitely not one of those people that's played like wingspan 700 times or size 700 times but like i've been a huge fan of stoneware games and to be
perfectly uh honest with you a a big fan of jamie's as well due to the transparency and you know how honesty is but also the fact that even before i was a customer of stonewayer games he offered me incredible customer support um i i don't want to get into exactly what that that that interaction was because i don't want to encourage other people to do what i've done um but even before i was a customer i asked something of him and he actually did it and i asked to reimburse him for it and he was no unnecessary so that went a long way to kind of um i guess endearing me to him in the brand and just as time went on i was somebody that was very active in the forums the facebook page that kind of stuff and on the wednesday live streams and so we just kind of got to talking about what the mill before it had a name you know what a youtube channel dedicated to stonewire games actually might look like and so you know we talked about it a little bit and here was the thing and i mentioned it in the the description every single time the show notes jamie has never told me what i can and can't cover what i should be talking about what i shouldn't be talking about it's i don't get it i get the same emails that every um reviewer and previewer get in that it the instructions be honest and um uh
there's no like talking points like i know sometimes like if you go to a a product and there's like a press release it's like hey this is these are the the facts about this product and it's all kind of written in marketing speak incredible new thing you know wonderful interactions you know it's very much like hyperbole hyperbole hyperbole um so it's been nothing like that i i could i could but i haven't had the the need to yet like i could like trash certain things if i wanted to but that's not who i am and that's not um i don't enjoy doing it it serves no purpose now i said that it makes it sound like i have an axe to grind with a stoneware game and i don't but i was just saying like there's also been that talk around uh tabletop games too right that that some people really want negativity in their reviews or they if there's not enough negativity they feel like maybe it's not honest um and then you know other reviewers have come forward and said like if there's a game i don't like i'm just not going to review it i'm not going to spend my time you know putting together something some content for something that i really dislike and um and so like i i feel like even though i don't do reviews or previews um or i guess i do previews because i show you guys stuff before um it's available to you know the general public but otherwise like i don't tell you this
thing is good or or whatever unless it's my opinion um and even that i don't think i've i i guess someone can correct me very wrong but i've never ever done the whole like you need to buy this and you need to go get this today um even though there's certainly some games in my some snowmeier games in my collection that that i feel that way about that i'm like this should be in everyone's collection um but again i wanted to talk about the fact that this is a sponsored show and what that means so as i mentioned jamie doesn't tell me what to talk about what not to talk about um there's no you know the only times he's ever offered his opinion on the channel at all is when i've asked him for it and um you know the things in terms of like what i've asked for were um okay so here's a perfect example of really probably the closest i've come to maybe compromising something i've produced and i i think it also speaks uh well to jamie so let's talk about a video that i made um i think when tapestry first came out and i was doing the unboxing and as i was doing and when i do the unboxing like it's still in shrink so i have no idea what's in the box um and so i i take the shrink off of of tapestry and take the lid off and one of the the the sealed decks of cards had slid
all over the instructions and it seems like maybe it got over top of it and underneath it because one of the or a couple of the the papers that were in there um i don't think it was the rule book i think it was like the the solo mode um it got wrinkled up pretty badly like it was obviously still with you know usable i could read everything like it was just you know there are some hard creases in there that you're not gonna get out like this um i guess in like trading card parlons like there was nothing um what meant about it so you know i i did that video and i put it together i edited i posted it online and it seemed like there were several comments like right off the bat that people were like oh man look at this thing was trashed and shipping and like this thing wasn't secured and maybe i should wait till the next um you know the next print run and i felt really bad because um and i don't know why but i felt really bad because like it instead of focusing on the stuff that i thought was really cool about tapestry it seemed like the focus then became hey look how these cards like slid around and and uh wrecked some of the documentation and you know maybe i should wait and i felt guilty for a minute and and i actually reached out to jamie um and said you know i'm hearing you know instead of people talking about like the unboxing like some some conversation about things getting destroyed would you
prefer if i you know i guess offered some kind of disclaimer or like cut that part of the video out entirely and to his credit jamie uh said absolutely not you know that was your unboxing experience that is why you know that is part of what i wanted the mill to be is i wanted that whatever that unboxing experience is like because he'd i mean he never told me make unboxing videos but like that's something i decided to do but whatever i made he wanted to be honest so he said no keep it up there thank you for letting me know um about you know the damage because i maybe he hadn't seen the video uh thank you thank you for letting me know about it i'm gonna reach out to panda and see if there's like maybe a better place we can put that deck of cards or or what can be done to prevent this to happening to somebody else and um you know don't feel bad about the video at all that was your experience that should be out there for people to see and from that point on um like i've never had any question about whether you know if i did an unboxing if something was destroyed hey that was my experience now thankfully it hasn't happened uh since then but um you know there hasn't been a whole lot of stuff since tapestry but uh but still you know honesty very important and so something that i i certainly appreciated so let's get into the the paid to uh is it
okay to pay reviewers or previewers and i think i don't think there's any question at least not in my mind that it's unfair to ask people to work for free and i know that compared to some youtube channels like this doesn't look like a whole lot like oh he sat down in front of a camera and you shoot but it took me about 30 minutes to set things up like i don't have a studio so like it took me like 30 45 minutes to set this up and then you know to get all the everything hooked up you know there's wires there's cables there's lighting there's like there's all this stuff and that's like 30 or 45 minutes i could be doing something else you know it's like i i enjoy talking to you guys like this um but at the same time if like i know that i'm not going to be you know the next breakout youtube star like i have a very of a very niche focus and a very niche hobby right like i'm not i'm never going to be doing the the page views or the video views in the millions and believe me i'm totally fine with that i i don't want anything to do with the attention that brings i'm sure um but at the same time if that money wasn't there if the sponsorship dollars weren't there the mill would be i think there'd probably still be opportunities where i'd be excited enough to like come on
camera and like share stuff with you guys um but i don't think the audience would be there right like i don't think and that's fine because like i'm not like producing videos because i'm like hey a thousand people saw that or 2 000 people saw that or seven people saw that because certainly i have stuff on my personal uh youtube channel that i've made it was for me it was like putting together the lego iron man pieces that you saw in my office um a few videos back um that was just fun to do you know so so there's certainly something to be said and you know for those fun videos you do absolutely do them but you do them for the love of it um to sit down here week after week after week and produce something you know even you're just not passionate and excited about the thing you're passionate excited about at the same level day in day out i mean maybe you are maybe i'm actually just revealing my own flaws i don't know um but the sponsorship is really what allows me to keep doing this um it's what helps me um i guess find the incentive to to keep doing this week after week i like i said i i enjoyed talking to the folks you that that talk to me you know either in the comments or if we talk on twitter or on facebook like whatever that is like i really enjoy that but like i think i wouldn't i would obviously enjoy that whether or not i was doing a youtube video or not right
um so so yeah so like i think i think it's wrong to expect people to work for free um now let's talk about reviewers now i don't do reviews um at all and that was actually something that jamie was very clear about right from the get-go do whatever you want on the channel but no reviews you know i'm paying you i don't want there to be any specter of bias um but here's the thing about bias um you have it whether or not you i guess whether or not you're being paid or not like the interaction i had with jamie before i was a paid customer of stoneware games biased me towards the company that experience you know was something that made me go yeah i like him i like you know i like his company and you know there's all kinds of experiences that will bias somebody um so i i in and of itself bias is is i don't think it's anything that can be avoided and i don't think that um it's inherently bad i think there's you have good biases too um you know there are some people like for example like you meet another random board gamer at work and you're biased towards liking them because you like board games big deal um as for reviewers i think this largely comes down to
the relationship that these people these reviewers have with the people they're reviewing for i would hope and i'm sure this is certainly not the case but i would hope that any publisher that sends a game to a reviewer does so with the expectation that they be honest with you because why would you want to build as somebody running a youtube channel why would you want to establish create a relationship with your viewers because let's make no mistake about it you got a relationship um why would you want a relationship based on lies like i don't want the people that are making videos for me to lie to me like if i'm going to spend the time to watch their content like i want it to be an honest relationship so i'm hopeful that you know the people that are doing these reviews and previews are being honest and are being encouraged to be honest i don't have a problem with overly positive reviewers so just for a second um one of the i'm going to say one of the reviewers that seems to love everything is rado and that makes sense because he's he's got an audience he's got a following and he has enough of those things that
he can be selective about the games he brings in you know he's been very you know honest on and candid on his channel too saying um i don't we don't like take tax he's he's usually playing two players he's usually playing with his wife they don't like take that they don't like what that feels like and so they you know rado can turn away you know copies of games that feature mechanics that he doesn't like um and so as a result a lot of the content he makes or all of the content he makes is stuff that he likes and i don't think there's anything wrong with that and i think it's i think it would be especially if you're somebody who's enthusiastic about board games i think it would be insincere for rado to like i'm lowering it down to two and i'm just gonna be like rado runs through another game of blah blah blah you know that's not what that's not what you're going to rattle for like you're going there for him to be a little bit you know whooped up or uh whipped up into a you know into a froth and all excited about what he's talking about it feels good to talk to people that are excited about what they're excited about and um again i think that's a good thing i think promoting positivity is a good thing as for um you know as for paying somebody so like i i think it would be absolutely wrong to for a game company that you know this this game is highly take that and they're like hey
rado we want you to do this video um we'll pay you 500 but it needs to be in the same tone as your other videos and um we don't need to drag in it don't do it it would be wrong for rado to take that money um but at the same time i i at the same time i think it would be wrong for somebody to send rado a game and expect him to put all of his time into a review and you know just for i guess whatever money the views generate like i think you should pay people for their content but i also think that you should pay people with the full expectation that they be honest i think that's a great thing that jamie did in approaching me and if you didn't know and you've made it this long um into this video if you didn't know when jamie sends out requests to previewers or to or actual to reviewers everyone who he sends those notices to um he says he doesn't watch reviews of his games like he watches reviews of other games but he doesn't watch reviews of his games because he acknowledges the fact that he's human he says i don't want to be negatively impacted by you know let's say let's say he sends me let's say i'm a reviewer and he sends me a copy of scythe and i just hate it you know and
i'm just like how could anyone make a game this awful it's terrible you know this or that or whatever it is um and what i mean what kind of idiot thought this was even a good thing you know of course as as the person who made the thing you're going to be super defensive and it's to be very hard to look past that when you see that person again like you're i don't want to send him a copy of you know viticulture i mean look at anybody trashed scythe you know it's like i think that's a natural human reaction and so for that reason jamie doesn't watch reviews and and i i don't know if he's encouraged the rest of you know stoneware games alex and um you know whether he he's indicated to um joe that he shouldn't watch any reviews i i don't know how far that goes but i do know that he doesn't because he doesn't want to be biased and he wants that honesty on camera and he wants that honesty in front of you and um i i think i think that should be ultimately what every publisher wants and i think that's a great practice don't watch reviews of your own stuff you know if you're you're sending stuff out like especially in india i understand that you know you have to be a little bit more select about who you send stuff out but man even if you are an indie publisher and you're making you're really stretching yourself then to put 300 copies of a game out there you obviously thought enough of that game that thought it needed to be made please encourage your reviewers whoever
you decide upon to just be honest just be honest because the good games are gonna you know are gonna get attention and in the the mediocre and bad ones are gonna are gonna fall away um but even then what's bad to one person is good to another what's mediocre to somebody is brilliant to another and i think that's that's part of this too i think somewhere along the lines here i am old man yelling at clouds somewhere along the lines we decided that we didn't want to think for ourselves that we wanted somebody to tell us how to how to feel and you don't see it um and so like i i guess at least that have heard it told to me that the news used to just state facts and they didn't spin it one way or another it wasn't feel this way think this way it was very much here's the facts do with them what you want and maybe it was never that way maybe that's you know someone you know waxing poetic about the the golden years or whatever the the better days were um because the better days are always before these days right um i think i think that ultimately um the onus the responsibility for determining whether a game is for you is ultimately on you it shouldn't like i can understand if there's somebody in
gaming that's making videos that you're like i agree with their opinions like most of the games the games they love i love the games they don't like i don't like um so you can certainly use them as um you know maybe a reference to see how do i i don't know how i feel about this am i gonna like this um but it's not everything it's not everything if you are somebody who will say you know is is a tight budget and so you aren't buying you know multiple board games a week or a month or whatever you know you're budgeting for what you bring in more so than any like you really should do the homework um and make sure like watch some playthroughs probably play throughs probably more than anything to to see if that is something that is legitimately going to resonate with you that you're going to um and don't put it on you know these reviewers that like you said this game was great i hated it okay they gave you their opinion and your opinion differs from theirs well i mean you know we've all heard sayings about what opinions are you know um and everyone's got one but um yeah so like i guess i i don't in particularly understand or in particular understand the the really heavy-handed disagreement with with paying people for their work
i i do disagree with paying people for favorable outcomes i definitely think that's wrong i i do agree with paying people to just be honest if if the the put in the work to produce the content then you know paying for it it's a no-brainer really in my opinion um i do understand again the whole like well if this person pays you you're gonna be biased are you somebody who is prone to that i mean you do you know that about yourself again like i said i don't think i don't think bias i'm going to start talking in circles here bias is just a natural thing um but hopefully you care more about your integrity and being honest than you do about um you know that game i think it's easier to just not talk about stuff now in my case i talk about stoneware games if i don't like a stoneware game i gotta do some content for it because you know it was sent to me i got at least show you an unboxing um i don't have to do anything else about it i can just go ahead and you know summarize jamie's wednesday videos or the blog posts or the videos that he puts out there i could i could do that um in in sometimes i do that because you know that's what i've had time to do um but um they're i guess more than anything
i i just wanted to explain why you're going to start seeing the the paid content notice and why um you know why i guess i i think we should encourage people to pay for uh you know other people's time um because even though you know it's fun you know to see a little audience grow up around your channel um ultimately it's a lot of work i mean it's a lot of work like go talk to anybody who's making you know videos and they're actually putting some effort into you know filming and editing and um you know talk to them about you know the preparations you know especially you know somebody who's doing just like you know beautiful um videography work like somebody's putting together videos that look sharp like uh tim um and i'll link to his stuff and stuff that you know people that are putting together videos that look like sam's over at lord of the board um you know people that are putting together just almost art really um that doesn't just happen it's a lot of work it's a lot of effort and they deserve um you know any funding that is is sent their way provided that they're being honest with you you know hopefully the companies that they're working with don't have thin skin and they're able to take a little bit of criticism when it's warranted but also if if they legitimately enjoy what they're presenting then man revel in it revel in it enjo be excited too have
some fun too um i i think i think that's uh that's something worth doing and um i i'm just gonna go ahead and say uh in the comments this week if you have any questions on the sponsorship or you know how things happened or you know what i'm paid for or how things usually work like whatever you have question wise feel free to toss them out there um i'll be honest with you i i have been honest with you um in in like i i mentioned i think the one time i waffled and jamie stood me right up and and and said hey this is what i expect you you know be honest put it out there and you know i did and i have continued to do so and um so i'm yeah i'm a sponsored show and i'm proud of it i'm proud of the the the channel i'm proud of the stuff that we've put together um i'm proud of the the company that that is sponsoring me and their the responsibility in my opinion that they're you know showing in the leadership that they're showing in some of their initiatives their by poc initiative the the geek weight of the west sponsorship and um you know trying to get um you know more uh more diversity in the the people we see around the table all things that i agree with and i am proud of and yeah that um didn't i really didn't think i had this much time worth of stuff to talk about but um it turns out pretty passionate about
it i guess so that's good let's see here's some news i guess i should throw in some stonewire news here before i call it a video wingspan is officially available on ios and ipad os that was finally released i think it's a ten dollar app a little bit on the pricey side but um it is every bit the app or you know the the the steam version on your pc or your nintendo switch or wherever you have it xbox um every bit it's it's the same thing so i can understand that price tag and and i paid it and it's worth it um i i probably could have reached out for a key but no i'm going to pay the developers they they put together something great um and i want to see the european expansion uh ported i want to see the oceania expansion ported um so i'm gonna i'm gonna send the money that way and um oh there is also a between two cities app that was mentioned in a digital app newsletter that went out um you can there's little variety of areas like you can indicate interest in stoneware stuff and so they sent a digital news newsletter that just kind of gave the latest on you know their apps and stuff like that and what's available and uh noticed between two cities listed there um take a look at the app store listing and see if um i do think what you see in the app store listing is very um accurate as to what that app looks
like so if that's for you take a look and and pick that up i do think it's probably better if you have a call at least one or two other people that um will will play with you online um the ai i haven't had a chance to goof around with yet too much but maybe i'll get around to it i think the tutorial needs a little bit of work but uh it you know if you know how to play the game then you're you're good to go that is all i have for you this week a whole long video but um important stuff i think if you hung around for the entire thing thank you so much and if you didn't well i get it that's all i have for you until next time take care of yourselves and each other thanks for watching
bye you