In Defense of Analysis Paralysis
Transcript
hey everyone this is me the undead Viking I'm here to talk to you about well just something that it came up in actually a uh I was playing a game with a few of my friends and then I don't know if I happen to like stumble across a video or whatever I I I don't know but it's been stuck in my head for a little while uh so I've played thousands of board games at this point in my life and uh I often say um I kind of I guess and not to be I don't know I know this might come across as a little little arrogant or whatever um but it's one of those things where it's like I feel like if you've done a lot of something um your opinion on that something is is it can be completely wrong don't get me wrong as far as that goes you you could be completely and totally uh inaccurate but I do think that you have uh more of a base uh for your um your ability to come to a conclusion if you will so I'm in a situation where with the number of board games I've played um with the amount of hours I spent at a table playing board games and and for that matter being at at a table playing any sort of tabletop game be it role play games miniature games board games I mean I've done all of those things and they've been part of my life for decades um I I I I guess I feel like my opinion is
a bit of an informed one but it doesn't mean a good right and you can disagree with uh that being said there are very few games that I if I ever when I did videos and did reviews on a more regular basis instead of like just the few I do a year now um if I found a game that like if I did did like an actual rating like I never did ratings I never said I just said the game was good or in rare cases uh when I played a game that I didn't like that I wanted to take the time to make a video um I would say it was bad so um but for myself and not for the people that watch my videos I do ratings I do consider I I used to keep up to date with my ratings on BGG a long long time ago um recently I've been trying to actually update my uh uh my on borging geek update my uh uh collection uh and if you go and you find me on not that I'm asking you to go creep on me or anything but if you go find under Viking AB borging Beek you'll see that there are way more games in the previously owned than they actually owned um you know so if you want to have a giggle about that you can go do that but um one of the things about being a board gamer is that there's all these different types of board games you play and uh one of the genres that um I've only ever really dipped my toes in I've
never actually played too much of um are war games uh there are some solitire war games that I've played um that I've enjoyed uh uh B7 Flying Fortress um most of the solo sub games I've played I've enjoyed those um why do I and I think that's one of those things where I enjoy them because um uh I found myself prepping for it getting excited to do it and then just letting the story kind of tell itself if you will I played a few coin games um I'm thinking about getting that uh guest of Robin Hood game um more because I think I'm going to be able to convince uh my son to play that with me um maybe in a year or so uh and I think that uh he would really like it um I haven't played it yet so I got of need to get pick that up that's a coin game it's like supposed to be like the intro level uh to coin games and I I think that would be good now the funny thing is is that I don't see myself actually taking that and actually expanding into deeper coin games I I've played a few of them I've enjoyed them but I've loved the fact that somebody else was there that knew how to play was able to teach it to me and then I was a they were able to dumb it down for me enough that I was able to grasp them so anyway I'm getting way off topic here the reason I was going to talk about war games is I was going to bring up Chad Jensen um Chad Jensen uh has designed for me um three
of the best games that I've ever played and if I have tens these are in the tens um these also designed games that weren't great uh in my opinion but regardless um if you known me or if you watch my videos you know I always said uh you know dominant species is is a fantastic game I I I love playing that game recently there was a board game meet up and I got there like a half hour late and they had started up a game of dominant species and even though I did not have the requisite amount of time to was going to take for them to play that game I was very disappointed that I wasn't able to play because that isn't a game that um that is that is small that is short and you need people that are going to be dedicated to that time to get your enjoyment out of it and I was very very disappointed um that I was unable uh to to to get there for that um I would have like canceled other plans to be able to sit there and play uh and then um the do species um marine version also very good uh and sadly um you know came out after Chad Jensen's far to uh untimely uh passing um which sucked uh but uh and I'm not here to bring things down but and also urban sprawl now Urban spraw is a game that I think that um I and very few people actually really really enjoyed it came out and a lot of
people um really took it to task if you will uh and and one of the things that people uh did not like about it was the propensity of it creating um analysis paralysis which if you watch the title of this video is the whole reason why I'm here to talk about um I can remember people saying this game's really good but we need to have a timer for people's terms and I remember I said well that's stupid I mean we don't need a timer you know for for these things and I've as much as I've enjoyed urban sprawl I've managed to get it to the table maybe 10 times since the game came out and I think that game came out I mean I I could look it up right now on my computer but I'm not going to um um I'm going to guess it's at least I'm going to guess it's somewhere between 8 to 10 years old at this point um and that's just a random stab but I mean for a game that I consider to be as good as it is as like a 10 for me um the fact that I don't get to play it that often you know it's kind of uh I'm alone I guess in my opinion of the game um and I'm not here to review that game again I think I did a video review of it a million years ago you can go check that out if you would will um and you maybe you've played it and whatever and if you want to leave your comments below and and tell me what you think of it go ahead I'll respond to them but I'm here to defend analysis paralysis and this is actually going to
be a very very quick explanation is why I don't have a problem and I've said this before I mean back when I was like people had me on podcasts and people um like ask me questions at at conventions or whatever and we would discuss analysis this why I would say I don't have a problem with it I don't have a problem with the fact that people take a long time on their term and ultimately what it is for me is that when I'm playing a game I want to be able to make you know and it's self serving a little bit for myself is the fact that I want to be able to take all the time I need to feel like I'm making the right decision to give me the best chance of winning now I know this mentality of like it doesn't matter if you win or lose just try to have fun well the problem is is that like I don't have fun unless I'm competitive in the game if if like I'm I'm losing and I'm not doing well I tend to growse and lose interest in what I am what what's going on um one of the reasons why there's a lot of games I really don't like is that like you feel like you're winning and then you find out at the end that you you were losing the entire time I don't like that I don't like that feeling of having the rug pulled up from underneath you um it's it's and that's another topic I'm not going to dive too too far into that um I remember just as a and mean this is a
bit of self ag ag rization here um they I was recently playing a game of space base uh with a few of my friends at that same board game meet up and I I enjoy that game I enjoy space Bas a lot and I remember I was just having horrible horrible luck and I think I told this story already and I apologize for that if you watch these videos a lot um but he he uh there there is this wonderful gentleman uh and his name eludes me uh for the moment but but I I just thoroughly enjoy playing games with him because he's very droll and very sarcastic and just his sense of humor Just Hits on every single button for me um but he he said um as I was sitting there grousing about my bad luck about the bad dice rolls and whatever and it's like ah yes uh Lance will Lance will gripe and grouch and complain and as he grinds his wayy in another Victory and and sure enough at the end of SP the whole thing of space Bas that's exactly what happened I I I I bemoaned my bad luck the entire time and then I ended up winning the game so um it was fun but regardless analysis paralysis I think the people should be have should have as much time as they need within reason take you know within reason as much time as they need to determine what they need to do on their
turn and this kind of goes to my whole process of like the um the equivalency at the table should be for for be as as even as possible for everybody that's involved um and this is kind of difficult in some situations like if you sit down to play war of the ring with somebody who's played the game a 100 times I mean more often than that that person's going to just you know you know beat the stuffing out of you I mean there's some random elements and things like that you can get lucky but you know people that understand the strategies understand what they need to do to win they're more often than not they're going to defeat the people that aren't now there are extreme uh to trying to get equivalency right I mean I there is a pretty famous person on board G geek I'm not going to mention uh their their their posting name um but uh and I you know I'm pretty sure this person wouldn't care uh if if if I if I mention them my name but it's not mine to say uh but the it was a pretty famous person who who will say that in games like that you should seek to have everybody in the same playing field as much as possible including giving people hints and tips on their turn even if they're not asked for so they can they can achieve the best possible results so the group as a whole has the most competitive field as possible um the
idea is is that beating down on somebody who doesn't know what they're doing doesn't give the person that's actually winning a real win and and the person that that doesn't know what they're doing they're not going to want to play that game again because of the fact that you know their their experience with the game is very negative and I and and to to a certain degree I agree with that I mean one of the things that this person says a lot is that if there's any sort of um hidden scoring that goes on in the game um then people should be allowed to have a notepad out and then keep track of other people's scores as they go and the reason behind that is is that it's quite possible somebody at the table might have a better form of identic memory that allows them to mentally keep track of everybody else's scores and they know exactly where they are and that should like even things out you know and and so there's extremes like that's kind of weird you know in my opinion but I also get it right it's on the same page as having the as even as possible so my my point here with analysis paralysis is that some people might be able to see the path of the victory that they want to achieve in on a given term they they know that I I can do x y and z and then that will give me you know 17 points and that's the best possible option for me whereas for other people seeing that X Y and Z for 17 points isn't as evident for them and they need to take some time to figure that out and get to that point and it is made worse
for that person if they are trying to achieve that now there might be people that are like I don't care if I win or lose doesn't doesn't matter to me let me just play and if I don't if I if if I do ABC for seven points instead of XYZ for 17 I'm fine with that and we can move on because they don't want to for a lot of reasons one they don't like taking a lot of time two it causes them anxiety over the fact that they know the other people are waiting on them um you know lots of different possibilities and and and that's fine and that and that's okay um then go at it but if a person is like I want to figure out exactly what I should do and I want to do as good as possible and and and figure this out and do exactly what I need to do then I think that it should be allowed right I think that it should that person should be given you know three four five minutes to figure out their turn and take their turn and do it and the thing is is that like in some situations you will see a table of people playing at like a convention and you will see three or four people you know men and women just sitting there playing a game and you can tell one person's taking their turn and the other ones are sitting in quiet silence let letting them decide maybe they're having a a conversation amongst each other uh while they wait for that person to complete it and that's fine and here's the deal I don't care if if my buddy is is is sitting over there and they're they're they're they're trying to
mentally figure out their turn and it is a game with three four people then I can have that conversation with other people and the whole point of the game I mean the game's the point right but the community of the game is for me as equally as important um so being able to sit down and have like some time some uninterrupted time where we can all talk and discuss and and figure out exactly what's going on and determine things amongst each other and talk about life talk about our families talk about our jobs talk about the world you know that's part of it as well and um yeah I mean it's just that's it right that's my stance and I do think also that like if somebody's taking three minutes four minutes five minutes on their turn to figure out what they want to do um when I see somebody being kind of a jerk like hey come on move on let's go let's take your turn it's like one I think it's a little like rude right and I understand people are saying well the person Tak long time is rude but two you know it's just like also usually that person is like trying to egg that person to make their decision because they see the thing they want to do and they want to make sure that that option is still available to them and they feel like if they can Rush that person then maybe they won't see that that spot or that opportunity or that combination or whatever and I mean I guess it comes down to is just like um for me uh you
know being nice right you're you're you're playing a game you know you're not you're not like using a bomb with only one minute to go right uh you you you you can take the time you you can relax I mean I'll say this if somebody's taking five minutes to make a decision about what they're going to do on Uno then fine go for it you know have at it uh you know just throw the person out of the game and move on with your lives but if if it's if you like you know you're sitting down to play you know anything that's even like you know like has a little bit of RIT to it um give some people some space give some people some time and and like and in my opinion like it's like hey do you do you need some help with your turn I mean and an offer kindly it's like oh hey don't you know and you can do it in such a way that will seem um not pushy I guess and I think that that's good point too just the golden rule of treat PE treat people the way you want to be treated kind of falls into play hereit and I know there's a lot of what's the word I'm looking for here I know there's there's there's a there's a lot of vager here and there's a lot of different opportunities in a lot of different situations that have different applications for different uh problems and I'm sure somebody out there who watches this will like say wait a minute no I had a situation like this and this
person was a complete jerk about were taking so long on their turn and that's like yeah exceptions are going to exist but for the most part just let some people breathe let the room breathe just relax and and and and the game will the game will be over before you know it and and and you want everybody there to have feel like they had a good time and also feel like they had a good time with you so there it is um thank you for watching this uh you might be watching this on my Undead Viking videos channel you might be watching this on my gray fox games Channel I do ask and I I I rarely ask these things but if you are happen to watch on one of those channels and you're not watching it on the other channel um please go and subscribe hit the Bell do the things to notify or whatever um leave some comments leave some likes do the thing um just basically because I mean I'm I'm I'm trying to do one of these every week I'm going to try to hold on to that that that schedule as long as possible um when I when I see people actually responding and interacting with me that kind of makes me happy if you will and it feeds my little my little ego monster that's inside of me um and then it it propels me forward to like want to do that if you don't want to feed that little ego monster I get it I understand but um I I I enjoy doing this stuff and and and I I usually will sit around and think about what I want to talk about and uh and then these ideas come to me and I'm like I said I'm trying to do these once a week and if you have a
suggestion or something that you want to know my opinion on um whether it is just out of board game public publishing or or being a reviewer or any something about the board game hobby or something outside of the board game hobby um you know leave those comments below and uh and then if it's something I think that I could entertain you with a short little video like this uh I'll make it all right so uh all that being said have a good one take care and we'll talk soon