Skip to main content
Loading video...

Guessing Games We Love from Negative Reviews | Vol. 2

Transcript 39:45

Hey, I'm Ryan. This is my brother Daniel. And this is Rolls in the Family. And today we are going to be talking about some uh some negativity about games. We felt we don't have enough negativity on the channel. Let's inject a bunch into one video.

Other people's negativity.

Other people's negativity. Let's get it out of the way. Just really concentrated and then move on to more positive content. This is something we did last year and thought it was kind of fun. It seemed like people found it somewhat entertaining where we compile list secretly each of us lists of negative comments on games that we quite like or even love

and you know games these kind of comments are like really bashing on these games.

Yeah, I can't fathom some of the things you people say.

Yeah, this is unbelievable. These are great games. But we are going to then read these comments to each other and the other person has to try to attempt

to guess. This is Daniel's favorite part. Try to guess what game they are talking about based on their comment and their rating

alone.

Uh and we encourage you to play along at home.

So as we finish reading them, maybe pause the video, maybe think about it, keep track of which ones you get right. If you're a longtime viewer of the channel, you have a slight advantage of like knowing cuz we're pulling from games we enjoy.

I like that. Rewards the longtime viewers. They know what kind of games we're talking about. I suppose they could look us up on like BGG and

look at our collection here if you wanted to and you know.

Yeah, there's lots of ways to play along.

Um, you know, we won't judge. We won't know. So,

we'll assume actually we'll assume that you're cheating that you're cheating.

Yeah. So, we're going to do five comments each for a total um of 10 here.

Uh and yeah, this this is always an interesting time. I guess we'll should we include links to these games?

You know, maybe our discussion moves in a way that makes somebody actually intrigued in buying this game. We will include links to these games in the description below.

But I'm going to kick us off here. Dango, you get the first crack at it here.

Okay,

with uh comment number one.

Okay, let's [clears throat] do this.

Did not enjoy at all. The choices are very obvious and even worse, your choices don't matter until the last few rounds. Card drawing is key, which is either arbitrary luck, or you have to spend the whole time card counting, which is insanely boring in a long game. Risks aren't rewarded, and victory can only be achieved following a narrow, repetitive formula. Pun intended. It's funny. Formula I was like, we don't own formula D. formula. Okay, there's something in that last line there. Formula you're in the right mental.

I was telling Ryan before this video, I am so bad at this. Like I need a list of video.

Daniel hears one of these comments and immediately forgets every game he's ever

I blank on I told Ryan before the video I want a list in front of me. He said no. So uh viewers, you're getting the result of Ryan's uh hope it's entertaining strict rules here. Okay. So the read that last line again cuz that

risks Yeah. Yeah. Risks aren't rewarded and victory [clears throat] can only be achieved following a narrow repetitive formula. Pun intended.

Formula. I'm like, I don't have a game that has like the name formula.

I'll give you a a slight hint that your [clears throat] initial gut instinct was very much on the right track.

I don't even remember what my initial gut instinct was

when you heard that the repetitive formula. Pun intended. Oh, and that I said Formula D. Um, well, I don't own that game, Ryan, so that was not on the right track. You trying to throw me off?

Just just saying in the

Yeah. Yeah. Yeah.

Right. Okay. This is where uh Good thing I've got my games behind me, right? Cuz

Yeah.

Um,

card drawing is key, you know. So, you got that going on.

Just taking a quick scan here. I would say Daniel, what game do we have that you think is closest thematically to Formula D?

Oh, okay. Heat pedal to the metal. Heat of the metal.

It's heat pedal. I thought you were going to get it actually immediately after you made the Formula.

That was a tricky uh clue there because Yeah, it threw me, you know, I was I was so locked out.

Daniel doesn't realize Formula D is like a racing term. He just thought that's what that game was called. I just thought that was a no connect. Okay, read the like just read through that comment real quick again for my

Yeah, I talked about the choices are very obvious and don't matter until the very last rounds. The card drawing is key, but it's either completely luck or like card counting which is insanely boring. Risks aren't rewarded and victory can only be achieved by following a narrow repetitive format.

I would push back on the risks aren't rewarded. Like I feel like I've had many times in that game where you you know especially because you do have the like stress cards or whatnot where you know it's you like right now I'm playing a game on BGA where I'm coming around this final turn and I either and I'm in first but I either could play it safe and play a card that like I know the number but it's going to put me before the curve or I can add a stress card because that's all I have left is stress cards in heat at a stress card which would get me past the curve but also could put me so if I draw like a four could spin me out. So you know I feel like

yeah I mean the whole game is a riskreward thing the whole thing of heat and when to use it and yeah I think in our experience we find that there's many times where you can make those risks and be rewarded in huge ways like if you can catch up a turn like get you get up with the pack.

Um I can see though why some people don't enjoy this game. it. I will give it to them that it's fairly repetitive. So if you don't like that cold

I love it

thing like that's all you're doing the whole time.

No, it is true. Yeah. And and like there are turns where the choice is fairly somewhat obvious about what you're trying to

be fairly obvious though. I think that's maybe losing some of the nuance of of the decisions in the game and what cards do you hold

and you don't know what other people are going to do. So like the, you know, there's all these mind games around like, okay,

if I go here, they're going to, and they think I'm going here, they're going to go here. So can I do something?

Yeah. There's turns where you're like,

if they land here, I can perfectly slipstream them for the perfect move. But if I play for that and they don't land there, then if I Yeah.

So it's tricky.

There you go. Okay.

Okay. Give me your best shot.

Well, Daniel's picking right back. Daniel's a car right now.

Theoretically, theoretically, we tried to order these by the easier ones to harder. So, my

might only be downhill from here for me. Well, Ryan, good thing you're [clears throat] the one that has proven you're you're good at this. So, we're so here is our comment um for you, Ryan.

Yes.

A fine cute game, but the production is something to be ashamed of. We were actively angry at the excess which made me never want to go near this again. [snorts] The short comment, but there's some there's some stuff in here.

Cute.

A fine cute. Yeah, you know, an interesting word. I I'll say a fine cute game. I I I wouldn't put too much stock in that word. I'll just say that.

Okay, cuz here I I'll tell you my guess. My guess would be Foundations of R.

That is correct. Four out of 10 people. Yeah, it's angry. I like

cute is a funny term. I wouldn't that maybe isn't the first word I would think of, you know. Um I mean cute in the sense of like it looks beautiful.

Yeah.

You know, but um but I like that the production is something to be ashamed of.

There there's a lot of uh there's a lot of people in that camp. And admittedly, when I first saw it, I think I was kind of like, okay, this is a little bit

absurd. But it's funny because you've said, you know, they they say the excess made me never want to go near this again. That's again just a funny thing. Um, which again I understand the like, okay, this game's production to what the game is is kind of absurd, but you see that as a as a pro in the sense of you don't have a game at that weight that delivers kind of just a

it's fun to have a table presence for that. Yeah,

I also am definitely against the opinion of like only heavy complex games deserve a more premium

treatment. I think that's just like a it's like well no I mean any game can be more premium or less premium and like people put different stock into that. We used to be way more to the side of not caring about right

what we like it's like give us the cheapest version of the game that lets us play the game was kind of where we started. But I think we've come around on a little bit. You know, there's games like Foundations of Rome. There's games like Nemesis, you know, Retaliation or these types of games where it's like, okay, the presentation here is elevating the experience. It really is. So,

right now, to be fair, I do own Foundations of Metropolis, and like

that's honestly what I'd recommend to most people.

That's what I Yeah. Yeah. I would like look there first because that it's it's great. It's a great implementation of it.

Yeah. Getting feeling good?

No, not at all. But we'll go to the second one. Here we go.

Okay.

Uggh.

That's it. Ugg.

So, I was like, "Okay, Rise, this is getting harder."

Contains practically every feature I hate in any competitive game. Swingy, unbalanced cards, realtime gameplay.

Okay,

take that attacks and an interminably long play time. No, just no. has the honor of being my least favorite game I actually agreed to play twice.

Oh man, real time. That is such a good clue.

Real time. Take that attacks and an interminably long play time.

Okay. And it's long, you know, usually not long.

Balanced cards, right? There's another uh

hint here. [clears throat]

You do in fact own it though that was not true for a a long time.

But you said it takes long.

It's a long game.

It's a long game. You know real you don't have a lot of uh real time long games.

Yeah. I I'll put mention it's not all real time. Like it's not the the entire game isn't real time.

Oh, okay. I I've got I've got something. Can you just read it again? And I'm going to run it through the guess I have.

Uh contains practically every feature I hate in any competitive game. Swingy, unbalanced cards, realtime gameplay, take that attacks, and an interminably long play time.

Okay.

No. Just no. So, I don't know about the take that attack side of it, but I'm going to guess Millennium Blades.

That is correct.

There you go. Okay. I I couldn't remember in that one how [snorts] much take that there was definitely cuz you can lean into the like cards that flip other people's stuff in their tableau um or do clashes and stuff. Yeah,

a lot of times it isn't like, you know, super super mean, but again, if you have a strategy that you're like counting on certain cards to score and then people flip them, that can be pretty pretty brutal.

You know, this comment's fair in the sense that this is not ever

like you talk about games in our collection that are the game that the line between

um this is like my favorite game ever and this is my the worst game that I would never want to play. like it doesn't feel like there's a lot of middle ground. It's kind of like you're either going to absolutely love this

or this is not your thing. Um I think you're right

cuz it's it is a very unique experience. Now we both fall in the camp of this is a very very fun

Yeah, we really enjoy it's not always the gaming experience I'm looking for. like it is a you know these real time stretches of just looking at cards and reading and going combos and knowing that time pressure of needing to build a deck and stuff.

Um but there's nothing like it and we do we do really enjoy

it. I I cuz I got it oh gosh probably a year ago. That's one of the ones that I haven't you know it is hard to get to the table. It's hard to get to the table, but I've got people, Ryan, that I think

And honestly, it's best with three.

Three,

you know, it's hard cuz two's fine, but you lose some of the like dynamic of checks and balances and like just having three people and four just starts to get pretty vulg

hour a player.

Four or five hours. Okay. Yeah.

So, like I think my three player games are often around 3 hours.

Okay. Well, there you go. We'll give it to you, D. Let's go. That's okay.

I think that's more than I got last week.

Yeah. There you go.

Okay. Hit me. Hit me with number two here.

Number two. [clears throat] The design is clever in a way, but they forgot to make it fun. This so-called game is incredibly tedious, dry, fiddly, and frustrating. Forget playing well if you don't know all the cards by heart or don't want to constantly recalculate ranges and bonuses all over the ugly board. The worst is that if you're not winning, you often don't get to do much at all. Repeat for four plus hours. No thanks. I'd play six hours of yatsi over this.

Wow.

Okay, there's a lot in there. Ryan, let me know.

I might I might have to hear it one more time. We're going to hit some kind of the so um kind of the big things in here. Um it's incredibly tedious, dry, fiddly, and frustrating. Um and forget playing well if you don't know all the cards by heart. Uh you Here's this is getting some big stuff right here. You don't want or don't want to constantly recalculate ranges and bonuses all over the ugly board.

Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. I have I have a good guess.

Okay. What's uh what's your

I think it's got to be food chain magnet. It is food chain magnet. Two out of 10. Uh for

Yeah. Yeah. The once I was the knowing all the cards is a big clue there. Yeah.

Which we just played that one for the You got the uh you know

Yeah. Like the new deluxe edition.

The new deluxe edition. We got to try that one for the first time.

Been a long time coming to try it. Yeah. And I'm I'm definitely interested in trying it some more. Uh not as negative experience as this person had. I can I can totally understand even getting a deluxe like if you don't understand the why of why they kept the map and the design the way they did why getting a deluxe edition and then seeing that you'd be like oh wow that's doesn't look

amazing you know what I mean um but it totally makes sense in terms of how they you know from

it's very important that this board is extremely readable without any friction in being able to calculate these things which you know was another pain point they pointed out,

right?

Um, another pretty fair comment, I would say. You know, that's another pretty polar we're picking some pretty polarizing games here.

That's where you get some of the best comments, right?

Yeah, it is true. You get the people that really hate them.

Mhm.

Okay. Shall we shall we move on to our our third round?

Here we go.

Here, very bad game.

No interaction with other players. When it's not our turn, we get bored. We also get bored during our turn. since the choices are ultimately quite predictable and it doesn't get better as matches go on because our viable choices become more and more limited.

There is a missing gameplay element to add a touch of strategy and progression. Why not special dices that we unlock slash choose at the end of each round? Ryan, this is unbelievable. Did we do it again?

We did it again. This goes uh is this a two out of 10 potentially?

Yes, it is a two out of 10.

And is this potentially a game that we uh guess in a lot of our videos?

It is. So we we now on both of these attempted videos have picked the exact same comment.

Ryan, I this so this goes to Sausage Sizzle. Um

Sausage Sizzle.

You know what's funny? You read most of the comment. It wasn't until actually the very end of it that I realized that's one that I had right there. This is unbelievable, Ryan. We were just before the video talking about this happened the last time, the odds because we don't talk at all

and we think about we could choose any game in either of our collections.

Sasha and Sizzle is just permeating our minds right now.

But not only that, I like I just pull up the game and I start just kind of scanning through some of the different comments and pick one.

The same one.

Um, unbelievable. A good thing I chose an extra.

You at home could still have guessed that for a point. Think of it as a bonus. A bonus here. I guess I'll pull in

Yeah,

my backup. I only have one backup, so hopefully we don't cross over again.

Hopefully we don't do that again. And you'll obviously have to pull in a backup if you were intending to use that one.

That's right.

Okay, let's try the backup here.

Let's do it.

The game is extremely frustrating to play. You have close to no control over your character. And once you fall into a punishing loop, you start getting damage cards. You are even more limited. Basically, you have to sacrifice everything to heal yourself. It takes ages to finish a single scenario. For me, this game is definitely badly designed. It promises fun and looks good, but its mechanics are frustrating.

Okay, you know what's funny? So, this isn't my guess, but initially when you were talking about like getting the damage cards, I was thinking like Mex's minions or something like that. I had just played that game. That was on my mind,

but I think this is going to go to Mage Knight.

It is NOT MAGE KNIGHT.

WOW. I Okay, cuz you were saying like the damage cards

you have close to no Yeah. Yeah, I can see where you

damage cards takes forever to play a session. Okay. Well, let me let me cuz that's that's where I locked in.

Yeah. Yeah. I think they threw you off with it takes ages to finish a single scenario. Cuz I think that's kind of an odd comment here.

Okay. Cuz I was like, okay, that's accurate.

I think a big key phrasing here. You have close to no control over your character,

which is why I was thinking versus min of like, oh, you're just kind of whatever. I don't know. Um

I mean, do you just want to go ahead and guess that one?

Oh, it is mech versus minions.

It's mechs versus minions.

Oh, okay. So the ages, that's where they did throw me off with the ages. I was like that long. Like we played it like [clears throat] we played our scenario and like

you must have had a bad group.

Hour, hour and a half. Um, wow. Okay. So I was right. Kind of right. Your gut.

I was kind of right. Yeah, cuz that's a Oh, that's um cuz they were talking about what did they say about the damage again? That you have close to no control over your character and once you fall into a punishing loop of getting damage cards, you're even more limited and you have to sacrifice everything to heal yourself. Oh gosh.

It's so funny cuz we've talked about how our the damage in that game is one of our favorite things about that game because instead of just like moving HP on a track or something, you're getting something that's messing up your and you're trying to work with it. Sometimes you can it's this new fun puzzle and often times it's just funny. We're just like laughing. We had so many moments of that in our we just played it this last week where like one of the guys we're playing with I mean he had figured out how to utilize like he had a bunch of damage but had figured out how to kind of make it work where he's

doing all these things and he was like side shuffling down the

and you do feel clever when you like

help complete the task despite all the stuff going on. I can see if you go with a group that just does not have the right mindset, that is maybe a little too overly serious or just like

could be frustrating, but that's definitely not been our experience. Um,

wow, the ages comment really threw me off.

I was No, cuz when you said that I was like, okay, it's definitely like that wouldn't be mess versus minions, but apparently they had a long game.

There you go.

Okay, Ryan,

round three.

Um, the deck building is dull. [snorts] The resource conversion is dull. The worker placement is worker placement. The bidding battles could be more exciting. It's just a mish mash of stuff. Well, at least the scores usually stop around a dozen points.

Interesting.

One out of 10.

One out of 10. Okay, read it one more time.

The deck building is dull. The resource conversion is dole. The worker placement is worker placement. The bidding battles could be more exciting. It's just a mishmash of stuff. Well, at least the scores usually stop around a dozen points. I don't know if I'm I I'll be honest. I don't know if that last line like how if that's like accurate or not.

Um

I have a guess.

Okay.

I think it's Dune Imperium.

It is Dune Imperium. Congratulations. There you go.

Is that is the ending around 12 points is a really good helpful clue cuz that moves out cuz I haven't played that game in a while so I couldn't remember.

It's basically 10 usually to win but usually people kind of overshoot it a little bit.

You It had me actually thinking of Resarch Arcana cuz Resarchana is also a race to 10. Also has

could go to

you draft to deck build and then you have resource conversion but then it has no worker placement. Hm.

Um, one out of 10.

It was well and it was hitting like a bunch of these like different mechanics. It was like could Ryan put together the

You know, I see this a lot actually of people that like hate on deck building in a game like Dune Imperium or some of this that like it's like they look through look at deck building so narrowly through the lens of like a Dominion or one of these ones that just lets you build and cycle like crazy and coal your deck and it's like that's the only way deck building can be. And so then when any other game like implements it in a slightly different way, it's like this isn't how you do deck building.

Well, it's like I mean it's like Clank Clank Catacombs. You know, the deck building isn't like

Yeah. You don't cycle your deck that many times. If you buy a new card, you'll see it a few times and

Yeah.

Um Nice.

Yeah, that that one adds some helpful

Yeah. Thanks.

Yeah. You ready for number four? Supposedly, these are getting harder. Dang. So,

here we go. No parts of this game work well together. There are a zillion different interactions, none of which are emergent. You just have to read and understand every pair of cards separately to learn what interactions exist. If you want to interact with other players, you have to carefully study way too much on the board to figure out what they need, turning it into a slog. Imagine if Race for the Galaxy had many more icons and none of them interacted with each other in any way.

Wow, that's a good one. Oh boy. Okay. You said there was a board.

Um,

you said on the board.

Yes.

Right.

Way too much on the board to figure out. I would I would read board as the

Oh, that's a

play area.

Play area.

Tableau. Okay.

Um, I have an initial guess, but I I would have to think

it makes you feel better. I don't think I would have gotten this.

Read. Well, then why don't you pick it?

No, read it again. I've got a guess. I I feel pretty good. Read it again.

No parts of this game work well together. There are a zillion different interactions, none of which are emergent. You just have to read and understand every pair of cards separately to learn what interactions exist. If you want to interact with other players, you have to carefully study way too much on the board to figure out what they need, turning it into a slo. Imagine if Race for the Galaxy had many more icons and none of them interacted with each other in any way.

Okay, I actually feel decent about this guess. I'm going to go with Earth. That's a good guess.

That's a good guess.

It's not You tell me it's right.

It's not right, but it's a good

It's not right. Okay. Um, let me just give me one more second here of Yeah, I'm trying to think of what are the biggest clues

because that one that one like there is a lot of like kind of iconography and

the race for the galaxy com comparison is kind of a big clue I think.

Right.

Um but you know a lot of it's like it is with a lot of these negative comments where you're going to be surprised that they're saying some of these things about this game.

I don't know. Is it like Underwater Cities?

It's not Underwater Cities. It's much lighter. It's much lighter.

Oh, is it forest shuffle?

It is forest.

Okay. You know what? I was scanning through and I had a moment where I was like, but for some reason my mind was just in heavy.

Well, I mean, they say things like uh

a slog. Uh

yeah, turned into a slog. More icons than Race for the Galaxy. Like it makes it sound like it's more complicated than Race of the Galaxy, which for shuffle is definitely not.

Um.

Wow.

Yeah. An interesting uh take here. No parts of the game work well together.

I like that.

Those are those are good. Um, wow. Yeah, that I that was not not the complexity that my mind was was going at first. Um, well, I've said, you know, I just texted you this probably a couple weeks ago that we, my wife and I have really been enjoying for shuffle and actually I I said that it actually scratches that same itch as Race for the Galaxy for me. Um, and

I actually remembered that when I picked this comment. I thought maybe that would help you get it.

Yeah. No, that's uh that's interesting. Okay, cool.

I'm doing way better this video, right?

Yeah, you look much more confident. It must be a year of rolls in the family.

I'm growing, folks. Experience.

I'm growing.

Adding up.

Look at this.

Watch out.

Imagine when I'm 80 doing this.

Yeah. Volume 80.

Uh you want to serve me up number number five? Okay.

Am I pitching a perfect game? I can't remember.

I think you are, Ryan. I don't see how this is anything other than falling into gamebreaking combos. The entire game is like playing Street Fighter and only using the leg sweep. That's the only reason I chose this comment. And then but then they added an update. I'm not sure how I keep getting convinced to play this. Further games have led me to believe this game is subpar and in the same vein of games as Flux. The game is either over very quickly or drags on until the person in last place ends it. to end their suffering. Memorizing cards/combos doesn't make this fun. Some sort of tension or real theme might have made this better. H I had one that came to mind, but I don't think it's right. I'm going to have to hear it one more I'm going to have to hear one more time here to see if I can

I don't see how this is anything other than falling into gamebreaking combos. The entire game is like playing Street Fighter and only using the leg sweep. That's a interesting comment there. But then update, I'm not sure how I keep getting convinced to play this. Further games have led me to believe this game is subpar and in the same vein of games as Flux. The game is either over very quickly or drags on until the person in last place ends it to end their suffering. Memorizing cards/combos doesn't make this fun. Some sort of tension or real theme might have made this better.

I feel like my guess fits like most of it.

Which part Which part do you think it doesn't fit?

But let me just I I'll just do my guess. I don't have a better guess. I'm going to say innovation.

That is correct. Ryan is right. That is right. Good job. You are on the three out of 10 by the way.

Three out of 10. Yes.

Yeah. No, I was thrown off a little bit by the until last place.

Yeah.

Puts it I'm trying to think of either over very quickly or drags on until the person in last place ends it to end their suffering.

I guess I'm confused how the person in last place ends it. I guess you could rush the ages even though you're losing. Um,

yeah,

there's something else there that was felt weird with

the leg sweep.

Yeah. Yeah. Well,

yeah. I guess I guess maybe what they're getting at is like once you get like a broken jump or something, you might you might kind of hit it over and over,

but but that's kind of the fun in the sense of then it puts the burden on the other player to like

figure out how to

and the game gives you plenty of ways to shake things up.

Yeah. I mean, the fact that they lead with gamebreaking combos being like a negative is enough to tell me they're probably not going to like innovation cuz I feel like that's a lot of the draw of the game is like, "Hey, do you want to play a game that every time you play you can find

seemingly game-breaking combos, but because there's so much of it, they're not as game-breaking as you think." Cuz you might have a game-breaking combo, but then things really turn. I've had multiple games of this where it's like I the game's in the bag. Even like right down the stretch, there's no and then something happens. It's like, oh my gosh, there's like a chance that if they pulled us off. So,

yeah.

Yeah. Not for everybody.

Wow. Ryan, you are on a roll today.

That was harder. That was harder.

You are on a roll.

You You You're not doing too bad yourself, D.

Thank you. I'm very proud. You want to try this last one?

Yeah, I guess.

Honorary one out of 10 for dis

Thank you.

The You could give it less.

The honorary one out of 10. honorary 1 out of 10 for disrespecting my friends time and derailing game days by locking them into five plus hour experiences.

Oh,

I have played this before, but I was basically subbing in for a player who had to leave and didn't really fully participate.

Oh, that probably didn't help.

Not sure how I would have participated more, though. Got a lot of cards that amounted to nothing happens. Looks like we're about to lose. Word spoken 90 minutes before they actually lose the game.

Can you read the last half of that kind of portion?

Uh, let's see. Not sure how I would have participated more though. Got a lot of cards that amounted to nothing happens.

Looks like we're about to lose.

Word spoken 90 minutes before they actually lose the game.

Okay, this is fair. I'm going to go with Elder Tour.

It is Elderore. Yeah. And and honestly again, some aspects of the comment is like there are those games where it's like, "Yep, we're going to lose." And the game can drag on a little bit until you actually see the

Yeah. And for someone who doesn't play the game that much, like that's going to be such a negative experience. The thing for us is when we have that experience where like, yeah, 90 minutes we knew we're going to lose and then 90 minutes later we lost. We also can point to several experience where 90 minutes left

we thought we were going to lose and miracles happen, you know, and some of the greatest gaming memories of just how we were able to pull something out. And so, you know, you only really experience that if you play the game enough to kind of see the variance of the types of experiences. And for us, those highs are high enough

to like be okay with the chance that you're going to get one of these lows. Yeah,

there has to be just a graveyard of gamers that have like played Elder Tour once, right?

You know, it's not for everybody.

It's not for everyone, but I bet there's people that probably would have loved it.

Yeah.

If but their first experience was just

Well, and if that first experience is with too many people like that really bogs it down or cuz the game says it goes to eight. Please, please don't.

Can you imagine?

Or you just have a group that you know doesn't know the rules as well. like it's going to get so long if you're not if you don't have the rules nailed down. Um I mean even just the fact they say a five plus hour experience. We probably have had like one or two games ever eclipse 5 hours out of like 40 plus.

Does the base box say go up to eight players?

It does. One is a tragedy.

It's hard. Even six were like I have we played a six player game. I have and you gota really have people that all love the game and you're in it for the long run.

I feel like five is our like

four is like the best.

Four is the best. Yeah, four is the best.

It is weird cuz the game gets harder at odd player counts just the way that they increase things. So like three and five are like harder than four.

But yeah, there you go.

Okay, Ryan, we're bringing up the uh um reserve here because of uh

our overlap. I still can't believe that happened, but we'll see. We'll see if you can get this

tradition at this point.

Excessively frustrating game with deceptively beautiful art that takes every single little opportunity, and the rules give it many, many of these, to stab you in the eye socket. I believe similar results could have been achieved without such blatant stacking against the player. Save yourself the trouble and play a game of beating your head on the table, seeing how many times it takes to get a headache, and maybe glance at the art each turn, giving three points because it has some good ideas buried in it. So, this one was definitely a harder one. There's not a lot of things in here, but but there's a few and there's there's obviously the artwork.

Yep, that's a that's a helpful clue. There is some some clues if you pay attention to the language that they use.

Okay, I'm going to have to hear it one more time.

Like uh well, like especially the eye socket. No, I'm just kidding. Um but uh so excessively frustrating game with deceptively beautiful art that takes every single little opportunity and the rules give it many many of these to stab you in the eye socket. I believe similar results could have been achieved without such blatant stacking against the player.

Mhm. Save yourself the trouble and play a game of beating your head on the table, seeing how many times it takes to get a headache. That doesn't help too much. Um, maybe glance at the art each turn, giving three points because it has some good ideas buried in it. We can't let Ryan bat perfect for today. So, let's see if we can get him on a hard one here. Yeah, I'm trying to figure out if it's cooperative or not. It's hard to tell from the cuz like the beating down the player that could still be true in a competitive game.

It could,

but it feels more cooperative to me.

It does.

So then I'm thinking of hard cooperative games that have good art is really where my brain is at.

Yeah. And you know, hard is a subjective thing for for people, but Yeah. I don't think that's it. But I'm struggling to think of another

stabbing your eye sockets, hitting your head in the chest.

And and they they think the rules are cuz they say give plenty of opportunity. So maybe a convoluted rules potentially.

I I'll do my guess. My guess is nemesis retaliation.

That is

or nemesis.

Incorrect.

Incorrect.

Incorrect. You're on the right track with the cooperative.

Uhhuh.

Um

there's another one that came to mind, but I don't

nemesis. Definitely could have definitely the art would be like the H I mean it could be it could be Final Girl.

That is a good guess.

But it is not Final Girl.

It could be Arkham Horror the card game.

You are getting closer, Ryan. But it is not Arkham Horror the card game.

You're getting very close actually.

Is it Lord of the Rings? is Lord of the Rings the card game. So they love the artwork.

Okay.

And I'm curious from your perspective, the rules were are do you

I mean I see those part of the course for an LCG style game. I mean it's got kind of everything you'd expect,

right? Enough to stab you in the eye socket.

Yeah.

I gota try the next time playing just getting my head on the table and occasionally looking at the art. So

the game does have good artwork. It does have good artwork though.

Yeah. Like I

maybe maybe not like blow you away per se, but um

Yeah, it's good artwork,

right?

Well, there you go. I I wasn't perfect. Daniel, you did it. But it felt fair. Like, you know, yeah, that was one that when I read it, I'm like, oo, that's there's not a lot in there, you know, because the stacking against the player that kind of leans you to cooperative.

Um getting you to think of like, okay, what games have good art and Yeah. And I didn't know if there was if you with that one if you would have thought, oh, the rule book is, you know, there's maybe a lot to grasp uh grasp in it. I know actually Arkham Horde with a card game. There's there's a decent amount of

rules you have to kind of understand. Um I don't know. I feel like what's hard is you're I mean you've played this game

a lot

a lot. So your perspective of it is very experience is not struggling with the rules. someone someone walking into it.

Well, we would love to hear how any of you did on this. It's inherently much harder for a viewer than for us cuz we're leaning into our beat us. Although they have all the time in the world.

True. I'm on the I'm

We just feel awkward. This the video is getting a little long. We got to answer something.

Actually, Ryan, I give us both uh credit. I think we did pretty solid.

That was That was pretty solid. We might actually post this video instead of throwing it away like all

all the 10 other ones that were those were horrible videos.

This this is worthy to actually seen by the public.

Thank you so much for watching and maybe even playing along. If you enjoyed this style video, uh we've got a volume one video where we did this and you want to watch Daniel perform much poorly than he did in this video. You'll uh you can go check that one out. Got a another video here as well. Links to all these games down below. We will see you in the next

Progress saved