Skip to main content
Loading video...

How I Try to Balance Honesty while Honoring Game Publishers – Board Games & Coffee Ep. 5

Transcript 30:23

good morning good morning and welcome to board games and coffee uh this week I asked my subscribers what aspects of reviewing board games on YouTube are you most curious about of the four options I gave the one that most people were excited about was balancing honesty with maintaining relationships with Publishers so in this video I'm going to be centered on that theme uh before I talk about how I try to balance honesty with board game Publishers I want to give a little bit of background about who I am why I started this channel uh what motivates me and with that information I'll talk about how I try to do reviews I'm also going to do things a little differently normally what I do is I go through my notes at the beginning and then I take questions at the end but today I'm going to open up for questions as I go along so if you've got something be sure to drop it in the comments and I'll try to address it uh so first I want to little talk a little bit about who I am sometimes I only mention this in passing uh but I was originally my name is Ben knuckles I was born in Oregon and I moved to New York in 2007 where I be I got my Masters in Education in math education and I became a high school teacher and I taught in high school for

10 years uh and then I got married along the way and we had our first child in 2014 and at that time also my wife decided to become a Navy dentist so uh knowing very well that that would mean I would be moving around the world I didn't want to keep applying for different jobs I didn't want to keep teaching and working at many different schools so I decided I needed to figure some things out in order to bring out uh I kind of doubled down on what I already knew about computer science went into software development uh we moved out of New York City in 2018 and I started doing some of my own work as a software developer and to make a long story short along the way uh I decided that I needed something that would give me greater flexibility as a father I had two kids at that time and I also wanted to do something that I was really passionate about also at this time I homeschool my kids so as my wife's job becomes more and more involved uh I enjoy being available to be there for the kids to teach the kids and I want something I could share with them so I got into YouTube which kind of is the embodiment of many of the things that I enjoy I really enjoy board games and I really enjoy teaching and in fact

not only do I enjoy board games but I specifically enjoy learning new board games I love learning new board games and so starting a YouTube channel to review board games was an outlet for me that was creative that had the potential of growing something that was my own and it also kind of encouraged me to continue learning more and more board games that's what I really enjoy and I enjoy teaching board games so this is something that's very exciting for me but the other thing that's very interesting about my position is that my wife's job and her benefits are sufficient for our family I don't need to have a job to bring in the income so it puts me in sort of a privileged position uh I don't have to pressure my viewers to join patreon or I don't have to ask for uh sponsors sponsored uh board game Publishers to pay for Kickstarter previews or any of this stuff in fact that's one of the things about YouTube that kind of aggravates me like I've seen some excellent uh people on YouTube making wonderful content but every time it kind of gets to the like be sure to like like And subscribe or you know the the commercial in the middle of so many

YouTube videos which asks viewers to join patreon I understand it I definitely get it and I'm thankful that I don't have to make a living doing this but I really didn't want to make a channel where I was doing it all the time or if I did it at all I wanted to do it very little maybe at the end because there are some great advantages to having a patreon community and there are are some advantages to working with Publishers and doing sponsored content like there are other reasons besides Financial ones to do these things but I kind of wanted to start a channel that was more focused on what I was interested in so that I wouldn't feel any obligation

so that's where I am today um initially now I had my own collection of board games and of course I bought them all and I was trying to keep ahead I had a theory that if I if I bought the newest board games and I reviewed them then I would get more views because I'd be doing the current content and then and then people would come in and subscribe now I guess I should pause there and say well why why does anybody if I have a channel and I'm not asking for likes and subscribers and why would I care if I had more views why would would I care why not do it for no view like 10 10 views why is that not enough why would I want more views CU I had I had one goal this is my one goal I wanted to do it for free I wanted to break even if I could get to the point where Publishers could send me board games then I was really making it so so yeah I didn't ask for money but I wanted to grow the channel so I started buying board games for the longest time thinking that it was going to pay dividends if I attracted people by reviewing the newest games that is an impossible Endeavor if you are watching this video because you want to be a Youtube board game reviewer it is impossible to buy enough games new games

to build your audience because you're you're uh reviewing the latest stuff there's one there's way too much and two established channels have a connection with Publishers where they're getting review games before they're released so you'll never be able to produce reviews uh and keep up with the ones that are already established of course I had to figure this out the hard way um and to be honest I kind of enjoyed it because it was an excuse to buy new games um but there are other things things that I wanted to figure out so I mentioned that I had the um computer the software development experience and of course I developed the perfect board game.com website and I wanted to kind of get people in on that as well because I had a theory I had a theory that was um when I looked at the list of games on Board Game Geek I didn't like how the game were rated I thought there were too many games on the list that didn't belong there specifically earlier on I was really irritated by Gloom Haven because I didn't think that Gloom Haven embodied what the H the hobby was about because to me the hobby was it was always Euro games I always always was a big fan of Euro games and I was like all this this glut Haven with its campaign and its Miniatures and all its cool story

telling stuff it's not that great it's it's pretty great uh but it was popular for a very long time and I thought you know what I want I want a website where I can just find the board games that I like because I can find lists that are that match me that that fit my liking that's what I wanted so I thought that's what I tried to make I tried to make the perfect board game.com where games would be organized according to the criteria that were important to people rather than because of ratings uh and you know with time I think that's going to become a really valuable tool it's still it doesn't have the um the user base that I think it needs to be competitive with with a site like Board Game Geek but there is a niche of people that are really into it and I'm very thankful those people by the way uh thank you okay so that's kind of my background uh how do I balance honesty with honoring board game Publishers so look this hobby is still very very Niche it's there aren't nearly as many people on the internet that are that are researching board games and watching reviews as there are looking at the newest Tech products if I maybe I could have reviewed Tech products but reviewing board games and it's a competitive Marketplace and everyone

who's doing it is doing it as a passion project some people try to do it in a way make a living but everyone who's doing it is doing it because they love it it's not it's not something you get into to make a lot of money and the and they work very very hard I've talked to some of these people they in order to stay afloat when you've got so many games out there these conventions they go everywhere they work so much in order to make their companies you know perform well and man I really want to support the whole industry like anybody who's making a game I want to support you you are making something wonderful for us the hobbyists so I want to do a service for them not because I want to like owe them but because I appreciate them so honoring Publishers is a really big deal to me but you know what else I really like I love just ranting on and on about things that I don't like I love it I I I get I have so much fun describing something in a bad way um I also I also have fun ranting about something that I love but I can really go to town destroying something with my very very strong opinions and so that is something

that um that is something that's hard to do on the internet the internet is full of negative opinions and it's full of people being mean I kind of think that like um roasting something like in a comedic way is hilarious like I think it's kind of fun to think of like a witty insult or kind of Trot on something like it can be entertaining um but I don't think it always is picked up by everyone I don't think everyone appreciates negativ negativity like some people probably like think that's the toxicity of the internet so I try to rain it in a little bit like sort of want to keep those opinions closer to my chest um and I don't think that even though I like doing that that it would would help me honor board game Publishers so sometimes I do rant and if you've been watching my channel for a while you've probably seen a few videos where I really go off on something um I try to do it in a fair way but most of the time what I try to do is stick to a policy a policy of how I'm going to review things so let me talk about the

policy let take another sip here um so first of all I only want to review board games that I want to play and you might think like why would like why would I what games do I not want to play right I only want to play I only want to review board games that I want to play so these are things that I want to play everything else I don't want to play I love playing in Rich in games for families what is enriching I don't want to play like Candy Land I don't want to play something that I have to dumb myself down to engage my kids I want to elevate my kids to the board games that I enjoy so I want to play enriching games for family now most of the time party games are extremely accessible you know dicks it or something but party games aren't like they they don't have as much value to me as as uh Euro board games do now some do some are I think are absolutely brilliant lately I've been like going off on or I've mentioned de crypto so many times because I keep playing it very you know recently in my circle of friends like some party games are great they're strategic but I don't play party games I don't play games with my family that are heavily based on luck um and I don't play games that have

rules sets that are like for for like very very young children um so there's that then Euro board games I personally personally if I could only play games that were satisfying to me and me alone which is not why I do the hobby by the way you know what I love about the hobby I love teaching games to people and I love matching board games to the right person I have like over 250 here in my house and when my mom came I played all these games with her and and then my friend came the one who was on the show last week and the games that I pulled out for him were completely different than the ones I pulled out for my mom I like learning people's tastes and I like matching games to their liking hence the website that I made right so that's why I do this but if I lived in a world where the only person who needed to be satisfied was me then I would want to play Heavy Euro board games all the time I'd want to spend two to three hours on very difficult games with lots of rules I love that I love that and I I have some I don't have enough friends who want to play games like that um but I will take that on any day and then like I like the intro like level uh kind of intro medium medium light games those are fun too so I try to collect games like that because those are the games going to play and those are the games that are going to fit in my circle because listen if I have games that are recommended for people who like that take that mechanic

right the backstabbing like kinds of games I don't like that and I don't have friends that want to play that so even though I I recognize that there are families that would enjoy that I I turn that away like that's not for my circle if I can't play the family game with my kids if a board game is going to make my daughters cry I'm going to decline it okay so I try to play games that I like next I'm very hesitant to review Kickstarter games I'm hesitant hant to review Kickstarter games because my fear is that they they might not be funded one and there's the the culture of Kickstarter the the fear of missing out I know why it's done but I I I don't I don't like it like I don't I almost don't want to support it I I do buy kickstarters by the way like I I get them I I I have one that I did recently a uh Ava's dream which is from black Aly or alleycat games um so to say that I don't like Kickstarter would be inaccurate but I I I just want to review games that people can go out and buy right now I want to review a game that you're like oh that's a cool game and I want you to order it and have it come in the mail next week I don't like this like wait for a year it's it I don't like that so I usually don't do kickstarters and I I man I used to but now I don't do any kickstarters if it's a Publisher's first time doing a Kickstarter because I've learned I've

I've met reviewed a few games that were kickstarters that didn't even get funded and that is annoying I get all my subscribers excited about a game and it doesn't even get funded they can never see it so that's not cool so I try to I try to use discretion when I do kickstarters so I only play games that I or accept games that I want to play I don't do kickstarters what else all right and then and then there's my angle right so when I review a board game I try to do it through the lens of the perfect board game formula which I'm not going to spend any time on in this video talking about it's the five attributes I talk about it all the time there's a link in the description but I use the five attributes to try to put an objective spin on it and I try to give an opinion that both expresses how I feel about the game and how I think other people would feel about the game or why they might not like it or whose Circle it isn't for so uh for example bizaar of ubar is one that I recently reviewed and the way that I expressed my opinion about bizar of vbar is I said this is a puzzly game with a lot of moving parts that I really enjoy it's like a puzzle within a puzzle I like this game but you know what I was the only one at my table who liked this game most people are going to think it's too finicky it's too puzzly it's probably not for them if you like Puzzles if you like lots of like things to work out you're going to love this game but it's going to it's a it's a game for

fewer people I got to say and that's how I said it and I think that honors the um the publisher um I mean I'm I'm really condensing my opinion context helps a lot I suppose I'll put a link to that revieww as well in the description um but yeah so I do my overview actually you know what let's look at the second poll let me show you the other poll I asked this week it was which type of of review is most engaging for you assuming the reviewer is entirely sincere now most people said a balanced review that weighs both the pros and the cons now I think that the key word may have been missed in this poll I did not ask how should a review be I asked which type of riew is most engaging for you in other words when you are watching a review what kind of thing keeps you watching see I suspect that more people actually really enjoy watching an overwhelmingly positive review or a negative review because it's cool when people get fired up it's engaging when people get fired up um but this is definitely what I tried to pursue now the thing that I learned from this particular poll is

that a non- opinionated objective tutorial or rules overview is not is not what's favorable which is funny because honestly I think that's what I most often do I like to watch the how to play video and then I make my opinion from the how to playay video or other times I'll just read a PDF of the rules and I will make my entire assessment of the game based on the PDF because again I think this is part of like my identity as a board game hobbyist I love learning games don't tell me what you think of it let me I want to learn it and I will assess it once I learn the game I love doing that anyway so I tried away the pros and the cons I'm hoping I'm doing a good time doing it now going into questions um

what about my better than Series so I have a series of videos five games that are better than x five games that are better than wingspan better than everdell better than Ticket to Ride better than Dominion what else have I done at least those so am I am I am I disrespecting the publisher when I make those okay so here's the thing way back when I was a young little reviewer I was trying to think of how to get attention and stand out from the crowd now what I like about board games is com or rather the ones that I buy is I like buying games that none of my friends have I'm sort of obsessed with it every time I find find a game that I really love that my friend has I say in my head this is there's no reason to buy this my friend has this and I played with my friend if I want to play it again I will play with my friend again brass Birmingham awesome awesome game I would love to own this game I don't need to Michael taught me the game I played it with him twice if I want to play it again I'm going to play with my friend Michael that makes so much sense to me you know what I want to find I want to find the games that someone like name Michael um is or you know whoever my friend is uh that they've never heard of before

I want to be able to walk in the room and say Hey you remember brass and how cool that was well have you heard of blah let's play this you know like I like showing something that no one's ever heard before um and I like owning games that no one's heard of before so that when those people want to play the game they have to play with me I think that's awesome so the reason I do the better than series is because I wanted to show people what they could play instead of uh what was the first I think everdell was the first one I did in this series I wanted to show people what they could play instead of everdell because everyone already owned everdell everdell was such a popular game already now the nice thing is because everell is so popular the publisher is not hurting because I did this video and if you watch the video despite what the title is called I think you will see that the spirit of the video is to not to uh not to to make fun of everell in any way but really to say Hey listen everdell is great but here are some things you could play instead and especially some things that you may not have heard of before um so that's that's why I do that I don't think it's uh it's it upsets the Publishers very much um the only other thing that kind of people really hate is they don't like how I review theme I give low theme score and people say you know why and understand when I rate theme I'm not saying that a game doesn't have a

cool theme I'm talking about how theme impacts gameplay but I've talked about that before so I get a lot of reactions the biggest reactions on my channel in the negative light are either people who don't like that I've compared something to a great game they don't like that I've said these games are better than everdale boy do I get attacked by that or they don't like that I say that root has a theme score that's like what I say three out of 10 or something how could it be three out of 10 well because root it's not about animals there's nothing animal focused about Roots it's just a area control game it could be anything it's just soldiers whatever it's not a thematic game even the power n whatever it's a more it's bigger focus on mechanics is what I'm trying to say like a Euro game all right well at this time I'm going to look at my questions and I think I will answer one question they came up from the poll as well so how do I select and obtain review copies from Publishers so I didn't I didn't actually address that I I talked about which ones I select games that I play games that WR kickstarters games that have mechanics that I'll play with my friends um but in the beginning I used to write publish um and some some don't respond I've had a few Publishers that just don't respond usually it's the really big Publishers

small Publishers almost always respond and they almost always say yes assuming I write them an email that says hey this is who I am here's a link to my YouTube channel I've reviewed games like the ones that you have I think that this particular game is going to be popular with my audience for this reason very specific about that I want them to see what I have to offer them and I say will you give me a review copy and almost always if they respond at all they respond yes um but now I'm at the point where Publishers write me and that's why I have to say no because a lot of them have games that I don't want to play um occasionally man I've I've met some I've been introduced to some incredible games simply because a publisher has written me first I don't think I ever would have discovered an age contrived if the designer didn't reach out to me which I love U and then I also wanted to talk a little bit about uh sources of revenue so there are a lot of ways to monetize a YouTube channel I have opened up many and I mean look it's not a lot of money because I've already made it pretty clear it's not really the biggest thing behind my channel um so one there's ad

revenue from YouTube on an average month I make about $70 in ad Revenue maybe a little bit higher because some months can be huge like I made $200 last month because the Boop short went almost like I don't know if it's is it qualified as viral if I get over a million views that game has 1.1 million views it has more views than my other videos by more than a factor of 10 incredible so I made like 200 bucks last month from ad revenue on YouTube ad Revenue has um affiliate purchasing so I do that on my shorts videos and that makes me about $15 a month and then on Amazon Affiliates which is what I do my primary source of AD revenue for the perfboard game.com um that is about less than $20 a month and then there's a little bit of merchandise um I'm actually working on a piece of merchandise right now this is my cup the green player it's got all these let's see if I can all these board game pieces on it anyway um this one isn't quite for sale yet I want to make a the the blue player the red player the green player I have a t-shirt those are all found on another E shopping site um I'll put a link in the description so these are all ways to

make Revenue but altogether I make a little over $100 each month and I don't pay for board games anymore I mostly get them for free so if you consider that I'm no longer spending $100 a month on board games is a little bit more than 200 bucks so not enough to make a living but it's definitely enough to be super uh excited because I get to do the thing that I love for free and I love that and I get to spend time with my kids that's the other thing the reason I do the family board games angle is because I really want to spend more time with my kids and it and it you know it all pays off my kids even help me sometimes and I pay them I pay my kids to play a new board game with me so that I can make a review about it um occasionally most of the time they have to do website work anyway so uh that is all about me and how I'm running the channel if you have any other questions you can throw them down there yeah it's already half an hour all the time we have for today thank you for joining me and thank you sincerely for your support over the years

Progress saved