5 More Games that are BETTER than Everdell
Transcript
this is everdale it's a game known for being especially beautiful not too difficult to learn with just the right amount of decision making to make it engaging for most players it's also known for being extremely popular and to some even a bit overrated in fact in my previous video I gave five recommendations of board games that I thought did one thing better than everdel but in this video I'd like to offer five more recommendations however this time all five of the games on this list are new games they all have something thematically similar to everdel and something in common with the mechanics as well I just think they're a little bit better foreign let's talk about what you're going to see in these games first of all I want to make sure this is an Apples to Apples comparison so every game has to have an animal or nature based theme secondly they all have to be mechanically similar to everdel so I'm looking for games that have a worker placement mechanic or card mechanic in my research I did find some games that wouldn't quite qualify for this list but would be great recommendations for a video called five games that are better than wingspan now I haven't made that video yet but when I do I'll be sure to leave a link in the description lastly I'm filming this in January of 2023 so at this time a lot of
the games on this list are very very new like some of them are still kickstarters that being said they might not be available at the time that you're watching this but I will again leave links in the description or on my web app the perfectboard game.com where you can watch this video as well as find the games their descriptions and Link links to where you can buy them alongside the video the first game on this list also features a big tree as the center point of the game and it's called Oak now Oak is a natural and mythology based game where you're not playing the role of animals but rather an order of Druids and in the game you can use your resources to get creatures that will help your order or you can build artifacts that will give you special actions or you can take temple actions under the shade of the oak tree that will help you strengthen your order the especially unique characteristic of Oak is that during the game you can upgrade your workers to give them special abilities the way this is done is by adding a little accessory to the worker and then the special ability associated with that accessory is granted to only that worker so for example a Bard will extend your player board or a recluse is a worker whose resting space is one of the areas that you don't have to provide for still there are other others will help you be more effective in building potions and others that will remove the penalty associated with placing your worker in a space where another worker is present there's even an ancient Elder
who takes on the benefit of every other Elder I do think Oak looks a little more complicated than it actually is and if you take a look at the rule book there are a ton of different symbols to interpret which means that this game has a little bit of a steeper learning curve however I do think the ability to upgrade workers really adds to the mechanics of this board game now the next game I think is an obvious comparison as soon as it came out I looked at the artwork I looked at the level of complexity and I thought clearly this is a game that's trying to fit into the same niche as everdel the game is Creature Comforts now in Creature Comforts you are living in a valley populated by animals and your objective is to store up Comforts for your home in the winter time so this is a game we're going to be collecting and building cards adding them to your home and trying to pair cards in such a way that you can maximize your points so it does have that card Drafting and building mechanic that everdel has however the gameplay is work replacement with dice the way that it works is at the beginning of every round you're going to roll two dice and using the values on those dice you're going to place workers on the board for actions that you wish to complete only once your workers have been placed four more dice are going to be rolled and these dice are going to be common to
everybody so on your turn you're going to use the common dice along with your own two dice to support the actions of each of your workers now because of that element of luck you place the workers before the common dice are rolled you might not always be able to use a worker to complete an action in which case you're going to learn A Life Lesson which is a token that you can use to modify dice later in the game so this is a worker placement with dice modifier game another thing about the game is that there is not a lot of conflict in the game this is the kind of game that you would play to a soundtrack of like a bubbling brook or rainfall in the forest and crickets and birds chirping or something it is a very very peaceful game and it plays well even with kids so that game is Creature Comforts the next game on this list deviates the most from the mechanics of everdel but I cannot deny how satisfying the gameplay is and how unique the win conditions are which is why I had to include on this list the game is called living Forest now in living Forest you are the spirit of the forest and you're trying to protect the forest from a fire spirit and help the forest grow by planting trees now on your side are the animals and you are going to be collecting them during the game so this game is actually a deck
builder on your turn you're going to be pulling out the cards from your deck and you're going to be using the icon Bonds on the cards you've pulled to support the actions that you take but the thing that I really like about this game is the semi-cooperative nature of it and the game's three very different Victory conditions see the semi-cooperative nature of it is that players really have to work together to keep the Fire Spirit from going rampant and destroying the forest now every time they put out a fire they're going to get one point that could possibly count towards their Victory conditions but that's not the only way you can win you can also win by planting trees or you can win by getting a certain number of symbols in the cards that you build during the game so whether it's from collecting cards planting trees or putting out fires there are three different ways to win and as you play through the game you'll find that if players are all trying to do the same thing it doesn't really work out so well you really need to kind of pick a strategy that compliments everybody else in order to pull ahead so this game has a very interesting dynamic between players as they figure out their path towards Victory and I really like that even though it is competitive you have to prevent that Fire Spirit from going crazy so I really enjoyed the game and again it's a game that I'm able to play with my eight and my six-year-old which I really appreciate I wish that everdel was more friendly to younger players and
it turns out that living Forest is okay the next game on this list I'm sure is going to induce a bit of an eye roll you're going to hear it and you're not going to take me seriously you've hear me out or at the very least at least skip to the next game recommendation I think this is a worthwhile consideration okay the game is my lil everdale yes the kid version of everdel is better than the original everdel boom hear me out here's why okay um in the kid version of everdale in my little everdel it is very very similar you still have a market of eight cards you have many of the same resources there are no stones in this game and you even have event cards you can trigger when you add cards to your own Tableau but the thing that really makes it different is that in each round of the game you can always only play three workers no extra workers are added to your board and there is no ability to build cards without placing a worker in fact on your turn you place a worker you gather the resources and then and only then you can build up to one card so the whole idea of uh buildings that can be occupied by creatures that you can put the little door on the card that is removed from this game and because of that you will only ever
have three actions per round and there are four rounds in the game which means the game is reduced to exactly 12 turns per player this is a very streamlined version of everdel it plays in 30 to 40 minutes it's very easy to teach it has all of the same high quality attractive artwork but one of my biggest gripes about everdell was that it was too much effort for thematically very little payoff I mean the cards thematically were very beautiful but essentially in everdale all you're doing is trading resources in order to get cards in order to help you trade more resources in order to get more cards on the other hand over here my little everdel thematically it's the same amount of significance but the game is just so much less effort so I get just as much satisfaction but playing a game that I think of as being very low in score thematically but with a very satisfying mechanic very smooth gameplay very satisfying and quick to play that's why I think my little everdel is actually a better game than the original everdel though I called this game five more games that are better than everdale I actually have a sixth game a runner-up if you will and I simply had to include it because even as you look at the cover art for this game you want to know how
it Compares with everdel you can take a look at everdel you've kind of got this Badger who's staring off in the distance and this very natural setting and then we take a look at this other game which is called uluk and uluk very similar cover you've got a badger he's kind of doing some cooking here you've got the background there's this interesting Monument it's a very natural setting this is clearly a world about animals so what is this game all about in oolok the objective of the game is to feed your workers and have enough Surplus that you can throw celebrations and build monuments to the Gods now in the game you can construct inventions that will help you get more food and then you'll be spending many of your workers to collect food and prepare food in order to feed your workers the thing about this game that really stands out is The Game's ecology phase so after a round of gameplay you're going to look at all of the spaces where food was collected if three workers are present there then the supply is going to be dropping by two if two workers are present it'll be reduced by one one worker will leave the supply as is and then finally if there are no workers collecting food there then the supply will actually increase that's not all though because as the supply of some things Falls the supply of other things increases so for example if less worms are available in the supply then the number of plants can
increase that ecology phase means that every action is being changed after every single round I really really love the ecology phase of this game but it didn't make the cut for this list except for as an honorable mention because really the only thing you're doing in this game is feeding your workers it doesn't have the same satisfaction as drafting cards of using those uh resources that you've collected to build interesting things you collect the food you process the food and then as soon as you processed processed it most of that food gets discarded as your workers eat it and that really left me unsatisfied in the end and I thought I don't know how much I would like this game when I can't get so excited about building an engine now there are inventions that you can build all you have to do is take an action it doesn't cost any resources and if you have a surplus you can also build monuments to the gods and every time a monument is completed aside from victory points they will actually add to the number of resources available in the game and I think that's cool too but again there's just too much being wasted on feeding workers and for a game I'd like to be doing a little bit more than that still I really love this ecology phase I love the shifting actions and I like how that supports the theme of oolog the final and really in my opinion the best game on this list is something that I am so excited about it I first
saw at Essen last fall right now it's a Kickstarter I can't wait to get my hands on it it's by the same producers of Autobahn which I think is a fantastic board game and I've already done a review on Autobahn it's called arboria now when you look at this board it looks very complicated but I actually think it isn't that difficult to explain and it's pretty even simple to understand with a very brief overview essentially what you want to do is actually over in your player board next to your player board you want to be building an ecosystem and putting animals in your ecosystem you are a spirit that is trying to rehabilitate the forest so that's the whole objective of the game the way that you'll do that is by placing workers on action spaces or on action tracks over on this main board now if we look closer what's going on here all of these paths are just showing what resources or events are triggered when a worker follows along the path the workers are going on a pilgrimage and they start on a Time Track now during a player's turn the time track moves towards the center of the board and as the worker gets closer and closer to the center of the board they find themselves at the head of a better path than the one they were on so in other words the longer a worker
stays at a position the better the path for them will become one of the things that makes this really interesting is that when a player advances a track it advances for every single player that's on that track so sometimes you might find yourself not wanting to select a track just because you don't want to help your opponents Advance along the track and it's really interesting how this affects decision making do you want to join a track where your opponent is and possibly move it along and help them while you're helping yourself that's not the only way way that you're helping your opponents though another very unique aspect of this game is that resources are shared so as you move along these paths and you collect a resource it's not a token that you put next to your player board rather it's a marker that you use on the track at the bottom of the board so you'll adjust the marker to show how many of that resource is available to be spent and then at the end of the turn you can use those resources or if you leave them on the board you can collect victory points for leaving them there it represents rehabilitating part of the forest now even though you'll collect the victory points those resources become available for the other players to use this game has so much going on shared resources action tracks that will get more valuable the longer you stay there and
then there's even a really cool mechanic about how cards get laid in order to get points for putting the creatures there there's just everywhere in this game is something that is very unique and that's why I'm recommending this game as the best game from this list however it is also probably the most complicated game I don't think it's too bad but it is very complicated Oak isn't that bad but it has a lot of resources that you'll need to interpret in different kinds of actions after that it's kind of a tie between Creature Comforts and living Forest although my six-year-old can play both games I don't know if she fully understands every aspect of both games but she is very it's very easy for her to come along for the ride and then finally the easiest game that even my six-year-old can play with no problem is my little everdel so take that into consideration don't just go off and buy arboria if you've never played a game that has a whole lot going on I hope you enjoyed this video if you'd like to check out more of my content I do have a web app called the perfectboard game.com it checks Amazon every day for the best deals and every game there as a profile that describes it in terms of its theme mechanics components strategy and complexity I will always leave links in the description for that otherwise thank you very much for watching and I will see you next time bye