Skip to main content
Loading video...

TABLE PRESENCE... creating board games that STAND OUT *Kipp Mir Saures* *Strand Under*

Transcript 8:18

in a recent video i discussed hooks in board game design the hook is the key feature which draws players in the thing which makes them want to engage it could be the theme of the game it could be the mechanisms or it could be contextual the reputation of the designer or publisher in this video we're not focusing on any of these we're looking at physical hooks board game circles we call this table presence i'm adam porter i'm a game designer from wales in 2018 brain games released my trick taking game picoco the game garnered a lot of attention but not necessarily from the sectors that i had anticipated many gamers did enjoy the game it even won a couple of awards but i was most surprised by the interest from toy companies the card holders really caught their imagination i was invited to talk on panels to toy industry professionals to pitch ideas to mass market toy companies to speak to product design students about board game design and the weird thing was none of these people had actually played the game the defining feature of picoco was not the gameplay as i'd imagined but the presentation i recently received complimentary copies of two games from german publisher zok verlag kipmia saurez and strandunter both are fun games and as with pacoco their core hook is not the gameplay but the memorable physical components the goal of kit is to score the most victory points by completing packages of sweets the game focuses around a large cardboard

contraption consisting of three tubes balanced over a central stand each player has three large dice of three different colors and likewise for three medium dice and three small on your turn you place a single die inside any one of the tubes and you're hoping that the tube will tip over spilling dice on your turn because then you're gonna have the first opportunity to select a dive from that pool once you've taken a dice and used its associated action each other player in turn selects a dive for themselves the action you take depends on the color of the tube which spilled the dice if your dice come from the copper tube you take coloured cubes representing sweets from the supply matching the number and color of the dye that you selected you also keep the dye itself if the tube the dye came from was silver you select a card from the central display this is an objective you'll need to complete a point scoring package of sweets you can only select a card matching the color of the die you selected unless you select a mixed package in which case you need to match the number on the die to the number of ingredients on the card but a die showing 6 is wild and allows you to select any mixed package if the tube the die came from was golden then you can complete a package choose a card in front of you which matches the die you selected discard the required suites and place the die onto the card to show that the package is complete the game ends when one player has completed their fifth package and players total the scores on their completed packages there's a bonus for completing one package of each color

including a mixed package and an individual bonus for having the most completed packages of each color in strand hunter the game board is a plastic beach with grooves corresponding to each round of the game a blue sheet lays across the beach representing the sea for the first eight rounds of the game the sea moves outwards with the tide revealing one extra groove full of shells each round and for the final few rounds the tide comes back in each round all players simultaneously reveal their chosen action for the round take a single shell and a sand castle or take a selection of shells chosen actions are resolved from the left of the dial to the right if a player has gathered enough appropriately coloured shells they can build one of their sand castles in the groove corresponding to the current round but if you build that too far out you run the risk of your castle being destroyed when the tide returns the game ends when one player has built their fourth castle and then players total their points from the value of castles they've built assuming they're still standing and the value of the grooves they've built them in so it pays to push your luck and build closer and closer to the sea at the end of the game the highest scorer wins with over a thousand games being released each year it's easy for really fun games to get lost in the shuffle a strong physical presence can really lift a product making it visible among a sea of competitors for consumers in 2022 gorgeous artwork is an expectation rather than a selling point so game makers have started to look to the third dimension extending their games

vertically in order to literally stand out stacking bamboo stalks in takanoko to recreate the colorful japanese garden or creating temples from resin pieces in tikal or placing plastic palm trees and statues in tobago these are the peaceful equivalents of warring miniatures the gentler cousins of the mex in scythe or the ninja clans of tmnt shadows of the past but table presence is about more than pieces occupying a board some games experiment with the board itself in brain games ice cool the board is created from a stack of boxes within boxes creating a large arena for the penguin flicking players in worker placement game everdell cards and components are placed on the upper branches of a cardboard tree a feature with little utility but great aesthetic appeal the goal is to make your game look great from across the room and towering game pieces are hard to miss they also look great in photographs when i was a kid some of the biggest selling board games were ghost castle hero quest and mouse trap all games which knew that three-dimensional components counted for an awful lot especially if you wanted to stand out in a 1980s christmas catalog 40 years on some publishers incorporate distinctive but entirely unnecessary contraptions in their games the bird box dice tower in wingspan which really serves little purpose beyond separating used from unused dice the pyramid dice dispenser in camel up which could easily be replaced with a simple cloth bag you

could dismiss these devices as cynical ploys unnecessary chrome included to squeeze a few more pounds out of undiscerning consumers but i think you'd be missing the point wingspan's bird box and camel ups pyramid are a significant part of the identity of those games yes the pieces could easily be set aside and replaced with something simpler but the games would be lesser without them atmosphere in games is important the strength of xox devices in particular is they're not unnecessary at all in fact the games are built around the devices rather than the device being built to supplement the game kit mia saurez couldn't exist without the teetering tubes integrating physicality into the game design from the earliest stages is a design philosophy which zock knows well their spielders yares winner niagara used the box as a river and waterfall with transparent discs representing the flow of the water i recently reviewed zok's gazanka after planka a simple pirate game where players attempt to unbalance a rocking pirate ship to send their opponents overboard physical design is similarly integrated into the game picker mouse from gigamik where players peer through the windows of a house lit by a small bulb with a built-in 30 second timer the best devices in games create moments players shriek when the tubes topple in kit mir saures they hold their breath when the pirate ship sways in kazankar after planka and they groan when the lights go out in picomaus so what does this all mean for us as game designers well maybe nothing and

maybe a lot the spark of an idea can come from anywhere so why not a contraption a cardboard device a gimmick a widget one of the most frequent questions asked of game designers is theme or mechanisms what comes first well how about neither starting your design from a physical component is every bit as valid and could create that rare thing in the board game industry a product which is truly unique let me know in the comments what's your favorite game with great table presence and if you enjoyed the video please watch some of my others hit like subscribe to the channel and i'll see you next time all the best

Progress saved