Skip to main content
Loading video...

Codenames: Critical Role Adventures Review - Not Just A Retheme

Transcript 19:01

Hey, I'm Alex from Board Game Co, and today we're reviewing Codenames Critical Role Adventures from CGE. Codenames Critical Role Adventures is a new spin on Codenames, a two-to-four-plus player game. The box says two-to-four-plus. It's not really four-plus. It's really two-plus. Honestly, it's just a two-plus player game. I'm not entirely sure why they chose four-plus. You can play this at two, at three, at four, five, six, seven, eight, nine, 10. It starts to get a little unwieldy, honestly, at that point. I would recommend it at like I guess maybe two-to-four players. I guess that's probably why they said two-to-four. Okay, I'm I get it now. I get it now. Two-to-four-plus player. This is a two-plus player game, Codenames Critical Role Adventures, that is not just a re-theme of Codenames. If you've played Codenames Disney or Codenames Marvel, and you're like, "I just don't need this." This is very different. It brings a lot of new mechanics to the table. I'm going to go ahead and dive into what Codenames generally is doing, what Critical Adventures brings to the table, as well as my thoughts and opinions. Before we do, this channel is sponsored by All Play. More about them at the end of the video. In this game, in this iteration of Codenames, well, let's talk about Codenames first. Codenames is a clue-giving game. The basic idea of Codenames is you have a grid of cards.

It's usually a five-by-five grid, not whatever this shape is over here. But in that five-by-five grid, what you're going to do is you're going to have a clue card that is telling yourself, the clue master, so to speak, what what the grid you're going for is. So again, without focusing too much on the specific details of this game, let's see these yellow cards over here. These yellow cards are going to be the things you're giving clues for. Which means I want to give a clue for friendship, and wand, and quest, and rune. But I really want to avoid apple, cuz that's the death card. And then in traditional Codenames, you have the other team. In Codenames Duet, there's other cards to avoid. But basically, the core idea is you have cards you're trying to get your clue your your team members to guess. So looking at this grid over here, if I have academy, wheel, quest, friendship, wand, I don't actually know which way I'd go with this. Uh we have blood. Blood, wheel. I probably should have thought of this beforehand. I'm not going to overly think of this. I might have just gone with magic. Who knows what. Academy. Academy and wand. Wizard.

I'll go with wizard, okay? So if I did wizard two, if that was my clue, then I'm hoping that wizard two is enough for them to connect wand and academy. Unfortunately, spell is also in the mix cuz that was a terrible clue, and they might guess spell, which would be a break the clue cycle. They wouldn't get that card. Maybe they guess wand. So, if they guess wand, I go ahead and mark, and I say, "Look, congratulations, you got wand." Then they guess spell, and I'm like, "Oh, no, unfortunately, your turn is over. You can no longer keep guessing cuz you got it wrong." The general idea is you give a word, in this case, wizard, and then you give a number, two, which is the number of cards you want that word to refer to, and you're trying to guess your teammates to figure out what you were trying to get them to do. When you get all of your cards, you win the game. That's the general idea of Codenames. There's of course a lot of small minutiae around the rules. There's the different variants that Codenames brings to the table. Codenames Pictures, brings you a 4x5 grid, but now it's picture-based. I don't like it quite as much. I still like it. I still have it, but I find words are far more open. And then there's also things like, you know, Codenames Duet, which is going to be a two-player cooperative version of the same thing. Basically, without getting too much into it, there's a lot of different ways to play Codenames. Which brings us to Critical Role. Oh, and then there's the offshoots, the variants, the themes. So, you have like Codenames Disney and Codenames Marvel. And those will just give you the same exact game, but all the words are Disney-themed, or all the words are Marvel-themed, which I find entirely less interesting and just less fun than open-ended Codenames.

Which is why when Codenames Critical Role Adventures was announced, at first I was like, "I guess this is more accessible than Disney or whatnot." Like, it's basically just a bunch of geek things. Like, I I never watched Critical Role. I have no idea the I mean, I know the general people behind it, I guess, but like, I don't I've never watched a single episode. I don't think I've seen more than two minutes of it in my entire life. So, I don't care about that, but it's still like just dungeon stuff and geek stuff, which I am a fan of. So, that's nice, but I still don't care for themed sets of Codenames cards. I find it's just less interesting than just playing open-ended Codenames. But then I found out that Critical Role Adventures is bringing in a bunch of different things to your Codenames experience. And we're going to go ahead and uh I guess walk you through those. The general idea is it is an adventure. This is cooperative Codenames. So, the first difference is going to be the player count. Traditional Codenames is going to be a four-plus player game. I think there's variants you can play at less, but traditional Codenames I would say is four-plus players. You need two teams. You need a clue giver and a clue guesser on both teams. You could play at six and have two clue guessers and one clue giver. You always have like flexibility around the team numbers, but it's a four-plus player game that plays best in even counts at four, six, eight, 10, and honestly at more than 10 it tops out. I really think it's four, six, eight is what I would play traditional Codenames at. Codenames Duet allows you to play as a two-player cooperative game, you and the other player. It's a clever system that allows you to break that. And then we have Codenames Critical Adventures, which I find works great at two, works great at three, works great at four. And once you go above four, it honestly works a little less great. It's still fine, but it does work a little less great, which is probably why the box says two to four-plus players, which I only realized when I was filming this video, but that's neither here nor there. So,

that's the first difference is going to be the player count. Because this is a cooperative Codenames game, but not strictly had to have the way Codenames Duet is. So, the first thing I'll say is if you're interested in playing Codenames at three players and you haven't done so until now because it's not the best game at a three-player count, this changes that. As far as the structure of it, you are going on an adventure. The game gives you three adventure maps to go through. There's going to be an adventure map with a starting point where you're going to be starting, shockingly enough, and then moving along branching pathways as you make choices going on an adventure and then choosing which which which the way your adventure is going to take you while occasionally visiting the merchant along the way until you eventually reach the adventure conclusion. That's all going to be handled in your little uh your little reference book over here, which gives you the specific adventure. Again, there's three campaign arcs. You can see those color palettes over here, which bring you through those, giving you a bit of a story. A a cutpurse stole your purse. You chase them into an alley. Now you have to choose whether to track them down, alternatively go to the wizard in the tower, and then the wizard in the tower is going to direct you to go to that way. And you have this kind of story you're going through, but each story is ultimately going to have you setting up a grid of cards, and then it's going to give you specific things you're trying to do. Because the things it's going to do is going to be the various the the colors over here. We have the traditional yellow cards. Those are the things you want to get. We have the blue cards, which are going to be good cards generally, but they're going to be things that are are specific changes to the adventure. So, for example, your very first quest to not be too spoilery, your very first quest the yellow cards represent general thugs you're attacking, and the blue cards represent special more powerful thugs that give you better rewards, but they're still cards you're just trying to get. So, all the abstracted theme and all that, they're basically just cards

you're trying to get your teammate to guess, and there's just rule differences around them. That's generally how the blue cards operate. Then there's going to be the misses. Misses over here are just a traditional Codenames miss. If you're playing Codenames, you get it wrong, you miss. The difference is, unlike traditional Codenames, your characters have health over here. Your characters are going to be starting with various health tokens, and then as you take a miss basically, you're going to be flipping that health token over to its wounded side, you take a wound. Your characters die, and unfortunately, that's not great for you. Try not to die in this game. So, that's the basic idea as far as the misses, they already give you a wound. But then to make matters worse, there's also going to be these countdown cards. Countdown cards represent how much time you have in each mission. If you've played Codenames Duet, you're familiar with the idea that if you're playing it cooperatively, you need something you're working against, and the clock is going to be that main thing. So, the clock here is going to be represented by these cards over here, which you have a variable number, generally from three to five per mission, but they also correlate to numbers over here. What does that mean?

That means if, for example, I had guessed prayer instead of spell when I was trying to do wizard, it wouldn't have been a great choice, but if I did do prayer, then they would have taken a card over here and put it down, and we would have lost one of our countdown timers. Not only does my character take a wound, or whoever guessed, but additionally, you're going to lose one of your precious turns. So, really try to avoid the red cards. They're not instant death, but they are the countdown timer you are working against, and if those cards run out, either through your guessing, or because when you're done guessing, you automatically flip one over, look at the number, and put it on that matching card, which does narrow the grid a little bit, but at the cost of time, which is the most precious resource that you do not want to run out of. I think I also rotated this. I think it was this way. I don't actually remember how this was. It was some way. Don't worry too much about that. But anyways, that's the idea as far as these cards over here. So now we have the basic cards you're going for, the special cards you're going for, the basic cards you're trying to avoid, the time cards you're trying to avoid, and then of course the death card, which is going to represent if you hit that, you instantly die, generally. Which is the other thing Codenames Adventures brings to the table is going to be different rules, changes, and structures as far as kind of these scenarios you're going for. There's a lot of things going on as far as the again, there's multiple There's all these three campaigns. Each campaign has multiple branching pathways. I don't I didn't do the full count of the mission, but it's probably something like, I don't know, nine, 10 missions. 30 There's like 30 or so missions uh that you can play through. Each has rule differences, and there's going to be interesting times.

There's going to be times where you want to get the death card, but possibly at a specific point in the adventure. So like, the rules change. The rules are different traditional Codenames. The goal is not get all yellow cards. The goal is do whatever the mission briefing says, which might be get four yellow cards, uh then get the two blue cards, then get the death card. It might be It could be any number of combinations of things you're trying to do before you eventually uh tap out, and then either stop guessing, run out of time, or die. The other thing the game brings is going to be characters. You have these character sheets. You're always going to have three characters per game, which means if you're playing head-to-head, if you're playing a two-player game, then you have one person controlling the three characters, one person giving clues. A four-player game, each person controls a character, another person gives clues. A three-player game, it works well, trust me. You're going to have two people controlling the three characters together, but don't worry, this isn't a game where you kind of have your own character to control you march around the dungeon. It's not like that.

The way it works is when you're making a guess, you choose a character, and you say, "I think this character will be the best one to make a guess." And then they go on the board, they make a guess. If you If you've got it right, you keep going, you pick another character make a guess. Then you make another character make another guess. Once you have all three characters on the board, then they can keep jumping around. You're not limited to three guesses, but you are limited to you have to place your characters out sequentially, not in the specific order, but you have to place them out one at a time, and you can't reuse a character until you've placed the other one out. This matters primarily because, first of all, who's going to take the wound if you're wrong? If you have a character down to one health, and you're less sure about that guess you're making, maybe don't choose them to make the guess because they'll die, and that's not great. So, that's the first reason it matters. The second reason is going to be the abilities. Characters have all kinds of abilities. They have basic abilities they start with. As you gain experience, which is every time you get some right, as well as the mission objectives, rewards, and all that, you're going to be ticking up this chart, gaining more health, and also gaining various abilities. So, over here we have Vexahlia, who's going to gain tracking and then longshot. Tracking's very cool. Tracking allows her to go ahead and kind of figure out where the death card is. Not necessarily the exact location, but is it around her? Is it any of the spaces around her? That's very, very helpful information to know if the death card is in a particular grid of cards, and you can slowly narrow that down through continuing to use Vexahlia over here.

Then you're going to unlock longshot, which is very cool, and you can go ahead and point at the death card and try to kill that. There's lots of interesting things. She's basically kind of a tracker/sniper, which is a very cool character. Grog over here is going to try to take wounds, well, not try to take wounds, but when he does take wounds, it's not the worst cuz it actually helps his roll modifier, cuz you're constantly going to be rolling a die for a variety of skill checks in this game to see what happens, and having an improved roll modifier is great, but he does kind of need to take wounds to get there. Until then, he's not not quite the best over there. So, characters are going to have Jester over here is kind of like a glorified Jinx almost. Again, I've never played Critical Role, I've never watched Critical Role, but I have I have watched a League of Legends. Jester comes across as a Jinx type character. She's kind of helpful, but also leaving pranks behind for her teammates to not quite so helpfully find. So, she's like, "You get an experience, and you get to heal, but also try not to step around any of the things I've left behind. That's not going to be great for anyone involved."

And so, you have these characters that are going to be leveling up, gaining abilities that are going to help you as you go through an increasingly difficult set of missions on any of the three campaign paths. So, to kind of summarize this up, this takes the core structure of Codenames, and turns it into a purely cooperative game for any number of players, not just two players. It gives you a sequence, a campaign to go through, which is going to have follow through. Like your character's health doesn't inherently heal game to game, so there is a degree of progression. You're going to have items you get at the merchants and slowly buy and level up your characters. You're going to be improving their skills as you go across this linked set of adventures, and you're doing so while controlling a host of different characters. The whole um ability sheet over here. Here's a whole sheet full of the various uh pads of different characters you can play as, as well as the different missions all the way at the end over there. So you can go through this multiple times controlling a variety of characters. I didn't actually count the characters. I think there's like eight characters or something like that. There's a bunch.

You can go ahead and uh dive into this in a variety of ways. That was much longer of an overview than I thought, but I wanted to give you an idea of what Codenames: Critical Adventures is doing. Which brings me to my thoughts and opinions. I'm a huge fan of Codenames. I love Codenames. I love Codenames: Duet. I love Codenames. I think word word puzzly games are tremendously satisfying. And Codenames: Critical Adventures does a great job of enhancing the formula of Codenames, really breaking it out in a way that I haven't seen them do since Codenames: Duet. They've had a lot of small things along the way. They've had expansion packs. They've had iterations and themes and all these things. But ultimately, this is the biggest innovation Codenames has seen since Codenames: Duet came on the scene, which I thought was a great addition to the Codenames family. It allowed you to play it cooperatively. And I'd say over time, I think I've still played Codenames more, but Codenames: Duet has come very very close to it. And I think this will rival that as well. When I play Codenames: Duet, I try to play the two-player little like map mode where you have different like sequences you go through. I always enjoy doing that, and this really takes that the kind of abstracted concept, and really brings it to the next level by giving you a genuine campaign with story, with branching pathways. They kind of loop back to the same places generally, but it's branching pathways, with a merchant you can visit, with characters that are leveling up and upgrading and taking wounds and dying along the way, and with real choices, not just about the guesses you're making, but about which characters make those guesses, what abilities to use, how to utilize those abilities. And it gives it to you in a variable kind of format because different ability combinations and different adventures you go on and different entire campaigns you go on will all affect the general story you're having. Not story, the general gameplay experience. The story is abstracted. The story is like a cute

little like again, you know, something happens and blah blah blah and then you find the goblins. Like the story is okay. I'm not here for the story. It is a nice cute charming thing that that for the first time I go through each mission, it's great. On subsequent plays, I'll probably kind of like, you know, not reread it each time. I guess it depends on the group. If I'm doing a new group, enough. It's a paragraph or two. But overall, this is an excellent and welcome addition to the Codenames formula. Now, there's two small things I will complain about. And so in terms of like what I like, it has everything I like about Codenames with a very well-done accessible campaign layered on top and with character growth and development and variability baked into the mix, just making this a better version of Codenames as far as I'm concerned. Between this and Codenames Duet, I think regular Codenames will see the table less and less, which has already been happening, but I think even less so. So, um this might replace Codenames. Not fully replace Codenames, it's not going anywhere, but it might replace Codenames to a large extent. Uh as far as things I don't like, there's really two things. The first is going to be the theme. The theme is still a dungeon crawl adventures. The good news is you can use Codenames cards with this. There's no reason you can't just mix in your Codenames cards, uh but trying to uh combine things with a bunch of dungeon-y things. Again, this is a pretty good pairing of cards, but occasionally you'll get things that just don't feel like like this is semi-randomish. Like it is definitely leaning more towards like, you know, the dungeon kind of theme, but even a word like clutch, like it's like it's not the easiest word to pair up with other things. Pairing up these combos is slightly harder. And I guess the tricky part there, that is the tricky part because the game's difficulty, I find generally themed Codenames sets to be more challenging. And so on the one hand, I want to integrate other Codenames sets of cards into Codenames

Critical Adventures because I find that to be more interesting and more open as opposed to trying to narrow down your clues within a subgenre of a genre. And so that's the tricky part though because the game has a difficulty adjustment, and it's not baked around making it easier. In traditional code names, if I had to had two-player game of code names, sorry, teams-based code team of code names, great, we are all playing on a level playing field. If you make this game slightly easier, even like 20% easier through utilizing less group themes of cards, and this might be a me issue. I've just always found a subgenre of a genre harder to target clues and just less satisfying. It's not the It's not the difficulty that's the issue. I just find it less satisfying to do so, but there is a difficulty component. And if I mix in regular code names cards, then it becomes slightly easier, and this cooperative game is not balanced around that. And so, that's something that I'll have to figure out and work through as I continue to play this, and figure out if house rules are necessary to adapt for that once I start integrating other code names decks. I haven't done so yet, but I'm certain I will do so in the future. So, that's my first nitpick. I still find the theme deck to be slightly less great. That would be 100% solvable with other code names decks, but then they'll make the game slightly less easier, which provides difficulty adjustments that I have to work through. That's my first nitpick. The other is just as far as campaign log tracking, some things are more easily trackable than others. Like, you can you can go ahead and make marks as far as how much health you have, but as far as things like how many wounds do you currently have as you go through a mission, a picture or jotting down notes is kind of the main thing you'll need to do. I almost wish I think it would have been overkill for this game, but I almost wish they had like dual-layered storage boards for the characters. That would have been amazing and great, and I

would have loved that. Um it's a small nitpick. It's not the biggest deal to track where you are as you go through mission to mission, cuz most people I don't think are going to sit through a full campaign in one shot. It's not super long. Like, you could play it maybe half an hour per game going through the arc, and it might be like a few hours. But, uh most people I find, at least for myself, I shouldn't say most people. I think most people, and for myself, um generally not playing code names in like 3 to 4 hour bouts of time at once. And so, you do need that ability to track things, and I don't think it's the best trackability. It's fine, not just just not the best. You'll need a bag, you know, whatever. You'll need notes. You'll need notes and pictures, generally speaking, I find. As As as final thoughts on code names Critical Adventures, I love Codenames. Codenames has been a five out of five game for me for a very, very, very long time. And Codenames Critical Adventures, and this is tricky because like do I rate this as a standalone or as an expansion, all of that? That's a little trickier for me to put in. I'll say that I'll give this as an expansion and as a new iteration of Codenames, I'm going to give it a 4.5 out of five. It brings a lot of new things to the table and it's a really, really good addition to the Codenames universe. But again, the tricky part is is this expansion is a standalone? Codenames to me is a five out of five game and this does elevate on what Codenames does, so it's an excellent experience. Highly recommended if you are a fan of Codenames, I definitely think you should check this out. And if you're not a fan of Codenames, this could well be a good time to start. As far as other game recommendations, definitely check out Codenames Duet or regular Codenames if you're looking for different variations of the same experience. And also check out So Clover, a game that has to me to a large extent replaced Codenames as my go-to, hey we need a small, short filler

party game to end the night or sometimes start the night. I think So Clover has taken over Codenames for me like for now it's it's been a while by now, but So Clover is phenomenal. So is Codenames, but definitely check out So Clover. And I mentioned that All Play is a channel sponsor. If you go to allplay.com, you can find a variety of games both from them as well as their partner publishers. If you're in the US, it's $4 flat rate shipping for anything. And I highly recommend checking out Alibi's. Alibi's is a great game that again leans in that same thing. I think between Codenames, So Clover, and Alibi's, I have all my clever word association games truly covered. Those are some of the best three they're probably the best three I have in my collection. Unless you start getting to Deduction, then like there's a whole other mix when you start doing like you know, intercepting the crypto whatever. There's a whole whole genre of these games out there. In any case, until next time, I'm Alex Radcliffe from Board Game Co. Hopefully you found this review helpful and as always, I hope you have a good one.

Progress saved