Skip to main content
Loading video...

TDG: Cody Ranks Legendary & Legendary Encounters Games (November 2026)

Transcript 25:27

Hello ladies and gentlemen and welcome to the discriminating gamer. You know, I watched a documentary last night about how they build airplanes. Riveting. Ladies and gentlemen, today we're going to go ahead and take a look at the Legendary and Legendary Encounters games. I'm going to rank them.

All right, ladies and gentlemen. So Legendary Legendary Encounters. By my count, there have been 15 Legendary and Legendary Encounters games that are complete core games. Not counting expansions, just the basic core games. This is a game system from Upper Deck. I have always loved the Legendary games uh since I first played level uh Legendary Marvel uh which I I played I I think I bought it in 2013 but I think it came out in 2012. I love love love this system. I think it's a fantastic game system and it's been so fun over the years to see which IPs they they they bring to the system and how they flush it out. It's very imaginative. So what I wanted to do is of those 15 kind of core systems, I'm just going to go through and I'm going to tell you how I would rank them and how how well I uh think they hold up and and and any other thoughts I might have about them.

But let me go ahead and jump right into it. My number 15, the one at the bottom of this list is Legendary, a Marvel deck building game. This is of course the first iteration of the Marvel deck building game and the reason why it's here is as much as I love it and and I easily played Marvel uh Legendary Marvel more than any other iteration many many times uh is because it the core game shows its age. Uh some of the masterminds are not the strongest. Some of the uh the hero cards are a bit OP. Um, and as we'll see, they've kind of refined the system, and this was their first stab at it, so you can kind of forgive them there. This is still a great game, but I don't know that I'm going to be playing just strictly this core game, I think ever again, because the system has been refined so well as we will see. But nevertheless, it set the stage for what Legendary is. It's got some great artwork, some great characters. Um, it is a very fun game that I that I love and holds a very special place in my heart. I'm actually keeping this set because I've got a lot of the expansions in this box at this point as well, but it's absolutely fantastic. So that is number 15, Legendary Marvel.

My number 14 was a version of the game that uh I played the game and I really I I loved the movie. In fact, I literally just watched the movie a few nights ago again with my wife uh cuz it's such a great film. Um, but this is well, I'll tell you right off the bat, my number 14 is Legendary Big Trouble in Little China. This was a very fun uh game to play because of the nostalgia factor. Um, it was great seeing uh you know, Jack and and and and you know, the Kim Cattrall's character and and uh Lo Pan and and and all the characters kind of put into card form in this game and how they played off of each other and and and really evoked the theme. I felt like gameplay was fun in and of itself, but to me, it was the theme that really carried this version. I didn't feel like there was a whole lot new here and this was not that long after the um Marvel Legendary came out. I I want to say this was maybe 10 years ago, 2015, 2016. So it it still kind of in its early stages, but it was a lot of fun, had a lot of of of character to the game and the theme the theme was just great.

So that is number 14 uh and I and I should put out I do know I I no longer have this. I did give this away to somebody when I moved away from uh Texas when I moved to Texas rather. Uh so Legendary Big Trouble in Little China, my number 14. All All ladies and gentlemen. So my number 13, this was from an IP I knew nothing about. Uh, but this was Legendary Buffy the Vampire Slayer. Now, Legendary Buffy the Vampire Slayer I had never seen the TV show. I still haven't. I saw the movie, the original movie, but I never saw the TV show. And so the theme kind of here did nothing for me, although I I do like vampires. But what was interesting here in this particular set is you had like the courage tokens and you could like bank these. These are like bankable recruit and and attack points, which I thought was pretty cool. And you had that track that like light and darkness track, and if you get too far to one side, it would actually triggers the the big bad's ability. So, there was some I thought there was some fun innovation here that again, even though the the the theme didn't do much for me, I really liked the the kind of steps they were taking forward and evolving the system. And it was a fun game. I really enjoyed it. I actually gave this game I think I sent it to Zach um because his girls were like big fans of Buffy the Vampire Slayer. So, I figured they'd they'd appreciate appreciate it more than I did. But I really did like this one. So, that was uh number 13, Legendary Buffy the Vampire Slayer.

My number 12 is uh Legendary Marvel Studios. Legendary Marvel Studios was great. It it as far as gameplay, I didn't feel like it was really terribly that different from the regular Marvel game. But this I mean really the the the fundamental thing that was different here was the screen caps, right? Instead of the artwork, you had the screen caps from the movies. So, this really was more of a tie-in with with the films. I really enjoyed it. I had a lot of fun with it. The theme really hit me because I was you know this was right in the heyday of the of the MCU. I think I want to say this came out in 2019. So, like right around the time of of you know like Endgame and and what have you. So, I really really enjoyed that aspect of the game here as well. I thought that was just just super fun that it tied into that thematically.

But as far as the actual gameplay goes, I I didn't think it was anything overly innovative here. It kind of played basically Marvel, but I did love the theme. And again, the theme kind of carried it for me. Uh so that is my my number 12 Legendary Marvel Studios. My number 11, this is the first Legendary Encounters game on this list. And the encounter system in some ways is superior to Legendary. Um one of the big differences is in the encounter system, the cards come off of the villain deck face down and you kind of have to pay attack in order to flip them up and reveal them. So that's a very interesting and scary prospect to a lot of these games. But this is my number 11 Legendary Encounters Predator. The Predator game was a lot of fun. And one of the things I really liked about Predator is there was kind of a different ways you could play it.

You could play it as you were humans fighting the predators or you could play it as you were predators hunting the humans. And so I really liked the different aspects of this game. I thought that was a lot of fun. Great artwork. Uh again, this is a game that you can kind of see some some some evolution in in how the game is evolving here with these different game modes. But also too, it was a it was a fun theme. I I was always a big fan of the Predator movies. Some are better than others. But I I I really like this character and it was fun to see Well, it's pretty gory too. And I kind of like to see a little more kind of mature approach to one of these Legendary games. But it was a lot of fun. And I gosh, somewhere along the line I want to Maybe I give this one to Zach again, I think. Um yeah, cuz I don't think I still have this one. But anyway, very very fun game that is a Legendary Encounters Predator.

That's my number 11. My number 10 is another Legendary Encounters. And this one was a game Again, I got this when I was down in Texas. I actually held on to this one for a long time. And when Zach was up here in August, uh I actually was looking to clear out some space and I hadn't played this one in a long time, so I went ahead and give it gave it to him. But again, this is another one that the theme really carried it, but there is still some fun gameplay here. But this is uh Legendary Encounters: X-Files. Now, I was a big fan of the X-Files. I I can't say I saw them all back in the day, but I watched a lot of them, particularly the later seasons. And I really enjoyed it. And this one was kind of fun because you had kind of that conspiracy and you were gathering evidence here. And it had some of the same great uh you know, Legendary Encounters ideas. Again, those cards coming at you face down. Uh but again, the theme was really strong with this one. I really enjoyed it. I think I did a a live play through of this one, a solo solitaire play through once. And and really enjoyed it. Played this with my friend several times when I was down in Texas. And so I so I hung on to it.

Now I'm talking about it, I kind of regret that I gave it away. But you know what? It is what it is. And I hope Zach really enjoys it. Uh but that is Legendary Encounters: X-Files. That is my number 10. My number nine is based on a film uh trilogy or I don't know. I guess they got four or five of them now. Uh I just saw the first film. And I got to be honest, I was severely underwhelmed when I saw the movie. This is Legendary Encounters: The Matrix. Uh I was not a fan of the Matrix. I In fact, Zach, when he saw the Matrix, he went on and on about it. He thought it was the greatest thing ever. And I finally uh went and saw I think I saw it with him and I was just so underwhelmed. I just thought it was not very good. Was not a fan of that film and I never saw any of the others. Never had any desire to. In fact, I heard from people who loved the first film, the others weren't very good.

But in any event, the game was great. I really liked the game. I liked how there was a there was a system here where you were um inside the Matrix or outside the Matrix. And you had like the telephone uh boxes that you you would put on the board. And if you could that get to that, you could go inside or outside. And kind of how you whether you were in out in side the Matrix or outside the Matrix would affect how you played the game. And you had little standies that would kind of show where you were. It was really fun. And I liked to I liked it. We'll see this again later. How you actually play through the sequence of events in the films. I really liked that. To that is just so much fun to to kind of relive the film. Now, again, I didn't get as much out of that this time because I was not a big fan of the film. But I really liked the idea of I I really liked that idea. And again, we'll see it again.

This was another [clears throat] one just last August I gave to Zach cuz Zach loves the Matrix. At least he loves the first one. And so I knew he'd be really excited with that. So I gave that one to him as well. Um and again, I kind of regret it cuz it's it's a fun game. I really enjoyed that iteration of it. But that is my number nine Legendary Encounters The Matrix. My number eight is a game uh that came out I want to say last year 25 I think. And it is based on an IP that I really enjoyed. And that is Game of Thrones, Legendary Game of Thrones. Uh Legendary Game of Thrones is uh first of all I I I I I read uh I started to read the books when the series before the series started and then I kind of would read a book before the series premiered. And I really loved the books. I loved the series, the beginning of the series. I thought that first season of the series was like one of the most faithful adaptations ever. I loved it.

And then as it got further away from the books, I liked it less and less and less. But the game was a lot of fun is a lot of fun. What I like about the game is this is kind of a dedicated competitive game where most of the other ways you play legendary are cooperative, this one is competitive. I don't think there is a way to play this one cooperative. I don't recall, but I if there is, I haven't played it. But what's cool about this one is you're the different houses. You're the Starks or the Lannisters or the I think the Baratheons or the Dothraki. And you are essentially trying to compete against each others um uh masterminds. You each each have your own mastermind on your own player board and you're trying to take that out, but you also have your own cards on your player board that you buy from. And then uh you you have kind of an allied deck that allied to the houses that come out and you can fight your enemies or try to advance your own. Really a fun game and and I to me I liked this one a lot because it was so innovative and it's too bad that this one didn't come out a few years earlier when the Game of Thrones hype was was really going on because I think this this game would have taken off a lot more. But it's a great game. It's really a lot of fun. I love the competitive angle of this game and again it's kind of fun playing in the Game of Thrones universe.

So that is number eight. That is Legendary Game of Thrones. Fantastic. All right, my number seven. This is again another TV show and this was one that I absolutely loved and so again the theme really grabs me. This is Legendary Encounters Firefly. I remember when Firefly aired originally I was not interested. I didn't think it looked that good and then about two or three years later a friend of mine says I've got the DVDs and he pretty much forced them on me. I'm like all right and I put one in and I go that's that's actually pretty cool and I watched it and I fell in love with it. I thought that is an amazing amazing show. So I was super excited. I've loved other games in the Firefly universe and I was really excited to play this one. Now what I liked about this one specifically is you got all the the characters from the TV show and what's fun is you play certain characters but then you have the other characters cards are the ones that actually will come out in the hero deck. So you kind of got a balanced crew that way.

It was really a fun and innovative system how the characters were were allocated in this game that I really enjoyed quite a bit. But you've got the ship on there. You got to make sure the ship's doing all right. But it's encounters. So again the cards are coming at you upside down. You got to flip them over and take them out. There's some real fun abilities with some of the cards here that were also coming out and then again to you see some of these just great moments from the TV show played out which I really really loved and so again this is another one that I really like the the the mechanics on it but the theme again probably pushes it over the edge for me. It is so much fun. So that is number seven that is Legendary Encounters Firefly. All right, my number six. This is a game based on a long running movie series. I was actually really surprised when they announced this one and it's awesome.

This is Legendary James Bond. Legendary James Bond is great. Again, this is one that plays through the movies. In fact, I think there's there's three or four of the movies in the base game. There have been several expansions and each expansion is a movie and you play through the movies. You got the characters and what not. You play through the movies and the events and villains and whatever. And so I really enjoy this and and and I've come to enjoy it, but you've also got the the the the final card that comes through that you're trying to stop here as you're going through the villain deck. You've got the the track also too. There's a track that you can can increase the danger or or what have you that affects the way the cards are moving on the board. It's just it's just great. And again, the theme here is so well integrated into the game with each movie plays a little bit different with with how you play it. And the I think there's usually one or two different schemes or one or two different masterminds for the movie and it's just it's phenomenal. I I love I always enjoyed the James Bond movies. I don't know anybody that doesn't like the James Bond movies.

And this is such a fun way to play in that universe. So again, the theme is just not going to get out of the park here. So that is my number six Legendary James Bond. All right, we're getting into my top five. Okay. I'll just tell you right now, it's Legendary Marvel What If. This was such a fun way to play Marvel because again, the what if that you got all these kind of crazy scenarios. I think my favorite one here is there's the Marvel Zombies one where you're actually fighting the the zombies. That was that was so cool. but again, great mastermind, some big concept ideas here with what if. I like how it takes your the typical kind of Marvel heroes or whatever and just kind of flips them on the side. Really a fantastic job. I really really really enjoyed this game quite a bit. It is um again, I'm going to say it's one where the theme, this kind of Marvel just just weird counterfactual Marvels if I can even say that, uh alternate history Marvel stuff just really brings a lot a lot to it.

Again, great characters here, some great schemes, and just a lot of fun. So that is uh my number five Legendary Marvel What If. My number four is a game that uh I bought pretty early on. I want to say it came out 2015 or there abouts, maybe 2014. And I bought it when it came out and I was really excited cuz it seemed like it didn't stick around long, which is a shame because it's a great version of the game. And this is Legendary Marvel Villains. This is great. You know, you've got it kind of again, it turns things on on on their head. You are the villains in the Marvel universe and you're fighting the heroes instead of a mastermind, you've got the commander, right? And it's just it's fun to kind of play that inversion of of of of the of the roles here. You've got some great again, great characters that you're playing, some great villains that you're playing. And the way the heroes come out and and and and and beat you up and and do all sorts of things. Again, very thematic, very thematic here. And it's just fun to play the baddies once in a while. Uh it's a great set.

And uh again, I I I think they only did one or two expansions for it. So I don't know that it this one particularly did that well, but it seemed like forever I was hearing people saying, oh, I wish they'd gotten that one. I wish I gotten that one. I'm glad I've got it. It's a great game. So that is uh the Legendary Marvel Villains. That's my number four. All right, my number three. Uh this is a game that just came out this year. And this is Legendary Marvel Second Edition. So this is the way you really should enjoy Legendary Marvel. They tweaked it. They they they they made the mastermind stronger. They've even got epic sides. Uh the heroes are more balanced. They changed the artwork on the heroes. There's more kind of variety there. The game just feels a little more challenging. It's it's just and that makes it more fun, right? You're it's kind of harder to get to where you need to be and to make the cards work for you.

Um but again, I've talked about Marvel left and right here. I love the various Marvel expansions that have come out and this is 100% compatible with all of the Marvel expansions. It's just a great game. This is the way to play Marvel, right? I I highly highly if you don't have the original base game, I highly urge you to get this one or even upgrade if you want to, but it's just it's a superior way to play the game and I really enjoy it. I've always loved the Marvel system and this is the way to play it. So that is my number three, Legendary Marvel Second Edition. Okay, my number two. This again is a game that just came out this year. And this is Legendary a DC deck building game. Now again, [clears throat] Legendary Marvel and Legendary DC as far as just the game Mexico, they're probably on par, but this crosses the finish line between those two because of the theme. I was always more of a DC guy than a Marvel guy. I love Batman and Superman and Wonder Woman and Green Lantern. I actually when I was a teenager, I collected these comic books and there's so much fun. The characters are so much fun. Marvel characters are fun too, but I don't know. I just part of my childhood is here. Batman is like to me the greatest superhero of all time.

And it's so fun to see these characters finally in this system. Now I have the DC deck building game. I've got pretty much everything for the DC deck building game right here if you can see it. And it is a great game. And Legendary DC in no way replaces it. It's a different game. Both deck builders of both DC characters, but it's a very different game. And I freaking love the DC Legendary game. It is so fun. Like I say, you got Green Lantern, Superman, Batman, Wonder Woman, Flash, Cyborg, uh, Zatanna, Zatanna. You've got just so many of these great iconic heroes. And then you've got so many great masterminds. You got Lex Luther, you've got the Joker, um, Circe. It's it's just so much fun.

Captain Cold. You've got so many great uh, villains here and they're all doing some fun and interesting things. Uh, you got some great schemes here as well that are, you know, you get one where you're like like bribing like like Gotham underworld and they're trying to like bribe characters and stuff. Uh, it's just Oh, it's so good. It's so much fun. I also like too you've got the hope and fear track that you're kind of manipulating and if you you you get the hope all the way up, you can draw an extra card. If it if it's all the way down, you got to discard a card. I just love this system so much and this DC one I've been waiting for this for a long long time. I remember years ago was thinking, oh, it'd be so great if we had the DC characters in the legendary system. I'm sure a lot of other people thought that too. And I'm so glad we finally got it and it succeeds brilliantly. It is so much fun. Um, and what what I like about it too is it is different enough from Marvel that you can have to and you get a different experience. Now, I mean, basic plays the same, but there's enough differences here that that make them distinct games and I love that. I was scared it was just going to be a clone of Marvel and it's not. It's a very different game in a lot of important ways.

So that is Legendary DC. That is my number two. All right, my number one. Now, I got to tell you for a long time I would go back and forth between Marvel and and this one. Um, a lot of times I go back and forth. And when I sat down to do this list, I really thought a lot about this. I mean, I knew DC had edged out Marvel, but then the question was well, is it DC or is it this one? And I went back and forth and back and forth and I just I realized no, I I just love this one so much. This is Legendary Encounters an alien deck building game. I love it. Now, I love it for a lot of the reasons that I've already mentioned. It's an Encounters. The cards are coming to your face down. Remember the first time I played it with Zach. He was like it's just like the movie Aliens when they're like, you know, 10 meters, 7 meters, they're coming. You just don't know. It's it's scary, and you got to do that scan action to to try to find out if they're coming.

But I like, again, the base set has the four movies in it. And as you are playing through these movies, again, you're seeing the Avengers. Now, I got to tell you, I wasn't a big fan of the third and the fourth film, but the games are fun. But I love playing the first two and reliving those movies in this game. It is just so good seeing the characters from the movies. Again, there's a big thematic component here, but mechanically this is great. And it's got the coordinate ability, too, which I love, which you see in some of the other additions later on. But coordinate allows you to under certain circumstances you play the card to give another player recruit or attack points when they need it. So there's always a possibility if you don't have enough recruit or attack, somebody else can help you out. And I love that aspect of the game here. Very thematic, great artwork. And again, I like how it's kind of gory. There's some blood on it and and gore. And I like I like that aspect of the game, too, a more mature Legendary.

It's just a great game. And I got to tell you something. This is a game it's a cooperative game that I lose far more often than I win, but I have won it. Played this game so much. I've won it several times. And it's a game that when you win you you cheer because you're not expecting to win, you know? You're not. It's a it's a hard game, but man, it's fun. So that is my number one Legendary game. That is Legendary Encounters, an alien deck building game. Well, ladies and gentlemen, what do you think? How would you rank the Legendary games? Would you put them higher, lower? Would you mix them around? Are you not a fan of Legendary? Let me know. I'm always interested to know what you have to say in the comments. So leave a comment here on YouTube, on Board Game Geek, on Facebook, on X. Love to hear what you have to say about these games as well. Now, again, I'd ask you to like this video, subscribe to the channel. That means a lot to us. Please, please, please check out my other channel, Cody Carlson PhD.

We talk about books and history and I put some of my lectures on there. It would mean the world to me if you would like uh subscribe to that channel as well. And if you do really like what we do here, please click on the super thanks button and leave a tip. You know, my wife says she's leaving me because of my Star Wars obsession. I just said, may divorce be with you.

Sideman.

Progress saved