Skip to main content
Loading video...

Making a board game people WANT to play *Boardgame Design* *Product Design*

Transcript 9:18

the starting point for user oriented design is empathy understanding your end user in my video last week i discussed how board games can facilitate social interaction by fulfilling some basic human desires in this video we're going to look at seven more human desires and explore how board games can tap into these in order to make the games valuable to their owners i'm adam porter i'm the designer of picoco and quasal and big bazaar and doodle rush and compromat and zuligans and throne and in the previous video we were looking at the sort of experiences that people care about and how we can design our board games to tap into these basic human needs the list of human desires we're working from was put together by stephen rice after a landmark global psychological study in the year 2000 rice identified 16 basic human desires that motivate human behavior we already dismissed romance and eating as probably falling outside the realms of what a board game can offer last week we talked about seven desires relating to human interaction so that leaves seven more basic human desires and once again i don't believe that all players desire all of these things and i certainly don't think that any one board game can fulfill every desire but a designer who addresses a number of these is probably creating something that people are going to want to play so players want a challenge i'm not a neuroscientist so forgive any anatomical inaccuracies here i understand though that there is a

specific portion of the brain which drives us to explore and learn new things this is called the seeking system and it's found in humans and animals alike essentially the process is driven by dopamine released from our brains often in anticipation of a reward and the dopamine arouses you and propels you to take action in my previous video about user experience or ux design i discussed feedback loops and how they engage players board games are wonderful at challenging us in all manner of different ways and then rewarding us for our actions or motivating us to try again to keep going until we succeed every game box offers up a new complex environment to explore with unique problems to solve whether they're tactical or strategic or interpersonal it's vital that game designers engage this seeking system by providing challenges and constant feedback to the players players want independence board games are at their best when they provide the players with meaningful decisions players are freed from their work life and home life and a board game provides a space where no one's going to tell you what to do you make your own choices and success or failure feels justly earned you also get to play at being autonomous in a myriad of different worlds that you would never experience in real life a designer needs to carefully consider whether the players are able to make choices in their game and even more importantly do the choices matter there's no autonomy in snakes and ladders you roll the dice and you see

where you land and this limits its appeal to young children and even they are going to lose interest fairly quickly monopoly is over 100 years old and it's starting to look a bit dated the game does feature decisions but they can sometimes be rendered irrelevant because of a poor dice roll or a damaging random draw from the chance deck this wouldn't necessarily be a problem in a short game but it can be really disheartening in a game which can take a long time to play modern game designers need to carefully consider the balance of meaningful choices versus random events to maximize the engagement of their players players want order board games have great appeal for people who love to organize there's a whole side industry built around custom box inserts to keep all your game pieces neatly stored collectors proudly share photographs of their ikea shelving packed with board games neatly organized according to color or box size or genre but the drive to organize doesn't stop at components in game players are compelled to manage resources purchasing them building them trading them upgrading them they build personal decks of cards or organize their hand of cards to maximize their scoring potential games which offer great opportunities to organize stuff have a really good chance of engaging players players want to collect some of the most successful tabletop games of all time have used this desire to generate massive profits most notably magic the gathering pokemon and warhammer all these games require players to purchase new components regularly to

customize your game and keep up with the opposing players in the case of magic the gathering and similar collectible games like star wars destiny the booster packs are sealed so you can't see what's inside until you rip them open these games often feature rare cards or items to drive the player to seek them out and to give them a huge dopamine rush when they happen upon a desirable component this drives further collecting behavior it's been criticized for being quite a cynical business model but there's no doubt that it forces players to engage and keep spending it's often said that sales of collectible card games keep most gaming stores afloat but even outside of collectible card games the hobby has a strong collecting aspect to it thousands of games are produced each year and a large proportion of these are aimed at adults who have a fair amount of disposable income some gamers will purchase a lot of games on a regular basis and they might follow certain publishers or designers or genres of game purchasing everything released in that category game designers and publishers can tap into this desire by creating a connected range of games expansions and sequels i'm going to talk about this more in a later video players want to improve society now i don't believe that this desire is inherently part of board games but there are opportunities here of course the primary goal of a board game is to engage the players and facilitate fun but if the game promotes positive messages along the way or at least if it doesn't propagate negative ones then that can only be a bonus

occasionally a board game will very deliberately wade into serious real-life subject matters freedom the underground railroad is an opt-quoted example and this one deals with guiding slaves to freedom holding on the troubled life of billy kerr is a cooperative game about end-of-life care other games touch on issues related to ecology or climate change commercially such a product might not appeal to a mass audience although i don't have access to sales figures so who am i to judge but such passion projects enrich the board game space and remind us that games don't have to be frivolous or disposable they really do hold up as pieces of art it also appears that the most prominent voices in board game media do have a strong desire to improve society among board game commentators conversation about social issues is almost as present as conversation about game mechanisms and content at least in my twitter or facebook echo chamber the designer of a game which ignores this push for societal progress is damning themselves to widespread criticism on social media and this can be really hard to recover from plus it's just not nice players want to demonstrate physical prowess now admittedly this isn't the first thing which comes to mind when talking about board games and i would suggest that it's a fairly niche corner of the hobby but dexterity games do remain popular with certain audiences they may not get you sweating from physical exertion but games like bandu and croconol and flick em up do allow players to demonstrate their

physical prowess if that's what's important to them players want to relax many board games are relaxing stress-free experiences particularly if they're not rules-heavy but of course it's also worth noting that some games do invoke significant anxiety in people whether it's because of a requirement to lie or to be creative or to demonstrate your general knowledge i've seen extremely clever people paralyzed with anxiety when faced with too many choices for fear of revealing themselves as unintelligent i've also witnessed strong strategic players terrified when faced with a game requiring creativity such as dixit for fear of revealing themselves as unimaginative i believe anxiety is one of the biggest hurdles preventing new people from entering the hobby there's no easy answer for this but an effective onboarding process is going to be very helpful make your rulebooks understandable make your graphic design clear and effective make your gameplay intuitive provide player aids how to play videos apps engage with rules queries online all of this and more is covered in my recent video about onboarding so that concludes a rather lengthy list of human desires and the challenge for you now is to work out which of these human desires your product fulfills and perhaps even more importantly how are you going to convey to your audience the experience that's contained within your box is it going to be the artwork the title what's written on the back of the box and i talk about that more in my recent

video about promises and expectations what is it about board games what is it that they offer that keeps you coming back to the table

Progress saved