Skip to main content
Loading video...

Top Solo Historical + War Games | 2024

Transcript 1:08:51

hey Gamers this is Liz Davidson beond solit here and we are here to celebrate the second year of the top historical and war game solo list that uh brand here from armer drons and I have put together uh with surveys from war Gamers like you or if you're watching and you didn't vote maybe you could do it next year um but I'm Liz uh obviously you're my Chanel is to be on soliter uh we have bran from armchair drons who is our data master who collects and handles all this data so he's going to talk to us about it uh we've got Mike Kelly from OneStop Cop Shop is a game designer and solo gamer extraordinaire and we also got Paul wries uh heavy solo gaming expert historical game expert and also uh incoming game designer woohoo so good morning gentlemen morning good morning uh all right so why don't we just start brand why don't you just give us like a quick overview of what we collected how we collected it so that as we talk about stuff throughout the video people know where it came from yeah sure um I made it up so yeah Liz came up with this idea last year that um I guess there's a there's a giant solo gaming survey that that is done on BGG every year but tends to kind of leave out a lot of the wargaming folks and the historical gaming folks and so last year Liz said hey we should do this focused on these guys all right great let's do it and and so we said we were going to make this an annual thing this is the second year we're doing this we we run a survey we use Google forms because it's easy and uh and and we ask folks um for their top five Solo or

solitaire games and kind of they don't have to be purpose designed for solitire they can be ones that you just enjoy playing solo even if that means multi-hand or using a bot or whatever uh so so you know prop a mirror up across the table from you to pretend you're playing with an opponent whatever you want to do um and then we do want to focus on war games or Liz what was the term you Ed games that deeply engage with history I think was the term you used yeah games that seriously engage history something like that yeah I paraphrasing but you can go read the original announcement and it's it's all there um and and the the one thing that is a little bit of a headache for some folks is that we we ask folks to paste the URL to the BGG listing in there and we do that because that allows us to keep the data consistent across all the entries we don't have to worry about somebody misspelling something or not putting the appropriate addition or or version of the game in there and that's relevant we'll talk about that when we get to the the actual games themselves um but we ask them for their their top five and then we ask a couple of fun questions at the end how long you've been wargaming how much of your your gaming is solo that kind of stuff and and we'll talk about some of those those questions in a minute also those at the end of the survey those are just optional so we don't necessarily have full numbers for every one of those um but then when we score these things we we do kind of college football poll scoring right first place vote is worth Five Points second place is worth four points and on down the way we stacked the list is that we go with the aggregate Score first so the highest

score across all the votes um and and rank them from there if there is a tie on that number the tie breaker then goes to the average um the game with the higher average wins out on the off chance that there is both a tie in the full score and the average we look at which one got the most number of votes quite frankly usually that ends up being a tie also so at that point we're just that a tie and we just call it even um but but that's how we rank them from the top down and so so aggregate score then the average and I think we had 426 total games this year we had slightly fewer participants this year than last year um but but we still have over 400 games total on the list that got at least one vote somewhere uh once you get toward the end of the list right it's a whole lot of games with a single vote just because there's a ton of games out there uh and everybody got their own personal favorite but uh especially toward the top of the list there's some there's some interesting stuff so that's that's how we crunch the numbers that's what we come up with excellent I think that's a good this is a good launching point so rather than kind of start lower and work our way up um I think what we decided to do is just uh bite the bullet and talk about number one because it was far in way far in away number one um and that was D-Day at Omaha Beach it had the highest number of votes it had the highest sum uh it actually did not have

the highest average but that's just because it had so many votes I would say had a lot of votes yeah so y'all feeling any surprise or shock that DJ doab be number one I wasn't because it was number one last year I was I was interested to see if it fell um and and if I mean it had nowhere to go but down but if it fell and and it didn't it it hung on to the top spot so that was that was pretty good I mean it's not one I personally played and you know just looking at length and my taste in war games these days is not probably one I would ever play but I'm glad people are enjoying it it did not surprise me at all um it is one of my all-time favorite solo games period let alone solo War Games the level of granular detail but also the playability of the Solo System and just the degree of challenge that game offers um I've occasionally done well in it I've often done very poorly in it but I always find myself coming back to it it is just a wonderful uh simulation yeah and and it's been around for a while too so I mean it's it's had the chance to sort of stand the test of time and and one of the things that we'll see as we go through the list is that there are a lot of older games around and I think part of that is folks have had a chance to play them over the years you don't always get a chance to play every game in the the year it comes out and so the fact that these games have been around for a number of years has have given more people an

opportunity to try them yeah yeah so there's actually been some movement in the top five so I want to talk about that but then I do actually want to talk about I guess the relative age of games in this list because I just think it's really really interesting um so uh in the in the top three so last year's actually let's just say top five because there's been some movement so last year's top five were dday D Beach PX from your second Ed Pavlov's house fields of fire and skies above Britain um all of those are still kind of up in that top range but things have moved around a bit this year um so this year's top five are dday Beach skies above Britain RAF Battle of Britain 1940 so an oldie surges up um it was in the top 10 last year uh and then we've got fields of fire I find that very very interesting and and P PX Premier second edition pack second sorry I just like blip right over it um but Pax Premier had been second last year it is now fourth um let me look at the relative votes it got actually significantly more votes last year and the sum was significantly higher as well however it also does have one of the highest averages on the entire list I do Wonder uh you know I don't know if People's thought process goes this way but I try all of Cole's games generally and even though they're not really you know like Pack's Premier second edition is not that similar to

John company second edition they don't really feel like the same kind of game but I could see the same people who love Cole's designs putting a lot of time into John company and I think then that one shoot up to to Ninth Place right and it was in like 18th or or lower so yeah know maybe there's something there like maybe they're they're they can't fit Pax Premier and John company in their brain at the same time so they have to votee for one or the other that very possible maybe that's just me maybe I'm insane you know like oh I like this one person's game I clearly don't like that other one as much anymore they can't be the same it it is possible Paul what do you think you've played both extensively I have and I love both and when I don't have a lot of time or I'm on the road and don't have a lot of table space in a tiny hotel room I'm going to go with Pax pamier of course not John company but um for my money I think John company second edition is uh H's Masterpiece I know the arcs people will want to have me shot for saying that but I really believe that and it is just such an engaging game and while a lot of it is a a dice affair with a great amount of luck there's just such a story it tells about the East India Company and all the machinations of these various am is trying to get ahead by running it uh and I've never had a bad game of it with a multiplayer group and I've really enjoyed the Solo System

it presents a challenge in its own right so of the two I would go with John company myself interesting I I would go with pxs by a pretty large margin I do think Ricky Royal did an amazing job with a solo mode for both I'm gonna talk about solo here I think John company is amazing for multiplayer I find that solo for John company so onerous flip through that book I I was you know even after like five six plays I didn't memorize a single part of what the solo bot would do I had to flip the dang book every time to every page for every step uh so yeah but I think they're both amazing games uh Mike I think that's a fair point about the solo mode and junk company it's not for everybody I think what I like about it is it's like flipping through the brain of your opponent you know you're actually studying you know every kind of mechanism that the can use against you and I actually think it has some uh usefulness in training you to play the multiplayer game which is something I like out of a solo yeah 100% 100% that's a great point that that's actually a point that's come up in uh in the coin games as well you mentioned the whole training you for the multiplayer thing one of the one of the recommendations that we've used for years so the armchair drons we run the wargaming program at Origins and we usually have at least one coin game there every year uh they're popular they're very accessible even for folks that aren't in into you know lots of shooty bangy kinds of things we can usually get them to sit down and and play one of the the coin games with us um they they scale really well and and once you've learned the

core of the system it's pretty transferable across the game so we we try to have one every year and one of the tools that we found over the years is that for somebody who's a brand new player with one of the coin games give them give them a little bot worksheet and and what we tell them is for the first two or three turns when you're not sure what to do follow the steps on here uh follow that flowchart because it's not not necessarily always going to give you the exact best move to make under any given circumstance but it's never going to give you a dumb move it's it's going to give you a a basically competent move and it gives you a flowchart to understand the mechanics as you're working your way through it so so they're designed for the solo mode or if you if you only have three people for a four player game like that's how you run the fourth player uh but they do have utility for the multiplayer as well definitely to your point brand uh I think think the latest generation of bots in the coin Series has been really helpful in that regard because those coin driven uh Bots are much easier to use than the classic flowcharts that you saw back with Andy and abyss and Cuba Libra and I think that's just going to be so helpful to a new player yeah yeah yeah exactly definitely so just talking a little bit about the movement we had in the top handful of games U dday Beach was one last year was one this year didn't move skies above Britain um was on the list last year it went up three places it finished second this year um RAF Battle of Britain 1940

uh went up five places it was third this year so e last year uh Pax prier second edition dropped two spots from last year still in the top five but it had dropped two spots Halls of hegra shot up quite a bit from last year it went up 20 spaces you mean f fi fire Brent well fields of fire is fifth but fields of fire was fourth last year so that's just had like a one it just it just dropped one to make room for RAF basically um yeah fields of fire dropped slightly Halls of hro went up sorry I yeah I had you're right I'm realizing that uh the the the spreadsheet I'm looking at has some of the numbers wrong for the movement so I got confused and then Mr president dropped one spot um the other big rocket up the list that we saw was B7 Queen of the Skies went up 18 spots so I kind of wanted to talk about that so we've got like I mean they're totally different games but we've got kind of older games about flying kind of flying up the list here uh so Skies of Britain went up into second place which is kind of fun RAF Battle of Britain is now third uh it was eighth last year and then B7 Queen of the Skies just went screaming at the list it was like uh 26 last year yeah it was little further down there eight but like it didn't come back into print what happened this year like I don't think it's I'm not that it's bad but it's just fascinating like these kind of older Classics like a weird one

for me is like I said maybe it's not weird the fact that it stayed so high fields of fire am I correct that the like updated rules that are coming are not released yet uh you you can download the more or less finished version of okay okay I was I about other people I've been totally like I was like I tried it I'm like nope I'm going to put that to the side for like a year I'll come back to it what's the like better rules are de but I guess others have printed them out or pushing through it has been notorious for a long time for its steep learning curve yeah yeah I I I have to a personal thing so I was looking at the list uh this actually last night Liz um and I saw skies above Britain had jumped a second place and I was like skies above Britain and I for for cont text I get a lot of review copies and sometimes they kind of fall through the cracks so I have just stacks of games under like my recording table um and I was like skies above Britain and I looked and there it sited like still in shrink I'm like oh God how long have I had this I think GMT said it to me like six months ago so I uh so I opened it and read the rules and actually uh I don't know 20 minutes before we started recording I I laid it on my table and did a few of like the basic dog fights and it's really fun fun so far so I think I'm going to play some more skies above Britain after the after we're done uh so yeah I definitely slipped on that one but it's pretty cool and i't even gotten to like I think where the probably meat of the game is and managing your squadrons and chasing down bombers and all that stuff so yeah

good good I think that game is a real achievement I mean it takes the things that were good about the previous volumes in that series um what is it storm above the Reich and and one other um and Jeremy white and Gina Willis um just improved on everything and fixed some things in those earlier volumes and just created such an immersive experience I mean if you play that game and put on on Zimmer's soundtrack for Dunkirk you know you're gonna be locked in for a number of hours but what's beautiful about it is like Mike was saying you can just play some simple dog fights you don't need to get too elaborate with it but the real heart of the game the thing that will suck you in for a whole day is playing that campaign Yeah well yeah the the first scenario like this they have sort of learning scenarios it's a single head-on confrontation I think it was a 5sec play time for me so you know very uh very indepth very meaty but it was great because they're very like slowly walking you through the rule book basically it's it's a nice system it reminds me of another one that I know is uh it was new to the list this year made it to number 14 Atlantic Chase yes that had a similar designer oh oh well that that makes sense because I was gonna say I didn't pay attention to that yeah because that one had a similar like tier tutorial like don't read the whole rule book yet and I thought that was really nice in both cases games of that complexity I think they've done an amazing job with those Rule books they really bring you in gradually to the system now does fields of Fire's new rule book have slow tutorial scenarios

that teach you the system they not only have a new rule book coming but they have a whole new field manual which is for the learner so something that's gonna take through everything that's what we need I'm so ready I'm so ready um so I want to talk a little bit more about the old hotness and then maybe we can talk about some new hotness um I'm very pleased to announce that Solitaire ASL came in at number 20 because the number one complaint I got about this list last year was where is the advanced squad leader where is it where is it where is it I was like well you could vote well a couple of things happen with that so first of all when people talk about playing ASL like that's fine there's the the pro this is one of those cases where the way in which we compile this list can be a little problematic for folks because if you're an ASL player odds are you don't have a single box of an advanced squad leader something somewhere that you only play that one box right if you're an ASL player like it's a lifestyle it's not just a game and and so you've probably got a wall of ASL stuff stacked up somewhere with about 16 different individual box sets I I know plenty of those people my wife is very happy I'm not one of those people because that would cost us another set of shelves downstairs um but but one of the challenges we have is that if you're an ASL player like what do you put in there and some folks there is a dedicated listing in BGG for solitary ASL and this year we just had a bunch of people pick that one out last year if you'd gone back and looked up

the combination of the starter kits the the different ASL starter kits plus the solitary ASL listing plus several of the other ASL modules you'd have seen a bunch of different Advanced squad leader stuff all over the list but it's all over the list it's not a unified thing and and so that is a case where series can be a little challenging to properly account for the way we're asking for specific individual titles um that appes quad leader that applies to Lock and Load tactical that applies to um I'm trying to think of a couple of the others there's uh the Second World War C Series from Avalanche press the conflict of Heroes series from um from Academy games which has a really good solo mode for it um if you're a fan of the series you kind of have to pick a title to enter into the into the survey Brant I was struck by Solitaire ASL specifically making its way onto the list I've used that system I have it my preferred way of soloing ASL when I do get a chance to do it is just to play multi-hand yeah um because there's already so much rules overhead and game to begin Infamous thr book right which is this thick uh that I feel like adding another layer on top of that with the soliter system is a bridge too far pardon the pun um but I I also think the beauty of that system for those who like it is that it will generate your opposition on the fly so it has a lot of

fog of War you don't know exactly what you're going encounter out there whereas in most ASL scenarios it's right there on the page you kind of see what you're gonna face so that's one of the nice things about that system and maybe that's why for some people they specifically listed it yeah that that could be that that could be there so um one of the other statistical quirks I do want to note so when when Liz and I were taking a look at the the different additions and and the actual data itself as it was coming in and we were making sure that it all kind of made sense and nobody put Ticket to Ride in there somewhere or you know left blank or whatever um one of the things so so there's a couple of places where we had to make a a few judgment calls on some things and one of them was uh the the RAF games because there's an RAF Battle of Britain 1940 and then there's a second edition and we got votes for both and the question that we we wrangled with slightly was whether or not to combine those two and we decided not to and here's why if you look up the original Edition it's just you're the RAF guy and you're defending England if you look up the second edition ition there's two additional modes in that box one of them is you get to flip it around and play the Germans attacking the UK and the other one is there's an actual head-to-head mode in the second edition box which isn't as relevant for solo play but you could multi-hand that and play both sides and we made the Judgment call to keep those two separate because folks voting specifically for second

edition might have been doing so for one of those other modes that's in the second edition box but not in the original had we combined those two they would have jumped from uh all the way up to number two and they would have been right behind D-Day at Omaha Beach I think the the sum at that point would have only been about three points behind um where dday at Omaha Beach was if we had combined them um and we did check nobody had voted for both there was no one that had both of them in their votes um so that was one of those cases where we did have to make a judgment call we thought it was a reasonable judgment call to make given the presence of different of of legitimately new content in the second edition that was was significant enough it wasn't like it was just a graphics redo or something um or a new publisher uh but if if we had combined those two that would have that would have jumped all the way up to number two and been very close to number one Brant I don't know if this will show up statistically in a future survey and I'm not going to be the one who will necessarily contribute the data here um but there are guidelines in the back of skies above Britain for combining it with RAF yeah so if somebody wants to get really ambitious they can put the two games together in a kind of hybrid Frankenstein version which I suppose would be fascinating but I'm not going to be the one to do it now in addition to the uh the whole question of like additions which I think is really oh in addition to additions that was dumb I apologize no I'm actually here for it I I I'm also now I know I'm kind of

like probably gonna make yall hate me and and derail the podcast but I'm a big fan of like Fantasy war games and sci-fi war games and and the whole history aspect of this list kind of leaves some things out that I love and I'm really interested in the games where a system is taken to a Sci-Fi place and sometimes better than the original so I'm thinking of just to name a few I see that resist the uh David Thompson I forget who his Cod designer was for that resist it's uh with Trevor benjaman and Roger ters that's right that's right thank you yes it was 15 last year and felt quite a bit this year um and I do wonder I know for me I completely stopped playing resist because I like witchcraft which is like the kind of revised and I think improved version of the system way better but witchcraft is a fantasy Witch theme so it would not you know fited on the list um and then similarly I just covered uh undaunted uh Kalisto I think that's the best that the solo has ever been I think it's better than the reinforcements uh system for Normandy and North Africa but that's not a uh historical thing and then I'm a p500 supporter for um Red Dust Rebellion yes which which I think has a very high chance of being my favorite coin game of all time based on the early stuff I've seen so far so it is interesting that like when you have okay hold on one second sorry my children so well I know Mike can hear me but he's also yelling because I'm going

to slip in and say so bran I think that you and I did this list this way specifically because I actually think those games have a better chance at hitting People's Choice top 200 if that makes sense like I think that I think I think we're going to see undaunted Kalisto on the top 200 list like for mainst streamers within a couple years yeah I think that witchcraft is probably going to be on there this year I'd definitely be willing to bet to I expect to see it um and then what was the other one red dust Rebellion yeah well that's not out yet once that comes out I do think we could see it because it's a very interesting coin I actually just interviewed Jay for the podcast so like you know I think that those have a very strong Fighting Chance of making it on the main list um and I this is just you know this is my personal uh saw right like so so we do the video show here with with this audience on lizz's channel we also um each fall after we we do this this survey we also do a podcast over with the drons because we've got our own podcast as well and so we bring Liz on there and we bring some of the dragons in to talk on that one and and one of the points that came up last year so I was I I went back and I relistened to I rewatched our video from last year and and listened to the podcast from last year also before we put the survey out this year because I I wanted to go back and catch you know hey we should make sure we fix this for next year that that we actually did fix it for next year and and one of the points that came up um on the podcast that we had I I

don't think it came up in the video discussion but on podcast um Mike from the dragons who's who's one of our guys all these guys seem to be named Mike I don't know what it is but was Mike yeah so so Mike Kelo is the guy that runs the YouTube channel for My Own Worst Enemy which he's doing all solo gaming he's His Own Worst Enemy um and and he plays a lot of games multi-hand uh as a solo player but he he's a big space and fantasy game fan space Empire 4X is one of his favorite games and that question came up last year and and I know Liz you've still got kind of the the you know wrinkled nose that oh my God those space games they're going to show up so but we did build this as war and historical gaming and so sci-fi and fantasy war games are still they they still meet the war part of that war game thing I think the fact that we build it as war and historical gaming folks leaned into the the historical wargaming part of that um as opposed to worrying so much about the the sci-fi and fantasy stuff but there are some in here there there there definitely are a few yeah like you just can't put a survey out like this and just have it not show up yeah um it's not what we're specifically looking for if you read the description text but it'll show up and like I don't it doesn't upset me in like a big way I'm just really trying to filter for like what historicals are people playing and I don't really want to fight about adjudicating what is and is not a war game so I think everybody's always

looking for that cross-section that they want to talk about and it's really really hard I think to draw lines and to Define stuff and so like I'd rather just have it be a little bit more open and get stuff that I wasn't expecting then try really hard to like lock everything down more than we already have because I feel like this is sufficient yeah and and they don't show up in in high enough numbers that they're crashing the top 10 or top 20 I'm not sure there's any in the top 30 uh I I don't think they show up till you get down to Triple digits but but there are some on the list just not in large quantities and again probably because we build it as war in historical gaming yeah yeah so one of the ironies here um if you think about bgg's top list right which I'm not saying we have to take our queue from them and I think we're right to put the emphasis on historical games to the degree we do while allowing for some outl outliers um but I'm sure we all know what the number one war game on BGG is right I'm checking right now War of the Ring so a total fantasy tale right but it's an excellent war game as war games go it has all these great elements to it so there is an audience out there that's hungry uh for for Fantasy war gaming and sci-fi War gaming I'm someone who's an omni gamer so I'll play it all um and I think there's something to be gained from playing all those different types of games yeah I mean I and I'm a big lover of besides War of the Ring it's one of my favorites uh root you know which just like some people might argue that corn games are not war games

some people might argue that Root's not a war game but I think it all kind of fits under the same umbrella and I think root is Insurgency in a petting zoo yeah yeah that's a good way to put it yeah I think rude is heavily oh Liz left us Liz Liz Li Liz heard me say root and she's like no that was it she checked out she's done the way I look at it is if root is good enough for them to use to teach uh students at the Army man and general staff College we can put it on the list sure but yeah I agree with what yall all said if this list is doing its own kind of historical bent while like the the top 200 list gets into a wider umbrella I think they all have value and have uh some cool things to dig into yeah what you also there are no shortage of examples in both the gaming and literature world of historical conflicts being dressed up as something else so as to either sort of you know a avoid some hard questions from audience or because that's the way the author or designer chose to to deal with their own personal issues around the topic in literature the great example is the uh the original Short Story collection in the book The Hammer Slammers by David Drake that was largely informed by his experiences with the 11th armored Cav in Vietnam a lot of those stories are straight out of his experiences um in the jungle similarly

the blood Tree rebellion game is I mean that that's the Vietnam War dressed up as a Sci-Fi game so the the fact that there are fantasy or SciFi sci-fi or or not true historical war games out there doesn't necessarily mean that that it's not a historical conflict somehow dressed up as something else I don't think that's the case with undaunted 2200 Kalisto I don't think they're they're disguising something as a Sci-Fi game but it's still the undaunted system just moved to a different setting and so I see that as comparable to the other undaunted settings okay great go do it there was um there's the commands and colors Series has been used for napoleonics ancients uh 30 Years War uh the American Revolution there's the the medieval one that also includes the the Far East so there's the the samurai battles y to it it's been used for Fantasy stuff with the battle lore line and there was a there was a a space combat one that like commands in colors red alert or something like I don't remember the exact title but but there is a space Fleet battles version of that same system okay sure and I think it makes sense especially when you have like those asymmetric like faction things you can go a little bit wackier you know what I mean like yeah exactly like I have blood Stones recently and like it's fun to have a dragon that can fly around and blow everybody up I guess I guess you could sort of say that's like an analog to I don't know air support and

helicopter squadrons and stuff but it's definitely doing its own thing Brent can I ask from a data point of view um talking about games that don't exactly fit the definition right such as it is of an historical game um I'm thinking here though of counterfactual historical games so I wonder how many are popping up on the list so for example there's a coin game in development I think it's called called bwolf or something like that which is about a German Insurgency in the wake of the end of World War II so it's a total counterfactual right but it's an historical setting so I'm curious do you see a number of games that fit that popping up there there weren't very many of them on the list and I think part of that is that up to this point the vast majority of those legit counter the things that are real the joke has always been that you know when you're playing a war game game you're you're doing counterfactual stuff on turn one so I mean there's there's always that kind of gag but but in terms of the underlying setting um werewolf's not out yet um so so Clint still got it on you know pre-order with uh I think it's Legion War Games gonna be doing that one um but but ones like Mississippi Bonsai and the different operation unthinkables which is you know Churchill pushes the Allies to invade Russia at the end of World War II like those th those really haven't got broad enough appeal that they're really going to show up on on you know any kind of war game list much less a a solo specific war game list right they're

there I just don't think they're common enough or published by by prominent enough Publishers that they're going to get a broader audience that they're going to show up on a list like this you're more to see the fantasy and sci-fi than any of that exactly yeah and in part because if you think about some of those fantasy and sci-fi was like Root's a bit of an outlier root has become its own IP but War of the ring is one of the most popular IPS in you know in in intellectual property history you know I mean it's to token's a monster in that space so it makes sense that war of the ring is going to show up there just because it's got such broad appeal to folks who are fans of the IP even if that's the only war game they ever play I I think also it makes sense that from like a value standpoint if I'm a buyer if I'm playing historical war games I probably value to some extent the historicity and like being able to look in the back of the Playbook and see you know what kind of things actually happened and so many of those games already provide alternate scenarios like hey what if you try this crazy thing within the exact same system I'll need to buy another product y so like why am I going to go for the game that is just the wacky oneoff like scenario craziness when I can already get that along with the historical stuff that I love with like the full package you know I don't know I think it's a it's a tough not not a non-starter but a tough spot to begin with even if designers are designing it I you know I'm a designer I don't know how I pitch that to a publisher in a way that's like sexy and gonna make them go

for it you know yeah yeah exactly so all right LZ is back yes I hope very much that that actually stayed in I mean we kept recording so yeah recording okay good because I this is good I actually I want it so you he what we said about yeah I was G to say we talked mostly about you Liz it was really I'll just I'll just edit that out and like dub it in be like Liz is such a great person oh man AI can do all that for me now um so it sounds like y'all had the really good like kind of sci-fi fantasy conversation that I will happily listen back to later um but the other thing I wanted to flag before we talked about some of the data stuff is the newcomers to the list like things that kind of shot up one thing I think is so interesting about this list is that you can really see and like we're going to talk about it right like the I think the relative longevity and the hobby of people who are contributing um because it is so consistent and some of these older games are really still alive and like still like kind of rising up really high on the list like B17 but you do see some new stuff so I want to particularly shout out um I Napoleon which is just freshly on tables um so it's pretty cool that like that has like shot up already it's a good time um we've got uh I'm not actually sure how to pronounce it but vagaga wait was that say say that again

Liz Vaga times I you know I I'm not sure what I feel like people say yeah I'm sorry I'm sorry I'm glad Liz is saying it and not me you know what if I'm wrong I'm wrong if I'm wrong it's if somebody would actually like to give me a short like an very clear tutorial about how to say this I would appreciate it because I've actually tried to look it up on YouTube and people say it so fast that I can't figure out what what salabo gets the empasis um there's a pronunciation guide in the rule book or in the Playbook I think most of the coin games have these they're I gotta hear it I gotta hear I'm terrible atation guys um and then actually you know it's not like brand new but it's really cool to see Halls of hegra fly up because I think it's a really quality game um the that's relatively recent and it's it's fun to see so kind of thing I want to know when people go and look at the master list over when we've got it published over at the dragon site so when people go look at the master list you will see where we show the difference from the 2023 survey and there's a lot of stuff in there that says new and there's a lot of things in there that say new but it's like a 20-y old game it's new to the list it's not necessarily a new release it did not appear on the 2023 list so it is new to the 2024 list not that it is a new release um I I will say Liz your your comment about I Napoleon shooting up here is is fairly interesting because uh like Atlantic Chase has been around for a little while now I mean it it was it

it was out before we did this the survey last year and didn't appear on the survey last year and it shot up into the top 20 this year um I Napoleon's been out like six weeks I yeah it's like fresh fresh yeah and so there's there's some things that have been out for a year or two and just took a little bit of time to get traction there's some things that were released since we did the survey last summer so they've had a year to to get out there but then you know again I Napoleon shipped in what June I mean but I'm really happy to see this in a way because I sort of feel like you know when we talk about the People's Choice top 200 right the the solist that inspired this one and Mike I know you probably have some ideas about this as well um you know people always complain about like oh all this stuff is only up here because it's hot and new and like there's definitely sort of a a lean towards new things but you know and like it's very interesting to kind of you know analyze the old stuff that stays but I feel like it'll be really interesting to watch this list develop over the years because I feel like there's a lot of continuing respect for older titles and continuing interest in things that people really do actually seem to have played again and again and again um and it'll be interesting to see like how new titles continue to interact like where will I Napoleon be next year uh we were very curious about where Mr President was going to end up because it was like oh is this a flash in the pan or is it going to stay um and so I'm very curious to like continue this project over time because I want to see

like what can kind of crack into this list of venerable Classics because I would say a lot of the the titles at the top of this list would count as that um and then how many of them become venerable Classics themselves Liz can I do a quick shout out to a game that's very important important to i Napoleon which is one of Ted Racer's Inspirations uh from clash of arms games Legion of Honor um which he acknowledges as an inspiration which is an incredibly fun storytelling game where as a grognard you can play a grognard uh you're playing a soldier in the Napoleonic era going through all those different campaigns and not only are you worried about the battles and your promotions and all that but you can duel other players uh you can have Mistresses you can get in uh fights in a Tavern you can gamble you can do all the things that a soldier might have experienced in those eras in that era uh and I think Ted kind of built on that repurposed his system entirely to make it about Napoleon um but those two games pair well together like you know a good meal and a good wine I'm so glad you said that because I've actually been planning to dig out Legion of Honor and play it now that I've played I Napoleon yeah you can solo that or multiplayer that one yeah yeah yeah um Liz you talk about you know which ones are going to have some staying power and which ones are going to stick around a little bit and and I'm going to have to sort of angle the head away from the camera here because I've got stuff on the side monitor on the desk next to me but uh one of the things that I did do was I went back and I crunched the the numbers for the top 30

or so at as split by different age categories so we asked folks how long have you been wargaming and and we did this last year and we we put the upper bound at 25 or more years and we realized that we needed to add a 40 or more years bracket on the end of that just because there were so many people in the 25 or more but the other thing that that we realize is that 25 or more gets you to the late 90s and like you've got folks that have been wargaming back to the 70s you needed to to add another boundary up above that and so what I did is I I split it for the purpose of of these comparisons I did the folks that had been 10 or fewer years the folks that had been 40 or more years years and then kind of that in between and so um put the glasses on so I can see the side monitor here the the top five of the folks that are 40 or more years of war gaming um starting with number one B7 Queen of the Skies skies above Britain D Omaha Beach was third in that group really solitare ASL and then the RAF Battle of Britain so it's all stuff that's close to the top of our list in part because that's a big chunk of the sample of of who voted um for the folks in the middle range so that 10 to 40 years worth um RAF Battle of Britain is one D-Day at Omaha Beach is two fields of fire is three John company second edition is four and Mr President was

fifth and then for the folks 10 or fewer years wargaming PX Premier second edition is the first one skies above Britain dday at Omaha Beach Atlantic Chase and Halls of hegra so we definitely see some of the more recent games pop higher in the list for the folks that have been wargaming for 10 or fewer years with Pax pamir and Halls of hegra jumping into their lists also shorter games I would say slightly overall which maybe makes sense right you're coming from a longer like wargaming background you might be more used to games that are like 3 four six hours long playing over the course of like a week um and then there's there there is a short list so there's seven games that showed up in the top 30 or so for all three age brackets and and this is alphabetically because there's no good way to sort that Ambush D Omaha Beach fields of Fire Halls of hegra Mr President Navajo Wars which we hadn't mentioned yet and then skies above Britain those were the seven that showed up in all three age brackets and what I'm going to publish those a those lists broken down by age brackets uh probably in about a week or two they they won't be out with the first article that we'll have but I will have them a little further on that is fascinating yeah I do I do agree with you Mike I think that probably people of the up to a decade of wargaming um that's still me

uh but hey just think in 20 years we'll check back that's right but your Twitter feed reliably assured us back in 2018 or whatever exact not a war gamer yes but it's changed but um anybody can see the light right uh but um you know I do think that I mean I know that I do favor shorter games a lot of the time because I just when am I G to fit it in um you know or if I do play longer games I play them pieces and so that that risks some continuity issues uh but I also think that the younger G or the newer gen I think it's probably better to say um I'm kind of interested too in like you know we talked about kind of our issues about okay War historical how do we thread the needle I'm also very curious to see how games that are definitely historical but people might quibble about whether they're a war game or not um I'll be interested in seeing how how those do over time as more new people kind of win their way over to this list because I do think that we argue about it you know within the community as like a technical thing I do also think that there's kind of an age and you know exposure to wargaming versus The Wider hobby kind of cross-section that's also causing those arguments well I think we we've had these these discussions and these conversations before we actually had them last year when we talked about this

is war and historical gaming and in part because we didn't want to fight the 38 seventh holy Jihad of what is a war game that that that we weren't going to try and parse whether or not coin games or war games or Twilight Struggle is a war you know we weren't going to get into that but one of the things that that we've had this conversation over the years and and and it's happened in the professional Community as well the center mass of the target of what is a war game is we we all kind of you know hex's counter CRTs some you know dice chucking historical scenarios we got all that as as you start to get further and further away from that Center mass of the Target and you replace uh CRT or or dice with card driven you know adjudication or you get away from counters and you're using cards to move things around um you may get rid of a map all together and now you're into upfront and Fields of fire territory or something like that the further out it from that Center Mass you get the fuzzier the definitions get and I think for for a long time war games were hex's counters dice SE RTS on a table you know and and folks that have been wargaming for 40 plus years that was their initial entry into the hobby folks that have been wargaming for 10 or fewer years that's not necessarily been their entry point to the Hobby and they may have come in through War of the ring or Memoir 44 or something like that or they may have come in through undaunted it's a deck building game or you know uh it

never snows or something similar to that and and so I think the entry point does make a difference um we did not ask how old people were you can draw some inferences from how long they've been wargaming if you've been wargaming over 40 years you're not under 30 like I we can do math but you could have some folks that are in their 40s or 50s that have been wargaming for fewer than 10 years absolutely yes by the way Paul Paul put in like the little chat if if we're willing to discuss it I think it's a good question I have my answer Paul was asking what solo title do you admire and play that either didn't appear on the survey or was only represented by a very few responsives one of my favorite war games of all time and this is primarily a competitive game but I I used to multi-hand it all the time is the Combat Commander series and uh Europe and Pacific were both on the list last year I think Europe was not super low I think it was 74 74 last year neither one is on the list at all this year at least not that I could find which yeah I think is unfortunate um although I I Liz I think you played the Prototype of this right firefight tactical that is has reached over 500 from GMT so is coming someday whenever it gets in their queue come on GMT get to it yeah that that that one from what I played is very much heavily inspired by Combat Commander and some squad leader stuff too of course and like Ambush like

all that kind of similar DNA is in there yeah but yeah I'm hoping that's because that has a dedicated solo mode that plays great from what I've seen so far whereas Combat Commander of course did not have that kind of functionality but yeah that's my answer what's a game that y'all maybe wish was on the list or higher on the list for me I don't know that it's necessarily a specific game I am a little surprised that none of the states of Siege games were really higher on the list and I think part of that has to do with the very fragmented way in which they in the marketplace today when Victory point games was still around the states of Siege series was was published and marketed as this unified series even though it was a variety of topics uh empires of America was a great game uh ottom and sunset hapsburg Eclipse especially being able to link them those were really fun games um the fact that you could use the system for something as as high level as you know Israeli Independence and ottoman Sunset hapsburg eclipse or as microscopic zoomed in as the Alamo I think was showed the strength of the system but the states of Siege games and and some of the other games that they inspired um Ben Madison's got a couple of them that are Loosely based on that states of Siege series like M thatchers war and uh and white tribe the the game about Rhodesia that are all very similar um but the states of Siege games not just any individual titles but like any of them

didn't really show up all that high on the Le and I think part of that's an availability issue the couple that are available are all from different Publishers um I so I think that's part of it and I think they've just sort of lost a little bit of oomph where where they're not kind of a unified presentation anymore they're great games uh Empires America is definitely one I'd recommend for anybody who's who's into that age of gunpowder kind of stuff um it's it it's North America during the French and Indian War Seven Years War where you're the French trying trying to fend off everybody trying to take over Canada um and then white tribe is on the list um it's Ben Madison's game about rodesia I think is a is a fascinating topic and and I think he does it in a pretty nuanced way which is tough to say about that topic um I I found I I've played the game a couple of times I I found the game's a lot of fun but there's a little bit of tedium in it here and there where they're sort of check to see if an event happened then check to see if an event really happened and then go check so there's a couple places where you're rolling like a table to look up a table to look up a table it's like we could have paired that down a little bit you know what though I think the real problem is that the best stage of Siege game is still the zombie one I was gonna say the same thing I was like dang it da his EDS and now we also have what was the what was the follow-up one that Herman did that's oh Plum Island horror yeah Plum I like Don of the Zeds better but I do too I do too although I'm curious what the expansion will add but

yes that my favorite stage of Siege as well unfortunately yeah but but again like when you say dawn of the Zeds people don't immediately think of states of Siege series way if you throw out one of the coin titles people immediately associate with coin series and that doesn't happen with the states of s states of Siege series and I think if we'd done this in 2011 people would have Associated all those together yeah because of the way Victory point games had had kept those as kind of a unified line the title that uh came to mind for me and I think it was on last year's list not this year's list but very um underrepresented from my point of view and I could be wrong in reading the the data but uh that would be one game and its followup which you can play as a combined game and that's nights of fire nights of ir and nights of fire I always get them confused which are about the Hungarian Uprising against the Soviets in 1956 and in that first game days of a uh you're just on the ground as kind of insurgents trying to make a mark and if you get through that then the Soviet tanks show up in nights of fire and then it gets really nasty and of course it's kind of doomed to failure but it's a beautiful uh storytelling game and it's really welld designed for solo play not too surprising because uh David tury is one of the designers of the game I just checked neither of them are on this year's list not yet not this year yeah yeah so kind of in the same van like things that show up either love

on this year's list or didn't so I'm going to just kind of flag a couple Holland Spiel titles that I would like to see get more attention in kind of in this vein so endurance is on the list but it's in like two 200 it's low uh this year and then That Others May Live um combat search and rescue in Vietnam uh was on the 2023 list but it didn't make the 2024 list uh also Legion of Honor didn't make the 2024 list like which we were talking about earlier it's a great game one thing I would like it's not so much about one game game I think it's about you know this is the historical and War list and you know we talked about kind of people wanting to push it the Sci-Fi Direction but I'd be really interested to see people push it in the historical Direction and like what does that look like and I feel like sometimes the results we get back may not even indicate what people are playing as much as what they think counts and I would like to continue to see a broadening of that over time because endurance is certainly a historical game I think a lot of people actually are playing it who would play these games and I'd like to see stuff like that do better but also Legion of Honor like okay yeah it's not a pew pew game but it's certainly like a historical game that's about being in the military like I would be interested in kind of seeing you know people if you if you're into storytelling games like B17 you know I think that there's room in your gaming life for for more of that stuff too one person was put obsession and Fifth and said first if it counts

and so we actually did honor their wish wait Obsession like the the Regency like yeah and you know what like my only argument it's historical it's definitely historical yeah I mean I I guess you could argue and like Dan howan has talked about that like on my podcast like it's not exactly one period in time but it is like a historical Vibe like I could see an argument for that because at least it's based on literature of a certain time and therefore like a historical attitude right but um we actually had more votes for Obsession last year than this year yeah so this year we only had that one person that voted for it whereas last year we had we had a couple of different people that that put it on the list yeah so that I mean one way to think think of this is um you know Pride and Prejudice by Jane Austin is not a history but I would argue in certain ways it's an historical novel because it's so embedded in its time there's so much going on in England at that time that if you understand even a part of that the book comes alive to you in a new way and I think Obsession captures that that Vibe so I'm I'm open to it well and I think I think lots of War games like wear on their sleeve like if you read the designers notes at the beginning you know Twilight Struggle is a good example of this like they say right in the beginning they're like yeah this isn't like really how the Cold War worked this is like more based on like how was presented in media and how we felt it was working you know so yeah I I think already a lot of games that we think of as like very crunchy kind of historical games are really more based

on a book's take or like here's how I interpreted this version of things because I mean history is never going to be a clear picture anyway right for for anything you try to cover yeah well I think that's true of pretty much any war game whether it's Solo or not so yeah what what you leave out um you know takes up as much or more space as what you put in yeah that's just it's it's the reality of trying to put things in there and and you know people want to confuse realism and complexity with granularity and you know that's that's not really making a change necessarily um that's that's a bit of a regular stump speech of mine is you know being granular does not mean you're being realistic that just means you like counting things yeah I think G really more about like what is it that you're trying to capture and is that accurate to its time yeah as far as we can tell one thing that we would be a task for us in the data analysis but quite frankly I just don't have the time in my life to try and figure it out it it would be interesting to go back and attach publication dates to the games and see based on when a game was published and I I realize there's some judgment calls you'd have to make based on which Edition but maybe you know first published in a certain date I think that would be interesting I think it would also be interesting to go back and sort of generally block things by Era the World War II games the Napoleonic games the Civil War Games the age of gunpowder the whatever yeah you're going to have to make a couple of weird judgment calls in there for some things that span different eras um but

but I do think it would be interesting to to go back and take a look at how the era of the conflict breaks down um I know I'm saying this and I promise you I am not going to be the one to do this for next year because that's just a lot of work and I've just got other things going on in my life but the data is out there if somebody wanted to do it they could exactly that's what I was about to say is we make the whole list openly available to everybody so anybody listening to this that that gets kind of a hair up their butt and wants to go do it you've got our permission to grab the data and run with it and go do it like please we want other people taking this data and crunching their way through it a little bit and seeing what they find of interest and and if there's some comparisons you would like to do that were not you know we didn't publish the data set on the site in such a way that that you've got all the pieces collected in a way that you could crunch it just reach out to me like I I don't have a problem sharing some of that data for you be able to do that um we're just we're going to strip the email addresses out of there yes leave everybody alone yeah but but I don't have a problem with letting folks take a look at sort of you know which game got the most second place votes like if you want to Crunch that I fine I don't mind sharing some of that data with you to do that I'd be thrilled to have other people take a look at this and and cut through the data in ways we didn't think about doing or in the case of the you know year it was published I'm just not going to bother to do yeah and so um before we we've kind of been on them for a little bit I don't want to like Abus anybody's time but there are a couple of other data things

that those of you who looking the spreadsheets can look at so we asked U people who responded like how much of your total board gaming is war or historical gaming how much of it is how much of your gaming are you doing solo um a lot of people were saying over 75 on that but you know we also have some less than 25% so there's people who are Solo gaming just a little bit for fun who are also responding which I think is really cool um it means it's like becoming part of a balance gaming diet right um and then also you know we had some good questions about um you know are you are you playing online or are you playing exclusively tabletop you know most people seem to be doing a mix these days but people are still definitely leaning towards the the analog play um I had those numbers up on the side screen here when we said do you play more on tabletop or using digital tools things like vassel or TTS um exclusively tabletop was almost 43% and mix but more tabletop was another 33% so well over three qus of the audience is still on the tabletop for at least most of their gaming and we only had three people that said they're exclusively digital to where they're only doing TTS or or table to or vassel or something and those are probably folks that just live in small apartments and don't have table space um and then the other one in terms of how much of your total board gaming is war or historical gaming um all of it and over 75% of it account for about 35% of the

crowd um but Liz to your point the less than 25% or 25 to 50% so the people that are half or less that's about a third of the audience of folks that are are you know half or less of their gaming is war and historical gaming um and then just because I know somebody's going to ask about it how long have you been wargaming over 40 years was still even though we adjusted to over 40 years as its own category that was still almost 35% of the audience that's the biggest slice of that pie and once you put them in the 25 to 40 years that's half of the audience right there so yeah the folks replying to this are people that have been wargaming for a long time yeah but you know we talk about longevity of the hobby one thing that makes me happy right is there are people who are dabbling clearly who are responding and I think that is a great sign because if you've got people who are just kind of War gaming or historical gaming some that means that they're also doing a lot of other gaming and that that we're having some crossover the other thing that I'm really really happy to hear about though is that you know if half of the audience is people who've been doing this 25 years plus that means the other half is not somebody new is coming in what was the percentage of people who were like fairly new just out of curiosity so less than a year there were five folks that's only two and a half percent one to three years is almost 10% there we go um the the 3 to 10 crowd that's 23% or so so I mean that's that's folks that are you know started sometime in the 201s so that's you know that's that's a

solid batch and and personally I'm really happy to see a lot of that new Blood come in because I started going to Origins when I was in my mid-30s um my first origins was 2005 and I got involved with the war College pretty early and for the first almost 15 years that I was involved with Origins I was the youngest dude in the room like at all those War College things all the war College talks and events and some of the bigger games that we were doing not necessarily all the game events we were playing on the floor when because we've been running the wargaming program at Origins for over a decade now um not necessarily all the people coming to play with us but the people in terms of of organizing and running and and supervis like I was the youngest dude in the room for 15 years and so it's it's nice to have some some you know not just one or two stray youngsters floating around but like we've got a whole crowd of youngsters running around in there and I think that's great um because for a long time I mean when you're in your mid late 40s and you're still the youngest dude in the room that's a little disheartening you know so it's nice to see all that new blood coming into the hobby now yeah I hope that we incidentally track some more of that over the next couple years yeah yeah so uh I definitely want more folks coming into play you you know get more youngsters to show up yes or at least noobs of some kind yes noobs of a certain age um uh so does anybody have any final thoughts as we kind of get ready to wrap this up um you know I feel

like an hour is long enough but we could go a lot longer final thought gonna go play more skies above Britain later today uh brand I wasn't sure if you were responding to my question or not in the last yes okay all right I still think it's an interesting question which designer is represented the most on this list in terms of sheer weight and and being such a great solo designer wouldn't surprise me if it's butter I think he's definitely well rep so Paul's question was is is John Butterfield the most represented designer on the list um just first glance probably especially toward the top of the list again there's because of the way the list works we really kind of have to cut it off at sort of double digigit numbers of votes for a specific game because once you get way down on the list and you got one person voting for something in first place or two people voting for something in fifth place this there's not many conclusions you can draw from that yeah but but once you've got you know somewhere around 10 or more votes across 200 something votes um that's that's kind of where we really care about the data analysis um but I I would say Butterfield probably is on the short list if he's not one he's two on the the list of folks towards the top of that the other one that I would expect if you're looking through the list quite a bit is uh Gregory Smith who does a lot of those

procedural aerial games uh especially for Compass uh probably during the course of this recording he's designed two more of them um did he do the hunters and the hunted is he also I don't think he did those U I think John CR actually did one of those um but he does all a lot of the the aerial games the uh America bomber um and then the where where it's you know the Germans bombing the US and but a lot of those aerial procedural games um I know he does a lot of those and Compass publishes a bunch of them he did do uh The Hunters by the way yeah he did okay yeah okay I I wasn't sure um but it's I I think it's a a great list I'm I'm happy with the responses we got I would like to have more responses for next year I I would still it's one of those things that technically I can describe the effect that I want like any good software analyst but but because I don't write code I'm not 100% sure how to do it I would like for us to be able to figure out a way that we can get away from pasting URLs from BGG in there BGG does have uh an API they've got an interface to their database that you can tap into that I would like to be able to figure out some way to do kind of a type of head similar to the way the search works in BGG so we can get folks just sort of typing their way into picking the game that they want in those spaces that's just it's more than I know how to make the technology do um so if there's anybody out there that that thinks they can tackle that uh please send up a flare we'd love to get you engaged and

help out with this um because I think it would make for an easier experience for the users so we got Paul got FR all right so it leaves me um final thoughts you know what I just really enjoy doing this and seeing the results it's really fun for me um you know I love the People's Choice top to 00 and hopefully it happens this year I don't know what it's going to look like because Kevin ersin kind of stepped down as the main person but um you know it's so fun for me to see like what people are playing that's I guess our kinds of games um at least over in this like kind of historical sector and so it's just really really good to see I hope we keep doing this for a long time because I want to watch the data develop and if you have opinions about this list but you didn't vote you know you need to do next year you need to not vote again and gripe about it on all the social media channels yeah exactly all right so uh thanks all of y'all for coming to talking to me on a weekend morning um thanks to everybody who will watch this do please you know like subscribe comment ask questions go check out Brand's posts on armchair drons because they're GNA be awesome and uh Happy gaming everybody thanks so much it was fun

Progress saved