Curating and Culling a Game Collection
Transcript
today on a very special positively board gaming. I always wanted to do an intro like that. I mean, it's it's just it's a little dramatic. Did Did it give you goosebumps? Was it dramatic enough for you? Okay.
Yeah, I'm excited. Yeah, I don't I'm I I want to know what happens next.
I I know. It's like coming up in a world where games are everything you need and want. Jamie Stegmire, Mitchell Whitfield, episode 25 of Positively Board Gaming. Who says I don't get to put my voice over career to work here? Welcome to Positively Board Gaming. I'm Mitchell. This is Jamie. And we are here, Jamie, for episode 25. I didn't have to ask this time.
That's right. That's right. Didn't didn't have to ask.
Kind of a big moment for me, I think. I don't know. I set the bar very low or I feel like if I get the number right somehow, yay, we have a good podcast episode. Yay, we've done it. Let's end it right now.
We did it. Yeah. I guess we'll we'll cut it off short today. Two-minute Well, one minute podcast. We're We're done. Yeah.
Uh, how are you? Um, I'm doing great. I'm doing great. I, uh, I just finished playing learning and playing a game or being taught and played a game. That's actually, that'll be my treat of the day. I love when someone else takes the time to learn a game and teach to me. So, that was a real teach friend real treat that a friend taught me how to play the game Bamboo. Bamboo, a 90-minute Euro game
kind of kind of with bamboo elements to it. More Japanese theme. Just a good solid um Japanese name, I guess, kind of.
Uh, what about you? Do you have a do you have a you have a treat of the day today,
Jamie? I sure do. Um, you know, I'm an unapologetic Trader Joe's fan.
I think most people that I don't know many people that go, "Oh, I hate Trader Joe's." I've never really heard that.
They're not really a hatable kind of company. They They really care about the environment. They care about customers. They try and, you know, and they have great stuff there. Um, so here I am pimping out, you know, Trader Joe's. Like, no, they're not a sponsor, but we're here if you need us, Trader Joe's. Yeah. So, I think I've talked about in the past they have these individual snack packs. They were basically
um peanut butter in a very light almost like file dough light wafer cylindrical little you know almost like a straw wafer filled with peanut butter and they had like um a raspberry preserve little dipping thing in the other part of the container. So, if you wanted like a little quick protein something sweet get the sugar level up real quick. They're really good and they're not that you know in terms of calories and maybe a little high in the sugar but they're delicious and something I've always gone to. Well, I don't know how long this has been out as I reach over. You know what? I'll just show the box and I'll pull out. They've taken it to a new level with uh peanut butter and chocolate.
Oh, okay. Talking my language. Yeah,
exactly. So, yeah, I I found Well, we know Jaime's love language, folks. It's been not been a secret. So basically it's a very similar thing to the peanut butter filled stick with you know the dipping that's the raspberry preserve but this one is almost like a a chocolate fil ch you know little wafer cylindrical wafer
and on the side is the peanut butter dipping.
So I know Jamie's like I see the drool starting to form Jamie. Um, and these are really good. Especially the other one, I consider it a sweet treat, but it's more of like a quick protein fix for me just to get a little bit of peanut butter and a little bit of sugar in my system. This one truly is a sweet treat.
It's like a Reese's peanut butter cup gone wild because you also have the crusty cookie on, you know, dough on the outside. I mean, it's it's lovely. So, this has been my new little treat of choice. And uh you can get them at your local Trader Joe's. Have fun. Uh yeah, and there I think they come with like eight or 10 in a box or something. Maybe. maybe six. Sorry. And they're delicious. So that was Yeah. CeCe, you had an experience-based treat of the day and I had a stuff my face at Trader Joe's treat of the day.
I think appropriate.
We had Trader Joe's for lunch today. We had a a ravioli. They make these like raviolis or pastas where you just put everything in the pan, it kind of steams up and if if the sauce is frozen in it and it kind of dissolves and becomes the sauce.
It was a It was a really delicious like mushroom ravioli that we had for lunch. So, Trader Joe's
doing great things for us today.
They really do. They have a lot of they have a lot of uh vegetarian friendly, vegan friendly, um traditional meat-based foods. And again, they also have like a frozen section and then they have a fresh section where you can buy they have freshly marinated. I think they do vegetables as well, but I know they have different chickens and beefs and different stuff if you're into that. So, there's a really wide V. Man, I really feel like we're just it's Trader Joe today, but you know what? We like, listen, we like, we like promoting or talking about things that we love.
Mostly it's board games, but why not show love to, you know, other things. Um, speaking of which, do you have a before we start?
Well, today we happened, this is a little Stonemire related, but I know you get excited about Stonemire stuff, and as do I. Um, and we announced, we kind of revealed three products today, so I thought I'd show them really briefly. We have, um, the Worms Dragon Academy expansion, Worms Span.
Okay.
Um, we have that. We also have uh our version of Tokaido Duo, an existing game, but um our version of it along with the separate solo mode for anyone who already owns the game but wants to just play the solo mode so they don't have to buy the whole game again.
And then there's a little surprise and it is little, but uh our little one to two player cooperative beam Smitten. We have Spitten 2 now.
Oh, that's awesome.
Same exact mechanisms, but new abilities on each card. You're trying to form these these card panoramas. Um, and it has a new artist, uh, the the Mo kind of that looks great
artist in in the board gaming space. So, that was our little surprise today. These will all be on our web store next week, but wow with you.
This is what I love about Stonem and what you do. Uh, not just as a as a designer, but a business owner and um developer and publisher. And we've talked about this before. I love the fact that we get excited about something and then we could have it the next week. Yeah,
I love that. I mean, there are certain exceptions. I know we talked about Vantage in advance because, you know, we wanted to talk a little bit about, you know, that and you know, then it was here before you know it. I was very happy, but there's something to be said for waiting until, you know, the products are available and then people get excited. Wait, you mean I can get it next week. So now, you know, people sprain their fingers trying to order and say, you know, I know what I'll be doing next week then. That is awesome. How did you did you have a live video today or did you just do did you do video today talking about it?
We we did it. So today we're recording this on a Tuesday. Normally I do an announcement like this on a Wednesday right at the live cast. Um but we're we're we have a pretty tight we decided to do a pretty tight window and I I wanted an extra day in there. I almost did it yesterday, but yesterday was Labor Day. Uh yeah. So it's a little different than normal. So I sent the newsletters for these uh today. Okay.
For like the wingspan newsletter and then next Wednesday when we when we launch them on our web store, I'll send the general big newsletter.
Oh, that's awesome.
Yeah.
Congratulations. It's always exciting when you get when you get your things out there into the world. We talk we talk about that, you know, especially when it's, you know, one of your games. There's this sort of nervous excitement, but just generally getting it out there and seeing the response and seeing people enjoying themselves because you you're in a business where you're doing it to bring other people joy. I mean, at at the end of the day. And uh to have that excitement of having it out there and receiving that joy. Not that you need the I need you I need the accolades, but there's just an excitement knowing that people are now going to get their hands on something you've been sort of holding back on sharing and that you're excited to get out there. So, I'm happy. That's really cool.
Thank you.
I like that.
Do you have anything else to add before we jump into our surprise topics of the day?
Uh, I I'll keep it really brief. Um, we'll go a little digital. You know, I I loved my I love my video games. Specifically, Diablo has been a franchise I've been a fan. I've been playing Diablo I 4, which is the latest iteration of Diablo from Blizzard. and they made a bunch of changes to sort of bring it back to more what Diablo III was like based on input from players. And I'm having a great time. I sort of had a milestone moment last night because there are different, you know, there are different seasons. That's one of the ways they keep the game exciting. They just have new seasons that have new things to do, new new quests that are season based, and then at, you know, you start a new character, do that season, at the end of the season, that character goes back into your main sort of stable of characters that you can play the regular campaign in if you want to. uh or you know the regular non-seasonal game. So I'm playing season. I created a character and I finally was able to bring it up to the top level because you know there different difficulties. Top level is is called Torment 4. So when you're in Torment level, you know it's not easy. So I got to Torment 4 and I got to solo the bosses really easily.
And the big bad boss I was able to get last night. I was like look at me go in season 4. I'm a monster now. True. I'm still tweaking. I could still get my character better, more optimized. But last night was a big moment. I actually fist pumped in the air very quietly. I was exhausted because my hands were going there. These fights are like dances. It's sort of like I don't know if you ever play World of Warcraft or any MMO RPG where the boss fights are sometimes these you know, okay, in phase one the boss is going to do this. You have to run behind them. Don't let them get close. They're going to spray something on the floor, jump away. So that these dances and you have to learn the dance and then physically you have to teach your hands the muscle memory to do the dance. So, I did the dance. I downed the bad guy. Didn't get the reward I was hoping for, but the reward was that I did it.
So, I congratulations.
Thank you. It's It's a really sad thing to congratulate your friend about, but you know what?
I'll take it. It was fun. I really I was really happy. I was like, I beat him. Yes. Yay me. Okay. So, uh if you if you've never listened or even if you have listened before, we welcome you all listening right now or watching us on the Stone Margarame YouTube channel. Jamie and I each bring a secret topic and uh we don't tell the other one. That's the nature of a secret of course. And Jamie, why don't you start off with a topic that I know nothing of or at least I don't know what you're going to talk about.
Yes. Uh yeah, I think you will know. Well, I'm actually very curious to hear your perspective on this knowing how much you love uh collecting games. And last week you revealed that you have between 300 and 350 games in your collection. You have a big collection of games. Yeah.
I probably have uh
I don't know. I have one I have four shelves around 200 games in my collection.
Wow.
And uh a few comments recently compiled into this topic. What someone uh mentioned the other day, they were like, "Oh, wow, Jamie, I thought you I thought you'd have a much bigger collection of games." And someone else said um uh that they were working on curating their collection a little bit and culling their collection a little bit. And they asked, "What are my methods for curating and culling?" You're already
Ding ding ding ding ding ding ding. It's finally happened. Yeah,
it's finally happened. Are you talking about Are you talking about the comment from Gary
about interested in hearing just how you how you uh remove or add games to your collection? Dude, it's finally happened. We have the exact same topic.
That is hysterical. So, please take the lead. Go for it. I I just had to take these name because it's never happened before.
Well, this is good. We'll we'll go back and forth.
Of course. Of course. Go for it.
I guess we'll I'll say this and then I want to I want to go into why you thought about this topic. Um the there are a lot of YouTube channels that talk about games that have like culling episodes where they'll have like a keeper cull and I I I don't I'm curious actually I guess this will be the first question for you. I'm curious if you watch those because I I don't want to watch those. And the reason I don't want to watch them is that
to me it seems inherently negative to showcase what you're calling. And I know there are different ways to present that that are less negative than others, but Um, and maybe it makes for entertaining viewing, but I it just seems inherently negative to me that you you'd showcase the things that you were getting rid of, the things that you don't deem are good enough for your collection.
And I know there are probably other ways to do it. There's probably a variety of ways to do it, but it just inherently I don't watch those videos. So, I'm curious, do you? And so, I wanted to do it in a positive way today. Right. Right. Of course.
So, I'm not even going to mention specific games. It's not about that. This is more about my process and how
about what how we do it, how we decide. Yeah.
Um, so I'm curious. Do you watch those videos when you see them?
Yes. And there's a specific channel. Well, I think it's a couple. I think his name is Johannes and her name, she says her name like Cinnabon. She says it very quickly. Remember? Yeah. Okay. And I and I I don't remember the name of the channel.
Ramblings. I think.
Yes. Board Game Ramblings. Um they're two lovely lovely folks and I enjoy watching their videos. They take a really interesting approach to their keeper call. So, you know, the game out they each have a little paddle and they put up keeper call and then if both of them even if one of them says keep, they'll keep it. The thing that I like about it is
it doesn't feel and I'm sensitive to this too. I mean, I've seen like videos titled, you know, games I played so you don't have to or, you know, 10 games I really didn't like, which I can't
I I can't watch those cuz I feel bad cuz it's to me those are unnecessary. If you can't find a lot of positive stuff online about a game, you probably have your answer without someone having to make a video about why they don't like a game, right? So, that's just that's a personal thing for me. The thing that I like about what they do about their keeper call is it's it's never because, oh, we both hate this game. I've never heard them say that. In fact, more times than not, we both love this game, but this other game scratches that itch we relate to a little bit more. If you can imagine, they do it with a lot more positivity. So, for me, it doesn't have that negative feel, but I get to learn what they like about the game. Maybe what didn't hit for them or maybe what they compare it to because if it's a game that I like, I'd like to know what they compared it to, too. Maybe I like that one as well. I think because they do it in a more positive way and they both end up saying positive things about the games they're calling all the time.
It doesn't feel bad to me. You know what I mean?
That's really good to know. That's good to know. And I do subscribe to that channel. It's a lovely channel. So I I will have to watch one of those.
I have to check it out because I think it's different than you think. Yeah, I think it's different than you think.
So we had some people comment about this and I think you said Gary was the one that suggested it. What made you decide that you wanted to talk about it today? Because I think first of all um should I just really read quick what what Gary said because actually cutting past I have it up right here. So and by the way thank you Gary. This was actually great because it it spurred both of us to do this together. Um I'm enjoying the podcast. Thank you so much. And have a topic I'd be interested to hear you discuss. You've touched on this here and there which we kind of have. Uh so when curating a collection, deciding which games to keep and which to move on from, what criteria do you would you use? Why do you keep a game in your collection? How do they earn a place on your shelf? And then he actually he actually gives five considerations.
It's a game I really enjoy playing. I think I'll always want to play. Very valid. It has a unique or unusual theme. Uh there's a nostalgic attachment to the game. That's number three. It's a good fit for a specific group or people that are new to the hobby. Or it has artwork/p production uh that's so good it warrants a place in my collection. Which and I read this and I was like, what can I add? This is actually really good.
Yeah, Gary pretty much. and we'll talk and we'll talk about that. But um and I have some reactions to that, but I thought I thought Gary gave some great reasons and really laid it out very elegantly uh a lot of reasoning why people keep or decide to get rid of a game. What was your take on that?
I really like that he gave those categories. I I certainly have a few things to add to it. Um and I'll say that maybe the core framework of mine is outside the categories a little bit and it's related to space. So I have the four shelves. One of them is just all Stonem stuff. One of them is is intended to be like my my shelf of opportunity. Um but I've almost gone through it. There are very few games on there that I haven't played. I keep a pretty slim shelf of opportunity. And then my um my small quick game shelf, uh which is bursting at the seams, but it's, you know, I can pack a lot of games into that shelf. But then I have my main 4x4 callex shelf, and it's uh I I gestured it. It's right over here out of view. And um
I'm trying to see but I
Yeah. No, you can't you can't see
can't get my head into that frame over there. Yeah.
And my signal to to myself that it's it's if I have games on top of that shelf, that is a little signal to me that I I've run out of room a little bit where I've started to stack things on top. And so, uh I'll get to how I do it once a year, but that is that is my that is my limit basically. You talked about last week a little bit that you have games in maybe you have it in the room that where you currently are. You have them in the garage space. Yeah. You have that limit to space as well or
I do. Okay.
But my my thing is honey, sorry. We'll have to find another place for the paper towels and toilet paper because my new Kickstarter just got here. Um so no, I try not to infringe on. In fact, I'm in the process now of this is really I can't again I'm shaming myself uh for for the sake of our show. So, we also have a storage unit. We have a storage unit of opportunity.
Dangerous. Storage of opportunity.
Yes. So, things go in phases. Um, there's stuff that I'll move in and out depending on if it's something that I'm moving into the rotation of stuff that I want to play or if I don't think I'm going to play it anytime soon, but I'm not ready to get rid of it. It might go in the storage. It's it's really And again, I'm trying to pair down my collection right now. conversation to it's very hard because I do get attached to games and one of the things that isn't in here it's like when you see a game first of all I'll I'll walk by my collection in different areas in the house as I've said and just seeing it up there I get a little oo and I've read the rules never like oh I love I love that it's there for me and that's not always the best way to base whether you keep or call a game from your collection
but For me, obviously, if I'm if I'm doing the math in my mind and I look and I say, if I'm being honest with myself, obviously the stuff that's in the storage that's in storage right now is stuff that I'm not thinking of playing right away. I have to take a good hard look and say, "Okay, if there's like 80% chance that I'm not going to play this. I like the idea of having it. That's not really fair. I can I can gift this to a friend that will enjoy it, that will play it." And the great thing about that is, and this is not why I do it, when even if it stays in your friend group, you're still probably going to be able to play that game at some point anyway, should you desire. Or your friend might want to bring it to the table, then you get angry and want it back, but that's not nice. No takeback seies. That's not good. No takeback seies. Um, so there I mean, do you have Have you ever had regrets? And I think I talked about this last week about
getting rid of something from your collection and going, "Huh,
I really want it back now. I really want it back. Not from the person, but I really want it back in my collection." Has that ever happened to you or do you really separate yourself once it's gone? It's like no, you made that decision and it's you you're pretty cool with it.
It has happened. Uh it's happened a few times, mostly related to my every other year family reunion. Well, I'll bring a lot of games to the family reunion and if someone at the reunion really connects with the game, I'll just say, "Oh, why don't you why don't you take the game?"
That's awesome.
I'll sometimes do that with with big friend gatherings as well. Uh, and every now and then, usually it isn't like I it isn't a huge deep miss of it, but usually they're the types of games that go over well with a variety of people. And so maybe at some point in the future I'm like, "Oh, wow. I wish I wish I still had code names in my collection because I'm pretty sure we could this would be a fun game to play with this group right now and I don't have it. So I'll just buy it. I'll buy it again."
Right? It's rare for me to have I know there are some like games where you really can only buy them once or buy them once in a certain form and then you can't get them again.
Yeah.
I I've been lucky where I have never regretted getting rid of one of those.
Okay. Okay. Yeah, that makes sense. And it's uh but I I want to hear more about your about your process because I again I I I've made like a little list sort of like a mini response to all five points and how I relate to that. But um is there is there a different way that you look at things or a different way that you make decision and again space is a huge thing
and you know it's sometimes it's not good to have too much space because you know you feel the need to fill it. It's like okay I have this space I should fill it rather than well I shouldn't fill it just because I have the space. It should be based on need or want or I really love that game. I let's let's get it and find so what what else what other criteria do you have aside from space that goes into your decision-m process? Yeah, my main criteria. Oh, there are two. Um, so I have two main criteria and then we'll get to later. We'll get to how I actually do it. And I'm curious to hear your your two answers to those things. Um,
my two main criteria. One is if I have not played the game in at least a year,
okay,
or if I don't foresee myself playing the game in the next in the next year, in the year to come. Um, and there's a reason for that for the year cycle that I'll talk about later. But uh the other criteria I guess those are those are related. The other criteria is if Megan really loves the game and doesn't want to leave the collection and that is uh that is always uh a fun discussion for us to have because uh I think Megan is maybe a little bit more of a collector than I am.
I know I love Megan for a reason. I knew I loved her for a reason. Yeah. Go ahead.
There are many games kind of on the bottom shelf of my shelf. Wow.
I shouldn't spoil where they are, but they are on the bottom shelf where I don't foresee us actually playing those games, but um my my wonderful partner has a hard time. She can hear me right now. I know she can hear me. Uh she
I think it's great, Megan. I I respect and understand 1,000%. She can't hear me because you're I mean you're here, right?
Right.
I'll let her know.
Thank you. Please. Here's my support. Yeah. So, we usually end up when we actually go through the process, I'll be like, "Okay, Megan, the these uh what between these two, can you pick one of them to go and one of them to stay?" Even though I know we're not going to play either of these games in the next,
right?
Okay. So, let's get to your your this part of the process. How do you choose and what how do you think about those things that Gary talked about? And then at the end of this, we'll get to how we actually get rid of these games.
Absolutely. Um, so first of all, what you said makes a lot of sense. If you haven't played it and you don't see yourself playing it, that's that's really easy.
Um,
so let's go through really quick what Gary said. Number one, is it a game I really enjoy playing? I think I I'll always want to play those games, the ones that get to the table are good with so many different types of people, ones that give you joy just by thinking of playing them. That's a no-brainer. So, Gary, number one, couldn't agree more. Number two, it has a unique or unusual theme that isn't seen in other games. I totally get that. But for not, not not but. That's totally valid and that's a great reason
for me it's not enough that the theme is unique. It has to be a theme that I sort of jive with in some way. Um a theme that and again there are games that have certain themes like oh you don't see that often and if I that theme intrigues me absolutely I don't think I do it for the sake of it being just oh they made a you know they made a game about collecting red marbles I have to get this game because no other no other game focuses on just collecting red marbles. Although that sounds kind of weird and cool. Um, I will buy that game. Who am I kidding? So,
I wonder if he's partially saying like if he finds the the bird game that he really likes and then he has that bird game and then he can share it with bird lovers and whatnot. Yeah, you're right. Need multiple
bird games, which I could I think multiple bird games could have a place in the collection. Multiple dragon games could have a place in the collection. But, I wonder maybe that's what he's I was thinking about.
Yeah, I think you're probably right. So, I think I think it's probably baked in a unique theme that that Gary likes. So, yes. um that that is reason for me to hold on to a game because again if it's a theme you don't see a lot of people for me like hockey based games you know trickshot when trickshot came out um I was like oh I have to it was more complex than I thought it would be but it's like I I have to have it and I will always have it plus I got the painted hockey player mini so you know you know me. Um uh so number three I have a nostalgic attachment to the game. Um, yeah, and that's Gary. Absolutely. And that's where things get tough when when emotions are involved. And again, what what Jamie said, you know, about if I'm if I haven't played it in a year and I'm not going to play it in the next year, and he'll explain that cycle in a little bit. Um, that's very, you know, that's that's using that's using your head.
That's an intellectual approach. Absolutely. And I it makes perfect sense for me. The nostalgia does have a place. And it just I to my probably to my detriment most of the time that nostalgia will probably have me hold on to something that maybe I'm not going to play or maybe I'm waiting for that one person to come over and say, "Can we play?" I'm like, "Yes, I've waited six years. It's been up there. Bring it down." So, I totally respond to that.
Is it if it's a good fit for a specific group of people, uh, new people, new people to the hobby? Absolutely. If there's something that I think, you know, maybe is not something I would play with my more hobby board hobbyist board game group, uh, but I know that people that are new and I want a welcoming game that I I know I could play with them or bring new people in. Oh, yeah. I I would,000% do that. I think that's a that's a great point.
I think that's a great category to have in that.
Yeah, I really do. I really do, too. And the last one, if it has artwork production that's so good, it warrants a place. Well, Gary, now you're speaking my love language. I've been known to keep a game just because of the pretty dice. And I wish I was joking. Jamie knows I'm not.
Yep.
That's why he's nodding and giggling because it's the truth. Um. Yeah. And I think those some of those games that have
I respect the work that goes into this, which is why I said before, well, I see like videos dedicated to like talking about games, you know, I play that you don't have to. I I sort of like oo because I know the work even for a game that you might not like very much or not respond to. somebody put their heart into that and thought, I want to get this out there into the world. Someone's going to enjoy this and that gives me joy. And I think having friends that do this for a living and not just for a living, but have passion about what they do for a living, it makes me, you know, just and I respond to artwork, production components, which can be part of the artwork of their artistic creation. So, yes, I've been known to keep a game just because it is so freaking pretty on the table. Um, yeah. And then he talks about like a ven diagram of like all these things crossing over and that's like the perfect which I thought was very funny because I could imagine those circles crossing over each other and finding like that that those those three games like oh my god these are my you know god tier games right um but yeah let's go let's go back to you let's talk a little bit maybe if you want to talk about that yearly cycle um or what whatever else goes into the creative process of
dis disgaming yourself
deaming well I wanted to throw out one thing that'll maybe segue over into that next step uh or the final step really.
Yeah.
What is your take on
um I guess campaign games where you've completed the campaign cuz for example we have uh Star Realms Legacy sitting on our shelf right now. We've completed the campaign. We've done it. Okay. There's a lot of components in there where we can't use them and then a jumble of components that I think we probably could use in Star Realms, but it's it it's going to take some work for me to figure out which of those components I can add to our I I can add to our game of Star Realms. And in the meantime, we have a giant box sitting on our shelf where we don't really need that. Do you ever keep campaign games out of like nostalgia? Because many of these you can't pass on to someone else. Some of them you can, but not all of them.
Okay, this is this is a great example because it was something I was going to ask you about. if you would want it. So,
as you know, we finished Kinfire Chronicles. Love the game. And yes, I have to I have to go through the the process of like resetting all the cards, right?
Um and maybe some of like the um the treasure packs cuz they have these bronze, silver, and gold treasure packs that you get to pick to open. I'd have to sort of find a way to repackage them so you couldn't see them. Maybe put in an envelope and say gold. And it would, you know, it would take some work, but it would be worth it. And I was thinking, you know, maybe, you know, Jamie's talked about wanting to play this. Maybe I'll see if he wants me to send it to him. He can try it. And then I and then I thought to myself, and this wasn't like, "Oh, I don't want to do something nice for Jamie." This was,
"Huh, and here's the conundrum.
What if they come out with expansion material and you need the base game to do it?"
That happened with Role Player Adventures. Yeah. They put out an expansion to the campaign game. Yeah, it can happen.
There you go. So that and I was like, "Ooh." And because it's a game that I played with my brother and his girlfriend Nicole, and it's like, "Oh, I can't because we love this game. This is We love playing this game together." and I was ready to pass it on, but I'm like, "What if the next one requires having the base game?"
So, you know what? I actually when I go to uh PAX Unplugged in Philadelphia every year, I always see uh the guy who runs the company and um you know we we talk about the game and you know what he has coming out and you know we had the new uh Euro style game that just came out this past year set in the Kfire universe and then there's Delve and you know I'm going to ask him if there is in the future maybe Kfire Chronicles will it require the base game? I'm not beyond asking that. I I think
it's fair to ask. I I think if you understand why you're asking like you're not looking for a spoiler. You're just looking to say, "Can I give this to a friend or should I hold on to even telling you what you're doing?
I was thinking of giving this to a friend, but if I need this game for maybe expansion content, should I keep it or get right there's like an easy way of doing that. So yeah. Um
yeah. So it's it's Did I What was your question by the way? I think did I answer it?"
I guess the question is what do you think in the process of culling curing? How do you think about campaign games?
Yes. So that's basically that's why I was saying thank you for reminding old man Whitfield um what he was thinking. So I think for me I have no problem giving away a campaign game at all. I want to share the joy with people. My only concern would be
if I love the game and there is going to be more content coming down the line. I know I'm going to want to play that content. Am I going to have to buy the game over again? So um and you know that that would be my only concern, but otherwise I have no problem passing on games to friends.
Cool. Well, let's get to the final step. How do we actually do it? Uh, for me, mine is pretty brief. Uh, so I'll go real quick. Uh, one, throughout the year, if I play a game and I'm like, I'm glad I'm really glad I played this game, but I don't think I'm gonna play it again, I'll put it on, I guess, a fifth shelf that is a signal to friends that that is a shelf that they can take a game from at game night, so they can just take the game from it. And like you said earlier, it is nice to keep some of those games in circulation with friends just in case on occasion I might want to play them. Um, but the main curation happens once a year at the Stomar Games Design Day where I uh bring a bunch of games from my collection and just give them away to the attendees. Uh, I don't have a game for every attendee. It's because it's just however many games I'm pulling off my shelf that I don't think I'll play again. But I usually give away around 50 I'd say around yeah around 40 to 50 games.
That's awesome. And it feels great because I'm giving away to wonderful people who are who are joining us for that day. And I know they're they're going to a good home and uh there is a a purifying sense to it that I like that I've cleared that that room off my shelves and given it to someone who is excited to play it.
I think that's amazing.
Yeah. So that's how it's once a year, once a year cycle for me.
How do you do it? What is your method? Uh, so well, uh, what I used to do was when I would go to game night, I'd bring some games from my collection that I knew I wasn't going to get to or I thought and I'd bring and I'd give them to friends at game night.
Yeah.
This became a problem because a lot of the games I would do this with were larger boxed games. M
so although my friends would be excited and say absolutely
the partners at a certain point would come to me and say look
the very reason you're giving these away is the reason don't give us any more of these I'm like okay I'm sorry so I had to find more creative ways so there are friends um I've donated games um I I've donated games to uh different like you know Salvation Army I've done Goodwill and you know when I just think if there are places where people are going to look for shelter or safety or be able to buy things at cheaper and want some joy. Maybe someone will see this and find some joy in it. So, it gives me
I try to I I've never gotten into the selling a game online. Although, I probably could because you know how I keep my things by the way we talk about this stuff. They're pristine with upgraded components.
Selling them to me, I don't know. I'd rather gift them and have people get the joy. Whether it's someone I don't know going through a hard time and being able to get finding this game and go, "Oh, let this is great. Let me do this." or friends or family, I try and pass them on. So, that's usually the way that I do it. But, I love the way that you do it. And the people must be super excited when they have when when they get these, especially getting them from you because now they're not just getting a game, going to an event and getting a game. They're getting a game from Jamie Stegmire. That's Have people ask you to sign them when they take them?
Oh, well, they're not most of them aren't Stommyer games. So, I
uh That's true.
Yeah. Yeah. So, I don't
Yeah, that's true. cuz you've you have a lot of stuff that you play throughout the year and if there's stuff that you know then oh okay
you still sign them it's still pretty cool. Um
I wanted to bring up one thing that I have a huge problem with that's tough for me.
I find a lot of stuff that I haven't gotten to and that I can't get rid of going back to that campaign either
uh dungeon crawl adventure/ RPG style tabletop game I have a huge problem letting go. The reason is, and again this is kind of like this is pure emotion. This is not using my head. This isn't smart in any way. I don't think this is a great way to feel about these things. But when I see these worlds that people create,
Mhm.
that I know are on the shelf waiting for me.
Yeah.
If I want to have an experience in that world, whether it's feudal Japan, whether it's a western with monsters, this in space, and there are all these different places. And I think this is why I respond to Vantage so much.
When I know there's a world waiting for me that's holding so much surprise and intrigue and drama and loot and people that you get to meet and you get to hear their stories.
Yeah.
It kills me to give away the potential of experiencing that. Again, it's not a smart way of looking at it.
But I see these games and I think that's what intrigues me especially about these RPG dungeon crawl. And dungeon crawl applies to a lot of different stuff. You can put, you know, many things are dungeon crawls. You can have a dungeon crawl in space.
Um,
and and again, the research that goes in, again, I have one that takes place in feudal Japan, and it's beautiful. The artwork is gorgeous and the monsters are sort of gerine to feudal Japan and their and the lore of feudal Japan. So, I was like, "Oh, wow." And again, it's like something unique. You talk about something unique, like, "Wow, I've never I've never played that before." So, even if I haven't played them in a couple years, and I know I might not for a couple years, they stick around because it gives me joy to know there's a world waiting for me somewhere should I decide to jump in. And I know it's not the smartest, but like I said, it's more of an emotional reaction.
Yeah. I mean, you have you have worlds on your shelf. That is a pretty cool concept, and I totally understand why why they remain on your shelf.
Yeah, that possibility.
I I mentioned Vantage very briefly, I must say. Uh, we won the other night.
You did? Okay,
we did. It wasn't an epic victory because we did it using a destiny. That's not a spoiler if I say there are destiny cards in there.
That's not a spoiler.
Uh, there are different ways to win. You know, you have your mission and you could have multiple destinies and all you have to do is fulfill one of those destinies and boom. And the funny thing is we got stopped at a certain point and had the which is I love that you did this. You said, "Look, you get to this point on your track, you can just say, "Hey, we we lost today or do this sort of check and see if you, you know, qualify, keep going, and then if you lose again or someone goes again, then the game's over." That's what we chose to do, which I thought was a wonderful option to have.
And um yeah, I managed to uh to find something in my journey. I won't say I don't want to spoil it because it was surprising and fun. I found it.
We had just pulled the destiny card. I had just pulled on the next well a few turns later what we needed to complete that destiny. Everyone's like, "Oh my god, oh my god, read it. Read it. Read the passage. Read the passage." And we're all like I'm getting goosebumps thinking about it. And we all like, "We won the game." Um, and it was one of these things where we had to the the main thing, the main focus was we had to get like four animal friends. And I was the only one who had an animal friend. And I did it I did it in a very clever way. Lee and Nicole would have had me do something different, but I they were like, "Go with your gut. How do you want to handle this?" And I looked at the six choices. I picked it and I said, "You now have an animal comp." I was like, "Yeah, I have an animal companion." So again, I love that it has those like fist pump moments without being competitive and without being in your face. It's just a shared a communal Yes, we did it. So, uh, yeah. So, we we won our first game advantage.
Uhoh. Uhoh. Did we lose the in Did we lose the interwebs for a second
for a very very second there? Yeah. Yeah.
All I It's going to be great. It's all I was saying. Uh oh. Uhoh. I lost Jamie. We lost. Is he the interweb? So yeah, I love I genuinely love that there there are those moments in the game uh that are shared um where everyone dresses like in their sense of exhaustion and elation at the same time. So yes, yes, yes, yes. I fulfilled my destiny. Congratulations.
Thank you. And thank you. You you you made you made it so I could fulfill it. That was awesome.
Well, Mitchell, I'm so glad we had an overlapping topic. I thought this was a wonderful conversation about uh the process of curating and culling in hopefully a very positive way. And I'm very curious to hear what uh what you, our listener, uh how you do this, how you go about this process, how you decide what games to um that that it's time for them to move on from your collection and how you go through that process. Yeah. And and also thanks to Gary for putting this out there for us. It was such a good comment that it inspired both Jamie and myself to jump on. And you know what? You know what's funny?
Shared topics actually work.
It took it took like half a year for it to happen. But it actually works because we have different different thoughts on it and we can share our reaction and our sort of experience based on what that comment is. So it actually is kind of awesome. We we should cross over more often, Jamie. Makes for makes for a good podcast, doesn't it? Anyway, thank you Jamie so much for being here. Um, we will be joining you again next week on Positively Board Gaming. So, make sure you either tune in to the Stonemire Games YouTube channel to watch our two faces, our mouths open and closed when we're actually saying these words or your podcast platform of choice and listen to us. You can also go to positively boardgaming.com and download or listen to any of our previous 24 episodes. So, Jamie, thank you. You're a wonderful partner and I will see you next week. I'll see you then. Take care.