Board Games I Got Rid Of (And Why) - Episode 15
Transcript
hey everybody and welcome to another edition of board games i got rid of and why so this is a series of videos where i talk about games that i've previously had in my collection but for one reason or another they are no longer in my collection and i'll try to give some rationale as to why that is so um first up i have a game called michael strogoff which is a kind of a strange pushy luck style game as you're trying to work your way along this track revealing cards as you go and basically try not to get duplicate symbols as you go because you start taking a bit of punishment which will make your journey a bit more difficult and you're trying to cover up these symbols you get a bit of an engine going as you start to tuck cards under your board and get bonuses and things um and i kind of wanted to like this one i thought it was a bit too long for what it is and i think i mentioned before it was a bit over engineered for me it seemed to have a bit too much going on for what the actual core gameplay was you know that pushy like mechanism was the kind of fun part of it and the rest of it was a bit a bit bells and whistles it didn't really add much to the experience so because of that and the game took about i think it's about 45 minutes to play it really felt like you could play a pure pushy luck game several times in the you know in the one play you'd get this one to the table so for that reason it didn't quite stick around i thought it was decent um but yeah it didn't quite hit that point where it was you know that was worth keeping and keep getting to the table um probably a good thing to um explore if you're really into your solo games i thought this game really did lend itself quite well to that solo thing but yeah
just plenty of other games i'll choose before getting michael straight off back to the table so that's why i left my collection at the next game i want to talk about is a game called maharajah um which is a wolfgang kramer and michael keisling design who designed you i absolutely adore um this one is a an area control style game as you're trying to control these regions where the maharaja is visiting you're basically building up a network building up these shrines and things all to control the area and get points you have this quite cool power system where you could have a a power available to you at any time you could swap it with other players depending on what you needed a lot going on here that i liked a really cool kind of action selection wheel as well um to be honest the game in its own right was perfectly fine i had no problems with it but the issue is there are so many area control games out there and this one just isn't quite as good as a lot of other ones out there so this one does kind of fall victim of being a such a saturated kind of niche in the market with those area control games as so many games with that mechanism and some of my favorite games have a mechanism which i you know i struggle to get those gains to the table again and again let alone one that i think is not as good as those so yeah for that reason this one get pushed getting pushed further and further down my kind of priority to get to the table and therefore i couldn't really warrant keeping it but in its own right it was very solid game and one i do recommend but because there are so many other great games out there it didn't quite hold up the next game is a game that i fl didn't like at all this is a game called imperium this is the classics version
so this was a game that did reach kind of a moderate amount of success and buzz last year um as you are trying to basically build up this tableau of cards of your own kind of unique nation so you've got like ancient rome and all stuff like that and all these decks play in very different ways so quite an asymmetric game um the problem i had with this game was that i thought the the rules dump initially was just huge it was very finicky and fiddly with the way this one played um lots of iconography very unintuitive rules i would say and ultimately i found the game feeling a bit too much like work and i got literally no fun extracted from this one so i'm probably the minority there because i know this was quite popular again mostly with that solo crowd um but yeah i thought i i just didn't it didn't work for me i thought it was way too fiddly and again that was overhead was just too high for me personally and i think as the time's gone this one has really dropped off for a lot of people as well i don't really hear anybody talking about this one so maybe they started to kind of discover those problems themselves but that is imperium classics next up is a game called inish this one's a pretty damn popular game another area control star game but with some drafting in this one is you have a very tight amount of cards actually that you can start to learn quite quickly um and you're basically trying to draft these cards in order to influence the bald state um you are trying to put your kind of clansmen out there to control regions different winning objectives out there and basically it had a quite a different flow to it that i love a lot of other um area control star games do
because this one you have this almost like chess approach to it where if you were in a winning position you had to announce it to the other players and then they would have kind of one turn or the end to the end of the round to try and stop you which i thought was quite interesting it did make this game feel a bit different a lot i liked about this one i thought mechanically very smooth and very very clean will set some quite clever and interesting ways that the game was designed ultimately i didn't really find the game tremendously fun i thought it was a bit too a bit too jarring especially in terms of the con combat and things as when you kind of come into combat with other people you would just have to keep discarding cards in order to fight them and when you're doing that you're kind of diminishing your actions you could take which yeah it's not a bad idea and it has massive fallout effects and stuff but ultimately i didn't find it fun and i found it a bit too abrupt um additionally there were some cards in the game that you could use which were very swingy and i didn't quite gel with the rest of the game in my opinion so um while i appreciate this one and i can certainly see why it is so popular because it is a good design but just not one that's quite right for me personally next up i have a game called king of 12.
this is a very light i mean talking ultra light kind of dice rolling style game and simultaneous selection game as you're rolling a d12 and then you're simultaneously playing cards with other players and that will kind of manipulate the state of the table so some might say add seven to your value or double your value or um maybe get the the lowest dice win so that kind of thing and then whoever kind of wins the round gets points and it's a race to get to a certain amount of win conditions or something um simple as it gets i thought it worked pretty well for what it was maybe good for um families and children but for me in my game group this was just a bit too light for me and um yeah it was again fine but just ultra nothing ultimately inspiring so yeah just felt a bit flat um despite being quite a cool concept i suppose that is king of twelve next up i have a pretty interesting game called hats so hats is actually a game i think is rock solid i think this is a very good design as it's a card driven game that weirdly works well at two and three players but doesn't work well at four players which is kind of one of the main things that i didn't like about it because when you played with four players you had to play in teams which felt a bit weird and then ultimately you'll be playing these cards from your hand and replacing ones in this kind of communal role row and then taking that one you've replaced and put it in front of you for scoring but when you place cards in this in this board that's going to determine the points value of that particular uh kind of set of cards so you'll be this constant manipulating on
the board stage to try and benefit you and hurt your opponent and of course your opponent is doing the same thing so it was a little bit swingy in that respect but you did have some good amount of or a good degree of forward planning in this game because you could map turns uh further ahead i might want to play this card so i could take that one and this one to take that one and therefore this would be worth that much and i'd have these cards in front of me to get a big score um so yeah it did it was clever um but ultimately i did find that there was diminishing returns with this one there's while it was a good design and one that i think is massively underrated and overlooked um there's always that game that i would prefer to play more than this one so if for that reason it wasn't a keeper but i did kind of pass on to someone in my immediate game group who so i can actually manage to play this again if i need to because i think it's just on the cusp of being really good but just not quite there for for kind of some some reason i can't quite articulate but it was good just not great and that was uh that's hats next up i have a game called roon which is an absolutely tiny little game i'm talking a box like this big basically this game is a set of cards and this game uses that kind of overlapping system that's used in a lot of games now like um games like sporopolis and circled the wagons and um hokkaido you know these games where you're overlapping cars trying to cover up symbols this one you're doing that you're trying to collect these or create these big sets of these runes and then basically place your meeple in those rooms to get points so the bigger kind of group you're getting the more points you're going to get another game is as clean and crisp as it
gets it's decent i didn't dislike it at all but ultimately again it lacked that special bit of interest to stand above the power pit so just felt a bit a bit pedestrian i felt a bit like it's been done a thousand times before but for a travel style game you know this is a game specifically for two players it was it was good i bet then it probably has a right to be because it is very small very affordable but just not quite special so that really i don't really keep games that i feel that way about so that's why roone got moved on next is a game that i do like quite a lot actually this one still holds my shield of quality this is a game called merv at the heart of the silk road so this is a beautiful game a euro style game that almost has that trajan feel where you have all these mini games that kind of synergize with each other um and i quite like the core system in this game you're moving around this grid each time putting like a meeple down and building up like a resource network but also like actions and things you're triggering you can use other people's buildings some cool things going on here that i like quite a lot um i like some of the crossover that the different regions had um but ultimately i thought the problem with this one was that it didn't have a lot of replayability i thought that once i played this a few times i was pretty much done with it and didn't really have that huge hook to go back and play it any further so i feel quite satisfied with where i've been with this game enjoy my place of it this is again this one still i at least rate a seven out of ten it's probably about seven and a half um but ultimately there's games that i think are a bit more inviting to play them
again and again and explore further and uh this one i feel like i'm kind of getting the same experience every time so that's why merv sadly left my collection but this one was certainly on that border line of keeping because it's a very solid design and that is merv and the penultimate game i'm going to talk about is a game called into the black forest so this is another very small box card game um one that probably has one of the worst rule books i've ever read in my life so this was almost unplayable and pretty much wasn't playable um from the rule set itself you kind of had to fill in a lot of the gaps yourself and hope you're playing it right uh but there were some cool concepts here as you are basically playing these cards on these different um to all these different locations on these separate cards and getting points in different ways depending on what other people have played um but ultimately when you don't know or have any confidence in the rules because they are so unclear and again so just just so scarce and not really knowing what you're doing here um that really does again make me lose a lot of confidence doesn't really make me want to play it and um it's for that reason sadly it it it did fail um there was some massive confusion over you know when you draw cars back do you cycle through cars do you just play the cars in your hand um yeah so for those reasons i i just massively recommend avoiding this one and hopefully they come up with a second version or just some clarifications because um it's unforgivable to be like that really so that is into the black forest and the final game i want to talk about on this installment is a game called operation faust so this was actually one of the
first games i ever had in my collection so going many many years back um and this one has a lot of similarities to a game like coo where you are declaring you're our role whether you're telling the truth or lying and you're basically collecting this intel buying these paintings and trying to get to a certain amount of paintings to win the game but at the same time you again you are stealing money from other people you can claim to have certain cars to get more money um you've got to buy art you can do all this kind of stuff um i to be honest this game is actually better than coo so i recently played qr actually and was a massive disappointment to me uh this green game actually does work better than that i think the bluffing aspect comes through better um it's a bit less take that ish um but ultimately it is very swingy because you can just draw cards that are worth a fortune compared to other cards yeah that's part of the fun because it is a simple game but ultimately i find these games where you are playing cards just stealing money for other people it feels a bit it feels a bit procedural and sometimes you're just picking people for no rhyme or reason i've had some good ideas of when you're calling people's bluffs you are just losing half your money rather than you know losing a life so you're always going to be in this game has a good tension as it ramped up towards the end but ultimately there are many great filler games out there this one's just okay it's getting pretty pedestrian pretty pretty standard there really lots of games like this out there and um there's some games out there that are fantastic that you can play in the same amount of time so therefore this one has to go unfortunately but i do like it and again if you like coo this one is even better so well that concludes this installment of games that got rid of and
why so hopefully you've enjoyed the video if you have please hit like and subscribe to the channel and check out my other videos too and for everyone else i'll see you next time on chairman of the board bye