DTBGB #34 - "Top" 10 Worst (or most disappointing) Games of 2014
Transcript
everybody Welcome to drive-through board game blog today we're going to talk about the top 10 worst games of 2014 at least my most disappointing games uh you'll probably see in a week the top 10 best games of the year I know normally I do like categories or something but I'm just going to do a top 10 this year because my categories are failing me so let's jump in and get this one out of the way and I was thinking about this the other day uh as just a little anecdote real quick is I don't like Americo and most of my group kind of likes Americo not everybody but a lot of them do and it's sort of a fun thing if I go in and I see them playing it or want to play it you know I of course say something crass and then you know they'll flip me a little bit about you know hey don't you want to play a Maro and so it's a fun jovial atmosphere and it's probably a little more colorful than you'll see on camera but that's what happens when you hang out with your friends is you kind of give each other smack and you know you talk about the movies that they like that you don't like and vice versa so I hope a little bit of that Spirit comes through here and I will of course try to present some kind of critical analysis and some of these games I've talked about before but let's get this one out of the way and try to have a little bit of fun with it and uh first I'm just going to have an honorable mention because most top 10 lists of actual top 10s get an honorable mention so let's do an honorable mention for the worst of and my honorable mention I can almost feel the shouts
come is five tribes and I do not think it's a bad design I don't think it's a bad production I really can't find anything at fault with it in that sense but the game I played it three times and I never want to see it again and I was bored to tears and we basically end up helping each other in a Cooperative way when like the last I don't know four or five rounds happen because it's like okay well where's the most points for you and what will that extrapolate into being points for everybody else to your left and that's really the game all it boils down to which is super kind of disappointing because it was really hyped in you know praise coming out of Gen Con and the first time you play it it's like well this is pretty cool and then the second time you play it or at least when I play it it's like H all right it's not as good as I thought and the third time I play it I'm like okay that's it and I know it gets a little bit of like hey don't play with Gamers or you should play it with um you know family more and I think I've kind of said that um so I don't really think it's really great in any shape or form there's way better games for that and actually got rid of Relic Runners stupidly thinking okay everybody's hyping this this is going to be really good I'll get more people to play this and then got this and I promptly not promptly but soon after traded five TRS away back to get Relic Runners I was like why did I let that go I really like Relic Runners the family likes Relic
Runners so uh anyway so I like Relic Runners better than five trpes there you go so let's jump into the number 10 now now the the top part of this list is not like in my opinion horrible but just I don't want to play them uh so the number 10 and this is there's some caveats here is actually lap dance and so I played it once and I kind of outlined a little bit sort of Loosey Goosey in my little sort of post playay video that I did of it uh some of the problems I had with it and you know everybody at the table really kind of had a problem with it not with the theme now just with the mechanics but from what I understand uh looking at their Kickstarter page they are addressing some of that stuff so might be kind of a fun game and you can kind of see a little bit of potential there with the core mechanics it's got a very sort of I don't know Whimsical frenzy dice rolling card play kind of thing now I do want to make a statement about the theme is I actually think the way that they treat the theme actually works pretty well because it's sexualized of course but it's also like a weird mixture of these cartoony characters and sort of this weird fetish kind of thing where it's very playful and and to me feels very non-threatening when maybe it could feel threatening and of course I assume that it might feel threatening to certain people so I would stay away from that kind of game if you're sensitive in that area but to me it was very whims I really liked how they treated the theme I like the artwork I liked you know the core of the rules and things now to me
the name of the game is a little bit unfortunate because the term lap dance I think puts you in sort of a sort of strip club mentality and that's really where the game takes place uh but there's a very seedy dark underbelly to that world and a very sort of I don't know despondency uh to the underlying part of that uh that's a whole other psychological topic but the game comes across very sort of you know very adult but also very funny and sort of you know kind of risque humor and interesting pairings and combinations and all this stuff so I thought that was kind of interesting uh from a game perspective but the mechanics and stuff there was a lot of stuff that was really frustrating with the push your luck and it kind of handcuffs you in more ways than one and you know with with terms of the gameplay mechanics but maybe that'd be something that you could revisit now something I won't ever bring into my house uh cuz there's children here and stuff and that's not appropriate but I think in certain settings it should be okay and you know I'll be interested maybe to play it one of these years down the road and see how they change it if how if they Chang it at all so that's kind of my number 10 but that's kind of Loosey Goosey because probably second edition will be a little bit better maybe they'll fix some of the stuff so and number nine is a similar thing uh a study in Emerald which I played also three times um and wanted to like it and I've talked about it before but there is a a new version of it coming out I think it's a little bit more paired down now this game has a little bit of deck building if you're not familiar with it
it's sort of a team game but you don't know who's on your team and you're doing some deck building and there's some area control where you're controlling different parts of the city and or different cities I think and so you're trying to figure out who's who and who's on your team and the team that has the player with the least amount of points nobody can win on that team uh so even if you're in first if the person on your team is in last then you can't win the second place player will win it's really cumbersome and really awkward and very interesting to play and probably one I would recommend you at least try but at the end of the day it didn't end up being very satisfying but they are making sort of a more purely streamline deck builder out of this and so I'm interested to try that because it's a type of game uh that I like you know you got like sort of your Battle Star Galactica your dead of winter um you know that kind of game so but at the end of the day it's like there's too much kind of thrown in it and I think one of the things that I read that they're trying to do with the new version is they kind of felt like they because it was sort of complex and awkward they lost s of the Neil Gaiman fan who would be the fan of just the basic story and they wanted to make something a little bit more accessible so well maybe that'll kind of clean up the gameplay a little bit too so that's another one that I'm looking forward to and then the number eight is rattle bones and this is a new game from Rio Grand games and I really wanted to like this game this is one I haven't talked about before and it's kind of geared as a kids game so it's a little bit higher up on this list
but having tried it with my son he was also kind we were kind of on the same page with it now he's not very young but basically you it's a roll and move game but you can reassemble the faces of the dice and you can get different special abilities and stuff so there is a little bit of strategy there to sort of as you equip the different die faces because it has a really interesting uh at least physically the way you pop D faces on and it's got this little wedge tool you can pop them off that actually works pretty well uh but the Dy things can be a little fiddly for kids a little bit I think small kids would have trouble with it but he didn't um but you kind of have a balance between trying to choose to give yourself some variability in terms of the places you can move versus the sort of special abilities you can do to get points but like at the end of the day it just wasn't like fulfilling there was no it was like I'm still randomly rolling and doing whatever I can do um and it just kind of plays itself so it might be something that smaller kids would enjoy and I almost hate putting on the list but it just really we couldn't get into it we just there was nothing there for us we felt like we were trying to make a strategic decision but the end it like never sort of paid off um so yeah so that's a kind of an interesting one there um but the next one here would be number seven and that would be Z this is another one that I really wanted to like this game and I think it's a Well produced game not just the miniature ships that come with the game
which are crazily overproduced but even the tiles and the cards and the artwork and stuff it's elicits a very sort of dynamic environment you know you've got some tiles that are these big supernovas and then crazy asteroid fields and then you'll have sort of a u you know like a very rich sector with a lot of planets and a lot of resources to go and ship and trade but the game needs to be developed I think a lot because like one of the things you can do is you can grab Mission cards and you draw three and choose one and most of the time they of involve hey if this sector is on the board you'll take a good from this sector and ship it over here and you're like well that sector is not on the board yet so I'm just going to ignore those and then on my next turn maybe I'll try to get another mission and then I'll draw three cards and well nothing nothing on the board that relates to this Mission okay and there's a few other that's kind of the basic problem right so you have the r move which is kind of a bummer but there's some mitigation there and you also have like mining or salvaging well it's basically a 50-50 shot if you get something or wreck your ship or wreck all the energy on your ship and there's not really any mitigation for that it's so it's like why would you ever try to mine or Salvage Salvage is the one that'll really hurt you and you know the the combat's a big dice Fest which isn't the end of the world I mean that's combat but there is some Merit to the game in terms of playing it sort of like a tales of the Arabian Knights Style game I guess where
it's more like sit back and let the game play you and there's kind of a story but I think the disappointment for me comes when I see the potential I'm like okay well if they had done a little bit more with the technology because there's really just three techs there's there's moving and there is the um you know you get engines and you get Shields and you get different guns and it's like oh that's it and you do a little Tetris thing on your ship and that's all there really is to the game it'd be cool if there were some other different crazy things that you could do I was talking to my buddy um Jeff gamble about this and he was like well it'd be cool if you like fly through a star or just have all these crazy things to really sort of just Tech out and make it crazy so you could mitigate a lot of this really lucky stuff because the game has fun moments this one I played twice where you like one game we had like all the NPC characters come out there's a lot happening and that was kind of fun and so there was enough to kind of keep us on our toes and then the second time we played it's like well none of these came out until like you know 34s away through going through all the sector tiles and the first I don't know how many turns was just like laborious like oh okay I move here okay I got my you know equipment to upgrade on my ship and okay I moved over here I moved one space you know just really plotting and methodical so it' be interesting to add more to it and I just would would could have been like cooked a little bit longer cuz there's a lot to really you know admire in terms of the production effort that went into it so what number on 10987 six number six is chaos ball talked about
this a little bit on a previous video uh like I said before I hate the card play and the card play just drives me bananas and I ended up not liking the whole like King of the Hill type of scoring where you kind of score spots on the board uh there's sort of you know two ways to score points you can sort of dominate a location and then also you know move the ball into the end zone and that that was kind of interesting you know to be fair cuz it's different than like a blood bow or a dread Ball but the card play where I can play a certain card value and then never play that again for that quarter or that round was super irritating I'm ridiculously irritating I mean that's another one where it's like a lot to like I like the different special abilities that you can get you can get the different uh heroes or the special units that you could add to your team and all that kind of stuff but then at the end of the day it's like I'm just handcuffed by this C Dynamic that was just so so frustrating and we got number five now is Shadow run I've also talked about that one this one maybe as I'm sitting here trying to verbalize this five is maybe a little bit high at the list it probably should be a little bit more towards the 10 cuz again something that has Merit and but it's like it's almost like this one is too difficult and you feel like you've baked your outcome into the deck uh with this one because it's a Cooperative Deck Builder and based on how you flop out the car cards and what
cards you can acquire and add to your deck is going to kind of determine already what how you're going to win you know or lose and to me it's too strict and too handcuffed and the whole grinding for the way the campaign Works didn't work out uh really at all and I felt like this is another one that could have been like developed more and more and more and more but like Pathfinder of the Aventure card game I mean to me that's just like Leaps and Bounds above the shadow run and uh so that was one that you know I talked more about it in the previous video but that's another one that just it's almost like these are the most frustrating games for me because I see the game and I'm like oh man there's so many other cool things I could have done with this and so that's kind of where Shadow run sits and the next one here Heroes wanted um I this is one I think I'm the only person on the planet that doesn't like and I've talked about it before and hate to harp on it but it's cool the idea is really neat where you can slap on the top part of your hero and the bottom part of the hero and you have this crazy like vegetable bear man or something or a robotic squirrel and you have these different you know scenarios to go in and the settings could be very cool where you have these super that are sort of competing to beat the bad guys so they want to get the headline uh but the actual mechanics of moving around in the combat was just like mind-numbing for me where the game just kind of like I don't I don't want to play this I want to sit here and just build the hero and you know talk about funny it' be cool like
as a role playing setup where you just okay we put these together and we set these up and then we kind of just Wing It far as the rules go this probably would have been pretty fun um so that was H number four and number three is my star and that's because the game is broken and it's a s canine game so it's a very disappointing game in that regard because you know the man obviously is not perfect and uh so you know this exemplifies that because there's a couple of really big issues with some of the different gishes you can use in this particular game uh CU you're trying to score customers and all that kind of cool stuff but um you know this was one unfortunately it was there but it just needed to be tested a little bit more I think and uh you know and played out because it's it's to me it's it's a broken game and I don't like to use that word but we have the number two which is say bye to villains which to me is also broken not in the sense of balance but it's more broken in the terms of it's a big guessing game it's a co-op game where players are playing these cards to sort of reveal villain cards and other cards that come out but nothing you do makes a difference it's already baked into the deck which is kind of where Shadow run falters but this is like 100% I mean you just kind of okay I'm guess I'm pushing my luck but there's not really any luck it's a big illusion and that's to me it's a complete failure as
a game you know um so that's the set number two and then the number one is uh bed pans and Broomsticks I talked about that quite a bit and I just want to you know say again I feel like I'm harping a little bit on it but I can't not say it either is I feel like they're really careless with the theme and the theme is basically you know adult old people that seem to have Alzheimer's or uh or Dementia or something and they're trying to escape from this bad nursing home or something or something trying to get out and you know it's sort of a deduction game cooperative versus uh Overlord kind of sort of scenario and they're trying to get out and I was like well that's to me the whole thing is that the carelessness of of the theme in that game and that's not something you usually see in a board game is the carelessness of a theme like that I mean you know you see very usually good treatments of themes that can be uh you know tricky to talk about um but you know like lap dance is one that I kind of thought was going to be careless but I thought they actually did a really good job you know treating that theme which is just a that's a big firework to touch uh whereas this one it was like they slapped the theme on and it really irritated me and I do have to sort of not necessarily apologize to them I maybe I should a little bit but you know I threw the thing in the trash you know literally and not joking around for video I was I was pretty irritated by it and you know I guess there's a certain a lot of decorum or
professionalism that was broken there um but uh I do think that Mayfair is a good company obviously and they make good games and um uh the designer whose name is escaping me but I know because he designed savur which is one of the games that I've really enjoyed over the years the last several years so I know these are people capable of putting out good work and I'm sure they're good people but it's like this this mistake was it's such a a front to me now to share a little bit about that you know I don't think I shared this in my previous video and I probably should have I guess somebody has told me that I should um you know my grandfather basically died of dementia where his body kind of shut down and um so that's kind of where the emotion comes from because having visited him you know a few times in the VA hospital and all that kind of stuff you kind of get a real good impression of what this kind of disease thing will do to somebody and uh I would probably think it interesting somehow if somebody came up with a game about these serious topics I don't mind that I think that's pretty cool if somebody would do that but not just to carelessly throw it on there and I think that's important for people to say that they don't think that's a good idea because I think uh yeah we can talk politics here in a second but I don't really want to so I think people should be able to say This is BS and I don't like this in axyz and um and not really get too crazy
about it but it should be able to say you don't like a thing and I don't want to ever see this thing happen again uh that's all there is to that so that was sort of a downer I going to start off being uh in fun I knew I was going to get to that point though um so anyway those are the games I don't like and I won't play and um maybe lap dance and study and emerald if they fix them I might try those but uh anyway so hopefully you have some good discussion and I think uh the only reason I do these is kind of just to get these off my chest and you know a lot of times people say you reviewer people are always so nice and you know you're your big shills for these companies nobody's ever said that to my face but you kind you see stuff online and people say stuff like that and um so I think it's important to take a couple of seconds and tell people you don't like a thing and uh for some reason uh just to show that you're a human being I guess anyway anyway so that is my top 10 worst games of the year and I you know I'm kind of thinking now as I'm saying this how I feel about this I'm going to go ahead and leave it on YouTube um but um I you know I don't really I didn't really have that much fun making this video now that I think about it and uh I don't really know how much how much I want to keep doing these I know I keep doing them throughout the year uh you know that's what I've been doing and I think it's fair to people uh that want to know how I feel about games that I don't like and I know I kind of brushed through several of these some of them I talked about on previous videos and so
you know if I think if you have feedback there that's good and the one thing I will say that I I won't do because two reasons a it's not my job and um I mean it's not my it is my job but it's not my job and you know B I don't have time and those kind of go together is to do like a full review like z i could sit down and I could show you the rules and how to play and you know other people that have enjoyed the game have done that um you know and I I guess there's some certain level of like proving somehow cuz I kind of get that sense in the back of my mind and I feel like people you know I'm just kind of talking off the cuff here I feel like people feel like you know they know that I can have played it and I probably played it right I understand there's a little bit of trust issue there sometimes with some people but going into that depth of it it's a very tricky thing you know um because it's not like I can sit and review a movie where that kind of review only takes 5 or 6 minutes anyway um you know I don't have to show you that I watched the movie you you can pretty much assume that I did so this is kind of one where it's like well I can sit there and spend it takes a while to make these reviews as well and I feel like if I were to review a game that I didn't like I probably wouldn't give it the same effort you know where I was reviewing a game that I do like you know what did I review recently the Golden Ages was one that I really quite liked and you know I put a lot of time into making the edits and all that kind of crazy stuff and like I don't feel like
doing that with a game I don't like but you know when I say that out loud it feels very hypocritical to say that and I'm sorry for just musing here but kind of follow me so I don't know if this is the right way to do it but I also feel like there's a certain Integrity thing and I don't mind talking about the game but you know of course there's you know you hurt people's feelings I guess if you say you don't like their game um but you know whatever right I mean I like kis and people don't like that and I'm sure the designer of kis has heard people call it dry and horrible and stuff so I think people can get over that pretty quickly um so anyway that's just some kind of rambling thoughts there on this whole negative review thing and it's a topic that comes up you know now and then you people say you need people need to be more negative and I think they probably do and people probably shouldn't be so so negative sometimes and what is this you know we have to be have some Integrity as you know game reviewers and things um it's a weird topic because at the end of the day that's not why I'm here you know I don't I'm not here to to help you figure out what to buy sometimes you know this I'm just I'm sorry but I do it because I want to tell you about the thing and what my experience was with the thing and in terms of like helping you make a purchase decision ision you know a lot of some of the reviewers say I recommend this or this is uh approved or whatever and that's good I think that's good I think we need sort of like a consumer
advocacy approach that we need reviewers that do that not every reviewer has to do that but we I think it's good to have reviewers that do that but at the end of the day when I'm here I'm not I don't think about that and I I don't I'm pretty sure people will get that sense from me but I don't think about should you buy this now sometimes I do but to me it's like should you play this should you try this you know if you see this at a shop and your buddy has it now you know some information about it and so you can engage with it you know the whole purchase decision thing is is weird I don't think reviewers are necessarily here for that yeah so I think that's an interesting topic to think about and the reviews don't always have to just be yes buy no buy and that kind of stuff and I think I've been getting that a lot this year where people are like you know they I think they watch the review most people that watch the review will make make a comment I like what you said here at minute 8 or whatever and then some people were like well what do you think should I buy it or something like that I'm like I have no idea if you should buy the game I really have no clue at all I mean I you know even my group and I we don't agree on everything we have a pretty good agreement and sympatico um you know not always but that's a sense that I get I know a game that I can take to the group or to my family here even and we're probably going to like it but most of it probably has to do with me and them you know and if I'm presenting the game and you know I get everybody involved or somebody's presenting the game to me and then we're all involved that's the whole point
there anyway I think I've rambled on way too much but I said I was going to leave it on YouTube anyway so I hope people have fun with this yeah anyway people just need to have fun with it and uh just you know chew on what I said don't feel like you have to tell me a right or wrong answer but please comment if you are so moved and I will absorb that comment and I will appreciate the comments uh no matter what it is so anyway have a good year and next week we'll be back with some more actual fun and some more reviews and everything so uh anyway thank you