Skip to main content
Loading video...

KDM vs. Middara vs. Oathsworn vs. Vampire the Masquerade vs. Vagrantsong | 5 Active Campaign Games

Transcript 18:37

hello welcome to qu thank you for being here today I'm going to be talking to you about the five Campaign games I currently have up and running both on camera and at home with my wife or my game group it's going to be comparing Kingdom Death monster to Madar to oathsworn to vagrant song and finally to vampire the Masquerade chapters I love this genre of gaming but they're big they're bulky they take a lot of table space and they a commitment to dive head first into I'm only able to semi balance the amount of games we have running because one I have an amazing gaming partner in Shira but then also two I do this for a living so for you if you're deciding on the next big campaign game you want to dive head first into spend your hard earned money on and of course occupy your table for the next month or couple of months if you're lucky then in this video I'm going to be breaking down some of the highs and lows my thoughts if I was just getting into a campaign game and where I think these fit in the spectrum of a gaming group and a board gamer specifically player counts and how I would approach them if I were you I'm doing this video one because this is one of my favorite genres of games and I always love an excuse to talk about massive Campaign games that are uh ambitious to say the least but also because vampire the Masquerade chapters

is currently launching their second printing Kickstarter the definitive edition of vampire the Masquerade chapters now we are doing some sponsored content alongside of them and the way that sponsorship looks is well with that link in the top of the video description if you click on that link and end up backing the campaign you'll be supporting quackalope as well so if you're already interested in Vampire Mas gra chapters do the simple task of hitting that Kickstarter link down below to make sure your support goes to both parties either way let's go ahead and dive into the campaigns we currently have operating the most obvious to start with is going to be Kingdom Death monster the gamblers chest we are currently posting a series of campaign videos almost every week I've missed a few trying to keep up with the editing backlog but you can watch our campaign up to this point so far and our first general Impressions around the gambler's chest have been that it makes Kingdom Death both more complex more advanced more nuanced and also better than it has ever been I think Sher and I both agree that the gambler's chest and elements of the gambler's chest is something we'll be incorporating into every game of Kingdom Death going forward but some base rules some ground rules for you who are considering getting into Kingdom Death in the first place and considering getting the gambler's chest on top of all of that base Kingdom Death is a massive brutal brutal settlement Builder

you'll be fighting one big creature trying to harvest resources from them and survive on the back end it's not about heroes you don't get to keep your favorite character alive in per in perpetuity instead they will be they will be killed they will be slaughtered and often in the most unfortunate ways possible so if you're okay with that Kingdom Death it might fit your game group it is also hard and brutally unfair at times so keep that in mind if you're going to be diving into playing it there is a lot of outside knowledge available to learn about the progression trees and how you should craft gear and prepare for the end of the game but the odds are You'll Play tens if not hundreds of hours of Kingdom Death monster before ever finishing a full campaign because the loss rate is or the loss potential is so high on those first few plays you go through if I was going to be incorporated the gambler's chest which I do recommend doing I would only do it with a minimum group group of two base Kingdom Death can be a solo player experience and it can be wonderful at that but you have to have some dexterity and some skill if you're going to be going into the gamblers chest it adds layers and complexities with a philosophy with a fifth character which is the Scout that's going out on the Hunting Expedition with you opens up tons of doors and a lot of opportunity but it is restrictive and I think it makes Kingdom Death a two plus preferably maybe three player game at min moving on down let's go ahead and

compare Kingdom Death monster to the other big boss batt we have which is going to be oorn from shatter born games this is a lovely game to critical Acclaim and we have really enjoyed the campaign up to this point it is a little bit less open-ended than Kingdom Death is Kingdom Death is more of an exploratory game and the bosses here feel surprisingly unique compared to the bosses that we fight in Kingdom Death monster they both have their own flavor their own text texture that you're going to be diving into if you like a little bit more of a hero focused game a little bit more of a Choose Your Own Adventure storyline and you like being surprised throughout the course of play Then oorn is absolutely a game you should be queuing in on whereas in Kingdom Death you're fighting very unique very dark very cryptic creatures and exploring a world full of the unknown here in oorn the world's going to be a little bit more revealed to you and as you open each one of the boss decks you will be facing you characters with their own unique mechanic system but you'll be playing as the hero grabbing your giant sword upgrading your abilities and playing cards in this cyclical refresh phase a little bit of a Rondell system that times how you do your most powerful actions but when you can do a powerful action it feels so so sweet for me this is another two-player game I like boss Battlers at two- player I'm going to be honest about that yet you have a little bit more to manage but I really enjoy sharing that experience with other

players around the table however I think my preferred place to play oorn would be for players I love the idea of sitting down with a full companion a full party of players reading through the narrative flavor text and then facing off against this giant Behemoth of a creature and every single one of the bosses has felt satisfying to take down and consequential to the storyline oor cannot recommend highly enough why won't you like this well if you don't like boss Battlers you're looking more for a Dungeon Crawl or a campaign if you're not so focused on the actual mechanics engine of the game like for instance if you didn't like Gloom Haven because Gloom Haven didn't have much of a story well this gives you quite a bit more of a story a ton more world to build out but I'd say the primary focus of oorn is still that mechanic engine of the cards you're playing down the abilities Your Heroes have and how you progress through the narrative and it's not as focused on the Choose Your Own Adventure consequences as I would prefer personally as a player moving on down from oorn we're talking about boss Battlers but we're also talking about Campaign games right Dungeon Crawlers we're merging towards the Madara esque and the vampire the chapters esque genre of gaming we got to mention vagrant song Here the small accessible bite-size version of a boss battling campaign game with a very cool midsize approach to the

heroes you're playing to the terrain that you're battling on a single roll out flip board to the beautiful standies there aren't any Miniatures at all included in this game and of course the narrative progression vagrant song has a lovely cryptic feels like overthe Garden Wall sense of narrative storytelling that I can't get enough of however the game play can be a little complex and a little convoluted you see you taken any turn after every single one of your characters go which means I can only really recommend vagrant song after playing it at multiple at I believe every player count I can only recommend it at one or two with my Preferred Player count actually being a solo player game a vagrant song where you're controlling multiple characters while you progress through the game it keeps you involved in the action and keeps you continuing to face the foes on the table I would say Kingdom Death compared to these last two games is the most consequential the most ruthless the most brutal boss battler of them all whereas of course oorn is going to be one of the more epic ones right the big heroes swinging their broadsword and cutting the throat of the giant rat feels glorious vagrant song merges storytelling with the boss battling in a very very interesting and amazing way from events that change the terrain that you're fighting on to cryptic or haunts that actually transform while you're in the middle of a combat sequence there's more storytelling that happens during the course of play in vagrant song than

I think either game other than of course the experiential things that you do by Rolling Dice and ripping off some lion testies vagrant song takes storytelling in a very unique Direction something that I hope I see boss Battlers do more often giving you a chance to explore the narrative route as well as just the violent kind of sock them up beat them route of the game playay this is one that I will end up finishing all of the expansion content for when it comes out but probably on my own and potentially not even on camera the views on the gameplay videos so far have been dedicated but not uh gigantic so I'm still deciding if I'm going to be bringing back the gameplay videos as a permanent sequence here or maybe just doing them over on patreon so a boss battler that brings in some narrative storytelling some adventuring let's talk about the two games that are more closely aligned with a classic Dungeon Crawler campaign a DND an RPG in the box and do storytelling in their own very unique very Innovative way starting with vampire the Masquerade chapters this game is kind of mindblowing it has these storybook mechanics where you're interacting with different NPCs you're investigating discovering things about the map and engaging in real actual dialogue back and forth with the characters on the board this really feels like you have a d that's running the narrative sequence and the entire game is focused on that yeah there is some combat and there is some bosses

that you have to take down but they're never your primary concern and you can usually figure out ways to work your way around them except for some of the very specific boss fights like taking down a werewolf and then when push comes to shove buy all the gear you need take out some allies and let them have a handgun at the end of the day that's kind of all you need to progress and focus on what V Empire of the Mas grade chapters does differently and does better than any of the other games on the table it tells a story one that you're in the middle of one that you're taking part in and I really do think it's remarkable for how it does it so if you're interested in backing vampire the M grade chapters like I said click the link in the top of the video description you'll not only be backing a game that I think is very good but you'll also be supporting quackalope when you do so so vamp the masade chapters innovates in the way that it tells the story the flip books the little storytelling books that allow you to engage in dialogue and do investigative work where you have consequences of your actions these little mini Choose Your Own Adventure scenarios that really do pay off in a variety of different ways madora takes the other approach Madara is I think one of the most aggressive RPG jrpgs whatever you want to call it and more classical board games that we're playing currently out of these five it's going to be a classic Dungeon Crawl a lot of tiles you're running in fighting a heap of enemies and taking down whatever objective you have usually get somewhere

break something or kill everything it's going to be your classic Dungeon Crawl but where it steps away from that is the way that you progress the various characters that you have and the way that you engage in the story this massive book fills this box with probably three or four novels worth of Flavor Tech storytelling and adventuring to explore exp an entire anime collection or Manga collection in a box and you have this little red cryptic die that you're going to be flowing over the page reading the consequences of what happens and what you do we are a few episodes into the beginning of this campaign so far and absolutely loving the adventure the storytelling can be a little gimmicky sometimes if any of you watched things like one piece or Dragon Ball Z you know at times the hair grits a little long long and the voices get a little loud but I can't stop loving everything we're running into it's the idea of these characters that are pulled into an alternative world where they suddenly have magical abilities and powers and they're figuring out how to survive function and graduate into real adventurers in the land and the world of Madara this game has some of the most beautiful artwork very very classic but rewarding play and allows you to focus on the hero and the narrative story in a way that other games don't it is massive it takes a long time to read and yet I really do enjoy it I would say that

vampire the M grade chapters is a two to three player game I wouldn't probably go to the maximum player count because some of the narrative options that you have uh don't reward multiple people wanting to do multiple things at the same time however there are benefits to having multiple players on the game board specifically with the powers and upgrades that each unique vampire has you're going to want to be engaging in the uh in the different events the investigation the dialog the things that you're trying to overcome and accomplish with various skill sets depending on what the challenge ends up being whereas Madara I really I really like Madara at I believe every player count with my Preferred Player count being four the reason being is because every character has their own unique build and progression and you are running for characters just like Kingdom Death when you play and I do find that it can be a little bit more unwieldy uh to run all four characters with two players or with one player if you're diving into it for the first time it starts you off kind of heart and hot and heavy with a lot of powers abilities and ways to progress so we've kind of ran through all of these you already know that Kingdom Death is my ground zero my favorite campaign game ever but the question is where do I rank these where do I put these from that point on I would say right now after Kingdom Death I would probably be leaning towards osor as coming in second place specifically

because it gives you these powers and abilities while still investing me in this incredible world of giant freakish boss battling after that it's going to be a close call Madara vampire the masade chapters and vagrant song all do things that are unique if I'm looking for an immersive RPG experience something that makes me feel like I'm playing an RPG board game without a DM vampire of the M grade chapters is going to take it if I love Japanese jrpgs and a little bit more of a classic Dungeon Crawl Madara has it in Spades and if I want a small box experience something that I can approach and play solo then I think I have to go with vagrant song along with that depending on player count if I have a two-player game or a three-player game that I'm running I'd say Kingdom Death is going to be topof the line there I'd then bring over to vampire the M grade chapters and oorn if I'm playing a solo player game I think it's got to be vagrant song I'm cutting out vampire the Masquerade chapters I'm potentially tossing in Madar cuz some of the flavor texts can be a lot to read if you're playing with an entire group of people so maybe that'll be rewarding to sit down I haven't tried it myself and vampire the Master Grade chapters can be run solo but preferred is definitely going to be Two Three or yeah two or three if I'm playing a four player game I think I want I don't think I want Kingdom Death because the odds of someone dying is going to be extremely

high I think at four players the top of the line for me is going to have to be Madara and oorn so you kind of have a sense of where my numbers lie when it comes to player count comes to genre of game and comes to the size scale and approach of them in terms of the commitment in the table space of course the biggest is going to be Kingdom Death following up on that I think is going to be Madara then we're going to have oorn then we're going to have vampire the M grade chapters kind of tied with vagrant song they both can spread out if need be they both can condense if need be in terms of the time it takes to actually sit down and play these games I think that Kingdom Death is going to be at the top ranging from anywhere from 1 and a half to 3 hours uh I think oorn and Madara are going to be tied and then vampire the M grade chapters is going to come in around that 30 minutes per player 45 minute campaign and vagrant song is going to be in that hour to an hour and a half range depending on how experienced you are with the game and how many players you have if you're playing solo that hour is really The Sweet Spot anything higher than that your enemies your hints are going to be getting a lot more turns than I'd prefer them to have so there you have it these are the five Campaign games we're currently playing through and experiencing I intend to get to the end of all of these games whether it's this year or next I'm not quite sure some of them will go on the back burner while other things come in that we have to cover here on the channel but we're

committed to these and we're genuinely enjoying all of them quite a bit so let me know what Campaign games are you playing and what out of the five of these are you the most excited to get down to the table as soon as possible whatever the case though whatever you do remember to do the important thing get out and play some games we'll see you next time bye

Progress saved