Skip to main content
Loading video...

Is My Board Game Collecting Getting Out of Control?

Transcript 14:56

When it comes to how I experience this hobby, I'm not only a board gamer, I'm also, and I think many of you can relate to this, I'm also sort of a collector, a completionist, a I want to have it all type of backer. Now, I don't know that collecting is always necessarily a bad thing. In fact, there's a satisfying reward to being a gamer and a collector. Kickstarters are fun to back and follow along. You discover a whole collection of unique and interesting things. I spent years pursuing resin rare models for Kingdom Death, my favorite game of all time. And I don't regret the time I spent doing that. I'm the one that gets really frustrated when there's a miniature and exclusive card or even non-gameplay related materials that I can't get because they were Kickstarter exclusive 5 years ago. I'm the one that wants to own every copy of every set. I want to own so many expansions. It makes the game entirely unplayable.

Here's to you looking at my copy of Wingspan and my copy of Kingdom Death Monster and my copy of Dominion and my copy of Marvel Champions and all the other titles that have been limited due to the sheer volume of stuff I have. But I am starting to run into a bit of a problem. And the problem is the intersection between those two categories of my personality, the gamer and the collector. Because not all games are collectible, but they're still good games and they're worth having and keeping on your shelf. And then more central to this video, some games that are collectible have one or two critical flaws. things that make it so that I really should get rid of 50% of them so that I can actually play, enjoy, and hold on to the other 50%.

But the collector in me doesn't want to let them go. So, I'm currently packing to go back to Cleveland, Ohio. Our car blew its engine about a month ago up here in New Jersey. And uh yeah, I flew back up to write a big check and uh drive the 8 hours home. I have some game stores I'm hoping to swing by on the way and lots of thoughts and ideas to explore. But I'm also confronting the collector as I pack my car. You see, we have a lot of games up here cuz we we we come and we play and we have a lot of games to bring back. And since I'm driving, not flying, I can actually bring home some of the titles that we've left. But here's where the problem really starts to show up. I've got three titles here. Three titles that I really have no reason to own, but I want to bring each one of them home. Not because I want to play them or because I enjoy the games or because there's not other versions of those exact same games that are better and more worthwhile and more likely to hit the table.

But I have three boxes here that I want to bring home simply and solely because they're part of a set and I'm keeping another percentage of that set because I love these games because they deserve to be on my shelf. But these three boxes are never going to get played, and I honestly don't have the space, room, or money to justify keeping them. But the collector in me doesn't want to let them go. Most central to this conversation is a game that I absolutely love, and it's central because I actually have all three copies here with me. That is Great Western Trail. We brought this down because Sheer and I had learned it recently and started playing it and wanted to explore it with our friend and we ended up picking up the uh expansion standalone for Argentina and New Zealand. Three copies of Great Western Trail, a game that is part of our collection and has been for a very long time. A game that is not going anywhere. Three beautiful boxes with lovely displayed artwork on the sides. Isn't that glorious? Won't that look amazing on a collector's shelf? But here's the problem. Only two out of three of these games is good. One of them we didn't like at all. One of them, yeah, we might play it one more time so I can bring a review to the channel and tell you about the

critical error that, you know, one of my favorite games made. What why one of them just doesn't work. And one of them is better than the other. We do have opinions on that as well. But classic Great Western Trail is excellent and and very very playable. And then paired with that, we also happen to really enjoy New Zealand. We thought it was innovative, unique, stylish, worth playing. But Argentina, Argentina, we hated. Hated might honestly be a bit of a strong word, too strong for this series of games. I think it's a fine game. Like a five and a half, maybe 6 out of 10. But when we're talking about the other two, we're talking about 7.5, 8, 8.5 out of 10. We're talking about games that aren't leaving my collection ever. And so when I'm making a decision of getting Great Western Trail to the table, it's either going to be the classic that we love and endure, it's potentially going to be the incredible New Zealand that introduces systems and mechanics, a unique way to approach the strategy of the game. For me, has new layers of depth that that make it not only slightly more open and complex. So instead of going on that same rondelle that you can get a little bit tired of 10 games in, this spices it up, changes

the script, makes it so I want to hop between both systems because both systems are satisfying. But never, never in that conversation, unless we just want to compare and contrast, unless we have a player who has never played this version and we want to have a less than good or less than perfect game night experience. Argentina's never getting to the table. Other people might love it. This might be the game for them. I don't mind that being the case. But the mechanics, the changes, the systems put in place here for me, for my gaming group, for Shira and one of our close friends who we were playing these with, we all agree it just didn't sing. It wasn't as good. But the collector in me, the collector in me doesn't want to let it go. Like I've let go of a substantial part of the hobby that gives me joy, at least in the realm of that one particular title. And if it was only one title, it wouldn't really be an issue. It wouldn't be worth doing an entire video about, but it's not just one title.

I also love Final Girl. I love the villains, the systems, the mechanics. But I purchased this separately, the Christmas, the Crumpus edition. Yeah, sure. It's a new villain, new heroes, new girls to play. It's not like I don't already have enough of those with the variability that exists in all four seasons of this incredible game. But on top of that, we don't really celebrate Christmas. It's not part of our family's tradition. And so Christmas games really don't have as much space on my shelf. And it's not that I don't like Christmas, but if I'm choosing what Final Girl to play, the Christmas edition isn't ever going to be the one. Not after I've tried it once. But if I get rid of that standalone box, doesn't fit perfectly into any of the big shelf cassette boom box sleeves. If I get rid of that one standalone box, the collector in me, even though I know I'm not going to play it, the collector in me feels like I'm feels like I'm missing something. feels like I shouldn't even bother having any of final girl at all if I'm not going to overcommit and get everything.

And then we run into another problem as well. Worms span. I have fin span and actually have grown to enjoy fininsspan a decent amount with Shira. We have Wingspan, which is already a little over ambitious with the fan art card packs, the sleeves, the multicolored eggs that no longer fit in the box, the bird tower that I actually have to keep on top of the shelf because for some reason I thought I need a bird tower to roll dice that looks like a bird box that looks glorious like a a bird. I should put it outside and let the birds make nests in it. That's what it really was created for. And then we have Worms Span. I mean, we're four games into Wormspan. And yeah, I want to have a copy of it in studio so I can do a compare and contrast between the three titles, but other than that, I genuinely don't even want this game.

And yet, and yet that little bug, that little whisper, that other part of my experience of the gaming hobby starts to tell me that this looks really nice on the shelf sitting next to Wingspan. And I still need to get that Wingspan big box. It helps explain the odd choice of titles in my opinion. Oh, it's a series. That's a little punny. that that that I suppose works. Even though worm span and fins span aren't aren't really terms that are used in the common nomenclature, but I don't like worms span at all. I don't want to play worms span again. I want to play with the birds. I want to play with the fish. Either give me the ability to do so with ducks or sea ducks, which are just all fish. I think pretty sure that's biologically accurate, right? fish just turned into like birds with like like little blobs with feathers and they like floated up.

Like one was hatched like came out of the egg really fuzzy. Couldn't sink anymore. Hatched. Had to figure out how to breathe air. That's what they're doing. They're besides the point. Besid I I know a lot about ducks. Besides the point. I really don't need to own any of these three titles. And maybe maybe if it was only these three I could justify it. But this is a feature that dominates my entire experience. And again, it's not necessarily bad. I like the collecting side of the hobby. I enjoyed pursuing all of Kingdom Death. I like backing a project all in and getting all the little goodies, even though I don't need more stuffed animals inspired off of board game characters that I have yet to even experience in the game. Looking at you, Awaken Realms or Flamecraft or Doomlings.

[sighs]

So, how do you all reconcile this? Where do you draw the line between the versions of you that are experiencing uh this hobby? You RPG players, how do you decide when the dice goblin stops needing more dice? I know, sacrilegious, the answer is never. They're always going to need more dice. Fill your house with dice until it's all you can eat, breathe, and think about. Stuff them off your nostrils and do your best to survive. That's just part of the adventurer's experience. But for us board gamers that aren't dice goblins, cuz that's a justifiable pursuit. The good lord made dice for a reason. And if the reason wasn't so that I could fit as many into my mouth, why did he make them so tasty?

For us board gamers, how do you decide when to go allin and when to not go allin? when to keep a game that you're never going to play just because it looks pretty on the shelf next to the other titles that you do actually truly love. I'm keeping Great Western Trail. Should I keep the version that I don't want to play? I'm keeping Wingspan and I'm keeping Finsspan. I'll get the expansions for them as they continue to come out cuz I'm an all or nothing. I'm a collector. Should I have Worms Band and leave it sitting there just looking pretty but being bad? And uh I'm going to have all of the Final Girl seasons and it if Crumpus fit into a standalone box like the core box like the rest of them wouldn't even be a debate. I'm not making a weird awkward hole in my uh display shelf of Final Girl, but it doesn't. It's a floater.

It's on its own. It's a one time off limited release random into the ether. It's a if you're celebrating Christmas, here's a fun way to do it. I don't even know why I bought it in the first place. I knew I didn't want it, but now I don't want to get rid of it. So, help me figure out. How do you decide? Where do you draw the line? Or do you just suffer along with me? If so, I'm going to be probably starting a therapy group where we meet once a month and shove as many dice into our mouth as possible so that we stop talking long enough to really examine the nature of our hobby, reflect on the internal monologues that fight between the gamer and the collector. And potentially by the time we either choke or spit out those dice for goblins to scurry around, collect and quickly sanitize, maybe by that point, we'll have an answer to our problem.

Until then, thank you for watching. Thank you for being here. I am uh getting the car packed up, hitting the road here soon. We will be back to filming gameplay content in the studio, hopefully with friends very soon. Been learning some solo games. I've got some new prototypes that have just come in. I am exceedingly excited to bring you all some content and I'm having fun with it, which is good cuz it's the whole point. Whatever the case though, whatever you do, remember to do the important thing. Get out and play some games and we'll see you next time. Bye-bye. Not as smooth of a transition as I wanted. I thought this would be really cool in my mind and then I realized I'd already said goodbye by the time that I was closing the trunk.

Progress saved