Skip to main content
Loading video...

5 Culled Board Games - Mystic Vale, Pagoda, Hashi, Kuh Nah, Stampede Reviews

Transcript 15:11

Hey everybody, today I am taking a look at five board games that weren't quite strong enough to stay in my collection. So for one reason or another, these didn't quite make the cut. Now before I start my reviews on these five games, I want to give a shout-out to the show's sponsor, keyenda.co.uk, who are my go-to online retailer. And if you use the link in the show notes or the QR code, then you can get 5% off your first order. Okay, so let's start with Pagoda. This is a two-player only game, takes 30 to 45 minutes to play. And the objective of this game, believe it or not, is to build pagodas, but you are building pagodas communally with your opponent. So you're both contributing to the same towers. Now this is a card-driven game with a pretty neat hand management system because five out of your seven available cards are actually visible to your opponent. So you have quite a good idea about what your opponent is capable of and vice versa.

Now what you'll be doing is that you'll be playing these cards to build these different pillars. Depending on the level of the pillar, you're going to get more points. So if you're building on the fourth level, that's going to be four points each pillar you build. And each time you mandatorily have to build at least one pillar, but you can build up to three should you wish to. And to be honest, this game is all about trying to avoid creating easy opportunities for your opponents to capitalize on. And because if you see here, after you build one of these levels of columns, you will place one of these pagodas floor on, which will determine the next level's color of pillars that you need. And of course, if you see that your opponent's got say, you know, four blue cards in their display, then you might not want to play a blue one because they can easily smash those down quickly and get a bunch of points without much effort. So again, it's all about trying to obstruct your opponent and just try and make it easy for yourself. Now there are a few additional wrinkles to this game where once you build one of these pagoda levels, you'll unlock a particular power. Now these powers are fairly They're fairly subtle. Like for example, they might increase your hidden hand limit.

They might do things such as give you the the ability to convert two cards into another card, so you got a bit of flexibility there. Those kind of things. And to be honest, I thought they were a little bit too reined in. I think they could have been a bit stronger, but I can see what they're going for here. And all in all, this game has a nice flow to it. It has some good table presence as you're building up these columns. Um but I found it a bit a bit too tactical for my liking. You're always kind of reacting to the cards you had in your hand. Um of course, you were pretty pigeonholed into what you could do. Um and you know, you are definitely subject to what you have and what you draw. So it's a little bit too luck-dependent, maybe trying to um make you feel a different way about the game. So it's actually, yeah, very reactive and you can't really do too many strategic decisions um because you are of course subject to the draw of the cards. But it's not a bad one, but I feel like once you play this one once or twice, you've seen everything the game has to offer.

I don't feel like there are those um layers to the game or different things to discover. Um I'm sure some people would disagree with me on that, but I think apart from again, blocking your opponent and setting yourself up, there's not really much else to explore here. So not a bad one, but certainly not a great one. I'd give this one probably a 5 and 1/2 out of 10. Okay, so let's move on to Stampede, which is a small box set collection card game. Two to six players, takes around 20 minutes to play. I don't actually have a whole lot to say about this one because I'm sure you guys have played a lot of games of this nature where all you're doing is you are drawing a card, playing a card, and then using that card's ability. Now these cards' abilities are things we've seen before in tons of different games. It's swapping your cards with somebody else's either in their hand or in their display.

Swapping cards in and out of a of a common display as well. And that's pretty much it. What you're trying to do here is you are trying to get, I believe it's nine different animal types or you're trying to get your five of the same animal. So two different win conditions there. And as you can imagine, as people are drawing into a close of the game, people are going to start targeting them, start messing around with their scoring and slowing them down. So at the same time, you want to have maybe a trick or two in your back pocket, maybe make someone feel like you're going for a certain win condition when in reality you're, you know, you're um misdirecting them and going for something else. Um I I don't mind the game. It's fine. It's pretty take that-ish at times. Um I just feel pretty numb on it, to be honest. And um when I played this game, I thought there's other alternatives out there that I'd rather lean towards with similar scoring conditions, but I think cleverer decisions. And uh the game that I think most this one compares to is a game called Cubirds. I think Cubirds is a bit more a bit more polished and a bit more interesting and doesn't have those wild and not very fun abilities, if I'm honest. So this one is a a straight-up pass for me. Probably give it about a four out of 10. That is Stampede.

So let's move on to Hashi. This is a one to four player game, takes 20 minutes or so to play. Now this is a flip and write style game with a certain difference to it because I can't really think of any other flip and write games that compares to this one. Now what you're doing is you are essentially drawing cards and these cards will show you what you can do. So this one for example says you have to write a two on one island and you can draw two bridges. Now when you are writing these numbers on these islands, that shows how many bridges you can have coming from that particular island. You know, no more, no less. And when it's got once it's got that perfect amount, then you can you can circle it and score it. And that'll be locked in for the rest of the game. And as you can imagine, as the the game progresses, your options are going to quickly run out because you cannot actually cross through other bridges. Now if I'm going this way, I can no longer build a a bridge that goes this way. So again, your options are quickly running out. You are going to be trying to get all of your islands with the red flags covered, all the dark flags covered, six I believe continuous islands completed. And you're also going to get two points for every island you've got completed as well.

So it's a pretty snappy game. It's a little bit esoteric, I think, for my liking. It doesn't really flow as nicely as a lot of the other more simple flip and write style games. Not saying this one is terribly complicated. It just doesn't quite gel, I think, initially when you start explaining it to people because it does feel that much different and it feels like you're kind of cramming a a square peg in a round hole, really. But it's nice as you progress through the game, you can kind of deduce what's going to come out, so you can work your things out and so on. And you know, all in all, it's it's a game that's interesting. I I certainly find it different and I always appreciate games that feel different. And but all in all, it's not really a game I felt like I needed to come back to and explore any more once I'd understood the mechanisms and understood how the games work. So longevity-wise, I'm not sure this one has it, but I definitely give it a pat on the back for being creative and trying something a bit different. So probably give it sort of a 5 and 1/2 out of 10, maybe a six on a good day. That is Hashi.

Penultimately, let's talk about a game called Kūna. This is a two to six player game that takes around 20 minutes to play on average. Now it's quite difficult to avoid talking about Kūna without directly comparing it to another game called No Thanks. And that's because it shares a very distinct mechanism with that game where each round a card will come up for grabs. You can either take that card and add it to your scoring tableau or you can place a token on it to avoid taking it and then it will move on to the next player. Now much like No Thanks, you are trying to score as low as possible because every point you get is bad in this game. But instead of like No Thanks, where each card is worth what it's worth at face value, this one you are building this pyramid structure where essentially only the the blocks on top are going to score. So you can use this mechanism where if you place higher value blocks below lower value blocks, only the lower value blocks score. So again, you want to keep covering up those higher valued cards.

Now I actually like the premise of this game. I think it sounds really cool, but in practice, it completely kills the tension of the game because you're not really that fearful of taking cards in this one because you know you can just cover them up later. And that's especially relevant when you play through the first half or the first three quarters of the game. You just know you've got enough time to keep taking cards and cover up your, you know, your your higher valued cards. So I definitely think that kind of cuts the legs out from its own from its own game, really. Now there are a few different rules that you can you can utilize. Like for example, you know, normally you'd have to place lower value blocks on top of higher value blocks, but if you match the symbols, you can break that rule, which you can use to your advantage. But all in all, I thought tension was not there.

I thought the just fell flat as well because I never really really found myself kind of, you know, spending them or needing that kind of cash flow because I always had stuff in my supply because I was never scared to take cards. And all in all, I think this game really does struggle to find its its own place in the in the marketplace because it is so similar to another game that is miles better than this one. So again, if this one's on your radar, I know it's not really a popular game, but just stick to the original No Thanks. It's better in every single regard. I really cannot see um what the designs were going for here. And maybe I'm missing something, but I'd easily always lean towards "No, thanks" rather than this one. So, I'd probably give this one about a four out of 10. Okay, so let's move on to the final game today, and this is Mystic Vale. Uh this one is a deck-building style game that takes around 45 minutes to play.

Um if I understand correctly, the game yeah accommodates two to four players. Now, generally speaking, I'm not the biggest fan of deck builders because I find them all very similar. Um and I find all the kind of shoveling and cycling through the decks a little bit tedious, to be honest. Um but, when I heard of the concept of Mystic Vale, where you have a very small deck of cards, and instead of acquiring new cards, you are buffing those cards as you go, and it has these very cool component choices, where you have these sleeves, and in order in the way you actually um improve your cards is by sliding these other kind of uh acetate sleeves in there, and getting new abilities as you go. Um as you'd expect with most deck builders, you have a a currency value, you'll spend that currency to buy better cards from the market, and um improving your your hand that way. Now, the game does have a slight push-your-luck mechanism, where at the start of your turn, um you are going to be revealing these kind of little burnt tree symbols, and you can keep flipping cards until you have four of those, and potentially go bust. And if you go bust, you are you're missing your turn, essentially. So, you know, if there's a particular card you want from the market, but you're one short, you might want to push your luck and try to reveal more of them, which I thought was quite a cool concept. Um especially considering the the synergized mechanisms in the game that can let you mitigate that by buff boosting cards, and again, canceling out those negative uh symbols.

Generally speaking, you will be collecting these little uh icons on here that will let you buy these location cards that will give you uh the ongoing benefits or end game scoring. And and the actual cards themselves will give you things such as passive points each turn, get more of these icons, um little special rule-breaking rules, stuff like that. Um and, you know, I really wanted to like this game because I thought the concept was so neat, but I was slightly concerned that this was just going to be uh another deck-building game, but maybe slightly repackaged in how it was presented to the user. Um it's kind of like a misleading way of, you know, this is another deck builder, but we've just kind of spiced up in a different way. Well, mechanically, it's the same, but it's just presented differently. And my impressions are that is the case, sadly.

I think that it just felt like a another one of those the deck-building games, but again, with that slight gimmick, I'd even call it, of of those um transparent cards that you're boosting as you go. Now, it is quite cool how you can either really kind of pimp up your certain cards, and give them several abilities, or do you want to spread those abilities thinner amongst all the cards in your deck, so you're constantly getting good things out? Um that's quite cool, um but all in all, I did you know, but last thing impression was that it did feel feel slightly um generic, and I felt like I'd seen everything here before, but again, repackaged in a different uh way. Now, um I thought the game also had a slight issue of ending before it even began.

Now, I normally don't mind that, but in this game, I thought that there weren't enough points in the supply before the game was brought to an end. Um especially if someone gets off to a good start, and gets a certain card that can generate them passive points as you go, um because again, there are it has that kind of portal ecosystem, where depending on the player count, there'll be X amount of points in the supply, and once those points have been gobbled up, then it's going to bring the end of the game. Um and that definitely can catch catch other players off guard, which is which is fine, but I would have liked it to run its course a little uh bit longer. So, yeah, all in all, I mean, it's a it's a good game, it's a well-polished game, and if I played this, say, I don't know, six to 10 years ago, I would would have thought this game was amazing. But because I played so many different deck builders now that, you know, despite having different artwork and different concepts, the mech- mechanically, they're generally in the same ballpark, and you know, I don't feel this one mm stood out from those, you know, sea of other deck-building games, uh despite the way it is presented. But yeah, again, I liked it, it's a decent game, I'd give it a six out of 10, but it's not going to stick around um for those reasons. But Mystic Vale, I'm sure um you know, there's a lot of you guys out there who really do appreciate this game, and I even I'm quietly optimistic about having expansion content making it a lot better. Um but as it stands, as a core box here, it's not really something that's grabbed my attention, despite me appreciating what it does. So, that is Mystic Vale, um again,

a near miss for me, um but really didn't kind of um it didn't grab my attention the way I wanted it to. So, there we have it, that's five games here that didn't quite make the grade. Um obviously, let me know your thoughts if you feel differently to me about these games, um but yeah, didn't quite do it for me. And hopefully, you've enjoyed the video. If you have, please be sure to hit like and subscribe to the channel, and check out my other content, too. But for everybody else, I'll see you next time on Chairman of the Board. Bye-bye.

Progress saved