Skip to main content
Loading video...

5 More First Impressions - Chu Han, Salton Sea, King of Monster Island and more

Transcript 14:28

when I didn't play the game enough but I still want to talk about it maybe it just had too much stuff or it wasn't quite the right F that's what first impressions are for to qualify our opinions and so today I have five more hey I'm Alex back from board Gameco and we have another five first impressions for you this is the second in our first impression series of videos and basically First Impressions uh these videos happen when either I only played the game one time or I still feel I haven't seen enough of the game to call it a review I think for today's video I think all of these are onetime plays Sal and C in particular is a tricky one we we'll we'll get we'll get to all of these we'll get to all of these let's go ahead and start off and I don't know if we're going to talk about these in order of ranking or not but let's go ahead and start off with Chuan let's do box size we're going to do an order of box size over here a Chuan over here from outo this is a two-player trick tick game designed by Tom Leman a Creator race for the Galaxy and other games and that had me very excited for this two-player trick taking game designed by him because he's pretty good at games and I figured hey two player trick I'm here for it this might be a game that needs more plays that might be the issue here I did not appreciate it at all after game one unfortunately uh for me my initial rating and keep in mind these are all First Impressions ratings uh when I have a first impression when I'm I'm diving into a game based off of a single play I would say around 10% of the time my rating does change after multiple plays especially as you see more or possibly a game that's a little more static so I will rate these games but they are all ratings you take with a further grain of salt than the usual

different people have different opinions kind of rating but to that end Chuan over here I'd give this a 2.5 out of five I didn't like Chuan and I'll tell you why uh I didn't feel okay first of all it's not a trick taking game it's a shedding game that's not a problem I like shedding games shedding is a sub I think shedding is a sub genre of trick taking not entirely sure generally goes hand in hand but either way this is a shedding game specifically in terms of where you're going to have a random hand of cards you're dealing up those cards to each other and then you're going to go ahead and try to win the tricks or win the shedding of the cards while utilizing abilities there going to be a whole bunch of abilities going to be some great art there going to be abilities on the various cards and specific suits will have specific numbers not suits will have abilities in them you're trying to figure out how to uh balance that now the thing the game has that I really did like it has this element where you can basically take a card to draw two cards that taking a card sounds weird take a token let's say to draw two cards and that token basically counts against your score if you lose so it's a little bit of a gamble you're giving the other Player points if you don't win but you can draw more cards possibly giving you you know a larger hand of of sixes or in particular this game you want to play a bunch of twos as well that could be a scoring points because of well specific rules in the game now the game also comes with a campaign or scenario mode not really campaign a scenario mode where gives you specific things you're trying to do uh but overall I would say I just didn't feel that I had any large sense of control over what's happening where many tring tricking games or shedding games I do and I think that the abilities were a little bit convoluted and too many of them to really be a game that I think is going to reward people who aren't playing it a lot now I do think there's almost certainly a high degree of strategy in there if you play it a lot if you learn the game if you

play with people who play it a lot I'm sure that can it can grow I would say that for me if a game requires multiple plays to appreciate it in the first place that's usually not a game for me I want to be able to appreciate it on game one and appreciate it more on game two if after game one the only thing I think is well that wasn't fun I'm not diving into game two that's the first problem you have with board games so for me unfortunately Chuan was looking forward to it not a game for me May well be a game that shows promise over time can 100% see that I'm not going to get to that point unfortunately so a 2.5 out of five with large caveat I think this will get better over multiple plays from there from there we're going to go into let's go into uh like I said box size let's do box size salt and SE over here almost certainly the best game on the table uh we're diving this is this is the best game on the table uh the reason this is getting a first impressions is because I've been trying to wait to get a second play in of this one and it just hasn't happened yet and uh I don't know exactly when it will he allten SE fun games I tabled it when it first came in and I thought it was really good but also really long for what it's doing so and that's the tricky part because if I'm rating this on the gameplay alone I'm instinctively I'd want to give it a four I am bumping it down to a 3.5 out of five because I think the complexity of the length of the teach and the length of the game and the fact that I think it really is a game that plays best at two because of that I think like this is not a game I'd want to play at more players I don't think you get enough extra out of the experience I think it would just take longer so for me I think I am d my rating down to a 3.5 of five because the more time has gone on The more I've realized I only want to play this as a two-player Euro game that's all I want to do it does uh it's a fascinating game really well done

the actual Mechanics Work incredibly well you're going to be basically trying to I mean suany has got a location aspect but you're going to be trying to rise up on these three tracks you're be trying to go further and further down into these mines over here be gathering mine cards and then delving into them and the main thing that makes the game compelling is all your cash in the game are also ability cards so whenever you have ability cards or cash they're kind of interchangeable in the way that you you spend these things but also when you spend it you're going to get some of the stuff back as well so there's an interesting puzzle of trying to figure out the tempo of when you need an ability when you need to spend money how you're managing that pace and flow of the game Gathering new cards buying new cards can really improve your engine but then again you are trying to use that money towards that as opposed to the seven other things you could be doing it is an incredibly tight game if you like tight experiences this is going to give you a tight experience I think it has a lot to offer for me the bigger problem I have is what does the game time say game time says 120 minutes I think you can probably get it down 2 120 Minutes at two players and after multiple plays this is a longer experience that's a little hard table I think it's a really well done game uh overall as far as everything going on as far as the unique aspects of P to the table again initial Instinct would have been a four but over time I think I mentally put it a 3.5 because of the barriers to entry which we're actually going to talk about in our next game over here because biob bash over here is another game that's getting dinged on barriers to entry rating wise on this alone would be a three out of five uh this instead I'm going down to a 2.5 because I think the complexity to gameplay reward is not not well done c b bash over here is from a weird games and this is a racing game that honestly is like a hair's breath

away from basically being Thunder Road vendela like well maybe the hair's breath is a bit too uh bit too bit too close it has a lot of gameplay elements that are similar to thunder Ro Vendetta if you enjoy Thunder Ro Vendetta b bash is a lot of that stuff it's going to have your little map over here it's got the same type of arcing spots over there you be moving spot to spot it also has a scatter die so again if you haven't played Thunder vetta some of this won't make sense to you but if it has a scatter die andever you have a reason to get scattered you're going to roll your scatter die and move in different locations so that unpredictability is is captured in the same way you can be able to race into people hit different zones try to ultimately win the race attract and gather fans the main thing and the reason Thunder Vendetta is so much in my mind when I talk about this game is I think Thunder Vendetta did an excellent job at giving you a lot of game with a very very very simple easy to read and easy to teach game I mean easy to read rule book and easy to teach game and the amount of gameplay they give you in Thunder data for that depth whatever is great and I think that happens to be one of the best I guess uh ratios as far as the the level of game experience versus the level of rulebook and things that get in the way I think Thunder that has one of the best ratios of any game I've played in that genre for that but most racing games shouldn't be overly complicated whether you're playing a death Road Allstars or tiny turbo cars or any of them they usually aren't super complicated games they don't have to be biob bash I think that the target like to me this feels lighter than most of the racing games I play and the rules felt more complicated and overwrought than most of the racing games I've played and so to me a gameplay alone would be a three out of five it's fun it's good doesn't stand out it's okay but when you throw one of the harder two

one of the more Works involved to get to that point this does drop to a 2.5 out of five I think there are better racing games out there and they will take less time effort and energy to play that's going to be biob Bash from there we're going to move to willam's Warehouse over here willam's Warehouse is a quirky one a quirky one from CMYK games uh they obviously brought monikers as well as wavelength they've had very popular games that have been very targeted at Mass Market but nothing wrong with mass Market you just have there's an overlap I think there's games that are mass market and they're not great games I think there are designer games and there's also not great designer games but there's often an overlap where you can find that game that hits the market and does well for both audiences games like monikers wavelengths codeen names of we're bacon away from CMYK there's a lots of games out there that have done a really good job balancing both Wilm Mar's Warehouse is quirky I think it's a little too much for it to capture some of the success they've had with their other games but I still think it's a cute game and worth checking out although for me my rating on this is a out of five and we'll talk about why so over here W Warehouse basically has you Gathering cards and place them into a warehouse so all these cards have just generic symbols on them and you're placing them into the warehouse in order to go ahead and create stories so for right now they actually have this example going on in the back we have the lock okay this is a lock do we place it over here because it protects the half eaten cookie from eaten by a slug or do we place it under the moon wait wait how do do this we place it I don't even know how they're doing this the under the moon we're enjoying whipped cream or on or a mug of hot cocoa oh okay gotcha you put down over here and that has uh the has the whipped cream is being protected from the hot cocoa or whatever it is you

basically create these narratives as you go so you see a random shape you put it into the grid and you tell each other a story that's what happens so like we have all these little shapes over here so I got this little thing I'm like oh let's put the man walking in the center of the grid cuz that's your first tile over there and that's because you can walk in all directions and then I gather this tile over here I'm like sushi great let's go ahead and put it next to the man walking to the right because I'm a righty I eat with my right hand so when I walk to the right I'm going to pick up a piece of sushi and then I go ahead and gather this I'm like sprinkles we're going to put that on top of sushi cuz sprinkles go on top of everything so you have food on top of food sprinkles on top of sushi you agree with the other players to create stories as you go it made more sense when I did it myself as opposed to when I was trying to read their stuff not that there don't make sense but everyone's going to have their own little weird ways the mind works that's round one then you go to round two where you do the same thing continuing to lay out the grid now whenever you do these you're putting them face down so you place down a token and you create a story and then as you do this you're creating a a memory game effectively and round two you have a new rule maybe the rule is that the person looking at the card can only say one word maybe the rule is you only have 2 minutes for the entire round of seven cards that you place out but across the course of the game you're placing up 35 Cards into the grid five days uh seven cards per day and they're all face down and then you go through a five minute time around when you start grabbing customers because a whole stack of matching cards which are the customers that they're looking for the lock or for the sprinkles or for the sushi or whatever you call these things and they have to find these things turning over and matching you don't you don't even turn over you just literally put the card face down on the spot and then you stop the time when you're done and you see how well you did and score accordingly so it's a memory game that's based on creating stories of how objects interact with each other working

together at the table in this Cooperative game that's going to be a little zany a little crazy a little quirky and it's also upside down so for me this is a three out of five I enjoyed my game of this but I don't think it's a game that I want to dive into again uh I just don't think that that kind of sheer memory experience with rules variances I'm not a huge memory game person only a few in my collection and they are very very specific as to why I like them willm mat Warehouse does do a good job of giving the players the a creative Journey that they're going on along the way I am skeptical that I would be that Innovative consistently with this game and I don't think the gameplay experience is to me it's more of a an interesting quirky experience that I've enjoyed tabling but would never ask the table again so uh that's where we are with with let toare house I enjoyed it and I'm not interested enough to pull it out again for there we have king of Monster Island uh the second favorite game at the table cuz I I I really like salt and sea and I really like king of Monster Island but I don't know if I like either of them enough for me to keep them king of on Ireland from Rich Garfield is going to be the newest game in the uh King of Tokyo Universe there was King of Tokyo there was King of New York there was King of Tokyo after dark or was that I don't know if after dark whatever it was the uh White and the yellow and black box they have all these different King of Tokyo versions they have King of Tokyo duel now as well that's the newest version so this is actually not the newest this is the second newest cuz King of Tokyo duel is the newest one I've not played King of toy duel I've played the others and king of Monster Island is a Cooperative version of that game using the same dice rolling yatsi Style game gameplay uh but against a common foe the beer Monster Who's rising out of the Volcano Island you have to take them all down because he's making it worse for all the other good monsters out there uh the actual

gameplay is basically going to have you have this giant island in the center you can to be rolling dice in Center grid where they fall will determine the uh actions of the evil boss you're fighting against awanas from Zone to zone triggering different dice over here trigging different of his dice over here generating more monsters that'll get in your way all while you try to stop him from building his beacons and taking over the world uh ultimately your Gathering powers and abilities just like you did in regular King of Tokyo you're rolling dice multiple times to get the right combination of results just like you did in regular King of Tokyo but this time you're doing so against a common monster but you also have your your ally card that you're getting the Ally card is AR arguably one of the most fun parts of the game because it gives your your monster which weirdly enough the monsters have no asymmetry but as you gather an ally card you get asymmetry so I wish they had asymmetry on both so you can mix and match either way as it is is still fine you get these these Ally cards that as you gain power you get consistently more powerful in the game throughout the course of the game and it's overall a fun enough experience uh where I struggle with this one is for me this is one where like I played this with my kids and my kids have various Rangers ranges and I think that it's a little more complicated that I had to run things a little bit more than I wanted to for playing with my kids but I also think that it's too light for playing it with my uh you know with my regular game group so I think this falls into a very specific Gateway audience or you know older kids range as far as what the target audiences for me I've enjoyed it I like it I just don't see the place where I'm going to pull it out and play it more it's a little a little too chaotic in life for my game group and a little too much for my kids I think King of Tokyo is actually a little bit more straightforward for kids I've played King of Tokyo with my kids and they've done just fine this one adds a little bit more as far as the

understanding what's going on overall I think it's still a good addition to the series and I think I'd still recommend getting King of Tokyo first and if you're just a huge King of Tokyo fan and you want more in the universe by all means king up pick up King of Monster Island personally King of New York I don't really recommend it all I think it's just worse than King of Tokyo King of Tokyo after dark same situation and King of Tokyo duel haven't played at all and that's you have it over here those are your five First Impressions reviews five games that I've played once and probably will not be playing again unless I happen to for some reason like I mean again saltan C I'd play this with my person someone who knew the game I'd happily play salt and C king of Monster Island I'd happily play again uh will Met's Warehouse pull me over at a con and go ahead let's make some stories together these two I think I'd actively turn down anyways until next time I'm Alex rff from board game Co I hope you found this video helpful and as always I hope you have a good one

Progress saved