Impressions - Beyond the Sun, Castles of Tuscany, Lost Ruins of Arnak, Whistle Mountain, & Vikings
Transcript
welcome to the jungkook's games impressions vlog where today i will be discussing five games that i've been playing recently now i will be going over them in alphabetical order and i do want to mention that if you'd prefer to listen to this vlog instead of watch it then you could do so by searching for the john gets games podcast wherever you normally listen to podcasts i'd also like to ask that if you end up enjoying this video that you please click the like button for it down below as well as the subscribe button for the channel in addition to that if you'd like to directly support this channel in the creation of future vlogs like this one then please go to jungusgames.com support there you'll find a bunch of ways that you can really help things out and some of them come with nice bonuses like voting on a few of the videos that i film each month alright let's now start discussing these games and the first of them is beyond the sun now before i say anything else i want to be totally upfront about the fact that i was paid to make a sponsored tutorial video for this game from the publisher now no part of that payment had anything to do with my subjective opinion that was just making a tutorial video and now in this vlog i'm going to give you my opinion which they did not pay for but of course you might think that i'm biased because of my professional relationship with the publisher now i have been able to play this game four times over the last two weeks and all of these plays happened with a private tabletop simulator mod so it is not currently publicly available but i have been able to play this with my friends now um just the fact that i've played this game four times over the last two weeks should probably give you a little bit of a spoiler as to my feelings and i'm just going to start this off by saying that i've been super impressed with this game and the reason i keep playing it is because i am curious to keep playing it now i'm
going to try to give you my opinion while i actually discuss how the game mechanically works and let's start with a very brief overview of the game now what you do in this game is you have a single worker pawn and on your turn you move it to an open work replacement spot in a communal board so it's kind of a worker movement game you just move this around to a new spot and you do whatever that spot says and the main thing that you're doing in this game or one of the main things is you're developing a technology tree at the start of the game everybody just has a basic space flight and as you take actions that let you develop new technology you're going to essentially follow these lines out on the board to then place new text down which will increase the variety of different actions available to the people who have developed that technology and you can then go from level two technologies to three and three to four and it has this great prerequisite mechanic where if you are doing uh if the prerequisite for a new technology is military then the new technology has to be a military type so you're not going to go from a military into like scientific or something like that uh unless you have a couple prerequisite options and again i'm not going to go into the specifics but um the short version of this is everybody is communally constructing a different tech tree every time you play the game uh when you develop these technologies you do have a decision to make between two different texts so it's not totally random and you are kind of sculpting this communal board now once one person develops a new technology then other people can follow up as long as they have the right prerequisites and um one of the main things you're doing in this game besides those technologies is you are creating spaceships and
moving them around on an exploration board to take control of different systems and then try to colonize those systems which means you claim them and you put them in front of yourself to get some points and some special effects now that's kind of the main arc of what you're doing in this game and the reason that i uh was initially quite interested in playing a full game of this is because as you play through the game the overall technology experience is going to grow you know the first half of the game involves just seeing some level two and maybe a level three technology or two but then once you get to the late stages of the game you will see many of these level three technologies and potentially level four technologies which are incredibly powerful and can give a lot of end-game victory points and seeing this mix of technologies in each game has been fascinating uh once i finished my very first game of this i was pretty high on it i really enjoyed it even though i did not come close to winning i think i came dead last um but i was i remember feeling really curious to see what a next game would be like and i asked my friends who played it with me it was a three player game what they thought one of them really enjoyed it and the other one enjoyed it but they were kind of concerned that maybe future plays would feel a bit samey now unfortunately i've not been able to play with that friend again but i can say now that i've personally played four different games i can say that even though i've seen many of the same technologies show up in multiple games the way they come out in the order in which they come out and the things that are before and after them on that technology tree really change the overall flow of the game in addition to that there are achievements which are essentially communal goals that people
are trying to get to and in fact claiming these achievements is the way the game ends and you deal out a couple random ones of those each game and those also drastically affect the game so in the first game that we played there was very little colonizing and we went crazy on the technology track and you get points for doing just about everything in this game including getting technologies and claiming the systems and colonizing them uh so in that first game we were like wow colonizing didn't really happen that much but in my second game there was a crazy amount of colonizing because three out of the four achievements had something to do with colonizing so obviously players were developing technologies that um helped us out with colonizing because that was an achievement we were going for and then in the third game that we played i personally tried to go crazy on technology i barely interacted with the exploration board i just um swarmed the technology board with as many of these technology advancements that i could get now my main goal in that game was to try and get multiple of the level four technologies but this is a somewhat tactical game and what ended up happening in that game in that third play is that the game ended with no ways to actually develop a level four technology now if i backtrack a little bit there are four levels of technology and at the start of the game um there are action spots to develop the level one and level two so at the beginning of the game there's no way to make three or four technologies but there are various events that will happen that i won't go into the specifics of that can unlock the ability to generate the level 3 techs and also level 2 technologies can give you the
ability to develop level 3s now in this one play even though i developed i think three of the level three technologies i never found one that let me develop a level four tech and even though in every game there is a possibility of a level uh for technology action becoming freed up on the main board which is details i'm not going to go into the way this game played out my opponents kind of had control as to whether that would happen and they could see that i was in a position to take multiple level four technologies so they didn't let that happen now there's ways that i could have tried to run up a different part of the research track to make that happen but you know in that play i ended up having to switch gears a little bit and use my massive amount of technologies to try and then go back to the exploration board and get a bunch of points that way and i came in a somewhat narrow second place i feel like if i could have developed a level 4 technology i might have been able to win that one but it's really hard to say because i was able to switch gears with my massive amount of powerful technology to do really strong stuff as well now as i said a little bit ago i'm going to talk a little bit about the tactics versus strategy in this game now this is a somewhat tactical game this is not the kind of experience where you can go into the game and say i'm going to specifically go really hard on x like in that game where i decided i was gonna go crazy on technologies i didn't start that game saying that i decided that because the first level two technology i got let me develop level three technologies so i was like okay i think you know i already have the ability to develop level 3 technologies so let's um press that button you know i have that button available to me i've already invested in it
and so that kind of guided me into going into a very technology-heavy game in other games when several colonizing options popped out and maybe lots of ways to build ships and move those ships around the exploration board in those games there was a lot more action on the exploration board because the game itself kind of dictated what good strategies were going to be available in that specific play now for some people who like to go into a euro style game saying uh this game i'm going to just do x from the very first turn uh you're likely going to be disappointed um now i've played this game with a variety of people a couple of which who have played it twice with me and one of those people um was pretty lukewarm on the game after the first play uh she uh after that first play i remember she said that she didn't really enjoy the play but she thought she liked the game and the reason for that is because she was really thinking about specifically going for a a one type of strategy in the beginning of the game and the options that became available didn't really lend towards that by the time they kind of figured out that was a problem they couldn't switch gears enough and they came very far last uh now on the subsequent play with that player we actually played with one of the advanced variants there are two advanced variants in the game and one of them is introducing some pretty significant asymmetry between all of the player boards that you can go with now these player boards do kind of give you a strategy that you're going to be going towards because they have an asymmetry that you can really lean into now i played the game again with um that one player and another friend who had played it already and we played with the asymmetric boards and uh that one player she destroyed us
like it was actually not destroyed it she she came in uh first place by a reasonable margin and um she really enjoyed that play much more because of using those advanced boards meant there was more of a strategy you could lean on from the very beginning versus having a strategy kind of emerge from the game state now my personal opinion after playing the game just once with those advanced boards is i don't actually think i'm that big a fan of them because of that reason i feel like the reason i really like beyond the sun is because it has an emergent strategic experience every time you play so i would rather play with the essentially symmetric boards the non-advanced variant because i want to see the options that the game is kind of guiding me towards and then make decisions from that the game isn't playing itself by any means but i would rather not find myself in a situation like i did in that game where it seemed like my uh asymmetrical ability of my board was saying do a and the situation i had out on the board was saying do be this was actually the game where i went heavy on the technologies and the situation on the board said go heavy on tech but my asymmetric ability was like you get discounts for colonizing and you know making ships and taking over control spots on the board so i kind of felt split and so i ended up not leaning into my asymmetry and i leaned into my board state advantage and um my friend who won they leaned into their asymmetric ability on their board which also happened to go along with some other situation decisions they made and they were able to win um so there are ways to play this game more strategically and i think that is specifically with those advanced boards
and i like that there's an option to go back and forth between those now there is another variant which is the technology market now when you play the game in the standard way every time you advance for a new technology you're going to draw two applicable texts from the deck and choose between those two and then that will be the technology so you always have a decision between two cards when you play with the advanced module where you have a technology market instead you have a set of face-up technology options on the table and those are going to show between one and potentially four different technologies that match the prerequisite for any tech that you advance now i've played the game with this once and i loved this variant uh honestly i don't think i'm ever going to play the game again without this variant because it did not really add much complexity at all um to a certain extent you could say oh you know there's all these technology cards you know staring at me that's just a lot more things to analyze but i found it wasn't that big of a problem and in that game one of the people who played in that three-player game had not played beyond the sun before and they they destroyed us i remember being destroyed once and it was just it was a stopping it was their first play it was the second play for both of the other players and uh man it was not even close but i just loved having all of those options face up from the uh beginning of the game so you have even more control when you go to develop a technology you can say i am developing this technology it's not even random a choice between two um you can still go random from the top if you want to but that never happened in our game because we just kept picking things from the market so i love that variant and i think if literally no one has played the game before it's probably not a good idea to
use that variant but if even one or two players have used that and anyone is interested i say that one's not particularly advanced it's just an alternate way to play that gives you a little bit more control and this at the end of the day is a euro game you know it's a worker movement game you are gathering resources and oh my gosh there's so many things i haven't even talked about just yet um which i'll try not to go into the specifics of but this is a euro game that has some input randomness quite a bit of it you have events that happen that will change the game state but usually doesn't uh throw the game in one player's direction or another you have technologies which you have control over but you know if you're not using that technology market um you're not sure exactly what you're going to get but you have a decision to make still and there are other ways that randomness can kind of peek in but it's a euro game there's a lot of decisions and there are a lot of deterministic things that you do have control over now there are like i said many other things i could say but there's one more mechanic that i would like to focus on and that is these resource cubes now at the start of the game you take what looks like a bunch of d6 dice you put them onto your player board but you essentially never roll them i say essentially because one event makes you roll them but um for all intents and purposes they are a token and so they it has six sides and as a part of the game you are essentially taking these things as resources which is a die face and you are i guess supplies and you turn those into population through various actions and then you can turn population uh by also using some space ore to make ships of various strengths and the strength number on the ships will
dictate um how strong you are for controlling these different systems so it's a really uh brilliant type of thing because then once the ships are over there on the systems and you colonize the system those ships turn back into supply and go back down onto your board so you have this wonderful kind of loop of these resources and based off of how you can grow out your infrastructure you can really find yourself in a tight situation if you are not really closing that loop so to speak or at least finding ways to better capitalize on the resources you have or you could be really slick and uh make that loop nice and fast and from one game to the next um you'll be able to do that really well sometimes and not others based off of the situation that you have so again i need to probably try to wrap this up i've talked about it a lot but at this point after playing four times with both of the advanced variants i can um i can honestly say this is one of my favorite games that i've played this year i've played it like i said four times one of those was a second play for all of us and it was impromptu we actually were playing a bunch of other games uh in a night and it was like 9 30 10 o'clock at night and three of us were left over and we're like do we just want to like slam out a game of beyond the sun we all know it let's just jump right into it and we did uh and that game took about 90 minutes and i will say that that particular play that was the one where i went heavy on tech for various reasons it took a while for the achievements to happen and if things had gone a different way i could easily see a three-player game of this taking you know a little bit over an hour um so the various situations that happened in the game is going to affect the overall timing but i really like this game i've only played it at three players so
far all four games have been three players i imagine the two player game would be great and i would not mind playing a four player game of this probably as long as most of the people were familiar with it i think analysis paralysis could certainly start to set in fortunately in this game it's very streamlined when it comes to resources you have ore you have uh population and that's essentially it so you are just spending these two things it's not like you're balancing a whole bunch of different resources for uh resource management but there's still quite a bit of things to talk to think about but down time hasn't been too bad and yeah that is beyond the sun i am looking forward to honestly many more plays of this as i continue to explore the different systems because it's just been a really fun emergent uh strategic experience every time i played sure there's tactics there but i really like the emergent strategies that the game presents itself especially when me personally when i don't use those asymmetric boards so that is beyond the sun okay let's now move on to the second game i'll be discussing and that is lost ruins of arnac now i was sent a physical press copy of this one from check games edition which i definitely appreciate and at the moment the main way that i'm playing board games is actually online with friends uh currently there is no publicly available mod for this so i spent six hours uh scanning and building my own private tabletop uh simulator mods that i can play this with friends now i was able to play this last night and i will uh spoil the impressions right now and by saying that uh everyone who played it quite liked it but let's now talk about the specifics of the mechanics a bit now this is a hybrid of many different types of games
you have some work replacement you have a decent amount of deck building and you also have quite a bit of resource acquisition and management while you're playing this game now thematically uh you have found a island in the middle of the ocean that has a bunch of uh lost temples and relics and various things on it and you are going to start exploring that island but in a competitive environment now every player has two archeologist workers and you will have them throughout the whole game and each game of uh lost ruins of arnac is going to take place over five rounds now when you send out your archaeologists they are going to go to an empty spot which means this is very worker placement-y when it comes to mechanics but whenever you send a archaeologist out you have to pay the travel cost for them to go out to a spot that spot might be a boot which means they walk there it might be a car or a boat which means they drove or you know i guess drove a boat to that spot and also they might show a plane which means you had to fly to that spot now the way you pay for this in general is you're going to pay a card from your hand now i said this is a deck building game and at the start of the game each player has the same identical deck of six cards you draw five of those into your hand at the start of each round and every card in the top left corner shows a travel icon which again could be a plane about a car or boots so that means if you want to use one of your two workers you send them out to a spot that's empty you also have to potentially pay a card from your hand so that means right away you have this interesting interplay between the work replacement elements of the game and the deck building elements because you have to decide
is the effect on this card better or worse than the worker placement spot that's because when you spend a card before the travel you don't get to do what's listed on the card as an action so um in the one game of this that i've played i can say that in one of the five rounds i actually didn't use either of my workers because the actions on my cards were stronger in my opinion than the potential things i was able to do with my workers now i did come in last so maybe that was a bad idea but those were the decisions that i made in the moment now fortunately there are also well i guess fortunately and not so good at the start of the game you begin with these fear cards in your deck a couple of them they're worth negative points at the end of the game and they don't have an action but they do show a boot so that means right at the beginning it does make sense to spend these fear cards to use the boot action to walk over to a spot and perform an action so that interplay sometimes is obvious spend it for your card to move but as you get deeper into the game you will likely get rid of those fear cards or potentially not draw them and then you have some real decisions to make now i did mention that this is a deck building game and at the start of the or at the top of the board there is a market of different cards now there are two different types of cards in the game you have artifacts and you have items and this game has a wonderful mechanic with splitting them up you have a deck of each of those and you also have this moon staff which hangs out kind of on the left side of the row on the one spot now that is to show that this is the first round of the game and you fill the artifacts in from one side and the items in from the other i'm probably getting this swapped on camera but what that means is in the first round of the game
there's only a single artifact showing but then there are i believe five of the items showing now thematically the idea there is that you just arrived and you have a bunch of items which are kind of like stuff that you brought with you and you've only just started exploring the island so there's not that many artifacts to choose from now when you go from the first round to the second round you move that staff over so now there is one less space for the items but there's one more space for the artifacts so as the game goes on and you proceed from round to round you're going to have the item market get smaller and the artifact market get bigger because again thematically you are using up your supplies and you have explored a lot more of the island so you have a lot more access to the different artifacts now there is a very important distinction between these two types beyond just buying them the artifacts cost compasses and the items cost coins but when you buy an item you put it to the bottom of your deck so that means unless you have a lot of card draw options it'll probably you'll probably draw in the next round of the game however when you buy the artifacts you immediately play them they go right into your play area you activate the ability that's listed on them so that means unlike most deck building games where you buy cards strictly for the future in this game one of the two different types of cards that you buy you immediately get to use so what that means is even though this game is only five rounds long there are many situations or at least that we saw in our first game where especially once we got to like the third fourth and fifth rounds we had enough resources to buy artifact cards to then put them in front of us immediately activate them which gave us the stuff that we needed to do something else that then gave us more resources to give us compasses that we can then use to buy another artifact to then use the ability and you can have
these crazy turns where again you start every round with just five cards in front of you but you might end up playing like 10 12 cards because of various card draw effects that you have and by buying these awesome artifacts that you find you get to use them immediately and then they go into your deck so you will hypothetically bump into them uh later on so that's a really cool interplay with the deck building now again i'm harping on the mechanics quite a bit right here but i'm trying to intersperse my opinion as well but the next big thing to talk about is the fact that um there are a lot of kind of closed doors in this game a lot of surprise actions and that's because as i mentioned you can send your archaeologist workers out but at the start of the game most of the work replacement spots are vacant you actually have to explore those locations by spending compasses now when you do that you actually spend the compasses and you send your worker out to a spot and then you draw a random location from a deck and you put it over there and that is the thing that you are going to perform so when you go exploring you don't know what you you're going to get odds are good it's going to be a variety of different resources but it could really be a very wide variety and on top of that so you go there and you spend the things and you explore it you get the random stuff there's also a guardian that shows up now this is a big monster type thing that is guarding that location and at the end of the round if you have not moved your archaeologist away from that location then that monster is going to terrify your archaeologist and you will gain a fear card which goes into your deck which again does not have an action on it and it loses you a point at the end of the game now fortunately you can spend the various
things that are listed on the guardian in order to defeat the guardian or i guess overcome them you don't technically fight them or at least you don't technically kill them you get their respect and they end up coming over to you they give you a one-shot bonus and they give you five points at the end of the game and then obviously that spot is cleared from the guardian but it's really important to note that you can always go to spots and activate their uh effects even if guardians are there they're kind of just passively around looming making you scared so you'll get the effects but if you don't deal with the guardian you get the negative one point which you know you certainly don't want so what that means is many of the actions in this game actually involve doing something that you don't know what's gonna happen you open the door and you're like oh cool i guess these are the resources that i get and i need to do this and then the other thing to fight off that uh guardian so this game really mixes a lot of pre-planning with also just kind of going with the flow tactics i say a lot of pre-planning because especially once you get into the mid to late game you're going to start the round with five cards in your hand and you start to plan things out you say okay do i want to do i want to use a work replacement spot yes okay well how am i going to do that am i going to spend a card it's worth noting there are also assistants that you can get which will give you resources and potentially movement and you can only spend two coins to essentially target a plane that lets you move anywhere so you don't have to spend a card but it's just one of the many decisions that you have to make but that being said i found myself oftentimes kind of making a plan saying okay i'm gonna do this this and this but before i do you know thing two and thing three let's do thing one which opens a random door and gives me some random stuff because that will definitely affect um you know the rest of my turn
now i say random that's because the card is random but then it stays out there as a new worker placement spot for the rest of the game so the first person to go to a spot will effectively get random things but everyone else can then plan around those locations and try to go to them now the last main mechanic i want to mention is the fact that there is this temple track along the side of the board and you are going to be sending up a little magnifying glass as well as a notebook and thematically the magnifying glass is you doing some research and finding some things and the notebook is you actually writing those things down or logging them now as you move up you're just going to be spending resources and in fact these are actions that don't involve playing cards or using your worker at all so in this game with work replacement and deck building many actions involve just spending your resources same with fighting the guardians often times that has nothing to do with cards although sometimes it does so you have a wide variety of different actions that you were trying to do and all of these things give you points fighting guardians gives you points exploring new locations gives you idols which give you points and also one-shot bonuses and also potential other bonuses and going up that temple track is going to give you a bunch of different things while also giving you victory points now as i said you're going to play this game over the five rounds and i played a three-player game of this and i remember when we were about halfway through the second round of the game i i said man it seems like this is gonna be a quick game like only five rounds that's kind of crazy right it's a deck building game right normally in a deck building game you go through your deck many times you have tons of different turns but a big difference in this game versus other deck building games is when you play cards they go
into a face-up discard pile and if you ever run through your deck that's it you just ran out of your deck you don't shuffle things up and make a new deck you only shuffle things back in and put them to the bottom of any cards you had already at the end of each of the five rounds so that means there are certainly some specializing things you can do and there are also some pitfalls you can go into for instance i came in a very close last place in our game and in the fifth round of the game i actually wasted two card draw opportunities because i had no cards left on the top of my deck i over specialized in getting card draw but i also over specialized in thinning my deck out at the start of the game my deck had six cards in it when the game ended my deck was nine cards and in every single one of the five rounds of the game i decked myself i drew every single card from my deck in every round of the game which normally sounds great but again if you are getting bonuses that say draw a card and you have no cards to draw so you get nothing that doesn't feel good so that means i probably a took too many card drop bonuses or b got rid of too many cards from my deck or i guess c did not buy enough cards to actually fill my deck out to work so that was definitely a decision that i made that i kind of regret but at the end of the day after we finished playing this game none of us felt like it was too short in fact from a time perspective our three player game which was the first game for all of us took about 2 hours and 15 minutes it was not a quick game by any means but at no point did i feel down time even though people might have been crunching through a lot of things because there's a lot of resource management at one point one of my friends got out some notes and started writing down
what exactly they needed to get to the top of the pyramid the temple track because they wanted to make sure they didn't miss it by one resource and they were crunching through it for a couple minutes but i wasn't sitting there twiddling my thumbs i was just staring at my cards staring at my resources staring in my options because there are so many different things that you can do and i was just constantly figuring out what the right thing to do was and then when it was my turn i would try to act so it's not terribly quick at least from my first perspective i think a second game with the same three players would easily lop like 30 to 40 minutes off that but i don't really see this being shorter than 90 minutes for three players at least with the people in my group and the amount of analysis paralysis that we naturally lean into now i also want to comment about how it feels because again midway through that second round it seemed like it wasn't going to be long enough to really utilize your engine and utilize your cards but the fact that when you buy those artifacts they immediately activate means it's kind of like your deck is even bigger than you thought it was and we did so many things in the fourth and fifth rounds of the game that i absolutely felt satisfied with um having run my deck enough and having built enough from it and i felt satisfied with the um when the game ended it seemed like it was a good time for it to end overall so this game did a really neat idea of mashing together work replacement deck building resource management in a way that that just kind of fulfills all of these different things they mesh super well together and i can easily see people saying oh this game doesn't do anything new it's just got work replacement and deck building that's a little bit different than normal but from my one experience my one play and my discussion with my friends who played it alongside me
it seemed like mixing all these things together into a stew really worked like the sum of these parts was uh i guess greater than each individual one the sum of the hole was greater than each individual part because of the way they interacted uh the decisions of do i spend cards for their action or for the movement for the workers and also do i spend resources to send my workers out to explore new areas or do i spend those same compass resources to get new artifacts which give me special abilities but then don't actually unlock those things they're just so many wonderful things to think about really the only detractor that i can think of is the fact that analysis paralysis was very real as i said the downtime didn't feel particularly bad because i had so much analysis to do so when my opponents were taking long turns that was fine because i was still crunching through things but there are quite a few different resources and many opportunities for you to miscount and be one tablet shy of your awesome plan and that doesn't feel great there are ways to get around that by burning some points with your idols if you happen to have idols which i won't talk about but that's just one more thing to keep in mind that you're crunching so for players who um are prone to analysis paralysis this game is definitely going to um i guess aggravate that to a certain extent but at the same time even players who had a good bit of ap in this game really enjoyed it at the end because it just seemed like we were all doing so much thinking collectively uh trying to piece together how to do well with this overall puzzle so yeah first impressions of lost ruins or arnac are a big thumbs up uh everyone i talked to seemed actively interested in playing it again
uh one player felt a little bit of reservations like this might feel samey if we keep playing it over and over again they weren't sure if it would actually break out and feel different enough from one game to the next same person actually who had the same worry about beyond the sun that i mentioned earlier i haven't played the game again so i can't really comment on that but from my personal perspective i feel like the mix of different um uh archaeologist spots that come out along with the mix of the the way the cards come out to build out your deck is probably gonna make this game feel fresh for many games so i'm looking forward to playing this one more i'm curious to try it at two that would probably be fine um i would play it at four i think as long as most of the people had played it before but i'm not super convinced four is going to be the best player count again because of the analysis paralysis i think four would just strictly make it a longer game so three is likely going to be my favorite sweet spot and two would probably be fine but uh yeah that is my initial impressions of lost ruins of our knack all of us are actively interested in playing this one more well let's now move on to the third game which is the castles of tuscany now this is effectively a sequel game to the castles of burgundy which came out i think four to five years ago both of them were designed by stefan pheld now there are definitely some similarities between these two games but let's talk about the castles of tuscany first um i guess the first thing i'll say is that i purchased a copy of this one from amazon.de because i saw uh slicker drips did a video for it and i thought it looked cool so i paid for it to be shipped over from germany and then actually
scanned in all of the documents and made my own tabletop simulator mods that i could play this with my friends because i was quite interested to do so now mechanically in this game you are going to have three different kind of area tiles that you assemble in front of you to make a mass of different hexagonal colored tiles that are all next to each other now as you play through this game every turn is really simple you are going to choose one option from three the first option is you're going to draw two or maybe more cards if you have upgrades so that's your whole term you just draw cards your turn is over the next person goes the next option is you can draw a hex tile from a public market as long as you have a free space on your personal area to reserve those tiles so once again it's your turn you take a tile put it down into an empty space your turn is done the next person goes the third option that you can do on your turn is you can place a hex tile that you have in your reserve out onto a open spot in your overall territory that you assembled at the start of the game now in order to do this you have to play two cards from your hand that match the color of the tile that you are playing and i believe there are eight different color tiles in the game something like that now if you don't have two matching cards that's fine because you can spend two identical cards of any other color as if it was one card of the applicable type so you could spend two orange and a yellow in order to get the two yellow that you need to place a yellow hex out this also means you could spend four cards if you want to you can spend two orange and two red both as a wild for a yellow to then put a yellow hex out if you want to so the first two actions which are
drawing a hex and drawing cards essentially facilitate the third action where you spend cards to place a hex that you have taken now you put the hex that you placed out onto your board adjacent to a previously placed text and each of the different hexagon tile types has a different reward some of them will give you workers which you can use as a wild card for placing new hexes out others will give you marble which you can spend just to get another turn immediately which is great uh others will just give you cards which help you play out new hexes later on and uh still others give you upgrades which might do things like every time you draw cards you draw more cards or you have more spaces to store the hexes in front of you or perhaps every time you take workers you get more workers so that's kind of the game as you play and as you take the hexes from the market you're actually going to refill the market from your own personal supply of these three stacks as soon as the first player empties their first stack which is seven tiles i think which effectively means as soon as one player has taken a hack seven times there is a scoring now at that point in the middle of the the table there's a board that has a red and a green track on it so what you're going to do is you're going to take the amount of points you have on the green track and add those to the points you have on the red track each time you score and that happens after the first person finishes their first and then their second and then the third stack so three times throughout the game there will be scorings where you just get the points the green points that you already have added to your red so that means if you get green points in the first round before the first scoring then that one green point you've got will score three times so that one green point is actually worth three points at the end of the game versus if you get a green point
before the last scoring obviously that's only going to be worth one so this game is definitely about trying to do things quickly before the scorings but also trying to build for the future getting things like upgrades out as well as laying these tiles down in such a way to actually be able to access various things that you want one of the big ways that you get the green points is by fully filling in a contiguous type of tile color that's in your player area and again you make your player territory by putting these three overall tiles down so you can kind of decide if you want to have big areas or smaller areas and the bigger the area that you complete the more green points that you get so for instance in the one game that i played i was able to complete one of the size three areas which is as large as they come i did that before the first scoring that gave me six green points which mean it technically gave me 18 points because i was six times three through the three scorings so focusing on getting that size 3 area done early ended up paying off for me because i did win the game by a few points it wasn't a blowout by any means but i definitely did well in this game so as you're playing this game you're just trying to constantly balance what you're trying to do it has an interesting uh cycle to it in that at the start of the game you only have one storage space so that means when you take a tile you can't take another tile like technically you can take a tile if you have no storage space but you have to get rid of a tile that you had prior which means you're kind of erasing an entire turn that you took which seems bad so you're kind of blocked by that tile that you have so you take a tile and then you really want to play that tile before you take another tile but you might not have the cards that match up the color of the tile that you want
to play but you took that tile so maybe you try to maybe you should try to focus on taking tiles they have cards that actually back that up of course if you're in a situation where you don't have the cards to play the towel maybe you just spend your whole turn drawing cards and we ended up playing a four player game of this it took i don't know probably about 90 minutes overall something like that it wasn't terribly long and the actions were really quick in this game oftentimes it was just like i'm drawing cards my turn's done you're taking a hex your turn's done and just like the average turn amount was probably about 20 seconds and then occasionally someone would have a big turn especially later on in the game where they might place a tile out where they might have to spend a few different cars to place that tile out that gives them a bonus and then they can spend a marble to take another turn which lets them do a bit more of a combo return which might take a minute and a half or something like that before the play moves on so while the turns seem really tiny even in a four player game it seemed like it was your turn again quite quickly and the play went around the table many many times so when the dust settled as i said i did win this game and i found that i quite enjoyed the overall experience um another one of the four of us quite enjoyed it another person was a bit lukewarm and the fourth person wasn't pretty wasn't too hot on it and it really it seemed like the breakdown was people who prefer lots of strategy in their games versus people who enjoy a decent amount of tactics uh this game does not have a lot of strategy you are randomly drawing tile uh cards from the top of the deck so you can't really you know base a strategy around that but
there is some strategy with the order in which you place these hex tiles down but maybe you really want a specific type of hex and it's just not showing up in the market well now you have to change up your strategy a little bit to find something else that you can do i quite enjoy a hefty dose of tactics in my games um versus you know just going with a strategy that's never going to be blocked and hopefully my strategy is better than your strategy there's a there's enough randomness in this game to make trying to be like bull headed with your strategy a very bad idea and honestly it'll just make you probably not have that much fun with the game now everyone who played this game has played castles of burgundy before and i think to a certain extent that's almost going to be the biggest issue with castles of tuscany for players is that if they really like castles of burgundy they're going to compare the two and the castles of tuscany is a much lighter game overall it has a lot less rules it's also a lot quicker to teach which is nice but it's also arguably more random it's arguably much more tactical and i feel like people who adore castles of burgundy are going to on average be disappointed with the castles of tuscany which is a little interesting because i think a big selling point of this game is oh my gosh there's a sequel to castles of burgundy everybody run out and get it uh if you liked burgundy and so it's a bit odd like i feel like if this game was any other theme if it wasn't called the castles of tuscany if it was just called tuscany or you know tuscan hills or something like that um by the same uh uh designer people might say oh well you could see a bit of castles of burgundy in there but it's its own thing but having it specifically called the
castles of tuscany i think makes people draw too many comparisons because it really is a lighter more streamlined significantly more tactical game and i personally think i fall more towards the tuscany side than the burgundy side i've played castles of burgundy several times i used to own it i gave it to a close friend of mine so it's still within my overall gaming group but i haven't played it in years i enjoyed it but i feel like if i was presented with the option to play burgundy or tuscany um you know five times i guess maybe four times is a better way to say it i'd probably go with tuscany three out of those four times because i tend to prefer a little quicker more streamlined more tactical experiences these days over um heavier experiences i know a lot of people say the castles of burgundy isn't a heavy game but you know i'm not saying it's heavy but it definitely has enough going on that if you have to teach somebody new there's a lot of little nuanced things you have to talk about there are special buildings with custom rules and the tiles are really tiny and the different buildings are hard to differentiate between the two and they have drastically different effects um there's dice that kind of fall in between each of these mechanics between taking the hexes and actually playing the hexes out whereas in tuscany you just take the hex and you play some cards to put the building out so it's just it's just designed and developed towards a different audience than the castle's burgundy and i think when you look at it through that lens i think it's a great game again i've only played it once so uh time will tell but i'm looking forward to playing this one more it's it's the kind of weight that i really enjoy it kind of reminded me of luxor um probably because i played luxor like
two or three weeks ago so it's on my mind um in that that's the kind of weight game that it is it's you know in luxor you have a hand of five cards and you play a card from the right or left of your hand and that's your turn you play it's on your turn you play a card you do the thing it's the next person's turn and castles of tuscany has that same kind of lightweight tactical feel trying to do the best that you can in every given circumstance and not really worrying about an overall strategy too much so i quite like it um not all of my friends are super sold on it i feel like all of them would be willing to play it again i will say that one of my friends actually played this two players afterwards one of the people who was a bit lukewarm on it didn't like all the tactics and they enjoyed the two-player game a little bit more because honestly it was a quick game but it went even quicker uh having just one other person take their turn between you um there was some concern with some of my friends about the market being too uh volatile in a four-player game the size of the hex market does not change with the player count i personally didn't see a problem with that but one of my friends really felt like eight tiles in the market was not enough for a four player game and you know to each his own um it seemed fine to me and it just seemed like they didn't vary the market size with the player account because they're going for a more streamlined rules approach in fact there is no rules changes between the player counts besides just having less people around the table and i think that was probably an active thing so yeah i quite like the castles of tuscany i'm looking forward to playing it more i won't say that i'm like crazy excited to play it more but i i do think this one will get more plays especially in situations where i want to knock out like a quick 60 to 90 minute game that will only take me about 10 or so minutes to teach to new
players okay let's now move on to the fourth game i'll be discussing and that is vikings now there is a significant difference between this game and all the rest that i'm talking about today and that's the fact that this game came out in 2007 whereas the rest of the games i'm discussing came out within the last month or two now vikings is a michael keisling designed game and it's one that i've essentially just missed throughout my modern board gaming uh life i really fell into modern board games in 2008 which is just a year after vikings came out and i never really saw it i didn't i didn't really know it existed until just a few months ago actually uh when somebody posted about it on twitter and i was like that looks like a cool game oh my gosh it's 13 years old now interestingly enough i actually mentioned that in my game's radar vlog and a friend of mine heard me say that and was like oh my gosh i love vikings i've played vikings over a hundred times on yukata which is a website where you can play board games and um they they said they would love to teach me the game and play it on yukata so that did end up happening a few weeks ago we played a three-player game and this is the first time i've used yukata this is a browser-based board game site and it has tens of games that you can play and unlike things like tabletop simulator yukata actually knows the rules so you are kind of going through making decisions and it will calculate the scores up for you it will tell you what you can do it will tell you it will not let you do things that you aren't allowed to do it's very structured in that way so interestingly enough it was kind of hard to learn because you couldn't just like pick things up and like point to other things
we did a screen share over zoom to make this happen but it's not that complicated of game and we ended up making it work so um in vikings what you do is uh you are going to be taking tiles that have vikings associated with them from the market and then you place those tiles and the vikings down into your area in front of you now the market um i think in real life is a circle but in yukata it's just a line and it is going to randomly deal out these tiles and then also randomly pull out vikings in different colors and put them in a specific order on top so when you buy a tile you actually buy a tile and a viking as kind of a combo now when you put these tiles down in front of you into your area you just have to put it adjacent orthogonally adjacent to a previously placed tile and you can't have it clash like have water going against you know land or something like that in a line and then you also have the ability to place the viking down on top of it if the row matches now the player area that you have in front of you is split up into a series of different rows that are matched up with the different color types of vikings so if you put that tile into the row that matches the color of the viking you have to buy you put the viking right on top of it if it doesn't match then you put the viking up on the top of your board and at the end of the round when you do some scoring um you will have the potential ability to kind of send out some more of these vikings to the different spots now this is essentially a puzzle that you are building in front of you with these islands the islands always go horizontally across the different rows and the way they work is at the top you're going to be potentially placing pirate ships which are bad if you are
able to defend against them you can get bonuses but they will also if undefended negate the effects of all of the vikings underneath them or at least up to a certain amount depending on the ship so you can think of the rows as associated with the different vikings and the columns as associated with invading pirates now right underneath the pirate ship you can put a warrior i think and if there's a warrior underneath the pirate ship that defends against the pirate ship and you get a benefit and everything below it is fine but if you're not protecting with a warrior that pirate ship once again will affect up to a certain amount of spaces and any vikings underneath it that would normally score your points for doing different things will no longer activate because they're being affected by those pirates so this game is really all about trying to position things correctly but the rounds go until all the tiles are taken so that means you are going to take pirates and also again if you defend against the pirates you get stuff like money or victory points so having pirates is not that big of a deal especially if you have warriors to actually extract those points from the pirate ships so as you play through the games round i can't remember how many rounds it goes through six something like that you are going to be building out more and more space in front of you and you score at the end of each round slightly differently i think every other round you score bigger try not to go into all of the specifics here but you are just trying to build out this puzzle that will hopefully uh squeeze out more points for you than your opponents as you're trying to defend against the pirates and also trying to build your tiles out in such a way that you can be efficient to place tiles with the correct type of pirates on sorry vikings on top
of them to score you points again for different conditions that i'm trying not to go into now we played one game of this and i really enjoyed it it was a slick experience it was essentially what i was expecting it to be going in um i enjoy thailand games in general uh carcassonne is one of my favorite games and this you know definitely had that kind of feel one game that i played a bunch years ago called maori was also all about building out uh horizontal rows of uh islands actually i think you could do vertical in that game as well and i really enjoyed that game not going to go into the specifics of it but i got kind of a tickle of that same vibe with this one and i really enjoyed just putting these things together but having the added mechanics of trying to score these vikings in the correct place to actually make yourself make it all work uh now i actually ended up winning this game which i felt pretty good about i beat somebody who's played this game like over 100 times but they were teaching the game and it's possible they pulled some punches or i probably just got a little bit lucky with how some of the things uh uh sorted themselves out but this is a neat game it's one i could certainly see myself playing again more online um i'd be curious to try in person as well that would be totally fine i don't think i'm like super excited about it i'm not going to rush out and buy a copy of it um if someone said you want to play vikings or do you want to play carcassonne i will always grab carcassonne even though they're significantly different games you know they're both thailand but they're significantly different um but that's you know not saying that much considering i think carcassonne is brilliant especially um at two players but this was a three player game and i love three player
carcassonne as well so um yeah vikings was cool i would not mind playing it again at some point if i stumble into a copy of it that i can buy for like five dollars or something then i would certainly go after it but i'm not planning on hunting it down at this point well we've now reached the fifth and final game i will be discussing and that is whistle mountain now this is a thematic sequel to whistle stop which was a train game designed by scott caputo that came out like three or so years ago but mechanically these games are completely different they just have a similar sounding name now uh this game is on tabletop simulator there is i believe an official uh publisher made mod for it and i got to play a four-player game of this with three of my friends just a few days ago now i actually first heard about this because i watched rado's run-through that he put out a week or two ago and i thought it looked really interesting so it definitely popped up on to my radar and i wanted to make playing this game happen and um actually another friend of mine was super excited about it as well and they ended up teaching the game to all of us now mechanically this is a work replacement game with some pretty interesting tweaks everybody has three workers which are in the shape of airships you have a small airship which is a size one by one a medium one which is a one by two and a large one i think a dreadnought is called which is a one by three now whatever it's your turn you can either send out an airship or you can recall all of your airships and then build some stuff now when you send out the airships there are worker placement or i guess airship placement spots around the outside of the board that let you
do whatever is associated with it you might go to a spot and spend some whistles in order to get some scaffolding another location might give you an upgrade which gives you a conditional bonus for the rest of the game other spots let you grab buildings that will go into your supply and um these things just let you do these things they just let you uh build up various stuff into your horde now another big thing that you're doing in this game and honestly the reason i got excited is you can send your airships out to the center of the board now at the start of the game there's just going to be some scaffolding that some gray pieces that are kind of built up it's this kind of tower of stuff that's being made and you this tower is very sharp so you can't land on top of it but you can go adjacent to it and every orthogonal space next to your airship which again could be a size one by one one by two or one by three every one of the adjacent spots is going to give you whatever is showing on it so it could be like a gold and a whistle or it could be a coal and um some water and you just take those resources and put it onto your player board now as you play through the game you're also going to be able to recall your airships and build as i mentioned before and when you build you get up to three builds which you have to spend some water for in order to place the scaffolding down as well as potentially constructing buildings on top of the scaffolding so it has kind of a polyamino a group polyamino puzzle vibe to it so you have to put scaffolding down and then once it's fully filled in you put the building on top of it and you're gonna score points for how many connections the scaffolding has and the buildings themselves will also score you points based off of the number that's on it now once you construct that building it is now going to stay there in this
communal tower for the rest of the game or at least while it's above water which i'll talk about in a second and now you can actually or anyone really can send their airship and land it on top of that machine because the machine isn't spiky like the uh the scaffolding so when you do that you then activate the machine but then you still activate everything that's orthogonally next to it so as this tower builds up you can have situations where you land an airship down onto a machine activate the machine but the machine the airship is actually kind of adjacent to two other machines that are next to the previous one so you get to activate both of those and then the back end of the airship is also next to a couple of resources so you get those so you have situations where you could send out an airship and get like two resources or you could send out an airship activate three different machines and get a bunch of resources the machines might spend resources to get more stuff to then let you build in the middle of your turn there's just a zany amount of combinations that you can get by slapping an airship down onto the machines in this tower now another big part of this game is the fact that there is a water level that is rising as the game goes on now players have these little workers some of them are kind of starting the game drowning in a whirlpool down at the bottom which is a bit dark but as you play through the game and specifically when you do the build actions you can send these workers out to places on the scaffolding now if anyone constructs a building on top of a worker then that worker is essentially deputized to work the building or something like that and they get sent over all the way to the right to a scoring location if you're the first person to that spot you get a medal which is a bonus and the networker is worth that many points now that's important because the game is going to keep going
until all of the workers are tasked out or until the water level reaches the top the middle section of the board now whenever the water level moves up any workers that are associated on that level either on the left side or on a scaffolding that has not had been built over yet those are all going to fall down into the whirlpool and just continue drowning with the rest of the drowning workers now the water level only goes up when a building is constructed over the main water level line so in this one play that i did we ended up kind of building a spire and lots of buildings started getting built above that water line which kept pushing the water level up into drowning more and more people and if i'm being honest i was actively pushing to do this and the reason for that is because i had a special upgrade card which let me rather easily send my workers out onto scaffolding where i could then rescue them by building on top of them so because i was able to pull them out quicker than my opponents were i decided to essentially rush the end game or as much as i could by constructing as many as much scaffolding as i could above the water line to then put buildings down to rush that up before my opponents were able to free up their workers this ended up working out very well for me because i won handily i had a score of about i think 140 second place had about 120 and then somebody else had like 92 and somebody else had 88.
now that's kind of the overall arc of this game and i have to admit that while i was playing this game i was loving it i was really digging these decisions uh right from the very beginning i thought i loved the communal work replacement polyamino building thing in the middle even though thematically it makes zero sense i have no idea what's actually supposedly happening in here with this collective tower of machines that are getting drowned out by the water and drowning people by the way you lose points for the people drowning in the lake at the bottom of the uh at the end of the game so i was loving the decisions i was making i had all sorts of different opportunities uh different things different plans it's very tactical because obviously you could plan to send an airship to a certain spot to then activate a bunch of different things and the person just to your right might do exactly that and suddenly you need a new plan so i spent this entire game constantly coming up with a plan a plan b a plan c because things were so dynamically changing as we were playing the game our four player game took i think around two hours it wasn't terribly long overall uh and so so the game ended i won which felt good and i asked everybody what they thought um obviously i very much enjoyed it i liked the decisions that was in it the player who came in with about 120 points said they really enjoyed it they're the ones who taught the game and then my friend who got i think about 92 points said and i quote i hated this game with every fiber of my being which you know was a bit hyperbolic i think he was playing uh things up a little bit but um he really really disliked the game and my other friend who had 88 points also
really disliked the game so we had this interesting conversation that lasted like 45 minutes to an hour after we played the game where half of us really liked it and half of us really did not like this game and we're trying to just hash it out and figure out why we weren't like arguing we're just discussing the different things and the big takeaway that we saw was much like i've talked about earlier that the two people who like the game are much more into tactical experiences and the two people who hated this game much prefer strategic experiences they actively disliked the fact that they could have a plan and it just goes up in smoke because somebody uh built a building that obstructs or maybe they sent their airship onto a spot that they wanted to go on to also the fact that airships can linger for like three or potentially even more turns on a spot effectively blocking it really uh irked two of my friends they did not like that whereas i was all about you know coming up with a new plan okay that sucks plan a is gone but let's try to do plan b i found i was constantly thinking constantly trying to come up with new strategies where i guess in new plans while my two friends who hated it they said they were they were bored that they like surfing their phone and like they just could not be engaged by the game at all and these are very good board game players who are very into board games so what we kind of ended up gleaning from this is really two things the first as i said people who prefer tactics over people who prefer strategy the other thing that emerged was discussing these cards now i haven't talked about them just yet but there's this deck of cards that you can draw from through work replacement actions but also through a variety of different bonuses
now on your turn you can spend up to one card and it just does what it says oftentimes it's essentially a carbon copy of another action out there or maybe it's a discount on doing something or maybe it just gives you some resources now in this game at the start of the game everyone gets an asymmetric bonus and my asymmetric bonus said if i draw at least one card on my turn i get to draw another card when my turn is over so i obviously decided to lean into as many ways to draw cards as i could because i got a latent bonus if i drew at least one card i'm gonna draw another one and you can use one turn so that's just more stuff to do so as i played through the game we kind of counted it out and i think i spent a card which again up to one a turn i spent a card on probably 75 of my turns and i ended the game with several cards left in my hand so i constantly on essentially every turn of the game i had a hand of cards that i could choose from to be part of my plan the person who came in uh second place they also had a technology that gave them a card every time they built so they had a decent card income as well they probably played a card on almost half of their turns something like that the other two people the people who hated this game one of them played maybe like three cards in the entire game the other person was honestly about similar so as we were having this long discussion we started she started to realize that a big difference between the people who liked the game and people who didn't like the game was having cards in their hand those two people didn't lean into ways to get cards they didn't really spend energy to gather those cards and we began to realize that they did feel a lot more hamstrung because they had a lot less options available to them because they didn't have this extra kind
of bonus action that they could do on most of their turns like i did because i leaned so heavily into gaining cards so i think that might be you know a first player situation like nobody knew how good the cards would be i just decided to lean into them and it worked out very well for me but also um i think if those opponents had had more cards that would have increased the number of options but still you're drawing them random from the top of the deck so it's just one more tactical element to the game so my big takeaway here is if you like tactical games especially work replacement games especially work replacement games where the options you can choose are drastically changing you might really like this game i actively really enjoyed this game a couple of my friends were like i would never play this again at four players it was way too hectic i had no problem with it i mean i did come in a distant first place so that's there could be a winner's bias going on here but i don't think i'd have any problem playing it again at four players whereas if you really enjoy strategy you enjoy having plans that can be tweaked a little bit by your opponents but not completely derailed um you might have big problems with this game like my friends did and i do want to mention that one of those two people um not the ever i hate it with every fiber of their being but the other person who still actively disliked it at four they ended up playing it with um the person who came in second uh two players because they were just super curious to try it at two when things are gonna be less chaotic there's just one other person to mess with your plans and that game apparently took a similar amount of time maybe like 90 minutes overall and um that person enjoyed it significantly more but they still gave me the caveat that they would
never suggest this game even at two players they said they could be convinced to play it again at two players but they have zero interest in four players and probably zero interest at three players so this is just a polarizing game so people are gonna dislike it a lot apparently and some people are going to potentially really like it and i know that's a bit of a wishy-washy opinion but i did want to let you know how it worked you know how it went over with the variety of different um active board gaming friends that i have uh this is one that i'm looking forward to playing more i i actively enjoyed the building up of the tower and you know maybe the second time i play it i'm gonna hate it maybe things just worked really well for me and it was great having these cards and uh you know i again have a winner's bias going on but that was the impressions that i had so that's going to wrap up my thoughts right now about whistle mountain i am hoping to play this one at some point in the future i'm just gonna have less friend options to play with considering some of my friends actively hate it alright that's gonna bring us to the end of this impressions vlog um i think this is gonna be a pretty long one i usually don't talk about five games but uh i played five games recently and i did want to discuss them even if i had a lot to say about most of them uh i'm quite happy that i enjoyed all of these new games even if not all of my friends actually enjoyed them as much as i did but there's been some really good new gaming going on um i will say that i am continuing to play the rise of queensdale campaign we're up to like eight or nine games at this point and i'm still planning on holding off on discussing that until we finish the campaign overall i'm not sure when that's gonna happen that's gonna bring this all right i think that's going to bring
this impressions vlog to a close